Abstract
The Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD)-based thermal-hydraulics and safety analyses of Lead-based Fast Reactor (LFR) have attracted great attentions in recent years. Commercial CFD tools have been widely used in the 3D simulations of pool-type reactors owing to their powerful abilities in geometric modeling and meshing. Compared with the commercial CFD tools, OpenFOAM is a free open-source CFD code, which is more flexible to perform multi-physics coupling activities. In this paper, in order to develop a solver for simulating the coupled flow and heat transfer behaviors of fluid (coolant) and fuel pin in LFR, the fuel pin Heat Conduction (HC) model was coupled to the modified icoFoam solver of OpenFOAM. Verifications were conducted by the steady-state coupled simulation of fluid and fuel pin heat transfer behaviors, comparing with the MPC-LBE code which has been verified by the benchmarks for LFR fuel pin channel. The results simulated by the coupled solver proposed in this paper agreed well with the ones provided by the MPC-LBE code. This study lays a foundation for the further development of transient safety analysis code for LFR in our future work.
You have full access to this open access chapter, Download conference paper PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Keyword
1 Introduction
As one of the Generation-IV advanced nuclear energy systems, Lead-based Fast Reactor (LFR), has appealed to many international research institutions owing to its excellent inherent safety and nuclear sustainability [1]. The Lead Bismuth Eutectic (LBE) coolant employed in LFR with special characteristics (such as better heat conduction) different from the water (conventional coolant), as well as its integrative pool-type configuration may give rise to complicated three-dimensional thermal hydraulic phenomena in the large space plenum, such as thermal stratification and coolant mixing [2], making the thermal-hydraulics and safety problems of LFR always the research highlights. Computational fluid dynamics (CFD)-based commercial programs for simulating, owing to its mature technologies (plentiful models and algorithms) as well as the powerful pre-processing (modeling and mesh generation of complex geometric structures) capability, is considered as an effective method to overcome the multi-dimensional complicated thermal hydraulic problems involved in the liquid metal pool-type reactors [3].
At present, some commercial CFD tools, such as ANSYS Fluent, Star-CCM +, ABAQUS, have been widely used for simulations of liquid metal pool-type reactors, particularly the multi-scale coupling simulations with other reactor core physical models. For example, Gu Z. developed an advanced two-dimensional fuel pin heat transfer model, then integrated it with the self-developed PK model into ANSYS Fluent to conduct multi-physics coupling [4]. Deng J. developed a three-dimensional transient nuclear thermal coupling solution program based on OpenFOAM platform [5]. Narayanan developed the numerical models that deal with lead thermal hydraulics and solidification with ANSYS Fluent and Star-CCM + software [2].
As we summarized above, CFD tools are popularly used for multi-physics coupling simulation on liquid-metal-cooled reactors, but such commercial CFD programs are incapable to conduct the advanced coupling algorithms due to their closed source codes. OpenFOAM, as a free open-source CFD code, has a unique advantage of direct contact with the source code of existing solvers, making it relatively convenient for us to develop a new solver by modifying its source code from existing solver to vitally design its core computing functions.
In order to conduct the multi-physics coupling simulation with a high degree of customization based on complex coupling algorithms, a solver for simulating the coupled flow and heat transfer behaviors of fluid (coolant) and fuel pin in LFR was developed, and the fuel pin HC model was coupled to the modified icoFoam solver of OpenFOAM in this study. Verifications were conducted by the steady-state coupled simulation of coolant and fuel pin heat transfer behaviors, comparing with the MPC-LBE code which has been verified by the benchmarks for LFR fuel pin channel [6]. The simulation results agree well with the results provided by the MPC-LBE code, which shows the feasibility and accuracy of the solver.
2 Coupling of HC Code with Modified IcoFoam Solver
For LFR, the fuel pin channel consists of a slender cylindrical fuel pin and LBE coolant. Especially, the fuel pin constitutes of a centra hole, pin fuel pellet made of mixed oxides of uranium and its proliferator plutonium, gas plenum filled with Helium (under high pressure) and cladding mainly made of Zr-4 alloy. All the features above can be found in the benchmark reports [7].
2.1 CFD-Based Modifications of IcoFoam Solver
The new solver developed in this paper is based on the icoFoam solver of OpenFOAM, which can simulate the laminar flow by solving the incompressible Newtonian fluid N-S equations shown in Eq. (1) with the finite volume method.
In icoFoam, the fluid flow model is simplified by the neglect of gravity as well as the assumption of constant fluid density and kinematic viscosity. As shown in Fig. 1, the coupling solution of velocity and pressure, based on the simplified N-S equations and continuity equations, is obtained by using the transient PISO algorithm.
However, icoFoam is incapable of simulating the heat transfer phenomena in fluid (coolant) region due to the neglecting of energy conservative equation for fluid. To conduct the simulation coupled flow and heat transfer behaviors in coolant region, corresponding energy equation containing the heat source term, shown as Eq. (2), is added to icoFoam source code.
The velocity-based solution of energy conservative equation using the existing solver in OpenFOAM, is carried out after the coupling solution of velocity and pressure, as shown in Fig. 2.
What’s more, the new variables involved in this new equation, such as temperature, specific heat, conductivity etc., indispensably need to be added to the solver as mesh-based variable fields just, which is similar to the pressure and velocity. Meanwhile, these newly added variable fields should be defined and initialized in include files, source code and running environment, including internal meshes and boundary conditions.
In particular, with the consideration of temperature changes caused by the energy change in coolant channel, it should be noted that most of the coolant parameters (density, conductivity, kinematic viscosity) are no longer constants as before but variables changing with temperature, whose calculation formulas can be obtained in detail from the benchmark reports [7]. Consequently, it is necessary to calculate then update these variables as feedbacks to corresponding mesh-based variable fields after the temperatures are solved in each time-step. In this paper, as shown in Fig. 3, only the kinematic viscosity (involved in N-S equations), density and conductivity (involved in energy equation) are regarded as variables with the feedbacks from continuous update.
2.2 Coupling Strategies with HC Code and Modified IcoFoam Solver
The modified icoFoam can simulate both the flow and heat transfer phenomena in coolant region, a three-dimensional mesh system based on OpenFOAM, after the works we did in the last section. As for the fuel pin region, its heat conduction process can be described by using the fully implicit finite volume method to discretize then solve the Heat-Conduction Equation in fuel pin sub-mesh system based on two-dimensional cylindrical coordinate system, which is already in our previous research work [4].
Through the convective heat transfer process at the interface (cladding outer surface) between fuel pin and LBE coolant, the heat transfers in these two regions are coupled as each other's dynamic boundary conditions with the explicit calculating strategy as shown in Fig. 4.
Firstly, the average convective heat transfer coefficient and average coolant temperature at specific axial position are provided to the fuel pin heat transfer module within the same axial position after the temperatures are solved in each time-step. Especially, the calculations of these two average variables are conducted by modifying icoFoam source code.
After that, the fuel pin region gives a heat source to coolant region in return. Generally, this heat source is transferred in the form of heat flux as a boundary condition, nevertheless, in this study we tried a new method to conduct this transfer. By the heat flux calculated in fuel pin region, the power transferred from cladding outer surface to LBE coolant can be also obtained, which is applied to the meshes at the inner wall of coolant channel as its volume power density (external heat source). Many mesh related parameters need to be obtained then used for calculations above.
Importantly, the fuel pin heat transfer module (HC code) is added after the coolant module to icoFoam source code based on the integral coupling framework shown in Fig. 5, so as to realize the coupling calculations in each time-step. These two modules use the same time-step size (0.02s) to coupled calculate, which has been already proved that this size of time-step can guarantee numerical stability. In each time-step, the temperatures of fuel pin module and coolant module are calculated iteratively, until the calculated time-steps meet the steady-state establishment.
3 Verifications on Coupled Solver
3.1 Description and Mesh Generation for Computational Domain
In this paper, only a single fuel pin channel model is considered as the computational domain, whose composition is shown in Fig. 6 [6].
Model of fuel pin channel [6]
The computational domain is treated as a hexagon prism by its symmetrical characteristic. For the convenience of calculations of steady-state process, the inlet coolant temperature and velocity are constantly equal to the initial value, and the heat decay power is neglected. The geometry data and material properties of the fuel pin channel can be found with details in the benchmark report [6].
The fluid region in fuel pin channel is only the coolant channel, which is a complex digging hexagonal prism with a central hole. Therefore, such complicated channel is meshed by ANSYS instead of the existing meshing tool (blockMesh) of OpenFOAM. Then, this three-dimensional mesh system, shown in Fig. 7, is imported into OpenFOAM, whose quality analysis meets the service conditions.
3.2 Computation Results and Code Verification Compared with the MPC-LBE
The steady state of the fuel pin channel is simulated by using the HC-coupled modified icoFoam solver code (coupled solver) developed in this paper. In Figs. 8 and 9, the coolant temperature spatial distributions, both at the mid-plane and outlet of the coolant channel, occur the thermal stratification, and the high-temperature heat ring on the inner wall of coolant channel is thicker, owing to the better heat transfer performance of LBE (liquid metal) coolant compared with other general coolants (such as water). And it is obvious that the overall level of the outlet temperature is higher than that of the mid-plane, and the trend of the former gradually decreasing outward along the radial direction is slower than that of the latter.
What’s more, as shown in Fig. 10, four axial distribution related temperature curves, representing the fuel pellet inner surface, fuel pellet outer surface, cladding outer surface and coolant temperatures (arranged from high to low), are drawn and compared with the ones by the MPC-LBE code whose feasibility and accuracy have already been verified [4]. Since the power generated from fuel pellet will heat the coolant channel around with coolant continuously flowing through the channel, the coolant temperature will gradually rise during the process from inlet to outlet. Obviously, such good agreements are achieved in terms of both the trends and values among the results provided by the HC-coupled modified icoFoam solver code and by the MPC-LBE code [4] in Fig. 10.
4 Conclusions
In this paper, a single fuel pin channel model is established for the reactor core of LFR, so as to analyse the coupled flow and heat transfer behaviors in coolant and fuel pin. Multi-physics simulation system is built by coupling the fuel pin heat transfer model (two-dimensional HC module) to the three-dimensional open-source CFD code OpenFOAM by its icoFoam. This coupled simulation system for reactor thermal-hydraulics and safety analyses is abbreviated as the HC-coupled modified icoFoam solver code (coupled solver), which copes with the key data transmission problems of multi-physics coupling strategy within the framework of OpenFOAM platform. Mathematics models and methods as well as the coupling strategy of two modules are elaborated.
Verifications were conducted by the steady-state coupled simulation of flow and heat transfer behaviors between coolant and fuel pin regions in fuel pin channel of LFR, including the comparison with the benchmarks-verified MPC-LBE code [4]. The results simulated by the HC-coupled modified icoFoam solver code proposed in this paper agreed well with the ones provided by benchmarks-verified MPC-LBE code. It is testified that the HC-coupled modified icoFoam solver code is capable to perform the multi-physics simulations involved in thermal-hydraulics and safety analyses of LFR with enough accuracy.
However, only a simple single fuel pin model is considered to preliminarily verify the basic coupling strategies and schemes of reactor core heat transfer behaviors. Therefore, the coupling simulation of the whole fuel assembly channel of reactor core should be further studied in the future work, which can describe the reactor core more carefully and comprehensively. Meanwhile, for the heat transfer calculation coupled with coolant and fuel pin regions, the implicit iteration can be considered instead of the explicit calculating strategy used in this study. All in all, this study already verified the initial steady state, laying a foundation for the further development of transient safety analysis code to conduct transient simulation for LFR in our future work.
References
(S1), 11–16.
Achuthan, N., et al.: Computational fluid dynamics modelling of lead natural convection and solidification in a pool type geometry. Nuclear Engineering and Design, p. 376 (2021).
Tenchine, D.: Some thermal hydraulic challenges in sodium cooled fast reactors. Nucl. Eng. Des. 240(5), 1195–1217 (2010)
Gu, Z., Li, F., Ge, L., et al.: Verification of a HC-PK-CFD coupled program based a benchmark on beam trip transients for XADS reactor. Ann. Nucl. Energy 133, 491–500 (2019)
Deng, J., Deng, J., Li, Z., et al.: Study on transient characteristics of nuclear ramjet reactor based on three-dimensional nuclear thermal coupling method. Nucl. Sci. Eng. 42(01), 18–27 (2022)
Gu, Z.-X., et al.: Verification of a self-developed CFD-based multi-physics coupled code MPC-LBE for LBE-cooled reactor. Nucl. Sci. Tech. 32(5), 1–17 (2021). https://doi.org/10.1007/s41365-021-00887-x
D’Angelo, A., Arien, B., Sobolev, V., et al.: Benchmark on Beam Interruptions in an Accelerator-Driven System Final Report on Phase I Calculations, Technical Report NEA/NSC/DOC(2003)17, NEA (2003)
Behar, C.: Technology roadmap update for generation IV nuclear energy systems. In: OECD Nuclear Energy Agency for the Generation IV International Forum, accessed Jan. 2014, 17, 2014–03
Alemberti, A., Smirnov, V., Smith, C.F., et al.: Overview of leadcooled fast reactor activities. Prog. Nucl. Energy 77, 300–307 (2014)
Chen, H., Chen, Z., Chen, C., et al.: Conceptual design of a small modular natural circulation lead cooled fast reactor SNCLFR100. Inter. J. Hydrog. Energy 41(17), 7158–7168 (2016)
Chen, H., Zhang, X., Zhao, Y., et al.: Preliminary design of a medium-power modular lead-cooled fast reactor with the application of optimization methods. Inter. J. Hydrog. Energy 42(11), 3643–3657 (2018)
Zou Zeren et al. (2020). 3D thermal hydraulic characteristics analysis of pool-type upper plenum for lead-cooled fast reactor with multi-scale coupling program. Nuclear Engineering and Design, pp. 370 110892-
(02), 326-336.
(11), 424–433.
T.H. Fanning, A.J. Brunett, T. Sumner, The SAS4A/SASSYS-1 Safety Analysis Code System, Version 5 (Argonne national lab. (ANL), argonne, IL United States, 2017)
Mesina, G.L.: A history of RELAP computer codes. Nucl. Sci. Eng. 182(1), v–ix (2016)
Lerchl, G., Austregesilo, H., Glaeser, H., et al.: ATHLET Mod 3.0— Cycle A. Validation. Gesellschaft fu¨r Anlagen-und Reaktorsicherheit (GRS) gGmbH, Garching bei Mu¨nchen, Germany, Report No. GRS-P-1, 2012, 3
Fanning, T.H., Thomas, J.W.: Advances in Coupled Safety Modeling Using Systems Analysis and High-Fidelity Methods (Argonne national lab. (ANL) argonne, IL United States (2010)
Pialla, D., Tenchine, D., Li, S., et al.: Overview of the system alone and system/CFD coupled calculations of the PHENIX natural circulation test within the THINS project. Nucl. Eng. Des. 290, 78–86 (2015)
Bandini, G., Polidori, M., Gerschenfeld, A., et al.: Assessment of systems codes and their coupling with CFD codes in thermal– hydraulic applications to innovative reactors. Nucl. Eng. Des. 281, 22–38 (2015)
Chen, Z., Chen, X.N., Rineiski, A., et al.: Coupling a CFD code with neutron kinetics and pin thermal models for nuclear reactor safety analyses. Ann. Nucl. Energy 83, 41–49 (2015)
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Editor information
Editors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
Open Access This chapter is licensed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license and indicate if changes were made.
The images or other third party material in this chapter are included in the chapter's Creative Commons license, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the chapter's Creative Commons license and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder.
Copyright information
© 2023 The Author(s)
About this paper
Cite this paper
Ou, W., Gong, Z., Pan, Q., Zhang, L., Dai, J., Gu, Z. (2023). Verification of Solver for Coupled Simulation of Fluid and Fuel Pin in LFR Based on Openfoam. In: Liu, C. (eds) Proceedings of the 23rd Pacific Basin Nuclear Conference, Volume 1. PBNC 2022. Springer Proceedings in Physics, vol 283. Springer, Singapore. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-981-99-1023-6_77
Download citation
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-981-99-1023-6_77
Published:
Publisher Name: Springer, Singapore
Print ISBN: 978-981-99-1022-9
Online ISBN: 978-981-99-1023-6
eBook Packages: Physics and AstronomyPhysics and Astronomy (R0)