Skip to main content
Log in

Differentiation of Wages of Industrial Workers at the End of NEP: Between Equalization and Labor Incentives

  • Published:
Herald of the Russian Academy of Sciences Aims and scope Submit manuscript

Abstract

During the NEP years, the task of regulating wages of industrial workers was one of the priorities of Soviet social policy. Wages at state-owned enterprises during the NEP period were regulated by the state, which was supposed, on the one hand, to implement the new principles of social policy (a policy towards equalizing wages), and on the other hand, to ensure production efficiency. The main tools for regulating wages were the tariff scale and terms of collective agreements. The policy pursued by the state regarding wages of industrial workers during the NEP years and the practice of its implementation are considered in this article, as is the reaction of workers to the ongoing processes of regulating the differentiation of wages among both skilled and unskilled workers. It is shown that no consistent equalizing (leveling) of workers’ wages was achieved. The workers’ attitude to the policy pursued in this area is analyzed on the basis of declassified materials from a multivolume publication of documents—information reviews and summaries of the Joint State Political Directorate (OGPU). Various forms of protest and discontent of workers regarding the regulation of wages are identified, which manifested themselves in different groups of workers, in different regions of the country, at enterprises of different industries, and for different reasons. The most characteristic ones were conflict situations generated by the policy of equalizing wages, which meant a decrease in labor motivation for skilled workers and caused their dissatisfaction.

This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.

Access this article

Price excludes VAT (USA)
Tax calculation will be finalised during checkout.

Instant access to the full article PDF.

Notes

  1. See, for example, the detailed monograph Il’yukhov, A.A., How the Bolsheviks Paid: The Policy of the Soviet Government in the Field of Wages in 1917–1941, Moscow, 2010.

  2. Rashin, A.G., Wages for the Recovery Period of the USSR Economy 1922/23–1926/27, Moscow, 1927, p. 13.

  3. CPSU in Resolutions, vol. 2, p. 422.

  4. Unions of the USSR: Documents and Materials: Trade Unions in the Period of Building Socialism in the USSR: 1917–1937, Moscow, 1963, vol. 2, p. 410.

  5. Braginskii, M.O., Bespalov, D.S., and Borodin, V.A., Essays on Wages of Textile Workers, Moscow, 1930, p. 79. Note that the lead author of this informative book, M.O. Braginskii, in the 1920s served as Assistant Director of the Directorate of the Textile Industry of the Central Directorate of State Industry (Tsugprom).

  6. Rashin, A.G., Wages for the Recovery Period of the USSR Economy 1922/23–1926/27, Moscow, 1927, p. 81.

  7. Rashin, A.G., Wages for the Recovery Period of the USSR Economy 1922/23–1926/27, Moscow, 1927, p. 38.

  8. Rashin, A.G., Wages for the Recovery Period of the USSR Economy 1922/23–1926/27, Moscow, 1927, p. 52.

  9. Rashin, A.G., Wages for the Recovery Period of the USSR Economy 1922/23–1926/27, Moscow, 1927, p. 52

  10. Rashin, A.G., Wages for the Recovery Period of the USSR Economy 1922/23–1926/27, Moscow, 1927, p. 81.

  11. Braginskii, M.O., Bespalov, D.S., and Borodin, V.A., Essays on Wages of Textile Workers, Moscow, 1930, p. 38.

  12. Braginskii, M.O., Bespalov, D.S., and Borodin, V.A., Essays on Wages of Textile Workers, Moscow, 1930, p. 38.

  13. Braginskii, M.O., Bespalov, D.S., and Borodin, V.A., Essays on Wages of Textile Workers, Moscow, 1930, pp. 81, 85.

  14. Braginskii, M.O., Bespalov, D.S., and Borodin, V.A., Essays on Wages of Textile Workers, Moscow, 1930, p. 97.

  15. Rashin, A.G., Wages for the Recovery Period of the USSR Economy 1922/23–1926/27, Moscow, 1927, p. 82.

  16. Rashin, A.G., Wages for the Recovery Period of the USSR Economy 1922/23–1926/27, Moscow, 1927, p. 64.

  17. Rashin, A.G., Wages for the Recovery Period of the USSR Economy 1922/23–1926/27, Moscow, 1927, pp. 72, 74.

  18. Borodkin, L.I., Dynamics of the standard of living of the urban population during the NEP years: New estimates, in The Regional Dimension of the Russian Economic Reforms: Proceedings of the All-Russia Scientific Conference Dedicated to the Centenary of the Beginning of the NEP, Novosibirsk, 2021, p. 344.

  19. “Top Secret”: Lubyanka to Stalin on the Situation in the Country (1922–1934): A Collection of Documents, in 10 vols., Moscow, 2001–2017.

  20. An electronic version of these volumes is provided, for example, at https://istmat.info/node/22548.

  21. “Top Secret”: Lubyanka to Stalin on the Situation in the Country (1922–1934): A Collection of Documents, Moscow, 2001–2017, vol. 3: 1925, part 1. https://istmat.info/node/22548.

  22. “Top Secret”: Lubyanka to Stalin on the Situation in the Country (1922–1934): A Collection of Documents, Moscow, 2001–2017, vol. 3: 1925, part 1. https://istmat.info/node/22548.

  23. “Top Secret”: Lubyanka to Stalin on the Situation in the Country (1922–1934): A Collection of Documents, Moscow, 2001–2017, vol. 3: 1925, part 2. https://istmat.info/node/22548.

  24. “Top Secret”: Lubyanka to Stalin on the Situation in the Country (1922–1934): A Collection of Documents, Moscow, 2001–2017, vol. 3: 1925, part 2. https://istmat.info/node/22548.

  25. “Top Secret”: Lubyanka to Stalin on the Situation in the Country (1922–1934): A Collection of Documents, Moscow, 2001–2017, vol. 3: 1925, part 2. https://istmat.info/node/22548.

  26. “Top Secret”: Lubyanka to Stalin on the Situation in the Country (1922–1934): A Collection of Documents, Moscow, 2001–2017, vol. 3: 1925, part 2. https://istmat.info/node/22548.

  27. “Top Secret”: Lubyanka to Stalin on the Situation in the Country (1922–1934): A Collection of Documents, Moscow, 2001–2017, vol. 3: 1925, part 2. https://istmat.info/node/22548.

  28. “Top Secret”: Lubyanka to Stalin on the Situation in the Country (1922–1934): A Collection of Documents, Moscow, 2001–2017, vol. 3: 1925, part 2. https://istmat.info/node/22548.

  29. “Top Secret”: Lubyanka to Stalin on the Situation in the Country (1922–1934): A Collection of Documents, Moscow, 2001–2017, vol. 4: 1926, part 1. https://istmat.info/node/22548.

  30. “Top Secret”: Lubyanka to Stalin on the Situation in the Country (1922–1934): A Collection of Documents, Moscow, 2001–2017, vol. 4: 1926, part 2. https://istmat.info/node/22548.

  31. “Top Secret”: Lubyanka to Stalin on the Situation in the Country (1922–1934): A Collection of Documents, Moscow, 2001–2017, vol. 5: 1927. https://istmat.info/node/22548.

  32. “Top Secret”: Lubyanka to Stalin on the Situation in the Country (1922–1934): A Collection of Documents, Moscow, 2001–2017, vol. 6: 1928. https://istmat.info/node/22548.

  33. “Top Secret”: Lubyanka to Stalin on the Situation in the Country (1922–1934): A Collection of Documents, Moscow, 2001–2017, vol. 6: 1928. https://istmat.info/node/22548.

  34. “Top Secret”: Lubyanka to Stalin on the Situation in the Country (1922–1934): A Collection of Documents, Moscow, 2001–2017, vol. 6: 1928. https://istmat.info/node/22548.

  35. “Top Secret”: Lubyanka to Stalin on the Situation in the Country (1922–1934): A Collection of Documents, Moscow, 2001–2017, vol. 6: 1928. https://istmat.info/node/22548.

  36. “Top Secret”: Lubyanka to Stalin on the Situation in the Country (1922–1934): A Collection of Documents, Moscow, 2001–2017, vol. 3: 1925, part 1. https://istmat.info/node/22548.

  37. “Top Secret”: Lubyanka to Stalin on the Situation in the Country (1922–1934): A Collection of Documents, Moscow, 2001–2017, vol. 3: 1925, part 1. https://istmat.info/node/22548.

  38. “Top Secret”: Lubyanka to Stalin on the Situation in the Country (1922–1934): A Collection of Documents, Moscow, 2001–2017, vol. 3: 1925, part 1. https://istmat.info/node/22548.

  39. “Top Secret”: Lubyanka to Stalin on the Situation in the Country (1922–1934): A Collection of Documents, Moscow, 2001–2017, vol. 3: 1925, part 1. https://istmat.info/node/22548.

  40. “Top Secret”: Lubyanka to Stalin on the Situation in the Country (1922–1934): A Collection of Documents, Moscow, 2001–2017, vol. 3: 1925, part 1. https://istmat.info/node/22548.

  41. “Top Secret”: Lubyanka to Stalin on the Situation in the Country (1922–1934): A Collection of Documents, Moscow, 2001–2017, vol. 4: 1926, part 1. https://istmat.info/node/22548.

  42. “Top Secret”: Lubyanka to Stalin on the Situation in the Country (1922–1934): A Collection of Documents, Moscow, 2001–2017, vol. 4: 1926, part 1. https://istmat.info/node/22548.

  43. “Top Secret”: Lubyanka to Stalin on the Situation in the Country (1922–1934): A Collection of Documents, Moscow, 2001–2017, vol. 4: 1926, part 2. https://istmat.info/node/22548.

  44. “Top Secret”: Lubyanka to Stalin on the Situation in the Country (1922–1934): A Collection of Documents, Moscow, 2001–2017, vol. 5: 1927. https://istmat.info/node/22548.

  45. “Top Secret”: Lubyanka to Stalin on the Situation in the Country (1922–1934): A Collection of Documents, Moscow, 2001–2017, vol. 5: 1927. https://istmat.info/node/22548.

  46. “Top Secret”: Lubyanka to Stalin on the Situation in the Country (1922–1934): A Collection of Documents, Moscow, 2001–2017, vol. 5: 1927. https://istmat.info/node/22548.

  47. “Top Secret”: Lubyanka to Stalin on the Situation in the Country (1922–1934): A Collection of Documents, Moscow, 2001–2017, vol. 4: 1926, part 1. https://istmat.info/node/22548.

  48. “Top Secret”: Lubyanka to Stalin on the Situation in the Country (1922–1934): A Collection of Documents, Moscow, 2001–2017, vol. 4: 1926, part 2. https://istmat.info/node/22548.

  49. “Top Secret”: Lubyanka to Stalin on the Situation in the Country (1922–1934): A Collection of Documents, Moscow, 2001–2017, vol. 5: 1927. https://istmat.info/node/22548.

REFERENCES

  1. Borodkin, L.I., Dynamics of urban population living standards in the years of the NEP: New estimates, in The Regional Dimension of the Russian Economic Reforms: Proceedings of the All-Russian Conference Dedicated to the Centenary of the Beginning of the NEP, Novosibirsk: Parallel’, 2021, pp. 337–347.

  2. Braginskii, M.O., Bespalov, D.S., and Borodin, V.A., Essays on the Wages of Textile Workers, Moscow: TsK Vsesoyuznogo profsoyuza tekstil’shchikov, 1930.

  3. Il’yukhov, A.A., How the Bolsheviks Paid: The Policy of the Soviet Government in the Field of Wages in 1917–1941, Moscow: ROSSPEN, 2010.

    Google Scholar 

  4. Rashin, A.G., Wages for the Recovery Period of the USSR Economy of 1922/23–1926/27, Moscow: Knigoizd. VTsSPS, 1927.

Download references

Funding

This study was supported by a grant of the Russian Science Foundation, project no. 21-18-00509, The Evolution of Inequality of the Income and Property of the Population of Russia: From the Great Reforms to the “Great Break” in the Regional Dimension (Statistical and Geoinformation Analysis) (supervised by L.I. Borodkin).

Author information

Authors and Affiliations

Authors

Corresponding author

Correspondence to L. I. Borodkin.

Ethics declarations

The author declares that he has no conflicts of interest.

Additional information

Translated by B. Alekseev

RAS Corresponding Member Leonid Iosifovich Borodkin is a Professor and Head of the Department of Historical Informatics at Moscow State University.

Rights and permissions

Reprints and permissions

About this article

Check for updates. Verify currency and authenticity via CrossMark

Cite this article

Borodkin, L.I. Differentiation of Wages of Industrial Workers at the End of NEP: Between Equalization and Labor Incentives. Her. Russ. Acad. Sci. 92 (Suppl 10), S955–S963 (2022). https://doi.org/10.1134/S1019331622160043

Download citation

  • Received:

  • Revised:

  • Accepted:

  • Published:

  • Issue Date:

  • DOI: https://doi.org/10.1134/S1019331622160043

Keywords:

Navigation