Abstract
This paper describes how the earthquake parameters of historical earthquakes have been determined in Europe from macroseismic data by means of the so-called “Boxer” method, in the frame of the European Commission 2009–2012 Project SHARE (Seismic Hazard Harmonization in Europe). The problems related to the assessment of magnitude are described with more detail; the methodological issues are developed with special reference to the “stable continental region”. The paper first describes how the coefficients of the Boxer method are determined in five tectonic regions of the European area from the relevant calibration data sets, and discusses the problems dealt with while performing this task. Then it describes how the results have been checked against data different from those used in the previous phase. Finally, the application of the new coefficients to nearly a thousand of European earthquakes before 1900 is described. Stressing that, for the first time in Europe, homogeneous results have been obtained at such a large scale, the final part of the paper is devoted to analyse such results, with special reference to the general trends and to some case-histories.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
AHEAD (2013) European archive of historical earthquake data. www.emidius.eu/AHEAD. Accessed 22 Nov 2013
Albini P, Pantosti D (2004) The 20 and 27 April 1894 (Locris, Central Greece) earthquake sources through coeval records on macroseismic effects. Bull Seismol Soc Am 94:1305–1326
Álvarez-Rubio S, Kästli P, Fäh D, Sellami S, Giardini D (2012) Parameterization of historical earthquakes in Switzerland. J Seismol 16(1):1–24. doi:10.1007/s10950-011-9245-8
Ambraseys NN (1985) Intensity-attenuation and magnitude-intensity relationships for Northwestern European earthquakes. Earthq Eng Struct Dyn 13:733–738
Archivio Macrosismico GNDT (1995) Studi preliminari di terremoti attraverso i repertori sismologici. Archivio macrosismico del GNDT, Milano. http://emidius.mi.ingv.it/DOM/consultazione.html. Accessed 22 Nov 2013
Austegard A (1975) The 1904-earthquake in the Oslofjord area. Five Alternative Sites around Oslofjord, for NVE Statskraftverkene. Preliminary Seismic Design Criteria. Dames and Moore, Job No. 6777-001, Oslo
Azzaro R, D’Amico S, Tuvè T (2011) Estimating the magnitude of historical earthquakes from macroseismic intensity data: new relationships for the volcanic region of Mount Etna (Italy). Seism Res Lett 82:533–544
Bakun WH, McGarr A (2002) Differences in attenuation among the stable continental regions. Geoph Res Lett 29:441–450. doi:10.1029/2002GL015457
Bakun WH, Scotti O (2006) Regional intensity attenuation models for France and the estimation of magnitude and location of historical earthquakes. Geophys J Int 164:596–610
Bakun WH, Wentworth CM (1997) Estimating earthquake location and magnitude from seismic intensity data. Bull Seismol Soc Am 87:1502–1521
Bakun WH, Gómez Capera A, Stucchi M (2011) Epistemic uncertainty in the location and magnitude of earthquakes in italy from macroseismic data. Bull Seismol Soc Am 101:2712–2725. doi:10.1785/0120110118
Baptie B, Ottemöller L, Sargeant SL, Ford G, O’Mongain A (2005) The Dudley earthquake of 2002: a moderate sized earthquake in the UK. Tectonophys 401:1–22
Baroux E, Pino NA, Valensise G, Scotti O, Cushing ME (2003) Source parameters of the 11 June 1909, Lambesc (Provence, southeastern France) earthquake: a reappraisal based on macroseismic, seismological and geodetic observations. J Geophys Res 108:2454. doi:10.1029/2002JB002348
Batlló J, Stich D, Palombo B, Macia R, Morales J (2008) The 1951 Mw 5.2 and Mw 5.3 Jaén, Southern Spain, earthquake doublet revisited. Bull Seismol Soc Am 98:1535–1545
Baumont D, Scotti O (2011) The French Parametric Earthquake Catalogue (FPEC) based on the best events of the Sisfrance macroseismic database—Version 1.1. IRSN/DEI/2011-012, Fonteney-aux-Roses
Bernardi F, Braunmiller J, Giardini D (2005) Seismic moment from regional surface-wave amplitudes: applications to digital and analog seismograms. Bull Seismol Soc Am 95:408–418
BGS (2008) Significant British Earthquakes. http://www.earthquakes.bgs.ac.uk/earthquakes/UKsignificant/index.html. Accessed 22 Nov 2013
Boschi E, Guidoboni E, Ferrari G, Mariotti D, Valensise G, Gasperini P (eds) (2000) Catalogue of Strong Italian Earthquakes from 461 B.C. to 1980. Ann Geophys 43:609–868
Bott JDJ, Henni PHO, Ford G (2002a) The 4.0 ML Arran earthquake of 4 March 1999. British Geological Survey, Technical Report CR/01/120N, Edinburgh
Bott JDJ, Henni PHO, Galloway DD (2002b) The 4.2 ML Warwick earthquake of 23 September 2000. British Geological Survey Technical Report, CR/01/121N, Edinburgh
BRGM-EDF-IRSN (2010) SisFrance, histoire et caractèristiques des sèismes ressentis en France. http://www.sisfrance.net/. Accessed 22 Nov 2013
Buforn E, Benito B, del Fresno C, Muñoz D, Rodriguez I (2005) Study of the damaging earthquakes of 1911, 1999, and 2002 in the Murcia, Southeastern Spain, Region: seismotectonic and seismic-risk implications. Bull Seismol Soc Am 95:549–567
Bungum H, Pettenati F, Schweitzer J, Sirovich L, Falaide JI (2009) The 13 October 1904 Ms 5.4 Oslofjord earthquake: reanalysis based on macroseismic and instrumental data. Bull Seismol Soc Am 99:2836–2854
Carletti F, Gasperini P (2003) Lateral variations of seismic intensity attenuation in Italy. Geophys J Int 155:839–856
Choffat P, Bensaude A (1912) Estudos sobre o sismo do Ribatejo de 23 de Abril de 1909. Comissão do Serviço Geológico de Portugal, Lisboa
Costantinescu L, Marza VI (1980) A computer-compiled and computer-oriented catalog of Romania’s earthquakes during a millennium (984–1979). Revue Roumanie de Geologie Geophysique et Geographie 24:171–191
CPTI Working Group (1999) Catalogo Parametrico dei Terremoti Italiani. ING, GNDT, SGA, SSN, Bologna. http://emidius.mi.ingv.it/CPTI99/. Acccessed 22 Nov 2013
CPTI Working Group (2004) Catalogo Parametrico dei Terremoti Italiani, versione 2004 (CPTI04). INGV, Bologna. http://emidius.mi.ingv.it/CPTI04/. doi:10.6092/INGV.IT-CPTI04. Accessed 22 Nov 2013
Delavaud E, Cotton F, Akkar S, Scherbaum F, Danciu L, Beauval C, Drouet S, Douglas J, Basili R, Abdullah Sandikkaya M, Segou M, Faccioli E, Theodoulidis N (2012) Toward a ground-motion logic tree for probabilistic seismic hazard assessment in Europe. J Seismol. doi:10.1007/s10950-012-9281-z
Efron B, Tbishirani RJ (1986) Bootstrap methods for standard errors, confidence intervals and other measures of statistical accuracy. Stat Sci 1:54–77
Fäh D, Giardini D, Kästli P, Deichmann N, Gisler M, Schwarz-Zanetti G, Álvarez-Rubio S, Sellami S, Edwards B, Allmann B, Bethmann F, Wössner J, Gassner-Stamm G, Fritsche S, Eberhard D (2011) ECOS-09 Earthquake Catalogue of Switzerland Release 2011 Report and Database. Public catalogue, 17. 4. 2011. Swiss Seismological Service ETH Zurich, Report SED/RISK/R/001/20110417, 42 pp + Appendixes
Galbis Rodríguez J (1940) Catálogo Sísmico de la Zona comprendida entre los meridianos \(5^{\circ }\) E. y \(20^{\circ }\) W. de Greenwich y los paralelos \(45^{\circ }\) y \(25^{\circ }\) N. Tomo II, Madrid
Gasperini P, Ferrari G (1995) Stima dei parametric sintetici. In: Boschi E, Ferrari G, Gasperini P, Guidoboni E, Smriglio G, Valensise G (eds) Catalogo dei forti terremoti in Italia daql 461 a.C. al 1980, ING-SGA, Bologna/Roma, pp 96–111
Gasperini P, Bernardini F, Valensise G, Boschi E (1999) Defining seismogenic sources from historical felt reports. Bull Seismol Soc Am 89:94–110
Gasperini P, Vannucci G, Tripone D, Boschi E (2010) The location and sizing of historical earthquakes using attenuation of macroseismic intensity with distance. Bull Seismol Soc Am 100:2035–2066. doi:10.1785/0120090330
Giesecke A, Gómez Capera AA, Leschiutta I, Migliorini E (2004) The CERESIS earthquake catalogue and database of the Andean Region: background, characteristics and examples of use. Ann Geophys 47:421–435
Gisler M, Schwarz-Zanetti G, Fäh D, Kästli P (2008) Das Erdbeben von Basel 1356: eine historisc-archäologische Annäherung. In: Gisler M, Fäh D, Giardini D (eds) Nachbeben. Haupt Verlag, Bern, pp 41–51
Gómez Capera AA, Leschiutta I (2004) Determining the parameters of earthquake sources in South America from macroseismic intensity data (CERESIS database). Earth Sci Res J 8:10–18
Gomez Capera AA, Meletti C, Musson R, Stucchi M (2009) The European Earthquake Catalogue (1000–1600), demo version. Part 1—The NA4 Calibration Initiative. NA4 deliverable D5, NERIES Project. http://emidius.mi.ingv.it/neries_NA4/docs/NA4_D5.pdf. Accessed 22 Nov 2013
Grünthal G, Wahlström R (2003) An Mw based earthquake catalogue for central, northern and northwestern Europe using a hierarchy of magnitude conversions. J Seismol 7:507–531
Guidoboni E, Ferrari G, Mariotti D, Comastri A, Tarabusi G, Valensise G (2007) CFTI4Med, Catalogue of Strong Earthquakes in Italy (461 B.C.-1997) and Mediterranean Area (760 B.C.-1500). INGV-SGA. http://storing.ingv.it/cfti4med. Accessed 22 Nov 2013
Hall P (1992) The bootstrap and edgeworth expansion. Springer, New York
Havskov J, Bungum H (1987) Source parametres for earthquakes in the northern North Sea. Nor J Geol 67:51–58
Hinzen KG, Oemisch M (2001) Location and magnitude from seismic intensity data of recent and historic earthquakes in the Northern Rhine Area, Central Europe. Bull Seismol Soc Am 91:40–56
IGN (2013) Servicio de Información Sísmica, Insituto Geográfico Nacional. Madrid. http://www.ign.es/ign/layout/sismo.do. Accessed 22 Nov 2013
INGV (2006) Bollettino Macrosismico Mensile. Istituto Nazionale di Geofisica e Vulcanologia. Roma
Instituto Nacional de Meteorologia e Geofisica (1983) Macrossismos Sentidos em Portugal Continental no Periodo de 1755 a 1959. Relatorio INMG 1983, Lisboa
Johnston A (1996) Seismic moment assessment of earthquakes in stable continental regions—II. Historical seismicity. Geophys J Int 125:639–678
Laboratorio Nacional de Engenharia Civil (1986) A Sismicidade Histórica e a Revisão do Catálogo Sísmico. Laboratorio Nacional de Engenharia Civil, Lisboa
LDG (2011) Bulletin sismique du Laboratoire de Détection et de Géophysique. http://www-dase.cea.fr/evenement/syntheses_resultat.php?n=-1&type_bulletin=proche&lang=fr. Accessed 22 Nov 2013
Locati M, Rovida A, Albini P, Stucchi M (2014) The AHEAD portal: a gateway to European historical earthquake data. Seismol Res Lett 85(3):727–734
Martinez Solares JM, Mezcua Rodriguez J (eds) (2002) Catalogo sismico de la Peninsula Iberica (880 a.C.-1990). IGN Monografía Núm 18, Madrid
Mayer-Rosa D, Cadiot B (1979) A review of the 1356 Basel earthquake. Tectonophys 53:325–333
Meghraoui M, Delouis B, Ferry M, Giardini D, Huggenberger P, Spottke I, Granet M (2001) Active normal faulting in the Upper Rhine Graben and paleoseismic identification of the 1356 Basel earthquake. Science 293:2070–2073
Mezcua J, Rueda J, García Blanco RM (2004) Reevaluation of historic earthquakes in Spain. Seismol Res Lett 75:75–81
MPS Working Group (2004) Redazione della Mappa di Pericolosità Sismica prevista dall’Ordinanza PCM del 20 marzo 2003, n. 3274, All. 1, Rapporto Conclusivo, INGV Milano/Roma. http://zonesismiche.mi.ingv.it/documenti/rapporto_conclusivo.pdf. Accessed 22 Nov 2013
Musson RMW (1994) Earthquake Catalogue of Great Britain and surroundings. British Geological Survey, Technical report WL/94/04, Edinburgh
Musson RMW (2008) The macroseismic survey of the 27 February 2008 Market Rasen earthquake. SECED Newsl 20:1–5
Musson RMW, Henni PHO (2002) The felt effects of the Carlisle earthquake of 26 December 1979. Scott J Geol 38:113–126
Musson RMW, Jimenéz MJ (2008) Macroseismic estimation of earthquake parameters. NA4 deliverable D3, NERIES Project. http://emidius.mi.ingv.it/neries_NA4/docs/NA4_D3.pdf. Accessed 18 June 2014
Musson RMW, Sargeant SL (2007) BGS UK Earthquake Database. Eurocode 8 seismic hazard zoning maps for the UK. British Geological Survey Technical Report, CR/07/125, Edinburgh
Musson RMW, Neilson G, Burton PW (1984) Macroseismic reports on historical British earthquakes I: Northwest England and Southwest Scotland. British Geological Survey Global Seismology Report 207, Edinburgh
Neilson G, Musson RMW, Burton PW (1984) Macroseismic reports on historical British earthquakes V: Midlands. British Geological Survey Global Seismology Report 228, Edinburgh
NOA (2010) Bulletin of the Seismological Institute. National Observatory Athens, Athens
Oncescu MC, Marza VI, Rizescu M, Popa M (1999) The Romanian earthquake catalogue between 984–1997. In: Wenzel F, Lungu D (eds) Contributions from the First International Workshop on Vrancea earthquakes, Bucharest, Romania, November 1–4, 1997. Kluwer, Dordrecht, pp 43–48
ORB (2007) Séismicité en Belgique. Observatoire Royal de Belgique. http://seismologie.be/index.php. Accessed 22 Nov 2013
Papazachos BC, Comninakis PE, Scordilis EM, Karakaisis GF, Papazachos CB (2009) A catalogue of earthquakes in the Mediterranean and surrounding area for the period 1901–2008. http://geophysics.geo.auth.gr/ss/catalogs_en.html. Accessed 22 Nov 2013
Parsons T (2004) Recalculated probability of \(\text{ M } {\>}= 7\) earthquakes beneath the Sea of Marmara, Turkey. J Geophys Res. doi:10.1029/2003JB002667
Pasolini C, Gasperini P, Albarello D, Lolli B, D’Amico V (2008) The attenuation of seismic intensity in Italy, Part I: theoretical and empirical backgrounds. Bull Seismol Soc Am 98:682–691
Pondrelli S, Morelli A, Ekström G, Mazza S, Boschi E, Dziewonski AM (2002) European-Mediterranean regional centroid-moment tensors: 1997–2000. Phys Earth Planet Int 130:71–101
Pondrelli S, Morelli A, Ekström G (2004) European-Mediterranean regional centroid moment tensor catalog: solutions for years 2001 and 2002. Phys Earth Planet Int 145:127–147
Pondrelli S, Salimbeni S, Morelli A, Ekström G, Boschi E (2007) European-Mediterranean regional centroid moment tensor catalog: solutions for years 2003 and 2004. Phys Earth Planet Int 164:90–112
Pondrelli S, Salimbeni S, Morelli A, Ekström G, Postpischl L, Vannucci G, Boschi E (2011) European-Mediterranean regional centroid moment tensor catalog: solutions for 2005–2008. Phys Earth Planet Int 85:74–81
RCMT (2013) European-Mediterranean Regional Centroid Moment Tensor Catalog. INGV, Bologna. http://www.bo.ingv.it/RCMT/. Accessed 22 Nov 2013
Rovida A, Camassi R, Gasperini P, Stucchi M (eds) (2011) CPTI11, the 2011 version of the Parametric Catalogue of Italian Earthquakes. Milano, Bologna, http://emidius.mi.ingv.it/CPTI. doi:10.6092/INGV.IT-CPTI11. Accessed 22 Nov 2013
Sanchez Navarro Neumann M (1911) Enumeración de los terremotos sentidos en España en 1910. Bol R Soc Esp Hist Nat
Sargeant SL, Stafford PJ, Lawley R, Weatherill G, Weston A-JS, Bommer JJ, Burton PW, Free M, Musson RMW, Kuuyour T, Rossetto T (2008) Observations from the Folkestone, U.K., Earthquake of 28 April 2007. Seismol Res Lett 79:672–687
Schneider G (1998) Neue Bemessungsspektren für Deutschland. DIN Symposium 21.01.1998 Leinfelden, Germany
Schwarz-Zanetti G, Fäh D (2011) Grundlagen des Makroseismischen Erdbebenkatalogs der Schweiz, Band 1, 1000–1680. Vdf Hochschulverlag AG an der ETH, Zürich
Scordilis EM (2006) Empirical global relations converting Ms and mb to moment magnitude. J Seismol 10:225–236
Sibol MS, Bollinger GA, Birch JB (1987) Estimations of magnitudes in central and eastern North America using Intensity and Felt Area. Bull Seismol Soc Am 77:1635–1654
Sousa Moreira VJ (1984) Sismicidade historica de Portugal continental. Revista Nacional de Meteorologia e Geofisica, Lisboa
Stich D, Batlló J, Macià R, Teves-Costa P, Morales J (2005) Moment tensor inversion with single-component historical seismograms: the 1909 Benavente (Portugal) and Lambesc (France) earthquake. Geophys J Int 162:850–858
Stucchi M, Locati M (2008) European macroseismic database (demo version) 1000–1600, \(\text{ M } >5.0\). NA4 deliverable D10, NERIES Project. http://emidius.mi.ingv.it/neries_NA4/docs/NA4_D4.pdf. Accessed 18 June 2014
Stucchi M, Rovida A, Gomez Capera AA, Musson RMW, Papaioannou Ch, Batlló J (2010) European Earthquake Catalogue (1000–1963), \(\text{ M }{\>}5.8\). NA4 deliverable D10, NERIES Project. http://emidius.mi.ingv.it/neries_NA4/docs/NA4_D10.pdf. Accessed 22 Nov 2013
Stucchi M, Rovida A, Gomez Capera AA, Alexandre P, Camelbeeck T, Demircioglu MB, Gasperini P, Kouskouna V, Musson RMW, Radulian M, Sesetyan K, Vilanova S, Baumont D, Faeh D, Lenhardt W, Makropoulos K, Martinez Solares JM, Scotti O, Zivcic M, Albini P, Batllo J, Papaioannou Ch, Tatevossian R, Locati M, Meletti C, Viganò D, Giardini D (2013) The SHARE European Earthquake Catalogue (SHEEC) 1000–1899. J Seismol 17:523–524. doi:10.1007/s10950-012-9335-2
Swiss Seismological Service (2002) ECOS—Earthquake Catalog of Switzerland. ECOS Report to PEGASOS, Version 31. 3. 2002, Appendix A: ECOS Database. SED, Zürich. http://histserver.ethz.ch/. Accessed 22 Nov 2013
Teves-Costa P, Batlló J (2011) The 23 April 1909 Benavente earthquake (Portugal): macroseismic field revision. J Seismol 15:59–70. doi:10.1007/s10950-010-9207-6
Torres-Vera MA (2010) Historical seismicity in Mexico during 1568–1837: intensity evaluation and data reliability. Nat Haz 54:863–878
Udías A, Muñoz D, Buforn E, Sanz de Galdeano C, del Fresno C, Rodriguez I (2005) Reevaluation of the earthquakes of 10 March and 19 May 1951 in southern Spain. J Seismol 9:99–110
University of Bergen (2003) Seismological Bulletin from Norwegian National Seismic Network. Seismological Observatory, Dept. of Earth Sciences
University of Thessaloniki (2003) Macroseismic Data used for the compilation of Papazachos and Papazachou (2003) catalogue. Online Macroseimic Data of Southern Balkan area. http://www.itsak.gr/en/db/data/macroseimic_data. Accessed 22 Nov 2013
Vilanova SP, Fonseca JFBD (2007) Probabilistic seismic-hazard assessment for Portugal. Bull Seismol Soc Am 97:1702–1717
Wells DL, Coppersmith KJ (1994) New empirical relationships among magnitude, rupture length, rupture width, rupture area, and surface displacement. Bull Seismol Soc Am 84:974–1002
Zsìros T (2008) Studies on earthquakes in Hungary (1000–1899). Georisk-NERIES NA4 collaboration’s report, Budapest
Acknowledgments
The results described in this paper represent the final output of a large round of trials and tests performed in the frame of the NERIES and SHARE Projects. We acknowledge here the valuable contribution, in terms of data, expertise and discussion, by: S. Álvarez Rubio, J. Batlló, H. Bungum, T. Camelbeeck, A. Cassera, V. D’Amico, D. Fäh, X. Goula, V. Kouskouna, M. Locati, C. Meletti, R. Musson, C. Mirto, C. Papaioannou, O. Scotti, C. Ventouzi. Special thanks are due to Bill Bakun for his constant and precious support, and to Domenico Giardini, for stimulating this work in the frame of NERIES and SHARE. This work has been supported by the EC—Research Framework Programme FP6, Network of Research Infrastructures for European Seismology, EC Contract No. 026130, and EC-Research Framework Programme FP7, Seismic Hazard Harmonization in Europe, Grant Agreement No. 226769.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Appendix
Appendix
See Table 9.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Gomez-Capera, A.A., Rovida, A., Gasperini, P. et al. The determination of earthquake location and magnitude from macroseismic data in Europe. Bull Earthquake Eng 13, 1249–1280 (2015). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10518-014-9672-3
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10518-014-9672-3