Elemental composition of the samples obtained
Elemental analysis of the activated carbons obtained (Tables 1, 2, 3) has shown that their elemental composition depends to a significant degree on the order of reaction with urea, pyrolysis and activation processes as well as on the variant of activation procedure. Samples SP6AX and SP7AX (where X is the time of activation) obtained by physical activation of char SP6 and SP7, not subjected to modification with nitrogen, have the highest content of Cdaf and simultaneously the lowest content of oxygen, hydrogen and nitrogen (Table 3). Sample SDAX obtained by DA of precursor and samples SUDAX obtained from the precursor modified with urea were found to have similar elementary composition (Table 3) (Table 1). The lowest content of Cdaf and the highest contribution of the other elements were noted for samples SDAXU, SP6AXU and SP7AXU (Table 3) subjected to reaction with urea after activation. The content of particular elements depends also on the time of activation and for the samples obtained by a two-step activation—on the pyrolysis temperature. The influence of these parameters is much less important than that of the sequence of technological processes applied to the precursor.
Table 1 Elemental analysis of the samples subjected to reaction with urea followed by DA or by pyrolysis and physical activation (wt%)
Table 2 Elemental analysis of the samples subjected to reaction with urea after pyrolysis followed by physical activation (wt%)
Table 3 Elemental analysis of the samples subjected to activation and next reaction with urea (wt%)
According to the results obtained, the sequence in which the precursor (sawdust) was subjected to pyrolysis, activation and modification with nitrogen determines to a great degree of the amount of nitrogen introduced into the carbon structure. The content of this heteroatom in the obtained activated carbon samples varied in a wide range, from 0.2 wt% in SUDA1 and SUDA2 (Table 1) to 9.2 wt% in SDA2U (Table 3). So great differences in the content of Ndaf between the samples subjected to the reaction with urea at the stage of precursor (SUDAX, SUP6AX, SUP7AX—Table 1) and those subjected to this reaction at the stage of chars (SP6UAX, SP7UAX—Table 2), and the samples modified after activation (SDAXU, SP6AXU and SP7AXU—Table 3) are most probably a consequence of a low thermal resistance of nitrogen groups introduced into the carbon structure. Earlier studies by XPS (Pietrzak et al. 2006; Nowicki et al. 2010b; Burg et al. 2002) have proved that the reaction of carbonaceous materials with urea or ammonia involves generation of considerable amounts of amine, amide, nitrile, imine and lactam groups, characterised by low thermal stability. An indirect evidence of formation of such groups is a simultaneous increase in the content of nitrogen and hydrogen after the reaction with urea.
As follows from the data presented in Tables 1, 2, 3, the greatest amount of nitrogen (17.0 wt%) was introduced upon modification of precursor (Table 1). It should be noted that the efficiency of this process is considerably higher than that of analogous modification of bituminous coal (Pietrzak et al. 2009), although the particle sizes of the coal were much smaller. Moreover, the amount of nitrogen introduced into the structure and on the surface of sawdust was close to that obtained upon modification of fossil coal by gas ammonia which is a more effective nitrogenising agent (Nowicki et al. 2009). This evidence proves high reactivity of sawdust pellets towards urea. Much less nitrogen (4.6 and 6.8 wt%, respectively) was introduced into the structure of chars SP6 and SP7 (Table 2), which is related to a decrease in the susceptibility to chemical modification caused by the structure ordering upon pyrolysis (Nowicki et al. 2009, 2008). Unfortunately, a significant amount of nitrogen functional groups introduced into the precursor and chars underwent decomposition upon further thermal treatment as evidenced by a pronounced decrease in Ndaf after pyrolysis (SUP6 and SUP7 samples—Table 1), and in particular after activation (SUDAX, SP6UAX and SP7UAX series—Table 1). According to the data from this table, DA of the modified precursor (SU) resulted in total removal of the earlier introduced nitrogen groups. This fact confirms the earlier supposition of low thermal stability of nitrogen groups and points to a very high reactivity of modified precursor towards the activating agent—carbon dioxide. Less pronounced changes in the content of nitrogen were noted as a result of activation of samples SP6U and SP7U (Table 2), but the greatest amount of nitrogen (from among the samples modified prior to activation) was left in the structure of SUP6AX and SUP7AX (Table 1). It is probably a consequence of the fact that a considerable amount of nitrogen groups upon pyrolysis underwent transformation to more stable forms (Kapteijn et al. 1999; Cagniant et al. 1998) which meant that their content in the products of activation was much higher than in the other activated carbons.
The content of nitrogen in the samples subjected to the reaction with urea after activation varied in the range 7.5–9.2 wt% (Table 3), so it was a little higher than in samples SUP6AX and SUP7AX (Table 1). Efficiency of nitrogenation at this stage is about twice smaller than during precursor modification, but it is much higher than for chars SP6 and SP7. This result is probably a consequence of the presence of numerous oxygen groups on the surface of activated carbons which favours introduction of nitrogen groups (Pietrzak et al. 2006; Bimer et al. 1998).
Textural studies of activated carbons
The values of surface area measured for the activated carbon samples, presented in Table 4, clearly illustrate a considerable influence of the activation method and time, temperature of pyrolysis and reaction with urea on the porous structure of the final product. The method of activation and the sequence in which the precursor was subjected to particular technological processes definitely have the greatest effect on the surface area. The samples obtained by DA of precursor have much more developed surface area and porous structure than the samples produced by the two-stage method. The greatest surface areas of 759 and 632 m2/g as well as the greatest total pore volumes of 0.40 and 0.37 cm3/g were found for SDA2 and SDA1 samples, respectively. Less beneficial textural parameters were determined for samples SP6AX and SP7AX obtained by the activation of unmodified chars SP6 and SP7 and samples SP6UAX and SP7UAX obtained by the activation of chars enriched in nitrogen after pyrolysis. The porous structure of carbon samples subjected to the reaction with urea at the stage of precursor, in particular those obtained by a two-step activation (except for sample SUP7A2) was even poorer. The poorest textural parameters were found for the samples subjected to the reaction with urea after the process of activation. Introduction of nitrogen at this stage caused a significant decrease in the surface area and the total pore volume, especially in samples SP6AXU and SP7AXU. The surface area of these samples varies from 23 to 70 m2/g, while the total pore volume is just 0.03–0.08 cm3/g. Most probably, such poor results follow from the fact that the nitrogen groups introduced upon modification have blocked the smallest pores playing the most important role in the porous structure of the carbon samples. This supposition is based on a considerable increase in the mean pore diameter from about 2.1–2.3 nm to even 5.25 nm and a drastic decrease in the contribution of micropores in the total pore volume.
Table 4 Porous structure of the activated carbons obtained
Much less significant are the changes in the textural parameters of samples SDA1U and SDA2U as follows from the fact that their surface area is twice smaller than that of the initial samples SDA1 and SDA2. Similarly as for SP6AXU and SP7AXU, a decrease in the contribution of micropores and an increase in the mean pore diameter are observed, but the scale of these changes is much smaller.
In the samples of activated carbons enriched in nitrogen at the stage of precursor and chars, the contribution of micropores is much greater and varies from 80 to 96 %. The greatest contribution of micropores was found for samples SP6UAX and SP7UAX, in which micropores made 95–96 % of all pores and the mean pore diameter did not exceed 1.95 nm. The smallest contribution of pores of diameters below 2 nm (80 and 84 %, respectively) was established for samples SUP7A1 and SUP6A2 also showing the least beneficial textural parameters from among all samples subjected to the reaction with urea prior to activation.
A significant effect on the specific surface area and total pore volume of the carbon samples also has the time of activation. As indicated by the data presented in Table 4, the majority of samples activated for 2 h (except for SUP6A2) have better textural parameters than the materials subjected to activation for 1 h. It means that for the precursor used and for the chars obtained by its pyrolysis, the variant of shorter activation proved insufficient for effective development of porous structure. A comparison of the textural parameters of activated carbons obtained by the two-stage activation reveals some influence of the temperature of pyrolysis on the specific surface area and total pore volume. The carbon samples obtained by the activation of chars SUP6, SP6 and SP6U chars have somewhat greater SBET and V
t than the samples obtained from chars SUP7, SP7 and SP7U. The differences are supposed to follow from the fact that a higher pyrolysis temperature favours greater ordering of the carbon structure, which makes it less reactive to the activating agent.
The particle size of the precursor and chars obtained by its pyrolysis, also influences the textural parameters of the activated carbon samples. As mentioned in the experimental section, the precursor (sawdust) was used in the form of pellets of relatively large size, which could significantly hinder the accessibility of deeper layers of carbon structure to carbon dioxide. Because of the use of large pellets, the surface areas and total pore volumes of the activated carbon samples are much less developed than those of the other carbon samples obtained by physical activation of sawdust (Ismadji et al. 2005; Tancredi et al. 1996).
Acid–base properties of activated carbons
In order to characterise the chemical properties of the surfaces of the activated carbon samples obtained, the contents of the surface oxygen functional groups of acidic and basic types as well as pH were measured. The data collected in Table 5 imply that the activated carbon samples obtained show much different acid–base properties. The pH of their surface changes from 7.0 to 10.4, while the total content of the surface oxygen groups varies from 0.10 to 2.20 mmol/g. The acid–base character of the surfaces of the samples obtained depends significantly on the method and time of activation, pyrolysis temperature and the stage at which the modification with urea was performed. From among the carbon samples modified with nitrogen at the stage of precursor, much higher content of oxygen groups was found in samples SUDA1 and SUDA2—obtained by DA. From among the samples subjected to the reaction with urea, followed by pyrolysis and activation, samples SUP6A1 and SUP6A2 were found to contain more acidic groups, while the analogous samples SUP7A1 and SUP7A2 had a higher content of basic groups. Similarly, dependencies were observed for the carbon samples modified with nitrogen at the stage of chars, so samples SP6UAX and SP7UAX. The difference between the two series of samples is much greater than that between samples SUP6AX and SUP6AX.
Table 5 Acid–base properties of the activated carbons obtained
The highest pH (from 9.8 to 10.4) was measured for the samples obtained by DA of the precursor and activation of char SP6 not subjected to the reaction with urea at any stage. Lower pH values were measured for the carbon samples subjected to enrichment in nitrogen at the stage of precursor or chars, particularly those activated for 2 h. The lowest pH (7–8) was found for samples SP6AXU and SP7AXU, subjected to the reaction with urea after the activation.
The amount and types of oxygen functional groups on the surface of the carbon samples change in an irregular and complex way so it is difficult to find a general correlation between the variants of carbon obtaining and the content of acidic or basic groups. The highest content of oxygen groups (2.20 mmol/g) and the greatest contribution of basic groups (1.35 mmol/g) from among all samples obtained were found for sample SUDA2. Much less surface oxygen groups and also a distinct prevalence of basic groups were measured for samples SDA1, SP6AX, SUP7AX and SP7UAX, which contained from 4 to 9 times greater basic than acidic groups. On the other hand, samples SUDA1, and in particular SP6UA1 and SP6UA2, contain about 2–5 times more groups of acidic than those of basic character. The other samples show an intermediate acid–base properties and contain comparable amounts of acidic and basic groups.
Nitrogen dioxide adsorption properties
Table 6 data show that the adsorption capacities of the activated carbons obtained towards nitrogen dioxide differ depending on many factors: the sequence of individual processes (reaction with urea, pyrolysis and activation), the temperature of pyrolysis, the type and time of activation, as well as the conditions of adsorption. Almost all activated carbons show much greater sorption capacities when adsorption takes place in dry conditions. The most probable reason for poorer sorption properties of activated carbons in the wet conditions can be the competitive adsorption of steam. Only for samples SP6AXU and SP7AXU, the sorption capacity did not depend on the conditions of adsorption, but their sorption capacities were very small and did not exceed 4 mg NO2/gads. The most effective adsorbents were SDA2 and SP6A2, whose NO2 breakthrough capacities were 69 and 62 mg/g in dry conditions as well as 46 and 43 mg/g in wet conditions, respectively. Also high and close to 60 mg NO2/g was the sorption capacity of samples SP6UA2, SP7UA2, SUP7A1 and SDA1 in dry conditions. None of the samples enriched in nitrogen proved more effective than samples SDA2 and SP6A2. Particularly, low sorption capacity was measured for samples SDA1U and SDA2U subjected to the reaction with urea after the DA. Their sorption capacities were about three times smaller than those of the initial materials. Samples SP6A1U, SP6A2U, SP7A1U and SP7A2U shown practically no sorption abilities towards nitrogen dioxide. The so poor sorption capacities are related to first of all of their poor textural parameters and very low content of oxygen surface groups.
Table 6 NO2 breakthrough capacities of the activated carbons obtained (mg/gads)
A comparison of the sorption capacities of particular series of adsorbents reveals that the most beneficial samples are those obtained by modification and DA of the precursor. From the economical point of view, this fact is advantageous as it permits reduction in the energy cost so also the cost of adsorbent production. It should be emphasised that these materials show sorption properties comparable with those of activated carbons obtained by high-temperature processing and modification of commercial materials based on wood or coal, or obtained by chemical activation of organic origin wastes. The latter process is expensive and generates large volumes of noxious wastes, related, e.g., with washing of the final product after activation. For the carbons obtained by the two-stage activation of great significance is the temperature of pyrolysis as evidenced by distinct differences in sorption capacities between the samples subjected to pyrolysis at 600 (P6) and 700 °C (P7). Also the time of activation influences the efficiency of nitrogen dioxide removal by the activated carbon samples obtained. For the samples not enriched in nitrogen at any stage and for those enriched in nitrogen at the stage of chars, a longer time of activation improves the sorption capacities towards NO2. This observation should probably be related to the fact that the carbon samples activated for 2 h have more beneficial textural parameters than those activated for 1 h. The opposite relation was found for the samples subjected to the reaction with urea at the stage of precursor. Such behaviour of the latter samples can follow from the facts that the samples activated for 1 h contain somewhat less surface oxygen groups than those activated for 2 h. Moreover, the above observation suggests that the presence of nitrogen in the carbon structure can influence to some extent the efficiency of nitrogen dioxide removal. Verification of this supposition needs further studies.
The results of sorption studies are also illustrated by the NO2 breakthrough curves (Fig. 2), and NO emission curves (Fig. 3) obtained during adsorption in dry and wet conditions. The character of the breakthrough curves changes in some degree depending on the variant of carbon samples obtaining and conditions of adsorption, which confirms the diversity of sorption capacities towards NO2 of the activated carbon samples. The curves recorded upon NO2 adsorption in dry conditions are similar for the majority of samples, which suggests a similar mechanism of NO2 adsorption. For the majority of samples, especially for SDA2 D, SP6A2 D, SP6UA2 D and SP7UA2 D, for a long time, the NO2 concentration recorded is close to zero and the adsorption curve is parallel to the x axis. Only for the carbon samples subjected to the reaction with urea after activation (SP6A1U D, SP6A2U D, SP7A1U D and SP7A2U D), the so-called breakthrough of adsorbents bed takes place after a very short time and then a rapid increase in the NO2 concentration to 20 ppm is observed. As indicated by the “desorption” fragment of the curves, when the supply of NO2 to the system is cut-off, a rapid decrease in the NO2 concentration is observed, which suggests that the majority of NO2 adsorbed has been strongly bound to the surface or structure of the activated carbon, probably by chemisorption (Kaźmierczak et al. 2013). For samples SDA1 D, SDA2 D, SP6A2 D, SP6UA2 D, SP7A2 and SP7UA2 D, the concentration of NO2 after 30 min of desorption was above 10 ppm, which means that a large part of the NO2 adsorbed has been loosely bound to the carbon surface and is released upon washing out with a flux of air. It suggests that in the latter samples, NO2 undergoes mainly physisorption.
A comparison of the shapes of NO2 breakthrough curves obtained during adsorption in dry and wet conditions (Fig. 2) shows that for the majority of samples, no significant differences in the character of breakthrough curves appeared after introduction of water, which suggests a similar mechanism of nitrogen dioxide adsorption irrespective of the conditions. The greatest differences in the breakthrough curves were noted for the carbon samples obtained by DA (in particular SUDA1 W) and for sample SP6UA2 W obtained by physical activation of nitrogen-enriched char SP6.
Analysis of the “desorption” parts of the curves implies that similarly as in dry conditions, the majority of NO2 adsorbed in wet conditions is permanently bound to the structure or surface of activated carbon samples. This conclusion is based on observations of very fast decrease in the NO2 concentration after cutting off its supply to the system. Thus, it can be supposed that adsorption in wet conditions has mainly chemical character. The supposition is based on the fact that the presence of water can lead to formation of HNO3 as well as HNO2, which favour effective adsorption of nitrogen dioxide on the surface of the adsorbents (Pietrzak and Bandosz 2008).
As follows from the data presented in Fig. 3, the activated carbon samples studied besides the sorption abilities towards NO2 also show the ability to NO2 reduction as evidenced by considerable amounts of nitrogen monoxide accompanying the process of NO2 adsorption. Efficiency of NO2 reduction in NO is much different for different samples and significantly depends on the conditions of adsorption. In general, the majority of activated carbon samples show much greater reduction potential when NO2 adsorption takes place in wet conditions. The evidence supporting the above claim is that in the wet conditions, the time needed to reach NO concentration of 200 ppm (maximum value detectable by the sensor used in the studies) was much shorter than in dry conditions. It can also be noted that NO2 reduction was the most intensive for the carbon samples obtained by modification and DA of the precursor, while the smallest amounts of NO were generated by the sample obtained by modification of char SP6.
Analysis of the data collected also implies that the ability of the activated carbon samples studied to reduce NO2 can to a significant degree influence the efficiency of NO2 adsorption. A greater efficiency of NO2 reduction in wet conditions is probably the reason for the poorer adsorption abilities towards this gas. Large amounts of NO generated in the process of adsorption can compete with NO2 molecules for the access to the active centres of the carbon samples studied and thus deteriorate the sorption capacity. Verification of this supposition would require a more complex measuring setup which would permit accurate record of the processes taking place in the adsorbent bed.