Abstract
The programs involving screening of newborn populations for abnormal chromosome genotype, in particular the study at the Boston Hospital for Women, have been subject to well publicized criticism because of the alleged consequences for infants (and their families) with XYY genotype detected in such studies (1–5). These criticisms have focused on some specific aspects of the Boston study, but they have much broader significance. Among other issues, they directly raise the question of the relationship of the XYY genotype to behavior and the broader social implications of such a purported relationship.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Access this chapter
Tax calculation will be finalised at checkout
Purchases are for personal use only
Preview
Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.
References
Beckwith, J., Elseviers, D., Gorini, L. et al, Harvard XYY study, Science 187: 298 (1975).
Beckwith, J. and King, J., The XYY syndrome: a dangerous myth, New Scientist, 64: 474 (1974).
Brody, J.E., Scientists group terms Boston study of children with extra sex chromosome unethical and harmful, The New York Times, Friday, Nov. 15, 1974, p. 16.
Culliton, B.J., ‘Patients’ rights: Harvard is site of battle over X & Y chromosomes, Science 186: 715 (1974).
Culliton, B.J., Harvard faculty says XYY study should continue, Science 186: 1189 (1974).
Hook, E.B., Behavioral implications of the human XYY genotype, Science 179: 139 (1973).
Hook, E.B., Rates of XYY genotype in penal and mental settings, Lancet 1: 98 (1975).
Robinson, A. and Puck, T.T., Studies in chromosomal non-disjunction in man. II, Amer. J. Hum. Genet. 10: 112 (1967).
Kessler, S. and Moos, R.H., The XYY karyotype and criminality: A review, J. Psychiat. Res. 7: 153 (1970).
Baker, D., Telfer, M.A., Richardson, C.E. et al, Chromosome errors in man with anti-social behavior, J.A.M.A. 214: 869 (1970).
Casey, M.D., Blank, C.E., Mobley, T. Et al, Special hospital research report number 2 (Broadmoor Hospital, Berks, U.K.) p. 1 (1971).
Price, W.H. and Whatmore, P.B., Criminal behaviour and the XYY males, Nature 213: 815 (1967).
Price, W.H. and Whatmore, P.B., Behaviour disorders and pattern of crime among XYY males identified at a maximum security hospital, Brit. Med. J. 1: 533 (1967).
Bordaonkar, D.S. and Shah, S.A., The XYY chromosome male ‐‐ or syndrome?, Prog. Med. Genet. 10: 135 (1974).
Hook, E.B.: Racial differentials in the prevalence rates of males with sex chromosome abnormalities (XXY, XYY) in security settings in the U.S.A., Amer. J. Hum. Genet. 26: 504 (1974).
Ratcliffe, S.G. and Evans, H.J., Sex chromosome abnormalities and social class, Lancet 1: 1144 (1975).
Anonymous, What becomes of the XYY male? Lancet 2: 1297 (1974).
Leonard, M.F., Landy, G., Ruddle, F.H. Et al, Early development of children with abnormalities of the sex chromosomes: A prospective study, Pediatrics 54:208 (1974) and Leonard, M.F., Personal communication (1974). The paper cited pools all data on those with sex chromosome abnormalities; data on the specific genotypes were provided by the senior author.
Lubs, H.A., Personal communication.
Zeuthen, E., Hanse, M., Christensen, A.L. et al, A psychiatric- psychological study of XYY males found in a general male popu-lation, Acta Psychiat. Scand. 51: 3 (1975).
Noel, B., Duport, J.P., Revil, D., et al, The XYY syndrome: Reality or myth? Clin. Genet. 5: 387 (1974).
Valentine, G.H., McClelland, M.A. and Sergovich, F.R., The growth and development of four XYY infants, Pediatrics 48: 583 (1971). This paper is cited by Beckwith Et al (Science 187:298 (1975))concerning anxieties induced by parents learning of the XYY genotype. Ironically, the child of the parents who did learn of the diagnosis had a better outcome than those of parents who were not informed but of course other factors probably contributed to the difference in outcome. The paper describes a parental reaction in the early part of 1968 incidentally when the publicity, a good deal of it false, was at its peak on this issue.
Rosenthal, R., The Pygmalion effect lives, Psychology Today 7: 56 (1973).
Caldwell, P.D. and Smith, D.W., The XXY (Klinefelter’s) syndrome in childhood: Detection and treatment, J. Pediat. 80: 250 (1972).
Mellman, W.J., Chromosomal screening of human populations, in “Ethical, Social, and Legal Dimensions of Screening for Human Genetic Disease,” Bergsma, D. (ed.), Birth Defects Original Article Series, X:123 (1974), Symposia Specialists, Miami.
Myhre, S.A., Ruvalcaba, R.H.A., Johnson, H.R., The effects of testosterone treatment in Klinefelter’s syndrome. J. Pediat. 76: 267 (1970).
Nielsen, J., Chromosome examination of newborn children, Humangenetik 26: 215 (1975).
Eller, E., Frankenburg, W., Puck, M. et al, Prognosis in newborn infants with X-chromosomal abnormalities, Pediatrics 47: 681 (1971).
Hilton, B., Callahan, D., Harris, M. et al, (eds.) Ethical Issues in Human Genetics. Plenum Press, New York, pp.275–281 (1973).
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Editor information
Rights and permissions
Copyright information
© 1976 Plenum Press, New York
About this chapter
Cite this chapter
Hook, E.B. (1976). Geneticophobia and the Implications of Screening for the XYY Genotype in Newborn Infants. In: Milunsky, A., Annas, G.J. (eds) Genetics and the Law. Springer, Boston, MA. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-4684-2229-0_8
Download citation
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-4684-2229-0_8
Publisher Name: Springer, Boston, MA
Print ISBN: 978-1-4684-2231-3
Online ISBN: 978-1-4684-2229-0
eBook Packages: Springer Book Archive