Abstract
The quantum theory of dispersion was an important conceptual advancement which led out of the crisis of the old quantum theory in the early 1920s and aided in the formulation of matrix mechanics in 1925. The theory of Charles Galton Darwin, often cited only for its reliance on the statistical conservation of energy, was a wave-based attempt to explain dispersion phenomena at a time between the theories of Ladenburg and Kramers. It contributed to future successes in quantum theory, such as the virtual oscillator, while revealing through its own shortcomings the limitations of the wave theory of light in the interaction of light and matter. After its publication, Darwin’s theory was widely discussed amongst his colleagues as the competing interpretation to Compton’s in X-ray scattering experiments. It also had a pronounced influence on John C. Slater, whose ideas formed the basis of the BKS theory.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
M. Beller,Quantum Dialogue: The Making of a Revolution, University of Chicago Press, Chicago (1999)
A. Blum, M. Jähnert, C. Lehner, J. Renn,Translation as heuristics: Heisenbergs turn to matrix mechanics, Stud. Hist. Phil. Mod. Phys. 60, 3–22 (2017)
N. Bohr,On the Constitution of Atoms and Molecules, Phil. Mag. 116, 1–25, 476–502, 857–875 (1913)
N. Bohr, Draft of an unsent letter to C.G. Darwin, July, 1919, Bohr Scientific Correspondence through 1922, A-D, American Philosophical Society, Philadelphia, PA, USA (1919)
N. Bohr, Letter to C.G. Darwin, December 21, 1922, Bohr Scientific Correspondence through 1922, A-D, American Philosophical Society, Philadelphia, PA, USA (1922)
N. Bohr, Letter to C.G. Darwin, February 14, 1922, Bohr Scientific Correspondence through 1922, A-D, American Philosophical Society, Philadelphia, PA, USA (1922)
N. Bohr, Letter to C.G. Darwin, September 20, 1922, Bohr Scientific Correspondence through 1922, A-D, American Philosophical Society, Philadelphia, PA, USA (1922)
N. Bohr, Letter to J.C. Slater, December 10, 1925, Niels Bohr Archive, Copenhagen, Denmark, Bohr Scientific Correspondence, Folder 317, Item 6: J.C. Slater (1922)
N. Bohr,Über die Anwendung der Quantentheorie auf den Atombau. I. Die Grundpostulate der Quantentheorie, Z. Physik 13, 117–165 (1923)
N. Bohr, H.A. Kramers, J.C. Slater,The Quantum Theory of Radiation, Phil. Mag. 47, 785–802 (1924)
W. Bothe,Elektronenrückstoß, bei der Zerstreung der Röntgenstrahlen und Lichtquantenhypothese, Die Naturwissenschaften 11, 965–966 (1923)
W. Bothe,Über eine neue Sekundärstrahlung der Röntgenstrahlen. II. Mitteilung, Z. Physik 20, 237–255 (1923)
W. Bothe, H. Geiger,Experimentelles zur Theorie von Bohr, Kramers and Slater, Die Naturwissenschaften 13, 440–441 (1925)
W. Bothe, H. Geiger,Über das Wesen des Comptoneffekts; Ein Experimenteller Beitrag zur Theorie der Strahlung, Z. Physik 32, 639–663 (1925)
W. Bothe,Über die Kopplung zwischen elementaren Strahlungsvorgängen, Z. Physik 37, 547–567 (1926)
J. Büttner, J. Renn, M. Schemmel,Exploring the Limits of Classical Physics: Planck, Einstein, and the Structure of a Scientific Revolution Stud. Hist. Phil. Mod. Phys. 34, 37–59 (2003)
H. Capellmann,The Development of Elementary Quantum Theory from 1900 to 1927, Springer International Publishing, Cham (2017)
H.A. Compton,Secondary Radiations Produced by X-Rays and Some of their Applications to Physical Systems, Bull. Nat. Res. Co. 4, 1–56 (1922)
H.A. Compton,The Scattering of X-Rays, J. Franklin Inst. 198, 57–72 (1924)
H.A. Compton, J.C. Hubbard,The Recoil of Electrons from Scattered X-Rays, Phys. Rev. 23, 439–449 (1924)
H.A. Compton, A.W. Simon,Directed Quanta of Scattered X-Rays, Phys. Rev. 26, 289–299 (1925)
O. Darrigol,From c-Numbers to q-Numbers: The Classical Analogy in the History of Quantum Theory, University of California Press, Berkeley (1992)
C.G. Darwin,A Theory of Absorption and Scattering of the α Rays, Phil. Mag. 23, 901–920 (1912)
C.G. Darwin, The Theory of Radiation, Charles Galton Darwin Papers, American Philosophical Society, Philadelphia, PA, USA (1912)
C.G. Darwin,On Some Orbits of an Electron, Phil. Mag. 25, 201–210 (1913)
C.G. Darwin,The theory of X-ray reflexion, Phil. Mag. 27, 315–333 (1914)
C.G. Darwin,Critique on the Foundations of Physics (also referred to as ‘The Basis of Physics’), a draft of a letter to be sent to Niels Bohr, July 1919, Charles Galton Darwin Papers, American Philosophical Society, Philadelphia, PA, USA (1919)
C.G. Darwin, Letter to Niels Bohr, July 20, 1919, Bohr Scientific Correspondence through 1922, A-D, American Philosophical Society, Philadelphia, PA, USA (1919)
C.G. Darwin, Letter to Niels Bohr, May 30, 1919, Bohr Scientific Correspondence through 1922, A-D, American Philosophical Society, Philadelphia, PA, USA (1919)
C.G. Darwin, The Theory of Radiation: Translation of Henri Poincaré’s ‘Sur la théorie des quanta’, Charles Galton Darwin Papers, American Philosophical Society, Philadelphia, PA, USA (1919)
C.G. Darwin,Letter to Niels Bohr, November 23, 1922 (1922)
C.G. Darwin,A Quantum Theory of Optical Dispersion, Nature 110, 841–842 (1922)
C.G. Darwin, R.H. Fowler,On the Partition of Energy, Phil. Mag. 44, 450–479 (1922)
C.G. Darwin, R.H. Fowler,On the Partition of Energy - Part II. Statistical Principles and Thermodynamics, Phil. Mag. 44, 823–842 (1922)
C.G. Darwin, Letter to Niels Bohr, April, 30 1923, Niels Bohr Archive, Copenhagen, Denmark, Bohr Scientific Correspondence, Folder 60, Item 9: Charles Galton Darwin (1923)
C.G. Darwin,A Quantum Theory of Optical Dispersion, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 9, 25–30 (1923)
C.G. Darwin,The Wave Theory and the Quantum Theory, Nature 111, 771–773 (1923)
C.G. Darwin,The Wave Equation of the Electron, Proc. R. Soc. A118, 654–680 (1928)
C.G. Darwin,The New Conceptions of Matter, Bell and Sons, Ltd., London (1931)
C. Davisson,Dispersion of Hydrogen and Helium on Bohr’s Theory, Phys. Rev. 8, 20–27 (1916)
P. Debye,Zerstreuung von Röntgenstrahlen, Ann. Phys. 351, 809–823 (1915)
M. Dresden,H.A. Kramers: Between Tkradition and Revolution, Springer, New York (1987)
A. Duncan, M. Janssen,On the Verge of, Umdeutung in Minnesota: Van Vleck and the Correspondence Principle. Part One, Arch. Hist. Exact Sci. 61, 553–624 (2007)
A. Duncan, M. Janssen,On the Verge of Umdeutung in Minnesota: Van Vleck and the Correspondence Principle. Part Two, Arch. Hist. Exact Sci. 61, 625–671 (2007)
A. Einstein,Strahlungs-Emission und -Absorption nach der Quantentheorie, Verh. D. Phys. G. 13/14, 318–323 (1916)
F. Exner,Über Gesetze in Naturwissenschaft und Humanistik: Inaugural Address held on 15. Oct. 1908, A. Hölder, Vienna (1909)
F. Exner,Vorlesungen Über die physikalischen Grundlagen der Naturwissenschaften, F. Deuticke, Vienna (1919)
D. Fick, H. Kant,Walther Bothe’s Contributions to the Understanding of the Wave-Particle Duality of Light, Stud. Hist. Phil. Mod. Phys. 40, 395–405 (2009)
P. Forman,Landé and the Anomalous Zeeman Effect, 1919-1921, Hist. Stud. Phys. Sci. 2, 153–261 (1970)
P. Forman,Weimar Culture, Causality, and Quantum Theory, 1918-1927: Adaption by German Physicists and Mathematicians to a Hostile Intellectual Environment, Hist. Stud. Phys. Sci. 3, 1–115 (1971)
R.H. Fowler,Letter to Niels Bohr, January 14, 1925, Niels Bohr Archive, Copenhagen, Denmark, Bohr Scientific Correspondence, Folder 92, Item 4: Ralph Howard Fowler (1925)
W. Hanle,Über den Zeemaneffekt bei der Resonanzfluoreszenz, Die Naturwissenschaften 11, 690–691 (1923)
W. Heisenberg,Zur Quantentheorie der Multiplettstruktur und der anomalen Zeemaneffekte, Z. Phys. 32, 841–860 (1925)
W. Heisenberg,Über eine Anwendung des Korrespondenzprinzips auf die Frage nach der Polarisation des Fluoreszenzlichtes, Z. Phys. 31, 617–626 (1925)
J. Hendry,The Development of Attitudes to the Wave-Particle Duality of Light and Quantum Theory, 1900-1920, Ann. Sci. 37, 59–79 (1980)
J. Hendry,Weimar Culture and Quantum Causality, Hist. Sci. 18, 155–180 (1980)
J. Hendry,Bohr-Kramers-Slater: A Virtual Theory of Virtual Oscillators and Its Role in the History of Quantum Mechanics, Centaurus 25, 189–221 (1981)
J. Hendry,The Creation of Quantum Mechanics and the Bohr-Pauli Dialogue, D. Reidel Publishing Company, Dordrecht (1984)
M. Jammer,The Conceptual Development of Quantum Mechanics, McGraw-Hill, New York (1966)
M.J. Klein,The First Phase of the Bohr-Einstein Diologue, Hist. Stud. Phys. Sci. 2, 1–39 (1970)
H. Kragh,Niels Bohr and the quantum atom : the Bohr model of atomic structure 1913 - 1925, Oxford University Press, Oxford (2012)
H.A. Kramers,Intensities of spectral lines: On the application of the quantum theory to the problem of the relative intensities of the components o the fine structure and of the Stark effect of these lines of the hydrogen spectrum, Det Kongelige Danske Videnskabernes Selskab. Skrifter. Naturvidenskabelig og Matematisk Afdeling 8, 285–386 (1919)
H.A. Kramers,The Law of Dispersion and Bohr’s Theory of Spectra, Nature 113, 673–674 (1924)
H.A. Kramers,The Quantum Theory of Dispersion, Nature 114, 310–311 (1924)
R. Ladenburg,Die quantentheoretische Deutung der Zahl der Dispersionselektronen, Z. Phys. 4, 451–488 (1921)
R. Ladenburg, F. Reiche,Absorption, Zerstreuung und Dispersion in der Bohrschen Atomtheorie, Die Naturwissenschaften 27, 584–598 (1923)
E. MacKinnon,Models, and the Rise of Matrix Mechanics, Hist. Stud. Phys. Sci. 8, 137–188 (1977)
J. Mehra, H. Rechenberg,The Historical Development of Quantum Theory Vol. 1, Part 1: The Quantum Theory of Planck, Einstein, Bohr and Sommerfeld: Its Foundations and the Rise of Its Difficulties, 1900-1925, Springer-Verlag, New York (1982)
J. Mehra, H. Rechenberg,The Historical Development of Quantum Theory Vol. 1, Part 2: The Quantum Theory of Planck, Einstein, Bohr and Sommerfeld: Its Foundations and the Rise of Its Difficulties, 1900-1925, Springer-Verlag, New York (1982)
J. Mehra, H. Rechenberg,The Historical Development of Quantum Theory Vol. 2: The Discovery of Quantum Mechanics, 1925, Springer-Verlag, New York (1982)
R.A. Millikan,A Direct Photoelectric Determination of Planck’s “h”, Phys. Rev. 7, 355–388 (1916)
H.G.J. Moseley, C.G. Darwin,The Reflexion of the X-rays, Phil. Mag. 26, 210–232 (1913)
J. Navarro,“A dedicated missionary”. Charles Galton Darwin and the new quantum mechanics in Britain, Stud. Hist. Phil. Mod. Phys. 40, 316–326 (2009)
H. Poincaré,La Science et l’Hypothèse, Ernest Flammarion, Paris (1902)
H. Poincaré,Science and Hypothesis, The Walter Scott Publishing Co., Ltd., New York (1905)
H. Poincaré,Sur la théorie des quanta, J Phys. Théor. App. 2, 5–34 (1912)
E. Schrödinger,Inaugural Address before the Prussian Academy of Sciences, Die Naturwissenschaften 17, 732–733 (1929)
D. Serwer,Unmechanischer Zwang: Pauli, Heisenberg, and the Rejection of the Mechanical Atom, 1923-1925, Hist. Stud. Phys. Sci. 8, 189–256 (1977)
J.C. Slater,Radiation and Atoms, Nature 113, 307–308 (1924)
J.C. Slater,The Nature of Radiation, Nature 116, 278 (1925)
J.C. Slater,A Quantum Theory of Optical Phenomena, Phys. Rev. 25, 395–428 (1925)
J.C. Slater, Interview of John Clarke Slater by Thomas S. Kuhn and John H. Van Vleck on 1963 October 3, Niels Bohr Library & Archives, American Institute of Physics, College Park, MD USA (1963)
J.C. Slater,Solid-State and Molecular Theory: A Scientific Biography, Wiley, New York (1975)
A. Smekal,Versuch einer allgemeinen, einheitlichen Anwendung der Quantentheorie und einer Quantentheorie der Dispersion, Die Naturwissenschaften 11, 411–412 (1923)
A. Smekal,Zur Quantentheorie der Dispersion, Die Naturwissenschaften 11, 873–875 (1923)
A. Sommerfeld,Die Drudesche Dispersionstheorie vom Standpunkte des Borschen Modelles und die Konstitution von H2 , O2und N2, Ann. Phys. 4, 497–550 (1917)
J. Stark,Zur experimentellen Entscheidung zwischen Aetherwellen- und Lichtquantenhypothese. I. Röntgenstrahlen, Phys. Z. 10, 902–913 (1909)
J. Stark,Über Röntgenstrahlen und die atomistische Konstitution der Strahlung, Phys. Z. 10, 579–586 (1909)
K. Stolzenburg,Niels Bohr, Collected WorksVol. 5, North-Holland, Amsterdam (1984)
R.H. Stuewer,The Compton Effect: Turning Point in Physics, Science History Publications, New York (1975)
R.H. Stuewer,The Experimental Challenge of Light Quanta, in M. Janssen, C. Lehner, eds.,The Cambridge Companion to Einstein, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge (2014)
M. Stöltzner,Vienna Indeterminism: Mach, Boltzmann, Exner, Synthese 119, 85–111 (1999)
J.M. Sánchez-Ron, Charles Galton Darwin and the Nonconservation of Energy, Beni culturali scientifici nella storia e didattica. Università degli studi di Pavia 185–198 (1993)
M.J. Taltavull, Transformation of Optical Knowledge from 1870 to 1925: Optical Dispersion between Classical and Quantum Physics, Ph.D. thesis Humboldt Universität zu Berlin (2017)
G.P. Thomson,Charles Galton Darwin, 1887-1962, Bio. Memoirs Fellows R. Soc. 9, 69–85 (1963)
J.H.V. Vleck,The Absorption of Radiation by Multiply Periodic Orbits, and its Relation to the Correspondence Principle and the Rayleigh-Jeans Law. Part I. Some Extensions of the Correspondence Principle, Phys. Rev. 24, 330–346 (1924)
J.H.V. Vleck,The Absorption of Radiation by Multiply Periodic Orbits, and its Relation to the Correspondence Principle and the Rayleigh-Jeans Law. Part II. Calculation of absorption by Multiply Periodic Orbits, Phys. Rev. 24, 347–365 (1924)
D.L. Webster,Quantum Emission Phenomena in Radiation, Phys. Rev. 16, 31–40 (1920)
D.L. Webster, Interview of David Webster by W. James King on 1964 May 21, Niels Bohr Library & Archives, American Institute of Physics, College Park, MD USA (1964)
C.T.R. Wilson, Investigations on X-Rays and β-Rays by the Cloud Method. Part 1 - X-Rays, Proc. R. Soc. A104, 1–24 (1923)
R. Wood,Selective Reflexion of λ 2536 by Mercury Vapour, Phil. Mag. 44, 1105–1106 (1922)
R. Wood, A. Ellett,On the Influence of Magnetic Fields on the Polarisation of Resonance Radiation, Proc. R. Soc. 103, 396–403 (1923)
Acknowledgments
Open access funding provided by Projekt DEAL.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Publisher’s Note
The EPJ Publishers remain neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Rights and permissions
Open Access This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
About this article
Cite this article
Johnson, B. Charles Galton Darwin’s 1922 quantum theory of optical dispersion. EPJ H 45, 1–23 (2020). https://doi.org/10.1140/epjh/e2020-80058-7
Received:
Revised:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1140/epjh/e2020-80058-7