Abstract
The use of concrete models for teaching students how to solve equations is often debated in scientific literature. This article aims to examine the balance model and to identify the issues that divide scientists. We based our reflections on the results of an empirical study and analysis of the various arguments put forward by supporters and opponents of the model. We describe learning situations that were the subject of the empirical study, which involved forty students in two 8th-grade classes. The aim was to teach the formal solving method, which involved performing the same operations on both sides of the equation using, notably, the balance model. Analysis of students' reasoning showed that the presence of negative numbers gave rise to many errors. The difficulties presented by negative numbers were reviewed, eight months later, during an interview with five students, chosen from those who took part in the experiment. Within that context, we discuss the relevance of the balance model and analyse the arguments put forward by researchers who either defend or reject its use.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
REFERENCES
Booth, L. and Cook, J.: 1988, 'Children's difficulties in beginning algebra', in A. Coxford and A. Shulte (eds.), The Ideas of Algebra, K-12. National Council of Teachers of Mathematics, pp. 20–32.
Brown, T., Eade, F. and Wilson, D.: 1999, 'Semantic innovation: Arithmetical and algebraic metaphors within narratives of learning', Educational Studies in Mathematics 40, 53–70.
Colomb, J.: 1995, Calcul littéral. Savoir des élèves de collège, Institut National de Recherche pédagogique. Document et travaux de recherche en éducation, Paris.
Combier, G., Guillaume, J.-C. and Pressiat, A.: 1996, Les débuts de l'algèbre au collège. Au pied de la lettre, Institut National de Recherche Pédagogique, Didactiques des disciplines, Paris.
Filloy, E. and Rojano, T.: 1989, 'Solving equations: The transition from arithmetic to algebra', For the learning of the mathematics 9(2), 19–25.
Filloy, E. and Sutherland, R.: 1996, 'Designing curricula for teaching and learning algebra', in A. Bishop (ed.), International Handbook of Mathematics Education, vol. 1, Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht, pp. 139–160.
Gallardo, A.: 2001, 'Historical-epistemological analysis in mathematics education: two works in didactics of algebra', in R. Sutherland, T. Rojano, A. Bell and R. Lins (eds.), Perspectives on School Algebra, Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht, pp. 121–139.
Gallardo, A. and Rojano, T.: 1994, 'School Algebra. Syntactic difficulties in the operativity', Proceedings of the XVI International Group for the Psychology of Mathematics Education, North American Chapter, vol. 1, USA, Louisiana State University, pp. 265–272.
Glaeser, G.: 1981, 'Epistémologie des nombres relatifs', Recherche en didactique des mathématiques 2(3), 303–346.
Henry, G.: 1996, Troisième étude internationale en Mathématiques et en Sciences. Epreuves de rendement-Mathématiques, Rapport technique. Service de Développement et d'Evaluation des Programmes de Formation de l'ULg.
Herscovics, N. and Kieran, C.: 1980, 'Constructing meaning for the concept of equation', The Mathematics Teacher 73(8), 572–580.
Herscovics, N. and Linchevski, L.: 1991, 'Pre-algebraic thinking: Range of equations and informal solution processes used by seventh graders prior to any instruction', Proceedings of the XV Annual Meeting of PME, vol. 3, Assissi, Italy, pp. 173–180.
Kieran, C.: 1981, 'Concepts associated with equality symbol', Educational Studies in Mathematics 12, 317–326.
Kieran, C.: 1990, 'Cognitive processes involved in learning school algebra', in P. Nescher et J. Kilpatrick (eds.), Mathematics and Cognition, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp. 96–102.
Kieran, C.: 1992, 'The learning and the teaching of scool algebra', in D. Grouws (ed.), Handbook of research on Mathematics Teaching and Learning, Mac Millan, New York, pp. 390–419.
Küchemann, D.E.: 1981, Chapitre 8: 'Algebra', in K.M. Hart (ed.), Children's Understanding of Mathematics, The CSMS Mathematics Team, London, pp. 11–16.
Linchevski, L. and Herscovics, N.: 1996, 'Crossing the cognitive gap between arithmetic and algebra: Operation on the unknown in the context of equation', Educational Studies in Mathematics 30, 39–65.
Linchevski, L. and Williams, J.S.: 1996, 'Situated intuition, concrete manipulations and the construction of mathematical concepts: The case of integers', Proceedings of the 20 th conference of the International Group for the Psychology of Mathematics Education, University of Valencia, Valencia, Vol. 3, pp. 265–272.
Pirie, S. and Martin L: 1997, 'The equation, the whole equation and nothing but the equation! One approach to the teaching of linear equations', Educational Studies in Mathematics 22, 1–36.
Radford, L.: 2001, 'Algebra as tekhnè. Artefacts, Symbols and Equations in the Classroom', Pre-print n°2. Université Laurentienne, Ecole des sciences de l'éducation, Ontario, Canada.
Radford, L. and Grenier, M.: 1996, 'Les apprentissages mathématiques en situation', Revue des Sciences de l'éducation XXII, 2, 253–276.
Sfard, A.: 1991, 'On the dual nature of mathematical conceptions', Educational Studies in Mathematics 22, 1–36.
Sfard, A. and Linchevski, L.: 1994, 'The gains and the pitfalls of reification: The case of algebra', Educational Studies in Mathematics 26(2-3), 191–228.
Slavitt, D.: 1999, 'The role of operation sense in transitions from arithmetic to algebraic thought', Educational Studies in Mathematics 37(3), 251–274.
Vergnaud, G.: 1989, 'L'obstacle des nombres négatifs et l'introduction à l'algèbre', in N. Bednarz & C. Garnier (eds.) Construction des savoirs, Obstacles et conflits. Editions Agence d'ARC Inc, Ottawa, pp. 76–83.
Vlassis, J.: 2001, 'Solving equations with negatives or crossing the formalizing gap', Proceedings of the 25 th conference of the International Group for the Psychology of Mathematics Education, July 11–17, 2001, Utrecht, The Netherlands, Volume 3, pp. 375–382.
Vlassis, J. and Demonty, I.: 2000, Épreuve d'algèbre en 2e année du secondaire: Résultats de population, Rapport de recherche, Liège: Service de Pédagogie expérimentale de l'Université.
Vlassis, J. and Demonty, I.: 2002, L'algèbre par des situations-problèmes, De Boek, Bruxelles.
Vygotsky, L.: 1962, Thought and Language MIT Press, Cambridge.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Vlassis, J. The balance model: Hindrance or support for the solving of linear equations with one unknown. Educational Studies in Mathematics 49, 341–359 (2002). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1020229023965
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1020229023965