Abstract
In many social species, after the alpha male has been replaced or the group disintegrates, a female’s infant is at risk of infanticide by a male. Female gorillas have developed the rare strategy of secondary dispersal in which they transfer between reproductive groups during the limited time period between weaning an infant and conceiving the next one (voluntary dispersal). By doing so they leave a weaker silverback near the end of his tenure and join a stronger silverback at an earlier stage of his own tenure, thereby mitigating the risk of infanticide if the former dies. If females are pregnant or have unweaned offspring when the only male in the group dies, their offspring are vulnerable to infanticide by the new silverback that they join (via involuntary dispersal). In the few known cases of female gorillas transferring when pregnant (mainly after group disintegration), their offspring were killed. We report here on three adult females that transferred voluntarily while pregnant multiple times between two groups yet their offspring were not killed by the new group’s silverback. The gorillas were observed from 1995 to 2015 at the Mbeli Bai research site in northern Republic of the Congo. The females gave birth 5–6 months (gestation period 8.5 months) after their last transfer. To our knowledge, these observations are the first to show that wild female western lowland gorillas can transfer voluntarily while pregnant without incurring infanticide by a new silverback. These observations highlight the behavioural plasticity shown by female gorillas in response to sexual coercion by males.
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
Introduction
Social mammals exhibit a range of intersexual conflicts and compromises (Clutton-Brock 2007). One clear example of sexual conflict suffered by reproductive females is infanticide by males (Lukas and Huchard 2014), which has been observed in a wide range of mammals, e.g. in rodents, ungulates, carnivores, pinnipeds and primates (van Schaik 2000a). Infanticide reduces the reproductive success of both parents, but it can increase the reproductive success of the infanticidal male if three conditions are met: there is a low probability that the infanticidal male sired the infant, the mother resumes reproduction sooner if the infant is killed, and the mother is likely to mate with the infanticidal male (Hrdy 1977; Smuts and Smuts 1993).
Female primates have developed several strategies to avoid infanticide, such as forming permanent associations with males that provide protection against other males, remaining with the father until weaning the infant, residing in a multi-male group, mating with multiple males to create paternity confusion, or joining a better protector male using secondary dispersal (Palombit 2015). Secondary dispersal (also referred to as transfer), which involves the movement of females between reproductive groups, is found in only a few mammals [e.g. Thomas langurs (Sterck et al. 2005); tropical bats (Nagy et al. 2007); feral horses (Debeffe et al. 2015); gorillas (Stokes et al. 2003; Robbins and Robbins 2015)] and is believed to represent female choice for a high-quality male where it occurs voluntarily (Harcourt and Stewart 2007; Lukas and Huchard 2014). However, it may also occur involuntarily after group disintegration [in gorillas (Stokes et al 2003)] or female eviction [in ursine colobus (Teichroeb et al. 2009)] and lead to infanticide if the females are pregnant or have unweaned offspring. When secondary dispersal occurs voluntarily, this ability to move between groups gives females an advantage over those of philopatric species as it allows them to reduce the risk of infanticide of their young (Lewis 2018). However, when females disperse, the timing of their voluntary dispersal must be carefully calculated, as due to the risk of infanticide, they have only a very short window of time in which to leave their current group between weaning an infant and conceiving again (Sterck et al. 2005; Robbins and Robbins 2015; Sicotte 1993; Sicotte et al. 2017). If a female transfers while pregnant or with an infant, the first and third criteria for infanticide are met, and the infant is at risk.
Infanticide by males has been directly observed or inferred in many populations of gorillas (Watts 1989; Yamagiwa et al. 2009; Breuer et al. 2010; Robbins et al. 2013). Infanticide is often inferred after the silverback’s death and subsequent group disintegration when infants disappear soon after their mother’s transfer to a new silverback (Robbins et al. 2013). However, cases of unweaned infants surviving after transferring together with their mother have been observed (Sicotte 2000; Stokes et al. 2003). The infanticide rate after death of the silverback (leading to group disintegration) is quite high (12%) in western lowland gorillas at Mbeli (Breuer et al. 2010; Robbins et al. 2013). With their strategy of voluntary secondary dispersal, female gorillas may be able to choose a better male before the death of the current silverback and protect their offspring from infanticide (Palombit 2015; Manguette et al. 2019, 2020).
In gorillas, dispersal of females while they are pregnant is known to occur after group disintegration, when females are forced to find another male since they typically do not range on their own. Transfer of females while pregnant after involuntary dispersal has been reported both at Mbeli Bai and at Kahuzi-Biega, and in all instances the infants were killed soon after birth (Stokes et al. 2003; Yamagiwa et al. 2009). Thus, the voluntary transfer of a female while pregnant carries a very high risk of infanticide. Here we report three cases of voluntary transfer by pregnant wild western lowland gorillas that did not result in the death of their young.
Methods
Study site and data collection
Western gorillas were studied at Mbeli Bai, a swampy forest clearing in the Nouabale-Ndoki National Park, northern Republic of the Congo. We observed the gorillas from a 9-m-high observation platform overlooking the bai with almost 100% visibility [for further details, see Parnell (2002) and Breuer et al. (2009)]. The Mbeli population demographic dataset comprised 440 individually identifiable gorillas (including 100 adult females in 40 different breeding groups) observed from February 1995 to November 2015. We specifically discuss three females (Ndebele, Khoisan and Efi) and four different groups (Gretsky, Boris, Zulu and Saha). The groups were observed on average between 19 and 38 times a year at the clearing (Table 1). Gretsky and Zulu, the group of origin of the females, were composed of 14 and 12 individuals, respectively, while Boris and Saha, the silverbacks the females transferred to, were both solitary (Table 1).
Due to the nature of observations at the bai, not all of the gorillas were observed daily and dates of birth and dispersal were estimated. Some infants were observed within a few days of their birth, as confirmed by previous recent observations of the group without them. Beyond a few days of age, birthdates were estimated by comparing the infants’ morphological and behavioural characteristics with those of infants of known ages (Parnell 2002; Nowell and Fletcher 2007; Breuer et al. 2009). The earliest possible birthdate was assumed to be the last date on which the mother was observed without her infant. The latest possible birthdate was assumed to be the first date that the mother was observed with her infant. Gorillas have an average gestation period of 255 days with a range of 240–280 days (Harcourt and Stewart 2007; Phillips et al. 2015). The expected conception date equalled the estimated birthdate minus 255 days. The earliest possible conception date equalled the earliest possible birthdate minus 280 days. The latest possible conception date equalled the latest possible birthdate minus 240 days (Table S1).
Dispersal dates were estimated as the midpoint between the last visit to the bai of the group of origin and the first visit of the group of destination (Manguette et al. 2019). We accounted for the maximum possible error by assuming that a female transferred and conceived on the day she was last observed in the previous group and that she gave birth on the first day she was observed with her offspring in the new group (Table S2).
Results
We report the dispersal of three females (Ndebele, Khoisan, and Efi) that transferred multiple times during pregnancy (Table S3 for all observation dates). Ndebele had been a member of Zulu’s group (Zulu was estimated to be 33 years old) for 13 years when she conceived between February and April 2013 (Fig. 1). She transferred to a solitary male, Saha (estimated to be 24 years old), between May and June, then briefly resided in Zulu’s group for a few weeks again in July, then returned to Saha’s group in August where she remained. She had been with Saha for the last 142 days of her gestation period when her next offspring (Nemo) was born in December 2013.
Khoisan had also been observed in Zulu’s group for 13 years when she conceived between March and May 2013 (Fig. 1). Her range of potential conception dates overlapped with her initial transfer to Saha between April and May. She briefly visited Zulu’s group again in July, then returned to Saha’s group where she remained from August onwards. She had been with Saha for the last 165 days of her gestation period when her next offspring (Kwasimodo) was born in December. The two offspring born in Saha’s group were both healthy (no sign of preterm birth; Fig. 2), which suggests that the gestation period was normal in both cases.
From November 2014 up to and including March 2015, Efi transferred seven times between the group of Gretsky (whose estimated age was 30 years) and a solitary male, Boris (whose estimated age was 24 years). She resided with each male during her range of potential conception dates between November 2014 and February 2015 (Fig. 3). She had been with Boris for the last 172 days of her gestation period when her next offspring (Estonia) was born between August and October 2015.
In all three of these cases of dispersal by pregnant females, the infants survived with their mother in the new group until the end of the study (i.e. when the infants were 24, 23 and 2.5 months of age). These three births represent only 1.5% of the 202 births that occurred during the study, which suggests that dispersal by pregnant females is extremely rare.
Discussion
Our findings show that in western lowland gorillas, although rare with regards to total births recorded in the current study (~1.5%), offspring born to mothers that voluntary transfer when pregnant may not be killed. All three females transferred multiple times between two different groups during their pregnancy, and potentially also during the period of conception of their offspring. However, as this strategy may result in infanticide, the question arises: why were these infants not killed by the new silverbacks?
It is likely that the new silverbacks did not kill the infants because they had some degree of paternity certainty or were actually the fathers. In the cases of Khoisan and Efi, the conception period may easily have coincided with a time when these females were with the new silverbacks during earlier transfers (Figs. 1, 2). Even in the case of Ndebele, we may have missed a previous transfer during the conception period if it lasted for only a few days (Table S3). Furthermore, the transferring female may have confused the new silverback by mating with him soon after transfer, as it is known that female gorillas copulate throughout pregnancy (Robbins 2003; Doran‐Sheehy et al. 2009). (Copulation by these three females was not observed, but this is not surprising given that copulation could only be rarely observed due to the presence of swampy vegetation in the clearing.) The mating behaviour of a transferring female may thus play a decisive role in preventing infanticide (van Schaik 2000b). However, the effectiveness of mating to confuse paternity and prevent infanticide decreases as pregnancy progresses. For example, infanticidal attacks after group takeovers were prevented when females mated during pregnancy until around 80 days before parturition in red colobus (151-day gestation period), 60 days in Hanuman langurs (198-day gestation period), 45 days in blue monkeys (138-day gestation period) and 40 days in sooty mangabeys (165-day gestation period) (van Schaik 2000b). Thus females in these species seem to be able to successfully prevent infanticide by spending at least 25–50% of their gestation period with a new male. The Mbeli females spent > 50% of their gestation period with the new silverback. The only observed case of unsuccessful transfer of a pregnant female at Mbeli (after group disintegration) occurred when she spent only 2 months with the new silverback (~ 25% of the gestation period) (Stokes et al. 2003). A prolonged period spent with the same male between the transfer (and potentially also the first mating) of a pregnant female and birth of her offspring may therefore be necessary to prevent infanticide. The timing of transfer may be more important than whether the dispersal is voluntary.
Another question remains as to why these females transferred while pregnant despite the substantial risk of infanticide. Hypothetically, a female may struggle to transfer during the limited time window between weaning her offspring and next conception if a silverback prevents her from doing so through herding (Sicotte 1993; Breuer et al. 2016). It is also possible that silverbacks of a group may avoid intergroup encounters to prevent a female from transferring (Watts 1994), which may occur more commonly in silverbacks that are older and weaker towards the end of their tenure (M. L. M., personal observation), or that a silverback’s physical condition may deteriorate suddenly after a female conceives. In these scenarios, poor male condition may lead to the transfer of females when they are pregnant, although a male’s condition rarely deteriorates suddenly after a female conceives. With regard to intergroup encounters, resident males typically cannot prevent these entirely. If a resident silverback is unable to protect offspring until weaning, then the lifetime reproductive success of a female might actually be higher if her infant is killed at birth (rather than postponing the inevitable). By deliberately risking infanticide, the dispersal of a pregnant female may be comparable to the termination of pregnancy observed in geladas (Roberts et al. 2012), or the abandonment of infants as seen in colobine monkeys (Sicotte et al. 2007).
Another possibility is that multiple transfers between two males is a bet-hedging strategy if a female is unsure which of the two is the better mate choice (Sicotte 2001). Females may need time with a new male/group to determine whether he/they are a better match than their current silverback (e.g. in terms of male quality, tolerance, mating ability, group size, and reaction of other females). In this regard, transferring multiple times between two males is somewhat analogous to male incursions or forays [e.g. in colobus monkeys (Sicotte and MacIntosh 2004)] and extra-group copulations seen in many mammalian species (Van Noordwijk and van Schaik 2000; Wolff and Macdonald 2004). In gorillas, extra-group copulations during inter-group encounters have been observed very rarely, and where they were observed involved immature individuals (Sicotte 2001). There is currently no evidence that infants are conceived during extra-group copulations in gorillas, e.g. a genetic study of 79 mountain gorilla infants that found that they were all sired in their respective groups (Bradley et al. 2005; Vigilant et al. 2015).
It is interesting that the extra-group paternity in our study population, where 1.5% of the infants lived in a group with a silverback that was not their father, is similar to that of human infants (1–2%) reported in a study where paternity confidence was high (Anderson 2006; Greeff and Erasmus 2015). Extra-group paternity, which is not uncommon in primates, is especially widespread in certain species (fat-tailed dwarf lemur, 44%; rhesus macaques, 36%; Japanese macaques, 33%), less common in others (chimpanzees, 7%; eastern lesser bamboo lemur, 8.5%) and completely absent in mountain gorillas and red-fronted lemurs (Isvaran and Clutton-Brock 2007). Isvaran and Clutton-Brock (2007) found that the number of cases of extra-group paternity increased in species with a short mating season and a large number of females where it was difficult for males to monopolize their mates. The low level of extra-group paternity found in our study of western lowland gorillas along with their lack of mating season and relatively small groups agrees with these findings. The low level of extra-group paternity may explain why males invested in the care of these infants even when there was doubt surrounding their paternity.
Our results suggest that pregnant females in the western lowland gorilla may be able to transfer to a new group under the right conditions (less than halfway into the gestation period) without incurring infanticide by a male, and highlight the behavioural plasticity that these females show in response to sexual coercion by males. The cases highlighted here do not challenge the hypothesis of sexually selected infanticide, as not every infant needs to be killed by a non-parent male to support this evolutionary strategy (van Schaik 2000b).
References
Anderson K (2006) How well does paternity confidence match actual paternity? Evidence from worldwide nonpaternity rates. Curr Anthropol 47:513–520
Bradley BJ, Robbins MM, Williamson EA, Dieter Steklis H, Gerald Steklis N, Eckhardt BC, Vigilant L (2005) Mountain gorilla tug-of-war: silverbacks have limited control over reproduction in multimale groups. PNAS 102(26):9418–9423
Breuer T, Hockemba MB-N, Olejniczak C, Parnell RJ, Stokes EJ (2009) Physical maturation, life-history classes and age estimates of free-ranging western gorillas—insights from Mbeli Bai, Republic of Congo. Am J Primatol 71:106–119
Breuer T, Robbins A, Olejniczak C, Parnell RJ, Stokes EJ, Robbins MM (2010) Variance in the male reproductive success of western gorillas: acquiring females is just the beginning. Behav Ecol Sociobiol 64:515–528
Breuer T, Robbins AM, Robbins MM (2016) Sexual coercion and courtship by male western gorillas. Primates 57:29–38
Clutton-Brock T (2007) Sexual selection in males and females. Science 318:1882–1885
Debeffe L, Richard E, Medill SA, Weisgerber JN, McLoughlin PD (2015) Costs of social dispersal in a polygynous mammal. Behav Ecol 26:1476–1485
Doran-Sheehy DM, Fernández D, Borries C (2009) The strategic use of sex in wild female western gorillas. Am J Primatol 71:1011–1020
Greeff JM, Erasmus JC (2015) Three hundred years of low non-paternity in a human population. Heredity 115:396–404
Harcourt AH, Stewart KJ (2007) Gorilla society: conflict, compromise, and cooperation between the sexes. Chicago University Press, Chicago
Hrdy SB (1977) Infanticide as a primate reproductive strategy. Am Sci 65:40–49
Isvaran K, Clutton-Brock T (2007) Ecological correlates of extra-group paternity in mammals. Proc R Soc Lond B 274(1607):219–224
Lewis RJ (2018) Female Power in Primates and the Phenomenon of Female Dominance. Rev Anthropol 47(1):533–551
Lukas D, Huchard E (2014) The evolution of infanticide by males in mammalian societies. Science 346:841–844
Manguette ML, Robbins AM, Breuer T, Stokes EJ, Parnell RJ, Robbins AM (2019) Intersexual conflict influences female reproductive success in a female-dispersing primate. Behav Ecol Sociobiol 73:118
Manguette ML, Robbins AM, Breuer T, Stokes EJ, Parnell RJ, Robbins AM (2020) Female dispersal patterns influenced by male tenure duration and group size in western lowland gorillas. Behav Ecol Sociobiol 74:81
Nagy M, Heckel G, Voigt CC, Mayer F (2007) Female-biased dispersal and patrilocal kin groups in a mammal with resource-defence polygyny. Proc R Soc Lond B 274:3019–3025
Nowell AA, Fletcher AW (2007) Development of independence from the mother in Gorilla gorilla gorilla. Int J Primatol 28:441–455
Palombit RA (2015) Infanticide as sexual conflict: coevolution of male strategies and female counterstrategies. CSH Perspect Biol 7:1–29
Parnell RJ (2002) Group size and structure in western lowland gorillas (Gorilla gorilla gorilla) at Mbeli Bai, Republic of Congo. Am J Primatol 56:193–206
Phillips JB, Abbot P, Rokas A (2015) Is preterm birth a human-specific syndrome? Evol Med Public Health 2015:136–148
Robbins MM (2003) Behavioral aspects of sexual selection in mountain gorillas. In: Jones CB (ed) Sexual selection and reproductive competition in primates: new perspectives and directions. American Society of Primatologists, Norman, pp 477–501
Robbins AM, Robbins MM (2015) Dispersal patterns of females in the genus Gorilla. Dispersing primate females. Springer, Berlin, pp 75–104
Robbins AM, Gray M, Basabose A, Uwingeli P, Mburanumwe I, Kagoda E, Robbins MM (2013) Impact of male infanticide on the social structure of mountain gorillas. PLOS ONE 8:e78256
Roberts EK, Lu A, Bergman TJ, Beehner JC (2012) A Bruce effect in wild geladas. Science 335:1222–1225
Sicotte P (1993) Inter-group encounters and female transfer in mountain gorillas: influence of group composition on male behavior. Am J Primatol 30:21–36
Sicotte P (2000) A case study of mother-son transfer in mountain gorillas. Primates 41:93–101
Sicotte P (2001) Female mate choice in mountain gorillas. In: Robbins MM, Sicotte P, Stewart KJ (eds) Mountain gorillas: three decades of research at Karisoke. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp 59–87
Sicotte P, MacIntosh AJ (2004) Inter-group encounters and male incursions in Colobus vellerosus in Central Ghana. Behaviour 141(5):533–553
Sicotte P, Teichroeb JA, Saj TL (2007) Aspects of male competition in Colobus vellerosus: preliminary data on male and female loud calling, and infant deaths after a takeover. Int J Primatol 28:627–636
Sicotte P, Teichroeb JA, Vayro JV, Fox SA, Badescu I, Wikberg EC (2017) The influence of male takeovers on female dispersal in Colobus vellerosus. Am J Primatol 79:e22436
Smuts BB, Smuts RW (1993) Male aggression and sexual coercion of females in nonhuman primates and other mammals: evidence and theoretical implications. Adv Stud Behav 22:1–63
Sterck EH, Willems EP, van Hooff JA, Wich SA (2005) Female dispersal, inbreeding avoidance and mate choice in Thomas langurs (Presbytis thomasi). Behaviour 142:845–868
Stokes EJ, Parnell RJ, Olejniczak C (2003) Female dispersal and reproductive success in wild western lowland gorillas (Gorilla gorilla gorilla). Behav Ecol Sociobiol 54:329–339
Teichroeb JA, Wikberg EC, Sicotte P (2009) Female dispersal patterns in six groups of ursine colobus (Colobus vellerosus): infanticide avoidance is important. Behav 146:551–582
van Schaik CP (2000a) Vulnerability to infanticide by males: patterns among mammals. In: van Schaik CP, Janson C (eds) Infanticide by males and its implications. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp 61–71
van Schaik CP (2000b) Infanticide by male primates: the sexual selection hypothesis revisited. In: van Schaik CP, Janson C (eds) Infanticide by males and its implications. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp 27–60
van Noordwijk M, van Schaik CP (2000) Reproductive patterns in eutherian mammals: adaptations against infanticide? In: van Schaik CP, Janson C (eds) Infanticide by males and its implications. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp 322–360
Vigilant L, Roy J, Bradley BJ, Stoneking CJ, Robbins MM, Stoinski TS (2015) Reproductive competition and inbreeding avoidance in a primate species with habitual female dispersal. Behav Ecol Sociobiol 69 (7):1163–1172
Watts DP (1989) Infanticide in mountain gorillas: new cases and a reconsideration of the evidence. Ethol 81:1–18
Watts DP (1994) The influence of male mating tactics on habitat use in mountain gorillas (Gorilla gorilla beringei). Primates 35:35–47
Wolff JO, Macdonald DW (2004) Promiscuous females protect their offspring. Trends Ecol Evol 19:127–134
Yamagiwa J, Kahekwa J, Basabose AK (2009) Infanticide and social flexibility in the genus Gorilla. Primates 50:293–303
Acknowledgements
Open access funding provided by Projekt DEAL. We are grateful to the Institut National de Recherche Forestière, Ministère de la Recherche Scientifique et de l’Innovation Technologique for permission to work in the Nouabalé-Ndoki National Park. We also thank the Ministère de l’Economie Forestière and the Agence Congolaise de la Faune et des Aires Protégées. We would like to thank Haneul Jang, Lauren White and especially Andrew Robbins for helpful discussions and revisions of previous versions of this manuscript, as well as two anonymous reviewers. We are grateful to the staff of the Nouabalé-Ndoki National Park Management Unit and the Wildlife Conservation Society Congo office for their support of the Mbeli Bai Study. The long-term research of the Mbeli Bai Study is supported by: Cologne Zoo; Columbus Zoo and Aquarium; Cincinnati Zoo and Botanical Garden; Cleveland Metroparks Zoo; Disney World Conservation Fund; Dublin Zoo; Riverbanks Zoo and Garden; Busch Gardens, SeaWorld; Woodland Park Zoo; and the Dutch Gorilla Foundation. M. L. M. received a research grant from the German Academic Exchange Program and a stipend from the Max Planck Institute for Evolutionary Anthropology.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Contributions
Data collection was performed by M. M., J. R. and V. K.; the first draft of the manuscript was written by M. L. M. and M. M. R.; all authors (except J. R.) commented on previous versions of the manuscript, and read and approved the final manuscript.
Corresponding author
Additional information
Publisher's Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Electronic supplementary material
Below is the link to the electronic supplementary material.
Rights and permissions
This article is published under an open access license. Please check the 'Copyright Information' section either on this page or in the PDF for details of this license and what re-use is permitted. If your intended use exceeds what is permitted by the license or if you are unable to locate the licence and re-use information, please contact the Rights and Permissions team.
About this article
Cite this article
Manguette, M.L., Breuer, T., Robeyst, J. et al. Infant survival in western lowland gorillas after voluntary dispersal by pregnant females. Primates 61, 743–749 (2020). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10329-020-00844-z
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10329-020-00844-z