From Knowing to Doing: Integrating Systems-Ready Physician Competencies in the Clerkship Setting

Abstract

There are increasing calls to graduate physicians with a strong understanding of health systems science (HSS). Many schools have incorporated didactics on health systems science content such as quality improvement, patient safety, or interprofessional education. Creating a systems-ready physician requires more than teaching content in classroom settings. Using Miller’s pyramid of assessment of clinical performance, we have developed strategies to move our learners from the cognitive-based “knows” level to the behavior-based “does” level of understanding of the HSS competencies. Our medical students begin learning HSS in classroom settings. Next, the students apply this knowledge during their core clerkships. This gives them an opportunity to get feedback increasingly from high-fidelity clinical settings.

We embedded assessment strategies and tools in the clerkship year to facilitate the demonstration, observation, and assessment of HSS competencies in the setting of our core clerkships. We also have students self-assess their competence in our graduation competencies at the end of each year. Student self-assessment from the beginning of the clerkship year to the end showed significant increases in the HSS competencies. Our clerkship student assessment data from our first cohort suggest that faculty had difficulty observing and assessing some of the competencies unique to health systems science. The clerkships have developed multiple projects and assignments to allow students to demonstrate HSS competencies. Faculty and resident training to prompt, observe, and assess these competencies is ongoing to close the assessment gap. In the area of professionalism, student self-assessment and faculty clinical assessment correlate strongly.