Relation between magnesium and calcium and parameters of pain, quality of life and depression in women with fibromyalgia

Abstract

Objective

Determine food intake and levels of serum magnesium (Mg) and calcium (Ca) and correlate these minerals with pain, quality of life and depression risk in women with and without fibromyalgia (FM).

Patients and methods

Fifty-three women diagnosed with FM and 50 healthy women participated in the study, where all of them had equivalent age and body mass index (BMI). All women underwent anthropometric assessment, physical exams of pain perception threshold and tender point (TP) count, blood sample collection, and filling out of FM impact questionnaire (FIQ), Patient Health Questionnaire-9 (PHQ-9), and 3-day dietary record (DR).

Results

Dietary intake of Mg and Ca was substantially lower by women with FM. There were no differences in levels of serum Mg and Ca in the groups under analysis. For the FM group, dietary intake of Mg and Ca had inverse correlation with TP and direct relation with the pain threshold.

Conclusions

Although women with FM had lower dietary intake of Mg and Ca, serum levels for these nutrients were not different between the groups. Low dietary intake of minerals correlated with worsened pain threshold parameters.

Introduction

Fibromyalgia (FM) is a complex chronic syndrome of unknown etiology characterized by profound, disseminated pain, sleep disorders, cognitive impairment, fatigue, and other functional symptoms. Recently, it has been suggested that an unbalance of dietary components including metallic ions and vitamins may play a major role in the development of FM [1].

Several research studies have shown that patients with chronic pain do not follow the recommended dietary intake of most vitamins and minerals [2,3,4,5]; and such deficiencies have been associated to several pathological conditions of chronic pain, including FM [1, 3, 4].

Additionally, studies have investigated the impact of magnesium (Mg) on pain improvement [4, 6,7,8,9]. Mg is an important trace element for many metabolic functions, also vital for the activity of over 300 enzymes [6]. Mg deficiency has been associated to headache, migraine, fibromyalgia, increase in C-reactive Protein (CRP), osteoporosis, cardiovascular disease, and other conditions [10].

Magnesium acts by inhibiting several nerve receptors, such as N-methyl-D-aspartate (NMDA), which relate to the origin of certain types of FM pain [11, 12]. Mg blocks Ca channels, including the channel of NMDA receptors, and that could probably explain its analgesic effect [13]. When Mg is deficient, it is possible to notice increase in the activity of the NMDA receptor [14], as well as Substance P, which may lead to increased pain and higher levels of hormones related to stress [7].

Mg plays a major role also in FM, given that several manifestations of this condition, such as fatigue, muscle weakness, irritable bowel, and paresthesia are similar to the symptoms of deficiency in Mg [4]. Moreover, such deficiency may have a shared link among stress, inflammation and metabolic syndrome, which may cause an inappropriate response with the activation of intracellular calcium (Ca) [2].

Mg frequently acts as natural antagonist of Ca [15]. While Ca acts as stimulator of muscle contraction, Mg acts as relaxant [16]. These two cations compete for the modulation of muscle contraction and regulate several enzymatic reactions involved in energetic metabolism, in signal transduction, and in brain activity [17].

It is not yet a consensus in the literature whether serum levels and dietary intake of Mg and Ca may be correlated with FM signs and symptoms. Therefore, this study aims to determine the food intake and serum levels of magnesium and calcium, and correlate these minerals to pain, quality of life and depression risk in women with and without fibromyalgia.

Materials and methods

A cross-sectional research study was performed between March and October 2012, and approved by the Research Ethics Committee of the Hospital de Clínicas of the Federal University of Paraná (HC/UFPR). The study analyzed women in ages between 18 to 60 years, selected at the Rheumatology Outpatient Clinic at the HC/UFPR, who had been diagnosed with FM according to criteria set forth by the American College of Rheumatology (ACR) in 1990 [18]. The reason for including only women in the study was the low prevalence of fibromyalgia among men. The control group consisted of women with the same age span who did not have FM and other associated clinical conditions.

Patients with fibromyalgia and depression or anxiety were only included if their treatment had remained unchanged for 3 months. The exclusion criteria were: use of calcium and magnesium supplements, medication change over the previous 4 weeks, use of corticosteroids or anticytokine agents, pregnancy, lactation, and a diagnosis of diabetes, decompensated endocrine diseases, infectious diseases (over the previous 4 weeks), demyelinating neurological diseases, peripheral neuropathies, inflammatory articular diseases, systemic autoimmune diseases, severe cardiovascular diseases, malignancy (over the previous year), and severe psychiatric diseases (substance abuse, schizophrenia, psychosis). Nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory agents were suspended 48 h before collection of blood samples, and all other medications were required to remain unchanged for at least 30 days.

After having executed an Informed Consent Agreement, all women underwent anthropometric assessment, physical exam of pain perception threshold and tender point (TP) count, blood sample collection, filling out of FM impact questionnaire, (FIQ), of Patient Health Questionnaire-9 (PHQ-9), and 3-day dietary record (DR).

Anthropometric assessment was performed by means of body mass index (BMI) consisting of the relation between body weight in kilograms and body height squared in meters: BMI = weight/height(m)² [19].

The pain threshold was evaluated at the trapezius muscle, using a Fischer algometer (model FDK 20, Wagner Instruments, Greenwich, CT, USA). Each TP was manually palpated with a strength of 4 kgf/cm² and the response was recorded as positive (with pain) or negative (without pain). In order to measure the pain threshold in the TP located in the right trapezius, the algometer was placed against the skin of the participant and pressed with a strength of 1 kgf/s until pain onset. Then, the pressure (in kgf/cm²) was recorded and defined as the pain threshold.

Blood samples for measuring serum magnesium (Mg) and calcium (Ca) were drawn in the morning after a 10–12-h fasting. Samples were then placed in ice and centrifuged at 4 °C. Serum was stored at − 80 °C. for later analysis at the UFPR Clinical Analysis Laboratory. For the determination of Mg and Ca levels, the Abbott C9000 and/or Ci8200 devices were used. According to the laboratory, reference range values for serum magnesium are 1.6–2.6 mg/dL and for serum calcium are 8.9–10 mg/dL.

The FIQ was employed to assess the impact of FM in quality of life. This questionnaire covers matters related to functional capacity, professional situation, psychological disorders and physical symptoms. It features a score ranging from 0 to 100 – the higher the score, the greater the impact of FM in quality of life – consequently, the lower the overall health [20].

PHQ-9 is a tool with 9 items used to identify individuals in risk of depression. Its score ranges from 0 to 27, with possible answers variating between 0 (not at all) and 3 (nearly every day). The higher the score, the higher the severity [21].

In order to fill out the Dietary Record, subjects were instructed to take notes on a form including the sort of food and drink they have had and their quantities, three times, in alternate days including 1 day on weekend [22]. Later, all these information was inputed in Avanutri® software and the average dietary intake was calculated. According to the DRIs (Dietary Reference Intakes), the EAR (Estimated Average Requirement) for Mg is 255 mg/d for women aged between 19 and 30 years, and 265 mg/d for women older than 31 years. For Ca, the EAR is 800 mg/d for women aged between 19 and 50 years and 1000 mg/d for women older than 51 years [23].

Statistical analysis

The analyses were performed by R software version 3.0.2. (R Development Core Team, 2013). The Shapiro-Wilk test was performed to assess data normality. To test statistical differences between the two groups, the parametric Student’s t-test was performed when data conformed to normality and the non-parametric Wilcoxon-Mann-Whitney test was performed for non-normal data. To establish correlation between the results, the Pearson correlation coefficient was used for data that conformed to normality and Spearman’s correlation coefficient was adopted for non-normal data. Significance level was assumed to be 95% (p < 0.05).

Results

Fifty-three women with FM and 50 women without it participated in this study. Average age and BMI were equivalent in both groups (Table 1). Kilocalorie, carbohydrate and protein intake was substantially lower in the group with FM, as well as intake of magnesium and calcium. No significant differences in serum measurement of these minerals were found in the groups (Table 1).

Table 1 General characteristics of the participants with fibromyalgia and controls

In the FM group, dietary intake of magnesium and calcium correlated negatively with TP count. This means that the higher the intake of said minerals the lower the TP count, including a positive correlation with pain threshold – the higher the magnesium and calcium intake the higher the pain threshold, therefore, the lower the clinical pain. In the control group, there were no such correlations (Table 2).

Table 2 Relationship between magnesium and calcium intake with the variables: pain, quality of life and risk of depression

The FM group did not have a correlation between levels of serum magnesium and calcium with pain, quality of life and depression risk. In the control group, levels of serum Mg and Ca correlated positively with the pain threshold. That is to say that the higher the levels of serum Mg and Ca, the less acute the pain (Table 3).

Table 3 Relationship between serum magnesium and calcium levels with the variables: pain, quality of life and risk of depression

Discussion

Deficiency of vitamins and minerals has been associated to countless clinical conditions, including chronic pain and FM [2, 5]. In this study, it has been found that dietary intake of magnesium and calcium remained below recommended levels for both groups, which reflects inadequate dietary consumption of said minerals by the Brazilian population [16]. This may be due to the increased consumption of processed food and fast food [13]. In parallel, there is also low intake of foods that are rich in magnesium such as dark-green vegetables, vegetables in general, fish, nuts and seeds, and wholegrain cereals [16], and low intake of foods that are rich in calcium such as milk and dairy, dark-green vegetables, seafood and fish [24].

In spite of the fact that the general population has low dietary intake of foods that are rich in Mg and Ca, the women with FM who participated in this study had substantially lower dietary intakes than the control group. That has been related to worsening of pain for women with FM. Such assumption was confirmed by the results of this research work, in which dietary intake of Mg and Ca correlated positively with the pain threshold and negatively with TP count. This means that the lower the intake of said minerals, the lower the pain threshold and higher TP count. That being said, it is necessary to make dietary assessments to adjust the intake of these minerals in order to ensure a healthy, balanced diet that helps reduce pain and painful points in women with FM.

In parallel, although the studied groups had lower dietary intake of magnesium and calcium, that did not reduced these minerals levels in blood samples. Moreover, even though some studies have shown reduced intracellular contents and levels of serum Mg and high levels of serum Ca in patients with FM [7, 8, 25, 26], in this study there was no differences in levels of serum Mg and Ca between the FM group and the control group. Nevertheless, such fact needs to be further investigated given that studies have adopted different methodologies for analysis of minerals, and present varying levels of serum, erythrocytes, leucocytes, urinary, muscular and hair.

Various authors have stated that plasma concentration of Mg may not reflect the entire body content of Mg since the body has mechanisms that maintain constant serum levels within a narrow range of normality [7, 16]. Additionally, several studies have shown that in spite of concentrations of Mg in plasma being within normal ranges, the concentration of erythrocyte Mg was below normal [9, 27]. Magaldi et al. [28] presented in their study that patients with FM had normal levels of serum Mg and reduced levels in leucocytes. This confirms the assumption that serum Mg is a poor predictor of the Mg status in the body as a whole, and that intracellular analyses are more representative [11, 16, 29,30,31,32].

Lower levels of serum calcium (Ca) have not been noticed in women with FM participating in this research work. Although some studies have already found low serum Ca levels in patients with FM, others present normal serum levels but with reduced intracellular concentrations of Ca, such as in leucocytes [28] and hair [3]. This demonstrates that, similarly to what occurs with Mg, Ca concentration may be normal in blood but different in the intracellular level [28].

Levels of serum Mg of women with FM participating in this study have not shown correlation with pain parameters, quality of life and depression risk. Similar results have been found by Sakarya et al. [9]. Sendur et al. [4] found solely correlation of serum Mg with fatigue severity.

On the other hand, Bagis et al. [7] presented correlation between levels of serum Mg with VAS (visual analogue scale of pain), TP count, TP index, FIQ, anxiety and depression score, and somatic symptoms in women with FM. Erythrocyte levels of Mg in this study correlated with the same variables, as well as with the pain threshold, fatigue, headache and numbness.

As to levels of serum Mg and Ca, only the control group presented positive correlation of said minerals with the pain threshold. It is important to notice the role of Mg in cognitive-affective functions, and studies have shown an improvement in pain and depression parameters after supplementation of Mg [6]. The Hagenston and Simonetti review study (2014) showed the involvement of neuronal calcium signaling in the processes that mediated chronic pain [33].

Although the minerals analyzed in this study did not correlate with quality of life and depression risk for women with FM, additional research is required to investigate the role of minerals in the symptoms of this disease in order to improve the impact of dietary therapies in the quality of life of patients.

The present study has limitations related to serum mineral dosage, which does not seem to be a good predictor of intracellular reserves. In addition, serum Ca values were not corrected by albumin, and it was not possible to measure complementary tests such as ionic Ca, Vitamin D, and PTH (parathyroid hormone), which would help to better analyze the metabolism of these minerals.

Additionally, the three-day food register is a method with intrinsic limitations to its use: it is subjective, requires a high level of motivation and collaboration, requires time, there may be difficulty in estimating portions, and the individual must know the home measures. In parallel, consumption may be altered as the individual knows that it will be assessed, and therefore there may be underreporting of consumption. There may also be regional variations and errors in the software used for data tabulation.

Finally, it is noteworthy that this was a cross-sectional study, which has a number of limitations inherent to its methodology. Therefore, it is very important to conduct clinical trials randomized, with food intervention to lead to a conclusion related to the specific intake of these evaluated nutrients.

Conclusion

Women with FM had lower dietary intake of magnesium and calcium in comparison with women who did not have the condition. However, serum levels of these nutrients did not turn out to be different between said groups. Lower dietary intake of magnesium and calcium correlated with worsened pain parameters (increased number of TP and decreased pain threshold) in fibromyalgia.