Abstract
Even with the increasing importance being placed on research into immigrant elders’ healthcare use as countries change their policies to reflect their increasing immigrant and aging populations, little research has examined changes in healthcare use disparities between immigrant and native elders in relation to these policy changes. To fill this gap in the literature, this study examined healthcare disparities in relation to the welfare reform that the US implemented in 1996 and then compared significant indicators of immigrants’ healthcare use during the pre- and post-reform periods. The difference-in-difference (DD) analyses and post hoc probing of the DD analyses were used in multivariate logistic regression of the National Health Information Survey data that were pooled for the pre- and post-reform periods. The results revealed that while inequalities in healthcare existed before the reform, they significantly increased after the reform. A further test showed that the changes in the inequalities were significant among relatively long-stay immigrants, but not significant among immigrants who entered the US before the reform and thus were exempted from the reform restrictions. During the pre-reform period, insurance, employment, sex, and race/ethnicity were related to healthcare use; however, the enabling factors (i.e., insurance, income, and education) and social structural factors (i.e., marital status, family structure, length of US residency, race/ethnicity, and geographical region) explained the post-reform immigrants’ healthcare use, while controlling for healthcare needs factors. These findings suggest that welfare reform may be the driving force of inequalities in healthcare.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Abramovitz, M., Zelnick, J.: Double jeopardy: the impact of neoliberalism on care workers in the United States and South Africa. Int. J. Health Serv. 40(1), 97–117 (2010)
Jenson, J.: Redesigning citizenship regimes after neoliberalism: moving towards social investment. In: Morel, N., Palier, B., Palme, J. (eds.) What future for social investment?, pp. 27–44. Institute for Future Studies, Stockholm (2009)
Siddiqi, A., Kawachi, I., Keating, D.P., Hertzman, C.: A comparative study of population health in the United States and Canada during the neoliberal era, 1980–2008. Int. J. Health Serv. 43(2), 193–216 (2013)
Arentz, C., Eekhoff, J., Kochskämper, S.: Private health insurance: a role model for European health systems. Eur. J. Health Econ. 13(5), 615–621 (2012)
Boas, T.C., Gans-Morse, J.: Neoliberalism: from new liberal philosophy to anti-liberal slogan. Stud. Comp. Int. Dev. 44(2), 137–161 (2009)
Gelormino, E., Bambra, C., Spadea, T., Bellini, S., Costa, G.: The effects of health care reforms on health inequalities: a review and analysis of the European evidence base. Int. J. Health Serv. 41(2), 209–230 (2011)
Pavolini, E., Ranci, C.: Restructuring the welfare state: reforms in long-term care in Western European countries. J. Eur. Soc. Policy 18(3), 246–259 (2008)
Maarse, H.: The privatization of health care in Europe: an eight-country analysis. J. Health Polit. Polic. 31(5), 981–1014 (2006)
Saltman, R., Figueras, J.: European health care reform. World Health Organization, Copenhagen (1997)
Saltman, R.B., Figueras, J.: Analyzing the evidence on European health care reforms. Health Affair. 17(2), 85–108 (1998)
Joppke, C.: Beyond national models: civic integration policies for immigrants in Western Europe. West Eur. Polit. 30(1), 1–22 (2007)
Kraler, A.: Civic stratification, gender and family migration policies in Europe (final report). ICMPD/BMWF, Vienna (2010)
Sainsbury, D.: Immigrants’ social rights in comparative perspective: welfare regimes, forms of immigration and immigration policy regimes. J. Eur. Soc. Policy 16(3), 229–244 (2006)
Staver, A.: Hard work for love: the economic drift in Norwegian family immigration and integration policies. J. Fam. Issues 36(1), 1453–1471 (2015)
Østergaard-Nielsen, E.: Counting the costs: Denmark’s changing migration policies. Int. J. Urban Regional 27(2), 448–454 (2003)
Sales, R.: The deserving and the undeserving? Refugees, asylum seekers and welfare in Britain. Crit. Soc. Policy 22(3), 456–478 (2002)
Minderhoud, P.E.: Het Immigratiebeleid (The immigration policy). In: Entzinger, H., Van der Meer, J. (eds.) Grenzeloze Solidariteit. Naareen Migratiebestendige Verzorgingsstaat (Solidarity without borders. Towards a migration-proof welfare state), De Balie, Amsterdam (2004)
Durán, A., Lara, J.L., van Waveren, M.: Spain: health system review. Health Syst Transit 8(4), 1–208 (2006)
De Cock, K.M.: Trends in global health and CDC’s international role, 1961–2011. Morb. Mortal. Wkly Rep. 60(04), 104–111 (2011)
De Cock, K.M., Simone, P.M., Davison, V., Slutsker, L.: The new global health. Emerg. Infect. Dis. 19, 1192–1197 (2013)
Marmot, M., Atkinson, T., Bell, J., Black, C., Broadfoot, P., Cumberlege, J., Diamond, I., Gilmore, I., Ham, C., Meacher, M., Mulgan, G.: Fair society healthy lives: the Marmot review. Strategic review of health inequalities in England post-2010. University College London, London (2010)
Buron, A., Cots, F., Garcia, O., Vall, O., Castells, X.: Hospital emergency department utilization rates among the immigrant population in Barcelona, Spain. BMC Health Serv. Res. 8(51), 1–10 (2008)
Jiménez-Rubio, D., Hernández-Quevedo, C.: Inequalities in the use of health services between immigrants and the native population in Spain: what is driving the differences? Eur. J. Health Econ. 12(1), 17–28 (2011)
Koning, E.A., Banting, K.G.: Inequality below the surface: reviewing immigrants’ access to and utilization of five Canadian welfare programs. Can. Public. Pol. 39(4), 581–601 (2013)
Mahmoud, I., Hou, X.: Immigrants and the utilization of hospital emergency departments. World J Emerg Med 3(4), 245–250 (2012)
Stronks, K., Ravelli, A., Reijneveld, S.: Immigrants in the Netherlands: equal access for equal needs? J. Epidemiol. Commun. H. 55(10), 701–707 (2001)
Solé-Auró, A., Guillén, M., Crimmins, E.M.: Health care usage among immigrants and native-born elderly populations in eleven European countries: results from SHARE. Eur. J. Health Econ. 13(6), 741–754 (2012)
Wendt, C., Frisina, L., Rothgang, H.: Healthcare system types: a conceptual framework for comparison. Soc. Policy Admin. 43(1), 70–90 (2009)
Burau, V.: Transforming health policy and services: challenges for comparative research. Curr. Sociol. 60(4), 569–578 (2012)
Gupta, K.: Comparative public policy: using the comparative method to advance our understanding of the policy process. Policy Stud. J. 40(S1), 11–26 (2012)
Heidenheimer, A.J., Heclo, H., Adams, C.T.: Comparative public policy: the politics of social choice in Europe and America. St. Martin’s Press, New York (1983)
Jasper, J.M.: Two or twenty countries: contrasting styles of comparative research. Comp. Soc. Re. 10, 205–229 (1987)
Lipset, S.M.: Historical traditions and national characteristics: a comparative analysis of Canada and the United States. Can. J. Sociol. 11(2), 113155 (1986)
Rinnert, D.: The politics of civil service and administrative reforms in development: explaining within-country variation of reform outcomes in Georgia after the rose evolution. Public Admin. Dev. 35, 19–33 (2015)
Ashenfelter, O., Card, D.: Using the longitudinal structure of earnings to estimate the effect of training programs. Rev. Econ. Stat. 67, 648–660 (1985)
Krieger, N.: Epidemiology and social sciences: towards a critical reengagement in the 21st century. Epidemiol. Rev. 22(1), 155–163 (2000)
Krieger, N.: Theories for social epidemiology in the 21st century: an ecosocial perspective. Int. J. Epidemiol. 30(4), 668–677 (2001)
Galea, S.: An argument for a consequentialist epidemiology. Am. J. Epidemiol. 178(8), 1185–1191 (2013)
O’Campo, P.: Are we producing the right kind of actionable evidence for the social determinants of health? J. Urban Health 89(6), 881–893 (2012)
Brunner, L., Colarelli, M.S.: Immigration in the twenty-first century: a personal selection approach. Indep. Rev. 14(3), 389–413 (2010)
Jasso, G., Rosenzweig, M.R.: Family reunification and the immigration multiplier: U.S. immigration law, origin-country conditions, and the reproduction of immigrants. Demography 23(3), 291–311 (1986)
Carr, S., Tienda, M.: Family sponsorship and late-age immigration in aging America: revised and expanded estimates of chained migration. Popul. Res. Policy Rev. 32, 825–849 (2013)
Kandel, W.A.: U.S. family-based immigration policy. Congressional Research Service, Washington, D.C. (2014)
Zong, J., Batalova, J.: Frequently requested statistics on immigrants and immigration in the United States. Migration Policy Institute, Washington, D.C. (2015)
Batalova, J., Lee, A.: Frequently requested statistics on immigrants and immigration in the United States. Migration Policy Institute, Washington D.C (2012)
He, W.: The older foreign-born population in the United States: 2000. US Census Bureau, Washington, D.C. (2002)
Leach, M.A.: America’s older immigrants: a profile. Generations 32(4), 34–39 (2009)
O’Neil, K., Tienda, M.: Age at immigration and the incomes of older immigrants, 1994–2010. J. Gerontol. B Psychol. 70(2), 291–302 (2015)
Kritz, M.M., Gurak, D.T., Chen, L.: Elderly immigrants: their composition and living arrangements. J. Sociol. Soc. Welfare 27(1), 85 (2000)
Beckfield, J., Krieger, N.: Epi+ demos+ cracy: linking political systems and priorities to the magnitude of health inequities—evidence, gaps and a research agenda. Epidemiol. Rev. 31, 152–177 (2009)
Esping-Andersen, G.: The three worlds of welfare capitalism. Princeton University Press, New Jersey (1990)
Sainsbury, D.: Welfare states and immigrant rights: the politics of inclusion and exclusion. Oxford University Press, Oxford (2012)
Xu, Q.: Globalization, immigration and the welfare state: a cross-national comparison. J. Sociol. Soc. Welfare 34(2), 87–106 (2007)
Angel, J.L.: Devolution and the social welfare of elderly immigrants: who will bear the burden? Public Admin. rev. 63(1), 79–89 (2003)
Fremstad, S., Cox, L.: Covering New Americans: a review of federal and state policies related to immigrants eligibility and access to publicly funded health insurance. Kaiser Commission on Medicaid and the Uninsured, Washington, D.C. (2004)
Friedland, R.B., Pankaj, V.: Welfare reform and elderly legal immigrants. The Henry J. Kaiser Family Foundation, Washington, D.C. (1997)
Ku, L., Kessler, B.: The number and cost of immigrants on Medicaid, the national and state estimates. Urban Institute, Washington, D.C. (1997)
Buff, R.I.: Immigrant rights in the shadows of citizenship. New York University Press, New York (2008)
Kandula, N.R., Kersey, M., Lurie, N.: Assuring the health of immigrants: what the leading health indicators tell us. Annu. Rev. Publ. Health 25(1), 357–376 (2004)
Quadagno, J.: One nation, uninsured: why the US has no national health insurance. Oxford University Press, New York (2005)
Yelowitz, A.: Public policy and health insurance choices of the elderly: evidence from the Medicare buy-in program. J. Public Econ. 78(3), 301–324 (2000)
Choi, S.: Insurance status and health service utilization among newly-arrived older immigrants. J. Immigr. Minor. Health 8(2), 149–161 (2006)
Choi, S.: Longitudinal changes in access to health care by immigrant status among older adults: the importance of health insurance as a mediator. Gerontologist 51(2), 156–169 (2010)
Carrasquillo, O., Carrasquillo, A.I., Shea, S.: Health insurance coverage of immigrants living in the United States: differences by citizenship status and country of origin. Am. J. Public Health 90(6), 917–923 (2000)
Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services: Medicare 2015 & 2016 costs at a glance. https://www.medicare.gov/your-medicare-costs/costs-at-a-glance/costs-at-glance.html (2015). Accessed 27 Dec 2015
Andersen, R.M.: Revisiting the behavioral model and access to medical care: does it matter? J. Health Soc. Behav. 36(1), 1–10 (1995)
Aday, L.A., Andersen, R.M.: Models of health care utilization and behavior. In: Armitage, P., Colton, T. (eds.) Encyclopedia of biostatistics, pp. 1841–1845. Wiley, New York (1998)
Choi, S.: A critical review of theoretical frameworks for health service use among older immigrants in the United States. Soc Theory Health 9(2), 183–202 (2011)
National Center for Health Statistics: National Health Interview Survey (NHIS): Public-use data release: NHIS survey description document. National Center for Health Statistics, Washington, D.C (2014)
National Center for Health Statistics: Variance estimation guidance, NHIS 2006–2014: Adapted from the 2006–2014 NHIS survey description documents. http://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/nhis/2006var.pdf (2015). Accessed 17 June 2015
National Center for Health Statistics: 1998 National Health Interview Survey (NHIS): Public-use data release: NHIS survey description document. National Center for Health Statistics, Washington, D.C (2000)
National Center for Health Statistics: Variance estimation and other analytic issues in the 1997–2005 NHIS: adapted from appendices III and VII of the 2005 NHIS survey description document, and appendix III of the 2006 NHIS survey description document. http://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/nhis/9705var.pdf (2009). Accessed 17 June 2015
Burg, M.M., Seeman, T.E.: Families and health: the negative side of social ties. Ann. Behav. Med. 16, 109–115 (1994)
Samek, D.A., Laporte, A., Nauenberg, E., Shen, L., Coyte, P.C.: The effect of social capital on the use of general practitioners: a comparison of immigrants and non-immigrants in Ontario. Health Policy 8(1), 49–66 (2012)
Harteloh, P.P.M.: The meaning of quality in health care: a conceptual analysis. Health Care Anal. 11, 259–267 (2003)
Lee, K.J., Simpson, J.A.: Introduction to multiple imputation for dealing with missing data. Respirology 19, 162–167 (2014)
Holmbeck, G.N.: Post-hoc probing of significant moderational and mediational effects in studies of pediatric populations. J. Pediatr. Psychol. 27(1), 87–96 (2002)
Hjelm, K., Albin, B.: Limited focus on the use of health care by elderly migrants: a literature review. Open J Nurs 4, 465–473 (2014)
Albin, B., Albertsson, M., Ekberg, J., Hjelm, K.: Health and consumption of health care and social service among old migrants in Sweden. Prim Health Care Res Dev 6(1), 37–45 (2005)
Denktaş, S., Koopmans, G., Birnie, E., Foets, M., Bonsel, G.: Ethnic background and differences in health care use: a national cross-sectional study of native Dutch and immigrant elderly in the Netherlands. Int J Equity Health 8(35) (2009)
Yeo, Y.S., Johnson, M.M.: Healthy immigrant effect on older adult immigrants in relation to welfare reform. J Soc Soc Work Res 4(3), 182–197 (2013)
Adler, N.E., Stewart, J.: Health disparities across the lifespan: meaning, methods, and mechanisms. Ann. NY Acad. Sci. 1186(1), 5–23 (2010)
Graham, H.: Social determinants and their unequal distribution: clarifying policy understandings. Milbank Q. 82(1), 101–124 (2004)
Teghtsoonian, K.: Depression and mental health in neoliberal times: a critical analysis of policy and discourse. Soc. Sci. Med. 69(1), 28–35 (2009)
Woodall, J.R., Warwick-Booth, L., Cross, R.: Has empowerment lost its power? Health Educ. Res. 27(4), 742–745 (2012)
European Network on Patient Empowerment: 1st European congress on patient empowerment. http://www.enope.eu/activities/congress-2012.aspx (2012). Accessed 27 July 2015
Holmström, I., Roïng, M.: The relation between patient-centeredness and patient empowerment: a discussion on concepts. Patient Educ. Couns. 79(2), 167–172 (2010)
Menon, S.T.: Toward a model of psychological health empowerment: implications for health care in multicultural communities. Nurs. Educ. Today 22(1), 28–39 (2002)
Derose, K.P., Escarce, J.J., Lurie, N.: Immigrants and health care: sources of vulnerability. Health Affair. 26(5), 1258–1268 (2007)
Feld, P., Power, B.: Immigrants’ access to health care after welfare reform: findings from focus groups in four cities. Kaiser Commission on Medicaid and the Uninsured, Washington, D.C. (2000)
Kaushal, N., Kaestner, R.: Welfare reform and health insurance of immigrants. Health Serv. Res. 40(3), 697–721 (2005)
Borjas, G.J.: Welfare reform, labor supply, and health insurance in the immigrant population. J. Health Econ. 22(6), 933–958 (2003)
Gerdtham, U-G., Jönsson, B.: Chapter 1 international comparisons of health expenditure: theory, data and econometric analysis. Handbook of Health Economics, 1(Part A), 11–53 (2000)
Kröger, T., Silipa, J.: Overstretched: European families up against the demands of work and care. Blackwell, Oxford (2005)
Boucher, A.: Familialism and migrant welfare policy: restrictions on social security provision for newly arrived immigrants. Policy Polit. 42(3), 367–384 (2014)
Albert, I., Ferring, D., Michels, T.: Intergenerational support and the emotional well-being of older Jews and Arabs in Israel. Eur. Psychol. 18(1), 59–69 (2013)
Chappell, N.L., Funk, L.M.: Social support, caregiving, and aging. Can. J. Aging 30(3), 355–370 (2011)
Chen, R., Simon, M.A., Chang, E.S., Zhen, Y., Dong, X.: The perception of social support among U.S. Chinese older adults: findings from the PINE Study. J. Aging Health 26(7), 1137–1154 (2014)
Dietz, T.L.: Patterns of intergenerational assistance within the Mexican American family: is the family taking care of the older generation’s needs? J. Fam. Issues 16(3), 344–356 (1995)
Hoff, A.: Patterns of intergenerational support in grandparent-grandchild and parent-child relationships in Germany. Aging Soc 27(05), 643–665 (2007)
Weeks, J.R., Cuellar, J.B.: The role of family members in the helping networks of older people. Gerontologist 21(4), 388–394 (1981)
Bass, S.A., Caro, F.G.: The economic value of grandparent assistance. Generations 20(1), 29–33 (1996)
Fabian, T.: Großeltern als helfer in familialen krisen [Grandparents as helpers in family crises]. Neue Praxis 24(6), 384–396 (1994)
Fthenakis, W.E.: Intergenerative familiale Beziehungen nach Scheidung und Wiederheirat aus der Sicht der Großeltern [Intergenerative family relations after divorce and remarriage from the perspective of the grandparents]. Zeitschr Soziol Erziehung Sozial 18(2), 152–167 (1998)
Glick, J.E., Bean, F.D., Van Hook, J.V.W.: Immigration and changing patterns of extended family household structure in the United States: 1970–1990. J. Marriage Fam. 59(1), 177–191 (1997)
Leach, M.A.: A burden of support? Household structure and economic resources among Mexican immigrant families. J. Fam. Issues 35(1), 28–53 (2014)
Treas, J., Mazumdar, S.: Older people in America’s immigrant families: dilemmas of dependence, integration, and isolation. J. Aging Stud. 16(3), 243–258 (2002)
Treas, J., Mazumdar, S.: Kinkeeping and caregiving: contributions of older people in immigrant families. J. Comp. Fam. Stud. 35(1), 105–122 (2004)
Fix, M., Laglagaron, L.: Social rights and citizenship: an international comparison: a report of the working group on social rights and citizenship of the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace Comparative Citizenship Project. The Urban Institute, Washington, D.C. (2002)
McCabe, K., Meissner, D.: Immigration and the United States: recession affects flows, prospects for reform. Migration Policy Institute, Washington, D.C. (2010)
Casado, B., Sacco, P.: Correlates of caregiver burden among family caregivers of older Korean Americans. J. Gerontol. B Psychol. 67(3), 331–336 (2012)
Covinsky, K.E., Goldman, L., Cook, E.F., Oye, R., Desbiens, N., Reding, D., Fulkerson, W., Connors, A.F., Lynn, J., Phillips, R.S.: The impact of serious illness on patients’ families. J. Am. Med. Assoc. 272(23), 1839–1844 (1994)
Lai, D.W.L.: Effect of financial costs on caregiving burden of family caregivers of older adults. SAGE Open 2(4), 1–14 (2012)
Stewart, M.J., Neufeld, A., Harrison, M.J., Spitzer, D., Hughes, K., Makwarimba, E.: Immigrant women family caregivers in Canada: implications for policies and programmes in health and social sectors. Health Soc. Care Commun 14(4), 329–340 (2006)
Strasser, E., Kraler, A., Bonjour, S., Bilger, V.: Doing family: responses to state constructions of “the migrant family” across Europe. Hist Family 14(2), 165–176 (2009)
National Bureau of Economic Research. US business cycle expansions and contractions. http://www.nber.org/cycles.html (2015). Accessed 27 July 2015
Charsley, K.: Transnational marriage. In: Charsley, K. (ed.) Transnational marriage: new perspectives from Europe and beyond, pp. 3–22. Routledge, London (2012)
The World Bank. GDP growth (annual %). http://data.worldbank.org/indicator/NY.GDP.MKTP.KD.ZG (2015). Accessed 27 July 2015
Wasem, R.E.: U.S. immigration policy: chart book of key trends. Congressional Research Service, Washington, D.C. (2013)
Islam, N.S., Khan, S., Kwon, S., Jang, D., Ro, M., Trinh-Shevrin, C.: Methodological issues in the collection, analysis, and reporting of granular data in Asian American populations: historical challenges and potential solutions. J. Health Care Poor Underserved 21(4), 1354–1381 (2010)
US Census Bureau. Historical income tables—households. http://www.census.gov/hhes/www/income/data/historical/household/ (2014). Accessed 18 Apr 2016
Acknowledgments
This study was supported by a grant from the Faculty Research Grant Committee at St. Cloud State University.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Yeo, Y. Healthcare inequality issues among immigrant elders after neoliberal welfare reform: empirical findings from the United States. Eur J Health Econ 18, 547–565 (2017). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10198-016-0809-y
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10198-016-0809-y
Keywords
- Inequalities
- Elderly immigrant population
- Neoliberalism
- Welfare reform
- Health care use
- National Health Information Survey