Abstract
This article surveys the diverse research that examines racial disparities in mortgage lending markets in the context of the fair housing legislation of recent decades. A review of the theoretical models, data, and empirical methods reveals deficiencies in all three areas. A new research agenda focusing on development of more complete models of mortgage lending together with panel data tracking mortgage loan performance over time is needed.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Abrams, Charles. (1955). Forbidden Neighbors, Port Washington, NY: Kennikat Press.
Ahlbrantdt, Roger. (1977). “Exploratory Research on the Redlining Phenomenon.” Journal of the American Real Estate and Urban Economics Association 5 (4) (Winter), 473–481.
Arrow, Kenneth. (1973). “The Theory of Discrimination.” In O. Aschenfelter and A. Reese (eds.), Discrimination in Labor Markets. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Ashenfelter, Orley, and Ronald Oaxaca. (1987). “The Economics of Discrimination: Economists Enter the Courtroom.” American Economic Review 77(2), 321–325.
Avery, Robert B., Patricia Beeson, and Paul S. Calem. (1997). “Using HMDA Data as a Regulatory Screen for Fair Lending Compliance.” Journal of Financial Services Research 11(1/2), 9–42.
Avery, Robert B., Patricia Beeson, and Mark Sniderman. (1994). “Accounting for Racial Differences in Housing Credit Markets.” Working Paper 93–09, Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland.
Barth, James, J. Cordes, and A. Yezer. (1983). “FHA Mortgage Insurance and High-Risk Mortgage Lending: Some Lessons for Policy.” Housing Finance Review, 93–107.
Bauer, Paul W., and Brian Cromwell. (1994). “A Monte Carlo Examination of Bias Tests in Mortgage Lending.” Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland Economic Review 27–39.
Becker, Gary S. (1957). The Economics of Discrimination. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Becker, Gary S. (1971). The Economics of Discrimination, 2nd Edition. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Becker, Gary S. (1993). “Nobel Lecture” Journal of Political Economy 101(3) 386–389.
Bentston, G. (1981). “Mortgage Redlining Research: A Review and Critical Analysis Discussion.” Journal of Bank Research (Spring), 8–23.
Bentston, G. and Dan Horskey. (1991). “The Relationship Between the Demand and Supply of Home Financing and Neighborhood Characteristics: An Empirical Study of Mortgage Redlining.” Journal of Financial Services Research 5, 235–260.
Berkovec, James A., Glenn B. Canner, Stuart A. Gabriel, and Timothy H. Hannan. (1996). “Mortgage Discrimination and FHA Loan Performance.” Citiscape 2(1) (February), 9–24.
Berkovec, James A., and Frank E. Nothaft. (1997). “Determinants of Loan Product Choice in the Conventional Market.” Paper presented at the 1997 FMA Annual Meeting, Honolulu, October.
Black, Harold A., M. Cary Collins, and Ken B. Cyree. (1997). “Lending Discrimination and Black-Owned Banks.” Journal of Financial Services Research 11(1/2), 189–204.
Black, Harold A., and Robert Schweitzer. (1985). “A Canonical Analysis of Mortgage Lending Terms: Testing for Lending Discrimination at a Commercial Bank.” Urban Studies 22, 13–19.
Black, Harold A., Robert Schweitzer, and Lewis Mandell. (1978). “Discrimination in Mortgage Lending.” American Economic Review 68(2), 186–191.
Bradbury, Karthryn, Karl Case, and Constance Dunham. (1989). “Geographic Patterns of Mortgage Lending in Boston, 1982–1987.” New England Economic Review (September-October), 3–30.
Bradford, Calvin. (1979). “Financing Home Ownership: The Federal Role in Neighborhood Decline.” Urban Affairs Quarterly 14(3), 79–92.
Browne, Lynn E., and Geoffrey Tootell. (1995). “Mortgage Lending in Boston: A Response to the Critics.” New England Economic Review (September-October), 53–78.
Campbell, Tim and J. Kimball Dietrich. (1983). “The Determinants of Default on Insured Conventional Mortgages.” Journal of Finance 38, 1569–1581.
Canner, Glenn, Stuart Gabriel, and James Woolley. (1991). “Race, Default Risk, and Mortgage Lending: A Study of FHA and Conventional Loan Markets.” Southern Economic Journal 58, 249–283.
Canner, Glenn, and Dolores S. Smith. (1991). “Home Mortgage Disclosure Act: Expanded Data on Residential Lending.” Federal Reserve Bulletin 77, 859–868.
Capon, Noel. (1982). “Credit Scoring Systems: A Critical Analysis.” Journal of Marketing 46 (Spring), 82–91.
Carr, James H. and Isaac Megbolugbe. (1993). “The Federal Reserve Bank of Boston Study on Mortgage Lending Revisited.” Journal of Housing Research 4(2), 277–313.
Cho, Man, and Isaac Megbolugbe. (1996). “An Empirical Analysis of Property Appraisal and Mortgage Redlining.” Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics 13, 45–56.
Cloud, Cathy, and George Galster. (1993). “What Do We Know About Racial Discrimination in Mortgage Markets?” Review of Black Political Economy (Summer), 101–120.
Courant, Paul N. (1978). “Racial Prejudice in a Search Model of the Urban Housing Market.” Journal of Urban Economics 5 (July), 329–345.
Courchane, Marcia, and David Nickerson. (1997). “Discrimination Resulting from Overage Practices.” Journal of Financial Services Research 11(1/2), 133–152.
Dane, Stephen. (1993). “A History of Mortgage Lending Discrimination in the United States.” Journal of Intergroup Relations 20(1) (Spring), 6–28.
Daniels, C. (1975). “The Influence of Racial Segregation on Housing Prices.” Journal of Urban Economics, 105–122.
Davis, F. James. (1991). Who Is Black: One Nation's Definition. University Park: Pennsylvania State University Press.
Dean, John. (1947). “Only CaucAsian: A Study of Race Covenants.” Journal of Land and Public Utility Economics (November), 428–432.
Degroot, Morris H., Stephen E. Feinberg, and Joseph B. Kadane. (1986). Statistics and the Law. New York: Wiley.
Evans, Richard D., Brian Maris, and Robert Weinstein. (1985). “Expected Loss and Mortgage Default Risk.” Quarterly Journal of Business and Economics 24, 75–92.
Ferguson, Michael F., and Stephen R. Peters. (1995). “What Constitutes Evidence of Discrimination in Mortgage Lending?” Journal of Finance 50(2) (June), 739–748.
Ferguson, Michael F., and Stephen R. Peters. (1997). “Cultural Affinity and Lending Discrimination: The Impact of Underwriting Errors and Credit Risk Distribution on Applicant Denial Rates.” Journal of Financial Services Research 11(1/2), 153–169.
Fix, Michael, and Raymond Struyk. (1993). Clear and Convincing Evidence. Washington, DC: Urban Institute.
Follain, James R. (1990). “Mortgage Choice.” Journal of The American Real Estate and Urban Economics Association 18, 125–144.
Follain, James R. (1996). “The Demand for Residential Mortgage Debt.” Paper presented at the American Real Estate and Urban Economics Meeting, January.
Follain, James R., and Stephen Malpezzi. (1981). “Another Look at Racial Differences in Housing Prices.” Urban Studies (June), 195–204.
Gabriel, Stuart A. (1987). “Economic Effects of Racial Integration: An Analysis of Hedonic Housing Prices and the Willingness to Pay.” Journal of the American Real Estate and Urban Economics Association 15(3), 268–278.
Gabriel, Stuart A., and S. Rosenthal. (1991). “Credit Rationing, Race, and the Mortgage Market.” Journal of Urban Economics 29, 371–379.
Galster, G. (1987). “Residential Segregation and Interracial Economic Disparities.” Journal of Urban Economics 21, 22–44.
Galster, G. (1992). “Research on Discrimination in Housing and Mortgage Markets: Assessment and Future Directions.” In Proceedings of the 1992 Fannie Mae Annual Housing Conference. May 19, 1992, Washington, DC: Fannie Mae.
Galster, G. (1993). “The Facts of Lending Discrimination Cannot Be Argued Away by Examining Default Rates.” Housing Policy Debate 4(1),141–146.
Gillmor, Dan, and Stephen K. Doig. (1992). “Segregation Forever.” American Demographics (January), 48–51.
Green, R. Jeffrey, and George M. von Furstenberg. (1975). “The Effects of Race and Age of Housing on Mortgage Delinquency Risk.” Urban Studies 12 (February), 85–89.
Harrison, Glenn W. (1998). “Mortgage Lending in Boston: A Reconsideration of the Evidence.” Economic Inquiry 36(1), 29–38.
Hendershott, Patric H., and Robert Van Order. (1987). “Pricing Mortgages: An Interpretation of the Model and Results.” Journal of Financial Services Research 1, 77–111.
Holmes, Andrew, and Paul Horvitz. (1994). “Mortgage Redlining: Race, Risk, and Demand.” Journal of Finance, 49(1) (March), 81–99.
Holmes, Andrew, Paul Horvitz, and Joe James. (1997). “Mortgage Loans to Non-occupants as an Indicator of Racial Redlining.” Journal of Financial Services Research 11(1/2), 95–108.
Holmes, Andrew, and Joe James. (1996). “Discrimination, Lending Practices, and Housing Values: Preliminary Evidence from the Houston Market.” Journal of Real Estate Research 11, 25–38.
Horne, David. (1994). “Evaluating the Role of Race in Mortgage Lending.” FDIC Banking Review 7(1), 1–13.
Horne, David. (1997). “Mortgage Lending, Race, and Model Specification.” Journal of Financial Services Research 11(1/2), 43–68.
Hunter, W. Curt, and M.B.Walker. (1996). “The Cultural Affinity Hypothesis and Mortgage Lending Decisions.” Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics 13(1), 57–50.
Hutchinson, Peter, James Ostas, and J. David Reed. (1977). “A Survey and Comparison of Redlining Influences in Urban Lending Markets.” Journal of the Amercian Real Estate and Urban Economics Association 5(4), 463–472.
Jackson, Kenneth T. (1980). “Race, Ethnicity, and Real Estate Appraisal.” Journal of Urban History 6(4), 419–453.
Kain, John. (1992). “The Spatial Mismatch Hypothesis Twenty Years Later.” Paper presented at the FNMA
Housing Conference. May 19, 1992. Washington DC: Fannie Mae.
Kain, John, and John Quigley. (1970). “Measuring the Value of Housing Quality.” Journal of the American Statistical Association (June), 532–548.
Kain, John, and John Quigley. (1975). “Housing Markets and Racial Discrimination: A Microeconomic Analysis.” New York: National Bureau of Economic Research.
Kau, James B., Donald C. Keenan, William J. Muller, and John F. Epperson. (1992). “A Generalized Valuation Model for Fixed-Rate Residential Mortgages.” Journal of Money, Credit, and Banking 24, 279–299.
Kaye, David. (1982). “Statistical Evidence of Discrimination.” Journal of the American Statistical Association 77, 773–783.
Kaye, David H., and Mikel Aicken (eds.). (1986). Statistical Methods in Discrimination Litigation. New York: Marcel Dekker.
King, A. Thomas. (1980). “Mortgage Lending, Social Responsibility, and Public Policy: Some Perspectives on HMDA and CRA.” Journal of the American Real Estate and Urban Economics Association 8, 77–90.
King, A. Thomas, and Peter Mieszkowski. (1973). “Racial Discrimination, Segregation, and the Price of Housing.” Journal of Political Economy (May-June), 590–606.
LaCour-Little, Michael. (1996a). “Application of Reverse Regression to Boston Federal Reserve Data Refutes Claims of Discrimination.” Journal of Real Estate Research 11(1), 1–13.
LaCour-Little, Michael. (1996b). “The Demand and Supply of Mortgage Credit: Implications for Testing for Discrimination.” Paper presented at the American Real Estate and Urban Economics Association Meeting, January.
LaCour-Little, Michael. (1996c). “Identification of Discrimination in Mortgage Lending Markets.” Ph.D. dissertation, University of Wisconsin, Madison.
LaCour-Little, Michael, and Richard K. Green. (1998). “Are Minorities and Minority Neighborhoods More Likely to Get Low Appraisals?” Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics 16(3), 301–315.
Lang, William, and Leonard Nakamura. (1993). “A Model of Redlining.” Journal of Urban Economics 33, 223–234.
Lapham, Victoria. (1971). “Do Blacks Pay More for Housing?” Journal of Political Economy 79, 1244–1257.
Liebowitz, Stan, and Ted Day. (1992). “Mortgages, Minorities, and Discrimination.” Working Paper, University of Texas at Dallas.
Liebowitz, Stan, and Ted Day. (1993). “A Study That Deserves No Credit.” Wall Street Journal, September 1, p. A14.
Liebowitz, Stan, and Ted Day. (1998). “Mortgage Lending to Minorities: Where's the Bias?” Economic Inquiry 36(1), 3–28.
Ling, David, and SusanWachter. (1995). “The Impact of Neighborhood Risk Characteristics on Home Mortgage Underwriting.” Working paper, University of Florida.
Long, J.E., and S.B. Caudill. (1992). “Racial Differences in Homeownership and Housing Wealth 1970–1986.” Economic Inquiry 30(1), 83–100.
MacChesney, Nathan W. (1927). The Principles of Real Estate Law. New York: Macmillan.
Macey, Jonathan R., and Geoffrey P. Miller. (1993). “The Community Reinvestment Act: An Economic Analysis.” Virginia Law Review 79(2), 291–348.
Maddala, G.S. (1983). Limited-Dependent and Qualitative Variables in Econometrics. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Maddala, G.S., and Robt P. Trost. (1982). “On Measuring Discrimination in Loan Markets.” Housing Finance Review 1(2), 245–268.
Malmquist, David, Fred Phillips-Patrick, and Clifford Ross. (1997). “The Economics of Low-Income Mortgage Lending.” Journal of Financial Services Research 11(1/2), 169–188.
Massey, Douglas, and Nancy Denton. (1993). American Apartheid. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
McKinney, Scott, and Ann B. Schnare. (1989). “Trends in Residential Segregation by Race: 1960–1980.” Journal of Urban Economics 26, 269–280.
Miller, Stephen M. (1982). “Mortgage Discrimination by Financial Intermediaries: A Case Study of Residential Mortgage in Hartford, Connecticut.” Working Paper No. 36, Center for Real Estate and Urban Economic Studies, University of Connecticut, Storrs.
Mills, Edwin S. and Richard Price. (1986). “Metropolitan Suburbanization and Central City Problems.” Journal of Urban Economics 15, 1–17.
Munnell, Alicia H., Lynn Browne, James McEneaney, and Geoffrey Tootell. (1992). “Mortgage Lending in Boston: Interpreting HMDA Data.” Working Paper 92–7, Federal Reserve Bank of Boston.
Munnell, Alicia H., Lynn Browne, James McEneaney, and Geoffrey Tootell. (1996). “Mortgage Lending in Boston: Interpreting HMDA Data.” American Economic Review 86 (1) (March), 25–54.
National Board of Realtors. (1943). Fundamentals of Real Estate Practice. Chicago: National Board of Realtors.
Olsen, Edgar O. (1974). “Do the Poor or the Black Pay More for Housing?” In von Furstenberg and Horowitz (eds.), Patterns of Racial Discrimination, Vol. 1, Housing. Lexington, MA: Lexington Books.
Phelps Edmund S. (1972). “The Statistical Theory of Racism and Sexism.” American Economic Review 62, 659–661.
Quercia, Roberto G., and Michael A. Stegman. (1992). “Residential Mortgage Default: A Review of the Literature.” Journal of Housing Research 3(2), 341–376.
Quigley, John M. (1996). “Mortgage Performance and Housing Market Discrimination.” Citiscape 2(1), 59–64.
Rachlis, Mitchell, and AnthonyYezer. (1993). “Serious Flaws in Statistical Tests for Discrimination in Mortgage Markets.” Journal of Housing Research 4(2), 315–336.
Reid, Clifford. (1977). “Measuring Residential Decentralization of Blacks and Whites.” Urban Studies 14, 353–357.
Rosenblatt, Eric. (1977). “A Reconsideration of Discrimination in Mortgage Underwriting with Data from a National Mortgage Bank.”
Rosenberg, Eric, and Alan Gleit. (1994). “Quantitative Methods in Credit Management: A Survey.” Operations Research 42(4) (July-August), 589–613.
Rosenblatt, Eric. (1994). “A Reconsideration of Discrimination in Mortgage Underwriting.” Ph.D. dissertation, Rutgers University.
Rutherglen, George. (1964). Major Issues in The Federal Law of Employment Discrimination Federal Judicial Center, Washington, DC.
Sandler, Andrew L., and Jonathan Biran. (1995). “The Improper Use of Statistics in Mortgage Lending Discrimination Actions.” In A. Yezer (ed)., Fair Lending Analysis. American Bankers Association. Washington, DC.
Schafer, Robert, and Helen F. Ladd. (1981). Discrimination in Mortgage Lending. MIT-Harvard Joint Center for Urban Studies. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Schnare, Ann. (1976). “Racial and Ethnic Price Differentials in Urban Housing Markets.” Urban Studies 13, 107–120.
Shear, William B., and Anthony Yezer. (1983). “An Indirect Test of Discrimination in Housing Finance.” Journal of the American Real Estate and Urban Economics Association 10, 405–420.
Shear, William B., and Anthony Yezer. (1985). “Discrimination in Urban Housing Finance: An Empirical Study Across Cities.” Land Economics 61(3), 293–302.
Schelling, Thomas C. (1969). “Models of Segregation.” American Economic Review 59, 488–493.
Schelling, Thomas C. (1972). “A Process of Residential Segregation: Neighborhood Tipping.” In Anthony H. Pascal (ed.), Racial Discrimination in Economic Life. Lexington, MA: Lexington Books.
Schill, Michael H., and Susan M. Wachter. (1993). “A Tale of Two Cities: Racial and Ethnic Geographic Disparities in Home Mortgage Lending in Boston and Philadelphia.” Journal of Housing Research 4(2), 245–276.
Schwemm, Robert G. (ed.). (1988). The Fair Housing Act After Twenty Years. Proceedings of a Conference at the Yale Law School, March 1988. New Haven: Yale University Press.
Scott, Hal S. (1995). “The Reinvented Community Reinvestment Act.” Monograph, The Heritage Foundation, Washington, DC.
Siskin, Bernard R. (1995). “Comparing the Role of Statistics in Lending and Employment Cases.” In A. Yezer (ed.), Fair Lending Analysis. American Bankers Association, Washington, D.C.
Smith, Barton A. (1981). “A Study of Racial Discrimination in Housing.” In J. Vernon Henderson (ed.), Research in Urban Economics, Vol. 1. Greenwich, CT: JAI Press.
Stengel, Mitchell, and Dennis Glennon. (1995). “Evaluating Statistical Models of Mortgage Lending Discrimination: A Bank-Specific Analysis.” Working Paper 95–3, Office of the Comptroller of the Currency, & Washington, DC.
Stiglitz, Joseph E., and Andrew Weiss. (1981). “Credit Rationing in Markets with Imperfect Information.” American Economic Review 71(3), 393–410.
Straszheim, Mahlon R. (1970). “Racial Discrimination in the Urban Housing Market.” In George M. von Furstenberg, Bennett Harrison, and Ann Horowitz (eds.), Patterns of Racial Discrimination, Vol. 1, Housing. Lexington, MA: Lexington Books.
Straszheim, Mahlon R. (1975). “An Econometric Model of the Urban Housing Market.” New York: National Bureau of Economic Research.
Struyk, Raymond, and Margery Turner. (1986). “Explaining the Effects of Racial Preferences on Urban Housing Markets.” Journal of Urban Economics 19, 131–147.
Stuart, Guy. (1994). “The Social Construction of Risk in Mortgage Lending.” Ph.D. dissertation, University of Chicago.
Sunstein, Cass R. (1990). “Why Markets Don't Stop Discrimination.” Social Philosophy and Policy 8, 22–45.
Swire, Peter A. (1995a). “Equality of Opportunity and Investment in Creditworthiness.” University of Pennsylvania Law Review 143(5), 1533–1560.
Swire, Peter A. (1995b). “The Persistent Problem of Lending Discrimination: A Law and Economics Analysis.” University of Texas Law Review 73 (June), 787–869.
Swire, Peter A. (1995c). “Safe Harbors: A Proposal to Reform CRA.” University of Virginia Law Review 79(2), 349–382.
Tootell, Geoffrey. (1993). “Defaults, Denials, and Discrimination in Mortgage Lending.” New England Economic Review (September-October), 45–51.
U.S. Federal Housing Administration. (1938). Underwriting Manual. Washington, DC: U.S. Government Printing Office.
Vandell, Kerry D. (1981). “The Effects of Racial Composition on Neighborhood Succession.” Urban Studies 18, 315–333.
Vandell, Kerry D. (1982). “Toward a Model of Credit Rationing and Term Adjustment in the Mortgage Market.” In C.F. Sirmans (ed.), Research in Real Estate, Vol. 1. Greenwich, CT: JAI Press.
Vandell, Kerry D. “Market Factors Affecting Spatial Heterogeneity Among Urban Neighborhoods.” Housing Policy Debate 6(1), 103–139.
Vandell, Kerry D., B.S. Hodas, and R. Bratt. (1974). “Financial Institutions and Neighborhood Decline: A Review of the Literature.” Federal Home Loan Bank Board, Mimeograph, Washington, DC.
Van Order, Robert, Ann-MargaretWestin, and Peter Zorn. (1995). “Neighborhood Racial Composition and Loan Performance.” Freddie Mac Working Paper.
Yezer, Anthony (ed.). (1995). Fair Lending Analysis: A Compendium of Essays on the Use of Statistics. Washington, DC: American Banker's Association.
Yezer, Anthony M., Robert F. Phillips, and Robert P. Trost. (1994). “Bias in Estimates of Discrimination and Default in Mortgage Lending: The Effects of Simultaneity and Self Selection.” Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economists 9(3), 197–216.
Yinger, John. (1978). “Black-White Price Differentials in Housing: Some Further Evidence.” Land Economics 54(2), 188–208.
Yinger, John. (1979). “Prejudice and Discrimination in the Urban Housing Market.” In P. Mieszkowski and M. Straszheim (eds.), Current Issues in Urban Economics. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins Press.
Yinger, John. (1986). “Measuring Racial Discrimination with Fair Housing Audits: Caught in the Act.” American Economic Review 76(5) (December), 881–893.
Yinger, John. (1993). “Discrimination in Mortgage Lending: A Literature Review.” Paper presented at the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development Conference on Discrimination in Mortgage Lending, June.
Yinger, John. (1994). “Cash in Your Face: The Cost of Racial and Ethnic Discrimination in Housing.” Manuscript, Center for Policy Research, Syracuse University, August.
Yinger, John. (1996). “Why Default Rates Cannot Shed Light on Mortgage Discrimination.” Citiscape 2(1) (February), 25–32.
Zandi, Mark. (1993). “Boston Fed's Bias Study Was Deeply Flawed.” American Banker (August 19), 13.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
LaCOUR-LITTLE, M. Discrimination in Mortgage Lending: A Critical Review of the Literature. Journal of Real Estate Literature 7, 15–50 (1999). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1008616203852
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1008616203852