Dye-modified ZnO nanohybrids: optical properties of the potential solar cell nanocomposites
We report the hybridization of ZnO with natural dyes [Laali, Zobo] or synthetic dye [methyl red] forming ZnO–laali, ZnO–zobo and ZnO–methyl red nanocomposites in bright colours. The structural, optical and dye photosensitization influence of the hybrid nanocomposites were studied by X-ray diffraction (XRD), scanning electron microscope (SEM), UV–Visible absorption spectroscopy and photoluminescence (PL). The surface plasmon absorption band of ZnO–laali and ZnO–zobo shifts towards red and blue, respectively, with significantly enhanced absorption intensities, indicating the interaction and optical influence of the respective dyes in photosensitization. Optical and absorption character of ZnO methyl red and bare ZnO are similar indicating the insignificant effect of methyl red on photosensitization. PL spectra of ZnO–laali and ZnO–zobo display enhanced UV light emission due not only to the surface electron transfer from their respective inherent isoplumbagin and anthocyanin to ZnO but also to the extension of the Fermi energy level to the ZnO. Dyes adopted influence the optical band gaps of the evolved hybrid nanocomposites.
KeywordsZinc oxide nanohybrids Natural dyes (Zobo) Hibiscus sabdariffa (Laali bark) Lawsonia inermis Optical properties
Nanosized particles of semiconductor materials have gained much more interest in recent years due to their desirable properties and applications in different areas such as catalysts,  sensors,  photoelectron devices [3, 4], and highly functional and effective devices . These nanomaterials have novel electronic, structural, and thermal properties which are of high scientific interest in basic and applied fields. Zinc oxide (ZnO) is a wide band gap semiconductor with an energy gap of 3.37 eV at room temperature. It has been used considerably due to its catalytic, electrical, optoelectronic, and photochemical properties [4, 6, 7]. ZnO nanostructures have a great advantage when applied to catalytic reaction process. This is due to their large surface area and high catalytic activity . The excellent optical properties of ZnO have made it a useful semiconductor in Dye-Sensitised Solar Cell (DSSC); a third generation photovoltaic device that holds a significant promise for the inexpensive conversion of solar energy to electrical energy.
The use of dye sensitization in photovoltaics has received a great interest after the breakthrough achieved by Grätzel et al. , in the early 1990s. They developed a DSSC with energy conversion efficiency exceeding 7% in 1991  and 11.4% in 2001  by combining nanostructured electrodes to efficient charge injection dyes. Since then, TiO2 nano-particle films have been widely investigated for DSSCs. However, TiO2 films have some defects such as lack of enough energy barriers between the interface of the films and electrolytes. The existence of plenty of electron-trapped surface states is the cause of the re-combination . The photo-catalytic activity of TiO2 is so high under the UV radiation of natural sun-light that organic materials in DSSCs may decompose during out-door use, resulting in long-term reliability problems for the conversion efficiency. Hence, some investigations have been turned to ZnO films, which have a much lower photo-catalytic activity and less electron-trapped surface states . It has been reported that ZnO performs particularly well when sensitised with organic dyes . However, in spite of its synthesis simplicity and promising industrial value, ZnO/dye-sensitised solar cell is still far below the TiO2/dye cell which is more expensive to produce. Consequently, a lot of activity has been exercised of late to enhance the performance of ZnO/dye solar cell.
The dye that is used as a photosensitizer plays an important role in the operation of DSSCs. The function of dye is to absorb light, inject electrons from the redox mediator. Light harvesting dyes absorb solar radiation incident which results in the excitation of molecules, which pass the energy obtained by means of transferring electrons onto a nanocrystalline semiconductor substrate onto which they are adsorbed. The efficiency of the cell is critically dependent on the absorption spectrum of the dye and its anchorage on the surface of the semiconductor. Much work has concentrated on organic dyes and organic metal complexes. On the other hand, natural dyes extracted from fruits and flowers have attracted the attention of many researchers , and many natural dyes have been proven to be efficient dyes as photo-sensitizers in DSSCs. Natural dye is readily available and cheap, thus, making it environmental friendly with potential capacity to reduce the cost of DSSC devices. In particular, Laali, as popularly called, is grown in the savannah region of West Africa  and are used as colouring material in the designing of fashionable tattoos on human bodies. Lawsonia inermis (Laali) is a very popular natural dye used in colouring fingers, hands, nails and hair (in northern part of Nigeria). The pyhtochemical mainly found in Laali stem bark is called Isoplumbagin. Zobo (Hibiscus sabdarifa) richly contains anthocyanin pigment, and is responsible for its red or wine colour depending on whether it has structural attachment of glucose or not . Cyanidin-3-glucoside is a member of anthocyanin family .
In this work, ZnO–laali, ZnO–zobo or ZnO–methyl red was prepared for the purpose of an enhanced optical properties and photosensitization. In view of the limitation of inorganic solids, organic additives certainly play a crucial role in boosting electro-optical speed of DSSC. Methyl red, a photo-sensitive dichroic dye has also been considered in comparison with Laali and Zobo to photosensitize ZnO for enhanced optical properties.
Zinc nitrate hexahydrate, Zn(NO3)2·6H2O, methyl red and ethanol were commercially procured. Sodium hydroxide, NaOH was obtained from FUNAAB laboratory. All chemicals were of analytical grade unless otherwise stated.
Natural dye extraction
Preparation of Lawsonia inermis ‘Laali’ extract
Laali dye was extracted as described by Adenike et al. . Fresh Laali stem barks were collected at Lemomu Ayeni Street, Oluwo-Onikolobo, Abeokuta, Ogun State, Nigeria. The Laali barks were washed with distilled water and dried at 60 °C in the oven. Laboratory ceramic made mortar and pestle were used to crush the dried sample. 20 g of the dried sample was weighed and soaked in 200 mL solution of ethanol. This was left to age at room temperature in a dark place for 24 h. The solid residues were filtered out to obtain a clear greenish solution which was concentrated in a rotary evaporator.
Preparation of Hibiscus sabdariffa (zobo) extract
The Hibiscus sabdariffa (Zobo) dye was extracted according to literature method . Dried succulent red calyxes of (Hibiscus sabdariffa) were purchased from the market, washed, air-dried and grinded to powdery form using mortar and pestle. 20 g of the ground sample was then soaked in 200 mL distilled water for about 24 h. After extraction, the solution was filtered to obtain a clear wine colour.
The solution was then concentrated in a rotary evaporator. To prevent darkening, the concentrate obtained was stored in amber-coloured bottle.
Preparation of ZnO–dye
ZnO–methyl red dye
ZnO–methyl dye was prepared according to Taher et al.  with some slight modifications. 14.4 g Zinc nitrate hexahydrate was dissolved in 100 mL of ethanol under stirring at room temperature. Simultaneously, the prepared 0.36 M sodium hydroxide solution was added drop-wise. The solution was then sealed at this condition for 1 h.
0.25 g of powdered methyl red dye was dissolved in 100 mL of ethanol. 1.0 mL of this solution was added to white ZnO Nanoparticles (ZnO Nps) drop-wisely while the stirring continued for another 1 h. It was observed that the whole solution changed from white to pink at this point. The ZnO–methyl red dye solution was allowed to settle overnight. The supernatant solution was separated carefully. The remaining solution was centrifuged for 10 min and the precipitate was removed. The precipitated ZnO–methyl red dye solution was washed three times with distilled water and ethanol and then dried in the oven at about 80 °C. The resulting ZnO–methyl dye composite was then examined in terms of structural, chemical and optical properties .
ZnO–zobo (Hibiscus sabdarifa) dye nanocomposite
1.0 mL of concentrated Hibiscus sabdariffa extract was added to the stirring suspension of ZnO particles. It was observed that the whole solution turned blue and stirring continued for another 1 h. The ZnO–zobo dye solution was allowed to settle overnight. The supernatant solution was separated carefully. The remaining solution was centrifuged for 10 min, and the precipitate was removed. The precipitated ZnO–zobo dye solution was cleaned three times with distilled water and ethanol and then dried in the ovum at about 80 °C. The resulting ZnO–zobo nanopowder was then examined in terms of structural, chemical and optical properties.
ZnO–laali (Lawsonia inermis) dye nanocomposite
ZnO–Lawsonia inermis (Laali) dye nanocomposite was prepared in a similar way as ZnO–zobo nanocomposite except that 1.0 mL of Laali was added instead of Hibiscus sabdariffa. In the third step, the colour changed from white to very light green.
The resulting ZnO–laali dye nanopowder was then examined in terms of structural, chemical and optical properties.
Desorption and re-adsorption experiment
To examine the nature of surface attachment of dyes onto ZnO, dye-desorption experiment was carried out by adding the coloured hybrid ZnO–dye nanocomposite into KOH (pH 10.5) and stirred for 2 h. Colour of the resulting nanocrystal was observed and subjected to UV–Vis analysis. The dye was re-adsorbed onto the resultant nanocrystals following the same experiments as outlined in 2.2.
The morphology, size distribution and the elemental composition of the nanocomposites were determined by scanning electron microscopy, SEM [JEOL/EO (version 1.0) (JEOL Ltd, Tokyo, Japan)] along with Energy Dispersive X-ray Spectroscopy (EDS) and JEOL 1010 TEM with an accelerating voltage of 100 kV. Crystallinity and phase purity of the materials were determined by X-ray diffraction (XRD) recorded at room temperature using X-ray diffractometer (ARL X’TRA) with Cu-Kα radiation (wavelength: 0.15405 nm). Data were collected in the range from 2θ = 10°–90°. Optical measurements were taken using UV–Vis absorption (T60 UV–Vis spectrophotometer) and Photoluminescence LS50 fluorescence spectrometer. EDS, XRD, UV–Visible spectra and SEM results were obtained from Sheda Science and Technology Complex (SHESTCO), FCT, Abuja, Nigeria and iThemba laboratory, Somerset west, South Africa.
Results and discussion
Hybridization of ZnO with the selected dyes was carried out with evidence of colour changes which signified adsorption inside or outside of the ZnO. The white ZnO changed colour when dye was adsorbed.
Buraidah et al.  reported anthocyanin dye extract from red cabbage as sensitization to semiconductor for solar cells. The cyanidin glucoside effectively formed a complex with TiO2 particles. The hydroxyl group in cyaniding molecule has been found to effectively bind to the surface of TiO2 as proposed by Hao and co-workers. On the contrary, Fig. 1b which represents ZnO–methyl red image displays excessive agglomerates in the form of “splash of dye” on ZnO surfaces. This means that the surface binding of –COOH of methyl red is limited by its stability, resulting into insufficient dye adsorption because of the acidic nature of the dye .
Absorbance data for dye desorption and dye readsorption onto ZnO
For ZnO–laali, the absorbance intensities recorded for desorption (0.36) and re-adsorption (0.39) are in a very close range at almost the same wavelength. KOH did not influence the dislodgement of dye from ZnO. These results signify a strong bond between isoplumbagin and ZnO surface which implies that the dye was adsorbed at the crystalline phases of ZnO. Similar trends are observed in the case of ZnO–zobo implying strong bond and adequate coverage of ZnO surfaces in and out with anthocyanin dye. The strong bond, unaffected by KOH, is an evidence of complexation between the respective active components of the dyes and ZnO. These results have been corroborated with SEM images. On the contrary, KOH strongly influenced structural connectivity between methyl red and ZnO causing a distinct separation between them and eventual bimodal absorbance bands assignable to methyl red (534 nm) and ZnO (341 nm). Methyl red on its own has a unique high intensity (1.4) at wavelength 534 nm which conforms with the report . Evidence of dye disengagement is seen in the relative intensities of the desorbed (0.08) and re-adsorbed (0.18). However, the intensity of the desorbed methyl red from ZnO surface is distinctively lower when compared with the desorption of anthocyanin or Zobo from ZnO. These results further serve as clarification that methyl red did not sensitise ZnO because of the unreactive nature of the acidic dye and agglomerates formation which limits electron injection from the dye to ZnO. Indeed, there is clear evidence from the absorbance intensities that Laali and Zobo possess reasonable character of dye-sensitising agent as the dye re-adsorption absorbance intensities are close to desorption counterpart.
However, peak position (101) is completely absent in the ZnO–laali spectrum. The shift of the characteristic prominent peaks diffraction angle towards the lower 2θ increases in diffraction intensities at (002), (102) and the absence of (101) indicates an evidence of ZnO–Laali dye coexistence and its formation in a single motif. This account for the gradual loss of crystallinity as dye is anchored predominantly on the (002), (101) and (102) crystalline phases. Hence, incorporation of the dye via complexation reaction between isoplumbagin of the dye molecule and Zn2+ caused considerable distortion of the ZnO lattice and stress at the interface between ZnO and Laali dye. The consequence of this stressful scenario resulted in shifting of various peak position of planes leading to suppression along the (101) face .
It is worth of note that no significant difference was noted on the XRD spectra of ZnO when compared with that of ZnO–methyl red and ZnO–zobo. Expectedly, XRD of ZnO–zobo should behave similar to that of ZnO–laali. Further explanation is required to support this anomaly.
The result has been corroborated with SEM image result displaying a splash of dye around ZnO with no evidence of ZnO/methyl red intermixing. The limited ZnO–methyl absorption performance may be explained by the instability of ZnO in acidic dyes, which implies that methyl red caused the dissolution of Zn atoms at ZnO surface, resulting in the slow electron-injection kinetic from methyl red to ZnO .
ZnO–laali and ZnO–zobo displays exceedingly higher absorption and optical characteristics when compared with ZnO and ZnO–methylene red. ZnO–laali is red shifted with increased absorption intensity higher than all other nanocomposites. ZnO–zobo is blue shifted with reasonable absorption intensity. The shift is quite distinctively different from reported absorption spectrum of extracted anthocyanin dye which is found at λ = 535 nm . The ascending increasing order of absorption intensities (ZnO–laali > ZnO–zobo > ZnO–methylene red >ZnO) is an indication of optical influence of various dyes which enhances photosensitization of ZnO. Red shifting is observed in the case of ZnO–laali as evident in an increased particle size (8.3 nm) as determined from the FWHM of the main intensity peak (2θ = 32.25°) using Debye–Scherrer’s equation. The average particle size of the ZnO was found to be 6.5 nm which was derived from the FWHM of the main intensity peak corresponding to (101) at 36.33° while that of ZnO–methyl red was found to be 6.3 nm. The close range in sizes of both ZnO and ZnO–methylene red suggests that the dye and ZnO in the composite are not in a single motif, confirming ZnO/methyl red unreactivity. ZnO–zobo has a reduced particle size (7.8 nm) when compare with ZnO–laali. The distinctive broadening, red shifting and enhanced intensity of ZnO–laali could be due to stronger interfacial complexation between isoplumbagin of the dye molecule and ZnO leading to electron transfer from the dye to ZnO.
The UV emission band display at 344 nm in all composites is attributed to the radiative recombination occurring in the ZnO. Furthermore, it can be seen that ZnO–laali and ZnO–zobo exhibit additional weak peak around 502 and 495 nm, respectively, giving two prominent peaks on each spectrum. These two weak bands are found to be red shifted and with higher intensity relative to the excitonic emission peak of ZnO nanostructure found at 344 nm. The intensity of the ZnO radiative recombination in ZnO–laali is with the highest intensity and is followed by ZnO–zobo. The observed intensities in the cases of ZnO and ZnO–methyl red are the same in overlapping style, suggesting insignificant effect of dye on the optical performance of the later. Under the irradiation of incident light having a wavelength larger than the particle size, the high-density electron of the active dye molecules form an electron cloud and oscillate. As Laali or Zobo molecule complexed with Zn2+, the electron accumulates at the interface between the dye and ZnO, leading to the downward band bending of the ZnO side and thus to the easy electron transfer from Laali, in particular, to the ZnO side .
The UV light emission intensity of the Zn–laali dye is observed as the highest peak distinctively. The reason for this is also due to the fact that, under this analogy, light scattering is stronger than absorption leading to efficient transfer of electron from Laali dye to ZnO as further provided in the literature  based on Rayleigh theory .
These results clearly indicate that optical band gaps of the ZnO nanocomposites are affected by the various dyes, which translate to an effective photosensitization of solar cells. However, optical band gaps of the ZnO–laali and ZnO–zobo shifted towards the red and blue regions, respectively, when compared with that of ordinary ZnO nanoparticle. Consequently, the optical band gaps changed proportionally with shift in absorption edge .
In conclusion, we have considered Laali and Zobo (natural dyes) and methyl red (synthetic dye) for the sensitization of ZnO nanoparticle while investigating the optical properties of the hybrid nanocomposites. The natural dyes have been considered because of their good standing photochemical and phototherapeutic applications. Wet chemistry hybridization protocols have been followed which successfully led to inorganic–organic dye nanocomposites (ZnO–laali, ZnO–zobo) as determined by XRD and SEM. There are evidences that isoplumbagin and anthocyanin that are, respectively, present in Laali and Zobo, successfully anchored themselves on ZnO surfaces. In this regard, methyl red behaves differently as a result of its acidic nature which undermined its stability and prevents anchorage. ZnO–laali and ZnO–zobo have demonstrated enhanced absorption and optical properties with evidence of electron injection from the dyes into ZnO scaffold. Contrary phenomenon was displayed by ZnO–methyl red. Overall, by nanoengineering these two materials into a single motif, the ensuing hybrid nanocomposite would not only exhibit the unique properties of dyes and the semiconductor, but also generate novel collective phenomenon based on the interaction of isoplumbagin or anthocyanin with ZnO. Indeed, ZnO–laali, in particular holds a significant promise for application in dye-sensitised solar cells.
- 4.Wang, Z.L.: Zinc oxide nanostructures: growth properties and applications. J. Phys.: Condens. Matter 16, R829–R858 (2004)Google Scholar
- 10.Nazeeruddin, M., Péchy, P., Renouard, T., Zakeeruddin, S., Humphry-Baker, R., Comte, P., Liska, P., Cevey, L., Costa, E., Shklover, V., Spiccia, L., Deacon, G., Bignozzi, C., Grätzel, M.: Engineering of efficient panchromatic sensitizers for nanocrystalline TiO2-based solar cells. ACS publications. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 123, 1613–1624 (2001)CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- 15.Boyo, A.O., Boyo, H.O., Abdusalam, I.T., Adeola, S.: Dye Sensitized nanocrystaline titania solar cell using laali stem bark (lawsonia inermis). Transl. J. Sci. Tech. 2, 60 (2012)Google Scholar
- 16.Ukwubile, C.A., Otalu, O., Babalola, B.J.: Comparative colour stabilization of Zobo (Hibiscus sabdarifa) drink containing anthacyanin pigment. J. Poisonous Med. Plants Res. 21, 16–19 (2013)Google Scholar
- 17.Ann, Mary: Anthocyanins and human health: an in vivo investigative approach. J. Biomed. Biotech. 5, 306–313 (2004)Google Scholar
- 18.Adenike, O.B., Henry, O.B., Ibrahim, T.A.: Dye sensitized nanocrystaline titania solar cell using laali stem bark (Lawsonia inermis). Transnal. J. Sci. Technol. 2(4), 60–72 (2009)Google Scholar
- 19.Olowosulu, A.K., Akpa, P.A., Eze, U.V., Adikwu, M.U.: Spectrophotometric analysis of Hibiscus sabdariffa colourant at different pH values Nig. J. Pharm. Sci. 7, 36–40 (2008)Google Scholar
- 20.Taher, M., El-Agez, Ahmed, A., El-Tayyan, Al-Kahlout, A., Sofyan, A., Taya, M., Abdel-Latif, S.: Dye-sensitized solar cells based on ZnO films and natural dyes. J. Mater. Chem. 2, 105–110 (2012)Google Scholar
- 23.Buraidah, M. H., Teo, L. P., Yusuf, S. N. F., Noor, M. M., Kufian, M. Z., Careem, M. A., Majid, S. R., Taha, R. M., Arof1 A. K.: TiO2/Chitosan-NH4I(+I2)-BMII-based dye-sensitized solar cells with anthocyanin dyes extracted from black rice and red cabbage. Int. J. Photoenergy. 2011 (2011). doi:10.1155/2011/273683
- 27.Rayleigh, L.: On the light from the sky, its polarization and colour. Philos. Mag. 41, 107, 274 (1871)Google Scholar
Open AccessThis article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made.