Summary
The benefit/risk ratio of β- blocking drugs is reviewed in the light of many years of widespread use.
It is reasonably certain that the ‘practolol syndrome’ will not occur in association with the currently available and commonly prescribed β- blockers. Other predictable side effects, such as bradycardia, fatigue and cold peripheries are discussed, as well as the possibility of exacerbation of obstructive airways disease, heart failure and intermittent claudication while on β- blocking drugs.
The incidence of these and other side effects is discussed in relation to the pharmaco- kinetic properties of various β- blockers and it is concluded that all β- blockers have a high benefit/risk ratio and that the ideal β- blocker profile for optimal safety and acceptability is high cardioselectivity plus high hydrophilicity (low lipid solubility).
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Amery, A.; De Plaen, J.F.; Lignen, P.; McAinsh, J. and Reybrouck, T.: Relationship between blood level of atenolol and pharmacologic effect. Clinical Pharmacology and Therapeutics 2(6): 691–699 (1977).
Amos, H.E.; Brigden, W.D. and McKerron, R.A.: Untoward effects associated with practolol: Demonstration of antibody binding to epithelia tissue. British Medical Journal 1: 598–600 (1975).
Anderson, O.; Berglund, G.; Hansson, L.; Sannderstedt, K.; Sivertsson, R.; Wikstrand, J. and Wilhelmsen, L.: Organization and efficacy of an out-patient hypertension clinic. Acta Med-ica Scandinavica 203: 391–398 (1978).
Bailey, R.R. and Neale, T.J.: Rapid clonidine withdrawal with blood pressure overshoot exaggerated by beta-blockade. British Medical Journal 1: 942–943 (1976).
Benaim, M.E.: Asystole after verapamil. British Medical Journal 2: 169 (1972).
Benson, M.K.; Berrill, W.R.; Cruickshank, J.M. and Sterling: A comparison of four beta-adrenoceptor antagonists in patients with asthma. British Journal of Clinical Pharmacology 5: 415–419 (1978).
Betts, T.A. and Alford, C: A double-blind comparison between four beta-blocking drugs and their effects on subjective reports of sleep. Ninth Scientific Meeting of the International Society of Hypertension, Mexico (1982).
Betts, T.A. and Alford, C: β-Blocking drugs and sleep: A controlled trial. Drugs 25 (Suppl. 2): 268–272 (1983).
BHAT: The Beta-blocker Heart Attack Study Group: Preliminary report. Journal of the American Medical Association 248 (No. 18): 2073–2074 (1981)
Booth, R.J.; Bullock, J.Y. and Wilson, J.D.: Antinuclear antibodies during acebutolol therapy. Clinical Pharmacology and Therapeutics 25(6): 800–805 (1979).
Boothby, C.G.; Garrard, C.S. and Pickering, D.: Intravenous verapamil in cardiac arrhythmias. British Medical Journal 2: 349 (1972).
Burgess-Record, N.: Acebutolol-induced pleuropulmonary lupus syndrome: Annals of Internal Medicine 95(3): 326–327 (1981).
Castle, W.M.; Cruickshank, J.M. and Waycott, J.A.: Retroperitoneal fibrosis associated with atenolol. British Medical Journal 2: 311 (1980).
Cocco, G.; Strozzi, C.; Chu, D.; Amrein, R. and Castagnoli, E.: Therapeutic effects of pindolol and nifedipine in patients with stable angina pectoris and asymptomatic resting ischaemia. European Journal of Cardiology 10(1): 59–69 (1979).
Cody, R.J.; Calabrese, L.H.; Clough, J.D.; Tarazi, R.C. and Bravo, E.L.: Development of antinuclear antibodies during acebutolol therapy. Clinical Pharmacology and Therapeutics 25(6): 800–805 (1979).
Committee on Safety of Medicines: Current Problems. Retroperitoneal fibrosis and beta-adrenoreceptor antagonists. No. 6 (July 1981).
Conolly, M.E.; Briant, R.H.; George, C.F. and Dollery, C.T.: A crossover comparison of clonidine and methyldopa in hypertension. European Journal of Clinical Pharmacology 4: 222- 227 (1972).
Conway, J.: Beta-adrenergic blockade and hypertension; in Oliver (Ed.) Cardiology 3, pp.376–403 (Butterworths, London 1975).
Cruickshank, J.M.: The clinical importance of cardioselectivity and lipophilicity in beta-blockers. American Heart Journal 100(2): 160–178 (1980).
Cruickshank, J.M.: Beta-blockers, bradycardia and adverse effects. Acta Therapeutica 7: 309–321 (1981).
Cumberbatch, J.B.: Skin reactions to beta-blockers. British Medical Journal 4: 528 (1974).
Davies, B.; Bannister, R.; Mathias, C. and Sever, P.: Pindolol in postural hypotension: the case for caution. Lancet 2: 982–983 (1981).
Day, J.L.; Metcalfe, J. and Simpson, C.N.: Adrenergic mechanisms in control of plasma lipid concentrations. British Medical Journal 284: 1145–1151 (1982).
Day, J.L.; Simpson, C.N.; Metcalfe, J. and Page, R.L.: Metabolic consequences of atenolol and propranolol in treatment of essential hypertension. British Medical Journal 1: 77–80 (1979).
Deacon, C.S.; Lennard, M.S.; Bax, N.D.S.; Woods, H.F. and Tucker, G.T.: Inhibition of oxidative drug metabolism by beta-adrenoceptor antagonists is related to their lipid solubility. British Journal of Clinical Pharmacology 12: 429–431 (1981).
Deacon, S.P.: Effect of atenolol and other beta-blockers on insulin-induced hypoglycaemia. Proceedings of the Royal Society of Medicine 70(Suppl. 5): 50–52 (1977).
Decalmer, P.B.S.; Chatterjee, S.S.; Cruickshank, J.M.; Benson, M.K.. and Sterling, G.M.: Beta-blockers and asthma. British Heart Journal 40: 184–189 (1978).
Diehm, C.; Comberg, H.U.; Ey, A.; Morl, H. and Schettler, G.: Peripheral arterial vaso-occlusive disease: no absolute contraindication to beta-receptor blockers. Deutsche Medizinische Wochenschrift 106: 1413–1415 (1981).
Ellis, M.E.; Sahay, J.N.; Chatterjee, S.S.; Cruickshank, J.M. and Ellis, S.H.: Cardioselectivity of atenolol in asthmatic patients. European Journal of Clinical Pharmacology 21: 173–176 (1981).
Epstein, S.E.; Robinson, B.F.; Kahler, R.L. and Braunwald, E.: Effects of beta-adrenergic blockade on the cardiac response to maximal and submaximal exercise in man. Journal of Clinical Investigation 44: 1745–1753 (1965).
Felix, R.H.; Ive, F.A. and Dahl, M.G.C.: Skin reactions to beta-blockers. British Medical Journal 1: 626 (1975).
Finlay, A.Y. and Waddington, E.: Cutaneous reactions to labetalol. British Medical Journal 2: 987 (1978).
Forrest, W.A.: A clinical trial of oxprenolol in general practice. Practitioner 208: 412–416 (1972).
Frisk-Holmberg, M.; Jorfeldt, L. and Juhlin-Dannfelt, A.: Metabolic effects in muscle during antihypertensive therapy with beta, and beta1/beta2 adrenoceptor blockers. Clinical Pharmacology and Therapeutics 30(5): 611–618 (1981).
Gange, R.W. and Wilson-Jones, E.: Bullous lichen planus caused by labetalol. British Medical Journal 1: 816–817 (1978).
Greminger, P.; Vetter, H.; Boerlin, J.H.; Havelka, J.; Baumgart, P.; Walger, P.; Luscher, T.; Siegenthaler, W. and Vetter, W.: A comparative study between 1 OOmg atenolol and 20mg pindolol slow-release in essential hypertension. Drugs 25(Suppl.2): 38–41 (1983).
Harrison, P.V. and Rowell, N.R.: Atenolol causing cutaneous eruption. Clinical and Experimental Dermatology 4(4): 547–548 (1979).
Harrison, R.N. and Tattersfield, A.E.: The cardioselectivity of atenolol and metoprolol at 2 and 24 hours after a single dose. Ninth Scientific Meeting of the Internation Society of Hypertension, Mexico (1982).
Imataka, K.; Seki, A.; Takahashi, N.; Fujii, J.; Ohuchi, Y.; Kuwako, K.; Umeda, T.; Machii, K.; Hasegawa, T. and Ozoe, A.: Elevation of serum creatine phosphokinase during pindolol treatment. Journal of the Japanese Society of Internal Medicine 70(4): 580–585 (1981).
Janzon, L.; Bergentz, S.E.; Ericsson, B.F. and Lindell, S.E.: Intermittent claudication and hypertension. Ankle pressure and walking distance in patients with well-treated and non-treated hypertension. Angiology 32(3): 175–179 (1981).
Jachuck, S.J.; Bird, T.; Stephenson, J.; Jackson, E.S. and Clark, F.: Practolol-induced autoantibodies and their relation to oculo-cutaneous complications. Postgraduate Medical Journal 53: 75–77 (1977).
Kaijser, L.; Kaiser, P.; Karlsson, J. and Rossner, S.: Beta-blockers and running. American Heart Journal 100(6): 943–944 (1980).
Kirch, W.; Kohler, H.; Spahn, H. and Mutschier, E.: Interaction of cimetidine with metoprolol, propranolol or atenolol. Lancet 2: 531–532 (1981).
Koch, G.; Franz, I.W. and Lohmann, F.W.: Effects of short-term and long-term treatment with cardioselective and non-selective beta-receptor blockade on carbohydrate and lipid metabolism and on plasma catecholamines at rest and during exercise. Clinical Sciences 651(Suppl. 7): 433s–435s (1981).
Kristensen, B.O.: Labetalol-induced Peyronie’s disease. Acta Medica Scandinavica 206: 511 (1979).
Kristinsson, J. and Johannesson, T.: A case of fatal propranolol intoxication. Acta Pharmacologica et Toxicologica 41: 190–192 (1977).
Larkin, H.; Gallery, E.D.M.; Hunyor, S.N.; Gyory, A.Z. and Boyce, E.S.: Cardiac and haemodynamic measurements in hypertensive pregnancy. Clinical Sciences 59: 357s–360s (1980).
Latour, Y.; Dumont, G.; Brosseau, A. and Lelorier, J.: Effects of sotalol in twenty patients with cardiac arrhythmias. International Journal of Clinical Pharmacology and Biopharmacy 15: 275–278 (1977).
Lawrence, D.S.; Sahay, J.N.; Chatterjee, S.S. and Cruickshank, J.M.: Asthma and beta-blockers. European Journal of Clinical Pharmacology 22: 501–509 (1982).
Leenan, F.H.H.; Coenen, C.H.M.; Zonderland, M. and Maas, A.H.J.: Effects of cardioselective and non-selective beta-blockade on dynamic exercise performance in mildly hypertensive men. Clinical Pharmacology and Therapeutics 28: 12–21 (1980).
Levene, G.M. and Gange, R.W.: Eruption during treatment with oxprenolol. British Medical Journal 1: 784 (1978).
Liedholm, H.: Atenolol in the treatment of hypertension of pregnancy. Drugs 25 (Suppl. 2): 206–211 (1983).
Lindenfeld, J.; Crawford, M.H.; O’Rourke, R.A.; Levine, S.P.; Montiel, M.M. and Horwitz, L.D.: Adrenergic responsiveness after abrupt propranolol withdrawal in normal subjects and in patients with angina pectoris. Circulation 6(4): 704–711 (1980).
Lyngsøe, J.; Lauridsen, U.B. and Christensen, N.J.: The effects of beta1-selective and non-selective beta-adrenergic blockade on glucose kinetics, plasma catecholamines and blood pressure during insulin-induced hypoglycaemia in man. Ninth Scientific Meeting of the International Society of Hypertension, Mexico (1982).
Marshall, A.J.; Roberts, C.J.C. and Barritt, D.W.: Raynaud’s phenomenon as side effect of beta-blockers in hypertension. British Medical Journal 1: 1498–1499 (1976).
McLean, A.J.; Skews, H.; Bobik, A. and Dudley, F.J.: Interaction between oral propranolol and hydralazine. Clinical Pharmacology and Therapeutics 27: 726–732 (1980).
Mikkelsen, H.I.; Erenlund Jensen, H.A.; Wadskov, S.; Lerche, A. and Sondergaard, J.: Aggravation of psoriasis and occurrence of psoriasiform cutaneous eruptions induced by beta-blocking agents. Clinical Pharmacology and Therapeutics 3: 152 (1975).
Miller, R.R.; Olson, H.G.; Amsterdam, E.A. and Mason, D.T.: Propranolol withdrawal rebound phenomenon. New England Journal of Medicine 293: 416–418 (1975).
Michinson, M.J.: Some clinical aspects of idiopathic retroperitoneal fibrosis. British Journal of Surgeons 59: 58–60 (1972).
Myers, M.G. and Wisenberg, G.: Sudden withdrawal of propranolol in patients with angina pectoris. Chest 71: 24–26 (1977).
Nattel, S.; Rangno, R.E. and Van Loon, G.: Mechanisms of propranolol withdrawal phenomena. Circulation 59(6): 1158–1164 (1979).
Neil-Dwyer, G.; Bartlett, J.; McAinsh, J. and Cruickshank, J.M.: Beta-adrenoceptor blockers and the blood-brain barrier. British Journal of Clinical Pharmacology 11: 549–553 (1981).
Neuvonen, P.J.; Elonen, E. and Tarssanen, L.: Sotalol intoxication, two patients with concentration-effect relationships. Acta Pharmacologica et Toxicologica 45: 52–57 (1979).
Ohlsson, O. and Lindell, S-E.: The effects of pindolol and prazosin on hand blood flow in patients with cold extremities and on treatment with beta-blockers. Acta Medica Scandinavica 210: 217–219 (1981).
Osborne, D.R.: Propranolol and Peyronie’s disease. Lancet 1: 1111 (1977).
Pasotti, C.; Capra, A.; Fiorella, G.; Vibelli, C. and Chierichetti, S.M.: Effects of pindolol and metoprolol on plasma lipids and lipoproteins. British Journal of Clinical Pharmacology 113: 435S–439S (1982).
Prichard, B.N.C.: Propranolol in the treatment of angina: a review. Postgraduate Medical Journal 52(Suppl. 4): 35–41 (1976).
Prichard, B.N.C.; McDevitt, D.G. and Shanks, R.G.: Uses of beta-adrenoceptor blocking drugs. Journal of the Royal College of Physicians 11(1): 35–37 (1976).
Pryor, J.P. and Castle, W.M.: Peyronie’s disease associated with chronic degenerative arterial disease and not with beta-adrenoceptor agents. Lancet 1: 917 (1982).
Pryor, J.P. and Khan, O.: Beta-blockers and Peyronie’s disease Lancet 1: 331 (1979).
Raftery, E.B. and Denman, A.M.: Systemic lupus erythematosus syndrome induced by practolol. British Medical Journal 2: 452 (1973).
Report of Medical Research Council Working Party on Mild to Moderate Hypertension: Adverse reactions to bendrofluazide and propranolol for the treatment of mild hypertension Lancet 2: 539-543 (1981).
Reybrouck, T.; Amery, A. and Billiet, L.: Haemodynamic response to graded exercise after chronic beta-adrenergic blockade. Journal of Applied Physiology, Respiratory, Environmental and Exercise Physiology 42(2): 133–138 (1977).
Richardson, P.S. and Sterling, G.M.: Effects of beta-adrenergic receptor blockade on airway conductance and lung volume in normal and asthmatic subjects. British Medical Journal 3: 143–146 (1969).
Rowland, E.; Evans, T. and Krikler, D.M.: Effect of nifedipine on atrioventricular conduction as compared with verapamil. Intracardiac electrophysiological study. British Heart Journal 42(2): 124–127 (1979)
Rubin, P.C.; Butters, L.; Low, R.A.; Clark, D.C. and Reid, J.L.: Atenolol in the management of hypertension during pregnancy. Drugs 25 (Suppl. 2): 212–214 (1983).
Simpson, W.T.: Nature and incidence of unwanted effects with atenolol. Postgraduate Medical Journal 53(Suppl. 3): 162–167 (1977).
Smith, R.S. and Warren, D.J.: Effect of beta-blocking drugs on peripheral blood flow in intermittent claudication. Journal of Cardiovascular Pharmacology 4(1): 2–4 (1982).
Sotaniemi, E.A.; Anttila, M.; Pelkonen, R.O.; Sako, S. and Sundqvist, H.: Role of liver drug metabolism in selection of beta-blocking drugs. Clinical Pharmacology and Therapeutics 27: 287 (1980).
Staughton, R.; Sutton, R. and Farrell, M.: Beta-blockers, autoimmunity and rashes. Lancet 2: 581 (1980).
Steiner, J.A.; Cooper, R.; McPherson, K. and Riley, A.: Effect of beta-blockers on prevalence of acrocyanosis in hypertensives. World Conference on Clinical Pharmacology and Therapeutics, London, 0428, (1980).
Strauss, F.G.; Franklin, S.S.; Lewin, A.J. and Maxwell, M.H.: Withdrawal of antihypertensive therapy. Journal of the American Medical Association 238: 1734 (1977).
Swanson, H.; Beauchamp, G.D.; Bell, H. and Kindred, L.: Reversible cardiogenic shock. Journal of the Kansas Medical Society 76: 260 (1975).
Thompson, J. and Julian, D.G.: Retroperitoneal fibrosis associated with metoprolol. British Medical Journal 284: 83–84 (1982).
Thomas, J.A. and Marks, B.H.: Plasma norepinephrine in congestive heart failure. American Journal of Cardiology 41: 233 (1978).
Trap-Jensen, J.; Carlsen, J.E.; Svendsen, T.L. and Christensen, N.J.: Cardiovascular and adrenergic effects of cigarette smoking during immediate non-selective and selective beta-adrenoceptor blockade in humans. European Journal of Clinical Investigation 9: 181–183 (1979).
Turner, J.E. and Cravey, R.H.: A fatal case involving propranolol and codeine. Clinical Toxicology 8(3): 271–275 (1975).
Vandenburg, M.J.; Conlon, C. and Ledingham, J.M.: A comparison of the effects of propranolol and oxprenolol on forearm blood flow and skin temperature. British Journal of Clinical Pharmacology 11: 485–490 (1981).
Warren, D.J.; McSorley, P. and Naik, R.B.: Effects of beta-adrenergic blocking drugs on peripheral blood flow. VIII. World Congress of Cardiology, Tokyo (1978).
Warren, V. and Goldberg, E.: Combined therapy with propranolol and permanent pervenous pacemaker. Journal of the American Medical Association 235: 841–842 (1976).
Webster, J.; Hawksworth, G.M.; Baber, H.E.; Jeffers, T.A. and Petrie, J.C.: Withdrawal of long-term therapy with atenolol in hypertensive patients. British Journal of Clinical Pharmacology 12: 211–214 (1981).
Weiner, L. and Rössner, A.: A comparison between 50mg atenolol or 200mg metoprolol/day with regard to blood pressure, side effects and serum lipoproteins. Ninth Scientific Meeting of the Internation Society of Hypertension, Mexico (1982).
WHO/ISH Mild Hypertension Liaison Committee: Trials of the treatment of mild hypertension. An Interim Analysis. Lancet 1: 149–156 (1982).
Wilcox, R.G. and Hampton, J.R.: Comparative study of atenolol, metoprolol, metoprolol durules and slow-release oxprenolol in essential hypertension. British Heart Journal 46: 498–502 (1981).
Wilcox, R.G.; Roland, J.M.; Banks, D.C.; Hampton, J.R. and Mitchell, J.R.A.: Randomised trial comparing propranolol with atenolol in immediate treatment of suspected myocardial infarction. British Medical Journal 280: 885–888 (1980).
Wilson, D.F.; Watson, O.F.; Peel, J.S. and Turner, A.S.: Trasicor in angina pectoris: a double-blind trial. British Medical Journal 2: 155–157 (1969).
Woods, P.B. and Robinson, M.L.: An investigation of the comparative liposolubilities of beta-adrenoceptor blocking agents. Journal of Pharmacy and Pharmacology 33: 172–173 (1981).
Yudkin, J.S.: Withdrawal of clonidine. Lancet 1: 546 (1977).
Yudkin, J.S.: Peyronie’s disease in association with metoprolol. Lancet 2: 1335 (1977).
Yusuf, S.; Peto, R.; Bennett, D.; Ramsdale, D.; Furse, L.; Bray, C. and Sleight, P.: Early intravenous atenolol treatment in suspected acute myocardial infarction. Lancet 2: 273–276 (1980).
Zacharias, F.J.: Cross-sensitivity between practolol and other beta-blockers? British Medical Journal 2: 1213 (1976).
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Cruickshank, J.M. How Safe are β-Blockers?. Drugs 25 (Suppl 2), 331–340 (1983). https://doi.org/10.2165/00003495-198300252-00096
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2165/00003495-198300252-00096