Abstract
Twenty years ago, the biopsychosocial model was proposed by George Engel to be the new paradigm for medicine and psychiatry. The model assumed a hierarchical structure of the biological, psychological and social system and simple interactions between the participating systems. This article holds the thesis that the original biopsychosocial model cannot depict psychiatry's reality and problems. The clinical validity of the biopsychosocial model has to be questioned. It is argued that psychiatric interventions can only stimulate but not determine their target systems, because intervention and outcome are only loosely coupled. Thus, psychiatric interventions have in principle limited ranges which differ according to the type of intervention and according to the system to be stimulated. Psychosocial interventions face far more obstacles to be overcome than psychopharmacogical therapy.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Anderson, N.B. and C.A. Armstead: 1995, ‘Toward understanding the association of socioeconomic status and health: A new challenge for the biopsychosocial model’, Psychosomatic Medicine 57, 213–225.
Birchwood, M., P. McGorry and H. Jackson: 1997, ‘Early intervention in schizophrenia’, British Journal of Psychiatry 170, 2–5.
Bury, M.: 1991, ‘The sociology of chronic illness: A review of research and prospects’, Sociology of Health and Illness 13, 451–468.
Conrad, P.: 1992, ‘Medicalisation and social control’, Annual Review of Sociology 18, 209–232.
Eikelmann, B.: 1997, Sozialpsychiatrisches Basiswissen. Grundlagen und Praxis. Stuttgart: Enke.
Engel, G.L.: 1977, ‘The need for a new medical model: A challenge for biomedicine’, Science 196, 129–136.
Engel, G.L.: 1981, ‘The clinical application of the biopsychosocial model’, Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 6, 101–123.
Engel, G.L.: 1982, ‘The biopsychosocial model and medical education: Who are to be the teachers?’, New England Journal of Medicine 306, 802–805.
Engel, G.L.: 1992, ‘How much longer must medicine's science be bound by a seventeenth century world view?’, Psychotherapy and Psychosomatics 57, 3–16.
Engel, G.L.: 1997, ‘From biomedical to biopsychosocial: Being scientific in the human domain’, Psychosomatics 38, 521–528.
Fairhurst, K., M. Blair, J. Cutting, M. Featherstone, B. Hayes, M. Howarth, D. Rose and I. Stanley: 1996, ‘The quality of hospital discharge. A survey of discharge arrangements for the over-65s’, International Journal of Quality in Health Care 8, 167–174.
Feinberg, T.E.: 1997, ‘The irreducible perspectives of consciousness’, Seminars in Neurology 17, 85–93.
Freedman, A.M.: 1995, ‘The biopsychosocial paradigm and the future of psychiatry’, Comprehensive Psychiatry 36, 397–406.
Haselbeck, H.: 1990, ‘Sozialpsychiatrie und das biologische Krankheitsmodell. Von der Konfrontation zur Integration’, In: A. Thom and E. Wulff (eds.), Psychiatrie im Wandel. Erfahrungen und Perspektiven in Ost und West. Bonn: Psychiatrie-Verlag, pp. 13–21.
Hastedt, H.: 1988, Das Leib-Seele-Problem. Zwischen Naturwissenschaft des Geistes und kultureller Eindimensionalität. Frankfurt/M.: Suhrkamp.
Kandel, E.R.: 1989, ‘Genes, nerve cells, and the remembrance of things past’, Journal of Neuropsychiatry 1, 103–125.
Kandel, E.R.: 1998, ‘A new intellectual framework for psychiatry’, American Journal of Psychiatry 155, 457–469.
Kendler, K.S.: 1997, ‘The genetic epidemiology of psychiatric disorders’, Social Psychiatry and Psychiatric Epidemiology 32, 5–11.
Liberman, R.P.: 1994, ‘Psychosocial treatments for schizophrenia’, Psychiatry 57, 104–114.
Luhmann, N.: 1997, Die Gesellschaft der Gesellschaft. Frankfurt/ M.: Suhrkamp.
Mai, F.M.: 1995, ‘Clinical and basic science aspects of the biopsychosocial model’, Journal Psychiatry and Neuroscience 20, 335–336 (Editorial).
Maturana, H. and F. Varela: 1993, Der Baum der Erkenntnis. Wie wir die Welt durch die Wahrnehmung erschaffen - die biologischen Wurzeln des menschlichen Erkennens, 3rd edn. Bern/München/Wien: Scherz.
Mechanic, D.: 1986, ‘The challenge of chronic mental illness: A retrospective and prospective view’, Hospital and Community Psychiatry 37, 891–896.
Mechanic, D.: 1995, ‘Sociological dimensions of illness behavior’, Social Science and Medicine 41, 1207–1216.
Mechanic, D. and L. Aiken: 1987, ‘Improving the care of patients with chronic mental illness’, New England Journal of Medicine 317, 1634–1638.
Metzinger, T.: 1993, Subjekt und Selbstmodell. Die Perspektivität phänomenalen Bewußtseins vor dem Hintergrund einer naturalistischen Theorie mentaler Repräsentation. Paderborn etc.: Schöningh.
Milner, B., L.R. Squire and E.R. Kandel: 1998, ‘Cognitive neuroscience and the study of memory’, Neuron 20, 445–468.
Monti, P.M., S. Bird Gulliver and M.G. Myers: 1994, ‘Social skills training for alcoholics: Assessment and treatment’, Alcohol and Alcoholism 29, 627–637.
Paris, J.: 1996, ‘Antisocial personality disorder: A biopsychosocial model’, Canadian Journal of Psychiatry 41, 75–80.
Picton, T.W. and D.T. Stuss: 1994, ‘Neurobiology and conscious experience’, Current Opinion in Neurobiology 4, 256–265.
Rabinowitz, J., M. Mark, M. Popper and M. Sluyzberg: 1995, ‘Predicting revolving-door patients in a 9–year national sample’, Social Psychiatry and Psychiatric Epidemiology 30, 65–72.
Ram, R., E.J. Bromet, W.W. Eaton, et al.: 1992, ‘The natural course of schizophrenia: A review of first-admission studies’, Schizophrenia Bulletin 18, 185–207.
Richter, D., K. Berger and B. Eikelmann: ‘Was bestimmt den psychiatrischen Problempatienten? Ergebnisse einer Untersuchung zur Patienteneinstufung in der Psychiatrie-Personalverordnung’, Fortschritte der Neurologie und Psychiatrie (in press).
Rössler, W., H.J. Salize, U. Biechele and A. Riecher-Rössler: 1994, ‘Stand und Entwicklung der psychiatrischen Versorgung. Ein europäischer Vergleich’, Nervenarzt 65, 427–437.
Sadler, J.Z. and Y.F. Hulgus: 1990, ‘Knowing, valuing, acting: Clues to revising the biopsychosocial model’, Comprehensive Psychiatry 31, 185–195.
Sadler, J.Z. and Y.F. Hulgus: 1992, ‘Clinical problem solving and the biopsychosocial model’, American Journal of Psychiatry 149, 1315–1323.
Schmid, S.: 1981, Freiheit heilt. Bericht über die demokratische Psychiatrie in Italien. Berlin: Wagenbach.
Schrott, L.M.: 1997, ‘Effect of training and environment on brain morphology’, Acta Paediatrica 422(Supplement), 45–47.
Scott, A.: 1995, Stairway to the Mind: The Controversial New Science of Consciousness. New York: Copernicus.
Veggeberg, S.K.: 1996, Medication of the Mind. New York: Henry Holt.
Weiner, H.: 1994, ‘Ist das ‘biopsychosoziale Modell’ ein hilfreiches Konstrukt?’, Psychotherapie Psychosomatik medizinische Psychologie 44, 73–83.
Wilkinson, R.G.: 1996, Unhealthy Societies. The Afflictions of Inequality. London/New York: Routledge.
Willke, H.: 1987, ‘Strategien der Intervention in autonome Systeme’, in: D. Baecker et al. (eds.), Theorie als Passion. Frankfurt/M.: Suhrkamp.
Zimmermann, C. and M. Tansella: 1996, ‘Psychosocial factors and physical illness in primary care: Promoting the biopsychosocial model in medical practice’, Journal of Psychosomatic Research 40, 351–358.
Zubin, J and B. Spring: 1977, ‘Vulnerability - A new view of schizophrenia’, Journal of Abnormal Psychology 86, 103–126
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Richter, D. Chronic mental illness and the limits of the biopsychosocial model. Med Health Care Philos 2, 21–30 (1999). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1009968106317
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1009968106317