Abstract
We comment on a recent Ecosystem paper by Odion and Hanson (Ecosystems 9:1177–1189, 2006), in which the authors claim that high severity fire is rare in the Sierra Nevada under current conditions. Odion and Hanson’s results are predicated on BAER soil burn severity maps, which are based primarily on fire effects to soil, not vegetation. Odion and Hanson, and we fear others as well, are misinformed as to the nature of the BAER severity mapping process, and proper applications of BAER soil burn severity maps. By comparing the BAER soil burn severity maps to a true vegetation burn severity measure (RdNBR) calibrated by field data, we show that the area in the high soil burn severity class for the three fires analyzed by Odion and Hanson is substantially less than the area of stand-replacing fire, and that BAER maps—especially hand-derived maps such as those from two of the three fires—also greatly underestimate the heterogeneity in vegetation burn severity on burned landscapes. We also show that, contrary to Odion and Hanson’s claims, Fire Return Interval Departure (FRID) is strongly correlated with fire severity in conifer stands within the perimeter of the McNally Fire.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Agee JK. 1993. Fire ecology of Pacific Northwest forests. Washington (DC): Island Press
Bobbe T, Finco MV, Quayle B, Lannom K, Sohlberg R, Parsons A. 2001. Field measurements for the training and validation of burn severity maps from spaceborne, remotely sensed imagery. Final project report, Joint Fire Sciences Program 2001–2
Bond WJ, van Wilgen BW. 1996. Fire and plants. London: Chapman and Hall
Caprio A, Conover C, Keifer M, Lineback P. 2002. Fire management and GIS: a framework for identifying and prioritizing fire planning needs. Assoc Fire Ecol Misc Pub No. 1:102–13
Cissel JH, Swanson FJ, Weisberg PJ. 1999. Landscape management using historical fire regimes: Blue River, Oregon. Ecol Appl 9:1217–31
Elvidge CD. 1990. Visible and near infrared reflectance characteristics of dry plant materials. Int J Rem Sens 11:1775–95
FRCC. 2005. Interagency fire regime condition class guidebook. Version 1.2. Available at: http://www.frcc.gov
Hann WJ, Strohm DJ. 2003. Fire regime condition class and associated data for fire and fuels planning: methods and applications. In: Omi PN, Joyce LA, Eds. Fire, fuel treatments and ecological restoration: conference proceedings. Proceedings RMRS-P-29. Fort Collins (CO): USDA-Forest Service. pp 397–433
Hardwick P, Lachowski H, Griffith R, Parsons A. 2002. Burned Area Emergency Rehabilitation (BAER): use of remote sensing and GIS. Assoc Fire Ecol Misc Pub No. 1:147–52
James A, Bryant L, Schroder E, Loadholt S. 2000. Manter Fire soils report. 6 p, on file with the Sequoia National Forest, Porterville, CA, USA
Keifer M, Caprio A, Lineback P, Folger K. 2000. Incorporating a GIS model of ecological need into fire management planning. In: Neuenschwander LF, Ryan KC, Eds. Proceedings—crossing the millennium integrating spatial technologies and ecological principals for a new age in fire management. Moscow (ID): University of Idaho
Key CH, Benson NC. 2005. Landscape assessment (LA). Sampling and analysis methods. In: Lutes DC, Keane RE, Caratti JF, et al. Eds. FIREMON: fire effects monitoring and inventory system. General Technical Report, RMRS-GTR-164. Ogden (UT): USDA Forest Service, Rocky Mountain Research Station. p 55
Kokaly RF, Rockwell BW, Hiare SL, King TVV. 2007. Characterization of post-fire surface cover, soils, and burn severity at the Cerro Grande Fire, New Mexico, using hyperspectral and multispectral remote sensing. Rem Sens Environ 106:305–25
Miller JD, Thode AE. 2007. Quantifying burn severity in a heterogeneous landscape with a relative version of the delta normalized burn ratio (dNBR). Rem Sens Env (in press)
Morrison P, Swanson FJ. 1990. Fire history and pattern in a Cascade Range landscape. USDA-Forest Service General Technical Report PNW-GTR-254. Portland (OR): Pacific Northwest Research Station
Odion DC, Hanson CT. 2006. Fire severity in conifer forests of the Sierra Nevada, California. Ecosystems 9:1177–89
Parsons A. 2002. Burn severity mapping. McNally Fire BAER Team, GIS and remote sensing information. 5 p, on file with the Sequoia National Forest, Porterville, CA, USA
Parsons A. 2003. Draft Burned Area Emergency Rehabilitation (BAER) soil burn severity definitions and mapping guidelines. Salt Lake City (UT): USDA-Forest Service, Remote Sensing Application Center
Parsons A, Orlemann A. 2002. BAER burn severity mapping methods and definitions. McNally Fire, Sequioa National Forest, July–August 2002. 3 page report on file with the Sequoia National Forest, Porterville, CA, USA
FRCC. 2005. Interagency fire regime condition class guidebook, version 1.2. Available at: http://www.frcc.gov
Swetnam TW, Betancourt JL. 1998. Mesoscale disturbance and ecological response to decadal variability in the American Southwest. J Climatol 11: 3128–47
Taylor AH, Beaty RM. 2005. Climatic influences on fire regimes in the northern Sierra Nevada mountains, Lake Tahoe Basin, Nevada, USA. J Biogeogr 32: 425–38
Thode AE. 2005. Quantifying the fire regime attributes of severity and spatial complexity using field and imagery data. PhD Dissertation. Davis (CA): University of California
USFS. 1995. Burned Area Emergency Rehabilitation handbook. Forest Service Handbook 2509.13, Amendment No. 2509.13-95-7. Washington (DC): USDA-Forest Service
USFS. 2004. Sierra Nevada Forest Plan Amendment. Final Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement. Record of Decision. Publication R5-MB-046. Vallejo (CA): USDA-Forest Service, Pacific Southwest Region
Van Wagtendonk JW, Fites-Kaufman J. 2006. Sierra Nevada bioregion. In: Sugihara NG, van Wagtendonk JW, Shaffer KE, Fites-Kaufman J, Thode AE, Eds. Fire in California’s ecosystems. Berkeley: University of California Press. pp 264–94
Acknowledgments
This paper benefited from conversations with and/or reviews by the following USFS-BAER team leaders and members: S. Anderson, T. Bettinger, T. Ellsworth, A. Gallegos, F. Linton, T. Kaplan-Henry, C. Kennedy, A. Orlemann, and B. Rust. Thanks also to the following for review and advice: B. Bahro, T. Caprio, J. Clark, J. Keeley, M. Keifer, E. Knapp, J. Moghaddas, and B. Schwind. We also gratefully acknowledge the constructive comments of two anonymous reviewers.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Safford, H.D., Miller, J., Schmidt, D. et al. BAER Soil Burn Severity Maps Do Not Measure Fire Effects to Vegetation: A Comment on Odion and Hanson (2006). Ecosystems 11, 1–11 (2008). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10021-007-9094-z
Received:
Revised:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10021-007-9094-z