Abstract
Extensive theoretical research has been conducted on the morning commute problem building on the bottleneck model (Vickrey in Am Econ Rev 59(2):251–260, 1969). There have been far fewer studies assessing the bottleneck model and its extensions using real data. This paper presents an analysis of empirical data from the toll plaza of the San Francisco–Oakland Bay Bridge, which is a major regional bottleneck. The Bay Bridge transitioned from a constant toll to a peak step toll on July 1, 2010, so the site is well-suited for assessing many relevant extensions to the classic bottleneck model for the morning commute, including theories for congestion pricing. This paper uses traffic data from the Bay Bridge to address two areas of theoretical work on bottleneck congestion: (1) heterogeneous schedule preferences, and (2) equilibrium response to step tolls. The results suggest that the predicted equilibrium for the morning commute is consistent with observed traffic patterns, especially at the beginning of the rush. The data can be analyzed through the lens of relevant theories to quantify commuters’ value of earliness and lateness relative to queuing delay. The pattern of queuing suggests that the peak step toll has not been implemented in a socially optimal way.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Arnott R, de Palma A, Lindsey R (1988) Schedule delay and departure time decisions with heterogeneous commuters. Transp Res Rec 1197:56–67
Arnott R, de Palma A, Lindsey R (1990) Economics of a bottleneck. J Urban Econ 27(1):111–130
Arnott R, de Palma A, Lindsey R (1992) Route choice with heterogeneous drivers and group-specific congestion costs. Reg Sci Urban Econ 22(1):71–102
Barnes IC, Deakin E, Frick KT, Skabardonis A (2012) Impact of peak and off peak tolls on traffic in the San Francisco–Oakland Bay Bridge corridor. In: 91st annual meeting of the transportation research board, 22–26 January, Number 12-4412, Washington, DC
Daganzo CF (1985) The uniqueness of a time-dependent equilibrium distribution of arrivals at a single bottleneck. Transp Sci 19(1):29–37
Deakin EA, Frick KT, Cervero R, Skabardonis A, Barnes I, Kingsley K, Rubin J, Murakami J, Amaro J, Jensen E (2011) Bay bridge toll evaluation: final report. Technical Report, Global Metropolitan Studies, University of California, Berkeley
Fosgerau M (2011) How a fast lane may replace a congestion toll. Transp Res Part B 45(6):845–851
Gonzales EJ, Daganzo FC (2012) Morning commute with competing modes and distributed demand: user equilibrium, system optimum, and pricing. Transp Res Part B 46(10):1519–1534
Hendrickson C, Kocur G (1981) Schedule delay and departure time decisions in a deterministic model. Transp Sci 15(1):62–77
Lindsey R (2004) Existence, uniqueness, and trip cost function properties of user equilibrium in the bottleneck model with multiple user classes. Transp Sci 38(3):293–314
Lindsey R, van den Berg VAC, Verhoef ET (2012) Step tolling with bottleneck queuing congestion. J Urban Econ 72(1):46–59
Melendez L (2010) Congestion pricing is here to stay. http://abclocal.go.com/kgo/story?section=resources/traffic&id=7533099
Newell GF (1987) The morning commute for nonidentical travelers. Transp Sci 21(2):74–88
PeMS (2013) Freeway Performance Measurement System. http://pems.dot.ca.gov
Qian Z, Zhang HM (2011) The morning commute problem with heterogeneous travelers: the case of continuously distributed parameters. Transportmetrica 9(2):1–26
Ramadurai G, Ukkusuri SV, Zhao J, Pang J-S (2010) Linear complementarity formulation for single bottleneck model with heterogeneous commuters. Transp Res Part B 44(2):193–214
Small KA (1982) The scheduling of consumer activities: work trips. Am Econ Rev 72(3):467–479
Smith MJ (1984) The existence of a time-dependent equilibrium distribution of arrivals at a single bottleneck. Transp Sci 18(4):385–394
Tseng Y-Y, Verhoef ET (2008) Value of time by time of day: a stated-preference study. Transp Res Part B 42(7–8):607–618
Vickrey WS (1969) Congestion theory and transport investment. Am Econ Rev 59(2):251–260
Xiao F, Qian Z, Zhang HM (2011) The morning commute problem with coarse toll and nonidentical commuters. Netw Spat Econ 11(2):343–369
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Gonzales, E.J., Christofa, E. Empirical assessment of bottleneck congestion with a constant and peak toll: San Francisco–Oakland Bay Bridge. EURO J Transp Logist 3, 267–288 (2014). https://doi.org/10.1007/s13676-013-0036-y
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s13676-013-0036-y