Abstract
Identifying process from pattern is one of the most vexing tasks inenvironmental monitoring. Given information on the distribution of speciesin a pre-defined area, together with comprehensive data on how environmentalconditions in that area have altered through time, is it possible toidentify the factors controlling the species‘ layout? Here, the practicalsignificance of this quandary is demonstrated using a series ofenvironmentally-degraded coastal lagoons in New South Wales. The TuggerahLakes (33°17′S,151°30′E) have over the last 50 yearsexperienced significant changes in species‘ distributions. Seagrasses,macroalgae, phytoplankton, molluscs, prawns and the jellyfish Catostylus mosaicus have altered in spatial pattern. Two human activitieshave been blamed for these perturbations: (1) agricultural clearance ofnative vegetation from the catchment, with associated input of top-soil andnutrients; (2) the commissioning of a coal-fired power station in 1967, withmassive uptake and recirculation of lake water for cooling purposes. In thispaper, spatial changes in macrophyte distributions over the last 50 yearsare reviewed in an attempt to identify the true source(s) of perturbation.The model adopted assumes that the power station is a point source of impactwhile nutrient inputs from the catchment are a diffuse source of impact;changes in species distributions can hypothetically be related back to thesesources according to whether they are localised or widespread. However,after a comprehensive analysis of available macrophyte data derived frominterviews, aerial photography and line transect methodologyies theconclusion is reached that changes in biogeographical pattern around theTuggerah Lakes cannot be attributed to specific anthropogenic pressures atanything beyond the coarsest of levels. This is considered to be the normfor most coastal management situations where natural background variation(’noise‘) and the complexity of linkages between physical, chemical andbiological components confounds the identification of causal relationships.The practical implications of this conclusion are discussed in the contextof litigation and remedial management design. Emphasis is placed on theneed to adopt an adaptive approach to estuarine management, incorporatingexplicit recognition of the limitations of available data, and to developnew techniques for identifying cause-effect relationships.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Batley, G. E., Body, N., Cook, B., Dibb, L., Fleming, P. M., Skyring, G., Boon, P., Mitchell, D. and Sinclair, R.: 1990, The Ecology of the Tuggerah Lakes System. A Review: with special reference to the impact of the Munmorah Power Station. Canberra, ACT: CSIRO Division of Water Resources.
Batley, G. E. and Brockbank, C. I.: 1992, Environmental Studies of Munmorah Power Station. Sydney, NSW: CSIRO Division of Coal and Energy Technology.
Boreman, J. and Goodyear, C. P.: 1988, ‘Estimates of entrainment mortality for striped bass and other fish species inhabiting the Hudson River estuary’. Amer. Fish. Soc. Monogr. 4, 152–;160.
Cheng, D.: 1987, Studies on the release of nutrients from sediment cores collected from Long Jetty, Tuggerah Lakes. Entrance, NSW: Wyong Shire Council.
Coulter, C. G.: 1983, Report on the effect of heated water discharges from power stations on the environments of Lake Macquarie and Tuggerah Lakes. Sydney, NSW: Pacific Power Development Division.
Dunsmuir, W. T. M.: 1982, Time Series Analysis of Tuggerah Lakes: Book 1, Sydney, NSW: SIROMATH Pty Ltd.
Higginson, F. R.: 1968. The ecology of submerged aquatic angiosperms within the Tuggerah Lakes system, Sydney, NSW: PhD thesis, Univ. Sydney.
Higginson, F. R.: 1970, ‘Ecological effects of pollution in Tuggerah Lakes’. Proc. Ecol. Soc. Aust. 5, 143–;152.
Justic, D.: 1987, ‘Long-term eutrophication of the northern Adriatic Sea’. Mar. Poll. Bull. 18, 281–;284.
King, R. J. and Hodgson, B. R.: 1986, ‘Aquatic angiosperms in coastal saline lagoons of New South Wales III. Quantitative assessment of Zostera capricorni’. Proc. Linn. Soc. NSW. 109, 51–;60.
Lavery, P. S., Lukatelich, R. J. and McComb, A. J.: 1991, ‘Changes in the biomass and species composition of macroalgae in a eutrophic estuary’. Est. Coast. Shelf Sci. 33, 1–;22.
Mance, G.: 1987, Pollution Threat of Heavy Metals in Aquatic Environments, London: Elsevier Applied Science.
Marcy, B. C. Jr.: 1971, ‘Survival of young fish in the discharge canal of a nuclear power plant’, J. Fish. Res. Bd. Canada, 28, 1057–;1060.
Naylor, E.: 1965, ‘Effects of heated effluents upon marine and estuarine organisms’, Advan. Mar. Biol. 3, 63–;103.
Norris, R. H., Hart, B. T., Finlayson, M. and Norris, K. R. (eds.): 1995, Use of biota to assess water quality. Special edition of the Australian Journal of Ecology. Volume 20,Number 1 March 1995. 227 pp.
Osenberg, C. W., Schmitt, R. J., Holbrook, S. J., Abu-Saba, K. E. and Flegal, A. R.: 1994, ‘Detection of environmental impacts: natural variability, effect size, and power analysis’. Ecol. Applic. 4, 16–;30.
Patrick, R. and Palavage, D. M.: 1994, ‘The value of species as indicators of water quality’. Proc. Acad. Nat. Sci. Philadelphia 145, 55–;92.
Phillips, R. C. and McRoy, C. P. (eds.): 1980, Handbook of Seagrass Biology: an ecosystem perspective, New York: Garland.
Powis, B. J.: 1975, The Benthic Fauna of the Tuggerah Lakes, Sydney, NSW: Univ. New South Wales.
Powis, B. J. and Robinson, K. I. M.: 1980, ‘Benthic macrofaunal communities in the Tuggerah Lakes’, New South Wales. Aust. J. Mar. Freshwater Res. 31, 803–;815.
Rosenberg, R.: 1985, ‘Eutrophication — the future marine coastal nuisance?’, Mar. Poll. Bull. 16, 227–;231.
Ruello, N. V.: 1978, Report on studies on the impact of the Munmorah Power Station on the Tuggerah Lakes prawns and fishes, Sydney, NSW: State Fisheries Dept.
Thorhaug, A., Segar, D. and Roessler, M. A.: 1973, ‘Impact of a power plant on a subtropical estuarine environment’, Mar. Poll. Bull. 4, 166–;169.
Thresher, A., Ward, T. and Crossland, C.: 1993, An assessment of the impacts of Munmorah Power Station on the fauna of the Tuggerah Lakes, Hobart, TAS: CSIRO Division of Fisheries.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Kennedy, A.D. Biological complexity confounds the separation of point- and non-point sources of human impact on the natural world. Environ Monit Assess 48, 173–192 (1997). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1005704720545
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1005704720545