Abstract
In this paper, I describe historical geographies of settler colonization and decolonization in the Port of Tacoma, Washington tideflats using the lens of biological, habitat, flow, and physico-chemical indicators of water quality. The Puyallup River empties into what is now known as the Port of Tacoma. Before the Port’s industrialization, the tideflats and bay were rich with shellfish and anadromous fish, important traditional sources of food for the Puyallup Tribe of Indians. Colonization and allotment led to severe environmental degradation and removal of the tribe from their land. Because of waste dumped by settler colonial industry, the nearshore tideflats at the Puyallup River’s mouth are now an EPA Superfund site, containing phthalates, heavy metals, pesticides, PCBs, and more. Over the years of its industrialization, the river has been channelized and the shoreline armored. In addition, for many years the City of Tacoma dumped sewage directly into the Port waterways. In the 1950 and 1960s, the Puyallup Tribe participated in the Puget Sound “Fish Wars,” forcing attention to treaty rights through off-reservation fish-ins, and leading to the 1974 Boldt Decision upholding tribal treaty rights. With the legal recourse enabled by the Boldt Decision, the Puyallup Tribe successfully sued the Port, interstate, railroad companies, polluting industry, and several cities for occupied land denoted as theirs by the Treaty of Medicine Creek. In addition, the tribe has participated in several lawsuits forcing aquatic habitat restoration and remediation efforts along the river and tideflats. I describe colonial and decolonizing processes of shaping and re-shaping the river mouth, beginning in the late 1800s, and assess changes in water quality from the mid-1800s through present day using recent data on contaminants, as well as proxies of indicator species for unavailable data from earlier eras. I use these data to understand the ways the tribe’s legal challenges to colonization have impacted the area’s environmental health. I conclude that legal affirmations of tribal sovereignty are positively associated with estuarine ecosystem health.
Similar content being viewed by others
Notes
Also known as Mount Rainier. Several Lushootseed interpretations of its name refer to its as a source of nourishment, a mother or breast (Clark 2003).
“Superfund,” also known as CERCLA (Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation, and Liability Act) is a federal law authorizing cleanup of sites with hazardous substances, funded by damages collected from polluters and/or a trust fund (the “Superfund”).
These “prairions” may be the meadowlands described by explorer Charles Wilkes’ men in 1838 (Morgan 1979).
See La Pointe-Gorman (2009).
Tribal Chair Bill Sterud has also discussed this in interviews; see Douglas (2015).
Specifically, the Puyallup, Nisqually, Muckleshoot, Hoh, Makah, Quileute, Skokomish, Lummi, Quinault, Sauk-Suiattle, Squaxin Island, Stillaguamish, and Upper Skagit River Tribes, as well as the Yakama Nation.
The phrase “gog-le-hi-te” means “where land and water meet” (Hunt 1916).
References
Anonymous (1993) Superfund site cleaned in record time. HazMat World 6(10)
Associated Press (1984) Puyallup Tribe lawsuit seeks Tacoma land. In: Spokane Chronicle. https://news.google.com/newspapers?nid=1345&dat=19840614&id=cldOAAAAIBAJ&sjid=jvkDAAAAIBAJ&pg=5676,2881062&hl=en. Accessed 28 Feb 2016
Associated Press (2015) Settlement reached in Commencement Bay pollution case. The Seattle Times. http://www.seattletimes.com/seattle-news/settlement-reached-in-commencement-bay-pollution-case/. Accessed 28 Feb 2016
Auburn Reporter (2009) Corps transports record number of salmon back into White River. http://www.auburn-reporter.com/news/63616987.html. Accessed 28 Feb 2016
Bagley CB (1915) Journal of occurrences at Nisqually House, 1833. Wash Hist Q 6(3):179–197. http://www.jstor.org/stable/40474397. Accessed 28 Feb 2016
Ballantine A (2016) “Whiteness as property”: colonialism, contamination, and detention in Tacoma’s Puyallup Estuary, (Masters Thesis), The Evergreen State College, Olympia
Bigart H (1966) Indians are pitted against game wardens in great fish war of Northwest. New York Times, New York. http://query.nytimes.com/gst/abstract.html?res=9901E6DB123BE333A25757C1A96E9C946791D6CF. Accessed 28 Feb 2016
Burns C, Adams H, Burns C (1971) As long as the rivers run. [Motion Picture]. Survival of American Indians Association, United States
Caster D (2010) Native American presence in the Federal Way area. Historical Society of Federal Way, Federal Way. http://www.federalwayhistory.org/powercms/files/Native_Presence.PDF. Accessed 28 Feb 2016
Chasan DJ (1981) The water link: a history of Puget Sound as a resource. University of Washington Press, Seattle
Cirone P, Coco M (1993) The lessons of Commencement Bay. EPA J 19(1):33
City of Tacoma (2016) Thea Foss waterway cleanup. CityofTacoma.org. http://www.cityoftacoma.org/cms/one.aspx?objectId=7283. Accessed 25 Feb 2016
Clark W (1985) Fishing in a sea of court orders: Puget Sound salmon management 10 years after the Boldt Decision. N Am J Fish Manag 5:417–434
Clark E (2003) Indian legends of the Pacific Northwest. University of California Press, Berkeley
Collins BD, Montgomery DR, Sheikh AJ (2003) Reconstructing the historical riverine landscape of the Puget Lowland
Cosgrove C (2011) Puyallup Tribe of Indians delivers generous $1 million donation. Multicare Vitals. https://www.multicare.org/news/puyallup-tribe-indians-delivers-generous-1-million-donation/. Accessed 28 Feb 2016
Cronon W (1991) Nature’s metropolis: Chicago and the great West. W. W. Norton & Company, New York
Department of Game & Department of Fisheries v. Puyallup Tribe (1972) 80 Wn.2d 561
Douglas M (2015) Transcript, “The Puyallup Land claims settlement: a lesson in struggle.” Tacoma Community History Project, University of Washington Library. http://digitalcollections.lib.washington.edu/cdm/compoundobject/collection/tacomacomm/id/577/rec/7. Accessed 28 Feb 2016
Dunbar-Ortiz R (2014) An Indigenous peoples’ history of the United States. Beacon Press, Boston, MA
Egan T (1988) Indian Tribe agrees to drop claim To Tacoma Land for $162 Million. New York Times. http://www.nytimes.com/1988/08/29/us/indian-tribe-agrees-to-drop-claim-to-tacoma-land-for-162-million.html. Accessed 28 Feb 2016
Evans D (1991) Commencement bay cumulative impact study: historic review of special aquatic sites. Prepared for the U.S. Army corps of engineers. Evans & Associates, Inc. Bellevue
Governor’s Office of Indian Affairs (2016)(1) Puyallup Tribe. http://www.goia.wa.gov/tribal-information/Tribes/puyallup.htm. Accessed 28 Feb 2016
Governor’s Office of Indian Affairs (2016)(2) Centennial accord between the federally recognized Indian Tribes in Washington State and the State of Washington. http://www.goia.wa.gov/government-to-government/data/centennialaccord.htm. Accessed 25 May 2016
Hale CH (1862) G1. Report of C. H. Hale, Superintendent of Indian Affairs, Washington Territory. United States Office of the Commissioner of Indian Affairs. Washington, DC. http://digitalcollections.lib.washington.edu/cdm/compoundobject/collection/lctext/id/240/rec/47. Accessed 29 Feb 2016
Haney López I (2006) White by law: the legal construction of race. New York University Press, New York
Harmon A (1998) Indians in the making: ethnic relations and Indian identities around Puget Sound. University of California Press, Berkeley
Harris C (1993) Whiteness as Property. Harv Law Rev 106(8):1707–1791
Holmes S (2013) Fresh fruit, broken bodies: migrant farmworkers in the United States. University of California Press, Berkeley and Los Angeles
Hunt H (1916) Tacoma its history and its builders: a half century of activity, vol 1. The S.J. Clarke Publishing Company, Chicago
Isley M (1970) Uncommon controversy; fishing rights of the Muckleshoot, Puyallup, and Nisqually Indians. A report prepared for the American Friends Service Committee. University of Washington Press, Seattle
Kershnar S, Haines S, Harkins G, Greig A, Wiesner C, Levy M, Shah P, Kim M, Carr J (2007) Toward transformative justice: a liberatory approach to child sexual abuse and other forms of intimate and community violence. Generation Five.org. http://www.generationfive.org/wp-content/uploads/2013/07/G5_Toward_Transformative_Justice-Document.pdf. Accessed 17 April 2016
Kerwin J (1999) Salmon habitat limiting factors report for the Puyallup River Basin (Water Resource Inventory Area 10). Washington Conservation Commission, Olympia. http://your.kingcounty.gov/dnrp/library/archive-documents/wlr/wrias/10/salmon-habitat-limiting-factors/pdf/wria-10-salmon-habitat-limiting-factors.pdf. Accessed 28 Feb 2016
Klingle M (2009) Emerald City: an environmental history of Seattle. Yale University Press, New Haven
Kurtz H (2009) Acknowledging the racial state: an agenda for environmental justice research. Antipode 41(4):684–704
La Pointe-Gorman C (2009) Transcript, “Ramona Bennett: Puyallup Tribe Indian activist.” Tacoma Community History Project, University of Washington Library. http://digitalcollections.lib.washington.edu/cdm/compoundobject/collection/tacomacomm/id/496/rec/4. Accessed 28 Feb 2016
LaCapra D (2001) Writing history, writing trauma. Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore
Larson J (2008) An agreement for the ages: land claims settlement forever changed the tribe and its neighbors. Tacoma Weekly. http://www.tacomaweekly.com/news/article/an_agreement_for_the_ages/. Accessed 28 Feb 2016
de Leeuw S (2012) Alice through the looking glass: emotion, personal connection, and reading colonial archives along the grain. J Hist Geogr 38(3):273–281
Lynn A (2015) Puyallup tribe asks court to halt permits for Tacoma gas plant. The News Tribune. http://www.thenewstribune.com/news/local/article50986020.html. Accessed 30 May 2016
Magden R, Martinson AD (1982) The working waterfront: the story of Tacoma’s ships and men. Port of Tacoma, Tacoma
Magden R (2008) Port of Tacoma—thumbnail history, Part 1. HistoryLink.org. http://www.historylink.org/index.cfm?DisplayPage=output.cfm&file_id=8592. Accessed 28 Feb 2016
Marine View Ventures (2016) At a glance. MarineViewVentures.com. https://www.marineviewventures.com/. Accessed 29 April 2016
McCarver MM (1868) Founder of Tacoma, Morton M. McCarver letter to L. M. Starr and James Steel of Portland, Oregon, regarding an investment in building a saw mill and the need for the Union Pacific Railroad to extend to Commencement City (Tacoma), August 29, 1868. Pacific Northwest Historical Documents, University of Washington Libraries. http://digitalcollections.lib.washington.edu/cdm/compoundobject/collection/pioneerlife/id/3878/rec/45. Accessed 28 Feb 2016
McShane D (2010) The Grassy Knoll—Tacoma’s. Reading the Washington Landscape: observations of state landscapes, geology, geography, ecology, history, and land use, May 13. Retrieved Sept 1, 2015 from http://washingtonlandscape.blogspot.com/2010/05/grassy-knoll-tacomas.html
McWhorter LV (1994) Tragedy of the Wahk-Shum: the death of Andrew J. Bolon, Yakima Indian Agent. As told by Su-el-il, Eyewitness. Also, the suicide of general George A. Custer. As told by owl child, eyewitness. Great Eagle Publishing, Inc, Issaquah
Morgan M (1979) Puget’s Sound: a narrative of early Tacoma and the Southern Sound. University of Washington Press, Seattle
Nader L (1972) Up the anthropologist: perspectives from studying up. In: Hymes D (ed) Reinventing anthropology. Pantheon Books, New York
Nagle M (2015) Puyallups reach out to Colvilles with generous donation: funds gifted to help Confederated Tribes of Colville rebuild after devastating wildfire season. Puyallup Tribal News. http://puyalluptribalnews.net/news/article/puyallups-reach-out-to-colvilles-with-generous-donation. Accessed 28 Feb 2016
National Lawyers Guild (1973) Law student Indian summer project. Seattle, WA
Newell GR (1975) Rogues, buffoons, and statesmen. Superior Publishing Company, Seattle
Northwest Indian Fisheries Commission (Producer). Anonymous (Director) (2014) Ramona Bennett (Puyallup Tribe of Indians) at Boldt 40. [Motion Picture]. Northwest Treaty Tribes, United States. https://vimeo.com/86357928. Accessed 28 Feb 2016
Northwest Treaty Tribes (2016) “Puyallup Tribe stands up against gas plant.” NWTreatyTribes.org. January 4, 2016. http://nwtreatytribes.org/puyallup-tribe-stands-up-against-gas-plant/. Accessed 28 Feb 2016
Outwater A (1996) Water: a natural history. Basic Books, New York, NY
Pegues J (2013) Interrogating intimacies: Asian American and Native relations in colonial Alaska. (Doctoral dissertation). Retrieved 5/29/2016 from the University of Minnesota Digital Conservancy, http://hdl.handle.net/11299/174884
Pulido L (2002) Reflections on a white discipline. In: Bauder H, Engel-Di Mauro S (eds) Critical geographies: a collection of readings. Praxis (e)Press, Kelowna
Puyallup Tribal News (2016) NWIW calls for pause in methanol plant review//Critics vow to continue fight. PuyallupTribalNews.net. http://puyalluptribalnews.net/news/article/nwiw-calls-for-pause-in-methanol-plant-review. Accessed 30 May 2016
Puyallup Tribe of Indians (2016) Our Tribe. Puyallup-Tribe.com. http://www.puyallup-tribe.com/ourtribe/. Accessed 30 May 2016
Puyallup Tribe of Indians v. Port of Tacoma (1981) 525 F. Supp. 65 (W.D. Wash. 1981)
Puyallup Tribe of Indians v. Port of Tacoma (1983) 717 F.2d 1251 (9th Cir. 1983)
Ruby RH, Brown JA, Collins CC, Trafzer CE (2010) A guide to the Indian Tribes of the Pacific Northwest. University of Oklahoma Press, Norman
Sailor C (2014) Arrival of white explorers in Puget Sound began cultural changes that have continued to this day. Tacoma, The News Tribune. http://www.thenewstribune.com/news/local/article25909267.html. Accessed 28 Feb 2016
Smith M (1940) The Puyallup-Nisqually. AMS Press, New York
Smith LT (2012) Decolonizing methodologies. Zed Books ltd, London
Squaxin Island Tribe (2016) Treaty of Medicine Creek-1854. http://www.squaxinisland.org/wp/wp-content/uploads/2010/03/TREATY-OF-MEDICINE-CREEK.doc. Accessed 28 Feb 2016
Stapanian M, Adams J, Gara B (2013) Presence of indicator plant species as a predictor of wetland vegetation integrity: a statistical approach. Plant Ecol 214(2):291–302
Sterud B (2016) RE: Notice of violation of non-discretionary duty to promulgate human health criteria applicable to Washington state in accordance with the Clean Water Act § 303. EPA.gov. https://www.epa.gov/sites/production/files/2016-03/documents/puyallop_tribe_noi.pdf. Accessed 25 May 2016
Tacoma Weekly (2008) Port hands Gog-le-hi-te II wetland over to tribe. http://www.tacomaweekly.com/news/article/port_hands_gog-le-hi-te_ii_wetland_over_to_tribe/. Accessed 28 Feb 2016
The Columbian (1853) Puyallup fisheries against the world! (Olympia). http://www.sos.wa.gov/history/newspapers_detail.aspx?t=2. Accessed 28 Feb 2016
Thrush C (2008) Native Seattle: histories from the crossing-over place. Weyerhaeuser Books, Seattle
Tolmie WF (1963) The journals of William Fraser Tolmie, physician and fur trader. Mitchell Press, Vancouver, BC
Trouillot M-R (1995) Silencing the past: power and the production of history. Beacon Press, Boston
Tuck E, Yang KW (2012) Decolonization is not a metaphor. Decolon Indig Educ Soc 1(1):1–40
U.S. Department of Agriculture (1989) Big islands management area: final environmental impact statement. Chugach National Forest, Anchorage
U.S. Department of State (2007) Treaties in force. http://www.state.gov/documents/organization/83046.pdf. Accessed 28 Feb 2016
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (2014) Fourth five-year review report for Commencement Bay nearshore/tideflats Superfund site. EPA.gov. https://www3.epa.gov/region10/pdf/sites/cb-nt/4th_fyr_cbnt_2014.pdf. Accessed 30 May 2016
U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service & National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (1996) Commencement bay draft restoration plan and programmatic environmental impact statement. USFWS and NOAA, Olympia
U.S. Forest Service (2016) Management indicator species. FS.fed.us. http://www.fs.usda.gov/Internet/FSE_DOCUMENTS/fsm9_019636.pdf. Accessed 30 May 2016
United States v. Ashton. 170 F. 509 (W.D. Wash. 1909)
United States v. Washington. 384 F. Supp. 312 (W.D. Wash.1974). (Boldt Decision)
United States v. Washington. 20 F. Supp. 3d 986 (W.D. Wash. 2013). (Martinez/ Culvert Decision)
Washington State Historical Society (1940) Building a State: Washington 1889–1939. Pioneer, Incorporated, Tacoma
Wilcox WP (1929) Anti-Chinese riots in Washington. Washington Historical Quarterly 20(3). https://journals.lib.washington.edu/index.php/WHQ/article/viewFile/7674/6710. Accessed 1 Sept 2015
Wonacott A (2008) Where the Mashel meets the Nisqually : the Mashel massacre of 1856. Bellus Uccello Publishing, Spanaway
wa Thiong’o N (2011) Decolonising the mind: the politics of language in African literature. James Currey, Melton
Acknowledgments
Dr. Zoltán Grossman; Dr. Martha Henderson; Jeremy van Orman; Liza Rognas; my anonymous reviewers.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Ballantine, A. The river mouth speaks: water quality as storyteller in decolonization of the Port of Tacoma. Water Hist 9, 45–66 (2017). https://doi.org/10.1007/s12685-016-0179-5
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s12685-016-0179-5