Abstract
Many authors suggest the need to define ‘sustainable development’in operational terms. This paper looks at the problems ofattempting to ask whether peasant farming systems are sustainable.Any attempt at sustainability assessment needs to consider issuesrelated to the selected indicators or performance criteria, spatialscale or boundaries, and temporal scale. While there is certainlya need for more rigorous analysis of sustainability issues, thereis limited outlook for an approach based on indicators. Even if themany purely technical problems associated with specific indicatorscan be surmounted, will accurate bio-physical data advance ourknowledge about sustainability? Peasant systems arepolitically-guided management systems, whose boundaries are the state,not the field or the farm. Given the dynamic nature of peasant farmingsystems, where do we draw the line in assessing sustainability?Attempts at sustainability assessment 100 years ago or even 20–30years ago would have been completely superseded by events. We drawattention to the system as a whole, to a web of interconnections,causes and effects – of varying significance over both time andspace.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Abel, N.O.J.& Blaikie, P.M. (1989). Land degradation, stocking rates and conservation policies in the communal rangelands of Botswana and Zimbabwe, Land Degradation and Development 1: 101–123.
Allen, P.L. & Sachs, C.E. (1992). The poverty of sustainability: An analysis of current positions, Agriculture and Human Values 9(4): 29–35. f ai]Anderson, I.P., Brinn, P.J., Moyo, M. & Nyamwanza, B. (1993). Physical resource inventory of the communal lands of Zimbabwe: An overview. Chatham, UK: Natural Resources Institute, Bulletin 60.
Ashworth, V.A. (1990). Agricultural technology and the communal farm sector.Main report. Background paper prepared for Zimbabwe Agricultural Sector Memorandum. Washington, DC: The World Bank, Agriculture Division, Southern Africa Department.
Beinart, W. (1984). Soil erosion, conservation and ideas about development: A southern African exploration, 1900-1960, Journal of Southern African Studies 11: 52–83.
Bradley, P.N. & Dewees, P.A. (1993). Indigenous woodlands: Agricultural production and household economies in the communal areas, in P. Bradley & K. McNamara (eds.), Living with trees: Policies for forestry management in Zimbabwe (pp. 63–95). Washington, DC: World Bank, Technical Paper, No. 210.
Bratton, M. (1987). Drought, food and the social organization of small farmers in Zimbabwe, in M. H. Glentz (ed.), Drought and hunger in Africa: Denying famine a future. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Brinn, P.J., Black, H.I.J., Spurway, J.K.R. & Mzezewa, J. (1993). Land micro-variability in southwest Zimbabwe. Paper presented to SADC Land and Water Management Research Programme, 4th Annual Conference, Windhoek, Namibia.
Campbell, B.M., Frost, P., Kirchmann, H. & Swift, M.J. (in press, b). A survey of soil fertility management in smallscale farming systems in northern eastern Zimbabwe, Journal of Sustainable Development.
Campbell, B.M., Grundy, I.M. & Matose, F. (1993). Tree and woodland resources-the technical practices of small-scale farmers, in P. Bradley & K. McNamara (eds.), Living with trees: Policies for forestry management in Zimbabwe (pp. 29–62). Washington, DC:World Bank, Technical Paper, No. 210.
Campbell, B.M., Swift, M.J., Frost, P. & Kirchmann, H. (in press, a). Comparative ecosystem characteristics of a miombo woodland and an adjacent maize field (Zimbabwe), in L. Bergston & H. Kirchman (eds.), Carbon and nitrogen dynamics in agricultural and natural tropical systems. London: CABI.
Carter, S.E., Chidiamassamba, A. & Jeranyama, P. et al. (1992). Soil fertility management in Mutoko Communal Area, Zimbabwe. Nairobi, Kenya: Tropical Soil Biology and Fertility Programme, 78 pp.
Carter, S.E. & Murwira, H. (1995). Spatial variability in soil fertility management and crop responses inMutoko Communal Area, Zimbabwe, Ambio 24: 77–84.
Chemistry and Soil Research Institute (1974). Annual report 1973/74. Salisbury, Rhodesia: Department of Research and Specialist Services, Ministry of Agriculture, 65 pp.
Cliffe, L. (1992). Towards agrarian transformation in southern Africa, in A. Seidman, K. Mwanza, N. Simelane & D. Weiner (eds.), Transforming Southern African Agriculture (pp. 53–68). New Jersey: Africa World Press.
Conway, G. (1985). Agroecosystem analysis, Agric. Admin. 20: 31–55.
Dover, M. & Talbot, L.M. (1987). To feed the earth: Agroecology for sustainable development. Washington, DC: World Resources Institute.
Drinkwater, M.J. (1991). The state and Agrarian change in Zimbabwe's communal areas: An application of critical theory. London: Macmillan.
Elwell, R.H. (1983). The degrading soil and water resources of the communal areas, Zimbabwe Sci. News 17: 147.
Elwell, R.H. (1984). Soil loss estimation: Amodeling technique, in R.F. Hadley & D.E. Walling (eds.), Erosion and sediment yield: Some methods of measurement and modelling (pp. 15–36). Norwich: Geobooks.
Elwell, R.H. (1985). An assessment of soil erosion in Zimbabwe, Zimbabwe Sci. News22: 79–82.
Elwell, H. & Stocking, M.A. (1984). Estimating soil life-span for conservation planning, Trop. Agric. 61: 148–150.
Esbjomson, C.D. (1992). Once and future farming: Some meditations on the historical and cultural roots of sustainable agriculture in the United States, Agriculture and Human Values 9(3): 20–30.
Frost, P., Medina, E., Menaut, J.C., Solbrig, O. Swift, M. & B. (1986). Responses of savannas to stress and disturbances Biologynternational, Special Issue 10. Paris: International Union of Biological Sciences.
George, K.P. (1992). Sustainability and the moral community, Agriculture and Human Values 9(4): 48–57.
Hagmann, J. (1996). Mechanical soil conservation with contour ridges: cure for, or cause of, rill erosion: Which alternatives?, Land Degradation and Development 7 (in press).
Harp, A. & Sachs, C.E. (1992). Public agricultural researchers: reactions to organic, low input and sustainable agriculture, Agriculture and Human Values 9(4): 58–71.
Haynes, R.P. (1992). From the editor, Agriculture and Human Values9(3): 1–3.
Larson, W.E. & Pierce, F.J. (1992). Conservation and enhancement of soil quality, in C.R. Elliot, M. Latham & J. Dumanski (eds.), Evaluation for sustainable land management in the developing world, Vol. 2, Technical Papers. Bangkok, Thailand: IBSRAM Proceedings 12.
Lynam, J.K. & Herdt, R.W. (1989). Sense and sustainability: Sustainability as an objective in international agricultural research, Agric. Econ. 3: 381–398.
McGregor, J. (1991). Woodland resources: Ecology, policy and ideology. PhD thesis. Loughborough: University of Loughborough.
Page, S.L. & Page, J.H.E. (1991) Western hegemony over African agriculture in Southern Rhodesia and its continuing threat to food security in independent Zimbabwe, Agriculture and Human Values8: 3–18.
Pearce, D., Barbier, E. & Markandya, A. (1990). Sustainable development. London: Earthscan.
Redclift, M. (1987). Sustainable development. London: Methuen.
Redclift, M. (1991). The multiple dimensions of sustainable development, Geography: 36–41.
Roberts, N. & Lambert, R. (1990). Degradation of dambo soils and peasant agriculture in Zimbabwe, in J. Boardman, I.D.L. Foster & J.A. Dearing (eds.), Soil erosion on agricultural land (pp. 537–558). Chichester: Wiley.
Scoones, I.C. (1990). Livestock populations and the household economy: A case study from southern Zimbabwe. PhDthesis. London: University of London.
Scoones, I.C. (1992) The economic value of livestock in the communal areas of Southern Zimbabwe, Agric. Syst. 39: 339–359.
Shumba, E.M. (1984). Reduced tillage in the communal areas, Zimbabwe Agric. J. 81: 235–239.
Soussan, J.G. (1992). Sustainable development, in A.M. Mannion & S.R. Bowlby (eds.), Environmental issues in the 1990s (pp. 21–36). London: Wiley.
Spenser, D.S.C. & Swift, M.J. (1991). Biodiversity and ecosystem function: Definition and measurement, in K. Mulongoy, M. Gueye & D.S.C. Spenser (eds.), Biology nitrogen fixation and the sustainability of tropical agriculture. Chichester: Wiley.
Stocking, M. (1986). The cost of soil erosion in Zimbabwein terms of the loss of three major nutrients. Rome: FAO.
Swift, M.J. & Woomer, P. (1993). Organic matter and the sustainability of agricultural systems: definition and measurement, in K. Mulongoy & R. Merckx (eds.), Soil organic matter dynamics and sustainability of tropical agriculture (pp. 3–18). Chichester: Wiley.
Thomspon, P.B. (1992). The varieties of sustainability, Agriculture and Human Values9(3): 11–19.
Vermeulen, S.J., Woomer, P., Campbell, B.M. & Kamukondiwa, W. (1993). Use of the SCUAF model to simulate natural miombo woodland and maize monoculture systems in Zimbabwe, Agroforestry Systems 22: 259–271.
Vogel, H. (1991). Sheet erosion from sandveld soils under conservation tillage in Zimbabwe, in Conservation tillage for sustainable crop production systems. Harare: Department of Agricultural Technical and Extension Services.
Weiner, D. & Harris, T. (1992). Agricultural Development in Zimbabwe: Transition in a labor reserve economy, in A. Seidman, K. Mwanza, N. Simelane & D. Weiner (eds.), Transforming Southern African agriculture (pp. 131–160). New Jersey: Africa World Press.
Whitlow, J.R. (1980). Deforestation in Zimbabwe. Zambezia Supplement, Salisbury, pp. 1–35.
Wilson, K.B. (1990). Ecological dynamics and human welfare: A case study of population, health and nutrition in Southern Zimbabwe. PhD thesis. London: University of London.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Campbell, B., Bradley, P. & Carter, S. Sustainability and peasant farming systems: Observations from Zimbabwe. Agriculture and Human Values 14, 159–168 (1997). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1007358823524
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1007358823524