Abstract
A standing enigma in pollination ecology is the evolution of pollinator attraction without offering reward in about one third of all orchid species. Here I review concepts of pollination by deception, and in particular recent findings in the pollination syndromes of food deception and sexual deception in orchids. Deceptive orchids mimic floral signals of rewarding plants (food deception) or mating signals of receptive females (sexual deception) to attract pollen vectors. In some food deceptive orchids, similarities in the spectral reflectance visible to the pollinator in a model plant and its mimic, and increased reproductive success of the mimic in the presence of the model have been demonstrated. Other species do not mimic specific model plants but attract pollinators with general attractive floral signals. In sexually deceptive orchids, floral odor is the key trait for pollinator attraction, and behaviorally active compounds in the orchids are identical to the sex pheromone of the pollinator species. Deceptive orchids often show high variability in floral signals, which may be maintained by negative frequency-dependent selection, since pollinators can learn and subsequently avoid common deceptive morphs more quickly than rare ones. The evolution of obligate deception in orchids seems paradoxical in the light of the typically lower fruit set than in rewarding species. Pollination by deception, however, can reduce self-pollination and encourage pollen flow over longer distances, thus promoting outbreeding. Although some food deceptive orchids are isolated through postzygotic reproductive barriers, sexually deceptive orchids lack post-mating barriers and species isolation is achieved via specific pollinator attraction. Recent population genetic and phylogenetic investigations suggest gene-flow within subgeneric clades, but pollinator-mediated selection may maintain species-specific floral traits.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Ackerman JD (1981) Pollination biology of Calypso bulbosa var. occidentalis (Orchidaceae): a food-deception system. Madrono 28(3):101–110
Ackerman JD (1986) Mechanisms and evolution of food-deceptive pollination systems in orchids. Lindleyana 1:108–113
Ackerman JD, Melendez-Ackerman EJ, Salguero-Faria J (1997) Variation in pollinator abundance and selection of fragrance phenotypes in an epiphytic orchid. Am J Bot 10:1383–1390
Ågren L, Kullenberg B, Sensenbaugh T (1984) Congruences in pilosity between three species of Ophrys (Orchidaceae) and their hymenopterean pollinators. Nova Acta Reg Soc Sci Ups Ser V:15–25
Aragon S, Ackerman JD (2004) Does flower color variation matter in deception pollinated Psychilis monensis (Orchidaceae). Oecologia 138:405–413
Ayasse M, Schiestl FP, Paulus HF, Löfstedt C, Hansson BS, Ibarra F, Francke W (2000) Evolution of reproductive strategies in the sexually deceptive orchid Ophrys sphegodes: How does flower-specific variation of odor signals influence reproductive success? Evolution 54(6):1995–2006
Ayasse M, Schiestl FP, Paulus HF, Ibarra F, Francke W (2003) Pollinator attraction in a sexually deceptive orchid by means of unconventional chemicals. Proc R Soc Lond B 270:517–522
Barkman TJ, Beaman JH, Gage DA (1997) Floral fragrance variation in Cypripedium: implications for evolutionary and ecological studies. Phytochemistry 44:875–882
Bateman RM, Hollingsworth PM, Preston J, Yi-Bo L, Pridgeon AM, Chase MW (2003) Molecular phylogenetics and evolution of Orchidinae and selected Habenariinae (Orchidaceae). Bot J Linn Soc 142:1–40
Bergström G (1978) Role of volatile chemicals in Ophrys-pollinator interactions. In: Harborne G (ed) Biochemical aspects of plant and animal coevolution. Academic Press, New York, pp 207–230
Bergström G, Birgersson G, Groth I, Nilsson AL (1992) Floral fragrance disparity between three taxa of lady’s slipper Cypripedium calceolus (Orchidaceae). Phytochemistry 31:2315–2319
Blanco MA, Barboza G (2005) Pseudocopulatory pollination in Lepanthes (Orchidaceae: Pleurothallidinae) by fungus gnats. Ann Bot 95:763–772
Bogdany FJ (1978) Linking of learning signals in honey bee orientation. Behav Ecol Sociobiol 3:323–336
Borg-Karlson A-K (1990) Chemical and ethological studies of pollination in the genus Ophrys (Orchidaceae). Phytochemistry 29(5):1359–1387
Bower CC (1996) Demonstration of pollinator-mediated reproductive isolation in sexually deceptive species of Chiloglottis (Orchidaceae: Caladeniinae). Aust J Bot 44:15–33
Cameron KM, Chase MW, Whitten MW, Kores PJ, Jarrell DC, Albert VA, Yukawa T, Hills HG, Goldman DH (1999) A phylogenetic analysis of the Orchidaceae: evidence from RBCL nucleotide sequences. Am J Bot 86(2):208–224
Coleman E (1927) Pollination of the orchid Cryptostylis leptochila. Victorian Naturalist 44:20–22
Cozzolino S, Aceto S, Caputo P, Widmer A, Dafni A (2001) Speciation processes in eastern Mediterranean Orchis s.l. species: molecular evidence and the role of pollination biology. Isr J Pl Sci 49:91–103
Cozzolino S, D’Emerico S, Widmer A (2004) Evidence for reproductive isolate selection in Mediterranean orchids: karyotype differences compensate for the lack of pollinator specificity. Biol Lett 271:259–262
Cozzolino S, Schiestl FP, Müller A, De Castro O, Nardella A, Widmer A (in press) Evidence for pollinator sharing in Mediterranean nectar mimic orchids: absence of premating barriers? Proc R Soc Lond B
Dafni A, Ivri Y (1981) Floral mimicry between Orchis israelitica Baumann and Dafni (Orchidaceae) and Bellevalia felexuosa Boiss (Liliaceae). Oecologia 49:229–232
Dafni A (1983) Pollination of Orchis caspia – a nectarless plant which deceives the pollinators of nectariferous species from other plant families. J Ecol 71:467–474
Dafni A (1984) Mimicry and deception in pollination. Annu Rev Ecol Syst 15:259–278
Dafni A (1987) Pollination in Orchis and related genera: evolution from reward to deception. In: Arditti J (ed) Orchid Biology: reviews and perspectives. Cornell University Press, Ithaca and London, pp 79–104
Dafni A, Bernhardt P (1990) Pollination of terrestrial orchids of southern Australia and the Mediterranean region. In: Hecht MK, Wallace B, Macintyre RJ (eds) Evolutionary Biology 24. Plenum Press, New York, pp 193–252
Darwin C (1885) On the various contrivances by which orchids are fertilised by insects, 2nd edn. John Murray, London
Daumann E (1971) Zum Problem der Täuschblumen. Preslia 43:304–317
Dressler R (1981) The orchids – natural history and classification. Harvard Univ Press, Cambridge, MA
Ehrendorfer F (1980) Hybridisierung, Polyploidie und Evolution bei europäisch-mediterranen Orchideen. Die Orchidee Sonderheft 15–34
Faegri K, van der Pijl L (1979) The principles of pollination ecology. Pergamon Press, Oxford
Fritz A-L, Nilsson A (1996) Reproductive success and gender variation in deceit-pollinated orchids. In: Lloyd DG, Barrett SCH (eds) Floral biology: studies on floral evolution in animal-pollinated plants. Chapman & Hall, New York, pp 319–338
Galizia CG, Kunze J, Gumbert A, Borg-Karlson A-K, Sachse S, Markl C, Menzel R (2005) Relationship of visual and olfactory signal parameters in a food-deceptive flower mimicry system. Behav Ecol 16:159–168
Gigord LDB, Macnair MR, Smithson A (2001) Negative frequency dependent selection maintains a dramatic flower color polymorphism in the rewardless orchid Dactylorhiza sambucina (L.) Soò. Proc Natl Acad Sci 98:6253–6255
Gigord LDB, Macnair MR, Stritesky M, Smithson A (2002) The potential for floral mimicry in rewardless orchids: an experimental study. Proc R Soc Lond B 269:1389–1395
Gill DE (1989) Fruiting failure, pollinator inefficiency, and speciation in orchids. In: Otte D, Endler JA (eds) Speciation and its consequences. Sinauer Associates, Sunderland, pp 458–481
Grant PR, Grant BR, Markert JA, Keller L, Petren K (2004) Convergent evolution of Darwin’s Finches caused by introgressive hybridization and selection. Evolution 58(7):1588–1599
Gumbert A, Kunze J (2001) Colour similarity to rewarding model affects pollination in a food deceptive orchid, Orchis boryi. Biol J Linn Soc 72:419–433
Heinrich B (1975) Bee flowers: a hypothesis on flower variety and blooming times. Evolution 29:325–334
Hodges SA, Arnold ML (1994) Columbines – a geographically widespread species flock. Proc Natl Acad Sci 91:5129–5132
Johnson SD (1994) Evidence for Batesian mimicry in a butterfly-pollinated orchid. Biol J Linn Soc 53:91–104
Johnson SD, Steiner KE (1997) Long-tongued fly pollination and evolution of floral spur length in the Disa draconis complex (Orchiaceae). Evolution 51:45–53
Johnson SD, Linder HP, Steiner KE (1998) Phylogeny and radiation of pollination systems in Disa (Orchidaceae). Am J Bot 85:402–411
Johnson SD, Nilsson LA (1999) Pollen carryover, geitonogamy, and the evolution of deceptive pollination systems in orchids. Ecology 80(8):2607–2619
Johnson SD (2000) Batesian mimicry in the non-rewarding orchid Disa pulchra, and its consequences for pollinator behavior. Biol J Linn Soc 71:119–132
Johnson SD, Alexandersson R, Linder HP (2003a) Experimental and phylogenetic evidence for floral mimicry in a guild of fly-pollinated plants. Biol J Linn Soc 80:289–304
Johnson SD, Craig PI, Nilsson AL, Ågren J (2003b) Pollination success in a deceptive orchid is enhanced by co-occurring rewarding magnet plants. Ecology 84(11):2919–2927
Johnson SD, Craig PI, Ågren J (2004) The effects of nectar addition on pollen removal and geitonogamy in the non-rewarding orchid Anacamptis morio. Proc R Soc Lond B 271:803–809
Jones DL, Clements ML, Sharma IK, Mackenzie AM (2001) A new classification of Caladenia R. Br. (Orchidaceae). The Orchadian 13:389–419
Kocyan A, Endress PK (2001) Floral structure and development of Apostasia and Neuwiedia (Apostasioideae) and their relationships to other Orchidacea. Int J Plant Sci 162(4):847–867
Kores PJ, Molvray M, Weston PH, Hopper SD, Brown AP, Cameron KM, Chase MW (2001) A phylogenetic analysis of Diurideae (Orchidaceae) based on plastid DNA sequence data. Am J Bot 88:1903–1914
Kullenberg B (1961) Studies in Ophrys pollination. Almquist & Wiksells Boktrykeri AB, Uppsala
Kullenberg B, Bergström G (1976) Hymenoptera aculeata as pollinators of Ophrys orchids. Zool Scr 5:13–23
Kunze J, Gumbert A (2001) The combined effect of color and odor on flower choice behavior of bumble bees in flower mimicry systems. Behav Ecol 12:447–456
Lammi A, Kuitunen M (1995) Deceptive pollination of Dactylorhiza incarnata: an experimental test of the magnet species hypothesis. Oecologia 101:500–503
Laverty TM (1992) Plant interactions for pollinator visits: a test of the magnet species effect. Oecologia 89:502–508
Mant J, Schiestl FP, Peakall R, Weston PH (2002) A phylogenetic study of pollinator conservatism among sexually deceptive orchids. Evolution 56:888–898
Mant J, Peakall R, Weston P (in press a) Specific pollinator attraction and the diversification of sexually deceptive Chiloglottis (Orchidaceae). Pl Syst Evol
Mant J, Brändli C, Vereecken NJ, Schulz CM, Francke W, Schiestl FP (in press b) Cuticular hydrocarbons as sex pheromone of the bee Colletes cunicularius and the key to its mimicry by the sexually deceptive orchid, Ophrys exaltata. J Chem Ecol
Mant J, Peakall R, Schiestl FP (in press c) Does selection on floral odor promote differentiation among populations and species of the sexually deceptive orchid genus, Ophrys? Evolution
Maynard Smith J (2002) Evolutionary genetics. Oxford University Press, Oxford
Menzel R (1985) Learning in honey bees in an ecological and behavioral context. In: Hölldobler B, Lindauer M (eds) Experimental behavioral ecology. Gustav Fischer, Stuttgart, pp 55–74
Moya S, Ackerman JD (1993) Variation in the floral fragrance of Epidendrum ciliare (Orchidaceae). Nord J Bot 13:41–47
Neiland MRM, Wilcock CC (1998) Fruit set, nectar reward, and rarity in the Orchidaceae. Am J Bot 85:1657–1671
Nilsson AL (1979) Anthecological studies of the Lady’s Slipper, Cypripedium calceolus (Orchidaceae). Bot Notiser 132:329–347
Nilsson AL (1980) The pollination ecology of Dactylorhiza sambucina (Orchidaceae). Bot Notiser 133:368–385
Nilsson AL (1983) Mimesis of bellflower (Campanula) by the red helleborine orchid Cephalanthera rubra. Nature 305:799–800
Nilsson AL (1984) Anthecology of Orchis morio (Orchidaceae) at its outpost in the north. Nov Acta Reg Soc Sci Ups V:(C3):167–179
Nilsson AL (1988) The evolution of flowers with deep corolla tubes. Nature 334:147–149
Nilsson AL (1992) Orchid pollination biology. TREE 7(8):255–259
Nilsson LA, Rabakonandriana E, Pettersson B (1992) Exact tracking of pollen transfer and mating in plants. Nature 360:666–668
O’Connell LM, Johnston M (1998) Male and female pollination success in a deceptive orchid, a selection study. Ecology 79(4):1246–1260
Paulus HF, Gack C (1990) Pollinators as prepollinating isolation factors: Evolution and speciation in Ophrys (Orchidaceae). Isr J Bot 39:43–79
Peakall R, James SH (1989) Outcrossing in an ant pollinated clonal orchid. Heredity 62:161–167
Peakall R (1989) A new technique for monitoring pollen flow in orchids. Oecologia 79:365–365
Peakall R (1990) Responses of male Zaspilothynnus trilobatus Turner wasps to females and the sexually deceptive orchid it pollinates. Funct Ecol 4:159–167
Peakall R, Handel SN (1993) Pollinators discriminate among floral heights of a sexually deceptive orchid: implications for selection. Evolution 47(6):1681–1687
Peakall R, Beattie AJ (1996) Ecological and genetic consequences of pollination by sexual deception in the orchid Caladenia tentactulata. Evolution 50(69):2207–2220
Peakall R, Schiestl FP (2004) A mark-recapture study of male Colletes cunicularius bees: implications for pollination by sexual deception. Behav Ecol Sociobiol 56:579–584
Pellegrino G, Caimi D, Noce ME, Musacchio A (2005) Effects of local density and flower color polymorphism on pollination and reproduction in the rewardless orchid Dactylorhiza sambucina (L.) Soò. Plant Syst Evol 251:119–129
Petterson B, Nilsson AL (1993) Floral variation and deceit pollination in Polystachya rosea (Orchidaceae) on an inselberg in Madagascar. Opera Bot 121:237–245
van der Pijl L, Dodson CH (1966) Orchid flowers / Their pollination and evolution. University of Miami Press, Coral Gables
Pridgeon AM, Bateman RM, Cox AV, Hapemann JR, Chase MW (1997) Phylogenetics of subtribe Orchidinae (Orchidoideae, Orchidaceae) based on nuclear ITS sequenes. 1. Intergeneric relationships and polyphyly of Orchis sensu lato. Lindleyana 12(2):89–109
Pouyanne A (1917) La fecundation des Ophrys par les insectes. Bull Société d’Histoire Naturelle l’Afrique du Nord 8:6–7
Rieseberg LH, Church SA, Morjan CL (2003) Integration of populations and differentiation of species. New Phytologist 161:59–69
Roubik DW (2000) Deceptive orchids with Meliponini as pollinators. Plant Syst Evol 222(1–4):271–279
Roy BA, Widmer A (1999) Floral mimicry: a fscinating yet poorly understood phenomenon. Trop Plant Sci 4(8):325–330
Rudall PJ, Bateman RM, Fay MF, Eastman A (2002) Floral antomy and systematics of Alliaceae with particular reference to Gilliesia, a presumed insect mimic with strongly zygomorphic flowers. Am J Bot 89:1867–1883
Sabat AM, Ackerman JD (1996) Fruit set in a deceptive orchid: the effect of flowering phenology, display size, and local floral abundance. Am J Bot 83(9):1181–1186
Schemske DW (1980) Evolution of floral display size in the orchid Brassavola nodosa. Evolution 34(3):489–493
Schiestl FP, Ayasse M, Paulus HF, Erdmann D, Francke W (1997) Variation of floral scent emission and post pollination changes in individual flowers of Ophrys sphegodes subsp. sphegodes (MILLER). J Chem Ecol 23(12):2881–2895
Schiestl FP, Ayasse M, Paulus HF, Löfstedt C, Hansson BS, Ibarra F, Francke W (1999) Orchid pollination by sexual swindle. Nature 399:421–422
Schiestl FP, Ayasse M, Paulus HF, Löfstedt C, Hansson BS, Ibarra F, Francke W (2000) Sex pheromone mimicry in the Early Spider Orchid (Ophrys sphegodes): patterns of hydrocarbons as the key mechanism for pollination by sexual deception. J Comp Physiol A 186:567–574
Schiestl FP, Ayasse M (2002) Do changes in floral odor cause speciation in sexually deceptive orchids? Plant Syst Evol 234(1–4):111–119
Schiestl FP, Marion-Poll F (2002) Detection of physiologically active flower volatiles using gas chromatography coupled with electroantennography. In: Jackson JF, Linskens HF, Inman R (eds) Molecular Methods of Plant Analysis, vol 21, Analysis of Taste and Aroma. Springer, Berlin, pp 173–198
Schiestl FP, Peakall R, Mant J, Ibarra F, Schulz C, Francke S, Francke W (2003) The chemistry of sexual deception in an orchid–wasp pollination system. Science 302:437–438
Schiestl FP, Peakall R, Mant J (2004) Chemical communication in the sexually deceptive orchid genus Cryptostylis. Bot J Lin Soc 144:199–205
Schiestl FP (2004) Floral evolution and pollinator mate-choice in a sexually deceptive orchid. J Evol Biol 17:67–75
Schieste FP, Peakall R (in press) Two orchids attract different pollinators with the same floral odor compound: ecological and evolutionary implications
Singer RB (2002) The pollination mechanism in Trigonidium obtusum Lindl (Orchidaceae : Maxillariinae): sexual mimicry and trap-flowers. Ann Bot 89:157–163
Singer RB, Flach A, Koehler S, Marsaioli AJ, Amaral ME (2004) Sexual mimicry in Mormolyca ringens (Lindl.) Schltr. (Orchidaceae: Maxillariinae). Ann Bot 93:755–762
Smithson A, Macnair MR (1996) Frequency-dependent selection by pollinators: mechanisms and consequences with regard to behaviour of bumblebees Bombus terrestris (L.) (Hymenoptera: Apidae). J Evol Biol 9:571–588
Smithson A (2002) The consequences of rewardlessness in orchids: reward-supplementation experiments with Anacamptis morio (Orchidaceae). Am J Bot 89:1579–1587
Smithson A, Gigord LDB (2002) Are there fitness advantages in being a rewardless orchid? Reward supplementation experiments with Barlia robertiana. Proc R Soc Lond B 268:1435–1441
Soliva M, Kocyan A, Widmer A (2001) Molecular phylogenetics of the sexually deceptive orchid genus Ophrys (Orchidaceae) based on nuclear and chloroplast DNA sequences. Mol Phyl Evol 20(1):78–88
Soliva M, Widmer A (2003) Gene flow across species boundaries in sympatric, sexually deceptive Ophrys (Orchidaceae) species. Evolution 57:2252–2261
Sprengel CK (1793) Das entdeckte Geheimniss in der Natur im Bau und in der Befruchtung der Blumen. Translation in Lloyd DG, Barrett SCH (eds) Floral Biology. Chapman & Hall, New York, pp 3–43
Steiner KE, Whitehead VB, Johnson SD (1994) Floral pollinator divergence in two sexually deceptive South African orchids. Am J Bot 81(2):185–194
Steiner KE (1998) The evolution of beetle pollination in a South African orchid. Am J Bot 85:1180–1193
Stowe MK (1988) Chemical mimicry. In: Spencer KC (ed) Chemical mediation of coevolution. Academic Press, San Diego, pp 513–587
Thakar JD, Krushnamegh K, Chauhan AK, Watve AV, Watve MG (2003) Nectarless flowers: ecological correlates and evolutionary stability. Oecologia 136:565–570
Thompson JD (1978) Effect of stand composition on insect visitation in two-species mixtures of Hieracium. Am Midland Naturalist 100:431–440
Tremblay RL (1992) Trends in the pollination ecology of the orchidaceae: evolution and systematics. Can J Bot 70:642–650
Tremblay RL, Ackerman JD, Zimmerman JK, Calvo RN (2005) Variation in sexual reproduction in orchids and its evolutionary consequences: a spasmodic journey to diversification. Biol J Linn Soc 84:1–54
Vogel S (1983) Ecophysiology of zoophilic pollination. In: Lange OL, Nobel PS, Osmond CB, Ziegler H (eds) Encyclopedia of Plant Physiology, Physiological plant ecology, new series, vol. 12c. Springer, Berlin, pp 560–611
Vogel S (1993) Betrug bei Planzen: Die Täuschblumen. 1. Akademie der Wissenschaften und der Literatur, Mainz, Franz Steiner, Stuttgart
Wasserthal LT (1997) The pollinators of the Malagasy Star Orchids Angraecum sesquipedale, A. sororium and A. compactum and the evolution of extremely long spurs by pollinator shift. Bot Acta 110:343–359
Wiens E (1978) Mimicry in plants. Evol Biol 11:365–403
Wickler W (1968) Mimicry in plants and animals. Weidenfeld and Nicolson, London
Wong BBM, Schiestl FP (2002) How an orchid harms its pollinator. Proc R Soc Lond B 269:1529–1532
Wong BBM, Salzmann C, Schiestl FP (2004) Pollinator attractiveness increases with distance from flowering orchids. Biol Lett 271:212–214
Yadav SR (1995) Pollination biology of the south west asian orchid Cottonia peduncularis. Hornbill 1:28–31
Acknowledgements
I would like to thank Rod Peakall (Canberra), Jim Mant (Zürich), Salvatore Cozzolino (Naples), Manfred Ayasse (Ulm), Wittko Francke (Hamburg), Fernando Ibarra (Hamburg), Claudia Schulz (Hamburg), and Roman Kaiser (Dübendorf) for sharing their insights during many years of fruitful collaboration. Rod Peakall, Jim Mant, Alex Widmer (Zürich), and Salvatore Cozzolino provided helpful comments on this manuscript, and Charlotte Salzmann (Zürich) supplied a picture for this paper. I would also like to thank Peter Linder (Zürich), Amots Dafni (Haifa), Steve Johnson (Pietermaritzburg), and Hannes Paulus (Vienna), for inspiring discussions on the mysteries of orchid pollination. The research of the author is supported by the SNF (3100–68173.02) and ETH Zürich (02297/41-2710)
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Schiestl, F.P. On the success of a swindle: pollination by deception in orchids. Naturwissenschaften 92, 255–264 (2005). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00114-005-0636-y
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00114-005-0636-y