Abstract
Duration of an anthropogenic fire event is one aspect of fire use and maintenance that is linked to combustion feature function but has low archaeological visibility. In this study, we describe the transformations to fresh, modern cortical bone with prolonged exposure to heat in order to evaluate the utility of archaeological bone for the recognition of long duration thermal alteration. Cores of bovid cortical bone were heated exposed to air at 300, 550, and 750 °C in a sequence of experimental trials in a Nabertherm muffle furnace for periods of 10 minutes, 9 hours, and 48 hours, plus an extensive cooling period on heat retaining sediments (gravel or gravel compacted with fine quartz sand) to mirror the smoldering and extinguishing of actualistic fires. After heating, bone cores were analyzed with a color tool, Fourier-transform infrared spectroscopy, and X-ray diffraction to evaluate changes in structure, composition, and crystallinity of bioapatite as a function of different temperature thresholds and time. Results indicate that prolonged heating in air induces specific structural and chemical changes in bone compared to shorter duration burned counterparts. Coloration changes also demonstrate that white coloration, a primary characteristic utilized by zooarchaeologists to record information about burning intensity, is not an exclusive indicator of calcination at moderate to high temperatures but may also result from long duration exposures at low temperatures.
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
Introduction
Ethnoarchaeological documentation of fire use in modern hunting and gathering societies has highlighted the variable of duration as a distinguishing factor between different functional roles of fire (Henry et al. 2018; Mallol et al. 2007; Mallol and Henry 2017). In observations of use of fire by living hunter gatherer populations, prolonged duration of a fire event was noted to be necessary for activities such as meat curing and hide smoking, as well as for long-lasting communally maintained cooking fires (Henry et al. 2018; Mallol et al. 2007; Mallol and Henry 2017). In contrast to that, natural wildfires in environments with low woody biomass have been reported to be only of short duration (Table 1). Duration may therefore present a valuable proxy to differentiate the occurrence of a natural fire event from people constructing spatially constrained combustion features or hearths (Gowlett et al. 2017; Cutts et al. 2019) and for identifying and reconstructing ancient fire use practices. The length of archaeological fire events has proven challenging to document, however, due to the ephemeral nature of fire.
Indirect fire proxies, such as thermally altered bone, provide opportunities to verify fire presence and document the conditions under which bone mineral is transformed with heat. To evaluate the impact of prolonged heating on bone we performed for this study a set of laboratory experiments heating modern mammalian (bovid) cortical bone at different durations (10 minutes, 9 hours, 48 hours) at controlled temperatures (300, 550, 750 °C). We recorded visible color with an RM200 CAPSURE Color Matching tool and utilized Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy (FTIR) with attenuated total reflectance (ATR) and X-ray diffraction (XRD) to provide information on the dual impact of duration and temperature on bone cortical tissue. Both observational and semi-quantitative spectroscopic data are considered here to reflect the practical and minimally invasive methodologies utilized by zooarchaeologists and to create a standardized dataset. Specific research objectives of this project include:
-
1.
To investigate the impact to bone color, chemistry, and structure with prolonged heating.
-
2.
To assess if prolonged heating at different temperature thresholds can be distinguished from each other.
-
3.
To evaluate the application of these observations for interpreting fire origins and functions with archaeological burned bone assemblages.
Duration times in the context of natural versus anthropogenic fires
It is difficult to discern evidence for anthropogenic control of fire (hominin management of a local fire via fuel control), use of fire (hominin use of fire or fire altered materials naturally occurring in the landscape), or non-anthropogenic wildfire (Buenger 2003; Goldberg et al. 2017; Gowlett et al. 2017; Sandgathe and Berna 2017; Stahlschmidt et al. 2020). Natural wildfires are common and integral to many ecosystems and vary in intensity in relation to biome, climate, and vegetation (Scott 2009). Variations in intensity and length are also influenced by the available fuel, fuel moisture, weather conditions, and topography. Grass and brush fires are primarily documented to be ephemeral and fast moving, passing in minutes, opposed to the longer and more intense heat associated with peat, dung, and tree stump fires (Bailey and Anderson 1980; Bellomo 1993; David 1990; Gowlett et al. 2017; Pyne et al. 1996; Santana et al. 2013; Scott 2000; Stinson and Wright 1969; Whelan 1995; For review see Stahlschmidt et al. 2023, this issue; Table 1). Data regarding the average lengths and temperatures of forest fires in differing conditions, such as boreal and tropical forests, are difficult to obtain and are not regularly reported. For dry and heavily wooded environments, fires are commonly acknowledged to burn for hours.
Prior research on mammalian animal carcasses burned in fast-moving wildfires has shown that the skin, flesh, and organs can shield bones from the rapid initial heating (Gowlett et al. 2017). For animals like tortoises, which have exposed bony components, passing brushfires do leave visible burning indications on remains, but the impact is generally low to moderate (Stahlschmidt et al. 2023). The less commonly observed high temperature intensities seen on the tortoise remains are likely related to the presence of naturally occurring fuel sources on the landscape. These fuel sources increased the combustion potential and available fuel, leading to a higher intensity of burning in those cases, even though the fire event was not long lasting (Stahlschmidt et al. 2023). These findings align well with the known impact of flesh on burning dynamics, as initially flesh acts as a protective layer on bone elements when heated or exposed to flame (Ellingham et al. 2016). However, when the flesh combusts given the opportunity of high temperature intensities and time, it becomes a fuel source itself, contributing to the overall intensity of alteration to the bone components (Ellingham et al. 2016).
Neither the duration of a fire event nor high temperatures are inherently or intrinsically linked to fires either of anthropogenic or natural origin. Despite this, duration times are considered potentially more informative than high temperatures for assessing the likelihood of anthropogenic fire, as in many instances and environments natural fire cannot stay self-sustained for extended periods (Gowlett et al. 2017; Hlubik et al. 2019; Table 1). Many ethnographically documented human controlled and curated fires do require several hours for activities such as meat or hide smoking, or communal cooking fires, however (Henry et al. 2018; Mallol et al. 2007; Mallol and Henry 2017). An assessment of prolonged heating in bone can therefore contribute valuable information within an integrated evaluation of the likelihood of an archaeological fire curated by hominins following the microcontextual approach (Goldberg and Berna 2010; Goldberg et al. 2017). This methodological and theoretical framework recommends the integration of multiple multi-scale analytical techniques and emphasizes the context of archaeological material, including the surrounding matrix. Several independent lines of evidence of fire proxies and heat induced transformations to materials and sediment are necessary to comprehensively verify anthropogenic fire signatures and address the presence and properties of ancient fire.
When employing thermally altered bone as an indirect proxy for fire, it is essential to recognize that observed changes in burned or heated bone offer insights solely into the localized conditions of the exposure. These conditions may only represent the properties of a fire at a specific moment in time. It is also possible for bones to be reheated, and overall alteration may represent several heating events. The duration of heat experienced by bone can therefore provide a metric of the time of heating from an unknown number of occurrences. Indications of prolonged heating still can offer valuable insights into the relative properties of a fire, however, both for bone intentionally included in fires or incidentally burned around or under a feature. This information can provide additional details to contribute within the microcontextual approach that otherwise would remain undetectable.
Transformations to bone mineral and chemistry with thermal alteration
Bone is a useful indirect proxy of fire and heating conditions, as thermal alteration results in permanent changes to bone structure and chemistry which may be measured both in experimental and archaeological settings. By analyzing the properties of burnt bone, we can accumulate valuable information about the conditions under which the faunal material was thermally altered, verifying the presence of ancient fire (e.g., Berna et al. 2012) and addressing aspects of hominin pyrotechnology (e.g., Théry-Parisot 2002).
Living bone itself is comprised of the inorganic mineral bioapatite, organic proteins primarily of collagen, and water (Martin et al. 2015; Stout et al. 2019). Bone is porous, to a large extent for facilitation of Haversian systems, with trabecular bone exhibiting a higher porosity due to a more open structure (Figueiredo et al. 2010; Lyman and Lyman 1994; Stout et al. 2019). Bioapatite crystallites in vivo are characterized by a hydrated, large surface area (above 200 m2/g) necessary for the regulation of homeostasis (Berna et al. 2004; Buikstra and Swegle 1989; Drouet et al. 2018; Koeppenkastrop and Eric 1992; Martin et al. 2015; Reynard et al. 1999; Rollin-Martinet et al. 2013; Trueman et al. 2008; Ubelaker 2009), and small, plate-like morphologies (1–7 nm thick, 15–200 nm in length, 10–80 nm in width) which are cross-linked to the organic collagen fibrils (Bala et al. 2013; Berna et al. 2004; Rey et al. 2009). Water is integrated into and around the organic and mineral components but also found in void spaces and in the extracellular matrix (Drouet et al. 2018; Nyman et al. 2008).
Macroscopic properties influenced by heat include changes to fragment size, friability, texture, and mass at different temperature thresholds (Buikstra and Swegle 1989; Ellingham et al. 2015; Stiner et al. 1995; Shipman et al. 1984; Thompson 2004; Zazzo et al. 2009). These transformations are intricately linked to the chemical and structural organization of the mineral, organic, and water content of bone. While these changes are similar to modifications which occur during normal bone diagenesis, heat induced transformations above median temperatures (~ 500 °C) are more exaggerated in the extent and amount of alterations. The degree of transformation, the material properties, and the chemistry of bone exposed to heat are also related to the specific conditions under which the bone was burnt, including maximum temperatures and burning atmosphere (Ellingham et al. 2015; Gallo et al. 2021; Reidsma et al. 2016; Snoeck et al. 2014, 2016; Van Hoesel et al. 2019).
Studies have documented these specific primary structural and chemical changes to bone heated at different temperatures, including the rate of organic loss, alterations in porosity, the presence of different compounds reflective of burning atmosphere, and mineral bioapatite recrystallization and crystallite size growth (Ellingham et al. 2015; Gallo et al. 2021; Reidsma et al. 2016; Van Hoesel et al. 2019). High-resolution spectroscopic analyses such as FTIR and XRD can directly monitor these transformations to verify true burning, rather than staining, and elucidate maximum temperature thresholds and different burning atmospheric conditions (Ellingham et al. 2015; Piga et al. 2008; Shahack-Gross et al. 1997; Snoeck et al. 2016; Thompson 2004).
Four major overlapping and interconnected stages of heating which broadly describe the transformations to the mineral, organic, and water components are well documented with macroscopic, microscopic, spectroscopic, and radiometric studies for bone burnt and heated in oxygen atmospheres (Ellingham et al. 2015; Mayne Correia 1997; Thompson 2004). Combustion (heating in the presence of oxygen) is here distinguished from charring (heating without the presence of oxygen), as bones undergoing thermal alteration in full reduction atmospheres experience different changes which do not overlap neatly with their oxygenated counterparts (Reidsma et al. 2016; Van Hoesel et al. 2019; for review see Marques et al. 2021).
For bones burnt and heated with access to oxygen, stage 1, dehydration (100–600 °C), describes the evaporation of the water content of bone from within and between the organic and mineral components environments (Ellingham et al. 2015; Mayne Correia 1997; Thompson 2004). Stage 2, decomposition (300–800 °C), details the combusting and depletion of the organic portion (Ellingham et al. 2015; Mayne Correia 1997; Thompson 2004). Bone at this stage of burning loses a great deal of mass and has the highest degree of porosity, as the organic and water components have been removed and the bioapatite minerals remain small and flat (Figueiredo et al. 2010; Gallo et al. 2021; Pramanik et al. 2012). Stage 3, inversion (500–1100 °C), describes the loss of structural carbonates. Stage 4, fusion (> 700 °C, estimated have full transformation closer to 900–1000 °C), accounts for the coalescing of the remaining inorganic component (Ellingham et al. 2015; Mamede et al. 2018; Mayne Correia 1997; Thompson 2005). Bone which has undergone the fusion stage changes substantially in shape with a drastic increase in crystallite size of bioapatite, which additionally decreases porosity and produces a more crystalline structure (for review, see Ellingham et al. 2015; Gallo et al. 2021; Mamede et al. 2018).
Calcination in the context of thermally altered bone is a categorization broadly identified by white or grey coloration, due to the removal of the combusted and charred organics, but further describes micro- and nanoscopic transformations to the bone material which occur alongside the stages of burning previously outlined. Many structural and chemical changes occur during this process, including replacement of carbonates with hydroxyl groups and, even before the large-scale coalescence of the fusion stage, bioapatite growth (Etok et al. 2007; Mamede et al. 2018; Piga et al. 2016). This crystallite growth is very similar to growth seen as a part of diagenetic processes (Ostwald ripening) as crystallites evolve to more stable phases with a more ordered structure (i.e., become more crystalline) (Dal Sasso et al. 2018; Hedges 2002). The growth induced by high temperatures can be more intense than during typical diagenetic alteration, however, as after the removal of structural carbonates there are less distortions on the crystal lattice (Dal Sasso et al. 2018; Gallo et al. 2021; Mamede et al. 2018). Calcined bone for the purpose of this study is therefore defined by both the light coloration from the elimination of the combusted and charred, organic components (Ellingham et al. 2015; Ramirez-Gutierrez et al. 2017) but also the rapid transformation of the mineral phase with high temperature exposure: loss of structural carbonates, shifting vibrational frequencies of the bone mineral reflecting differing chemical compositions, large average crystallite sizes, and the corresponding high crystallinity indicating more ordered crystals and low lattice strain (Ellingham et al. 2015; Gallo et al. 2021; Mamede et al. 2018; Marques et al. 2018).
The reported temperatures under which bones are calcined varies, likely due to different experimental variables including the initial status of bone sampled, temperature steps utilized, and method of measurement (Table 2; Ravaglioli et al. 1996; Snoeck et al. 2014).
Color changes in thermally altered bone
The connections between burning stages and visible color are most clearly seen in reference to the state of organic decomposition, as the dark coloration (dark brown or black) of burnt bone is reflective of the charred or carbonized organic content (Snoeck et al. 2014). Dark brown and black surface colorations can also be indicative of discoloration or staining (from mineral manganese, soil, wood tannins, and/or the depositional environment) and not indicative of burning (Bradfield 2018; Dupras and Schultz 2014; Nicholson, 1993; Pollock et al. 2018; Shahack-Gross et al. 1997; Turner et al. 2018). For example, fauna can gain a saturated brown hue when in soils with high humic content (Dupras and Schultz 2014). White coloration occurs at higher temperatures associated primarily with calcination due to the elimination of the organic char, but bone can also become stark white in color with prolonged exposure to UV radiation (Dupras and Schultz 2014). This process, known as sun bleaching, also achieves depigmentation through the removal of organics with UV radiation (Dupras and Schultz 2014).
The color changes of heated bone are widely recognized, with many scholars noting that a sequence of color gradients can be connected broadly to different intensities of burning and heating, i.e., carbonized/charred and calcined (Costamagno et al. 2005, 2009; Ellingham et al. 2015; Shipman et al. 1984; Stiner et al. 1995). Observations of these color changes have established widely used zooarchaeological scales of heating, such as the Stiner et al. (1995) scale which utilizes macroscopic cues of color to indicate > / < 50% charred and > / < 50% calcined (Table 3). Studies which report and investigate heating through zooarchaeological methods often utilize these scales and similar schema to categorize the burning variability within an assemblage.
Colorimetric studies that consider the hue (brightness) and chromatic qualities (color) alone to discern attributes such as temperature of thermal alteration in burnt bone have been demonstrated to be unreliable, however (Bradfield 2018; Fredericks et al. 2015). These issues are reasonably understood in the context of archaeological staining and depigmentation, as well as through an understanding of the origin of bone coloration. The changing color gradients within burnt bone at increasing temperatures reflect the charring and removal of the organic component and are not specifically tied to the temperature itself. Exemplifying these issues with coloration are studies which observe in laboratory settings bones that are black and brown after being heated at temperatures above 700 °C without access to oxygen, when white coloration is expected at temperatures ≥ 700 °C when bone is burned in the presence of oxygen (Marques et al. 2021; Reidsma et al. 2016; Walker et al. 2008). Oxygen is not needed to create the changes to the organic composition seen ~ 300 °C known as char, but oxygen is necessary for combustion, in which the char and present volatiles oxidize (Braadbaart et al. 2007; 2012; Reidsma et al. 2016). Further, in these anaerobic conditions, amorphous inorganic carbon is produced in these bone samples, contributing to the dark black coloration (Marques et al. 2021).
Solely utilizing color, therefore, can be problematic in studies utilizing bone as an indirect proxy for fire. It is only with consideration of other heat related variables and characteristics, such as surface warping and texture, weight and porosity transitions, and spectroscopic or radiometric measures of bioapatite transformation (including crystal size growth and shifts in the chemical arrangement) that heat alteration can be verified, and relative thresholds of burning conditions can be distinguished.
Evaluation of duration effects in prior experimental studies
Previous studies addressing the thermal alteration of bone have not systematically evaluated the impact of prolonged duration times. Prior experiments have incorporated a range of lengths when assessing questions of temperature intensity (Ellingham et al. 2016; Gallo et al. 2021; Reidsma et al. 2016; Shipman et al. 1984; Snoeck et al. 2014; Van Hoesel et al. 2019), burial environments (Bennett 1999; Herman and Bennett 1999; Stiner et al. 1995), carbon exchange (Snoeck and Schulting, 2013; Snoeck et al. 2014) and burning atmospheres (Marques et al. 2021; Reidsma et al. 2016; Van Hoesel et al. 2019; Table 4). Many studies utilizing durations limited to 1–3 hours have reported that time length of heat exposure has little impact on the transformations to bone mineral at different temperatures (Ellingham et al. 2016; Gallo et al. 2021; Krap et al. 2019). It is challenging to compare these results to experiments which do have duration times that exceed 3 hours, as many of these studies do not include spectroscopic data to provide insight into the degree of chemical and structural alterations (Table 4). This pattern is likely due to the relatively recent advancements in the ease of spectroscopic analyses for archaeological and experimental application and because of the difficulty of sustaining prolonged heating experiments at high temperatures.
Discrepancies found between the different studies working with thermally altered bone, such as the reports of calcination from underground burning experiments in Bennett (1999) that recorded a maximum temperature of 506 °C, but not in Stiner et al. (1995), may be explained by considering the impact of length of the heat exposure and the initial status of the bone components (i.e., fresh or weathered) at time of the experiment (Bennett 1999; Ramirez-Gutierrez et al. 2017; Stiner et al. 1995). Additional factors which must be considered and vary between studies include fragment size and thickness, an initial status of powdered or solid bone, the degree of flesh covering, differences within and between species, and, potentially, duration.
An advantage in utilizing ATR-FTIR is that spectra characterizing the vibrations of bonds within the sample reflecting heat and diagenesis induced changes can be produced with minimal sample preparation (Beasley et al. 2014; Dal Sasso et al. 2018; Ellingham et al. 2015, 2016; Gallo et al. 2021; Gianfrate et al. 2007; Lebon et al. 2014; Lebon et al. 2016). These spectra provide semi-quantitative measures of bone composition that reflect structural and chemical changes induced by heat, such as specific peaks representing new chemical compounds and peak changes that correspond to higher degrees of crystallinity due to increasing bioapatite mineral order, size, and strain (Ellingham et al. 2015; Gallo et al. 2021; Mamede et al. 2018; Snoeck et al. 2014; Weiner and Bar Yosef 1990). The changes in width of diffraction peaks in XRD patterns provides complementary information on the sizes of bioapatite crystallites which experience substantial growth at temperatures > 650 °C (Ellingham et al. 2015; Etok et al. 2007; Figueiredo et al. 2010; Gallo et al. 2021; Pramanik et al. 2013; Ramirez-Gutierrez et al. 2017).
Materials and methods
Sample preparation and experimental methods
Cortical bone of bovid (Bos taurus) femurs, humeri, and radii were obtained from a local butcher (Fleischerei Engeln, Leipzig, Germany) to be utilized in this study. At time of purchase the bones segments were never frozen, and criteria for bone selection included the present bone availability and freshness. Bones were sourced in several waves so that samples for this study were only stored for a maximum of three days after purchase to preserve fresh cortical bone mechanical properties (Zhang et al. 2018), and trial order was determined by this time limitation. Each bone prepared was given a unique identifying label (A-L, SI Table 1).
The domesticated cow long bones were mechanically scraped of remaining flesh and periosteum and the diaphysis portions were cored utilizing a PROXXON Rotary Tool MICROMOT 60/EF drill with a Dremel 663 ¼ inch Diamond grit drill bit (SI Table 1). Resulting solid cortical bone core diameters were therefore standardized at ~ 4 mm, and length measurements varied between 2 and 7 mm, with an average of 3.92 mm (n = 240; Fig. 1). Bone cores of this size were chosen as heat would uniformly impact the entire sample. All samples were stored wrapped in saline (NaCl 0.9%) soaked gauze to maintain a hydrated state following removal of the periosteum and refrigerated at temperatures around 4 °C (Zhang et al. 2018). Bone segments for each trial were selected as to not be from the same element (e.g., both segments from the same left femur), but potentially could represent different elements of the same living animal (e.g., the left and right femur of the same animal).
Bone tissues sourced from different species are observed to have small differences in bone hierarchical organization and in bone organic composition. The chemical formula for bioapatite itself is acknowledged to have small variances related to element and ion substitutions. Such variance is common even within bones and elements of a single species, however. As this study is primarily concerned with the changes to bone mineral crystals and the rate of organic loss, the use of bovid bone as a medium is not considered to be a problematic factor here and results can be broadly compared to prior studies using bone tissue from different species.
For each trial cores from three different bone segments (labeled A–L) were positioned in a crucible with the intention of randomizing the variables related to the natural state of the animal raw material that are outside of direct experimental control (SI Table 1). Each of the three bone cores were arranged approximately 1 cm distance from each other in consistent placements relative to labeling information on the crucible surface for later identification and retrieval (Fig. 2). For six of the trials, a layer of bone samples were also buried − 2 cm under the surface of the substrate (Table 5). Ceramic crucibles were 8 cm in maximum diameter and were filled either with substrates of loosely packed gravel (2–4 mm) or compacted gravel with fine quartz sand (1/8–1/4 mm) to emulate sediments with different heat retention properties (Fig. 2; Table 5).
Heating trials were designed to observe three temperature thresholds: 300 °C, a moderate temperature well beneath published temperatures of calcination; 550 °C, to test the brink of the calcination boundary; and 750 °C, firmly within the range of calcination. Length of trials were selected to represent a quick heating event for example during a grass wildfire (10 minutes) with expected minimal alteration, a fire event of a moderate length (9 hours) and a long length (48 hours) exceeding alterations currently reported with spectroscopic analyses in the literature. Inferences on moderate and long anthropogenic fire events were drawn from reported data on hunter-gatherer fires, of which include quick hunting or meal roasting fires, daily fires centered around an activity, and communal cooking fires which are kept continuously burning for days (Henry et al. 2018; Mallol et al. 2007). Trials were completed in a muffle furnace, programmed to reach desired temperature at the fastest rate achievable by the instrument (~ 25 °C/60 s) and to hold temperature for the length of the experiment (SI Fig. 48). Temperatures were monitored through the instrument display, and there is not an internal ventilation system. The muffle furnace was allowed to cool at a natural rate before samples were removed, mirroring the slow heat dissipation of an extinguished fire event (SI Figs. 48 and 49).
Sample analyses
Bone color was documented with a color matching tool on all bone cores post heating and prior to powdering with an agate mortar and pestle (Munsell Color (Firm), 2010).
ATR-FTIR and XRD instruments are used here to monitor the transformations that occur to bone mineral with heat and to evaluate changes in crystallinity. XRD specifically can provide information on the average size of the growing crystals even after the ATR-FTIR peak ratios related to crystallinity decrease above 800–900 °C when the lattice organization significantly alters. ATR-FTIR spectra (4000–400 cm−1) were produced with a Nicolet 6700 Fourier transform infrared spectrometer equipped with a deuterated triglycine (DTGS) detector and a single bounce diamond crystal. ATR was specifically utilized to minimize sample preparation, and contamination (Bruno 1999; Hollund et al. 2013; Thompson et al. 2009; Nakamoto 2009). 256 scans were collected with a sample gain of 8 and resolution of 4 cm−1.
To assess organic content and calcination, eight peaks and peak transformations were collected for all samples in this study (n = 234), and all measurements and equations were standardized and processed using OMNIC Macros Basic software (Tables 6 and 7). The CO/P ratio was monitored for the relative concentrations of organic components in bone, as this measurement assesses the functional group recognized as Amide I, a component of collagen proteins (Thompson et al. 2013; Mamede et al. 2018). Another measurement, the carbonate to phosphate (C/P) ratio, is utilized to understand the relative amount and loss of structural lattice carbonates within the sample (Thompson et al. 2013; Mamede et al. 2018). For reconstructing the degree of crystallinity (crystal order and lattice strain), a measure known as the infrared splitting factor (IRSF or SF) captures the splitting of the PO43− v4 peak in bone, a trough which lengthens with increasing crystallinity until heat transformation above 800–900 °C, when the SF ratio experiences a decrease (Mamede et al. 2018; Weiner and Bar-Yosef 1990). This decrease is related to the chemical and structural changes with the fusion stage of bone mineral transformation, as bioapatite crystals melt and sinter (Mamede et al. 2018; Piga et al. 2018).
Finally, the appearance of two shoulders on different phosphate peaks indicate compositional changes within the chemical structure of the bone mineral which occur solely with high temperatures (~ 700–1100 °C) including the growth of a shoulder at ~ 1090 cm−1 off the PO43− v3 peak suggested to be the presence of francolite and a ratio measured from a shoulder at ~ 625 cm−1 on the PO43− v4 peak known as the phosphate high temperature (PHT) shoulder indicating an OH- librational mode associated with hydrogen bonding within the crystalline framework (Gallo et al. 2021; Mamede et al. 2013; Marques et al. 2018; Thompson et al. 2013).
To determine average crystallite size, diffraction peaks were obtained with a Bruker D2 Phaser diffractometers using CuKα radiation and run from 7 to 70° 2θ with 0.04° step and 0.02 θ increment. Divergent slits were set at 0.6 mm with a 1 mm anti-scatter screen, and a maximum opening of position sensitive detector (4.8°). The powdered bone samples were spread with ethanol on a zero background silicon holder. Average crystallite size was refined with whole pattern fitting (Rietveld refinement Rietveld 1969) using hydroxyapatite Ca5(PO4)3OH structure (space group P63/m) with the GSAS-2 package (Toby and Von Dreele 2013).
Results
Color
Color observations are represented through the Munsell values given by color matching tool (Munsell Color (Firm), 2010). For the 10 minute duration trials, at 300 °C (T2A, T2B) bones from all crucibles were shades of browns, ranging from pale to darker hues including grey-brown (Fig. 3). At 550 °C for 10 minutes (T4), bones were categorized as darker greys, and at 750 °C (T5) heat altered bones were shades of light greys and whites (Fig. 3; SI Figs. 1–47).
For the 9 hour duration trials, bones heated at 300 °C still were recognized as brown in color, although considerably lighter browns and less saturated hues than the 10 minute trials (Fig. 3). At 550 °C for 9 hours (T3A, T3B), a range of greys including blueish-grey and brownish-greys were recognized (Fig. 3). These samples are very light in coloration and are likely, given standard scales of zooarchaeological classification, to be considered heated at a higher temperature based on visual observation. At 750 °C for 9 hours all heated samples were stark white and very desaturated greys as expected (Fig. 3).
Bones heated for 48 hours at 300 °C (T7) were very pale, resembling light tans and pale greys (Fig. 3). This degree of depigmentation would additionally be difficult to classify given the established color classification schemes for burnt bone, and may be mistaken to have experienced high temperatures and calcination based solely on coloration. A similar scenario is also seen in the bones heated at 550 °C for 48 hours (T1). All samples from this trial range from whites to light greys, with multiple samples determined as bluish-grey (Fig. 3).
All bones excluding 300 °C for 9 hours (T6) and 300° C for 10 min (T2A, T2B) would be likely classified as Stiner et al. (1995) Stage 6 based on coloration (white, grey, and heavily muted pale tans).
FTIR results
Ten-minute trials
Four trials were conducted with duration times of 10 min: 300 °C with dry, loose gravel (T2A), 300 °C with dry compacted gravel and fine sand (T2B), 550 °C in dry loose gravel (T4), and 750 °C in dry loose gravel (T5). At 300 °C, bones exhibited strong presence of Amide I and II (1630–1660 cm−1), relevant to their strong organic tissue and water content, and have CO32− v3 peak heights similar to fresh, unburnt bone (1400–1550 cm−1), typical of bones burnt to this temperature for brief durations (Gallo et al. 2021; Fig. 4). For both 300 °C trials, there is no indication of high temperature alteration, primarily seen through the low SF ratio (565 and 605 cm−1 peaks and the 595 cm−1 trough) and the absence of a PO43− v3 shoulder or a PHT shoulder at 1090 cm−1 and 625 cm−1, respectively (Fig. 4).
At 550 °C for 10 minutes, much of the organic components and the lattice carbonates have been eliminated from the samples as seen in the 1630–1660 cm−1 and 1400–1550 cm−1 wavelength regions (Fig. 4). This is consistent with the described first release of carbonates (CO2) from organic combustion, but not full structural carbonate loss (Etok et al. 2007; Mamede et al. 2018). Despite the dehydration and carbonate loss, the physical and chemical structure of the bioapatite here has not radically changed and there are no indications of high temperature alteration or calcination when referencing the SF, the 1090 cm−1 shoulder off the 1030 cm−1 peak, or the PHT shoulder (Fig. 4). This spectrum is typical of bone burned to this temperature threshold for brief durations (Gallo et al. 2021).
For the highest temperature threshold, 750 °C, major changes are seen when compared to the lower temperatures. At 750 °C, all organics and water are eliminated and for the CO32− v3 functional group (the structural lattice carbonate within the bone), there is either a complete absence or a barely present small doublet absorption (Fig. 4). Off the PO43− v3 peak at 1030 cm−1 there is a strong presence of a shoulder at 1090 cm−1, linked to high temperature alteration also seen in bones burnt for short durations between 700 and 1100 °C (Gallo et al. 2021; Thompson et al. 2013; Fig. 4). For the PO43− v4 peak area there is both a strong presence of a PHT shoulder as well as a much deeper trough at 595 cm−1 between the 565 and 605 cm−1 peaks which constitute a measurement of crystallinity through the SF ratio (Table 6; Fig. 4). These spectra are clearly calcined and exhibit a higher crystallinity than the samples burnt at 550 °C and 300 °C.
Nine-hour trials
Four additional trials were completed at 9 hours of sustained temperature duration: 300 °C in dry loose gravel (T6), 550 °C in both dry loose gravel (T3A) and dry compacted gravel and fine sand (T3B), and 750 °C in dry loose gravel (T8). For the lowest temperature experiment, the primary difference seen between the 9 hour and 10 minute trials is the depletion of the organic content as monitored by the Amide I and II functional group areas (1630–1660 cm−1; Fig. 5). This is similar to the degree of reduced organics seen in archaeological bone, where organics are depleted through normal diagenetic processes (Gallo et al. 2021). There remains a strong presence of the lattice carbonate, and there is no high temperature shoulder at 1090 cm−1 nor a PHT shoulder (Fig. 5). The infrared SF remains low and is not indicative of a highly crystalline sample nor of calcination (Fig. 5).
Samples heat altered at 550 °C show no influence from the different substrates and have a lower organic presence than both the 300 °C, 9 hour trial (T6) and the 550 °C, 10 minute trial (T4). Weakly present shoulders emerge for both the 1090 cm−1 area off of the 1030 cm−1 PO43− v3 peak and the PHT shoulder off of the PO43− v4 peak, which are not found in the 550 °C 10 minute trial (T4). There are also deepened troughs at 595 cm−1 which results in a higher SF ratio, but these spectra do not indicate samples which have been fully calcined (Fig. 5).
For the 750 °C trial, again we see clearly calcined bone with spectroscopic signatures of high temperature alteration through the very large splitting factor ratio on the PO43− v4 peak, the PHT shoulder, and the PO43− v3 1090 cm−1 shoulder (Fig. 5). There are also no remaining organics as seen through the predicted Amide I and II functional group area (1630–1660 cm−1) and there is only a small remaining doublet regarding the CO32− v3 area (Fig. 5).
Forty-eight-hour trials
Two trials, 300 °C (T7) and 550 °C (T1), were held at steady temperature for 48 hours. Elevated temperatures also continued for a substantial cooling period after the 48 hour set experiment, as temperatures slowly disseminated for over 7 hours (SI Figs. 48 and 49). For the 300 °C trial (T7), crucibles were filled with dry, loose gravel, and for the 550 °C trial (T1) four crucibles had a dry, loose gravel sediment base, and four had dry, compacted gravel with fine sand.
Bones heated at 300 °C for 48 hours show reduced organics in the 1630–1660 cm−1 wavelength region when compared to their 10 minute counterparts (Fig. 6). There are no indications of calcination on any part of the spectra, however, neither in the PO43− v3 peak area nor in the PO43− v4 region through the splitting factor ratio or in the presence of a PHT shoulder (Fig. 6).
At 550 °C for 48 hours (T1), two different signatures are seen within the same trial. This pattern of differential alteration is potentially correlated with crucible placement within the furnace, as crucibles farthest from the furnace door (crucibles 1, 2, 5, and 6) exhibited the greatest amount of heat induced transformations with both the presence of the PHT shoulder, the PO43− v3 shoulder at 1090 cm−1, and elevated SF ratios (Fig. 6). These changes are not seen in the bones within crucibles near the door of the furnace, indicating that potentially temperatures varied within the same experimental trial (SI Figs. 50 and 51). This observation validates the selection of 550 °C as a temperature of interest, as it rests on a margin very close to temperatures capable of reaching full structural and chemical calcination in samples with prolonged heating. For all bones in this trial a small doublet peak representing the likely functional group of structural lattice carbonates, the CO32− v3 peak area at 1400–1550 cm−1, remains (Fig. 6). In an experimental reference collection utilizing the same FTIR-ATR instrument the full elimination of these carbonates was indeed not seen until temperatures above 900 °C are reached (Gallo et al. 2021). This indicates that despite the presence of heat induced changes to the mineral portion of the bone seen in the 550 °C, 48 hour trial (T1), a small amount of lattice carbonates remained (Gallo et al. 2021).
Summary of FTIR results
In sum, the results of the ATR-FTIR spectra for the short-term (10 minute duration) thermal alteration trials follow general expectations for each temperature threshold on the timing of heat induced stages to bone, dehydration, decomposition, inversion, and fusion. In the 10 minute trial, bones heated at 300 °C retain their organic components, at 550 °C have depleted organics and lattice carbonate, and at 750 °C have fully lost organics and the lattice carbonate (Figs. 7 and 8). With the 9 hour trial, the 300 °C trial results clearly indicate the further loss of organics, finally reaching depleted levels in range of 550 and 750 °C level of thermal alteration with 48 hours of prolonged heating (Fig. 7). Lattice carbonates are also further altered at 300 °C with long durations (9 and 48 hours), but do not reach the levels of 550 or 750 °C at any duration time (Fig. 8). This shows that low temperature prolonged heating of bone reaches the end of the decomposition stage and effectively the start of inversion stages without reaching higher temperatures.
The crystallinity of bone heated at 300 °C for long durations (here 9 and 48 hours) does not increase, as seen by the stable SF ratios (Fig. 9). These values demonstrate that these 300 °C samples do not experience the final stages of inversion and fusion representing bioapatite crystal growth. They are therefore not calcined, despite pale coloration. The SF ratio does increase in the 550 °C and 750 °C trials at 9 hours when compared to their 10 minute counterparts (Fig. 9). Bone thermally altered for 48 hours at 550 °C show even larger SF values, as some begin the fusion stages of thermal alteration (Fig. 9). In the 750 °C for 48 hour trial, bones experience an expected decrease in SF ratio (Fig. 9). This is expected with thermal alteration, although usually seen at temperatures greater than 900 °C (Gallo et al. 2021), as the bone mineral lattice transforms to the extent that the SF ratio no longer represents the relative size of the bioapatite crystals. The decreasing ratio seen for prolonged heating at 750 °C therefore represents tremendous growth of the bioapatite crystals in the fusion phases of bone thermal alteration.
SF values were further tested between differences of sediment (gravel or compacted gravel with fine quartz sand) and placement within the crucible (surface or buried at − 2 cm) for Trial 1. We first tested for normality using Shapiro–Wilk tests and the data was plotted to visually assess the distributions. T-tests were further used to evaluate both categories, and both showed that there is insufficient evidence to reject a null hypothesis of no difference for both variables (p = 0.98 for sediment, p = 0.27 for placement).
The presence of the heat-induced shoulder, measured with the PHT ratio, on the PO43− v3 peak at 1090 cm−1 is seen in both 750 °C trials as well as with a weak expression in all 550 °C/9 hour trials (T3A and T3B). For the 48 hour at 550 °C trial (T1), this peak at 1090 cm−1 is seen fully present in the crucibles located at the back of the furnace (crucibles 1, 2, 5, and 6), with weak expression in the front crucibles near the furnace door (crucibles 3, 4, 7, and 8; Fig. 6; SI Figs. 50 and 51). The PHT ratio unsurprisingly highest in both 750 °C trials (Fig. 10). The combination of PHT and SF ratios supports the inference that the 750 °C/48 hour bone samples have very large crystal growth, as despite the lower SF ratio the PHT is unaffected and remains high (Fig. 11). Utilizing SF ratios in combination with other peak transformations related to high temperature alteration can assist with interpretations which would be difficult to assess using the SF ratio alone.
XRD results
The average crystallite sizes as measured by XRD provide an independent calculation of average bioapatite crystallite growth, and therefore, heat-induced transformation. Results align closely with inferences taken from the ATR-FTIR spectroscopic data, with samples heated for 9 and 48 hours at 300° not experiencing growth in average crystallite sizes beyond reference samples burned either for 30 minutes or 1 hour and 30 minutes (Fig. 12, SI Figs. 52 and 53).
Samples from the 550 °C trials at 9 hour also have average crystallite sizes similar to 30 minutes and 1 hour 30 minutes reference counterparts (Gallo et al. 2021; Fig. 12). With 48 hours, 550 °C samples show a range of crystallite sizes bridging the divide between bones which are and are not calcined at 30 minutes or 1 hour and 30 minutes (Gallo et al. 2021; Fig. 12). This also mirrors the ATR-FTIR spectral inferences, and samples with large crystal sizes do match the same samples which have high SF and PHT values from these trials.
Drastic crystallite growth is seen for 9 hours at 750 °C (T8) samples (Fig. 12). These large bioapatite minerals clearly show separation from bones burnt at lower temperatures both at the same duration and longer durations (Fig. 12). Bone cores burnt under these conditions demonstrate average crystallite sizes larger than twice the size of referential samples burned at 700 °C and even 1000 °C (Gallo et al. 2021). Such increase in crystallite size but without full elimination of the lattice carbonate functional group as seen in the ATR-FTIR spectra may indicate long duration heating at temperatures above calcination but where the carbonates have been completely removed as seen from reference spectra heated at 30 minutes and 1 hour and 30 minutes (Gallo et al. 2021). This observation indicates that long duration fires at high temperatures can likely be recognized archaeologically, despite all calcined samples not having any macroscopic coloration differences to distinguish them.
Discussion
The duration of an anthropogenic fire is deeply relevant and interconnected to fire function, construction, and maintenance. Additionally, as grass and brush wildfires are predominately rapid events, prolonged thermal alteration in bone can be a variable useful for assessing between likely natural or anthropogenic fire traces in certain environments (Buenger 2003; Gowlett et al. 2017; Table 1). Relative duration lengths in this way can provide a crucial lens for interpreting and understanding the properties of ancient fire which impacted heat altered bone in archaeological assemblages. This study explicitly includes heating length as an experimental variable to evaluate the degree of transformation in bone material at different temperatures. We find that by using the threshold of structural and chemical calcination, detected with spectroscopic and radiometric methods (ATR-FTIR, XRD), and macroscopic observations of coloration, duration of heating does impact properties of cortical bone in ways that can be measured and applied to the archaeological record, and are not seen in experimental studies using heating times around 3 hours or less (Table 4; Fig. 13).
The results of this study indicate that the timing of alterations with prolonged heat can be distinguished at different temperature thresholds (Fig. 13). Long-duration heating in air depletes the combusted organic content of bone at lower temperatures (here seen in samples heated at 300 °C for 9 and 48 hours) and therefore changes the visible color (Fig. 1 and 3, SI Figs. 1–47). These long duration but low temperature bones potentially would be evaluated by archaeologists to be calcined based on visual cues alone. The depigmentation and organic depletion from prolonged heat duration, and not calcination, can be observed here through the ATR-FTIR CO/P ratio (Fig. 7). The lowering CO/P ratio for bones heated at 300 °C 9 and 48 hours is seen to correlate with the loss of pigmentation as the combusted organic char is eliminated. Therefore, the recognition of thermally altered bones which are muted white, grey, and tan in color as represented from the Munsell color schema therefore are not always directly representative of high temperatures and calcination, but may also result low temperatures at long durations.
The average crystallite sizes monitored by XRD support the ATR-FTIR data, and can distinguish samples burned for 10 minutes and 9 hours at 750 °C (Figs. 12 and 13). The samples burned for 9 hours at 750 °C even experience crystal growth not seen at temperatures 700–1200 °C burned for either 30 minutes to 1 hour and 30 minutes in a referential sample (Fig. 12).
To summarize, with prolonged heating of 9 hours, bone heated at 300 °C shows less organic content than the 10 minute counterparts, correlating with the CO/P ratio, and also experiences a loss in structural carbonate, represented by the CP ratio (Figs. 7, 8, and 13). At 550 °C for 9 hours, bone also loses structural carbonate that is not seen in briefer heating events at the same temperature (Figs. 8 and 13). The organic component of these bones has already been depleted when brought to temperatures above 300 °C (Fig. 7). At a duration of 9 hours, bones thermally altered at 750 °C experience a tremendous growth in average crystallite sizes, more than double the sizes of bones kept at 750 °C for 10 minutes (Figs. 12 and 13).
At 48 hours of thermal exposure at 300 °C, bones are pale in color as any remaining organic content has been eliminated, but they are not calcined (Figs. 7 and 13). For 48 hours at 550 °C, some bones do become structurally and chemically calcined, although this is not seen uniformly throughout all samples, indicating that this trial temperature and duration is very close to the energetic conditions necessary to for bones to calcine (Figs. 7, 8, 9, 10, 12, and 13).
Our results also indicate that these observations can be used to recognize archaeological bone which has experienced prolonged heating. This is as all metrics considered here can be discerned from aspects of diagenesis, including crystallinity growth. Diagenetic crystal growth cannot reach the sizes measured by XRD for the prolonged heating at 750 °C, and diagenesis cannot cause the heat induced transformations what are seen to accompany calcination like the PHT peak visible in ATR-FTIR spectra.
Limitations predicted in detecting prolonged heating in archaeological bone do include issues of equifinality with different combinations of temperatures and heating lengths, as well as the impact of exogenous carbonate inclusions. This may make it challenging to assign specific temperatures or exact durations in archaeological settings. Despite this uncertainty, research investigating thermally altered archaeological bone can certainly investigate relative thresholds of duration times when discrepancies in pigmentation and bone structure and chemistry are seen, i.e., pale white or tan bones which are not calcined. Prolonged heating within bone samples which are calcined can also use the exponential crystallite growth documented in this study, as the average crystallite sizes are above what is possible to be reached in natural settings at short durations (Fig. 12). These observations can contribute valuable data even if it is not possible to discern with great confidence the exact duration length.
For integration into zooarchaeological methodology, we therefore recommend conducting spectroscopic testing primarily with ATR-FTIR on white, pale tan, and grey archaeological burned bone classified as calcined based on the macroscopic color evaluations. The purpose of this screening is to test for true signals of structural and chemical calcination: the presence of high temperature dependent peaks, high calculated SF ratio, little to no organic content. If they are not calcined, this would be a strong indication of depigmentation from long duration heating at temperature below the calcination threshold. Alternative scenarios which may result in light coloration of archaeological bone without burning is limited to processes such as sun bleaching, but these specimens can be distinguished from bones exposed to heat for long durations by differences in surface texture (Behrensmeyer 1978; Dupras and Schultz 2014; Shipman 1989).
Subsequent to the spectroscopic testing, we suggest XRD analyses on the verified calcined archaeological bones to calculate and compare to average crystallite sizes of referential assemblages. This is to infer the extent of the bioapatite transformations and to detect heating at high temperatures for extended time periods. Sampling strategies will likely fluctuate considering the different parameters and conditions of the archaeological assemblage, but large sampling procedures are made reasonable by the relatively low cost, minimal sample material, and minimal preparation needed for these analyses. The average crystallite sizes measured with XRD in this study for samples burned at 750 °C for 9 hours indicates how duration length of archaeological samples which would all be considered to fall within the same category of burning based on visual identification, calcination, can be distinguished. This would include all bones identified as Stage 6 following the Stiner et al. (1995) burning scale.
Future research, including work done in cremation studies, can provide further context on the threshold of these structural and chemical changes. Studies can also address the internal variation of temperature distribution in heating instruments to investigate internal variances in samples tested within the same experimental conditions. Work done to more precisely illustrate the timing of long-duration heat exposure at lower temperatures considering organic depletion and color changes, and at high temperatures measuring extreme crystallite growth, can contribute to the development prediction models to address the issues of equifinality and uncertainty for archaeological detection and interpretation.
The results of this study of short-term heating (10 minutes) on cortical bone tissue are found to be consistent with prior work characterizing heat alteration to bone and the timing of the stages of transformations (Table 4). The results of the trials investigating prolonged heat exposure do present new evidence for colorimetric studies and provide context for discrepancies within the burned bone literature. Calcination based on visible bone coloration alone in prior experiments (which did not reach temperatures above 700 °C and did not conduct spectroscopic analyses) potentially indicate bone which was depigmented due to depletion of organics achieved through prolonged duration of heating and not true structural and chemical calcination. Much like recent perspectives on colorimetric approaches to identifying burnt bone, this study therefore also recommends coloration in a supporting role to the spectroscopic and chemical investigations (Bradfield 2018; Krap et al. 2019).
For application of results to anthropological questions of hominin fire using behavior we recommend the inclusion of the zooarchaeological approach outlined here as a component of the microcontextual approach for investigating anthropogenic fire. This framework evaluates multiple independent lines of evidence for thermal alteration and crucially considers information within micromorphological thin sections. The detection of prolonged heating in bones cannot confidently identify anthropogenic fire alone, but when considered alongside their depositional context can provide valuable data on minimal duration times and maximum temperatures for integrated studies considering hominin pyrotechnology.
Conclusions
Duration times of anthropogenic fire are integrally related to the social, economic, and technological behaviors most important to understanding hominin fire use and control. Results from these experiments suggest that prolonged heating does impact and transform bone in distinguishable ways, as monitored with ATR-FTIR and XRD, from shorter duration counterparts at the same temperature. Thermally altered bone therefore provides a minimal measure of the length of a fire event. The identification of long duration fire impacted bones in archaeological settings can also help researchers more confidently distinguish between wildfire events and combustion features of variable duration within a microcontextual framework.
This present study intersects with study of bone as an indirect fire proxy and the greater zooarchaeological recognition of calcination. Calcined bone is a reliable source of inorganic C-14 for radiocarbon dating as the large bioapatite crystals of true calcined bone provide protections from diagenetic substitutions of carbon (Lanting et al. 2001; Zazzo and Saliege 2011). Our results call for caution in solely macroscopic identification of calcination, primarily white and light coloration. This is exemplified by the light tan and muted grey color of bones produced by prolonged heating of 48 hours at 300 °C. Bone which is muted in color and can be recognized as heated or burnt through other visible cues (e.g., surface texture, weight) but without the chemical or structural signatures of high heat alteration and calcination can therefore be explored further as examples of prolonged heating at low temperatures. Bone which is also recognized as white in coloration but has average crystallite sizes greater than 150 nm also can likely indicate prolonged heating at higher temperatures. Methodological recommendations resulting from this study are therefore to systematically use both color classifications and investigations into structural and chemical compositions to sample thermally altered faunal assemblages. This approach can combine the ease of analysis of traditional zooarchaeological methodologies, which first classify burnt bone based on macroscopic observations, alongside a sampling strategy of spectroscopic and radiometric methods.
Alongside the data presented here, future research on prolonged heating must also consider the starting condition of bone (i.e., fresh or weathered), different diagenetic conditions, and different types of bone tissue and species variability to fully understand the material properties of thermally altered bone and the full potential of this indirect fire proxy to extrapolate behaviors of fire using hominins.
Data Availability
Peak heights collected from FTIR-ATR spectra, which are utilized for the equations in this study, are provided in the supplementary materials. XRD spectra of sampled specimens, XRD grain size data, and full color photographs of bones from each trial, including information on the tested depth and sediment, are also available in the supplementary materials.
Data availability
All data generated or analyzed during this study are included in this published article (and its supplementary information files).
Code availability
Not applicable.
Change history
25 September 2023
A Correction to this paper has been published: https://doi.org/10.1007/s12520-023-01861-x
References
Bailey AW, Anderson ML (1980) Fire temperatures in grass, shrub and aspen forest communities of central Alberta. Rangeland Ecol Manag/J Range Manag Arch 33(1):37–40
Bala Y, Farlay D, Boivin G (2013) Bone mineralization: from tissue to crystal in normal and pathological contexts. Osteoporos Int 24(8):2153–2166
Beasley MM, Bartelink EJ, Taylor L, Miller RM (2014) Comparison of transmission FTIR, ATR, and DRIFT spectra: implications for assessment of bone bioapatite diagenesis. J Archaeol Sci 46:16–22
Behrensmeyer AK (1978) Taphonomic and ecologic information from bone weathering. Paleobiology 4(2):150–162
Bellomo RV (1993) A methodological approach for identifying archaeological evidence of fire resulting from human activities. J Archaeol Sci 20(5):525–553
Bennett JL (1999) Thermal alteration of buried bone. J Archaeol Sci 26(1):1–8
Berna F, Matthews A, Weiner S (2004) Solubilities of bone mineral from archaeological sites: the recrystallization window. J Archaeol Sci 31(7):867–882
Berna F, Goldberg P, Horwitz LK, Brink J, Holt S, Bamford M, Chazan M (2012) Microstratigraphic evidence of in situ fire in the Acheulean strata of Wonderwerk Cave, Northern Cape province, South Africa. Proc Natl Acad Sci 109(20):E1215–E1220
Braadbaart F, Wright PJ, van der Horst J, Boon JJ (2007) A laboratory simulation of the carbonization of sunflower achenes and seeds. J Anal Appl Pyrol 78(2):316–327
Braadbaart F, Poole I, Huisman HD, van Os B (2012) Fuel, fire and heat: an experimental approach to highlight the potential of studying ash and char remains from archaeological contexts. J Archaeol Sci 39(4):836–847
Bradfield J (2018) Some thoughts on bone artefact discolouration at archaeological sites. J Archaeol Sci Rep 17:500–509
Bruno TJ (1999) Sampling accessories for infrared spectrometry. Appl Spectrosc Rev 34(1–2):91–120
Buenger BA (2003) The impact of wildland and prescribed fire on archaeological resources. Dissertation, University of Kansas
Buikstra JE, Swegle M (1989) Bone modification due to burning: experimental evidence. In: Bonnichsen R, Sorg M (eds) Bone Modification, Center for the Study of the First Americans, institute for Quaternary Studies, University of Main, Ororo, pp 247–258
Costamagno S, Thery-Parisot I, Brugal JP, Guibert R (2005) Taphonomic consequences of the use of bones as fuel. Experimental data and archaeological applications. In: O'Connor T (ed) Biosphere to lithosphere: new studies in vertebrate taphonomy, Oxbrow Books, Oxford, pp 51–62
Costamagno S, Théry-Parisot I, Castel JC, Brugal JP (2009) Combustible ou non? Analyse multifactorielle et modèles explicatifs sur des ossements brûlés paléolithiques. In: Thery-Parisot I, Costamagno S, Henry A (eds) Gestion Des Combustibles Au Paléolithique Et Au Mésolithique: Nouveaux Outils, Nouvelles Interprétations, Proceedings of the XV World Congress UISPP, BAR Publishing, Oxford, pp 61–80
Cutts RB, Hlubik S, Campbell R, Muschinski J, Akuku P, Braun DR, ... Harris JWK (2019) Thermal curved-fragments: A method for identifying anthropogenic fire in the archaeological record. J Archaeol Sci 106:10–22
Dal Sasso G, Asscher Y, Angelini I, Nodari L, Artioli G (2018) A universal curve of apatite crystallinity for the assessment of bone integrity and preservation. Sci Rep 8(1):1–13
David B (1990) How was this bone burnt. Problem Solv Taphonomy: Archaeol Paleontol Stud Europe, Africa Oceania 2:65–79
Drouet C, Aufray M, Rollin-Martinet S, Vandecandelaère N, Grossin D, Rossignol F, ... Rey C (2018) Nanocrystalline apatites: The fundamental role of water. Am Mineral: J Earth Planet Mater 103(4):550–564
Dupras TL, Schultz JJ (2014) Taphonomic bone staining and color changes in forensic contexts. In: Pokines J, Symes S (eds) Manual Forensic Taphonomy, CRC Press, Boca Raton, pp 315–340
Ellingham ST, Thompson TJ, Islam M, Taylor G (2015) Estimating temperature exposure of burnt bone—A methodological review. Sci Justice 55(3):181–188
Ellingham ST, Thompson TJ, Islam M (2016) The effect of soft tissue on temperature estimation from burnt bone using Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy. J Forensic Sci 61(1):153–159
Etok SE, Valsami-Jones E, Wess TJ, Hiller JC, Maxwell CA, Rogers KD, ... Woodgate SL (2007) Structural and chemical changes of thermally treated bone apatite. J Mater Sci 42(23), 9807–9816
Figueiredo MJDFMD, Fernando A, Martins G, Freitas J, Judas F, Figueiredo H (2010) Effect of the calcination temperature on the composition and microstructure of hydroxyapatite derived from human and animal bone. Ceram Int 36(8):2383–2393
Fredericks JD, Ringrose TJ, Dicken A, Williams A, Bennett P (2015) A potential new diagnostic tool to aid DNA analysis from heat compromised bone using colorimetry: A preliminary study. Sci Just 55(2):124–130
Gallo G, Fyhrie M, Paine C, Ushakov SV, Izuho M, Gunchinsuren B, ... Navrotsky A (2021) Characterization of structural changes in modern and archaeological burnt bone: Implications for differential preservation bias. PloS one 16(7):e0254529
Gianfrate G, D’Elia M, Quarta G, Giotta L, Valli L, Calcagnile L (2007) Qualitative application based on IR spectroscopy for bone sample quality control in radiocarbon dating. Nucl Instrum Methods Phys Res, Sect B 259(1):316–319
Goldberg P, Berna F (2010) Micromorphology and context. Quaternary Int 214(12):56–62
Goldberg P, Miller CE, Mentzer SM (2017) Recognizing fire in the Paleolithic archaeological record. Curr Anthropol 58(S16):S175–S190
Gowlett JAJ, Brink JS, Caris A, Hoare S, Rucina SM (2017) Evidence of burning from bushfires in southern and east Africa and its relevance to hominin evolution. Curr Anthropol 58(S16):S206–S216
Hedges RE (2002) Bone diagenesis: an overview of processes. Archaeometry 44(3):319–328
Henry A, Zavadskaya E, Alix C, Kurovskaya E, Beyries S (2018) Ethnoarchaeology of fuel use in northern forests: towards a better characterization of prehistoric fire-related activities. Ethnoarchaeology 10(2):99–120
Herrmann NP, Bennett JL (1999) The differentiation of traumatic and heat-related fractures in burned bone. J For Sci 44(3):461–469
Hlubik S, Cutts R, Braun DR, Berna F, Feibel CS, Harris JW (2019) Hominin fire use in the Okote member at Koobi Fora, Kenya: New evidence for the old debate. J Hum Evol 133:214–229
Hollund HI, Ariese F, Fernandes R, Jans MME, Kars H (2013) Testing an alternative high-throughput tool for investigating bone diagenesis: FTIR in attenuated total reflection (ATR) mode. Archaeometry 55(3):507–532
Koeppenkastrop D, Eric H (1992) Sorption of rare-earth elements from seawater onto synthetic mineral particles: An experimental approach. Chem Geol 95(3–4):251–263
Krap T, Ruijter JM, Nota K, Karel J, Burgers AL, Aalders MC, ... Duijst W (2019) Colourimetric analysis of thermally altered human bone samples. Sci Rep 9(1):8923
Lanting JN, Aerts-Bijma AT, van der Plicht J (2001) Dating of cremated bones. Radiocarbon 43(2A):249–254
Lebon M, Zazzo A, Reiche I (2014) Screening in situ bone and teeth preservation by ATR-FTIR mapping. Palaeogeogr Palaeoclimatol Palaeoecol 416:110–119
Lebon M, Reiche I, Gallet X, Bellot-Gurlet L, Zazzo A (2016) Rapid quantification of bone collagen content by ATR-FTIR spectroscopy. Radiocarbon 58(1):131–145
Lyman RL, Lyman C (1994) Vertebrate taphonomy. Cambridge University Press
Mallol C, Marlowe FW, Wood BM, Porter CC (2007) Earth, wind, and fire: ethnoarchaeological signals of Hadza fires. J Archaeol Sci 34(12):2035–2052
Mallol C, Henry A (2017) Ethnoarchaeology of Paleolithic fire: methodological considerations. Curr Anthropol 58(S16):S217–S229
Mamede AP, Gonçalves D, Marques MPM, Batista de Carvalho LA (2018) Burned bones tell their own stories: A review of methodological approaches to assess heat-induced diagenesis. Appl Spectrosc Rev 53(8):603–635
Martin RB, Burr DB, Sharkey NA, Fyhrie DP (2015) Skeletal Tissue Mechanics. Springer
Marques MPM, Mamede AP, Vassalo AR, Makhoul C, Cunha E, Gonçalves D, ... Batista de Carvalho LAE (2018) Heat-induced bone diagenesis probed by vibrational spectroscopy. Sci Rep 8(1) :1–13
Marques MP, Gonçalves D, Mamede AP, Coutinho T, Cunha E, Kockelmann W, ... Batista de Carvalho LAE (2021) Profiling of human burned bones: oxidising versus reducing conditions. Sci Rep 11(1):1361
Mayne Correia P (1997) Fire modification of bone: a review of the literature. In: Sorg M, Haglund W (eds) Forensic taphonomy: the postmortem fate of human remains, CRC Press, Boca Raton, pp 275–293
Munsell Color (Firm) (2010) Munsell soil color charts : with genuine Munsell color chips. Grand Rapids, MI :Munsell Color
Nakamoto K (2009) Infrared and Raman spectra of inorganic and coordination compounds, part B: applications in coordination, organometallic, and bioinorganic chemistry. John Wiley & Sons
Naysmith P, Scott EM, Cook GT, Heinemeier J, van der Plicht J, Van Strydonck M, Freeman SP (2007) A cremated bone intercomparison study. Radiocarbon 49(2):403–408
Nyman JS, Ni Q, Nicolella DP, Wang X (2008) Measurements of mobile and bound water by nuclear magnetic resonance correlate with mechanical properties of bone. Bone 42(1):193–199
Person A, Bocherens H, Mariotti A, Renard M (1996) Diagenetic evolution and experimental heating of bone phosphate. Palaeogeogr Palaeoclimatol Palaeoecol 126(1–2):135–149
Piga G, Malgosa A, Thompson TJU, Enzo S (2008) A new calibration of the XRD technique for the study of archaeological burned human remains. J Archaeol Sci 35(8):2171–2178
Piga G, Gonçalves D, Thompson T, Brunetti A, Malgosa A, Enzo S (2016) Understanding the crystallinity indices behavior of burned bones and teeth by ATR-IR and XRD in the presence of bioapatite mixed with other phosphate and carbonate phases. Int J Spectrosc. https://doi.org/10.1155/2016/4810149
Pollock CR, Pokines JT, Bethard JD (2018) Organic staining on bone from exposure to wood and other plant materials. Forensic Sci Int 283:200–210
Pramanik S, Hanif ASM, Pingguan-Murphy B, Abu Osman NA (2012) Morphological change of heat treated bovine bone: a comparative study. Materials 6(1):65–75
Pyne SJ, Andrews PL, Laven RD (1996) Introduction to wildland fire, 2nd edn. Wiley, New York
Ramirez-Gutierrez CF, Londoño-Restrepo SM, Del Real A, Mondragón MA, Rodriguez-García ME (2017) Effect of the temperature and sintering time on the thermal, structural, morphological, and vibrational properties of hydroxyapatite derived from pig bone. Ceram Int 43(10):7552–7559
Ravaglioli A, Krajewski A, Celotti GC, Piancastelli A, Bacchini B, Montanari L, ... Piombi L (1996) Mineral evolution of bone. Biomaterials 17(6):617–622
Reidsma FH, van Hoesel A, van Os BJ, Megens L, Braadbaart F (2016) Charred bone: Physical and chemical changes during laboratory simulated heating under reducing conditions and its relevance for the study of fire use in archaeology. J Archaeol Sci Rep 10:282–292
Rey C, Combes C, Drouet C, Glimcher MJ (2009) Bone mineral: update on chemical composition and structure. Osteoporos Int 20(6):1013–1021
Reynard B, Lécuyer C, Grandjean P (1999) Crystal-chemical controls on rare-earth element concentrations in fossil biogenic apatites and implications for paleoenvironmental reconstructions. Chem Geol 155(3–4):233–241
Rietveld HM (1969) A profile refinement method for nuclear and magnetic structures. J Appl Crystallogr 2(2):65–71
Rollin-Martinet S, Navrotsky A, Champion E, Grossin D, Drouet C (2013) Thermodynamic basis for evolution of apatite in calcified tissues. Am Miner 98(11–12):2037–2045
Sandgathe DM, Berna F (2017) Fire and the genus Homo: an introduction to supplement 16. Curr Anthropol 58(S16):S165–S174
Santana VM, Baeza MJ, Blanes MC (2013) Clarifying the role of fire heat and daily temperature fluctuations as germination cues for Mediterranean Basin obligate seeders. Ann Bot 111(1):127–134
Scott AC (2000) The Pre-Quaternary history of fire. Palaeogeogr Palaeoclimatol Palaeoecol 164(1–4):281–329
Scott AC (2009) Forest fire in the fossil record. In: Cerda A, Robichaud P (eds) Fire effects on soils and restoration strategies. CRC Press, Boca Raton, pp 17–54
Shahack-Gross R, Bar-Yosef O, Weiner S (1997) Black-coloured bones in Hayonim Cave, Israel: differentiating between burning and oxide staining. J Archaeol Sci 24(5):439–446
Shipman P, Foster G, Schoeninger M (1984) Burnt bones and teeth: an experimental study of color, morphology, crystal structure and shrinkage. J Archaeol Sci 11(4):307–325
Snoeck C, Brock F, Schulting RJ (2014) Carbon exchanges between bone apatite and fuels during cremation: impact on radiocarbon dates. Radiocarbon 56(2):591–602
Snoeck C, Schulting RJ, Lee-Thorp JA, Lebon M, Zazzo A (2016) Impact of heating conditions on the carbon and oxygen isotope composition of calcined bone. J Archaeol Sci 65:32–43
Stahlschmidt MC, Mallol C, Miller CE (2020) Fire as an artifact—advances in paleolithic combustion structure studies: Introduction to the special issue. J Paleo Archaeol 3(4):503–508
Stahlschmidt MC, Mentzer SM, Heinrich S, Cooper A, Grote MN, McNeill PJ, Wilder JC, Steele TE (2023) Impact of a Recent Wildfire on Tortoises at Cape Point, South Africa, and Implications for the Interpretation of Heated Bones in the Archaeological Record. Archaeol Anthropol Sci. https://doi.org/10.1007/s12520-023-01806-4
Stiner MC, Kuhn SL, Weiner S, Bar-Yosef O (1995) Differential burning, recrystallization, and fragmentation of archaeological bone. J Archaeol Sci 22(2):223–237
Stinson KJ, Wright HA (1969) Temperatures of headfires in the southern mixed prairie of Texas. J Range Manag 22:169–177
Stout SD, Cole ME, Agnew AM (2019) Histomorphology: deciphering the metabolic record. In: Buikstra J (eds) Ortner’s identification of pathological conditions in human skeletal remains, 3rd edn. Academic Press, Cambridge, pp 91–167
Théry-Parisot I (2002) Fuel management (bone and wood) during the Lower Aurignacian in the Pataud rock shelter (Lower Palaeolithic, Les Eyzies de Tayac, Dordogne, France). Contribution of experimentation. J Archaeol Sci 29(12):1415–1421
Thompson T (2004) Recent advances in the study of burned bone and their implications for forensic anthropology. Forensic Sci Int 146:S203–S205
Thompson T (2005) Heat-induced dimensional changes in bone and their consequences for forensic anthropology. Journal of Forensic Science 50(5):JFS2004297-8
Thompson TJU, Gauthier M, Islam M (2009) The application of a new method of Fourier Transform Infrared Spectroscopy to the analysis of burned bone. J Archaeol Sci 36(3):910–914
Thompson TJU, Islam M, Bonniere M (2013) A new statistical approach for determining the crystallinity of heat-altered bone mineral from FTIR spectra. J Archaeol Sci 40(1):416–422
Toby BH, Von Dreele RB (2013) GSAS-II: the genesis of a modern open-source all purpose crystallography software package. J Appl Crystallogr 46:544–549
Trueman CN, Privat K, Field J (2008) Why do crystallinity values fail to predict the extent of diagenetic alteration of bone mineral? Palaeogeogr Palaeoclimatol Palaeoecol 266(3–4):160–167
Turner E, Hutson J, Villaluenga A, García Moreno A, Gaudzinski-Windheuser S (2018) Bone staining in waterlogged deposits: a preliminary contribution to the interpretation of near-shore find accumulation at the Schöningen 13II-4 ‘Spear-Horizon’site, Lower Saxony. Germany Histor Biol 30(6):767–773
Ubelaker DH (2009) The forensic evaluation of burned skeletal remains: a synthesis. Forensic Sci Int 183(1–3):1–5
van Hoesel A, Reidsma FH, van Os BJ, Megens L, Braadbaart F (2019) Combusted bone: physical and chemical changes of bone during laboratory simulated heating under oxidising conditions and their relevance for the study of ancient fire use. J Archaeol Sci Rep 28:102033
Van Strydonck M, Boudin M, De Mulder G (2009) 14C dating of cremated bones: the issue of sample contamination. Radiocarbon 51(2):553–568
Walker PL, Miller KW, Richman R (2008) Time, temperature, and oxygen availability: an experimental study of the effects of environmental conditions on the color and organic content of cremated bone. In: Schmidt C, Symes S (eds) The Analysis of Burned Human Remains. Academic Press, Cambridge pp 129-xi
Weiner S, Bar-Yosef O (1990) States of preservation of bones from prehistoric sites in the Near East: a survey. J Archaeol Sci 17(2):187–196
Whelan RJ (1995) The ecology of fire. Cambridge University Press
Wright HA, Bailey AW (1982) Fire ecology: United States and southern Canada. John Wiley & Sons, New York
Zazzo A, Saliege JF, Person A, Boucher H (2009) Radiocarbon dating of calcined bones: where does the carbon come from? Radiocarbon 51(2):601–611
Zhang G, Deng X, Guan F, Bai Z, Cao L, Mao H (2018) The effect of storage time in saline solution on the material properties of cortical bone tissue. Clin Biomech 57:56–66
Acknowledgements
The authors would like to thank Dr. Sanjai Parikh and the Parikh Environmental Soil Chemistry Group at the University California at Davis for instrument access and training, as well as Dr. Teresa Steele for feedback and helpful comments and Dr. Zwyns for sponsorship through the Center of Experimental Archaeology at UC Davis (CEAD). We are also grateful for the support of Drs. Sarah Pederzani and Geoff Smith regarding sample preparation advice and assistance, and the further generosity of Andre Santana and Drs. Li Li and Sarah Pederzani for their time and counsel for data visualization. This work was made possible through the Leakey Foundation and the Max Planck Institute for Evolutionary Anthropology, who provided instrumentation infrastructure and resources crucial to the success of this project. We would also like to extend further gratitude to the useful comments and feedback provided by our anonymous reviewers.
Funding
Travel for this project was funded through the Leakey Foundation. Supplies and instrumentation were provided through the Max Planck Institute for Evolutionary Archaeology, the Center for Experimental Archaeology at UC Davis, and the Arizona State University Center for Materials of the Universe.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Contributions
G.G. and M.C.S. conceptualized this project, developed experimental protocol, and conducted all experimental trials. G.G. wrote the main manuscript text, prepared figures, and is responsible for all ATR-FTIR analyses. S.V.U. prepared samples for XRD and refined all XRD data. A.N. and the laboratories of A.N. provided analytical tools and XRD instrumentation. All authors reviewed the manuscript and provided feedback and commentary.
Corresponding author
Ethics declarations
Competing interests
The authors declare no competing interests.
Ethics approval
All animal remains utilized in this study were obtained through a local butchery where animals prepared for consumption were euthanized humanely (stunned before exsanguination) following German government standards through the Federal Ministry of Food, Agriculture, and Forestry. These guidelines were established to ensure the welfare of animals within the German state.
Consent to participate
Not applicable.
Consent for publication
Not applicable.
Conflict of interest
The authors declare no competing interests.
Additional information
Publisher's Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Supplementary Information
Below is the link to the electronic supplementary material.
Rights and permissions
Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article's Creative Commons licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article's Creative Commons licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this licence, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/.
About this article
Cite this article
Gallo, G., Ushakov, S.V., Navrotsky, A. et al. Impact of prolonged heating on the color and crystallinity of bone. Archaeol Anthropol Sci 15, 143 (2023). https://doi.org/10.1007/s12520-023-01842-0
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s12520-023-01842-0