Abstract
We examined the abundances of three common insect herbivores on pure and hybrid pinyon pines along a 250-km transect in west-central Arizona, United States. Using six morphological traits, we developed a hybrid index to classify trees as pure Pinus californiarum, hybrid, or pure Pinus edulis. The insects (the stem-boring moth, Dioryctria albovittella, the scale insect, Matsucoccus acalyptus, and several species of pitch moths that produce wounds on the trunk and branches) exhibited different distributional patterns across tree types. Stem-boring moths were significantly more abundant on trees at “hybrid” sites compared to trees at “pure” sites. In addition, within hybrid sites, hybrids supported significantly more moth larvae than pure trees of either species. These two patterns support the hybrid susceptibility hypothesis in which hybrid breakdown results in increased susceptibility to herbivory. In contrast to stem-borers, there were significantly more pitch moth wounds on trees at pure P. californiarum sites than at hybrid and pure P. edulis sites. Within the hybrid zone, pitch moth abundance was equal on pure P. californiarum and hybrids, and both were significantly greater than on pure P. edulis. These within-site comparisons support the dominance hypothesis where hybrid resistance differs from one tree species, but not the other. Scale insects exhibited the most restricted distribution; over the 250 km transect they were found only in the hybrid zone. This supports the hybrid susceptibility and/or the stress hypothesis (i.e., species at the edge of their range suffer greater stress and are more susceptible to herbivory). We summed the mean numbers of these three common herbivores across sites and found that hybrid sites supported 2.1 and 3.9 times more herbivores than pure P. californiarum and P. edulis sites, respectively. Furthermore, tree mortality was on average, 35 times greater within the hybrid zone compared to pure zones of each species and was associated with the cumulative abundance of herbivores (r 2=0.646). Regardless of whether this mortality is due to insect infestation, stress or a combination of both, these results suggest that hybrid zones are important arenas of natural selection.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Aguilar JM, Boecklen WJ (1992) Patterns of herbivory in the Quercus grisea X Quercus gambelii species complex. Oikos 64:498–504
Barker JF (1990) Sunflower trichome defenses avoided by a sunflower stem weevil, Cylindrocopturus adspersus LeConte (Coleoptera: Curculionidae). J Kansas Ent Soc 63:638–641
Bailey DK (1987) A study of Pinus subsection cembroides I: the single-needled pinyons of the Californias and Great Basin. Notes R Bot Gard Edinb 44:275–310
Boecklen WJ, Spellenberg R (1990) Structure of herbivote communities in two oak (Quercus spp.) hybrid zones. Oecologia 85:92–100
Brussard PF (1984) Geographic patterns and environmental gradients: the central-marginal model in Drosophila revisited. Annu Rev Ecol Syst 15:25–64
Bunce JA, Chabot BF, Miller LN (1979) Role of annual leaf carbon balance in the distribution of plant species along an elevational gradient. Bot Gaz 140:288–294
Cain R, Cota J, Ward C (1990) Conifer pests in New Mexico. New Mexico State University Cooperative Extension Service, Las Cruces
Cobb N, Mitton JB, Whitham TG (1994) Genetic variation associated with chronic water and nutrient stress in pinyon pine. Am J Bot 81:936–940
Cranshaw W, Leatherman D, Kondratieff B (1993) Insects that feed on Colorado trees and shrubs (Bulletin 506A). Colorado State University Cooperative Extension, Ft. Collins
Conover WJ (1980) Practical nonparametric statistics. 2nd edn. Wiley, New York
Daniel WW (1990) Applied nonparametric statistics. 2nd edn. PWS-Kent Boston
Drake DW (1981a) Reproductive success of two Eucalyptus hybrid populations I. Generalized seed output model and comparison of fruit parameters. Aust J Bot 29:25–35
Drake DW (1981b) Reproductive success of two Eucalyptus hybrid populations II. Comparison of predispersal seed parameters. Aust J Bot 29:37–48
Ericson L, Burdon JJ, Wennstrom A (1993) Interspecific host hybrids and phalacrid beetles implicated in the local survival of smut pathogens. Oikos 68:393–400
Floate K, Whitham TG (1993) The “hybrid-bridge” hypothesis: host shifting via plant hybrid swarms. Am Nat 141:651–662
Floate K, Whitham TG (1994) Aphid-ant interaction reduces chrysomelid herbivory in a cottonwood hybrid zone. Oecologia 97:215–221
Floate K, Whitham TG (1995) Insects as traits in plant systematics: their use in discriminating between hybrid cottonwoods. Can J Bot (in press)
Floate KD, Kearsley MJC, Whitham TG (1993) Elevated herbivory in plant hybrid zones: Chrysomela confluens, Populus and phenological sinks. Ecology 74:2025–2034
Floate KD, Whitham TG, Keim P (1994) Morphological versus genetic markers in classifying hybrid plants. Evolution (in press)
Fritz RS, Nichols-Orians CM, Brunsfeld SJ (1994) Interspecific hybridization of plants and resistance to herbivores: hypotheses, genetics, and variable responses in a diverse herbivore community. Oecologia 97:106–117
Gallun RL, Khush GS (1980) Genetic factors affecting expression and stability of resistance. In: Maxwell FG, Jennings PR (eds) Breeding plants resistant to insects. Wiley, New York, pp 63–85
Grant V (1981) Plant speciation, 2nd edn. Columbia University Press, New York
Jennrich R, Sampson P (1983) Stepwise discriminant analysis. In: Dixon WJ (ed) BMDP statistical software. University of California Press, Berkeley, pp 519–537
Keim P, Paige KN, Whitham TG, Lark KG (1989) Genetic analysis of an interspecific hybrid swarm of Populus: occurrence of unidirectional introgression. Genetics 123:557–565
Keim P, Beavis W, Schupp J, Freestone R (1992) Evaluation of soybean RFLP marker diversity in adapted germ plasm. Theor Appl Genet 85:205–212
Lanner RM (1974) Natural hybridization between Pinus edulis and Pinus monophylla in the American Southwest. Silv Genet 23:108–116
Lanner RM, Phillips AM (1992) Natural hybridization and introgression of pinyon pines in northwestern Arizona. Int J Plant Sci 153:250–257
Little EL (1968) Two new pinyon varieties from Arizona. Phytologia 17:329–341
Malusa J (1992) Phylogeny and biogeography of the pinyon pines (Pinus subsect. Cembroides). Syst Bot 17:42–66
Manley AM, Fowler DP (1969) Spruce budworm defoliation in relation to introgression in red and black spruce. For Sci 15:365–366
Martinsen GD, Whitham TG (1994) More birds nest in hybrid cottonwoods. Wilson Bulletin 106:474–481
Maxwell FG, Jennings PR (1980) Breeding plants resistant to insects. Wiley, New York
McClure MS (1985) Patterns of abundance, survivorship, and fecundity of Nuculaspis tsugae (Homoptera: Diaspididae) on Tsuga species in Japan in relation to elevation. Environ Entomol 14:413–415
Mitchell RG, Johnson NE, Wright KH (1974) Susceptibility of 10 spruce species and hybrids to the white pine weevil (=sitka spruce weevil) in the pacific northwest USDA For Serv Res Note PNW-225
Mopper S, Mitton JB, Whitham TG, Cobb NS, Christensen KM (1991) Genetic differentiation and heterozygosity in pinyon pine associated with resistance to herbivory and environmental stress. Evolution 45:989–999
Moran NA, Whitham TG (1988) Evolutionary reduction of complex life cycles: loss of host alternation in Pemphigus (Homoptera: Aphididae) Evolution 42:717–728
Moran NA (1991) Phenotype fixation and genotypic diversity in the complex life cycle of the aphid Pemphigus betae. Evolution 45:957–970
Morrow PA, Whitham TG, Potts BM, Ladiges P, Ashton DH, Williams JB (1994) Gall-forming insects concentrate on hybrid phenotypes of Eucalyptus. In: Baranchikov YN, Price PW, Mattson WJ Jr (eds) Gall-forming insects: ecology, physiology and evolution. USDA For Serv North Central For Exp St, GTRNC-174, pp 121–134
Paige KN, Capman WC (1993) The effects of host-plant genotype, hybridization, and environment on gall-aphid attack and survival in cottonwood: the importance of genetic studies and the utility of RFLPs. Evolution 47:36–45
Paige KN, Keim P, Whitham TG, Lark KG (1990) The use of restriction fragment length polymorphisms to study the ecology and evolutionary biology of aphid-plant interactions. In: Campbell RK, Eikenbary RD (eds) Aphid-plant genotype interactions. Elsevier, Amsterdam, pp 69–87
Parsons PA (1991) Evolutionary rates: stress and species boundaries. Annu Rev Ecol Syst 22:1–18
Price PW (1991) The plant vigor hypothesis and herbivore attack. Oikos 62:244–251
Riesberg LH, Wendel JF (1993) Introgression and its consequences in plants. In: Harrison RG (ed) Hybrid zones and the evolutionary process. Oxford University Press, New York, pp 70–109
Stace CA (1987) Hybridization and the plant species. In: Urbanska KM (ed) Differentiation patterns in higher plants. Academic Press, New York, pp 115–127
Tingey WM, Singh SR (1980) Environmental factors influencing the magnitude and expression of resistance. In: Maxwell FG, Jennings PR (eds) Breeding plants resistant to insects. Wiley, New York, pp 87–113
Waring GL, Cobb NS (1992) The impact of plant stress on herbivore population dynamics. In: Bernays EA (ed) Insect-plant interactions. CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL, pp 167–226
White TCR (1969) An index to measure weather-induced stress of trees associated with outbreaks of psyllids in Australia. Ecology 50:905–909
Whitham TG (1989) Plant hybrid zones as sinks for pests. Science 244:1490–1493
Whitham TG, Morrow PA, Potts BM (1991) Conservation of hybrid plants. Science 254:779–780
Whitham TG, Morrow PA, Potts BM (1994) Plant hybrid zones as centers of biodiversity: the herbivore community of two endemic Tasmanian eucalypts. Oecologia 97:481–490
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Christensen, K.M., Whitham, T.G. & Keim, P. Herbivory and tree mortality across a pinyon pine hybrid zone. Oecologia 101, 29–36 (1995). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00328896
Received:
Accepted:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00328896