Abstract
Surgeries utilizing human allograft tissues have increased dramatically in recent years. With this increase has come a greater reliance on the use of swab culturing to assess allograft tissues for microbial contamination prior to distribution. In contrast to the typical industrial microbiological uses for swabs, the tissue banking industry has relied on swab cultures as a sterility release method for allograft tissues. It has been reported in the literature that swabs have limitations, both in sensitivity and reproducibility, so their suitability as a final sterility release method was evaluated in this study. Two different swab-culturing systems were evaluated (COPAN, EZ Culturette) using human allograft tissues spiked with low levels of multiple bacterial and fungal microorganisms. The average microbial recoveries for all challenge microorganisms for each tissue type and each swab system were calculated. Percent recoveries for each challenge microorganism were also calculated and reported. The results indicated that both swab systems exhibited low and highly variable recoveries from the seeded allograft tissues. Further analysis indicated there was no statistical difference (∝=0.05) between the two swab systems. It is the recommendation of the authors that swab culturing not be used to assess relatively low levels of microbial contamination on allografts. Instead, alternative validated microbial detection methods with improved sensitivity and reproducibility should be employed and validated for this critical task.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
AAMI/ISO/ANSI (1995) Sterilization of medical devices—microbiological methods. Part 1: estimation of population of microorganisms on products. (AAMI/ISO/ANSI standards, ISO 11737) AAMI/ISO/ANSI, Washington, D.C.
Bill TJ, Ratliff CR, Donovan AM, et al (2001) Quantitative swab culture versus tissue biopsy: a comparison in chronic wounds. Ostomy Wound Manage 47:34–37
Blue SR, Singh VR, Saubolle MA (1995) Bacillus licheniformis bacteremia: five cases associated with indewelling central venous catheters. Clin Infect Dis 20:629–633
Brosnikoff CL, Rennie RP, Turnbull LC (2003) Evaluation of two swab transport systems and the recovery of anaerobic bacteria after variable incubation times and media. Abstr Am SocMicrobiol Meet 103:C-048
Centers for disease control and prevention (2002) Comprehensive procedures for collecting environmental samples for culturing Bacillus anthracis. Centers for disease control and prevention, Washington, D.C. (http://www.bt.cdc.gov/Agent/anthrax/environmental-sampling-apr2002.asp)
Centers for disease control and prevention (2003) Follow-up of deaths among US postal service workers potentially exposed to Bacillus anthracis—district of Columbia, 2001–2002. Morbid Mortal Wkly Rep 52:937–938
Centers for disease control and prevention (2001) Notice to readers: unexplained deaths following knee surgery—Minnesota, Nov 2001. Morbid Mortal Wkly Rep 50:1035–1036
Centers for disease control and prevention (2001) Septic arthritis following anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction using tendon allografts—Florida and Louisiana, 2000. Morbid Mortal Wkly Rep 50:1081–1083
Centers for disease control and prevention (2004) Summary of notifiable diseases—United States. Morbid Mortal Wkly Rep 51:1–84
Centers for disease control and prevention (2002) Update: allograft-associated bacterial infections—United States, 2002. Morbid Mortal Wkly Rep 51:207–210
Collee JG, Watt B, Brown R, Johnstone S (1974) The recovery of anaerobic bacteria from swabs. J Hyg 72:339
Deijkers RLM, Bloem RM, Petit PLC, et al (1997) Contamination of bone allografts: analysis of incidence and predisposing factors. J Bone Joint Surg Br 79B:161
Hornicek FJ, Woll JE, Kasprisin D (eds) (2002) Standards for tissue banking. American Association of Tissue Banks, Washington, D.C., pp 56–57
Kainer MA, Linden JV, Whaley DN, et al (2004) Clostridium infections associated with musculoskeletal-tissue allografts. New Engl J Med 350:25
Lemmen SW, Hafner H, Zolldann D, et al (2001) Comparison of two sampling methods for detection of gram-positive and gram-negative bacteria in the environment: moistened swabs versus RODAC plates. Int J Hyg Environ Health 203:245
Niskanen K, Pohja MS (1977) Comparative studies on the sampling and investigation of microbial contamination of surfaces by the contact and swab methods. J Appl Microbiol 42:53
Restaino L, Hemphill JB, Frampton EW, Bluestein RL (1994) Hycheck slides versus rodac plates compared to the swab technique for the recovery of bacteria from hard smooth surfaces. Dairy Food Environ Sanit 14:529
Rigney PR Jr (2004) State of the association 2004. Slides presented at the Board of Governors Meeting. Am Assoc Tissue Banks Annu Spring Meet 9
Roberts MA, Mills AR (2001) Evaluation of culturing methods at predicting allograft sterility for aseptically processed tissue. Abstr Annu Meet Am Assoc Tissue Banks 25:S-9
Roelofsen E, Van Leeuwen M, Meijer-Servers GJ, et al (1999) Evaluation of the effects of storage in two different swab fabrics and under three different transport conditions on recovery of aerobic and anaerobic bacteria. J Clin Microbiol 37:3041–3043
Rose L, Jensen B, Westbrook G, et al (2003) Recovery efficiency of swabs for sampling hard nonporous surfaces for Bacillus anthracis spores. Abstr Am Soc Microbiol Meet 103:Q-369
Scott E, Bloomfield SF, Barlow CG (1984) A comparison of contact plate and calcium alginate swab techniques for quantitative assessment of bacteriological contamination of environmental surfaces. J Appl Microbiol 56:317
United States Pharmacopeia/National Formulary (2004) Microbiological tests, sterility tests. United States Pharmacopeial Convention, Rockville
United States Pharmacopeia/National Formulary (2004) General information, validation of microbial recovery. United States Pharmacopeial Convention, Rockville
Veen MR, Bloem RM, Petit P (1994) Sensitivity and negative predictive value of swab cultures in musculoskeletal allograft procurement. Clin Orthop 300:259
Vehmeyer SBW, Bloem RM, Dijkers RLM, et al (1999) A comparative study of blood and bone marrow cultures in cadaveric bone donation. J Hosp Infect 43:305
Vehmeyer SBW, Bloem RM, Petit PLC (2001) Microbiological screening of post-mortem bone donors—two case reports. J Hosp Infect 47:193
Workowski KA, Flaherty JP (1992) Systemic bacillus species infection mimicking listeriosis of pregnancy. Clin Infect Dis 14:694–696
Yrios JW, Balish E, Helstad A, et al (1975) Survival of anaerobic and aerobic bacteria on cotton swabs in three transport systems. J Clin Microbiol 1:196
Acknowledgements
The authors wish to thank the donor families for their gift of donation to help make this research possible. Thanks go to Gayla Fernandez for her laboratory assistance in the generation of the study data. The execution of this study was funded and conducted by AlloSource, a not-for-profit Tissue Bank. The authors do not have any commercial affiliations associated with the outcome of this study.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Ronholdt, C.J., Bogdansky, S. The appropriateness of swab cultures for the release of human allograft tissue. J IND MICROBIOL BIOTECHNOL 32, 349–354 (2005). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10295-005-0251-0
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10295-005-0251-0