Abstract
Lamb waves exhibit conical dispersion at zero wave number when an accidental degeneracy occurs between thickness mode longitudinal and shear resonances of the same symmetry. Here we investigate the propagation of Lamb waves generated at the conical point frequency and the interaction of these waves with defects and interfaces. The group velocity and mode shapes of Lamb waves at the conical point are found, and it is shown that as the wavenumber gets close to zero, considerable group velocity is seen only for material properties supporting a degeneracy or near-degeneracy. The unusual wave propagation and mode conversion of Lamb waves generated at the conical point are elucidated through numerical simulations. Experimental measurements of near conical point Lamb wave interaction with holes in a plate demonstrate that these waves flow around defects while maintaining a constant phase of oscillation across that plate surface.
Similar content being viewed by others
Introduction
Lamb waves are guided waves that propagate through plates and are the result of reflection, refraction, and mode conversion of bulk waves from the plate surfaces. The theory of Lamb wave propagation is well established and Lamb waves have been used for a multitude of applications including nondestructive evaluation (NDE) of plates, structural health monitoring, and sensing systems1,2,3. Lamb waves follow a complex dispersion relation described by the Rayleigh-Lamb equation, and the specific shape of the dispersion curves in a homogeneous, isotropic plate is dictated by the Poisson’s ratio4. For a given application, it is often advantageous to access specific Lamb wave modes with favorable propagation characteristics. For long-range inspection applications, for instance, Lamb waves with small group velocity dispersion are used in order to minimize wave packet spreading with propagation distance. For local measurements, one can excite Lamb waves at particular points on the dispersion curve where the group velocity goes to zero while the phase velocity remains finite. At such zero group velocity (ZGV) points, a strong and localized resonance can be excited and used, for example, to determine elastic properties, monitor adhesion, or track fatigue damage5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12,13,14,15,16.
ZGV points are common to both acoustic and optical waveguides and are the result of a repulsion between two modes near a wave vector (k) of zero that leads to backward wave propagation, or a wave propagation with counter-directed phase and group velocities, in one of the modes17,18. The ZGV point is located at the transition between backward and forward wave propagation. The repulsion between modes is the strongest when an accidental degeneracy occurs19. In the case of Lamb waves, this means that there is a coincidence between the frequencies of longitudinal and shear resonances of the same symmetry20. A salient feature associated with accidental degeneracy is that the dispersion curve passes linearly through k = 0, allowing for a peculiar type of wave which propagates with an infinite wavelength but retains a finite group velocity. This wave propagates away from a source without a phase advance, producing a temporal oscillation of the plate that is uniform across the surface. Such behavior, evident in homogeneous elastic and optical waveguides, has also seen widespread attention in acoustic and optical “zero index” or “near zero index” metamaterials where linear dispersion, or conical dispersion in a three-dimensional sense, is achieved through a combination of materials structure and induced degeneracy21,22,23,24,25,26,27.
Recently, it was recognized and experimentally demonstrated that a simple, homogenous, aluminum plate shows linear dispersion through k = 0 at a particular Poisson’s ratio where accidental degeneracy occurs28,29. Degeneracy was induced by adjusting the elastic properties of the plate over a small range through temperature change. It was also shown that waves excited in a plate near k = 0, referred to as conical point waves, exhibited angle independent mode conversion upon encountering a plate edge. Here, we derive the group velocity of conical point Lamb waves through implicit differentiation of the Rayleigh-Lamb equations, and provide the mode shapes as k approaches zero. We track the group velocity of modes at low k values and show that long wavelength Lamb waves can propagate with non-negligible group velocity only if the mechanical properties are such that degeneracy or near-degeneracy on a given mode occurs. We provide a computational and experimental study of near conical point Lamb wave interaction with holes and other discontinuities in a plate and find that the near conical point waves flow around defects while maintaining a constant phase of oscillation across that plate surface. Mode conversion at a hole interface is nearly spatially isotropic, regardless of the position of the excitation source. We propose that conical point and near-conical point Lamb waves provide a facile means of investigating the physics of “zero index” wave propagation. In addition, for specific materials that exhibit near-degeneracy of modes with like symmetry, they could find application in the nondestructive characterization of elastic waveguides.
Background and Theory
Conical dispersion: group velocity and mode shape
A dispersion curve for a homogeneous, isotropic plate found using the Rayleigh-Lamb equations is shown in Fig. 1(a). Here, the longitudinal wave velocity c1 = 6276 m/s, the shear wave velocity c2 = 3138 m/s, and the plate thickness is taken as 1.54 mm. The plot shows both the antisymmetric (Ai) and symmetric (Si) modes where the subscript represents the mode number. The modes are numbered with respect to the order which they occur with increasing temporal frequency on the k = 0 axis. Dispersion curves are generally parabolic at low wavenumber (k) values, and at the limit of k = 0 energy is trapped in the plate in the form of simple thickness resonances. Each resonance corresponds to a fundamental mode (longitudinal or shear) reflecting normally between the top and bottom faces of the plate. Such resonances occur at distinct frequencies determined by the plate thickness and longitudinal or shear wave velocity. In the special case of a plate in which the ratio of the longitudinal wave velocity (c1) and shear wave velocity (c2) is the ratio of two positive integers of different parity, then a longitudinal and a shear resonance of the same symmetry can occur at coincident frequencies. The interaction between the two bulk mode thickness resonances causes the otherwise stationary resonances to propagate at a finite group velocity, and results in linear dispersion at k = 0. For the dispersion curve in Fig. 1(a), for example, \(\frac{{c}_{1}}{{c}_{2}}=2\) and degeneracies between modes of the same symmetry occur at 2.04 MHz and 6.12 MHz. Linear dispersion at k = 0 is also referred to as conical dispersion due to the fact that the dispersion surface in three dimensions forms the shape of a cone as shown in the inset of Fig. 1(a) for the lowest frequency degeneracy. At the conical point waves are produced which have an infinite wavelength (k = 0) and spread over the plate surface with a spatially uniform surface oscillation.
The group velocity (\(\frac{d\omega }{dk}\)) at the conical point was calculated by Mindlin by linearizing the Rayleigh-Lamb dispersion equations for small values of k20. Here we take an alternate, but essentially equivalent, approach to find the conical point group velocity. Considering symmetric modes only, the Rayleigh-Lamb frequency equation (\({\varOmega }_{S}\)) is given by:
where \({p}^{2}={(\frac{\omega }{{c}_{1}})}^{2}-{k}^{2}\), \({q}^{2}={(\frac{\omega }{{c}_{2}})}^{2}-{k}^{2}\), h is half the plate thickness, and ω is the angular frequency. Given that \(d\varOmega s(\omega ,k)=0\), the group velocity can be expressed as30,31,32:
We find the group velocity at a particular conical point by taking the limit of Eq. 2 for \(k\to 0\). Here we consider, for example, the conical point that occurs at a frequency of \(\omega =\pi {c}_{2}/h\) when \({c}_{1}=2\,{c}_{2}\). Taking the limit and applying L’Hôpital’s rule we find:
At k = 0, we find that \({\partial }^{2}{\varOmega }_{S}/\partial k\partial \omega =0\). Plugging this in and solving for the group velocity we obtain:
Here we assume the limit is unique regardless of the direction of the derivative. An identical result has been obtained by Delph et al. using a Taylor expansion of the characteristic equation33.
We now consider the mode shapes of plate oscillations at the conical point. Taking the case of plane strain where the waves propagate in the x direction and the y direction is perpendicular to the plate surface, the displacement fields associated with symmetric waves are given by34:
where A and B are amplitude coefficients. The amplitude ratio can be found by applying traction free boundary conditions on the plate surfaces:
We again consider the case of \({c}_{1}=2\,{c}_{2}\) with linear dispersion near the conical point of the form \(\omega (k)=\pi {c}_{2}/h\pm 2{c}_{2}k/\pi \). Substituting this into Eq. 5 and taking the limit as k approaches zero we find an amplitude ratio of \(\frac{A}{B}=\pm 2\) and considering the real part of the displacement mode shapes in Eq. 4, the displacements near the conical point are:
The mode shape as k approaches the conical point is therefore the sum of two simple thickness resonances that oscillate out of phase and, interestingly, have equal amplitudes.
Long wavelength Lamb waves
The existence of conical point dispersion in plates leads to a unique type of wave propagation. At k = 0 this is particularly evident; waves with infinite wavelength propagate through the plate with finite group velocity. A source exciting waves at the conical point thus produces a spatially uniform oscillation that spreads or flows over the plate surface and is insensitive to wavelength dependent wave phenomena such as diffraction and scattering. The connection between the temporal and spatial aspects of the wave field essentially breaks down. Here we examine the group velocity of long wavelength Lamb waves as a function of Poisson’s ratio (ν). The mode that originates at the longitudinal resonance frequency of \(\frac{{c}_{1}\pi }{2h}\), corresponding to the S2 mode for \(\nu > \frac{1}{3}\) and the S2B mode for \(\nu < \frac{1}{3}\), is first considered. At each value of Poisson’s ratio, Eqs 1 and 2 are solved to calculate the group velocity for \(0 < k(2h) < 0.02\). The resulting plot is shown in Fig. 1(b), where the color scale gives the magnitude of the group velocity normalized to the conical point group velocity. A non-negligible group velocity is only observed in the vicinity of \(\nu =\frac{1}{3}\) where the S2/S2B mode accidental degeneracy leads to conical dispersion. The velocity is near the conical point velocity \(({c}_{g}=\frac{2{c}_{2}}{\pi })\) for the degenerate case over this narrow range of k values due to the linear dispersion. Figure 1(c) shows a zoomed in region of the plot near \(\nu =\frac{1}{3}\). Even in the case of near-degeneracy where the group velocity is zero at k = 0, exceptionally long wavelength Lamb waves with appreciable group velocity exist. From a practical standpoint, this gives some flexibility in materials selection in the experimental study of conical dispersion.
Figure 1(d) shows a similar plot for the mode that originates at the longitudinal resonance frequency of \(\frac{3{c}_{1}\pi }{2h}\), corresponding to the S5/S5B modes shown in Fig. 1(a). Here the degeneracy between the 3rd longitudinal symmetric resonance and the 6th transverse symmetric resonance occurs at \(\nu =\frac{1}{3}\) and the conical point group velocity is \({c}_{g}=\frac{2{c}_{2}}{3\pi }\). Again, long wavelength Lamb waves with non-negligible group velocity are observed only near the degeneracy. Comparing the result with Fig. 1(c), the range of Poisson’s ratio over which the group velocity is enhanced is significantly narrower. This trend continues for higher order degeneracies.
Experimental Set-Up
A schematic of the experimental setup is shown in Fig. 2. Lamb waves were generated using a contact piezoelectric transducer (Olympus v109) with a diameter of 25.4 mm coupled to the plate surface using a thin layer of oil. The transducer was driven by a sinusoidal voltage from a function generator coupled to a power amplifier. The displacement of the plate surface was measured on the opposite side of the plate from the excitation source using a photorefractive crystal based interferometer35 incorporating a single-longitudinal mode frequency doubled Nd:YAG laser (λ= 532 nm) with an output power of 200 mW. The magnitude and phase of the plate displacement response at the excitation frequency were measured using an RF lock-in amplifier. The reference signal for lock-in detection was derived from the function generator driving the piezoelectric transducer. The lock-in time constant was 300 ms with a 12 dB per octave roll off. The detection point was scanned over the plate surface using a 2-axis computer controlled translation stage.
Experimental measurements were taken on the two sample geometries shown in Fig. 2, each using 6061-O aluminum alloy plates. The room temperature Poisson’s ratio of this alloy was found to be 0.3349 ± 0.0006 using the method developed by Clorennec et al. based on ZGV frequency measurements8. Further details on our measurement approach are available in the literature29. In sample 1, the transducer was placed 60 mm from a 6 mm diameter hole in a \({d}_{1}=1.54\) mm thick plate. The detection laser was scanned over a 40 × 40 mm grid surrounding the hole with a step size of 0.5 mm. In sample 2, a symmetric step change in plate thickness from \({d}_{1}=1.54\) mm to \({d}_{2}=1.45\) mm was created by masking the plate and immersing it in an acid bath. A 25.4 mm hole was machined in the thick side of the plate approximately 46 mm from the thickness step. The piezoelectric transducer was positioned 60 mm from the hole on the side opposite the step. The detection laser was scanned in a 130 × 80 mm (x, y) rectangular grid around the hole and across the thickness step using 0.5 mm steps. For both samples, thick adhesive tape was placed around the sample boundaries to help reduce the amplitude of edge reflections.
Results and Discussion
In order to investigate conical point Lamb wave scattering, we first simulated Lamb wave interaction with a hole in a plate using a commercial finite element time domain software package (On-Scale, PZ-Flex). For the simulation, c1 = 6.00 mm/µs, c2 = 3.00 mm/µs \((\nu =\frac{1}{3}),\) and the plate thickness was 1.5 mm. The plate was modeled on an orthogonal grid with element dimensions 50 × 25 × 50 µm3 (x, y, z) and a 6 mm diameter hole was positioned in the center of the plate. Absorbing boundary conditions were used on the plate edges. Lamb waves were excited using a normal forcing function line source with a Gaussian spatial distribution normal to the line and a full width at half maximum (FWHM) of 12 mm. The source was 35 mm from the hole and temporally modulated at a frequency of 2.0 MHz, which corresponds to the frequency of the S2/S2B conical point.
The displacement normal to the plate surface is shown in Fig. 3(a). The field is displayed at after steady state has been reached at a time of 38 μs. In the figure, the waves are incident on the hole from the left side (negative x). The result shows a nearly perfectly symmetric periodic wave field surrounding the hole. Furthermore, the displacement field is offset from zero. Figure 3(b) shows the displacement field after processing with a spatial low pass filter with a cutoff of k = 0.5 mm−1 in order to isolate the conical point S2 mode. Remarkably, the conical point wave produces a spatially uniform oscillation of the plate surface that shows little evidence of perturbation by the hole.
Figure 3(c) shows the displacement field in Fig. 3(a) after a high pass spatial filter with a cutoff of k = 3.0 mm−1 in order to isolate the higher spatial frequency mode. This corresponds to the So mode which has a wave number of k = 4.14 mm−1. Here the spatially broad line source couples primarily into the long wavelength conical point S2 mode. At the free surface of the hole, the incident field is partially mode converted into the So mode in order to satisfy the traction free boundary conditions. Because the incident wave uniformly drives the mode conversion process around the hole, the So mode is emitted in phase around the hole producing the observed circular pattern. Figure 3(d) shows the magnitude of the two-dimensional Fourier transform of the displacement field in Fig. 3(c). The bright ring corresponding to the So mode (\(|k\,|=4.14\,{{\rm{mm}}}^{-1}\)) shows no evidence of directional dependence. This further demonstrates that the conical point wave is immune to scattering, producing a mode converted field of equal magnitude and phase over all points on the hole surface. We note that this also implies that the displacement field produced by the line source is independent of the position of the line with respect to the hole.
Experimental measurements taken on sample 1 are shown in Fig. 4. As the Poisson’s ratio of the plate is slightly above \(\frac{1}{3}\), we have a near-degeneracy and very long wavelength Lamb waves with non-negligible group velocity can be accessed. We choose an excitation frequency of 2.047 MHz, very close to the S2/S2B (k = 0) cutoff frequencies. The magnitude and phase of the displacement field are measured at each location on the surface, and the resulting displacement field at an arbitrary phase is shown in Fig. 4(a). In agreement with the simulation, we observe the circular waves emitted from the hole boundary in phase due to mode conversion of the near conical point Lamb wave to the So mode. In addition, the near conical point mode causes an offset over the entire field of view. The interplay between the overall plate oscillation and the waves emitted by the hole is evident in Supplementary Movie 1. Figure 4(b) shows the magnitude of the spatial Fourier transform of the displacement field. The incident near conical point S2 mode appears as a bright spot near the origin and the S0 mode appears as a relatively uniform ring near \(|k|=4.0\,{{\rm{mm}}}^{-1}\). Note that the contact transducer also generates an incident S1 mode that is observed over a limited angular range around \(|k|=2.2\,{{\rm{mm}}}^{-1}\). This is due to the fact that the transducer does not act as a perfect Gaussian source and edge effects lead to some coupling into higher spatial frequency modes. The near conical point mode is observed in Fig. 4(c) by processing the measured displacement field with a low pass filter (k = 0.8 mm−1). The displacement is nearly uniform over the inspection area, and spatial variation can be attributed to both the finite wavelength of the mode and some change in detection sensitivity across the scan region. The S0 mode is isolated by processing the displacement field with a bandpass filter between k = 3.8 mm−1 and k = 4.2 mm−1. The experimental result, shown in Fig. 4(d), compares favorably with simulation (Fig. 3(c)). The S0 mode is generated with uniform magnitude and phase over the boundary of the hole and there is no indication of diffraction or scattering of the near conical point mode.
As a further demonstration of the unique nature of conical point waves, we now consider wave propagation in sample 2 (see Fig. 2). Here, the hole size is increased to 25.4 mm and the hole is positioned near a thickness step in the plate. We first consider a numerical simulation, where the plate is excited by a normal force with a Gaussian profile (FWHM = 25.4 mm) positioned 30 mm from the hole. The spot diameter was selected to match the size of the transducer used in the experiments. The hole is between the source and a symmetric thickness step, where the thickness changes from h1 = 1.50 mm to h2 = 1.48 mm (see Fig. 2). The mechanical properties of the plate and element grid size are the same as in the previous simulation, and the plate is excited with a sinusoidal forcing function at the conical point frequency of 2.0 MHz starting at t = 0. The evolution of the displacement field normal to the surface over time is shown in Fig. 5. At 6.8 μs, the conical point wave is spreading from the source and just begins to impinge upon the hole (Fig. 5(a)). The conical point mode then begins to envelop the hole, appearing to flow around the hole with uniform phase advance (Fig. 5(b)). There is little evidence of interaction of the conical point wave with the hole apart from mode conversion to the S0 mode at the interface. Figure 5(c) shows the displacement as the conical point mode is just incident on the step change in thickness at a time of 38.2 μs. At the interface, the conical point mode is converted primarily to the S2B mode. Considering Snell’s law, the angle of refraction from a conical point mode at an interface would be zero degrees, regardless of the angle of incidence. This is evident in Fig. 5(d) where planar S2B wave fronts are seen after the step. Note the uniformity of the S2B mode and the absence of wave field perturbation by the hole. Higher order modes in the thin plate region produced by mode conversion of modes other than the conical point mode (such as the S0 mode) continue to diverge as expected.
The experimental measurements on sample 2 (see Fig. 2) are shown in Fig. 6. The plate was again excited near the S2/S2B cutoff frequencies (k = 0) at 2.047 MHz. Figure 6(a) shows the displacement field measured across the plate surface. In agreement with the simulations, we observe mode conversion from the near conical point mode to the S0 mode at the hole boundary and to the S2B mode at the interface (x = 45 mm). Figure 6(b) gives the filtered displacement field where on the left side of the step (x < 45 mm) a spatial low pass filter at k = 0.1 mm−1 is used to isolate the near conical point mode. On the right side of the step, a band pass filter between k = 0.3 mm−1 and k = 0.6 mm−1 is used to isolate the S2B mode and only negative k values are retained to eliminate reflections from the plate edge. The spatial Fourier transforms of the unfiltered wave field before and after the step are given in Fig. 6(c,d), respectively. The near conical point mode (x < 45 mm) produces reasonably uniform oscillation of the plate close to k = 0. Beyond the interface, S2B mode has a spatially uniform and planar phase front corresponding to the single bright spot on the Fourier transform near k = −0.5 mm−1. In agreement with the simulation, the uniformity of the S2B mode is due to the absence of diffraction and scattering of the near conical point mode by the hole. Supplementary Movie 2 shows the propagation of the conical point mode and its conversion into plane S2B backward waves.
Conclusion
In conclusion, we have studied the propagation of conical point and near-conical point Lamb waves in an isotropic plate and the interaction of these waves with plate boundaries and interfaces. By calculating the group velocity of long wavelength Lamb waves as a function of Poisson’s ratio, we show that Lamb waves with non-negligible group velocities close to k = 0 exist only near degeneracies between thickness mode longitudinal and shear resonances of the same symmetry. Numerical simulations and experimental results demonstrate that Lamb waves generated at the conical point frequency are immune to scattering and diffraction from holes in the plate. Conical point waves appear to flow around holes and, in the steady state, the conical point mode produces a surface oscillation with a uniform phase over the plate surface irrespective of the presence of holes. Mode conversion of conical point waves to shorter wavelength modes at the free surface of the hole leads to a spatially isotropic wave field emitted perpendicular to the hole surface. Similarly, mode conversion of the conical point mode at a thickness step in the plate leads to a spatially uniform mode converted field propagating perpendicular to the step. In both cases, conical point modes exhibit an unusual spatial invariance where the steady state wave field is insensitive to the source location. Conical point dispersion in isotropic plates provides access to exceptionally long wavelength Lamb waves with high group velocity that may find application in nondestructive testing and Lamb wave based sensing systems.
References
Mitra, M. & Gopalakrishnan, S. Guided wave based structural health monitoring: A review. Smart Mater. Struct. 15, 053001 (2016).
Yantchev, V. & Katardjiev, I. Thin film Lamb wave resonators in frequency control and sensing applications: a review. J. Micromech. Microeng. 23, 043001 (2013).
Rose, J. L. Ultrasonic Waves in Solid Media (Cambridge University Press, New York 1999).
Auld, B. A. Acoustic Fields and Waves in Solids (John Wiley and Sons, New York 1973).
Gibson, A. & Popovics, J. S. Lamb wave basis for impact-echo method analysis. J. Eng. Mech. 131(4), 438 (2005).
Holland, D. & Chimenti, D. E. Air-coupled acoustic imaging with zero group velocity Lamb modes. Appl. Phys. Lett. 83(13), 2704 (2003).
Prada., C., Balogun, O. & Murray, T. W. Laser-based ultrasonic generation and detection of zero-group velocity Lamb waves in thin plates. Appl. Phys. Lett. 87, 194109 (2005).
Clorennec, D., Prada, C. & Royer, D. Local and noncontact measurements of bulk acoustic wave velocities in thin isotropic plates and shells using zero group velocity Lamb modes. J. Appl. Phys. 101, 034908 (2007).
Clorennec, D., Prada, C., Royer, D. & Murray, T. W. Laser impulse generation and interferometer detection of zero group velocity Lamb mode resonance. Appl. Phys. Lett. 89, 024101 (2006).
Balogun, O., Murray, T. W. & Prada, C. Simulation and measurement of the optical excitation of the zero group velocity Lamb wave resonance in plates. J. Appl. Phy. 102, 064914 (2007).
Grünsteidl, C. M., Veres, I. A. & Murray, T. W. Experimental and numerical study of the excitability of zero group velocity Lamb waves by laser-ultrasound. J. Acoust. Soc. Am. 138, 242 (2015).
Cès, M., Clorennec, D., Royer, D. & Prada, C. Thin layer thickness measurements by zero group velocity Lamb mode resonances. Rev. Sci. Instrum. 82, 114902 (2011).
Prada, C., Clorennec, D. & Royer, D. Local vibration of an elastic plate and zero-group velocity Lamb modes. J. Acoust. Soc. Am. 124, 203 (2008).
Mezil, S. et al. Investigation of interfacial stiffnesses of a tri-layer using Zero-Group Velocity Lamb Modes. J. Acoust. Soc. Am. 138, 3202 (2015).
Yan, G., Raetz, S., Chigarev, N., Gisev, V. E. & Tournet, V. Characterization of progressive fatigue damage in solid plates by laser ultrasonic monitoring of zero group velocity lamb modes. Phys. Rev. Appl. 9(6), 061001 (2018).
Grünsteidl, C., Berer, T., Hettich, M. & Veres, I. Determination of thickness and bulk sound velocities of isotropic plates using zero-group-velocity Lamb waves”. Applied Physics Letters 112(25), 0–5 (2018).
Cubukcu, E., Aydin, K., Ozbay, E., Foteinopoulou, S. & Soukoulis, C. M. Electromagnetic waves: Negative refraction by photonic crystals”. Nature (London) 423, 604 (2003).
Meitzler, A. H. Backward-Wave Transmission of Stress Pulses in Elastic Cylinders and Plates. J. Acoust. So. Am. 38, 835 (1965).
Ibanescu, M. et al. Anomalous Dispersion Relations by Symmetry Breaking in Axially Uniform Waveguides. Phy. Rev. Lett. 92, 6 (2004).
Mindlin, R. D. An Introduction to the Mathematical Theory of Vibrations of Elastic Plates (World Scientific, Singapore, 2016).
Huang, X., Lai, Y., Hang, Z. H., Zheng, H. & Chan, C. T. Dirac cones induced by accidental degeneracy in photonic crystals and zero-refractive-index materials. Nat. Mater. 10, 582 (2011).
Liu, F., Lai, Y., Huang, X. & Chan, C. T. Dirac cones at k = 0 in phononic crystals. Phys. Rev. B 84, 224113 (2011).
Silveirinha, M. & Engheta, N. Tunneling of Electromagnetic Energy through Subwavelength Channels and Bends using ε-Near-Zero Materials. Phys. Rev. Lett. 97, 157403 (2006).
Liu, R. et al. Experimental Demonstration of Electromagnetic Tunneling Through an Epsilon-Near-Zero Metamaterial at Microwave Frequencies. Phys. Rev. Lett. 100, 023903 (2008).
Liu, F., Huang, X. & Chen, C. T. Dirac cones at k = 0 in acoustic crystals and zero index acoustic materials. Appl. Phys. Lett. 100, 071911 (2012).
Nguyen, V. C., Chen, L. & Halterman, K. Total Transmission and Total Reflection by Zero Index Metamaterials with Defects. Phys. Rev. Lett. 105, 233908 (2010).
Liu, F. & Liu, Z. Elastic Waves Scattering without Conversion in Metamaterials with Simultaneous Zero Indices for Longitudinal and Transverse Waves. Phys. Rev. Lett. 115, 175502 (2015).
Maznev, A. A. Dirac cone dispersion of acoustic waves in plates without phononic crystals. J. Acoust. Soc. Am. 135, 577 (2014).
Stobbe, D. M. & Murray, T. W. Conical dispersion of Lamb waves in elastic plates. Phys. Rev. B 96, 144101 (2017).
Bernard, A., Lowe, M. J. S. & Deschamps, M. Guided waves energy velocity in absorbing and non-absorbing plates. J. Acoust. Soc. Am. 110(1), 186 (2001).
Grünsteidl, C., Murray, T. W., Berer, T. & Veres, I. A. Inverse characterization of plates using zero group velocity Lamb modes. Ultrasonics 65, 1–4 (2016).
Tassoulas, J. L. & Akylas, T. R. On wave modes with zero group velocity in an elastic layer. J. Appl. Mech. 51(3), 652–656 (1984).
Delph, T. J., Herrmann, G. & Kaul, R. K. On coalescence of frequencies and conical points in the dispersion spectra of elastic bodies, Int. J. Solids Structures 13, 423–436 (1977).
Graff, K. F. Wave motion in elastic solids (Courier Corporation, 2012).
Blouin, A. & Monchalin, J. P. Detection of Ultrasonic motion of a scattering surface by two-wave mixing in photorefractive GaAs crystal. Appl. Phys. Lett. 65, 932 (1994).
Acknowledgements
T.W. Murray and D.M. Stobbe gratefully acknowledge the support of this research by the National Science Foundation under Grant No. CMMI 1335426 and C. Grünsteidl gratefully acknowledges support by the Max Kade Foundation.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Contributions
T. Murray and D. Stobbe suggested the experiment. C. Grünsteidl and D. Stobbe performed the experiments and numerical simulations. All authors contributed to the theory, analyzed the data, and wrote the manuscript.
Corresponding author
Ethics declarations
Competing interests
The authors declare no competing interests.
Additional information
Publisher’s note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Supplementary information
Rights and permissions
Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article’s Creative Commons license, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article’s Creative Commons license and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this license, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/.
About this article
Cite this article
Stobbe, D.M., Grünsteidl, C.M. & Murray, T.W. Propagation and Scattering of Lamb Waves at Conical Points in Plates. Sci Rep 9, 15216 (2019). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-019-51187-9
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-019-51187-9
- Springer Nature Limited
This article is cited by
-
Dirac cones of guided waves in isotropic functionally graded plates: the Wiechert case
Zeitschrift für angewandte Mathematik und Physik (2023)