Introduction

Hypertension (HTN) is the leading modifiable risk factor for premature cardiovascular disease (CVD), increasing the risk of coronary artery disease, arrhythmias, stroke, renal failure, and mortality [1,2,3,4,5]. It is increasingly common, affecting up to 45% (103–115 million) of US adults [6] and 31% (1.4 billion) of adults globally [7]. Even those who do not develop HTN by 45 have a lifetime risk of 80% to over 90% for developing HTN [8]. Only 40% of American adults with HTN are well-controlled, leaving tens of millions at risk [9]. HTN also accounts for $131 billion of healthcare costs, resulting in an additional $2000 of individual healthcare expenditure annually compared to those without HTN [10]. With increasing prevalence, complications, cost, and continued suboptimal control, further action to address HTN is imperative.

Guidelines from major medical organizations continue to recommend lifestyle modification, with diet as a primary component, as the first-line therapy for HTN [8, 11,12,13]. More specifically, minimally processed or whole-food, plant-based (WFPB) diets effectively prevent and treat HTN, along with many other cardiometabolic comorbidities [14]. Evidence-based nutrition interventions are under-taught in medical schools globally [15]. While physicians report insufficient training and knowledge regarding nutrition [16], patients view them as having nutrition expertise [17].

This paper aims to help address the gap between evidence-based therapeutic approaches, patient expectations, and clinician knowledge. It is not meant to be a complete literature review, as an in-depth review has been previously published [18••]. Rather, it should function as a primer for busy clinicians, providing clinically relevant information to improve the delivery of evidence-based, patient-centered dietary interventions to comprehensively address HTN.

First, we will review HTN-related clinical outcomes for WFPB diets and the proposed mechanistic evidence for their effectiveness. Then, we will describe dietary recommendations for patients with HTN and explain why and how clinicians should discuss nutrition with their patients, ways to overcome common barriers to adherence, and how to incorporate nutrition assessment and counseling into the workflow of busy clinical practice. Finally, we will explore future directions clinicians can take to promote a system that prioritizes ethical care of patients using the most effective treatment modalities.

While this paper focuses on nutrition, several other important lifestyle factors impact chronic disease, including HTN and CVD. The American College of Lifestyle Medicine (ACLM) describes six pillars of health. In addition to healthful eating, they include physical activity, restorative sleep, stress management, social connection, and avoiding the use of harmful substances [19].

Evidence-Based Dietary Patterns

Various dietary patterns have been described to reduce systolic blood pressure (SBP) and diastolic blood pressure (DBP). Current recommendations by the American Heart Association (AHA) include an eating pattern that emphasizes fruits, vegetables, whole grains, predominantly plant-based proteins (legumes and nuts), fish, and seafood [13]. For those who choose to still consume meat or poultry, they advise selecting lean cuts and avoiding processed forms. Recommendations also include avoiding ultra-processed foods, which contain added salt, sugars, or fats, and artificial colors, flavorings, and preservatives.

Several dietary patterns have been evaluated for their consistency with AHA dietary guidance. The DASH, Mediterranean, pescetarian, and vegetarian (ovo, lacto, ovo/lacto) have been characterized as tier 1 dietary patterns, those with scores > 85 for alignment with the 2021 AHA Dietary Guidance [20•]. Tier 2 patterns score from 75 to 85 for alignment with 2021 AHA Dietary Guidance and include vegan and low-fat diets [20•]. Recent systematic reviews note that plant-based dietary patterns result in superior HTN, and cardiovascular-related health outcomes compared to animal-based diets [21, 22]. As this paper will outline, optimizing the quality of plant-based dietary patterns has the potential to immensely impact the prevention and treatment of HTN [23].

DASH Diet

The Dietary Approach to Stop Hypertension (DASH) diet is one of the most effective dietary patterns for preventing and treating HTN [24, 25]. It emphasizes fruits, vegetables, and low-fat dairy foods; includes whole grains, poultry, fish, and nuts; and minimizes fats, red meat, sweets, added sodium, and sugar-containing beverages [26]. Interestingly, the initial premise of the DASH diet was to “have the blood pressure-lowering benefits of a vegetarian diet, yet contain enough animal products to make it palatable to nonvegetarians,” after earlier studies showed those consuming vegetarian diets had the lowest blood pressures in industrialized societies [27].

Recent systematic reviews and meta-analyses demonstrate the impact of DASH diets on the prevention and treatment of HTN [28, 29]. Those with the highest, compared to the lowest, adherence to the DASH diet resulted in a 20% decreased risk of developing HTN [28]. Additionally, compared to a control diet, the DASH diet significantly reduces SBP by 3.2 mm Hg and DBP by 2.5 mm Hg regardless of HTN diagnosis [29]. Individual clinical trials are even more impressive, with mean SBP reductions from 5.3 to 20.8 mm Hg for those with SBP < 130 and ≥ 150 mm Hg, respectively [30].

Mediterranean Diet

A Mediterranean diet (MedDiet) represents commonalities of diets in Mediterranean countries [31]. It consists of high consumption (every meal) of fruits, vegetables, whole grains, nuts, and legumes; moderate consumption (daily to weekly) of fish, poultry, and dairy products; limited intake (less than twice weekly) of red meat and sweets; and red wine “in moderation” [32]. The MedDiet also emphasizes using unsaturated fats, mainly olive oil, as the primary source of added fat. Two recent meta-analyses exploring the relationship between MedDiet and HTN specifically noted small but significant average reductions in SBP (1.44–1.5 mm Hg) and DBP (0.7–0.9 mm Hg), with greater reductions achieved in those with higher baseline SBP [33, 34].

Further analysis of the MedDiet shows its main benefit is from low meat consumption and high intake of vegetables, fruits, nuts, and legumes, with no additional benefit from the consumption of fish and dairy [35]. Additionally, while the Mediterranean diet includes moderate wine consumption, recent evidence suggests that no amount of alcohol can be deemed unequivocally beneficial for HTN and overall health [36]. We note that the healthful effects traditionally attributed to wine may instead reflect those of other lifestyle factors, such as social connection.

Vegetarian and Vegan Diets

Lacto-ovo vegetarian diets exclude all animal flesh—meat, game, poultry, fish, and shellfish—but include dairy and eggs, while vegan diets exclude all animal products. Large cross-sectional studies have demonstrated an inverse relationship between the restriction of animal products and both age-adjusted HTN prevalence and blood pressure readings, with vegans having the lowest, omnivores having the highest, and vegetarians and pescatarians in between [37,38,39]. Meta-analysis data demonstrated that vegetarian dietary patterns reduced SBP by 4.8–6.9 mm Hg and DBP by 2.2–4.7 mm Hg compared to omnivorous diets [40]. More recent meta-analysis data suggest that while non-calorically restricted vegan diets do not outperform non-vegan diets in all-comers, they do among those with elevated SBP above 130 mm Hg, resulting in an average decrease in SBP and DBP of 4.10 mm Hg and 4.01 mm Hg, respectively [41].

While more healthful plant-based diets decrease HTN risk, vegan and vegetarian diets in which unhealthy, highly processed plant-based foods predominate can increase the risk of HTN [42]. This highlights the importance of not only limiting animal-based dietary components but also ensuring the high nutritional quality of included plant foods.

Whole-Food, Plant-Based (WFPB) Diet

The dietary patterns above are associated with beneficial outcomes, largely due to their common factors, including minimally processed, plant-based foods while limiting processed foods and animal products. A whole-food, plant-based (WFPB) diet is a rigorous variation on these shared healthful components, maximizing consumption of minimally processed, plant-based foods and minimizing or excluding all processed foods and animal products, including red meat, processed meat, poultry, fish, eggs, and dairy products [43]. The individual whole, plant-based food groups—fruits and vegetables [44], legumes [45], whole grains [46], nuts and seeds [47], and herbs and spices [48]—have each been shown to improve HTN-related outcomes.

Mechanistic Evidence

A balanced WFPB diet exerts its blood-pressure-lowering effect through several mechanisms, including promoting weight loss, minimizing sodium, containing adequate levels of health-promoting micronutrients and phytonutrients, and avoiding harmful components of animal foods [18••].

Weight Loss

Higher BMI is linked to a higher incidence of HTN, and weight loss often improves blood pressure [49, 50]. In fact, in some studies, BMI accounts for up to 50% of the blood pressure variations between diet groups [37]. WFPB diets have been shown to effectively promote weight loss and improve HTN [51].

Sodium and Potassium

Sodium consumption is a significant risk factor for HTN [52], responsible for up to 9–17% of the population attributable risk [53]. Sodium-restricted diets, such as the DASH and WFPB diets, stress the avoidance of highly processed foods, the predominant source of dietary sodium in the USA [54], and have been shown to decrease blood pressure in large meta-analyses [55].

Potassium has been shown to reduce blood pressure by improving vasodilation, reducing vascular tension, and promoting natriuresis [56,57,58]. The most concentrated sources of potassium include legumes, fruits, and starchy and non-starchy vegetables.

The sodium-potassium-ratio is a stronger risk factor for HTN, CVD, and mortality than either element alone [59,60,61]. As most Americans both overconsume sodium [62] and underconsume potassium [63], dietary patterns for patients with HTN should aim to correct this imbalance.

Magnesium and Calcium

Magnesium intake is inversely related to blood pressure and can help prevent and treat HTN by promoting healthy endothelial function and vasodilation [64, 65]. Magnesium is concentrated in leafy greens, legumes, seeds, nuts, whole grains, and other high-fiber foods.

While low calcium intake promotes vasoconstriction and increased peripheral vascular resistance [66, 67], sufficient intake appears beneficial for preventing and treating HTN [68, 69]. Though often associated with dairy in Western cultures, there are many excellent plant sources of calcium, including low-oxalate green leafy vegetables, tofu, legumes, nuts, seeds, and nondairy milks.

Fiber, Naturally Occurring Nitrates and Phytonutrients

Only 5% of US adults meet daily recommendations for fiber [70]. Fiber reduces the risk of HTN and has been shown to reduce BP independently of its effect on weight loss in a meta-analysis of clinical trials [71, 72]. High-fiber plant-based diets may also beneficially affect the gut microbiome composition [73], which may help regulate blood pressure [74]. Dietary fiber is plentiful in whole plant foods but is not naturally present in animal products.

Nitrate-rich leafy green vegetables reduce inflammation and enhance nitric oxide production, which relaxes vascular smooth muscle and thereby lowers blood pressure [75, 76]. Beetroot juice has also been shown to reduce blood pressure among patients with HTN in several systematic reviews through nitrate-dependent and independent mechanisms [77,78,79]. However, due to high oxalate content, significant beet consumption may not be advisable for patients prone to nephrolithiasis [80]. In contrast to naturally occurring nitrates, synthetic nitrates and nitrites used to preserve processed meats are linked to the production of nitrosamines, which are known carcinogens and may also contribute to higher blood pressure [81, 82].

Phytonutrients, such as polyphenols and plant sterols, can help to control HTN via antioxidant, anti-inflammatory, vasodilatory, and apoptosis-inducing pathways [83,84,85]. The most concentrated sources are colorful whole-plant foods such as vegetables, fruits, legumes, whole grains, nuts, seeds, herbs, spices, and teas.

Animal Food Components

Diets higher in animal foods tend to be associated with a greater risk of HTN [38, 39, 86,87,88]. They contain higher levels of saturated fat [89, 90] and advanced glycation end products (AGEs) [91] and promote the formation of trimethylamine-N-oxide (TMAO) [92], which have all been linked to HTN and CVD. A more comprehensive review of the health harms of animal food consumption can be found elsewhere [93•].

Dietary Recommendations for HTN

While consuming adequate amounts of specific key nutrients is important for individuals with HTN, the most effective way to address HTN is with an overall health-promoting dietary pattern, as in Table 1. These recommendations are illustrated in a 3-day sample menu, as shown in Fig. 1. The foods included are healthy sources of macronutrients and rich sources of dietary fiber and micronutrients that promote vascular health. Additionally, though beyond the scope of this article, such plant-based dietary patterns can powerfully affect cardiovascular and metabolic health beyond HTN alone [94].

Table 1 Dietary guidelines for treating hypertension with WFPB diets
Fig.1
figure 1figure 1

Sample menus for treatment of hypertension. 1All menus are under 2000 cal. Fiber ranges from 66 to 75 g. Protein ranges from 80 to 96 g. Saturated fat ranges from 3 to 4% of total calories. Sodium averages less than 1200 mg over 3 days. Potassium is over 5000 mg, magnesium is over 600 mg, and calcium is over 1100 mg. These levels all meet the recommendations outlined above. The only nutrition shortfalls are for vitamin B12, vitamin D, and iodine, for which supplementation is recommended. 2Menu was created using ESHA Food Processor Nutrition Analysis Software [95] and USDA FoodData Central [96]

Implementation

While identifying specific dietary recommendations and the evidence behind them is important, their utility is determined by clinicians’ ability to integrate them into clinical care. While a detailed review of dietary assessments, counseling techniques, and nutrition prescriptions is beyond the scope of this paper, this section will provide a brief overview of them along with existing comprehensive references for those who wish to learn more.

Approaching the Conversation

It is important not to justify withholding minimal counseling by assuming patients are uninterested, unwilling, or unable to make lifestyle changes. This not only compromises beneficence but also threatens patient autonomy by failing to provide transparent information about the risks and benefits of all potential treatment options [97]. Learning that dietary interventions can lead to comparable or even more profound benefits than medication with less risk of side effects may sway patients to consider lifestyle changes. While the prospect of avoiding or deprescribing antihypertensives may be a powerful motivator, it is important to manage both patient and clinician expectations. Some patients will not make significant lifestyle changes, and others may still require pharmacotherapy despite adherence to dietary recommendations. Therefore, the clinician should balance communicating with patients in line with their readiness and willingness to change while clearly outlining optimal treatment goals. A reasonable first step clinicians can take is initiating a conversation about nutrition with patients [98].

Dietary Assessment

Several rapid dietary screening tools can accurately assess patients’ nutritional status. Vadiveloo et al. [99] present a flowchart with recommendations for busy clinicians. They recommend using the Nutrition Screening Protocol Questions [100] when clinicians have less than 5 min, Starting the Conversation tool [101] for visits between 5 and 10 min, and the Mediterranean Diet Adherence Screener [102] for visits longer than 10 min. For those with more time, it can be helpful to perform a 24-h dietary recall [103].

Counseling Basics

In-office counseling using evidence-based techniques, such as the 5 As model, brief action planning (BAP), and motivational interviewing (MI) can help with goal setting and behavior change in busy clinical settings. Importantly, they involve coaching patients to set their own goals, which is more likely to improve self-efficacy and result in behavioral change than dictating goals using an expert approach [104].

The 5 As model (ask, assess, advise, agree, assist) is a theory-based, patient-centered, practical framework for discussing obesity and dietary behaviors [105]. Brief action planning (BAP) is a self-management support technique used to assist an individual in creating an achievable action plan for health behavior change [106]. With practice, BAP can be conducted with patients in less than 5 min. Motivational interviewing (MI) is a patient-centered communication style that aims to resolve ambivalence to behavior change by identifying and encouraging patients’ internal motivation and commitment to change [107]. Using MI has been shown to positively impact HTN outcomes [108,109,110]. A recent excellent editorial outlines the key principles and necessary steps to incorporate BAP and MI into patient care [111].

SMART Goals and Nutrition Prescriptions

SMART goals are specific, measurable, achievable/attainable, relevant/realistic, and time-sensitive. Accompanied by step-by-step action plans, they define the what, where, when, and how of goal-directed behavior change [112]. Nutrition prescriptions apply these concepts to provide specific, time-bound dietary recommendations to patients about the type, amount, and frequency of food that should be consumed or avoided [113]. Similarly to pharmacologic prescriptions, it is essential to prescribe the right “dose” or intensity of intervention to help patients meet their goals and produce desired clinical outcomes. A further explanation of SMART goal-informed nutrition prescriptions with examples can be found in supplementary Table S1. Supplementary Table S2 demonstrates the application of the 5As model, BAP, and MI techniques to develop a sample nutrition prescription for patients with HTN.

Addressing Barriers to Change

Barriers to dietary health behavior change can range from the individual level to the complex interplay between interpersonal, organizational, environmental, and public policy factors [114]. This review focuses on the individual level, which has greater potential to be addressed within a traditional clinical encounter. In her 2008 article, Robinson outlines that individual barriers to improving dietary behavior “include taste preferences, lack of knowledge and/or belief in the association between diet and health, habits, and self-efficacy [115]”. These can generally be divided into insufficient knowledge, motivation, or skills needed to execute dietary change. Lack of knowledge can be addressed by providing patients with evidence-based resources outlining basic information, success strategies, recipes, and sample meal plans. Clinicians can address difficulty with initiating behavior by identifying and discussing barriers to behavior change, sharing resources to learn cooking skills, and referring to registered dietitians or health coaches as appropriate. To address issues with motivation, clinicians can use motivational interviewing to determine the cause of the lack of motivation, develop discrepancies between the current behavior and the desired outcome, provide resources for social support, and refer to behavioral health specialists, social workers, or health coaches to help navigate challenges. Karlsen and Pollard outline several additional strategies to address patient concerns about plant-based nutrition and increase engagement [116]. Supplementary Table S3 outlines recommended resources clinicians can share with patients to help them overcome these barriers, such as dietary guides, cookbooks, and therapeutic lifestyle change programs.

Clinicians also experience barriers to addressing lifestyle changes during visits, namely the difficulty of changing patient behavior, lack of sufficient time, and issues with patient adherence [117]. We hope the strategies and resources referenced in this article can help overcome those barriers. However, this is sometimes outside of the clinician’s expertise and scope of the practice, and it may be more appropriate to refer to allied health professionals, such as health coaches, dieticians, or behavioral specialists, to assist the patient.

When to Refer to a Registered Dietitian or Health Coach

Providing in-depth, individualized nutrition advice is outside the scope of practice of most physicians, who do not typically have the time or expertise to offer these consults [118]. However, these skills are within the scope of registered dietitians (RDs), health and wellness coaches, and other lifestyle support staff.

RDs have the training to teach patients how to implement the diet their physician recommends in a culturally appropriate, acceptable, and effective manner. They also have the time and ability to conduct more intensive nutritional assessments and address dietary concerns among patients longitudinally. For this reason, patients who receive dietary prescriptions, who have comorbidities, such as eating disorders, type 2 diabetes, or cardiovascular disease, or who have undergone bariatric surgery should be referred to RDs. Studies demonstrate better target outcomes when RDs are included in team-based care [119].

Health and wellness coaches can also be key players in helping patients with nutritional habits. They offer a patient-centered approach, using goal setting, identifying and overcoming barriers, and accountability to help patients navigate the day-to-day challenges of behavior change [104]. Data shows that health coaching effectively promotes healthy lifestyle behaviors, such as diet, and improves outcomes among patients with chronic diseases, including HTN [120, 121].

Group classes or support groups led by RDs and health coaches provide an opportunity to share ideas, knowledge, challenges, and successes and offer ongoing social support integral to positive, sustainable behavior change [122]. Ultimately, collaboration between nutrition professionals and the medical team can ensure that patients receive the support they need to achieve their diet and lifestyle goals.

Visit Logistics

Behavior change takes time; not everything can be covered in one visit by one clinician. Initial clinician visits may focus predominantly on building a relationship with a patient to understand their motivations, interests, and facilitators and barriers to behavior change. The clinician can then use this information to relay relevant knowledge, initiate goal setting, and place relevant referrals. Follow-up visits can focus on reviewing goal progress, addressing barriers, correcting inaccurate information, providing motivation and brief education, and setting new goals [116]. Clinicians should provide patients with high-quality resources, such as those recommended in Supplementary Table S3 below, to review between visits, allowing for the most relationship-strengthening and high-yield conversations to happen during the visit. This both accommodates the busy clinician’s schedule and empowers the patient to take ownership of their health. The Sample Doctor-Patient Script in Supplementary Table S4 illustrates how nutritional assessment and counseling can be done in practice.

Social Barriers: A Call to Action

While the primary goal of this review is to educate and empower individual clinicians to help individual patients implement nutrition-based interventions for the treatment of HTN, systemic change will be essential to allow for the large-scale adoption of effective, pragmatic, and affordable interventions. Clinicians should be educated and empowered to provide helpful cost-saving tips to improve financial accessibility, such as buying dry grains and legumes in bulk, frozen fruits and vegetables, and locally sourced food at community-based markets when available.

Community-level barriers to healthy eating include a high prevalence of businesses serving processed food, limited access to fresh and traditional foods, and urbanization [114]. Practices with ancillary support staff, such as social workers, can identify and leverage community assets and resources that help address these barriers. Partnerships with community organizations can promote urban farming initiatives and advocate for subsidies to improve physical and financial access to produce in food deserts. Clinicians can also advocate for medical school curricula and continuing medical education to develop more explicit content related to nutrition education and counseling so that tomorrow’s physicians are better equipped to educate and counsel patients about nutrition.

Conclusion

Given its associated morbidity, mortality, and cost, it is imperative to utilize the most effective means possible to prevent and treat HTN. A preponderance of evidence across large-scale epidemiological studies, mechanistic studies, high-quality clinical trials, and meta-analyses supports adopting healthful plant-based dietary patterns to prevent the onset of HTN and improve outcomes among those already affected.

Clinicians can use evidence-based assessment tools and counseling techniques specifically designed to fit in with busy schedules. While individual and larger societal barriers to healthy plant-based diets exist, excellent resources are available to support and empower patients in their behavior change journey. However, addressing nutritional issues with patients is not solely the job of any one clinician. Collaboration between physicians, advanced practice providers, nurses, registered dieticians, social workers, health coaches, behavioral health specialists, and others will be crucial to providing patients with the expertise and support to enact sustained lifestyle changes.

Not all patients are interested in or capable of making significant dietary changes, and some patients will require pharmacologic intervention despite their best attempts. However, clinicians should still aim to address nutrition with their patients to fulfill their obligation to offer the most comprehensive and effective treatment plans, empowering patients to make more informed decisions about their care. The benefits of healthful plant-based nutrition are not limited to HTN, nor is diet the only important factor in addressing HTN. However, helping patients adopt a healthful plant-based diet is a powerful way to improve their health and blood pressure, one meal at a time.