Abstract
This article analyzes learning in context through the prism of a sustainable dairy-farming project. The research was performed within a nutrient management project that involved the participation of farmers and scientists. Differences between heterogeneous forms of farmers’ knowledge and scientific knowledge were discursively constructed during conflict and subsequent alignment over the validity and relevance of knowledge. Both conflict and alignment appeared to be essential for learning in context. Conflict spurred learning when disagreeing groups of actors developed their knowledge in order to strengthen their arguments. Conflict caused self-referentiality when the actors no longer listened to each other. This inhibited self-reflection, thus blocking ongoing learning. Nevertheless, after a period of alignment, scientific models and knowledge of farmers were reevaluated and recontextualized. Through determining how to use scientific models and farmers’ knowledge for further learning, aimed at a shared goal, the participating actors also learned how to learn.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
N. Aarts (1998) Een kwestie van natuur: een studie naar de aard en het verloop van communicatie over natuur en natuurbeleid Wageningen University Wageningen, The Netherlands
C. Argyris R. Putnam D. Smith (1985) Action Science Jossey Bass San Francisco, California.
C. Argyris D. A. Schön (1996) Organizational Learning II. Theory, Method, and Practice Addison-Wesley Publishing Reading. Pennsylvania.
P. Atkinson M. Hammersly (1998) “Ethnography and participant observation” N. K. Denzin Y. S. Lincoln (Eds) Strategies of Qualitative Inquiry Sage Publications Thousand Oaks California 110–136
G. Atsma F. Benedictus F. Verhoeven M. Stuiver (2000) De sporen van twee milieucoöperaties Drukkerij Modern Bennekom The Netherlands
T. Baars (2002) Reconciling Scientific Approaches for Organic Farming Research Louis Bolk Institute Driebergen, The Netherlands
T. Baars A. Van de Vries J. Bloksma G. J. Burgt Particlevan der (1999) De boer als ervaringswetenschapper: handboek voor ervarend leren in de landbouwpraktijk Elsevier Doetinchem, The Netherlands
H. S. Becker (1970) Sociological Work: Method and Substance Allen Lane, The Penguin Press London, UK
M. Burawoy A. Burton A. A. Ferguson K. J. Fox J. Gamson N. Gartrell L. Hurst C. Kurzman L. Salzinger J. Schiffman S. Ui (1991) Ethnography Unbound: Power and Resistance in the Modern Metropolis University of California Press Berkeley, California
M. Callon (1986) “Some elements of a sociology of translation: Domestication of the scallops and fishermen of St Brieuc Bay” J. Law (Eds) Power, Action and Belief: A New Sociology of Knowledge Routledge and Kegan Paul London, UK 196–233
J. Clark J. Murdoch (1997) ArticleTitle“Local knowledge and the precarious extension of scientific networks: A reflection on three case studies” Sociologia Ruralis 37 IssueID1 38–60 Occurrence Handle10.1111/1467-9523.00035
Commissie Bemesting en Voedergewassen (1998). Adviesbasis bemesting grasland en voedergewassen. [Foundations of Fertilizer Recommendations for Grassland and Foddercrops.] Lelystad, The Netherlands: Research Station for Cattle, Sheep and Horse Husbandry. Series Themaboek No. 35.
J. Dewey (1922) Human Nature and Conduct: An Introduction to Social Psychology Allen & Unwin London
P. Engel (1995) Facilitating Innovation: An Actor-oriented Approach and Participatory Methodology to Improve Innovative Social Practice in Agriculture Wageningen University Wageningen, The Netherlands
J. W. Erisman (2000) De vliegende geest: ammoniak uit de landbouw en de gevolgen voor de natuur Beta Text Bergen, The Netherlands
J. Eshuis M. Stuiver F. Verhoeven J. D. Ploeg Particlevan der (2001) Goede mest stinkt niet: een studie over drijfmest, ervaringskennis en het terugdringen van mineralenverliezen in de melkveehouderij Wageningen University Wageningen, The Netherlands
J. Forester (1999) The Deliberative Practitioner: Encouraging Participatory Planning Processes The MIT Press Cambridge
A. Giddens (1984) The Constitution of Society: Outline of the Theory of Structuration Polity Press Cambridge, UK
B. Gray (1997) “Framing and reframing of intractable environmental disputes” B. Lewicki B. Sheppard R. Bies (Eds) Research on Negotiation in Organizations JAI Press Greenwich, UK 163–188
M. Hajer (1995) The Politics of Environmental Discourse Clarendon Press Oxford UK
N. A. Hamilton (1995) Learning to Learn with Farmers: A Case Study of an Adult Learning Extension Project Conducted in Queensland, Australia 1990–1995 Wageningen University Wageningen The Netherlands
N. Hasseinen J. R. Kloppenburg (1995) ArticleTitle“Where the grass grows again: Knowledge exchange in the sustainable agriculture movement.” Rural Sociology 60 IssueID4 721–740
M. Hobart (Eds) (1993) An Anthropological Critique of Development: The Growth of Ignorance Routledge London, UK
S. C. Jarvis (1997) “Emission processes and their interaction in grassland soils” S. C. Jarvis B. F. Pain (Eds) Gaseous Nitrogen Emission from Grasslands CAB International Wallingford, UK 1–17
J. Jiggins N. G. Röling (2000) ArticleTitle“Adaptive management: Potential and limitations for ecological governance” International Journal of Agricultural Resources, Governance and Ecology 1 IssueID1 28–42
P. Kant K. Blanken J. Lent Particlevan (1998) ArticleTitle“Geen lagere ammoniakemissie gemeten bij Euromestmix” Rundvee Praktijkonderzoek 11 13–16
O. T. Kibwana M. Haile L. Veldhuizen Particlevan A. Waters-Bayer (2001) ArticleTitle“Clapping with two hands: Bringing together local and outside knowledge for innovation in land husbandry in Tanzania and Ethiopia – a comparative case study” The Journal of Agricultural Education and Extension 7 IssueID3 131–142
W. J. M. Kickert E. H. Klijn J. F. M. Koppenjan (Eds) (1997) Managing Complex Networks: Strategies for the Public Sector Sage London, UK
J. R. Kloppenburg (1991) ArticleTitle“Social theory and the de/reconstruction of agricultural science: Local knowledge for an alternative agriculture” Rural Sociology 56 IssueID4 519–548
K. Knorr-Cetina (1981) The Manufacture of Knowledge: An Essay on the Constructivist and Contextual Nature of Science Pergamon Oxford, UK
D. Kolb (1984) Experiential Learning: Experiences as the Source of Learning and Development Prentice-Hall Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey
E. A. Lantinga P. Deenen H. Keulen Particlevan (1999) ArticleTitle“Herbage and animal production responses to fertilizer nitrogen in perennial ryegrass swards” Netherlands Journal of Agricultural Science 4 IssueID7 243–261
B. Latour (1987) Science in Action: How to Follow Scientists and Engineers through Society Harvard University Press Cambridge, Massachusetts
J. Law (1994) Organizing Modernity Blackwell Oxford, UK
K. N. Lee (1993) Compass and Gyroscope: Integrating Science and Politics for the Environment Island Press Washington, DC
C. Leeuwis (1993) Of Computers, Myths and Modelling: The Social Construction of Diversity, Knowledge, Information, and Communication Technologies in Dutch Horticulture and Agricultural Extension Wageningen University Wageningen, The Netherlands
Leeuwis, C. with A. van den Ban (2004). Communication for Rural Innovation: Rethinking Agricultural Extension. Oxford, UK: Blackwell.
N. Long (1989) Encounters at the Interface: A Perspective on Social Discontinuities in Rural Development Agricultural University Wageningen, The Netherlands
N. Long A. Long (Eds) (1992) Battlefields of Knowledge Routledge London
J. Murdoch J. Clark (1994) ArticleTitle“Sustainable knowledge” Geoforum 25 IssueID2 115–132 Occurrence Handle10.1016/0016-7185(94)90010-8
P. Reason (1998) “Three approaches to participative inquiry” N. K. Denzin Y. S. Lincoln (Eds) Strategies of Qualitative Inquiry Sage Publications Thousand Oaks, California 261–291
J. W. Reijs F. P. M. Verhoeven J. Bruchem Particlevan J. D. Ploeg Particlevan der E. A. Lantinga (2004) “The nutrient management project of the VEL and VANLA environmental co-operatives” J. S. C. Wiskerke J. D. Ploeg Particlevan der (Eds) Seeds of Transition: Essays on Novelty Production, Niches and Rregimes in Agriculture. Van Gorcum Assen, The Netherlands 149–181
D. Roep (2000) Vernieuwend werken, sporen van vermogen en onvermogen: een socio-materiele studie over vernieuwing in de landbouw uitgewerkt voor de westelijke veenweidegebieden Wageningen University Wageningen, The Netherlands
N. G. Röling (1988) Extension Science, Information Systems in Agricultural Development Cambridge University Press New York
N. G. Röling E. Fliert Particlevan der (1998) “Introducing integrated pest management in rice in Indonesia: A pioneering attempt to facilitate large-scale change” N. G. Röling M. A. E. Wagemakers (Eds) Facilitating Sustainable Agriculture: Participatory Learning and Adaptive Management in Times of Environmental Uncertainty Cambridge University Press Cambridge, Massachusetts 153–171
J. H. A. M. Steenvoorden W. J. Bruins M. M. Eerdt Particlevan (1999) Monitoring van nationale ammoniakemissies uit de landbouw: op weg naar een verbeterde rekenmethodiek DLO-Staring Center Series Wageningen The Netherlands
M. Stuiver J. S. C. Wiskerke (2004) “The VEL and VANLA environmental co-operatives as a niche for sustainable development” J. S. C. Wiskerke J. D. Ploeg Particlevan der (Eds) Seeds of Transition: Essays on Novelty Production, Niches and Regimes in Agriculture Van Gorcum Assen 119–148
M. Stuiver J. D. Ploeg Particlevan der C. Leeuwis (2003) ArticleTitle“The VEL and VANLA environmental co-operatives as field laboratories” NJAS – Wageningen Journal of Life Sciences 51 IssueID1/2 27–39
L. Susskind J. Cruikshank (1987) Breaking the Impasse: Consensual Approaches to Resolving Public Disputes Basic Books New York
C. J. A. M. Termeer J. F. M. Koppenjan (1997) “Managing perceptions in networks” W. J. M. Kickert E. H. Klijn J. F. M. Koppenjan (Eds) Managing Complex Networks: Strategies for the Public Sector Sage London, UK 79–97
V. Upreti (2001) Conflict Management in Natural Resources: A Study of Land, Water and Forest Conflicts in Nepal Wageningen University Wageningen, The Netherlands
R. Usher I. Bryant (1989) Adult Education as Theory, Practice and Research: The Captive Triangle Routledge London, UK
Van Bruchem, J., M. W. A. Verstegen, and S. Tamminga (1999a). “From nutrient fluxes in animals to nutrient dynamics and health in animal production systems.” In D. Gagnaux, R. Daccord, A. Gibon, J. R. Poffet, and A. R. Sibbald (eds.), Livestock Farming Systems: Integrating Animal Science Advances into the Search for Sustainability: Proceedings of the Fifth International Symposium on Livestock Farming Systems (pp. 28–48). Posieux (Fribourg), Switzerland, August 19–20, 1999. Wageningen, The Netherlands: Wageningen Press.
J Bruchem ParticleVan H. Schiere H. Keulen Particlevan (1999) ArticleTitle“Dairy farming in The Netherlands in transition towards more efficient nutrient use” Livestock Production Science 61 145–153 Occurrence Handle10.1016/S0301-6226(99)00064-0
J. D. Ploeg ParticleVan der (1992) “The reconstitution of locality: technology and labour in modern agriculture” T. Marsden P. Lowe S. Whatmore (Eds) Labour and Locality: Uneven Development and the Rural Labour Process David Fulton Publisher London, UK 19–43
J. D. Ploeg ParticleVan der G. Dijk Particlevan (Eds) (1995) Beyond Modernization: The Impact of Endogenous Rural Development Van Gorcum Assen, The Netherlands
L. Veldhuizen ParticleVan A. Waters-Bayer H. Zeeuw Particlede (1997) Developing Technology with Farmers: A Trainer’s Guide for Participatory Learning ZED Books London, UK
T. V. Vellinga (1998) Verfijning bemestingsadvies 1998 Research Station for Cattle Sheep, and Horse Husbandry Lelystad
F. P. M. Verhoeven G. M. J. H. Made Particlevan der J. Bruchem Particlevan (1998) ArticleTitleStikstof in balans: cijfers van 100 Friese melkveebedrijven tonen belang bodembenutting Veeteelt 15 496–498
F. P. M. Verhoeven J. W. Reijs J. D. Ploeg Particlevan der (2003) ArticleTitle“Re-balancing soil-plant-animal interactions: Towards reduction of nitrogen losses” NJAS – Wageningen Journal of Life Sciences 51 IssueID1/2 147–164
A. A. Voogt (1991) “Managing of social-cognitive configurations in a multiple context” R. J. Inhet Veld L. Schaap C. J. A. M. Termeer M. J. W. Twist Particlevan (Eds) Autopoiesis and Configuration, Theory: New Approaches to Societal Steering Kluwer Academic Publishers Dordrecht 67–85
C. J. Walley (2002) ArticleTitle“‘They scorn us because we are uneducated’: Knowledge and power in a Tanzania marine park” Ethnography 3 IssueID3 265–298 Occurrence Handle10.1177/146613802401092751
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Jasper Eshuis is a PhD candidate in the Department of Communication Management at Wageningen University, The Netherlands. His research deals with multiple land use, governance processes, and farmers’ decision-making. He is currently interested in monitoring and trust.
Marian Stuiver is a PhD candidate in the Department of Rural Sociology of Wageningen University, The Netherlands. Her current research focuses on nutrient management, farmers’ innovation, and co-production of knowledge within the agricultural sciences.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Eshuis, J., Stuiver, M. Learning in context through conflict and alignment: Farmers and scientists in search of sustainable agriculture. Agric Hum Values 22, 137–148 (2005). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10460-004-8274-0
Accepted:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10460-004-8274-0