Abstract
Performance of WATCOM (a numerical model) and CRPSM (a simple water balance model) were assessed in simulating root zone water storage and water balance components under cowpea in Nigeria using a line source sprinkler system. Three sets of field data were collected: the first was used for calibration and model parameters’ estimation and the other two for testing and comparisons. The simulated soil water storage and crop evapotranspiration with WATCOM and CRPSM were in good agreement with field-measured data though WATCOM performed significantly better (P < 0.05) under the stressed condition. The maximum average error between predicted and measured soil water storage was −0.95 and +1.47 mm for WATCOM and CRPSM, respectively, while that between measured and predicted actual crop evapotranspiration was +2.7 and +11.38 mm, respectively, for the two models. WATCOM gave generally higher cumulative deep percolation and lower evapotranspiration than that of CRPSM for all irrigation levels (P < 0.05), and values of deep percolation for WATCOM were in better agreement with field data than that of CRPSM. This suggests that drainage below the field capacity needs to be included in CRPSM and that WATCOM will be a more useful management tool when detailed soil parameter is required and under variable water regime.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Allmaras RR, Nelson WW, Voorhees WB (1975) Soybean and corn rooting in South-western Minnesota 1. Water-uptake sink. Soil Sci Soc Am Proc 39:764–771
Arora VK, Gajri PR (1996) Performance of simplified water balance models under maize in a semi arid subtropical environment. Agric Water Manage 31:51–64
Arora VK, Prihar SS, Gajri PR (1987) Synthesis of a simplified water use simulation model for predicting wheat yield. Water Resour Res 23:903–910
Belmans C, Wesseling JG, Feddes RA (1983) Simulation model of the water balance of a cropped soil—SWATRE. J Hydrol 63:271–286
Clemente RS, De Jong R, Hayhoe HN, Reynolds WD, Hares M (1994) Testing and comparison of three unsaturated soil water flow models. Agric Water Manage 25:135–152
Dasilva CC, De Jong E (1986) Comparison of two computer models for predicting soil water in a tropical monsoon climate. Agric Forest Meteorol 36:249–262
Dyer JA, Mack AR (1984) The versatile soil moisture budget-version three. Technical bulletin no. 1984-IE. Land Resources Research Institute, Research Branch, Agriculture Canada, Ottawa, ON
FAO (1998) Evapotranspiration. Irrigation and drainage paper 56, Rome, Italy
Faria RT, Madramootoo CA, Boisvert J, Prasher SO (1994) Comparison of the versatile soil moisture budget, VB4 and SWACROP models for a wheat crop in Brazil. Can Agric Eng 36(2):57–67
Hanks RJ, Keller J, Rasmuseen VP, Wilson GD (1976) Line source sprinkler for continous variable irrigation—crop production studies. Soil Sci Soc Am Proc 40:426–429
Hayhoe HN, De Jong R (1982) Computer simulation model of soil water movement and uptake by plant roots. Land Resource Research Institute. Agriculture Canada, Ottawa, Ontario, Canada, 74 pp
Hayhoe HN, De Jong R (1988) Comparisons of two soil water models for soybeans. Cana Agric Eng 30:5–11
Hill RW, Hanks RJ, Wright JL (1996) Crop yield models adapted to irrigation schedules programs (CRPSM). Research Report. Utah State University, Logan, Utah, USA
McGowan M, Williams JB (1980) The water balance of an agricultural catchment. 1. Estimation of evaporation from soil water records. J Soil Sci 31:218–230
Saxton KE, Johnson HP, Shaw RH (1974) Modeling evapotranspiration and soil moisture. Trans ASAE 17:673–677
Schwab GO, Frevert RK, Edminster TW, Barnes KK (1992) Soil and water conservation engineering. 4th edn. Wiley, New York, pp 49–91
Vanclooster M, Viaene P, Diels J, Christians K (1994) WAVE - A mathematical model for simulating water and agrochemical in the soil and vadose environment. Institute for Land and Water Management, K.U. Leuven, Belgium
Van-Genuchten MTh (1991) The RETC-code for qualifying the hydraulic functions of unsaturated soils. EPA/600/2-91/065, 83 pp
Wagenet RJ, Hutson JL (1989) LEACHM leaching estimation and chemistry model, version 2. In: Vanclooster et al (1994) WAVE. Institute for land and water management. K.U. Leuven, Belgium
Acknowledgments
The WATCOM model was obtained through the assistance of Dr. G.C.L. Wyseure of the University of Newcastle upon Tyne, UK, while the first author was on British Council sponsored linkage between Obafemi Awolowo University and University of Newcastle. The CRPSM model was obtained from Dr. Robert W. Hill of Utah State University, Logan, USA.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Communicated by T. Trooien.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Adekalu, K.O., Fapohunda, H.O. Comparisons of two soil water flow models under variable irrigation. Irrig Sci 25, 375–385 (2007). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00271-006-0053-9
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00271-006-0053-9