Abstract
This paper examines the ability of bilingual children to reason deductively in mathematics. In particular, the findings of a recent study of bilingual Punjabi, Mirpuri, Italian and Jamaican 11–13 year old children growing up in England are reported. It is found that first language competence is an important factor in the child's ability to reason in mathematics in English as a second language. This gives considerable support to theories which assert that a cognitively and academically beneficial form of bilingualism can only be achieved on the basis of adequately developed first language skills. However for both English monolingual and bilingual children knowledge of logical connectives in English is a crucial factor. It is suggested that published weaknesses in mathematics found among certain Asian and West Indian pupils may well be due to language factors. Furthermore there are strong cultural forces which predispose differential performance among boys and girls. The implications of the findings for a relevant mathematical education for bilingual children are discussed.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Albert, M. L. and Obler, L. K.: 1978. The Bilingual Brain: Neuropsychological and Neurolinguistic Aspects of Bilingualism, Academic Press, New York.
Austin, J. L. and Howson, A. G.: 1979, ‘Language and mathematical education’, Educational Studies in Mathematics 10, 161–197.
Bagley, C.: 1977, A Comparative Perspective on the Education of Black Children in Britain, Centre for Information and Advice on Educational Disadvantage, Manchester.
Bailey, Beryl L.: 1966, Jamaican Creole Syntax, C.U.P. at Cambridge.
Bishop, A. J.: 1979, ‘Visualising and mathematics in a pre-technological culture’, Educational Studies in Mathematics 10, 136–146.
Bruner, J. S.: 1975, ‘Language as an instrument of thought’, in Problems of Language and Learning, Alan Davies (ed.), Social Science Research Council, Heinemann, London.
Collis, K. F.: 1975, A Study of Concrete and Formal Operations in School Mathematics: A Piagetian Viewpoint, ACER, Hawthorn, Victoria.
Cornish, G. and Wines, R.: 1977, Teachers Handbook, Operations Test, ACER Mathematics Profile Series, The Australian Council for Educational Research, Hawthorn, Victoria.
C.R.E.: 1978, Ethnic Minorities in Britain: Statistical Background, The Commission for Racial Equality, London.
Cummins, James: 1978, ‘Educational implications of mother tongue maintenance in minority-language groups’, Canadian Modern Language Review 34, 395–416.
Cummins, James: 1979, ‘Linguistic interdependence and the educational development of bilingual children’, Review of Educ. Research 49, 2, 222–251.
Dawe, L. C. S.: 1982, The Influence of a Bilingual Child's First Language Competence on Reasoning in Mathematics, Unpublished Ph.D Dissertation, University of Cambridge.
Delahunty, C.: 1973, An Investigation into the Development of Mathematical Ability of Deprived Children Through the Mediation of Linguistic Operators, Unpublished Ph.D Thesis, University of Dublin.
Driver, G.: 1980, ‘How West Indians do better at school (especially the girls)’, New Society, 17th January, pp. 111–113.
Edwards, V. K.: 1976, West Indian Language and Comprehension, Unpublished Ph.D Thesis, University of Reading.
Edwards, V. K.: 1978, Dialect interference in West Indian children’, Language and Speech, 21, Part 1, 76–86.
Edwards, V. K.: 1979, The West Indian Language Issue in British Schools, Routledge & Kegan Paul, London.
Essen, J. and Ghodsian, M.: 1979, ‘The children of immigrants: school performance’, New Community 7, 3, 422–429.
Gardner, P. L.: 1977, Logical Connectives in Science, a report to the Education Research and Development Committee, Dept. of Education, Commonwealth Government, Australia. Faculty of Education, Monash University, Victoria, Australia.
Halliday, M. A. K.: 1974, ‘Aspects of Sociolinguistic Research’, a preparatory paper for Internactions between Linguistics and Mathematical Education the symposium held at Nairobi, Kenya, Sept. 1–11, 1974, UNESCO, Paris.
Jensen, Arthur R.: 1980, Bias in Mental Testing, Free Press, New York.
Kline, Morris: 1962, Mathematics: A Cultural Approach, Addison-Wesley, Reading, Mass.
Lambert, W.: 1977, ‘The effects of bilingualism on the individual: cognitive and sociocultural consequences’, in Bilingualism: Psychological, Social and Educational Implications, P. A. Hornby (ed.), Academic Press, New York.
Lambert, W. E.: 1978, ‘Cognitive and socio-cultural consequences of bilingualism’, Canadian Modern Language Review 34, 3, 537–547.
Lambert, W. E. and Anisfield, E.: 1969, ‘A note on the relationship of bilingualism and intelligence’, Canadian Journal of Behavioural Science 1, 123–128.
Lean, G. and Clements, M. A.: 1981, ‘Spatial ability, visual imagery and mathematical performance’, Educational Studies in Mathematics 12, 3, 267–299.
Le Page, R. B.: 1968, ‘Problems to be faced in the use of English as the medium of education in four West Indian territories’, in Language Problems in Developing Nations, J. A. Fishman, C. A. Ferguson and J. D. Gupton (eds), Wiley, New York.
Little, A.: 1975, ‘Performance of children from ethnic minority backgrounds in primary schools’, Oxford Review of Education 1, 2, 117–135.
MacFarlane Smith, I.: 1964, Spatial Ability: its Educational and Social Significance, University of London Press, London.
MacNamara, John: 1967, ‘The bilingual's linguistic performance’, Journal of Social Issues 23, 2, 58–77 (special issue).
Nie, N. H., Hadlai Hull, C., Jenkins, J. G., et al.: 1975, Statistical Package for the Social Sciences, Second Edition, McGraw-Hill, New York.
Rosen, H. and Burgess, T.: 1978, Survey-of Linguistic Diversity in ILEA Schools Interim report, University of London Institute of Education.
Rutter, M. and Madge, N.: 1976, Cycles of Disadvantage, Heinemann, London.
Saifullah-Kahn, Verity: 1974, Pakistani Villagers in a British City: the world of the Mirpuri villager in Bradford and in his village of origin, unpublished Ph.D Thesis, University of Bradford.
Shuard, H. B.: 1982, ‘Differences in mathematical performance between girls and boys’, in Mathematics Counts. Report of the Committee of Inquiry into the Teaching of Mathematics in Schools, W. H. Cockcroft, Chairman, HMSO, London, pp. 273–284.
Skutnabb-Kangas, T. and Toukomaa, P.: 1976, Teaching Migrant Children's Mother Tongue and Learning the Language of the Host Country in the Context of the Sociocultural Situation of the Migrant Family, The Finnish National Commission for UNESCO, Helsinki.
Skutnabb-Kangas, T. and Toukomaa, P.: 1977, The Intensive Teaching of the Mother Tongue to Migrant Children of Pre-School Age and Children in the Lower Level of Comprehensive School, The Finnish National Commission for UNESCO, Helsinki.
Strevens, Peter: 1971, ‘The language of instruction and the formation of scientific concepts’, in Science and Education in the Developing States, Proceedings of the 5th Rehovot Conference on Science and Education in Developing Countries, P. & H. Gillon (eds.), Praeger, New York.
Sutcliffe, D.: 1978, The Language of First and Second Generation West Indian Children in Bedfordshire, M.Ed. Thesis, University of Leicester.
Swain, M. and Cummins, J.: 1979, ‘Bilingualism, cognitive and functioning and education’, Language Teaching and Linguistic Abstracts 12, 1, 4–18.
Wilson, Bryan: 1981, Cultural Contexts of Science and Mathematics Education, a bibiographic guide, Centre for Studies in Science Education, University of Leeds.
Witelson, S. F.: 1976, ‘Sex and the single hemisphere: specialization of the right hemisphere for spatial processing’, Science 193, July 30, pp. 425–427.
Young, C. N.: 1973, Belize Creole: A Study of the Creolized English Spoken in the City of Belize in its Cultural and Social Setting, unpublished Ph.D Thesis, University of York.
Zirkel, P. A.: 1976, ‘A method for determining and depicting language dominance” in English as a Second Language in Bilingual Education, selected TESOL papers, James E. Alatis and K. Twaddel (eds.), TESOL, Washington, D.C., pp. 133–142.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Dawe, L. Bilingualism and mathematical reasoning in English as a second language. Educational Studies in Mathematics 14, 325–353 (1983). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00368233
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00368233