Skip to main content
Log in

The Final Stage of Negotiations: Beginning of the Russo–Japanese War 1904–1905

  • Published:
Herald of the Russian Academy of Sciences Aims and scope Submit manuscript

Abstract

The progress of Russian–Japanese negotiations in 1903–1904 is covered; the positions of the parties are analyzed; , the reasons for the intransigence of the Japanese side in the negotiations on the conclusion of a new agreement are examined; and the reaction in the ruling spheres of Russia to the amendments of the Japanese government to the Russian text of the agreement and the nature of Russian–Korean relations on the eve of the Russo–Japanese War are studied. The author focuses on Japan’s responsibility for starting the war, showing Japan’s aggressive policy in Korea. The essence of the Japanese proposals, tantamount to a demand from the Russian government for the formal recognition of Japan’s protectorate over Korea, is analyzed; attempts by Japanese representatives in Seoul to intimidate the Korean Emperor Gojong and impose an agreement on the appointment of a Japanese resident in Seoul to manage domestic and foreign policy to ensure the “moral right” to establish its undivided dominance on the Korean Peninsula and the request of the Korean emperor for the protection and patronage of Russia are shown, the position of the Russian side during the negotiations, based on the preference to continue negotiations with Japan to avoid an armed clash, its perception and evaluation are studied. The article is based on newly discovered archival materials and published sources. Their study indicates that Russian diplomacy showed great pliability, seeking to delay the aggravation of a military conflict. By the final period of the negotiations, the Russian side had agreed to meet Japan halfway on almost all points concerning the Korean issue, seeking only to preserve the mutual obligation to respect the independence, territorial integrity, and inviolability of the Korean Empire.

This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.

Access this article

Price excludes VAT (USA)
Tax calculation will be finalised during checkout.

Instant access to the full article PDF.

Notes

  1. Copy of a secret telegram from the envoy to Tokyo dated October 19, 1903. to No. 34, Sobytiya na Dal’nem Vostoke, predshestvovavshie russko-yaponskoi voine. Chast’ III. Poslednii god pered voinoi, Sost. Gen Shtaba Gen-Maior Simanskii [Events in the Far East, Preceding the Russo–Japanese War, Part III: The Last Year before the War, Compiled by Gen-Major Simanskii, General Staff], Izd. Voenno-Istoricheskoi Komissii po opisaniyu russko-yaponskoi voiny, St. Petersburg, 1910, р. 180.

  2. Dispatch from Baron Rosen dated October 24, 1903. Sobytiya na Dal’nem Vostoke, predshestvovavshie russko-yaponskoi voine. Chast’ III. Poslednii god pered voinoi, Sost. Gen Shtaba Gen-Maior Simanskii [Events in the Far East, Preceding the Russo-Japanese War, Part III: The Last Year before the War], Compiled by Gen-Major Simanskii, General Staff, St. Petersburg: Izd. Voenno-Istoricheskoi Komissii po opisaniyu russko-yaponskoi voiny, 1910, рp. 181, 182.

  3. Dispatch from Adjutant General Alekseev to Count Lamsdorf dated November 2 (15), 1903, Sobytiya na Dal’nem Vostoke, predshestvovavshie russko-yaponskoi voine. Chast’ III: Poslednii god pered voinoi, Sost. Gen Shtaba Gen-Maior Simanskii [Events in the Far East, Preceding the Russo–Japanese War, Part III: The Last Year before the War, Compiled by Gen-Major Simanskii, General Staff, St. Petersburg: Izd. Voenno-Istoricheskoi Komissii po opisaniyu russko-yaponskoi voiny, 1910, p. 182.

  4. Telegram from Baron Komura to Mr. Kurino, Tokyo, December 12, 1903, Man’chzhuriya I Koreya. Angliiskaya sinyaya i Yaponskaya belaya kniga. 1901–1904 [Manchuria and Korea: English Blue Book and Japanese White Book: 1901–1904], St. Petersburg: Izd. kantselyarii Osobogo komiteta Dal’nego Vostoka, 1904, p. 209; Documents on negotiations with Japan in 1903–1904 stored in the Chancellery of the Special Committee for the Far East (Documents of Sp. Com. for the Far East), St. Petersburg, 1906, pp. 23, 24.

  5. From Baron Komura to Mr. Kurino, Telegram, Tokyo, December 21, 1903, Man’chzhuriya i Koreya. Angliiskaya sinyaya i Yaponskaya belaya kniga. 1901–1904 [Manchuria and Korea: English Blue Book and Japanese White Book: 1901–1904], St. Petersburg: Izd. kantselyarii Osobogo komiteta Dal’nego Vostoka, 1904, p. 211.

  6. From Adjutant General Alekseev to His Imperial Majesty, Telegram, Port Arthur, December 13, 1903, Documents on negotiations with Japan in 1903–1904 stored in the Chancellery of the Special Committee for the Far East (Documents of Sp. Com. for the Far East), St. Petersburg, 1906, pp. 252.

  7. Documents on negotiations with Japan in 1903–1904 stored in the Chancellery of the Special Committee for the Far East (Documents of Sp. Com. for the Far East), St. Petersburg, 1906, pp. 27, 28.

  8. Man’chzhuriya i Koreya. Angliiskaya sinyaya i Yaponskaya belaya kniga. 1901–1904 [Manchuria and Korea: English Blue Book and Japanese White Book: 1901–1904], St. Petersburg: Izdanie kantselyarii Osobogo komiteta Dal’nego Vostoka, 1904, pp. 214–215.

  9. Letter from the Director of the Naval Ministry for the Main Naval Staff F.K. Avelan to the Minister of Foreign Affairs V.N. Lamsdorf dated January 10, 1904, No.15, Department of Manuscripts of the State Historical Museum (OPI GIM), Fund 444, Inventory 1, File 101, fol. 224.

  10. Lamsdorf’s secret letter to the Director of the Naval Ministry, Jan. 12, 1904, No. 55, OPI GIM, Fund 444, Inventory 1, File 101, fol. 226.

  11. Documents on negotiations with Japan in 1903–1904 stored in the Chancellery of the Special Committee for the Far East (Documents of Sp. Com. for the Far East), St. Petersburg, 1906, pp. 36, 37.

  12. Man’chzhuriya i Koreya. Angliiskaya sinyaya i Yaponskaya belaya kniga. 1901–1904 [Manchuria and Korea: English Blue Book and Japanese White Book: 1901–1904], St. Petersburg: Izd. kantselyarii Osobogo komiteta Dal’nego Vostoka, 1904, pp. 216, 217.

  13. Documents on negotiations with Japan in 1903–1904 stored in the Chancellery of the Special Committee for the Far East (Documents of Sp. Com. for the Far East), St. Petersburg, 1906, p. 37.

  14. Journal of the special meeting held by Imperial order on January 15, 1904, Sobytiya na Dal’nem Vostoke, predshestvovavshie russko-yaponskoi voine. Chast’ III. Poslednii god pered voinoi, Sost. Gen Shtaba Gen-Maior Simanskii [Events in the Far East, Preceding the Russo-Japanese War, Part III: The Last Year before the War, Compiled by Gen-Major Simanskii, General Staff], St. Petersburg: Izd. Voenno-Istoricheskoi Komissii po opisaniyu russko-yaponskoi voiny, 1910, p. 201; OPI GIM, Fund 444, Inventory 1, File 105, fols. 166–172.

  15. Journal of the special meeting held by Imperial order on January 15, 1904, Sobytiya na Dal’nem Vostoke, predshestvovavshie russko-yaponskoi voine. Chast’ III. Poslednii god pered voinoi, Sost. Gen Shtaba Gen-Maior Simanskii [Events in the Far East, Preceding the Russo-Japanese War, Part III: The Last Year before the War, Compiled by Gen-Major Simanskii, General Staff], St. Petersburg: Izd. Voenno-Istoricheskoi Komissii po opisaniyu russko-yaponskoi voiny, 1910, p. 201; OPI GIM, Fund 444, Inventory 1, File 105, fol. 166 verso; Archive of Foreign Policy of the Russian Empire (AVPRI), Fund “Chinese Table,” Inventory 491, File 52, fol. 85.

  16. Journal of the special meeting held by Imperial order on January 15, 1904, Sobytiya na Dal’nem Vostoke, predshestvovavshie russko-yaponskoi voine. Chast’ III. Poslednii god pered voinoi, Sost. Gen Shtaba Gen-Maior Simanskii [Events in the Far East, Preceding the Russo–Japanese War, Part III: The Last Year before the War, Compiled by Gen-Major Simanskii, General Staff], St. Petersburg: Izd. Voenno-Istoricheskoi Komissii po opisaniyu russko-yaponskoi voiny, 1910, p. 201; OPI GIM, Fund 444, Inventory 1, File 105, fol. 166 verso. Archive of Foreign Policy of the Russian Empire (AVPRI), Stock “Chinese Table,” Inventory 491, File 52, fol. 85.

  17. Journal of the special meeting held by Imperial order on January 15, 1904, Sobytiya na Dal’nem Vostoke, predshestvovavshie russko-yaponskoi voine, Chast’ III. Poslednii god pered voinoi, Sost. Gen Shtaba Gen-Maior Simanskii [Events in the Far East, Preceding the Russo–Japanese War, Part III: The Last Year before the War, Compiled by Gen-Major Simanskii, General Staff], St. Petersburg: Izd. Voenno-Istoricheskoi Komissii po opisaniyu russko-yaponskoi voiny, 1910, p. 201.

  18. Special most humble note of Lamsdorf to Nicholas II dated January 31 (18), 1904, Sobytiya na Dal’nem Vostoke, predshestvovavshie russko-yaponskoi voine. Chast’ III. Poslednii god pered voinoi, Sost. Gen Shtaba Gen-Maior Simanskii [Events in the Far East, Preceding the Russo–Japanese War, Part III: The Last Year before the War, Compiled by Gen-Major Simanskii, General Staff], St. Petersburg: Izd. Voenno-Istoricheskoi Komissii po opisaniyu russko-yaponskoi voiny, 1910, p. 201.

  19. From the Minister of Foreign Affairs Count Lamsdorf to Adjutant General Alekseev, Telegram, St. Petersburg, January 20, 1904, Telegram No. 1, Documents on negotiations with Japan in 1903–1904 stored in the Chancellery of the Special Committee for the Far East (Documents of Sp. Com. for the Far East), St. Petersburg, 1906, pp. 44–46.

  20. From the Minister of Foreign Affairs Count Lamsdorf to Adjutant General Alekseev, Telegram, St. Petersburg, January 21, 1904, Telegram No. 2, Documents on negotiations with Japan in 1903–1904 stored in the Chancellery of the Special Committee for the Far East (Documents of Sp. Com. for the Far East), St. Petersburg, 1906, pp. 46, 47.

  21. See Pak, B.D. Rossiya i Koreya [Russia and Korea], pp. 197, 198; Narochnitskii, A.L., Guber, A.A., Sladkovskii, M. A., and Burlingas, I.Ya. Mezhdunarodnye otnosheniya na Dal’nem Vostoke, Kn. 1: S kontsa XVI veka do 1917 g. [International Relations in the Far East, Book. 1: From the End of the 16th century to 1917], Moscow, 1973, pp. 224–228.

  22. See, for example: Grazhdantsev, A. Koreya [Korea], Translated from English, Moscow, 1948, p. 140; Treat, P.J. The Far East, New York; London, 1928, p. 399; A Short History of Korea, Tokyo, 1963, p. 81.

  23. See: Gippius, A.I. O prichinakh nashei voiny s Yaponiei [On the Causes of Our War with Japan], St. Petersburg, 1905, p. 229.

  24. From Baron Komura to Mr. Kurino, Telegram, Tokyo, February 5, 1904, 2:15 p.m. Man’chzhuriya i Koreya. Angliiskaya sinyaya i Yaponskaya belaya kniga, 1901–1904 [Manchuria and Korea: English Blue Book and Japanese White Book: 1901–1904], St. Petersburg: Izd. kantselyarii Osobogo komiteta Dal’nego Vostoka, 1904, pp. 225, 226;

  25. From Baron Komura to Mr. Kurino, Telegram, Tokyo, February 5, 1904, 2:15 p.m. Man’chzhuriya i Koreya. Angliiskaya sinyaya i Yaponskaya belaya kniga. 1901–1904 [Manchuria and Korea: English Blue Book and Japanese White Book: 1901–1904], St. Petersburg: Izd. kantselyarii Osobogo komiteta Dal’nego Vostoka, 1904, pp. 227, 228;

  26. Count Lamsdorf’s circular dispatch to Russian representatives in Constantinople, Paris, London, Rome, Vienna, Washington, and Berlin dated January 24, 1904, Sobytiya na Dal’nem Vostoke, predshestvovavshie russko-yaponskoi voine. Chast’ III. Poslednii god pered voinoi, Sost. Gen Shtaba Gen-Maior Simanskii [Events in the Far East, Preceding the Russo–Japanese War, Part III: The Last Year before the War, Compiled by Gen-Major Simanskii, General Staff], St. Petersburg: Izd. Voenno-Istoricheskoi Komissii po opisaniyu russko-yaponskoi voiny, 1910, p. 229.

  27. Documents on negotiations with Japan in 1903–1904 stored in the Chancellery of the Special Committee for the Far East (Documents of Sp. Com. for the Far East), St. Petersburg, 1906, p. 50.

Author information

Authors and Affiliations

Authors

Corresponding author

Correspondence to B. B. Pak.

Ethics declarations

The author declares that she has no conflicts of interest.

Additional information

Translated by D. Venyavkin

The original version of the article in Russian was written for Peterburgskii istoricheskii zhurnal, where it will be published in 2023.

Bella Borisovna Pak, Dr. Sci. (Hist.), is a Leading Researcher and Head of the Cabinet (Laboratory) of Korean History and Culture of the RAS Institute of Oriental Studies.

Rights and permissions

Reprints and permissions

About this article

Check for updates. Verify currency and authenticity via CrossMark

Cite this article

Pak, B.B. The Final Stage of Negotiations: Beginning of the Russo–Japanese War 1904–1905. Her. Russ. Acad. Sci. 92 (Suppl 12), S1175–S1184 (2022). https://doi.org/10.1134/S1019331622180101

Download citation

  • Received:

  • Revised:

  • Accepted:

  • Published:

  • Issue Date:

  • DOI: https://doi.org/10.1134/S1019331622180101

Keywords:

Navigation