Abstract
We conducted a systematic review of the literature on the electronic databases Medline, Embase, Ovid and Cochrane to identify studies from 1990 to 2011 regarding the surgical management of non-parasitic liver cysts treated with laparoscopy (LT) and/or laparotomy (OT) to identify short-term and long-term outcomes of the relative treatments. Two reviewers independently extracted data regarding the following parameters: first author, year of publication, type of journal, study design, number of patients operated on, male/female ratio, mean age, mean size of the cysts treated, laparoscopic conversion rate, morbidity, mortality and recurrence in both groups (LT and OT). A qualitative analysis was carried out using the Pearson Chi square test and the Fischer’s exact test where necessary. The data analysis was conducted by dividing the sample into three periods in relation to the development of laparoscopic surgery: period 1 (P1), 1990–1995 “pioneering” period of laparoscopy; period 2 (P2), 1996–2000 period of the “development of laparoscopy”; period 3 (P3), 2001–2011 period of “diffusion of laparoscopy.” Thirty studies involving 948 patients comparing LT with OT were included in the final pooled analysis. Twenty-two studies were retrospective (73.3 %) and only 8 (26.7 %) were prospective. The number of publications increased during the three periods analysed. The correlation between the type of journal and the year of publication showed an increase (p = 0.048) in journals dedicated to LT during the three periods. In P1, the preferred approach was open surgery (66.3 %) with only 11 cases treated with LT. The conversion rate was 18.1 %. The overall complication rate was 33.3 % with a substantial equivalence between the two approaches (27.2 % for laparoscopic surgery and 36.6 % for laparotomic). The overall recurrence rate was 18.1 % with 36.3 % in the laparoscopic group and 9.2 % in the laparotomic group. In P2, the preferred approach was laparoscopic (56.7 %). The conversion rate was 2.3 %. The overall complication rate was 5.8 % but with some differences between the two approaches (10.3 % for the laparoscopic approach and 0 % for open surgery). The overall recurrence rate was 14.4 % with 17.4 % in the laparoscopic group and 10.4 % in the laparotomic group. In P3, the preferred approach was laparoscopic (69.9 %). The overall recurrence rate was 11.1 %; it was 6.1 % for the laparoscopic approach while it was 11.5 % for laparotomic. In all three periods analysed, the laparoscopic approach showed a statistically significant reduction in operative time (p = 0.009) and hospital stay (p = 0.001) and a significant (p < 0.05) reduction rate in symptomatic recurrences in patients with polycystic liver disease (25 %) as compared with simple liver cysts (7.5 %). The current data in the literature show that the laparoscopic approach may be the treatment of choice in patients with symptomatic non-parasitic cysts of the liver, providing the short-term advantages of minimally invasive surgery. Recurrence rates were acceptable and comparable to those of conventional surgery. Long-term outcomes should be verified by additional randomised controlled trials and long-term follow-ups.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Caremani M, Vincenti A, Benci A et al (1993) Ecographic epidemiology of non-parasitic hepatic cysts. J Clin Ultrasound 21:115–118
Carrim ZI, Murchison JT (2003) The prevalence of simple renal and hepatic cysts detected by spiral computed tomography. Clin Radiol 58:626–629
Seo JK, Kim SH, Lee SH et al (2010) Appropriate diagnosis of biliary cystic tumors: comparison with atypical hepatic simple cysts. Eur J Gastroenterol Hepatol 22(8):989–996
Morino M, De Giuli M, Festa V et al (1994) Laparoscopic management of symptomatic non parasitic cysts of the liver. Indications and results. Ann Surg. 219:157–164
Starzl TE, Reyes J, Tzakis A et al (1990) Liver transplantation for polycystic liver disease. Arch Surg 125:575–577
Petri A, Höhn J, Makula E et al (2001) Experience with different methods of treatment of nonparasitic liver cysts. Langenbecks Arch Surg 387:229–233
Gigot JF, Legrand M, Hubens G et al (1996) Laparoscopic treatment of nonparasitic liver cysts: adequate selection of patients and surgical technique. World J Surg 20:556–561
Furuta T, Yoshida Y, Saku M et al (1990) Treatment of symptomatic non-parasitic liver cysts—surgical treatment versus alcohol injection therapy. HPB Surg 2:269–277
Henne-Bruns D, Klomp HJ, Kremer B (1993) Non-parasitic liver cysts and polycystic liver disease: results of surgical treatment. Hepatogastroenterology 40(1):1–5
Kabbej M, Sauvanet A, Chauveau D et al (1996) Laparoscopic fenestration in polycystic liver disease. Br J Surg 83(12):1697–1701
Emmermann A, Zornig C, Lloyd DM et al (1997) Laparoscopic treatment of nonparasitic cysts of the liver with omental transposition flap. Surg Endosc 11(7):734–736
Koperna T, Vogl S, Satzinger U et al (1997) Nonparasitic cysts of the liver: results and options of surgical treatment. World J Surg 21(8):850–854
Hansen P, Bhoyrul S, Legha P et al (1997) Laparoscopic treatment of liver cysts. J Gastrointest Surg 1(1):53–59
Kakizaki K, Yamauchi H, Teshima S (1998) Symptomatic liver cyst: special reference to surgical management. J Hepatobiliary Pancreat Surg 5(2):192–195
Martin IJ, McKinley AJ, Currie EJ et al (1998) Tailoring the management of nonparasitic liver cysts. Ann Surg 228(2):167–172
Katkhouda N, Hurwitz M, Gugenheim J et al (1999) Laparoscopic management of benign solid and cystic lesions of the liver. Ann Surg 229(4):460–466
Zalaba Z, Tihanyi TF, Winternitz T et al (1999) The laparoscopic treatment of non-parasitic liver cysts. Five years experience. Acta Chir Hung 38(2):221–223
Hansman MF, Ryan JA Jr, Holmes JH et al (2001) Management and long-term follow-up of hepatic cysts. Am J Surg 181(5):404–410
Regev A, Reddy KR, Berho M et al (2001) Large cystic lesions of the liver in adults: a 15-year experience in a tertiary center. J Am Coll Surg 193(1):36–45
Tocchi A, Mazzoni G, Costa G et al (2002) Symptomatic nonparasitic hepatic cysts: options for and results of surgical management. Arch Surg 137(2):154–158
Pitale A, Bohra AK, Diamond T (2002) Management of symptomatic liver cysts. Ulster Med J 71(2):106–110
Fiamingo P, Tedeschi U, Veroux M et al (2003) Laparoscopic treatment of simple hepatic cysts and polycystic liver disease. Surg Endosc 17(4):623–626 (Epub 2003 Feb 10)
Tan YM, Chung A, Mack P et al (2005) Role of fenestration and resection for symptomatic solitary liver cysts. ANZ J Surg. 75(7):577–580
Kornprat P, Cerwenka H, Bacher H et al (2004) Minimally invasive management of dysontogenetic hepatic cysts. Langenbecks Arch Surg. 389(4):289–292
Szabó LS, Takács I, Arkosy P et al (2006) Laparoscopic treatment of nonparasitic hepatic cysts. Surg Endosc 20(4):595–597
Neri V, Ambrosi A, Fersini A et al (2006) Laparoscopic treatment of biliary hepatic cysts: short- and medium-term results. HPB (Oxford) 8(4):306–310
Palanivelu C, Jani K, Malladi V (2006) Laparoscopic management of benign nonparasitic hepatic cysts: a prospective nonrandomized study. South Med J 99(10):1063–1067
Caetano-Júnior EM, Linhares MM, Matos D et al (2006) Laparoscopic management of hepatic cysts. Surg Laparosc Endosc Percutan Tech. 16(2):68–72
Garcea G, Pattenden CJ, Stephenson J et al (2007) Nine-year single-center experience with nonparastic liver cysts: diagnosis and management. Dig Dis Sci 52(1):185–191
Bai XL, Liang TB, Yu J et al (2007) Long-term results of laparoscopic fenestration for patients with congenital liver cysts. Hepatobiliary Pancreat Dis Int 6(6):600–603
van Keimpema L, Ruurda JP, Ernst MF et al (2008) Laparoscopic fenestration of liver cysts in polycystic liver disease results in a median volume reduction of 12.5 %. J Gastrointest Surg 12(3):477–482
Loehe F, Globke B, Marnoto R et al (2010) Long-term results after surgical treatment of nonparasitic hepatic cysts. Am J Surg 200(1):23–31
Treckmann JW, Paul A, Sgourakis G et al (2010) Surgical treatment of nonparasitic cysts of the liver: open versus laparoscopic treatment. Am J Surg 199(6):776–781
Donati M, Stavrou GA, Wellmann A, Flemming P, Donati A, Oldhafer KJ (2010) Laparoscopic deroofing of hepatic cysts: the most effective treatment option. Clin Ter 161(4):345–348
Gigot JF, Metairie S, Etienne J, Horsmans Y, van Beers BE, Sempoux C, Deprez P, Materne R, Geubel A, Glineur D, Gianello P (2001) The surgical management of congenital liver cysts. Surg Endosc 15(4):357–363
Conflict of interest
None.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Antonacci, N., Ricci, C., Taffurelli, G. et al. Systematic review of laparoscopic versus open surgery in the treatment of non-parasitic liver cysts. Updates Surg 66, 231–238 (2014). https://doi.org/10.1007/s13304-014-0270-3
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s13304-014-0270-3