The Indirect Displacement Hypothesis: a Case Study in Washington, D.C.
Stereotypes abound about the clash between newcomers to urban neighborhoods and their longstanding residents. In a case study of Columbia Heights in the District of Columbia, the preferences and attitudes of newcomers and longstanding residents are compared. The comparison will help assess the extent to which indirect displacement pressures in the domain of retail activity might be occurring in Columbia Heights. Data from surveys conducted in 2008 by the Howard University Center for Urban Progress (HUCUP) form the empirical base of this study. A total of 217 completed surveys were received, 116 from an Internet survey and 101 one-on-one street interviews. The sample was split into thirds (according to length of time that the participant lived in the neighborhood) leading to break points at two years and eight years of residency. All respondents who lived in the neighborhood two years or less or eight years or more were kept in the final sample. The former were defined as “newcomers” and the latter were defined as “longstanding residents”. There were 77 newcomers and 74 longstanding residents in the final sample. The survey instrument inquired about respondents’ opinions about the availability and quality of stores by type, the variety of stores, and what types of stores they would like to see added to the neighborhood. Respondents were then asked their assessment of the new commercial developments and of the previously existing businesses in the corridor. Chi-square tests were used to test the hypotheses that there were differences between the two populations -- newcomers and long-standing residents -- in terms of preferences and attitudes. The findings demonstrated significant differences between the two groups in terms of their opinions about the commercial corridor, although both groups were generally pleased with the new retail developments. The analysis of these data weakly supports the hypothesis that indirect factors could heighten pressures for displacement of longstanding residents, but it is argued that the main focus of gentrification studies should continue to be on the direct economic factors affecting longstanding residents during neighborhood revitalization.
KeywordsGentrification Neighborhood transition Indirect displacement Commercial development Washington, DC
- Atkinson R, Wulff M. Gentrification and displacement: a review of approaches and findings in the literature. AHURI Positioning Paper No. 115, Australian Housing and Urban Research Institute Limited, Melbourne. 2009. https://www.ahuri.edu.au/research/position-papers/115.
- Abramson D, Manzo L, Hou J. From ethnic enclaves to multi-ethnic translocal community: contested identities and urban design in Seattle’s Chinatown-International District. J Architect Plan Res. 2006;23(4):341–60.Google Scholar
- Billingham C. The broadening conception of gentrification: recent development and avenues for future inquiry in the sociological study of urban change. Mich Sociol Rev. 2015;29:75–102.Google Scholar
- Byers A. Interview of Andre Byers, Manager, Office of the Deputy Mayor for Planning and Economic Development, District of Columbia, with Judy Mulusa. 2010.Google Scholar
- Columbia Heights/Washington D.C. Crime-Areavibes. http://www.areavibes.com/washington-dc/columbia+heights/crime/. Retrieved 17 Aug 2016.
- Davidson M. The two faces of gentrification: can zoning help? Am Plan Assoc News. 2002.Google Scholar
- Glemmer G. Quantitative and spatial analysis techniques for analyzing gentrification patterns, case study of Portland Oregon, Independent Research Project. 2000.Google Scholar
- Hamnett C. Gentrification and residential location theory: a review and assessment. In: Hebert D, Johnson R, editors. Geography and the urban environment vol. 6: progress in research and applications. New York: John Wiley Publishers; 1984.Google Scholar
- Hamnett C. The blind men and the elephant: the explanation of gentrification. Trans Inst Br Geogr. New Series. 1991; 16:2.Google Scholar
- Hyra D. Mixed income housing: where have we been and where do we go from here? Cityscape. 2013;15:2.Google Scholar
- Kennedy M, Leonard P. Dealing with neighborhood change: a primer on gentrification and policy choices. Discussion Paper, Brookings Institution Center on Urban and Metropolitan Policy. 2001.Google Scholar
- Kolko J. The determinants of gentrification. San Francisco, CA: Public Policy Institute of California; 2007.Google Scholar
- Lees L. Gentrification and social mixing: towards an inclusive urban renaissance? Urban Stud. 2008;45:12.Google Scholar
- Ley D. Reply: the rent gap revisited. Ann Assoc Am Geogr. 2010;77(3):465–68.Google Scholar
- Maly M. Beyond segregation: multiracial and multiethnic neighborhoods in the United States. Philadelphia: Temple University Press; 2005.Google Scholar
- Moore R. Interview with Robert Moore, CEO, Development Corporation of Columbia Heights, by Judy Mulusa. 2010.Google Scholar
- Nesbitt A. A model of gentrification: monitoring commercial change in selected neighborhoods of St. Petersburg Florida using the Analytical Hierarchy Process. MA thesis, University of Florida. 2005.Google Scholar
- Slater T. The eviction of critical perspectives from gentrification research. Int J Urban Reg Res. 2006; 30.Google Scholar
- Smith N. Gentrification and the rent gap. Ann Assoc Am Geogr. 2010;77(3):462–65.Google Scholar
- Smith N. The new urban frontier: gentrification and the Revanchist City. London: Routledge; 1996.Google Scholar
- Vigdor J, Sanford T. Does gentrification harm the poor? Brookings-Wharton papers on urban affairs. Washington, DC: Brookings Institution Press; 2002.Google Scholar
- Washington, DC Economic Partnership (WDCEP). DC neighborhood profiles. Washington, DC: Washington DC Economic Partnership. 2015.Google Scholar
- Wilson V. State unemployment rates by race and ethnicity at the start of 2016 show a plodding recovery, with some states continuing to lag behind. Washington, D.C. Economic Policy Institute. 2016. http://www.epi.org/publication/state-unemployment-rates-by-race-and-ethnicity-at-the-start-of-2016-show-a-plodding-recovery-with-some-states-continuing-to-lag-behind. Retrieved 2 Oct 2016.
- Zukin S. Gentrification, culture and capital in the urban core. Annu Rev Sociol. 1987; 13.Google Scholar
- Zukin S. The naked city: the death and life of authentic urban places. New York: Oxford University Press; 2010.Google Scholar