Advertisement

Monash Bioethics Review

, Volume 34, Issue 3–4, pp 189–205 | Cite as

Does organ selling violate human dignity?

  • Zümrüt Alpinar-Şencan
  • Holger Baumann
  • Nikola Biller-Andorno
Original Article

Abstract

Shortages in the number of donated organs after death and the growing number of end-stage organ failure patients on waiting lists call for looking at alternatives to increase the number of organs that could be used for transplantation purposes. One option that has led to a legal and ethical debate is to have regulated markets in human organs. Opponents of a market in human organs offer different arguments that are mostly founded on contingent factors that can be adjusted. However, some authors have asked the question whether we still have a reason to believe that there is something wrong with offering human organs for sale for transplantation purposes, even if the circumstances under which the practice takes place are improved. One prominent argument regarding this appeals to the notion of human dignity. It is argued that organ selling violates human dignity. This paper presents a systematic discussion of dignity-based arguments in the organ selling debate, and then develops a social account of dignity. It is argued that allowing the practice of organ selling inherently runs the risk of promoting the notion that some persons have less worth than others and that persons have a price, which is incompatible with dignity. The approach is defended against possible objections and it is shown that it can capture the notion that autonomy is linked to human dignity in important ways, while dignity at the same time can constrain the autonomous choices of persons with regards to certain practices.

Keywords

Autonomy Dignity Dignity as a constraint Dignity as empowerment Organ donation Organ markets Organ selling 

Notes

Acknowledgements

We would like to thank Dr. iur. Roberto Andorno for his valuable comments and suggestions. This research is a part of the project entitled “Human Dignity and Autonomy – The Limits of Self-Ownership” that is supported by the University of Zurich Research Priority Program for Ethics (URPP for Ethics) and the Swiss National Science Foundation (SNSF).

References

  1. Andorno, R. 2011. Four paradoxes of human dignity. In Menschenwürde und moderne medizintechnik, ed. J. Joerden, E. Hilgendorf, N. Petrillo, and F. Thiele, 131–140. Interdiszipliniäre studien zu recht und staadt; n 50. Baden-Baden: Nomos-Verlag.Google Scholar
  2. Beyleveld, D., and R. Brownsword. 1998. Human dignity, human rights, and human genetics. The Modern Law Review 61 (5): 661–680.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  3. Beyleveld, D., and R. Brownsword. 2004. Human dignity in bioethics and biolaw. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
  4. Biller-Andorno, N., and Z. Alpinar. 2014. Organ trafficking and transplant tourism. In Handbook of global bioethics, ed. H.A.M.J. ten Have, and B. Gordijn, 771–783. Dordrecht: Springer.Google Scholar
  5. Bole, T.J. 1999. The sale of organs and obligations to one’s body: Inferences from the history of ethics. In Persons and their bodies: Rights, responsibilities, relationships, ed. M.J. Cherry, 331–350. Philoosphy and medicine, Vol. 60. Dordrecht: Kluwer.Google Scholar
  6. Boyle, J. 1999. Personal responsibility and freedom in health care: A contemporary natural law perspective. In Persons and their bodies: Rights, responsibilities, relationships, ed. M.J. Cherry, 111–141. Philoosphy and medicine, vol 60. Dordrecht: Kluwer.Google Scholar
  7. Brennan, J., and P.M. Jaworski. 2015. Markets without symbolic limits. Ethics 125: 1053–1077.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  8. Budiani-Saberi, D.A., and F.L. Delmonico. 2008. Organ trafficking and transplant tourism: A commentary on the global realities. American Journal of Transplantation 8 (5): 925–929.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  9. Cherry, M.J. 2005. Kidney for sale by owner: Human organs, transplantation, and the market. Washington, D.C.: Georgetown University Press.Google Scholar
  10. Cohen, C.B. 1999. Selling bits and pieces of humans to make babies: The gift of the magi revisited. The Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 24 (3): 288–306.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  11. Cohen, C.B. 2002. Public policy and the sale of human organs. Kennedy Institute of Ethics Journal 12 (1): 47–64.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  12. Council of Europe/United Nations. 2009. Trafficking in organs, tissues and cells and trafficking in human beings for the purpose of the removal of organs. Joint study of Council of Europe/United Nations. Strasbourg: Council of Europe/United Nations.Google Scholar
  13. Daar, A.S. 2006. The case for a regulated system of living kidney sales. Nature Clinical Practice Nephrology 2 (11): 600–601.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  14. de Castro, L.D. 2003. Commodification and exploitation: Arguments in favour of compensated organ donation. Journal of Medical Ethics 29 (3): 142–146.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  15. George, L.K. 1998. Dignity and quality of life. Journal of Gerontological Social Work 29 (2–3): 39–52.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  16. Gerrand, N. 1999. The misuse of Kant in the debate about a market for human body parts. Journal of Applied Philosophy 16 (1): 59–67.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  17. Gewirth, A. 1992. Human dignity as the basis of rights. In The constitution of rights: Human dignity and American values, ed. M.J. Meyer, and W.A. Parent, 10–28. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.Google Scholar
  18. Gill, M.B., and R.M. Sade. 2002. Paying for kidneys: The case against prohibition. Kennedy Institute of Ethics Journal 12 (1): 17–45.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  19. Goyal, M., R.L. Mehta, L.J. Schneiderman, and A.R. Sehgal. 2002. Economic and health consequences of selling a kidney in India. JAMA 288 (13): 1589–1593.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  20. Heubel, F., and N. Biller-Andorno. 2005. The contribution of kantian moral theory to contemporary medical ethics: A critical analysis. Medicine, Health Care and Philosophy 8 (1): 5–18.Google Scholar
  21. Hill, T.E., and A. Zweig, eds. 2002. Editor’s introduction: Some main themes of the groundwork. In Groundwork for the metaphysics of morals, ed. T.E. Hill and A. Zweig, 19–108 (trans: Zweig, A.). New York: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
  22. Jacobson, N. 2007. Dignity and health: A review. Social Science and Medicine 64 (2): 292–302.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  23. Jacobson, N. 2009. A taxonomy of dignity: A grounded theory study. BMC International Health and Human Rights 9 (1): 3.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  24. Joseph, J. 2006. Selling with dignity: Organ selling and the safeguarding of human dignity. Penn Bioethics Journal 2 (1): 16–19.Google Scholar
  25. Kant, I. 1996. The Metaphysics of Morals (M. Gregor, Trans., Ed.). New York: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
  26. Kant, I. 1997. Lectures on Ethics (P. Heath, trans., P. Heath and J.B. Schneewind, eds.). New York: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
  27. Kant, I. 2002. Groundwork for the metaphysics of morals (A. Zweig, Trans., T.E. Hill and A. Zweig, eds. New York: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
  28. Kass, L.R. 2002. Life, liberty and the defense of dignity: The challenge for bioethics. New York: Encounter Books.Google Scholar
  29. Kaufmann, P., H. Kuch, C. Neuhauser, and E. Webster. 2011. Human dignity violated: A negative approach—introduction. In Humiliation, degradation, dehumanization: Human dignity violated, ed. P. Kaufmann, H. Kuch, C. Neuhauser, and E. Webster, 1–5. Library of ethics and applied philosophy, Vol. 24. Dordrecht: Springer.Google Scholar
  30. Kerstein, S.J. 2009. Kantian condemnation of commerce in organs. Kennedy Institute of Ethics Journal 19 (2): 147–169.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  31. Macklin, R. 2003. Dignity is a useless concept. British Medical Journal (BMJ) 327 (7429): 1419–1420.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  32. Margalit, A. 1998. The decent society (N. Goldblum, Trans.). Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
  33. Morelli, M. 1999. Commerce in organs: A Kantian critique. Journal of Social Philosophy 30 (2): 315–324.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  34. Naqvi, S.A.A., B. Ali, F. Mazhar, M.N. Zafar, and S.A.H. Rizvi. 2007. A socioeconomic survey of kidney vendors in Pakistan. Transplant International 20 (11): 934–939.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  35. Nordenfelt, L. 2004. The varieties of dignity. Health Care Analysis 12 (2): 69–81.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  36. Phadke, K.D., and U. Anandh. 2002. Ethics of paid organ donation. Pediatric Nephrology 17 (5): 309–311.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  37. Pinker, S. 2008. The stupidity of dignity: Conservative bioethics’ latest, most dangerous ploy. The New Republic 238: 28–31.Google Scholar
  38. Radcliffe-Richards, J. 2013. The ethics of transplants: Why careless thought costs lives, 1st paperback ed. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
  39. Radcliffe-Richards, J., A.S. Daar, R.D. Guttmann, R. Hoffenberg, I. Kennedy, M. Lock, R.A. Sells, N. Tilney, and for the International Forum for Transplant Ethics. 2006. The case for allowing kidney sales. In Bioethics: An anthology, ed. H. Kuhse and P. Singer, 487–490, 2nd ed. Oxford: Blackwell.Google Scholar
  40. Rid, A., L. M. Bachman, V. Wettstein, and N. Biller-Andorno. 2009. Would you sell a kidney in a regulated kidney market? Results of an exploratory study. Journal of Medical Ethics 35 (9): 558–564.Google Scholar
  41. Sandel, M.J. 2012. What money can’t buy: The moral limits of markets, 1st ed. New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux.Google Scholar
  42. Schachter, O. 1983. Human dignity as a normative concept. The American Journal of International Law 77 (4): 848–854.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  43. Scheper-Hughes, N. 2003. Keeping an eye on the global traffic in human organs. The Lancet 361 (9369): 1645–1648.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  44. Schroeder, D. 2008. Dignity: Two riddles and four concepts. Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics 17 (2): 230–238.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  45. Smith, A.L., Jr. 1999. An orthodox Christian view of persons and their bodies. In Persons and their bodies: Rights, responsibilities, relationships, ed. M.J. Cherry, 95–108. Philosophy and medicine, vol 60. Dordrecht: Kluwer.Google Scholar
  46. Stempsey, W.E. 2000. Organ markets and human dignity: On selling your body and soul. Christian Bioethics 6 (2): 195–204.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  47. Sulmasy, D.P. 2009. Dignity and bioethics: History, theory, and selected applications. In Human dignity and bioethics, ed. E.D. Pellegrino, A. Schulman, and T.W. Merrill, 469–501. Notre Dame: University of Notre Dame Press.Google Scholar
  48. Taylor, J.S. 2005. Stakes and kidneys: Why markets in human body pars are morally imperative. Aldershot: Ashgate.Google Scholar
  49. UNESCO. 2005. Universal declaration on bioethics and human rights [Electronic version]. http://unesdoc.unesco.org/images/0014/001461/146180e.pdf. Retrieved 21 Dec 2011.
  50. United Nations. 1948. The universal declaration of human rights [Electronic version]. http://www.un.org/en/documents/udhr/. Retrieved 4 Nov 2014.
  51. Wilkinson, S. 2003. Bodies for sale: Ethics and exploitation in the human body trade. London: Routledge.Google Scholar
  52. Wilkinson, S., and E. Garrard. 1996. Bodily integrity and the sale of human organs. Journal of Medical Ethics 22 (6): 334–339.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  53. World Health Organization. 2010. WHO guiding principles on human cell, tissue and organ transplantation. Transplantation 90 (3): 229–233.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  54. Zargooshi, J. 2001. Quality of life of Iranian kidney donors. The Journal of Urology 166 (5): 1790–1799.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Monash University 2017

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Institute of Biomedical Ethics and History of MedicineUniversity of ZurichZurichSwitzerland
  2. 2.The Center for EthicsUniversity of ZurichZurichSwitzerland

Personalised recommendations