Abstract
In this case study, we investigated the conversion of an existing Swedish kraft pulp mill to the production of dissolving pulp, with export of electricity, lignin, and a hemicellulose stream suitable for upgrading. By increasing the level of heat integration of the mill, it was possible to achieve self-sufficiency in terms of steam and to produce significant amounts of excess steam. The excess steam could facilitate the integration of a lignin separation plant or be used for power generation. The production of dissolving pulp requires a higher input of wood that is required for the same level of pulp production as is achieved with kraft pulp. For the studied mill, the batch digester was the main limitation for pulp production. Nevertheless, if the digester capacity was increased, then the level of pulp production could be maintained. In addition, the recovery boiler, causticization plant, and evaporation plant had sufficient capacities for preserving the same production level upon conversion, and could easily be upgraded to a certain degree through relatively simple measures for an increase in pulp production. However, increasing pulp production beyond that limit required extensive upgrades or investments in new equipment, which negatively affected annual earnings. Annual earnings were found to be also dependent upon the level of heat integration, type of by-product, and the costs for lignin and electricity. However, our results suggest that the optimal process configuration is more dependent upon other factors, such as the long-term vision of the company and policy instruments.
Similar content being viewed by others
Abbreviations
- a:
-
Annuity factor [1/years] see Eq. 2
- ADt:
-
Air-dried metric tons, i.e., 90 % solids content
- CEPCI:
-
Chemical engineering plant cost index
- cost2012 :
-
Equipment investment cost updated to year 2012 with CEPCI; see Eq. 3
- costoriginal year :
-
Equipment investment cost in the reference year; see Eq. 3
- cA :
-
Equipment cost having a corresponding size sA; see Eq. 4
- cB :
-
Equipment cost having a corresponding size sB; see Eq. 4
- GCC:
-
Grand composite curve (of pinch analysis)
- HWWS:
-
Hot and warm water system
- HX:
-
Heat exchanger
- i:
-
Interest rate for an investment; see Eq. 2
- LP:
-
Low-pressure steam; 4.5 bar (a)
- MP:
-
Medium-pressure steam; 11 bar (a)
- n:
-
The economic lifetime of an investment [years]; see Eq. 2
- RB:
-
Recovery boiler
- SEK:
-
Swedish crown (currency)
- ΔT:
-
Driving temperature difference (in the heat exchanger)
- ΔT min :
-
Minimum ΔT for the pinch analyses
- €:
-
Euro (currency)
References
Chemical-Engineering (2013) Chemical Engineering’s Plant Cost Index. http://www.che.com/pci/. Accessed 25 Apr 2013
Delin L, Berglin N, Lundström A, Samuelsson A, Backlund B, Sivard A (2005) FRAM 09: bleached market kraft pulpmill. STFI, Stockholm
Hamaguchi M, Kautto J, Vakkilainen E (2013) Effects of hemicellulose extraction on the kraft pulp mill operation and energy use: review and case study with lignin removal. Chem Eng Res Des 91(7):1284–1291
Harvey S, Axelsson E (2010) Scenarios for assessing profitability and carbon balances of energy investments in industry. http://publications.lib.chalmers.se/records/fulltext/98347.pdf. Accessed 05 June 2013
Jylhä P, Dahl O, Laitila J, Kärhä K (2010) The effect of supply system on the wood paying capability of a kraft pulp mill using scots pine harvested from first thinnings. Silva Fennica 44(4):695–714
Laaksometsä C, Axelsson E, Berntsson T, Lundström A (2009) Energy savings combined with lignin extraction for production increase: case study at a eucalyptus mill in Portugal. Clean Technol Environ Policy 11(1):77–82
Lundberg V, Axelsson E, Mahmoudkhani M, Berntsson T (2012a) Energy Analysis for Conversion of a Kraft Pulp Mill into a Dissolving Pulp Mill. Chem Eng Trans 29. doi: 10.3303/CET1229003
Lundberg V, Axelsson E, Mahmoudkhani M, Berntsson T (2012b) Process integration of near-neutral hemicellulose extraction in a Scandinavian kraft pulp mill—Consequences for the steam and Na/S balances. Appl Therm Eng 43:42–50
Lundberg V, Mahmoudkhani M, Berntsson T, Axelsson E (2013a) Converting a kraft pulp mill into a multi-product biorefinery—Part 1: energy aspects. Nord Pulp Paper Res J 28(4):480–488
Lundberg V, Mahmoudkhani M, Svensson E, Axelsson E (2013b) Converting a kraft pulp mill into a multi-product biorefinery—Part 2: economic aspects. Nord Pulp Paper Res J 28(4):489–505
Macdonald C (2011) Dissolving pulp draws renewed interest. Pulp Paper Can 112(3):19–26
Marinova M, Mateos-Espejel E, Paris J (2010) From kraft mill to forest biorefinery: an energy and water perspective. II. Case study. Cell Chem Technol 44(1–3):21–26
Mateos-Espejel E, Radiotis T, Jemaa N (2013) Implications of converting a kraft pulp mill to a dissolving pulp operation with a hemicellulose extraction stage. Tappi J 12(2):29–38
McCormick C (2013) Wild ride for dissolving pulp. Pulp Paper Can 114(5):24–26
Moshkelani M, Marinova M, Perrier M, Paris J (2013) The forest biorefinery and its implementation in the pulp and paper industry: energy overview. Appl Therm Eng 50(2):1427–1436
Olsson MR, Axelsson E, Berntsson T (2006) Exporting lignin or power from heat-integrated kraft pulp mills: a techno-economic comparison using model mills. Nord Pulp Paper Res J 21(4):476–484
PaperAge (2013) The pix pulp benchmark indexes. http://www.paperage.com/foex/pulp.html. Accessed 25 Apr 2013
Shahid Ul I, Shahid M, Mohammad F (2013) Perspectives for natural product based agents derived from industrial plants in textile applications—A review. J Clean Prod 57:2–18
Sinnott RK (2005) Costing and Project Evaluation. In: Sinnott RK (ed) Coulson and Richardson’s Chemical Engineering Design, vol 6. 4th edn. Elsevier Butterworth-Heinemann, Oxford, pp 243–283
Sixta H, Iakovlev M, Testova L, Roselli A, Hummel M, Borrega M, van Heiningen A, Froschauer C, Schottenberger H (2013) Novel concepts of dissolving pulp production. Cellulose 20(4):1547–1561
Smith RM (2007) Chemical process: design and integration. Wiley, Chichester
Södra (2012) Massapriset höjs till 840 dollar per ton (In Swedish). http://www.sodra.com/sv/Pressrum/Nyheter/Inlagg/Pressmeddelande/Aktuella-nyheter/Massapriset-hojs-till-840-dollar-per-ton/. Accessed 14 Feb 2013
Swedish Forest Agency (2013) Price trends for pulpwood for coniferous, Norway spruce and birch, delivery logs, in the price level of 2012. http://www.skogsstyrelsen.se/Myndigheten/Statistik/Amnesomraden/Priser/Tabeller–figurer/. Accessed 12 June 2013
Tomani P (2010) The lignoboost process. Cell Chem Technol 44(1–3):53–58
Acknowledgments
The authors acknowledge the financial support of the Södra Foundation for Research, Development and Education. We are grateful to the personnel at the mill for supplying data and answering our questions, with special thanks to Gustaf Collin, Linda Rudén, and Maria Edberg.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Lundberg, V., Bood, J., Nilsson, L. et al. Converting a kraft pulp mill into a multi-product biorefinery: techno-economic analysis of a case mill. Clean Techn Environ Policy 16, 1411–1422 (2014). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10098-014-0741-8
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10098-014-0741-8