Abstract
This paper aims to establish whether there was a gap in biological living standards between urban and rural areas in late nineteenth-century Catalonia, and if so, to determine its extent. The study makes use of a large new dataset based on military records for the cohort of males born in the year 1890 and enlisted in the year 1911. By combining individual heights with information at municipal level, we conclude that the 1890 cohort of conscripts living in rural areas were shorter than those that resided in towns and cities with populations of more than 20,000 people. We also hypothesise about the reasons why urban dwellers in late nineteenth-century Catalonia were taller than their rural counterparts by considering the potential role of rural–urban migration, improvements in public sanitation and health care, and progresses in the quantity and quality of food availability for urban dwellers.
Similar content being viewed by others
Explore related subjects
Find the latest articles, discoveries, and news in related topics.Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
1 Introduction
The comparison of historical human heights between urban and rural populations has become a well-established area of research. Mean human height is a measure of biological living standards and is a good indicator of the nutritional status and the health of populations. A comparison between populations of different sizes and functions may therefore contribute to a better understanding of health inequality (Blum 2016, p. 180), a central topic in social sciences and policy-making.
The analysis of urban biological living standards in contrast to rural areas has attracted the attention of a large number of scholars. This is particularly true in north-western Europe; there, a large body of historical research shows that in the first stages of modern economic growth between the late-eighteenth and the mid-nineteenth centuries the combination of industrialisation and rapid population growth resulted in an urban height penalty (e.g. Komlos 1985; Sandberg and Steckel 1988; Mokyr and Ó Gráda 1989; Floud et al. 1990; Mokyr and Ó Gráda 1994; Riggs 1994; Mokyr and Ó Gráda 1996; Ó Gráda 1996; Drukker and Tassenaar 1997; Komlos 1998; Baten and Murray 2000; A’Hearn 2003; Haines 2004; Heyberger 2007; Cinnirella 2008; de Beer 2010; Heyberger 2014; Kok et al. 2018; Tassenaar 2019; Groote and Tassenaar 2020; and for summaries Steckel and Floud 1997a; Komlos and Baten 2004; Floud et al. 2011; Blum 2016; Meinzer and Baten 2016; Meinzer et al. 2018).Footnote 1
Various reasons contribute to explaining why the heights of urban dwellers decreased relative to rural heights. Workload, nutrition and diseases influence height; and in urban areas these factors evolved in a way that negatively affected the physical stature of the population. In Britain, for example, several cities grew up in parallel to the spread of factory-based industrialisation, and this process transformed both working and living conditions. Apart from the more regular, monotonous and disciplined working patterns of the mechanised factories, leisure time declined as working hours increased by around 20–35 percent in the century after 1750 (Thompson 1967; Clark 1994; Voth 1998, 2001, 2003). Child labour was also used intensively during the Industrial Revolution (e.g. Humphries 2010, 2013). While working conditions probably became harder between the mid-eighteenth and the mid-nineteenth centuries, this was compensated, to some extent at least, by gains in other indicators of living standards such as real wages over the first half of the nineteenth century (e.g. Feinstein 1998; Clark 2005; Allen 2009; Gallardo-Albarrán and de Jong 2021). On the other hand, according to some estimates, food consumption (measured by trends in daily calories per person) declined or, at best, remained stagnant between 1750 and 1850 (e.g. Meredith and Oxley 2014a, b; Broadberry et al. 2015; Harris et al. 2015; Harris 2016). In addition, diets were in general less diverse and poorer in industrial than in rural areas (e.g. Meinzer and Baten 2016), and food supply tended to be more dependent on the market, making urban dwellers more vulnerable to periodical food shortages due to transport limitations and crop fluctuations (Komlos 1998). Moreover, urban factory workers were probably less exposed to sunlight and the production of vitamin D than rural labourers, a circumstance that may also have influenced height trends across these two subgroups (Carson 2009). Finally, the new industrial cities of Britain and elsewhere tended to be overcrowded and had poor housing and sanitary conditions (Floud et al. 2011, p. 171). Clean water was often in short supply and the sewerage systems were substandard (Hassan 1985). All this created an unhealthy environment that promoted the transmission of infectious and contagious diseases.Footnote 2
The emergence of an urban height penalty is, in fact, associated with a more general issue: the “early industrial growth paradox or puzzle”, namely a fall in physical stature in a period when economy was growing. A similar pattern was found in the USA, termed the “Antebellum Puzzle” (Komlos 1998). Recently, the existence of an industrialisation puzzle has been questioned (Bodenhorn et al. 2017); the most recent papers support the presence of shrinking heights in a growing economy (Heyberger 2007; Komlos 2019; Zimran 2019; Komlos and A’Hearn 2019), but the debate is still open.
The urban height penalty did not last forever. The gap between rural and urban heights declined over time and finally the urban penalty reversed into an urban premium. The construction of the railways, and domestic and international market integration, increased the supply of food products in urban areas, making the earlier nutritional advantages of rural settings less apparent (e.g. Blum 2016). Public investment in clean water supply and sanitation such as sewerage systems improved health conditions in the urban areas (e.g. Hassan 1985; Szreter 1988; Bell and Millward 1998; and also the more recent studies quoted in Sect. 4), and medical services tended to expand more rapidly in cities and large towns than in rural areas (e.g. Lucey and Crossman 2014). As a result, from the final decades of the nineteenth century onwards the gap between urban and rural heights closed or simply vanished and, finally, urban populations became taller than their rural counterparts (e.g. Komlos and Baten 2004; Tassenaar 2019; Groote and Tassenaar 2020).
This general account of an urban height penalty reversing into an urban height premium was, nevertheless, far from universal. For eastern Belgium, Alter et al. (2004) found that urban-born men remained taller than their rural counterparts throughout the nineteenth century. Twarog (1997) reached similar conclusions by comparing rural areas and small towns in the southern German territory of Württemberg. Also in Germany, Baten (2009) concluded that in the first half of the nineteenth century “urban men were relatively tall in Bavaria”, whereas “the areas near towns (…) [were] among the districts with lower average height”, partially because the former drained food from the latter (Baten 2009, p. 175, see also Lantzsch and Schuster 2009, p. 50). For Switzerland, Schoch et al. (2012, p. 160) argued that “no urban height penalty existed in nineteenth century Switzerland” and that “the conscripts from rural areas of canton Bern never have been taller than the conscripts from the city of Bern” in the cohorts of 19-year-old conscripts measured in the late nineteenth and the first half of the twentieth centuries.
In contrast, there is also evidence showing a permanent rural advantage relative to urban heights both in north-western Europe and in the USA. For example, Riggs and Cuff (2013) reported a height advantage of about 2 cm in the rural cohorts born in late nineteenth-century Scotland by comparing rural and urban members of the military forces serving in World War I. Zehetmayer (2013) concluded that the cohorts of US soldiers born in rural counties between 1847 and 1890 were taller than those born in the 10 largest cities in the USA or in the 90 next-largest cities (1.5 and 0.9 cm taller, respectively). A rural height premium was also found in nineteenth-century Pennsylvania (Carson 2008). Nevertheless, Zehetmayer also observed that urban height converged over time: in the mid-nineteenth century “the best urban place to live in terms of height were small cities, while in the end of the nineteenth century, it was in larger cities with about 250,000 inhabitants, but not in the largest cities” (Zehetmayer 2013, p. 175).
The urban–rural gap is also found in nineteenth- and early-twentieth-century southern Europe, and the Iberian Peninsula provides a good example of its complexity. With a lower per capita income and a shorter height than their north-western European counterparts (Hatton and Bray 2010), rural and urban dwellers in Iberia also presented height disparities. In Spain, aggregate country-level analyses show that young males living in provincial capitals and towns with more than 10,000 inhabitants were taller than their rural counterparts for the cohorts born in the last quarter of the nineteenth century and that this situation continued at least until the birth cohorts of the 1920s (Quiroga 2001).
At regional level, the absence of an urban penalty is also found in south-eastern Spain in males born between 1837 and 1900. Yet, rural heights experienced a strong process of convergence towards the urban ones from this latter birth cohort to that of 1915 (Martínez-Carrión and Moreno-Lázaro 2007, see also Martínez-Carrión and Pérez-Castejón 1998 for particular towns). Urban conscripts born in the central Spanish region of Castile-La Mancha were on average slightly taller than rural ones from the birth cohort of 1887 to 1933 and were able to widen their height advantage from then until the cohorts born in the early 1960s (Cañabate-Cabezuelos and Martínez-Carrión 2017). Similarly, the region of Extremadura and the Canary Islands presented a permanent rural height penalty from the mid-nineteenth century to the late twentieth century (Linares-Luján and Parejo-Moruno 2021; Martínez-Carrión et al. 2022).
Portugal provides another example of urban heights being higher than rural heights, this time throughout the nineteenth century. The biological standard of living in Lisbon—a large city by European standards—was not lower than in the rest of the (mostly rural) country: conscripts from Lisbon were, in fact, slightly taller than those from outside the capital (Reis 2009).
While the absence of an urban height penalty seems to have prevailed in Iberia, this cannot be said of the protoindustrial and industrial areas. In the central region of Castile and Leon, rural and urban heights were roughly the same between the 1830s and the 1860s, but from then until the 1910s urban heights increased and intermittently surpassed rural heights (Martínez-Carrión and Moreno-Lázaro 2007; see also Hernández and Moreno 2011 for more detailed analysis). More importantly, in the central decades of the nineteenth century, there were episodes of urban penalty in proto-industrial areas of Castile and Leon owing to the over-exploitation of the workforce and, in fact, between the birth cohorts of 1851–1855 and 1861–1865 urban conscripts became shorter than their rural counterparts (Moreno-Lázaro and Martínez-Carrión 2010). The same is found in the south-eastern industrial town of Alcoi, particularly for the cohorts born between the early 1860s and the late 1870s, and perhaps also in Antequera, a town in southern Spain, for the cohorts born in the third quarter of the nineteenth century (Puche and Cañabate-Cabezuelos 2016, for Alcoi; Martínez-Carrión and Cámara 2015, for Antequera; see also Martínez-Carrión et al. 2014; Gallardo-Albarrán and García-Gómez 2022). Height data for the Mediterranean region of Valencia also show that rural conscripts were between 0.5 and 1.0 cm taller than their urban counterparts. Although a process of convergence took place, in the first third of the twentieth century, inhabitants of rural irrigated areas remained taller than their peers in the cities (Ayuda and Puche-Gil 2014). A similar picture of urban–rural convergence but an enduring rural height premium also applies to the province of Biscay in the Basque Country, as far as the cohorts born between 1856 and 1915 are concerned (Pérez-Castroviejo and Martínez-Carrión 2018). Finally, in Catalonia, an urban height penalty was also found for the cohorts of males born during the first two-thirds of the nineteenth century, but not for subsequent cohorts up until World War I (Ramon-Muñoz 2009, 2011). This pattern seems to have been more apparent in the industrial areas and in other more densely populated towns (Ramon-Muñoz and Ramon-Muñoz 2015, 2016).
Owing to the diversity of the situations, categorical conclusions on the evolution of the urban–rural height gap are not easy to obtain. The presence (or absence) of an urban penalty, as well as its magnitude and its time course, is a contextual phenomenon that may differ both across countries and across regions. Moreover, it is a phenomenon that can be easily associated with the characteristics and intensity of industrialisation and its consequences on the biological standard of living of the population in the early stages of modern economic growth.
This paper contributes to the well-established literature on industrialisation, living standards and urban–rural inequality in physical stature. It explores the case of Catalonia, a prosperous industrial area in north-eastern Iberia with a per capita income in the second half of the nineteenth century that was converging with that of Western Europe (Carreras 2019). This is not the only factor that makes Catalonia an interesting case study. With around 30 per cent of its workforce employed in industry in 1900, Catalonia had also become a leading manufacturing centre as well as one of the regions with the highest per capita income in Southern Europe (Nadal 1975; Nicolau 1990; Díez-Minguela et al. 2018; Rosés and Wolf 2018).
In addition, the demographic pattern of this north-eastern Iberian region presents certain notable features of its own. For a territory on the European periphery, Catalonia was relatively modern; fertility rates were low (Nadal 1966; Cabré 1999), with 171.4 live births per 1000 married women aged 16–50 in 1900 (Livi-Bacci 1968), a rate substantially lower than those recorded in Spain, southern Europe as a whole, and several western European regions (Coale and Treadway 1986). Death rates did not compare so well with other territories. However, infant mortality rates were 138.8 per 1000 live births in 1901–1905 (Dopico 1985), among the lowest in Spain and below those observed in other Mediterranean areas (Raftakis 2021; Klüsener et al. 2014 for 1910 data). In Catalonia, fertility and death rates began to decline simultaneously in the first half of the nineteenth century (Nadal 1959; Nadal and Sáez 1972; and above all, Ferrer Alòs 2021), mirroring the pattern of demographic transition that had previously characterised France (e.g. Perrin 2022).
Industrial growth and relatively high GDP per capita also led to respectable levels of urbanisation. By the late nineteenth century, the population living in localities with more than 5000 inhabitants was between 35 and 45 per cent, depending on the estimation method used (Gómez Mendoza and Luna Rodrigo 1986). These rates were above the Spanish mean, although some other less industrialised regions had higher urbanisation levels. They were also above the mean urbanisation rates prevailing in other countries bordering the Mediterranean basin (Bairoch and Goertz 1986) and the population density (61 inhabitants per square kilometre) was in line with those of some of the most densely territories populated in this area (Martí-Henneberg 2005).
In spite of its notable similarities with the rest of southern Europe, in terms of the timing of economic transformation Catalonia was certainly one of the pioneers in southern Europe. Whether and to what extent this also resulted in a specific urban–rural height gap pattern relative to other southern European regions is an intriguing topic. Did Catalonia’s industrialisation and modern economic growth lead to the emergence of height differences between rural and urban areas? We attempt to answer this question by using a unique dataset that includes height data for a large percentage of males born in 1890 who were living in Catalonia in 1911.
A second contribution made by this paper is indeed to do with the data it uses and, partially as a result, with the approach it adopts. The currently available literature generally investigates the urban–rural gap based on samples consisting of a small number of villages, towns and cities.Footnote 3 Limited by the data and the samples used, many studies in this field also tend to follow a binary classification of population settlements: sites are simply classified as urban or rural, and no gradients in population size can be established. This study attempts to contribute to filling these gaps. It uses a large new dataset (comprising almost 18,000 observations) based on military records for the cohort of males born in the year 1890 and enlisted in the year 1911, at a time when (though some exceptions continued until one year later) universal compulsory military service was introduced (e.g. Molina 2012). The dataset has been designed to provide height evidence at individual level for each of the almost 950 current Catalan municipalities (See Fig. 1). This large geographical coverage represents a novelty with regard to previous studies. Our dataset also offers a clear advantage (as does the paper by Groote and Tassenaar 2020 for the province of Fryslân, the Netherlands) over previous analyses by overcoming a dichotomic classification of territory into rural and urban, and, therefore, to test for linear (or nonlinear) relationships between height and the size and economic nature of villages, towns and cities.
Map of Catalonia: provinces, counties and municipalities. Notes and sources: Based on Eurostat (http://epp.eurostat.ec.europa.eu) and Municat (http://municat.gencat.cat)
The remainder of this paper is organised as follows: Based on primary and secondary sources, Sect. 2 provides a brief overview of the evolution of biological living standards in nineteenth-century Catalonia. Section 3 presents the new dataset and some preliminary results. Section 4 applies an econometric model to test for the relationship between population size and biological living standards as well as to discuss the results of this test. Section 5 concludes by pointing out the existence of an urban premium in late nineteenth-century Catalonia.
2 The evolution of biological living standards in nineteenth-century Catalonia: an overview
Catalonia underwent industrialisation unusually early compared with other regions on the European periphery (Pollard 1981). The origins and the development of Catalan industrialisation have been well researched. Initially, they were associated with the establishment of calico printing and, later on, with the progressive growth of cotton spinning and weaving (Sánchez 1989; Thomson 1992, 2005). Catalan industrialisation took a step forward in the early 1830s, when cotton manufacture began an intensive process of mechanisation and, partially as a result, the factory-system emerged (Nadal 1975; Sánchez 1989). Between 1835 and 1850, the number of mule-jennies multiplied by a factor of more than 17, from 27,220 to 475,490 (Nadal 1975, p. 196). As modern manufacturing developed, industrial production expanded rapidly in Catalonia: in the 1830s it grew at an annual rate of more than 7 percent, and in the 1840s and 1850s this rate was 5.4 and 5.7 percent, respectively (Maluquer de Motes 1994, p. 61; see also Carreras 1985, 1990).
Did industrial and economic growth influence biological living standards? In the UK, and in other north-western European countries, the early stages of modern economic growth coincided with a decline in heights, giving rise to the so-called early-industrial growth puzzle (e.g. Komlos 1998). The estimates by Cinnirella (2008) show, for example, that in Britain the mean height of a young man aged 18 years declined by around 4 cm during the second half of the eighteenth century and by around 3 cm during the 1820s and the 1840s.
In Catalonia, there is also some evidence of an “early-industrial growth puzzle”. The case of Igualada, a medium-sized industrial town located some 60 kms west of Barcelona, is illustrative in this respect. Around the middle of the nineteenth century, the town’s economy experienced rapid growth due mainly to the expansion of the cotton industry. Large new factories were built and by the 1840s Igualada and its surrounding area had become Catalonia’s largest cotton centre, in terms of the numbers of both workers and spindles. However, at the time that this local economy was emerging as a factory-based industrial centre and was attracting immigration, the mean height of the males dropped. In particular, the mean height of the cohorts of conscripts born in Igualada between the 1830s and the 1860s decreased by more than 3 cm, from around 165 cm to around 162 cm. The data presented in Fig. 2 suggest that the pattern seen in Igualada can be extended to other towns and, perhaps, to the whole of industrial Catalonia, at least for the cohorts born between the early 1840s and the early 1860s. Interestingly, put in the Iberian context, the fall in the Catalan urban male heights during the early stages of industrialisation was something of an exception (Ramon-Muñoz and Ramon-Muñoz 2015, 2016).
Industrial production index (IPI) and urban heights trend in Catalonia, 1840–1914 (five-year moving averages, 1914 = 100). Notes and sources: Based on data from Carreras (1985), Maluquer de Motes (1994) and Ramon-Muñoz and Ramon-Muñoz (2021, pp. 41, Table A1). Urban heights include three urban industrial Catalan cities in central and southern Catalonia, Igualada, Manresa and Reus
With urban male heights declining between the 1840s and the 1860s, one might expect the emergence of an urban penalty in Catalonia. Indeed, this is what the data displayed in Fig. 3 suggest. By the early 1840s, Catalan rural conscripts were already taller (+ 0.6 cm) than their urban counterparts (t = –1.899; p = 0.058). As Fig. 3 shows, rural heights dropped after the 1840s, paralleling the urban trend. The duration of this declining period was, nevertheless, restricted to the decade of 1850 and contrasts with the evolution of urban heights; in this latter case, reductions in physical stature were permanent and lasted until the 1860s. By then, rural conscripts were again taller (+ 0.5 cm) than their urban peers (t = –1.810, p = 0.070).
Heights of conscripts from rural and urban Catalonia in the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries (in millimetres). Notes and sources: Ramon-Muñoz and Ramon-Muñoz (2021, pp. 41, Table A1). Rural and urban data refer to Rural Western Catalonia (RWC) and to Industrial Central & Southern Catalonia (ICSC), respectively. The rural data include the rural towns of Balaguer, Cervera, Juneda and Tàrrega, and for the urban data, see Fig. 2
A new cycle in the evolution of Catalan heights emerged in the last third of the nineteenth century. With regard to urban heights, Fig. 3 shows an increase of more than 3 cm for the cohorts born between the 1860s and the early 1910s. The possible explanations for this remarkable improvement are discussed in Sect. 1. Nevertheless, one might also suggest that it was precisely during the last third of the nineteenth century when the expected productivity gains derived from industrialisation began to be distributed more equally. In the industrial town of Igualada, for example, height inequality (measured using the coefficient of variation) increased throughout the third quarter of the nineteenth century; however, it fell sharply over the following years, a period in which the mean height also began to rise (Ramon-Muñoz and Ramon-Muñoz 2015, 2016).
If urban heights evolved positively, there is also evidence that in Catalonia the heights of the cohorts of rural conscripts born from the 1870s onwards followed a similar pattern (see also Ramon-Muñoz and Ramon-Muñoz 2018 for the long-term evolution of biological living standards in rural Catalonia). Although the causes of the emergence of a positive trend in rural heights require further analysis, there is evidence of a positive association between rural heights and rural wages for the cohorts born between the mid-1890s and the early 1910s. A similar association may be established when agricultural production and land productivity are taken into consideration (Ramon-Muñoz 2009).
The improvement of Catalan heights in both urban and rural areas had an important consequence: the emergence of Catalonia as one of Iberia’s leading regions in terms of biological living standards. On the eve of World War I, the mean height of the male cohorts born at that time was 166 cm in Catalonia, compared with 165 cm in rural Madrid and south-eastern Spain, 164 cm in Portugal and 163 cm in Castile and Leon (Fig. 4).Footnote 4 At that time, Catalonia had already become “Spain’s factory” and was also the Spanish region with the highest GDP per capita (Nadal 1985; Parejo 2001; Díez-Minguela et al. 2018; Rosés and Wolf 2018).
Mean male height trends in Iberia, 1840–1914 (in millimetres). Notes and sources: For Portugal, height data include six Portuguese districts and are only available for the cohorts born in 1840, 1850, 1860, 1870, 1880, 1890, 1900 and 1910. Based on data from Cámara et al. (2019), García Montero (2009), Martínez-Carrión and Moreno-Lázaro (2007), Ramon-Muñoz (2009, 2011, updated data), Ramon-Muñoz and Ramon Muñoz (2016) and Stolz et al. (2013). We exclude from the sample regions with samples comprising fewer than five municipalities as well as regions for which data are not available
Interesting as it may be, this account of the evolution of biological living standards in nineteenth-century Catalonia needs to be complemented. The cycle of growth in Catalan heights that began in the late 1860s went hand in hand with a reversal in the urban penalty. In fact, by the last quarter of the nineteenth century urban heights were above rural ones and continued so for the next four decades. The available evidence suggests, therefore, that during the second half of the nineteenth century the urban–rural height gap in Catalonia evolved from an urban height penalty to an urban height premium. Unfortunately, the Catalan data upon which this interpretation depends are still quite fragmentary, based on five rural municipalities and three industrial towns, which means that the currently available dataset covers a very low percentage of the Catalan geography. In order to fill this gap, a new dataset has been constructed. The next section describes its main features as well as its potential shortcomings.
3 A unique new dataset on heights in late nineteenth-century Catalonia
The dataset used in this paper is based on military records generated during the enlistment process for military service in early twentieth-century Spain. In particular, mainly due to data availability, the information we collected refers to the recruitment year of 1911, which corresponds to the birth cohort of 1890.Footnote 5 For this cohort, legal exemptions still prevented a certain number of young males from effectively joining the army. These exemptions were in force until 1912 (thus affecting the cohort of 1891), when a new law was enacted (e.g. Molina 2012). In practice, however, the recruitment and enlistment process for the birth cohort on which our data relies was universal and compulsory. In 1911, all 21-year-old men were called up for military service and inspected. In other words, conscripts who finally decided to pay in order to avoid conscription are also included in our dataset.Footnote 6 It is important to stress this point, since it shows that our study sample is minimally affected (if at all) by the potential biases suggested by the literature (Komlos 2004; Bodenhorn et al. 2017; Schneider 2020).
A first step in the recruitment and enlistment process involved measurement and medical inspection, which was conducted at local level. The authorities of every single municipality had to prepare local lists of recruitment, the Actas de Clasificación y Declaración de Soldados (Acts of Classification and Declaration of Soldiers), which included, among other data, the name, birth year, and the physical stature of the draftees. Based on height measurements and other additional information, local boards established whether or not conscripts were fit to serve.
The second step in the process took place at provincial level (Cámara 2006). The Recruitment and Replacement Act of 1896 established the creation of examination commissions in the provinces, known as the Comisión Mixta (Mixed Commission). These commissions were designed to rule on applications made by the draftees to be excused from obligatory military service. The information collected in both the local and the provincial recruitment rounds was summarised in the Libros de Reemplazo (Recruitment Books).
A third step in the process took place once the inspection procedure had finished. All conscripts fit to serve were included in a local lottery, a public event designed to select the conscripts who would finally join the Spanish army. The exact number of conscripts selected varied from one year to another, depending on the army’s requirements. The number was established at the beginning of each year by the Spanish government, which then distributed the required number of conscripts by provinces and in accordance with the population of each province. Then, the provincial authorities did the same and, therefore, established the corresponding distribution at municipal level. In any case, the provincial authorities were asked to send the Ministry of War detailed information about each conscript who was finally to join the army (Molina 2012). This information was summarised in the Hojas de Filiación de los Expedientes Reglamentarios de Tropa (Registration Records from the Troops’ Statutory Files).
Our dataset uses height data originating from the second of the phases that made up the conscription process. Thus, it comprises information collected from the Recruitment Books of the conscripts enlisted in the recruitment year of 1911. In terms of the number of conscripts included by the source, the Recruitment Books cover as many conscripts as in the Acts of Classification and Declaration of Soldiers. In fact, they sometimes include even more, as they added conscripts that were not present in the municipalities in which they officially resided on the day of military inspection. The Recruitment Books also include more conscripts than the Registration Records from the Troops’ Statutory Files. In total, we use information from 19,686 individuals and height data from 17,968 (Table 1). The difference between these two figures is related to several factors. Although all young men were called up for military service, some of the draftees deserted before inspection, and so height information is lacking for some individuals. In addition, some conscripts were living outside their official places of residence at the time of enlistment, and so they were not always able to respond to the call of the local or provincial authorities. Finally, inaccuracies and changes in the criteria used in the registration process might have prevented us from using a larger set of height data. Nevertheless, the dataset we have constructed is able to cover a very large percentage of the cohort of men born in 1890 and living in Catalonia in 1911. In fact, the mean heights of this birth cohort differ little from most of the available estimates (Ramon-Muñoz and Ramon-Muñoz 2021, pp. 42, Figs. A1 and A2, respectively), which are based on aggregate data (Gómez Mendoza and Pérez Moreda 1985) or on smaller samples (Ramon-Muñoz 2011).
So are the heights in our dataset normally distributed? Figure 5 suggests that the answer is affirmative. More precisely, it shows that our data follow a quasi-normal (Gaussian) pattern, with a negative skew due to the existence of several extremely low heights, which are not necessarily explained by measurement errors. Finally, and very importantly, the distribution presented in Fig. 5 also suggests that our dataset is not affected by truncation, one of the main potential shortcomings in military samples (e.g. Komlos 2004). This makes the dataset we use for late nineteenth-century Catalonia something of an exception compared to other height samples used in the international anthropometric literature.
Our dataset covers a large percentage of the male cohort born in 1890 and living in Catalonia in 1911, and it also has a broad geographical range, including data for 919 out of the 947 municipalities existing in Catalonia today and for 1067 out of the 1073 municipalities in Catalonia in 1910 (Table 1). In other words, the municipalities covered by this dataset account for 99.9 per cent of the population residing in Catalonia around 1890. Even more interestingly, perhaps, the distribution of both sets of conscripts fits extraordinarily well to the distribution of population by municipality size as measured by the number of inhabitants (Fig. 6). To be sure, the geographical coverage of the dataset used in this study represents a novelty with regard to other datasets available for Iberia as well as for some other European countries and regions. For example, the largest dataset for nineteenth-century Iberia has been constructed for the region of Castile and Leon (Hernández and Moreno 2009, 2011), including almost 68,000 observations for the male cohorts born between 1839 and 1915. It takes into account the largest towns in the region as well as a considerable number of rural areas. For obvious reasons, however, the total number of localities included in this dataset is limited: namely, 25 localities out of the 2248 municipalities that currently make up the region of Castile and Leon.Footnote 7
Of course, the dataset that we developed is not without certain limitations. Firstly, we do not have information on the place of birth for most of the conscripts, only on the place of residence. This is simply because places of birth are not specified in most of the data sources at our disposal. Therefore, we had to arrange conscripts’ heights by municipality of residence at the time of enlistment rather than by municipality of their birth. What is more, we did so using present-day municipal boundaries. As will be explained below, this point has to be taken into account when interpreting the results, particularly regarding the municipalities in the province of Barcelona (Table 2). Nevertheless, the data reported by the Spanish Population Census of 1910 show that for the rest of the Catalan provinces, i.e. Girona, Lleida and Tarragona, more than 90 percent of the inhabitants resided in the same province (and perhaps locality) as the one in which they had been born.
Secondly, during the process of data collection we noticed that for certain localities the information available on conscripts’ heights might be affected by censuring. In these cases, the sources we used offered no information on the stature of the conscripts below 1540 mm, which was the minimum height required to join the army at that time. However, the sources did detail the number of conscripts below the minimum stature required. While they were mostly concentrated in the province of Barcelona, the number of records affected by censoring was fortunately quite low: 52 out of 17,968 records. We estimated these heights and included them in our dataset. The estimation procedure of these 52 heights is based on the assumption that the left-hand distribution of our local samples was similar to the right-hand distribution, for which we have complete data.
To sum up, in spite of these limitations, we believe that the dataset we developed is reliable and able to produce robust, non-biased and valuable results on the relationship between population size and biological living standards. One of these results is shown in Fig. 7, which suggests a positive, linear relationship between height and population size. As the conscripts residing in municipalities with fewer than 5001 inhabitants were shorter than the rest, the data seem also to support the existence of an urban premium (and a rural penalty) in late nineteenth-century Catalonia. Interesting as it is, the picture emerging from Fig. 7 is, nevertheless, far from being conclusive; it is through the use of quantitative methods that we may assess the robustness of our findings.
4 Testing for the relationship between population size and height: model and results
This section aims to test the relationship between population size and height. It analyses whether (and if so, to what extent) econometric analysis confirms the late nineteenth-century urban premium, and the positive linear relationship between population size and height suggested in Sects. 2 and 3. To this end, we apply a model that uses cross-sectional data and is based on ordinary least squares (OLS), summarised in Eq. (1).
In this model, the dependent variable is the height of most of the young Catalan males who were called up for military inspection in the 1911 draft. As previously explained, they were born in 1890 and were measured and enlisted at the age of 21. The total number of conscripts with height data is set at 17,968, belonging to 919 municipalities. In Eq. (1), the notation HEIGHTji thus refers to the height of the recruit j residing in municipality i born in 1890. The other variables included in the model are CATMUNPOPSIZEji and Zji. CATMUNPOPSIZEji is the main independent variable. It refers to the category of municipality i (by population size in the census year of 1887) where the recruit j, born in 1890 and inspected in 1911, officially resided at the time of enlistment. The variable Zji designates a series of controls, namely population density, literacy rate, relative presence of railway stations, distance from ports and altitude of the municipalities where the given conscript resided, and, finally, the error term μji.
Regarding the independent variables included in the econometric model, there are three preliminary issues that need to be mentioned. Firstly, the independent variables we use always refer to the period around the year of birth of the conscripts. This decision has a simple explanation: in line with most studies in anthropometric history, we assume that the stature of the 21-year-old Catalan conscripts was influenced most by environmental and nutritional factors during the conscripts’ first years of life rather than during their teenage years (e.g. Tanner 1978; van Zanden et al. 2014; Schneider 2020; Gao and Schneider 2021).
Secondly, due to limitations in the data sources, the independent variables included in the econometric analysis are variables at municipal level. This means that we link the individual height information for each of the 17,968 conscripts that form our dataset with some factors characteristic of the 919 municipalities where the given conscript officially resided at the time of military inspection. Unfortunately, as mentioned in the previous section, limitations in data sources also prevent us from having precise information on the localities where the conscripts were born and lived during their early childhood.
Thirdly, we were unable to include other potential independent variables in our model, such as sanitation. A growing body of literature has made it clear that clean water supply and adequate sewerage systems were essential for eliminating waterborne diseases and, therefore, for mortality rates to decline.Footnote 8 We might hypothesise that the same applies to biological living standards. Thus, we might argue that municipalities with access—or early access—to clean water and with better sanitation facilities had healthier populations as proxied by height. Unfortunately, due to data constraints we are unable to test this hypothesis. For example, in some Catalan municipalities, the 1860s saw the introduction of piped clean water supplies, which expanded during the last third of the nineteenth century; in contrast, other localities did not enjoy this amenity until early in the twentieth century (e.g. Capel and Tatjer 1991; Larrosa 1992; Riba Gabarró 2006; Guàrdia et al. 2014; Serra 2016; Fernández Álvarez 2017; Matés-Barco 2019). However, we cannot provide consistent and systematic data on the year, amount and coverage of the waterworks and sewerage systems constructed in Catalonia at the municipal level in the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries. We will come back to these issues later in this section.
Bearing all this in mind, we have constructed six different independent variables to be included in the model (Table 3). The main variable of interest is the population size of the municipality where conscripts in question resided when they were measured and enlisted. Population data have been taken from Spain’s population census of 1887, which is the closest census to the birth cohort of 1890. In line with other studies (e.g. Zehetmayer 2013; Heyberger 2014), we have constructed several categories of municipalities in order to take account of municipal population size. These categories are: below 2001 inhabitants, between 2001 and 5000 inhabitants, between 5001 and 10,000 inhabitants, between 10,001 and 20,000 inhabitants, and more than 20,000 inhabitants. The first two categories can be considered as coming clearly under the definition of rural areas (Gómez Mendoza and Luna Rodrigo 1986), whereas a definition for the remaining groups is more difficult to establish. In late nineteenth-century Catalonia, municipalities between 5001 and 20,000 inhabitants might be defined as towns of different population sizes, even if some scholars would perhaps prefer to include them under the category of rural areas. Finally, municipalities with more than 20,000 inhabitants conform clearly to the definition of urban areas and, in some cases, they might be defined as industrial cities. These five categories of municipalities have entered into the regression as dummy variables (e.g. if the conscript resides in a municipality of fewer than 2001 inhabitants 1, otherwise 0). Descriptive statistics suggest a positive relationship between population size and height.
Population size of the municipalities is the main variable of interest, but we also consider other potential factors that might affect the stature of the young Catalan males called up for military service. These factors are included as controls in the regression. The first (and perhaps obvious) variable we take into consideration is population density. Certainly, this variable is highly (and positively) correlated with population size (Table 4). Nevertheless, population size is included in the regression as a categorical variable and, in the end, population density may contribute to capturing the potential (negative) impact of overcrowding on biological living standards, as discussed above in the introduction. Population data have again been taken from Spain’s population census of 1887. As we use the current municipal boundaries, we have taken information on municipal areas from the Statistical Institute of Catalonia (IDESCAT) for 2021.Footnote 9
The second control variable we take into consideration is literacy rate. While literacy is considered a proxy for human capital, it also reflects differences in socioeconomic status between individuals. The anthropometric literature has generally suggested a positive relationship between literacy and height, with literate males being significantly taller than the illiterate ones (e.g. Ayuda and Puche-Gil 2014; Palma and Reis 2021 for Iberia). Unfortunately, we are only able to capture literacy rates at municipal level. This means that our data provide information on the percentage of the population able to read and write in the municipality in which the conscript resided, but not on the literacy of the individual draftee. Again, we use data referred to the closest birth year of the conscript, namely local literacy rates taken from Spain’s population census of 1887. Bivariate correlations suggest a positive and statistically significant relationship between literacy rates and height in late nineteenth-century Catalonia (Table 4).
The third and fourth variables of control included in our regression aims to measure access to railway and water transport and, therefore, market access and market integration. The third variable refers to railway transport. There is a large body of literature that shows that the railway had an influence on heights. On the one hand, this influence tends to be positive in the case of urban dwellers since railways facilitated the transport of foodstuffs from rural to urban areas. As a result, foodstuffs became cheaper and more abundant in towns and cities, a circumstance that may well have helped to improve the nutrition of urban dwellers (e.g. Guven Solakoglu 2006; Yoo 2012; Zehetmayer 2013). However, railways might be detrimental to the biological living standards of the rural population. Firstly, they might facilitate the spread of diseases from cities to rural areas, and secondly, they might contribute to depriving country-dwellers of proteins and other nutrients, thus negatively affecting the height of rural communities (e.g. Komlos 1987; Haines 1998, 2004; Haines et al. 2003). In order to capture these potential impacts, we have constructed a variable that states the number of railway stations per 100 sq. km, in the municipality where the conscript in question resided. Using data provided by Pascual (2016, Appendixes) as well as other complementary information, this variable only considers the municipalities that had a station in broad gauge railway lines in 1890, coinciding with the year of the conscripts’ birth. In that year, the railway lines with broad gauge accounted for more than 90 percent of all railway lines operating in Catalonia (Pascual 2016, p. 27–30). We have complemented the information on railways by considering water transport. Thus, our fourth control variable measures the distance (in metres) between the locality where the focus conscript resided and the closest custom port.Footnote 10 The reasons for including this variable are similar to those taken into account for railways.
The last control variable we consider in our econometric model is the altitude of the municipalities where the conscript was officially residing at the time of inspection. This variable, which we have taken directly from IDESCAT, has been considered in several studies on biological living standards. For example, in Argentina, Bejarano et al. (2009) found a negative relationship between mean height and geographical altitude in a sample of 48,589 conscripts born between 1870 and 1960. By reviewing the findings of a Portuguese physical anthropologist, Da Costa Leite (1998, p. 460) observed that in the 1890s men were “shorter in the areas of higher altitude” of Northern Portugal. Ramon-Muñoz et al. (2022) arrived at similar conclusions for late nineteenth-century western Catalonia using a sample of 16,389 conscripts born between 1879 and 1890. This negative association between stature and altitude might reflect a number of factors, including, among others, climatic conditions, agriculture orientation, poor economic conditions in highlands, transport costs, isolation, as well as difficulties in accessing to richer and more abundant resources. In addition, altitude is also correlated to other variables that might negatively affect height. In our dataset, and as expected, it is significantly and negatively correlated with population size and population density (Table 4). However, in both cases the R2 is not as strong as one might have expected (around 0.25). Interestingly, the matrix of correlations presented in Table 4 also shows a negative relationship between altitude and height, while, as suggested above, height correlates positively with both population density and population size.
Finally, we also add territorial dummy controls to some of the specifications in our model. We consider that the territories where the conscripts lived differed in some unobservable way that might affect our dependent variable. Based on the information provided by the IDESCAT, we have considered eight different territorial areas: Alt Pirineu i Aran, Camp de Tarragona, Comarques Centrals, Comarques Gironines, Àmbit Metropolità de Barcelona, Penedès, Ponent, and Terres de l’Ebre.Footnote 11 While these areas include quite homogeneous counties, they also differ one from each other geographically as well as economically. This internal homogeneity combined with heterogeneity across territories would have been more difficult to identify if we had used dummies at provincial level.
Table 5 presents different specifications of the model. The results indicate a positive and statistically significant association between male heights and population size, although this significance is not universal in all municipality categories. In the absence of control variables, this association is statistically significant in the three first categories, namely up to 10,000 inhabitants (Table 5, Column 1). Relative to the conscripts that resided in cities with more than 20,000 inhabitants, which is the reference category, residents of these areas were –5.2, –7.2 and –9.8 mm shorter, depending on whether they lived in small towns (5001–10,000 inhabitants) or in larger (2001–5000 inhabitants) and smaller villages (less than 2001 inhabitants), respectively.
This urban advantage is not negligible, but it is lower than that recorded in other areas of the Iberian Peninsula that shared an urban height premium by around 1890. For example, we observe an urban advantage of between 15 and 20 mm in eastern Andalusia, south-eastern Spain and the Canary Islands (Martínez-Carrión and Pérez-Castejón 1998; Cámara 2007; Martínez-Carrión and Moreno-Lázaro 2007; Cañabate-Cabezuelos 2015; Cañabate-Cabezuelos and Martínez-Carrión 2017; Martínez-Carrión et al. 2022). The exceptions to this general rule are regions in central Spain, including Castile and Leon and Extremadura, where the height of urban dwellers exceeded that of the rural conscripts by around 5 mm (Hernández and Moreno 2011; Linares-Luján and Parejo-Moruno 2021). Moreover, Reis (2009, p. 83) found an urban premium of less than half a centimetre for Portugal. All these areas had lower levels of industrialisation than Catalonia. Furthermore, they mostly experienced a permanent urban premium throughout the nineteenth century, suggesting that the sectoral composition of the towns and cities might be as crucial as urbanisation in explaining urban–rural differences in biological living standards.
This relationship seems to find partial confirmation in Fig. 8. This figure contains the information referring to the above-mentioned regions and, in addition, the Valencian Community (Puche 2011) and the Basque Country (Pérez-Castroviejo and Martínez-Carrión 2018). While the results in Fig. 8 show that less industrialised areas tend to experience higher urban height advantages, they also leave an unresolved puzzle. Catalonia was more industrialised than Castile and Leon, located in central Spain, and the Mediterranean coastal Valencian Community, characterised by dynamic commercial agriculture and the emergence of some notable industrial towns in the nineteenth century. However, by the 1890s, the urban height advantage we find for Catalonia was higher than for these two regions. In fact, in the latter region, rural conscripts were taller than their urban counterparts. A rural height advantage is also recorded in the province of Biscay (Basque Country, northern Iberian Peninsula), with relatively high levels of industrialisation, although lower than those for the province of Barcelona.
The relationship between the urban–rural height male gap and the share of total employment in industry in Spain by regions, c. 1890. Notes and sources: We obtained the share of employment in the industry from the 1887 Population Census (Instituto Geográfico Estadístico 1892) and the urban–rural height gap from the references quoted in the text. Regarding employment, the actual figure refers to the districts of the localities included in the samples. As far as height is concerned, we estimated the urban–rural male height gap for Castile and Leon and Biscay by visually examining the graphs provided by the authors in their publications. For references, see the text
Resolving this potential puzzle is beyond the scope of this article. Nevertheless, it highlights a relevant methodological issue: the care we should take when comparing data sets with different characteristics. Whereas our analysis considers almost the whole of Catalonia and practically the entire male population enlisted in 1911, the rest of the historical research in Iberia uses samples from towns, which sometimes do not include localities with fewer than 5001 inhabitants. On other occasions, studies have excluded the region's largest cities. Occasionally, they take a single locality and differentiate within the same town or city according to type of environment. Last but not least, the criteria to define urban and rural settlements may vary from one study to the other, a circumstance that complicates comparative analysis.
Using a comprehensive dataset, we find an urban height premium for the young males living in Catalan cities with more than 20,000 inhabitants. The addition of control variables to the basic regression does not change the direction of the association between population size and height. However, coefficients and their statistical significance tend to vary. First, the linear relationship observed between population size and height, at least for the categories of municipalities of up to 10,000 inhabitants, becomes less clear. This is the case when, in addition to population density, number of railway stations, and literacy rate, we also control for the distance from a custom port and the municipality’s altitude. The same is true when we include dummies at territorial level in our model.Footnote 12 In early nineteenth-century England and Wales, Humphries and Leunig (2009a, p. 468) found that population became a significant (and negative) determinant of height only in towns with a population of more than 8000 inhabitants, and particularly in big cities. In the USA, Zehetmayer (2013, p. 175) found an inverse U-shaped relationship in which height reaches its maximum value in cities with about 250,000 inhabitants and then declined thereafter for the cohorts born in late nineteenth century. In Catalonia, we find no substantial differences in height between the residents in villages of up to 2000 inhabitants and those living in municipalities between 2001 and 5000 inhabitants (Table 5, columns 6 and 7), probably because these localities shared a rural environment, and differences in physical stature are mainly explained by factors other than population size. Perhaps more surprisingly, in our last econometric model specification, we also find no statistically significant differences in height in the draftees living in municipalities between 5001 and 20,000 inhabitants relative to our reference group. Clearly, these results point to the absence of a linear relationship between population size and height.
Second, after controlling for population density, literacy rate, number of railway stations, distance to a custom port and altitude, the differences between the heights of conscripts residing in municipalities with fewer than 5001 inhabitants and those living in towns (> 5000 inhabitants) and particularly cities (> 20,000 inhabitants) drop substantially (Table 5, column 6). Nevertheless, rural residents remain significantly shorter, and so the existence of an urban premium for late nineteenth-century Catalonia is confirmed. Evidence suggests a height gap of between one-half and three quarters of a centimetre between young males living in rural areas (≤ 5000 inhabitants) and those living in cities (> 20,000 inhabitants) (Table 5, columns 6 and 7). Although this difference might be regarded as slight, urban–rural height gaps of less than 1 cm are not uncommon in the context of nineteenth-century Europe when the relationship between height and population size is controlled for other factors.Footnote 13 In addition, though moderate, this urban–rural height gap is by no means irrelevant, particularly if we agree that height positively correlates with cognitive ability and is a good proxy for human capital, thus determining person’s life opportunities and outcomes. A recent review of the modern evidence linking childhood stunting and undernutrition to economic outcomes concluded that a 1-cm increase in adult height was associated with a “4 percent increase in wages for men and a 6 percent increase in wages for women” (McGovern et al. 2017, p. 17). Seen in this way, an urban premium of between one-half and three quarters of a centimetre might be considered less negligible than it initially appears, particularly in terms of long-term inequality across individuals and territories.
The confirmation of an urban premium for the cohorts born in the late nineteenth century is also a novelty relative to the European regions that experienced an urban penalty before 1900. In Spain, there are two areas that fall into this category: the already-mentioned province of Biscay, and the Valencian Community. The existing studies for these two territories do not always control for other variables and do not consider all the municipalities of the province or region they analyse. Nevertheless, they show a permanent urban penalty that persisted for the cohorts born in the first decade of the twentieth century and even later.
In western Europe, many regions and countries experienced an urban height penalty before the late nineteenth century. However, the available evidence suggests that only a limited number of them presented an urban height premium before or around 1900: examples are Sweden and the Netherlands, which we will now discuss.
For Sweden, the height data collected by Sandberg and Steckel (1988) show the emergence of a regional divide in the first half of the nineteenth century. Thus, the stature of the males born in the east and the north of the country increased between 1818–1837 and 1838 –1856. The opposite was true for the “densely populated and child intensive West” and in the “urban, and especially unhealthy, environment” of Stockholm, where males’ heights declined (Sandberg and Steckel 1988, p. 1 and 7). Therefore, in the 1838–1856 period, the mean height of these two latter regions had fallen below the Swedish mean, although probably less than initially considered (Heintel et al. 1998). However, this penalty was not permanent; in fact, it reversed into an urban height premium at some point in the second half of the nineteenth century or the first years of the twentieth. By 1905–1906, there was already “no evidence of an ‘urban penalty’ in height in the largest cities in Sweden” (Öberg and Collin 2017, p. 141); the males living in the urban counties of Stockholm and Gothenburg and Bohus were already significantly taller than the mean for Sweden as a whole. The precise point in time when Sweden’s urban premium emerged is uncertain, but at least regarding trends in the urban–rural height male gap, it does not seem to differ substantially from Catalonia.
In the Netherlands, Tassenaar (2019) found an urban male height premium from the 1860s onwards, at least for smaller and medium-sized cities. This chronology is similar to what our sample data for Catalonia show, namely the emergence of an urban premium starting in the 1870s that we can confirm for the 1890 birth cohort. For the province of Fryslân, Groote and Tassenaar (2020) also found an urban height advantage, which in that province began to emerge as early as the late 1850s. This is also what de Beer (2010, p. 70) concluded in analysing prisoner registers in the Netherlands. However, Tassenaar’s data suggest a less clear height advantage for the country’s two largest cities, which was not the case in Sweden. Thus, in the conscription years 1889–1913, the height of Amsterdam’s young males was 8 mm above the national male mean height, but it “lagged behind their counterparts from smaller urban residencies” (Tassenaar 2019, p. 158). In Rotterdam, young males were not only shorter than their counterparts in Amsterdam, but they fell more than 10 mm below the national mean and that of some rural provinces (Tassenaar 2019, p. 159). In contrast, in Sweden, the mean male height in the biggest cities was always above the national mean: the county of Stockholm had a height advantage of 14 mm and that of Gothenburg and Bohus of around 4 mm (Öberg and Collin 2017 table A1). After controlling for several variables, the results from Catalonia also suggest a qualified urban premium, as in the Netherlands. An urban advantage is apparent when we compare villages and towns of up to 5000 inhabitants and towns and cities of more than 20,000. In contrast, height differences are not statistically significant in the rest of the settlements (Table 5).
For other regions and countries in western Europe, the important point is the absence of a clear and consistent reversal of the urban height penalty before 1900. A first limitation in analysing this reversal is the small number of studies on long-term regional trends in the urban–rural height gap as compared to those that focus on the decades prior to the mid-nineteenth century. As a result, detailing whether, when, and to what extent urban height disadvantages turned into an urban height premium is a challenge. Table 6 provides some of the available evidence on the topic. To construct this table, we used three criteria. First, we considered only those regions that experienced a persistent urban penalty sometime in the nineteenth century; second, we selected only published papers whose data covered at least the cohorts born around 1850; and third, we included only studies whose regression analysis used control variables when testing for a potential urban–rural height gap. From this evidence, we can tentatively conclude that by the late nineteenth century, in contrast to Catalonia, the Netherlands, and perhaps Sweden, a qualified urban height disadvantage remained in Bavaria and Scotland. Additional evidence for the French region of Alsace points in the same direction: for the birth cohorts of 1890–1895, the males from the urban and industrial town of Mulhouse were shorter than those from the rural district of Sélestat (Heyberger 2007, p. 238).
The case of Scotland is particularly illuminating. The studies by Riggs (1994) and Riggs and Cuff (2013) show a height disadvantage of around 2 cm in the first half of the nineteenth century for cohorts of males living in Scottish cities and urban counties. This gap remained up to the end of the century. Further evidence on child heights suggests that in Scotland this height penalty in the urban environment might have persisted until the first decades of the twentieth century (Harris 1993; Riggs and Cuff 2013). Interestingly, in Alsace, the same occurs between Mulhouse and Sélestat, at least until the birth cohorts 1910–1920.
Since we observe a reversed urban height male penalty for Catalonia, our case study differs from the northern European regions and countries with a permanent urban premium throughout the nineteenth century. Examples are eastern Belgium, the German region of Württemberg, and Switzerland. With an urban male height advantage of less than 1 cm between villages and cities in the 1890 birth cohort, Catalonia is nevertheless comparable with the canton of Bern. Perhaps as expected, the late nineteenth-century Catalan urban premium was substantially lower than in the rest of western European regions that had avoided an urban penalty. This includes the Swiss cantons of Zurich and Basel and Württemberg in Germany, where urban dwellers were between 1.5 and 3 cm taller than their rural counterparts.Footnote 14
In short, urban–rural height differences were far from uncommon in modern Europe, but the direction of this gap, its magnitude, and its evolution differed across territories. There was no single pattern in the reversal of urban height male disadvantages. Similarly, one might expect the reversal patterns to be associated with the timing and intensity of the transformation of the cities into better health environments from the last decades of the nineteenth century onwards (e.g. Hatton 2014).
So, what are the reasons for the urban premium in late nineteenth-century Catalonia? As suggested in previous sections, improvements in public health and food supply are the obvious candidates. In the context of this study, however, an additional factor has to be considered: migration. The dataset we use provides information on the place of residence of conscripts, but not on their place of birth. Therefore, it might be that the urban–rural height gap we observe in our data was mainly the result of rural boys and young males who, at a certain time point between their birth (1890) and the enlistment years (1911) left their place of birth to settle in other areas, particularly cities. This was not uncommon in nineteenth-century Catalonia (e.g. Camps 1995; Cabré 1999). Fostered by the labour opportunities (and probably the higher wages) provided by industrial growth, a notably high number of Catalans born in villages and small towns emigrated to the city of Barcelona and to other towns on its outskirts where industrial and service activities had become predominant (Fig. 9). The same was true of the population born in the neighbouring regions of Aragón and València, who had also begun to settle in the province of Barcelona in the last decades of the nineteenth century (e.g. Silvestre 2003; Pinilla and Silvestre 2017; Pitarch Calero et al. 2018), mainly in the city of Barcelona, which attracted the bulk of Catalonia’s immigration.
Male population employed in the agricultural sector in Catalonia, 1887–1910 (in percentages). Notes and sources: Based on data from Nicolau (1990, p. 53)
Interestingly, the evidence available for the city of Barcelona also suggests that the migration pattern experienced significant transformations over the two decades and a half following the census year of 1887 (see Table 7). First, migration growth—including intra-Catalan migration—decelerated between 1900 and World War I compared to 1887–1900. Second, perhaps more critical in our discussion, non-Catalan migration to Catalonia outperformed intra-Catalan migration. As a result, the percentage of Catalan-born population in Barcelona tended to decline between 1887 and 1910.
The question of whether or not migration influenced the late nineteenth-century Catalonia urban–rural height gap needs to be addressed. The evidence in Table 7 suggests that this influence was probably less intense than expected, at least regarding the Catalan-born population. In 1910, the male Catalan population born outside Barcelona accounted for only 10 per cent of the total male population of this large urban area; in contrast, males born outside Catalonia made up about one-third. In other words, if urban Catalan conscripts were taller than their rural counterparts, this does not seem to be because rural conscripts were moving to urban areas. However, this issue needs to be explored in more depth.
In order to do so, we have collected data for a sample of towns located in the province of Barcelona which had a population of more than 10,000 inhabitants in the census year of 1887. We call these localities “urban towns”. Our dataset comprises the cohorts born in 1890, 1891 and 1892, who were enlisted in 1911, 1912 and 1913, respectively, and include about 3200 observations. We have classified the conscripts of these towns by place of birth.
Figure 10 summarises the raw results obtained. First, in the enlistment period of 1911–1913, conscripts born in urban towns were taller than others born elsewhere, who accounted for 30 percent of the total observations. Perhaps as expected, residents born outside Catalonia were shorter than Catalan-born conscripts, whether or not they were born in the towns considered as urban. Second, as conscripts born elsewhere were shorter than Catalan-born conscripts, our calculations record a fall in the mean height of the residents in industrial towns in 1911–1913 (birth cohorts of 1890–1892) when those born outside Catalonia are included. While these data await a more formal analysis, these preliminary results suggest that our urban height data are to some extent a lower-bound representation of urban-born heights.
The mean height of a sample of conscripts residing in the province of Barcelona in municipalities with more than 10,000 inhabitants by place of birth (male cohorts born in 1890–1892 and enlisted in 1911–1913, in mm). Notes and sources: Based on data for Badalona, Igualada, Manresa, Sabadell, Terrassa, Vic and Vilanova i la Geltrú from the Actas de Clasificación y Declaración de Soldados (Acts of Classification and Declaration of Soldiers), 1911–1913, and Ramon-Muñoz and Ramon-Muñoz (2022a)
Unfortunately, at the present stage of research it is still difficult to fully assess whether the Catalan rural-born males living in urban areas in 1911 were taller (or shorter) than their rural-born and rural-resident counterparts. The literature available indicates a higher physical stature for rural-born movers compared to rural-born stayers (e.g. Humphries and Leunig 2009b; Juif and Quiroga 2019, and for international movements Kosack and Ward 2014; Blum and Rei 2018). However, our sample data suggest otherwise: the mean height of those conscripts born in rural Catalan areas (in villages and towns of up to 5000 inhabitants) residing in urban municipalities (in towns with more than 10,000 inhabitants) in 1911 was 1640 mm. This figure is very similar to the 1639 mm we obtain as the mean height of the rural draftees born in 1890 who were still living in rural areas in 1911, which, if confirmed by further analysis, would suggest that internal migration had only a modest impact on the urban premium we find in late nineteenth-century Catalonia. It might also suggest a higher urban premium than our data indicate. Although referring to the male birth cohorts of 1900–1904, additional information for a sample of 1382 conscripts residing in the Barcelona neighbourhood of Sarrià between 1921 and 1925 points in the same direction: migration may have reduced the mean height of urban areas (Fig. 11).Footnote 15
The mean height of a sample of conscripts residing in the Barcelona neighbourhood of Sarrià by place of birth (male cohorts born in 1901–1905 and enlisted in 1921–1925, in mm). Notes and sources: “Born outside Catalonia” excludes conscripts born outside Spain. “All residents” also includes conscripts born outside Spain (11 obs.) and those whose place of birth is unknown (1 ob.). Based on data from the Actas de Clasificación y Declaración de Soldados (Acts of Classification and Declaration of Soldiers), 1921–1925, and Ramon-Muñoz and Ramon-Muñoz (2022a)
Among other possible explanations of the urban premium observed, we have already mentioned the potential improvements in public sanitation and in housing conditions, as well as better and more widespread access to medical services in cities. In spite of these measures, however, contemporary descriptions do not always suggest very optimistic conclusions with regard to the extent of the progress achieved, above all for the city of Barcelona and the cohorts born before the early 1890s (e.g. Capel and Tatjer 1991; Martín Pascual 2009, 2011; Tello and Ostos 2012; Guàrdia et al. 2014; Sabaté 2017). Water supply and the sewerage system were still very deficient, which favoured the emergence and transmission of infectious diseases such as the 1885 cholera epidemic. Housing conditions do not appear to have been much better. Perhaps an exception to this grim picture is healthcare: indeed, the last two decades of the nineteenth century witnessed notable improvements in health services, mainly as a result of the opening of new hospitals, organisation of municipal medical services and, in general, an increase in local budget allocations. While the 1885 cholera epidemic accelerated the authorities’ intervention in public health, it was only from the 1890s onwards that systematic action was taken to improve the water supply and sanitation.Footnote 16 In the years around 1890, mortality rates in the city of Barcelona were still higher than in the rest of the province. This pattern is also found in other Catalan and Spanish provinces (e.g. Ramiro-Fariñas and Sanz-Gimeno 2000; Reher 2001; Escudero and Nicolau 2014; Pérez Moreda et al. 2018; Ramon-Muñoz and Ramon-Muñoz 2022b).
If the information above on mortality reflects environmental conditions and, therefore, improvements in public sanitation and healthcare, one might hypothesise that the urban height premium we find for the cohorts born in late nineteenth-century Catalonia had little to do with “care and cure” factors. If so, the Catalan case would differ from some recent well-researched cases in northern Europe (e.g. Heyberger 2014; Groote and Tassenaar 2020). Nevertheless, the data we have at our disposal, namely crude mortality rates and the number of doctors per 1000 inhabitants at district (county) level (n = 35), suggest that environmental factors may also have played a non-negligible role in explaining the Catalan urban–rural height gaps (Figs. 12 and 13). Crude mortality rates correlate negatively with height, and this bivariate correlation is statistically significant (p-value = 0.010). The number of doctors per 1000 inhabitants correlates positively with height at district level, and once again the correlation is significant (p-value = 0.001). While both data sets tell the same story, the latter is not influenced by the age composition of the population and thus may be more accurate as a proxy for environmental conditions.
Relationship between mean height (mm) and crude death rates (per 1000 population) in Catalonia by districts, c. 1890. Notes and sources: Instituto Geográfico y Estadístico (1895). The y and x axes display the data in logarithms
Relationship between mean height (mm) and the number of doctors (per 1000 population) in Catalonia by districts, c. 1890. Notes and sources: Instituto Geográfico y Estadístico (1892). The y and x axes display the data in logarithms
Another group of factors that might also explain the urban premium in late nineteenth-century Catalonia is to do with improvements in the quantity and quality of food availability for urban dwellers (e.g. see Steckel and Floud 1997b for an overview of the role of nutritional factors in explaining biological living standards). Table 5 shows that the overall influence of the railway on height is, in general, not statistically significant. The possibility that the results would have been different if we had used a different proxy for measuring the impact of railways on height cannot be ruled out (Heyberger 2014). In fact, the existing evidence suggests that food availability improved in the last decades of the nineteenth century, thanks above all to the greater intake of high-protein products (e.g. Cussó and Garrabou 2004, p. 73). Estimates in Barcelona, for example, show that per capita meat consumption increased by 44 percent between 1881 and 1900; and perhaps more importantly, per capita milk consumption more than tripled between 1865 and 1900 (Nicolau and Pujol 2005, p. 117; Hernández-Adell and Pujol 2017, p. 89). Milk is a high-protein product, whose intake has been, in general, positively associated with physical stature (e.g. Takahashi 1984; Baten 2009; de Beer 2012).
This rapid increase in the availability of high-protein products deserves further comment. As expected, our preliminary estimates based on the available Spanish cattle censuses (Giralt 1990) show that, by the turn of the nineteenth century, per capita milk consumption (as proxied by milk availability) was still higher in the rural areas of northern Catalonia than in urban centres such as Barcelona (Fig. 14), although it was in the districts with higher population density where per capita consumption had grown the most since the 1860s (Fig. 15). In addition, the same estimates suggest that, as far as meat is concerned, per capita levels of consumption were lower in rural than in urban districts. These estimates are based on cattle slaughtered in slaughterhouses for public consumption, a measure which probably underestimates the consumption of meat products in rural areas. In spite of this, the higher levels of per capita meat consumption in cities do not seem surprising in the light of the available evidence for Spain (e.g. Pérez Moreda et al. 2018 p. 312).
5 Conclusions
This study has explored whether (and if so, to what extent) there was an urban–rural height gap in the north-eastern Iberian region of Catalonia in the nineteenth century. By using long-term data on heights, it first showed that as industrial production grew between the early 1840s and the late 1860s urban heights declined and that urban dwellers remained on average shorter than their rural counterparts. These findings suggest both the existence of an “early industrial growth paradox” and the emergence of an “urban penalty” in the middle decades of the nineteenth century. From the late 1860s onwards, urban heights began an upward trend and in the last quarter of the nineteenth century the previous urban penalty turned into an urban premium.
The urban height premium which emerged in Catalonia in the last quarter of the nineteenth century is further confirmed by the construction of a unique new dataset consisting of almost 18,000 observations for the cohort of males born in the year 1890 and enlisted in the year 1911 and covering almost all the municipalities that form present-day Catalonia. The broad geographical coverage of our dataset represents a real novelty in the context of historical anthropometrics in Iberia. It also represents a step forward in the existing international literature on the topic. A long list of publications have focused on the decades before the mid-nineteenth century, showing the emergence of an urban height penalty. Unfortunately, this list is considerably shorter for the last decades of the nineteenth century, and this circumstance has prevented us from establishing with clarity when an earlier urban height disadvantage might have transformed into a premium.
By applying cross-sectional data and an ordinary least squares (OLS) model, the urban premium is confirmed after controlling for population density, presence of a rail station, distance to seaports, literacy rate, and altitude. The results of our test show an urban premium of between one-half and three quarters of a centimetre for young males living in cities (> 20,000 inhabitants) compared to those residing in rural areas (≤ 5000 inhabitants), which, though moderate, is not unsubstantial if we place this height difference in a broader context. Gaps of similar magnitude were not uncommon in nineteenth-century Europe. In terms of economic outcomes, the implications of this urban–rural height differential do not seem negligible, as discussed throughout the previous sections. A linear relationship between physical stature and population size is, nevertheless, not observed when control variables are included in the regressions. Other studies using large samples have suggested a lack of a linear relationship between height and population size, and this also seems to be the case of Catalonia.
The main findings of this research contribute to the literature on industrialisation, living standards and urban–rural inequality in physical stature in several ways. First, they qualify previous studies suggesting the absence of an urban penalty in the Iberian Peninsula.Footnote 17 While the economic growth pattern in Catalonia differed from most Iberian regions, the same applies to the urban–rural height gap. Although very tentative and subject to qualifications, the comparative evidence presented in this article points to this direction: it suggests that in late nineteenth-century Spain, less industrialised areas tended to experience higher urban height advantages. In the international context, we also find a distinctive pattern in Catalonia relative to eastern Belgium, Württemberg, and Switzerland, where scholars have found a permanent urban premium in the nineteenth century.
Second, we found that Catalonia appears to have overcome the adverse health effects caused by urban agglomerations rather earlier than might perhaps have been expected. It has been argued that “urban populations were generally shorter than rural ones until the early twentieth century” (Komlos and Baten 2004, p. 195; see also Komlos 1998). However, by controlling for several variables, we can confirm that in Catalonia, a qualified urban premium had already emerged for the 1890 birth cohort. Interestingly, comparing our case study with areas that also experienced an urban penalty, we also found the emergence of an urban premium earlier than in some territories in Britain, France, Spain and perhaps also Germany, but in line with other regions and countries in northern Europe; in Scotland, Alsace, and the Basque province of Biscay for example, urban dwellers remained generally shorter than their rural counterparts until the first decades of the twentieth century. In our study, we confirm an urban height premium in Catalonia for the male cohorts born in 1890. We also report notable similarities between Catalonia and the Netherlands, which places Catalonia in the context of the European regions that experienced a transition from an urban penalty to an urban premium during the second half of the nineteenth century. Sweden followed the same transition as Catalonia and the Netherlands. Nevertheless, in the case of Sweden, we can only confirm an absence of height disadvantages for urban males in the first years of the twentieth century.
Third, in comparing Catalonia with other European regions, this paper shows that several patterns emerged in nineteenth-century Europe in the relationship between population size and height. As observed, this pattern may vary substantially within the same country, a fact which underlines the relevance of the regional analysis in strengthening and sometimes qualifying approaches based on broader geographical classifications. For the same reason, it also highlights why regions follow one pattern or another in height inequality according to the type of settlement and, as suggested when comparing regions in Spain, according to regional productive specialisation.
Fourth, this paper has also explored the reasons why urban dwellers in late nineteenth-century Catalonia were taller than their rural counterparts. At present, we can only hypothesise that internal migration exerted no clear effect. Further analysis should confirm whether the urban height premium in late nineteenth-century Catalonia is better explained by the epidemiological environment or by nutritional factors, and, if so, to what extent.
Finally, this research has provided new insights into the urban–rural divide in well-being in areas and over a period of critical economic transformations, such as nineteenth-century Europe. Using a rich new dataset and focusing the analysis on the late nineteenth century, this paper has shown that a binary classification of population settlements may be misleading. When it emerged, the urban–rural gap was not linear; it was associated with a kind of threshold from which population size differences translated into differences in biological living standards. Moreover, this urban–rural gap could change its direction over time. By extending and focusing the analysis of the urban–rural height gap to the last decades of the nineteenth century, this research suggests that, in Europe, an urban height premium may have emerged earlier and may have been more widespread, than previously believed.
Notes
Nevertheless, for the particular case of Alsace, Heyberger (2007, p. 237) found similar heights in urban and rural areas until about the 1840s, “when the two diverged until the end of the century, as is expected for the height of urban inhabitants”. This author argued that “it is unusual that the rural–urban divergence in height happened relatively late in Alsace (1840s) and even at its peak in the 1850s birth cohorts it was only about 1 cm-lower than in many other parts of the world”. On the other hand, Kok et al. (2018) stress the importance of the compositional effect in explaining urban–rural differences, e.g. poorer families are more likely to be found in cities.
This also might contribute to explaining why life expectancy at birth in cities above 100,000 inhabitants in England and Wales was lower and did not converge with the country’s average in the first decades of the nineteenth century (Szreter and Mooney 1998). Nevertheless, R. J. Davenport has recently challenged Szreter and Mooney's account (Davenport 2020, see also Davenport et al. 2019). For a discussion, see, Szreter and Mooney (2021) and Davenport (2021).
For the particular case of Spain, this applies to all the studies quoted with the exception of Quiroga (2001), who uses provincial samples.
Additional evidence confirms Catalonia’s height leadership observed in Fig. 4 for male cohorts born some years before the outbreak of World War I, at least as far Spain is concerned. In contrast, for the cohorts born in the late nineteenth century the available evidence is less conclusive. See Quiroga (2001, 2002), Gómez Mendoza and Pérez Moreda (1985), and Martínez-Carrión et al. (2016).
Indeed, the primary and fundamental reason for our selection of this birth cohort is that this is the only year we found height information for almost all localities in Catalonia. In addition, data for the birth cohort of 1890 (corresponding to the recruitment year of 1911) may shed light on the possible reversal of fortune in the biological living standards of Catalan urban dwellers. As shown in Sect. 2, the last two decades of the nineteenth century appear to have been a critical period in the development of the urban–rural height gap, as urban heights may have surpassed rural ones.
In fact, exemptions from military service were made effective once the enlistment process ended (Nicolau and Fatjó 2016).
Certainly, there are other broad datasets in Iberia, although they are not always designed to search for the existence of a urban–rural height gap. The datasets that include a large number of localities refer to Extremadura (35 localities, cohorts of males born from 1855 to 1979), rural Catalonia (102 localities, cohorts of males born from 1879 to 1896) and rural Madrid (18 localities, cohorts of males born from 1837 to 1915). See García Montero (2009), Linares-Luján and Parejo-Moruno (2021), and Ramon-Muñoz et al. (2022), respectively. In contrast, the database with the largest number of observations (n = 358,253) with male cohorts born between 1840 and 1964 includes only 19 localities. See Cámara et al. (2019).
See, for example, the more recent studies by Alsan and Goldin (2019), Chapman (2019, 2022), de Looper et al. (2019); Floris and Kaspar Staub (2019), Harris and Helgertz (2019), Harris and Hinde (2019), Helgertz and Önnerfors (2019), Peltola and Saaritsa (2019), Gallardo-Albarrán (2020), Raftakis (2021), Troesken et al. (2021).
See http://www.idescat.cat/en/ (last accessed July 5, 2021).
Esteban-Oliver (2020). The custom ports are Alcanar, Arenys de Mar, Badalona, Barcelona, Blanes, Cadaqués, Cambrils, l’Escala, Lloret de Mar, Malgrat, Masnou, Mataró, Palafrugell, Palamós, Roses, Salou, la Ràpita, Sant Feliu de Guíxols, el Port de la Selva, Sitges, Tarragona, Torredembarra, Tortosa, Tossa de Mar, el Vendrell, Vilanova i la Geltrú.
See https://www.idescat.cat/codis/?id=50&n=28 (last accessed July 5, 2021), and Ramon-Muñoz and Ramon-Muñoz (2021, pp. 45, Figure A6).
As a robustness check, and to control for potential multicollinearity between independent variables, we examined other specifications of the model. Thus, we dropped from the regression the variable municipal population density, which, as already argued, is highly correlated with municipal population size. In the same vein, we also substituted the population density variable with the variable municipal area, which, to some extent, might indirectly reflect the important issue of overcrowding. Appendix (Table 8) presents the results we obtained after controlling for the variables literacy rates, railway station, distance from a custom port, altitude, and territorial dummies. Although coefficients may vary slightly, they confirm that the young males resident in rural municipalities were shorter than those living in cities of more than 20,000 people.
See, for example, Humphries and Leunig (2009a, pp. 466–69), and Jaadla, Shaw-Taylor and Davenport (2020, p. 13) for England and Wales in the early nineteenth century, Cinnirella (2008, p. 340) for early and mid-nineteenth-century Britain, and Heyberger (2014, pp. 128–30) for mid-nineteenth-century France. In all these cases, urban heights are lower.
According to this information, conscripts born in Barcelona were taller than their peers: between 3 and 9 mm taller, depending on the place of birth. Not surprisingly, the difference between the conscripts born in Barcelona and those born in other Catalan municipalities would be 5 mm instead of 3 mm if we exclude young males born in the province of Barcelona, where urban settlements were predominant.
By the mid-nineteenth century, in Barcelona, the water supply and its network had increased substantially relative to the 1820s (Tello and Ostos 2012, p. 349). However, according to Guàrdia et al. (2014, p. 418), “technically speaking, the facility was not very different from the system that had existed (…) during ancient Roman times”. From the 1860s onwards, several projects and works to improve and increase access to clean water also took place. They represented a breakpoint in water supply; and two of them have been considered “the beginning of the first (…) modern supplies provided by private companies in Barcelona” (Martín Pascual 2011, p. 70; the translation is ours). As for the first project, Matés-Barco (2019, p. 62, the translation is ours) also argued that the “incorporation of the modern drinking water system can be traced back to 1867, with the construction of the Torre de las Aguas [Torre de les Aigües, Water Tower] by the Sociedad de Crédito y Fomento de Barcelona [Barcelona Credit and Development Society]. By the early 1870s, another private company—the Companyia d’Aigües de Barcelona [Barcelona Water Company]—had a water network in operation that served two Barcelona neighbourhoods (Guàrdia et al. 2014, p. 419). This was the second modern project. Nevertheless, in the mid-1880s water supply and sanitation still showed “important deficiencies” (Martín Pascual 2011, p. 71, the translation is ours). Advances in sanitation appeared only later. A crucial decade in the organisation of the “fight against disease and death” was that of 1885–1895 (Capel and Tatjer 1991, p. 51). In 1884, the local authorities set up a Commission to analyse the situation of the sewage system, the conclusions of which were published in 1886; as a result, five years later, in 1891, a project for reforming this system was approved. In that year, a new project was also passed to increase water supply, partly to meet the expected sewer requirements. Nevertheless, it was only in 1902 that the renewal of the sewer system began (Guàrdia et al. 2014, p. 423). In addition, the available estimates show that per capita urban water consumption remained unchanged until the mid-twentieth century (Tello and Ostos 2012, p. 349).
See Sect. 1 for references.
References
A’Hearn B (2003) Anthropometric evidence on living standards in Northern Italy, 1730–1860. J Econ Hist 63(2):351–381. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0022050703001827
Allen RC (2009) Engels’ pause: Technical change, capital accumulation, and inequality in the British industrial revolution. Explor Econ Hist 46(4):418–435. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.eeh.2009.04.004
Alsan M, Goldin C (2019) Watersheds in child mortality: the role of effective water and sewerage infrastructure, 1880–1920. J Polit Econ 127(2):586–638. https://doi.org/10.1086/700766
Alter G, Neven M, Oris M (2004) Stature in transition: a micro-level study from nineteenth-century Belgium. Soc Sci Hist 28(2):231–247. https://doi.org/10.1017/s0145553200013146
Ayuda MI, Puche-Gil J (2014) Determinants of height and biological inequality in Mediterranean Spain, 1859–1967. Econ Hum Biol 15:101–119. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ehb.2014.07.003
Bairoch P, Goertz G (1986) Factors of urbanisation in the nineteenth century developed countries: a descriptive and econometric analysis. Urban Stud 23(4):285–305. https://doi.org/10.1080/00420988620080351
Baten J (2009) Protein supply and nutritional status in nineteenth century Bavaria. Prussia and France Econ Hum Biol 7(2):165–180. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ehb.2009.02.001
Baten J, Murray JE (2000) Heights of men and women in 19th-century Bavaria: economic, nutritional, and disease influences. Explor Econ Hist 37(4):351–369. https://doi.org/10.1006/exeh.2000.0743
Bejarano IF, Dipierri JE, Andrade A, Alfaro EL (2009) Geographic altitude, surnames, and height variation of Jujuy (Argentina) conscripts. Am J Phys Anthropol 138(2):158–163. https://doi.org/10.1002/ajpa.20915
Bell F, Millward R (1998) Public health expenditures and mortality in England and Wales, 1870–1914. Contin Chang 13(2):221–249. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0268416098003142
Blum M (2016) Inequality and Heights. In: Komlos J, Kelly IR (eds) The Oxford handbook of economics and human biology. Oxford University Press, New York, pp 178–191
Blum M, Rei C (2018) Escaping Europe: Health and human capital of Holocaust refugees. Eur Rev Econ Hist 22(1):1–27. https://doi.org/10.1093/ereh/hex014
Bodenhorn H, Guinnane TW, Mroz TA (2017) Sample-selection biases and the industrialization puzzle. J Econ Hist 77(1):171–207. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0022050717000031
Broadberry S, Campbell BMS, Klein A et al (2015) British economic growth, 1270–1870. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Cabré A (1999) El sistema català de reproducció: cent anys de singularitat demogràfica. Proa, Barcelona
Cámara AD (2006) Fuentes antropométricas en España: problemas metodológicos para los siglos XVIII y XIX. Hist Agrar 38:103–118
Cámara AD (2007) Niveles de vida en el medio rural de Andalucía Oriental (1750–1950). Universidad de Granada, Ph.D. diss.
Cámara AD, Martínez-Carrión JM, Puche J, Ramon-Muñoz J-M (2019) Height and inequality in Spain: a long-term perspective. Rev Hist Econ - J Iber Lat Am Econ Hist 37:205–238. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0212610919000089
Camps E (1995) La formación del mercado de trabajo industrial en la Cataluña del siglo XIX. Ministerio de Trabajo y Seguridad Social, Madrid
Cañabate-Cabezuelos J (2015) Estatura, salud y niveles de vida en Castilla-La Mancha. El caso de Hellín, 1887–2000. Universidad de Murcia, Ph.D. diss.
Cañabate-Cabezuelos J, Martínez-Carrión JM (2017) Poverty and stature in rural Inland Spain during the nutritional transition. Hist Agrar 71:109–142
Capel H, Tatjer M (1991) Reforma social, serveis assistencials i higienisme a la Barcelona de finals del segle XIX (1876–1900). In: Roca Rosell A (ed) Cent anys de salut pública a Barcelona. Ajuntament de Barcelona, Barcelona, pp 31–73
Carreras A (1985) La producción industrial catalana y vasca, 1844–1935. In: González Portilla M, Maluquer de Motes J, de Riquer Permanyer B (eds) Industrialización y nacionalismo: análisis comparativo. Universitat Autònoma de Barcelona, Barcelona, pp 197–210
Carreras A (1990) Cataluña, primera región industrial de España. In: Nadal J, Carreras A (eds) Pautas regionales de la industrialización española (siglos XIX y XX). Ariel, Barcelona, pp 259–295
Carreras A (2019) L’economia catalana: una visió plurisecular. Institut d’Estudis Catalans, Barcelona
Carson SA (2008) Health during industrialization: evidence from the nineteenth-century Pennsylvania state prison system. Soc Sci Hist 32(3):347–372. https://doi.org/10.1215/01455532-2008-002
Carson SA (2009) Geography, insolation, and vitamin D in nineteenth century US African-American and white statures. Explor Econ Hist 46(1):149–159. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.eeh.2008.09.002
Chapman J (2019) The contribution of infrastructure investment to Britain’s urban mortality decline, 1861–1900. Econ Hist Rev 72(1):233–259. https://doi.org/10.1111/ehr.12699
Chapman J (2022) Interest rates, sanitation infrastructure, and mortality decline in nineteenth-century England and Wales. J Econ Hist 82(1):175–210. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0022050721000589
Cinnirella F (2008) Optimists or pessimists? A reconsideration of nutritional status in Britain, 1740–1865. Eur Rev Econ Hist 12(3):325–354. https://doi.org/10.1017/S136149160800227X
Clark G (1994) Factory discipline. J Econ Hist 54(1):128–163. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0022050700014029
Clark G (2005) The condition of the working class in England, 1209–2004. J Polit Econ 113(6):1307–1340. https://doi.org/10.1086/498123
Coale AJ, Treadway R (1986) A Summary of the changing distribution of overall fertility, marital fertility, and the proportion married in the provinces of Europe. In: Watkins SC (ed) The decline of fertility in Europe. Princeton University Press, pp 31–181
Cussó X, Garrabou R (2004) La transició nutricional a la Catalunya contemporània: una primera aproximació. Recer Història, Econ Cult 47(48):51–80
Da Costa LJ (1998) Male height in northwest Portugal in the 1890s: old data revised. In: Komlos J, Baten J (eds) The Biological standard of living in comparative perspective. Franz Steiner Verlag, Stuttgart, pp 459–466
Davenport RJ (2020) Urbanization and mortality in Britain, c. 1800–50. Econ Hist Rev 73(2):455–485. https://doi.org/10.1111/ehr.12964
Davenport RJ (2021) Nineteenth-century mortality trends: a reply to Szreter and Mooney. Econ Hist Rev 74(4):1096–1110. https://doi.org/10.1111/ehr.13109
Davenport RJ, Satchell M, Shaw-Taylor LMW (2019) Cholera as a ‘sanitary test’ of British cities, 1831–1866. Hist Fam. https://doi.org/10.1080/1081602X.2018.1525755
de Beer H (2010) Physical stature and biological living standards of girls and young women in the Netherlands, born between 1815 and 1865. Hist Fam 15(1):60–75. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.hisfam.2009.12.003
de Beer H (2012) Dairy products and physical stature: a systematic review and meta-analysis of controlled trials. Econ Hum Biol 10(3):299–309. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ehb.2011.08.003
de Looper MW, Booth H, Baffour B (2019) Sanitary improvement and mortality decline in Sydney, New South Wales, 1857–1906: drinking water and dunnies as determinants. Hist Fam 24(2):227–248. https://doi.org/10.1080/1081602X.2018.1550725
Díez-Minguela A, Martínez-Galarraga J, Tirado-Fabregat DA (2018) Regional inequality in Spain. Palgrave Macmillan, Cham
Dopico F (1985) Desarrollo económico y social y mortalidad infantil. Diferencias regionales (1860–1950). Dynamis 5–6:381–396
Drukker J, Tassenaar V (1997) Paradoxes of modernization and material well-being in the netherlands during the nineteenth century. In: Steckel RH, Floud R (eds) Health and welfare during industrialization. University of Chicago Press, Chicago, pp 331–378
Escudero A, Nicolau R (2014) Urban penalty: Nuevas hipótesis y caso Español (1860–1920). Hist Soc 80:9–33
Esteban-Oliver G (2020) The curse of geography? Railways and growth in Spain 1877–1930. Working Paper Asociación Española de Historia Económica (DT-AEHE) no. 2011
Feinstein CH (1998) Pessimism perpetuated: Real wages and the standard of living in britain during and after the industrial revolution. J Econ Hist 58(3):625–658. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0022050700021100
Fernández Álvarez A (2017) Mina, Aigües de Terrassa (1842–2017). Una crònica de 175 anys. Mina Pública d’Aigües de Terrassa, Terrassa
Ferrer-Alòs L (2021) La transició demogràfica primerenca de Catalunya. Recer Història, Econ Cult 78:27–96
Floris J, Staub K (2019) Water, sanitation and mortality in Swiss towns in the context of urban renewal in the late nineteenth century. Hist Fam 24(2):249–276. https://doi.org/10.1080/1081602X.2019.1598460
Floud R, Wachter K, Gregory A (1990) Height, health and history: nutritional status in the United Kingdom, 1750–1980. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Floud R, Fogel RW, Harris B, Hong SC (2011) The changing body: health, nutrition, and human development in the western world since 1700. Cambridge University Press, New York
Gallardo-Albarrán D (2020) Sanitary infrastructures and the decline of mortality in Germany, 1877–1913. Econ Hist Rev 73(3):730–757. https://doi.org/10.1111/ehr.12942
Gallardo-Albarrán D, de Jong H (2021) Optimism or pessimism? A composite view on English living standards during the Industrial Revolution. Eur Rev Econ Hist 25(1):1–19. https://doi.org/10.1093/ereh/heaa002
Gallardo-Albarrán D, García-Gómez JJ (2022) Growth or stagnation? Well-being during the Spanish industrialization in Alcoy (1860-1910). Investig Hist Económica 18:26-37. https://doi.org/10.33231/j.ihe.2021.03.002
Gao P, Schneider EB (2021) The growth pattern of British children, 1850–1975. Econ Hist Rev 74(2):341–371. https://doi.org/10.1111/ehr.13002
García Montero H (2009) Antropometría y niveles de vida en el Madrid rural, 1837–1915. Hist Agrar 47:95–117
Giralt E (1990) L’agricultura. In: Nadal i Oller J, Maluquer de Motes J, Sudrià i Triay C, Cabana i Vancells F (eds) Història econòmica de la Catalunya Contemporània. S. XIX. Població i agricultura. Enciclopèdia Catalana, Barcelona, pp 121–305
Gómez Mendoza A, Luna Rodrigo G (1986) El desarrollo urbano en España, 1860–1930. Rev Demogr Histórica - J Iberoam Popul Stud 2:3–22
Gómez Mendoza A, Pérez Moreda V (1985) Estatura y nivel de vida en la España del primer tercio del siglo XX. Moneda y Crédito 174:29–64
Groote P, Tassenaar V (2020) Living standards in a dairy region, 1850–1900: from urban penalty to urban premium. J Hist Geogr 70:12–23. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jhg.2020.08.001
Guàrdia M, Rosselló M, Garriga S (2014) Barcelona’s water supply, 1867–1967: the transition to a modern system. Urban History 41(3):415–434. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0963926813000692
Guven Solakoglu E (2006) The net effect of railroads on stature in the postbellum period. Res Econ Hist 24:105–117. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0363-3268(06)24003-5
Haines MR (1998) Health, height nutrition and mortality: evidence on the «Antebellum Puzzle» from Union Army Recruits for New York State and the United States. In: Komlos J, Baten J (eds) The biological standard of living in comparative perspective. Franz Steiner Verlag, Stuttgart, pp 155–180
Haines MR (2004) Growing incomes, shrinking people—can economic development be hazardous to your health? Soc Sci Hist 28(2):249–270. https://doi.org/10.1215/01455532-28-2-249
Haines MR, Craig LA, Weiss T (2003) The short and the dead: nutrition, mortality, and the ‘Antebellum Puzzle’ in the United States. J Econ Hist 63(2):382–413. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0022050703001839
Harris B (1993) The demographic impact of the first world war: an anthropometric perspective. Soc Hist Med 6(3):343–366. https://doi.org/10.1093/shm/6.3.343
Harris B (2016) Food supply, health and economic development in England and Wales during the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries. Sci Danica, Ser h, Humanist 4(7):141–154
Harris B, Helgertz J (2019) Urban sanitation and the decline of mortality. Hist Fam 24(2):207–226. https://doi.org/10.1080/1081602X.2019.1605923
Harris B, Hinde A (2019) Sanitary investment and the decline of urban mortality in England and Wales, 1817–1914. Hist Fam 24(2):339–376. https://doi.org/10.1080/1081602X.2018.1556722
Harris B, Floud R, Hong SC (2015) How many calories? Food availability in England and Wales in the Eighteenth and nineteenth centuries. Res Econ Hist 31:111–191. https://doi.org/10.1108/S0363-326820150000031003
Hassan JA (1985) The growth and impact of the british water industry in the nineteenth century. Econ Hist Rev 38(4):531–547. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1468-0289.1985.tb00387.x
Hatton TJ (2014) How have Europeans grown so tall? Oxf Econ Pap 66(2):349–372. https://doi.org/10.1093/oep/gpt030
Hatton TJ, Bray BE (2010) Long run trends in the heights of European men, 19th-20th centuries. Econ Hum Biol 8(3):405–413. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ehb.2010.03.001
Heintel M, Sandberg LG, Steckel RH (1998) Swedish historical heights revisited: new estimation techniques and results. In: Komlos J, Baten J (eds) The biological standard of living in comparative perspective. Franz Steiner, Stuttgart, pp 449–458
Helgertz J, Önnerfors M (2019) Public water and sewerage investments and the urban mortality decline in Sweden 1875–1930. Hist Fam 24(2):307–338. https://doi.org/10.1080/1081602X.2018.1558411
Hernández R, Moreno J (2009) El nivel de vida en el medio rural de Castilla y León. Una constatación antropométrica, 1840–1970. Hist Agrar 47:143–166
Hernández R, Moreno J (2011) Industrialización, desindustrialización y niveles de vida en las ciudades de Castilla y León, 1840–1935. Indicadores antropométricos y demográficos. Hist Soc 69:25–48
Hernández-Adell I, Pujol J (2017) Cities and milk consumption in Europe, 1890–1936: the emergence of a new market in Spain. Hist Agrar 73:59–89. https://doi.org/10.26882/HistAgrar.073E03h
Heyberger L (2007) Toward an anthropometric history of provincial France, 1780–1920. Econ Hum Biol 5(2):229–254. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ehb.2007.04.003
Heyberger L (2014) Received wisdom versus reality: height, nutrition, and urbanization in mid-nineteenth-century France. Cliometrica 8(1):115–140. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11698-013-0095-1
Humphries J (2010) Childhood and child labour in the British industrial revolution. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Humphries J (2013) Childhood and child labour in the British industrial revolution. Econ Hist Rev 66(2):395–418. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1468-0289.2012.00651.x
Humphries J, Leunig T (2009a) Cities, market integration, and going to sea: stunting and the standard of living in early nineteenth-century England and Wales. Econ Hist Rev 62(2):458–478. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1468-0289.2008.00458.x
Humphries J, Leunig T (2009b) Was Dick Whittington taller than those he left behind? Anthropometric measures, migration and the quality of life in early nineteenth century London? Explor Econ Hist 46(1):120–131. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.eeh.2007.08.001
Instituto Geográfico Estadístico (1892) Censo de la población de España según el empadronamiento hecho en 31 de diciembre de 1887. Imprenta de la Dirección General del Instituto Geográfico y Estadístico, Madrid
Instituto Geográfico Estadístico (1895) Movimiento de la población de España. Septenio de 1886–92. Imprenta de la Dirección General del Instituto Geográfico y Estadístico, Madrid
Jaadla H, Shaw-Taylor L, Davenport RJ (2021) Height and health in late eighteenth-century England. Popul Stud (NY) 75(3):381–401. https://doi.org/10.1080/00324728.2020.1823011
Juif D, Quiroga G (2019) Do you have to be tall and educated to be a migrant? Evidence from Spanish recruitment records, 1890–1950. Econ Hum Biol 34:115–124. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ehb.2018.12.006
Klüsener S, Devos I, Ekamper P et al (2014) Spatial inequalities in infant survival at an early stage of the longevity revolution: a pan-European view across 5000+ regions and localities in 1910. Demogr Res 30:1849–1864. https://doi.org/10.4054/DemRes.2014.30.68
Kok J, Beekink E, Bijsterbosch D (2018) Environmental influences on young adult male height. A comparison of town and countryside in the Netherlands, 1815–1900. Hist Life Course Stud 6:95–110. https://doi.org/10.51964/hlcs9330
Komlos J (1985) Stature and nutrition in the habsburg monarchy: the standard of living and economic development in the eighteenth century. Am Hist Rev 90(5):1149–1161. https://doi.org/10.1086/ahr/90.5.1149
Komlos J (1987) The height and weight of west point cadets: dietary change in antebellum America. J Econ Hist 47(4):897–927. https://doi.org/10.1017/S002205070004986X
Komlos J (1998) Shrinking in a growing economy? The mystery of physical stature during the industrial revolution. J Econ Hist 58(3):779–802. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0022050700021161
Komlos J (2004) How to (and how not to) analyze deficient height samples. Hist Methods 37(4):160–173. https://doi.org/10.3200/HMTS.37.4.160-173
Komlos J (2019) Shrinking in a growing economy is not so puzzling after all. Econ Hum Biol 32:40–55. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ehb.2018.11.005
Komlos J, A’Hearn B (2019) Clarifications of a puzzle: the decline in nutritional status at the onset of modern economic growth in the United States. J Econ Hist 79(4):1129–1153. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0022050719000573
Komlos J, Baten J (2004) Looking backward and looking forward: anthropometric research and the development of social science history. Soc Sci Hist 28(2):191–210. https://doi.org/10.1215/01455532-28-2-191
Kosack E, Ward Z (2014) Who crossed the border? Self-selection of Mexican migrants in the early twentieth century. J Econ Hist 74(4):1015–1044. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0022050714000849
Lantzsch J, Schuster K (2009) Socioeconomic status and physical stature in 19th-century Bavaria. Econ Hum Biol 7(1):46–54. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ehb.2008.08.001
Larrosa M (1992) Acció pública i iniciativa privada en el subministrament d’aigües de Sabadell durant la industrialització. Arraona Rev D’història 11:9–31
Linares-Luján AM, Parejo-Moruno FM (2021) Rural height penalty or socioeconomic penalization? The nutritional inequality in backward Spain. Int J Environ Res Public Health 18(9):4453. https://doi.org/10.3390/ijerph18094483
Livi-Bacci M (1968) Fertility and nuptiality changes in Spain from the late 18th to the early 20th century. Popul Stud 22(2):211–234. https://doi.org/10.1080/00324728.1968.10405536
Lucey DS, Crossman V (2014) Healthcare in Ireland and Britain from 1850: voluntary, regional and comparative perspectives. University of London Press, London
Maluquer de Motes J (1994) El índice de la producción industrial de Cataluña: una nueva estimación (1817–1935). Rev Hist Ind 5:45–71. https://doi.org/10.1344/rhi.v0i5.18231
Martí-Henneberg J (2005) Empirical evidence of regional population concentration in Europe, 1870–2000. Popul Space Place 11:269–291. https://doi.org/10.1002/psp.373
Martín Pascual M (2011) La revolució de l’aigua. In: Guàrdia M (ed) La revolució de l’aigua a Barcelona: de la ciutat preindustrial a la metròpoli moderna, 1867–1967. Ajuntament de Barcelona, Barcelona, pp 69–73
Martín Pascual M (2009) Barcelona: aigua i ciutat. L’abastament d’aigua entre les dues exposicions (1888–1929). Fundació Agbar & Marcial Pons, Madrid
Martínez-Carrión JM, Cámara AD (2015) El nivel de vida biológico durante el declive de la industrialización andaluza: el caso de Antequera. Rev Hist Ind 58:129–159. https://doi.org/10.1344/rhi.v24i58.21257
Martínez-Carrión JM, Moreno-Lázaro J (2007) Was there an urban height penalty in Spain, 1840–1913? Econ Hum Biol 5(1):144–164. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ehb.2006.09.001
Martínez-Carrión JM, Pérez-Castejón JJ (1998) Height and standards of living during the industrialisation of Spain: The case of Elche. Eur Rev Econ Hist 2(2):201–230. https://doi.org/10.1017/s1361491698000094
Martínez-Carrión JM, Pérez-Castroviejo PM, Puche Gil J, Ramon-Muñoz J-M (2014) La brecha rural-urbana de la estatura y el nivel de vida al comienzo de la industrialización Española. Hist Soc 80:35–57
Martínez-Carrión JM, Pérez-Castejón JJ (2002) Creciendo con desigualdad. Niveles de vida biológicos en la España rural mediterránea desde 1840. In: Martínez-Carrión JM (ed) El nivel de vida en la España rural, siglos XVIII-XX. Publicaciones de la Universidad de Alicante, Alicante, pp 405–460
Martínez-Carrión JM, Cámara AD, Pérez-Castroviejo PM (2016) Parámetros antropométricos de los reclutas españoles antes de la transición nutricional. Análisis de las desigualdades territoriales (1858–1913). Nutr Hosp 33(6):1477–1486. https://doi.org/10.20960/nh.812
Martínez-Carrión JM, Candela-Martínez B, Román-Cervantes C, Díaz-Carmona G (2022) Poor but tall. The height premium in the Canary Islands at the beginning of nutritional transition. Working Paper Sociedad de Estudios de Historia Agraria (DT-SEHA) no. 2206
Matés-Barco JM (2019) El abastecimiento de agua a Barcelona (1850–1936): Origen y desarrollo de las compañías privadas. Hist Contemp 59:161–194. https://doi.org/10.1387/hc.19434
McGovern ME, Krishna A, Aguayo VM, Subramanian SV (2017) A review of the evidence linking child stunting to economic outcomes. Int J Epidemiol 46(4):1171–1191. https://doi.org/10.1093/ije/dyx017
Meinzer NJ, Baten J (2016) Global perspectives on economics and biology. In: Komlos J, Kelly IR (eds) The Oxford handbook of economics and human biology. Oxford University Press, New York, pp 275–295
Meinzer NJ, Steckel RH, Baten J (2018) Agricultural specialization, urbanization, workload, and stature. In: Roberts CA, Larsen CS, Baten J, Steckel RH (eds) The backbone of Europe: health, diet, work and violence over two millennia. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp 231–252
Meredith D, Oxley D (2014a) Food and fodder: feeding England, 1700–1900. Past Present 222(1):163–214. https://doi.org/10.1093/pastj/gtt020
Meredith D, Oxley D (2014b) Nutrition and health, 1700–1870. In: Floud R, Humphries J, Johnson P (eds) The Cambridge economic history of Modern Britain, vol I. 1700–1870. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp 118–148
Mokyr J, Ó Gráda C (1989) The height of Irishmen and Englishmen in the 1770’s: some evidence from the East India Company Army records. Eighteenth-Century Irel / Iris an Dá Chultúr 4:83–92
Mokyr J, Ó Gráda C (1994) The heights of the British and the Irish c. 1800–1815: evidence from recruits to the east India Company’s Army. In: Komlos J (ed) Stature, living standards, and economic development: essays in anthropometric history. University of Chicago Press, Chicago, pp 39–59
Mokyr J, Ó Gráda C (1996) Height and health in the United Kingdom 1815–1860: evidence from the East India company army. Explor Econ Hist 33(2):141–168. https://doi.org/10.1006/exeh.1996.0007
Molina F (2012) Servicio militar y conflicto. Historia y sociología de las quintas en España (1878–1960). Editorial Milenio, Lleida
Moreno-Lázaro J, Martínez-Carrión JM (2010) Secular trend in Castile and Leon (Spain): 1830–1990s. Rev Esp Antropol Fis 31:1–12
Nadal J (1959) Demografía y economía en el origen de la Cataluña moderna. Un ejemplo local: Palamós (1705–1839). Estud Hist Mod 6:281–309
Nadal J (1966) La población española: siglos XVI a XX. Ariel, Barcelona
Nadal J (1975) El fracaso de la revolución industrial en España, 1814–1913. Ariel, Barcelona
Nadal J, Sáez A (1972) La fécondité à Sanit Joan de Palamós (Catalogne) de 1700 a 1859. Ann Demogr Hist (Paris) 1972:105–113. https://doi.org/10.3406/adh.1972.2110
Nadal J (1985) Catalunya, la fàbrica d’Espanya. In: Nadal J, Maluquer de Motes J (eds) Catalunya, la fàbrica d’Espanya. Un segle d’industrialització catalana, 1833–1936. Ajuntament de Barcelona, Barcelona, pp 131–135
Nicolau R (1990) Els factors demogràfics del creixement econòmic: Catalunya, 1787–1910. In: Nadal i Oller J, Maluquer de Motes J, Sudrià i Triay C, Cabana i Vancells F (eds) Història econòmica de la Catalunya Contemporània. S. XIX. Població i agricultura. Enciclopèdia Catalana, Barcelona, pp 13–62
Nicolau R, Pujol J (2005) El consumo de proteínas animales en Barcelona entre las décadas de 1830 y 1930: evolución y factores condicionantes. Investig Hist Econ 1(3):101–134. https://doi.org/10.1016/S1698-6989(05)70021-7
Nicolau R, Fatjó P (2016) Morbilidad y mortalidad de los soldados del ejército Español, 1886–1933. Asclepio 68(1):1–19. https://doi.org/10.3989/asclepio.2016.08
Öberg S, Collin K (2017) Regional variation and convergence of height and living conditions in Sweden during the twentieth century. Essays Econ Bus Hist J Econ Bus Hist Soc 35(1):123–150
Ó Gráda C (1996) Anthropometric history. What’s in it for Ireland? Hist Mes 11(1):139–166. https://doi.org/10.3406/hism.1996.1472
Palma N, Reis J (2021) Can autocracy promote literacy? Evidence from a cultural alignment success story. J Econ Behav Organ 186:412–436. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jebo.2021.02.011
Parejo J (2001) Industrialización, desindustrialización y nueva industrialización de las regiones españolas (1950–2000). Un enfoque desde la historia económica. Rev Hist Ind 19/20:15–75. https://doi.org/10.1344/rhi.v0i19-20.19393
Pascual P (2016) El ferrocarril a Catalunya (1848–1935). Una història de la seva explotació. Eumo, Vic
Peltola J, Saaritsa S (2019) Later, smaller, better? Water infrastructure and infant mortality in Finnish cities and towns, 1870–1938. Hist Fam 24(2):277–306. https://doi.org/10.1080/1081602X.2019.1598462
Pérez Moreda V, Reher DS, Sanz Gimeno A (2018) La conquista de la salud. Marcial Pons, Madrid
Pérez-Castroviejo PM, Martínez-Carrión JM (2018) Diferencias rural-urbana del estado nutricional en Vizcaya durante la Revolución industrial. Nutr Hosp 35(extra5):47–53. https://doi.org/10.20960/nh.2084
Perrin F (2022) On the origins of the demographic transition: rethinking the European marriage pattern. Cliometrica 16(3):431–475. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11698-021-00237-2
Pinilla V, Silvestre J (2017) La emigración aragonesa a Cataluña desde la Revolución Industrial a nuestros días. In: Sabio Alcutén A, Lahuerta V (eds) Los vínculos históricos entre Aragón y Cataluña, siglos XVIII-XX. Institución Fernando el Católico - Gobierno de Aragón, Zaragoza, pp 132–149
Pitarch Calero K, Villar Garruta C, López-Gay A (2018) Being a migrant in Barcelona in 1930. Valencian immigration in the neighbourhood of la Barceloneta. Pasado y Memoria Rev Hist Contemp 17:259–299. https://doi.org/10.14198/PASADO2018.17.10
Pollard S (1981) Peaceful conquest: the industrialization of Europe 1760–1970. Oxford University Press, Oxford
Puche J (2011) Evolución del nivel de vida biológico en la Comunidad Valenciana, 1840–1969. Investig Hist Económica 7(3):380–394. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ihe.2010.10.003
Puche J, Cañabate-Cabezuelos J (2016) Did physical stature diminish during Spain’s early industrialisation? The case of Alcoy, 1840–1915. Rev Hist Ind 64:119–147. https://doi.org/10.1344/rhi.v25i64.21217
Quiroga G (2001) Estatura, diferencias regionales y sociales y niveles de vida en España (1893–1954). Rev Hist Econ - J Iber Lat Am Econ Hist 19(S1):175–200. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0212610900009587
Quiroga G (2002) Medidas antropométricas y condiciones de vida en la España del siglo XX. Universidad de Alcalá de Henares, Ph.D. diss.
Raftakis M (2021) Why were infants dying and what were they dying from? Infant mortality patterns in the Greek urban centre of Hermoupolis, Syros (1860–1940). Hist Fam 26(3):405–433. https://doi.org/10.1080/1081602X.2021.1921008
Ramiro-Fariñas D, Sanz-Gimeno A (2000) Structural changes in childhood mortality in Spain, 1860–1990. Int J Popul Geogr 6(1):61–82. https://doi.org/10.1002/(SICI)1099-1220(200001/02)6:1%3c61::AID-IJPG168%3e3.0.CO;2-C
Ramon-Muñoz J-M (2009) Bienestar biológico y crecimiento agrario en la Cataluña rural, 1840–1936. Hist Agrar 47:119–142
Ramon-Muñoz J-M (2011) Industrialización, urbanización y bienestar biológico en Cataluña, 1840–1935: Una aproximación antropométrica. Rev Hist Ind 46:41–71
Ramon-Muñoz R, Ramon-Muñoz J-M (2015) Height and industrialisation in a city in Catalonia during the nineteenth century. UB Economics Working Papers no. E15/334
Ramon-Muñoz R, Ramon-Muñoz J-M (2016) The biological standard of living in nineteenth-century industrial Catalonia: a case study. Rev Hist Ind 64:77–118
Ramon-Muñoz R, Ramon-Muñoz J-M (2018) Biological standards of living in rural Catalonia over the long run: a comparison with urban areas (1840–1960). Nutr Hosp 35(extra5):54–62. https://doi.org/10.20960/nh.2085
Ramon-Muñoz R, Ramon-Muñoz J-M (2021) The urban–rural height gap: evidence from late nineteenth-century Catalonia. Working Paper Sociedad de Estudios de Historia Agraria (DT-SEHA) no. 2105
Ramon-Muñoz R, Ramon-Muñoz J-M (2022a) Internal migrations and biological living standards in late-nineteenth and early-twentieth centuries Catalonia. Unpublished Manuscript
Ramon-Muñoz R, Ramon-Muñoz J-M (2022b) Spatial health inequality in a large European City: Barcelona in the late-nineteenth and early-twentieth centuries. Unpublished Manuscript
Ramon-Muñoz R, Ramon-Muñoz J-M, Koepke N (2022) Well-being and the late 19th century agrarian crisis: anthropometric evidence from rural Catalonia. Unpublished Manuscript
Reher DS (2001) In search of the ‘Urban Penalty’: exploring urban and rural mortality patterns in Spain during the demographic transition. Int J Popul Geogr 7(2):105–127. https://doi.org/10.1002/ijpg.212
Reis J (2009) «Urban premium» or «urban penalty»? The case of Lisbon, 1840–1912. Hist Agrar 47:69–94
Riba Gabarró J (2006) Etapes dels sanejaments privats i públics de la ciutat d’Igualada. Misc Aqualatensia 12:323–352
Riggs P (1994) The standard of living in Scotland, 1800–1850. In: Komlos J (ed) Stature, living standards, and economic development: essays in anthropometric history. The University of Chicago Press, Chicago, pp 60–75
Riggs P, Cuff T (2013) Ladies from Hell, Aberdeen Free Gardeners, and the Russian influenza: An anthropometric analysis of WWI-era Scottish soldiers and civilians. Econ Hum Biol 11(1):69–77. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ehb.2012.03.005
Rosés JR, Wolf N (eds) (2018) The economic development of Europe’s regions: A quantitative history since 1900. Routledge, Abingdon & New York
Sabaté F (2017) Public health in Catalonia between 1885 and 1939. Catalan Hist Rev 10:43–57. https://doi.org/10.2436/20.1000.01.131
Sánchez A (1989) La era de la manufactura algodonera en Barcelona, 1736–1839. Estud Hist Soc 48:65–113
Sandberg LG, Steckel RH (1988) Overpopulation and malnutrition rediscovered: hard times in 19th-century Sweden. Explor Econ Hist 25(1):1–19. https://doi.org/10.1016/0014-4983(88)90019-8
Schneider EB (2020) Sample-selection biases and the historical growth pattern of children. Soc Sci Hist 44(3):417–444. https://doi.org/10.1017/ssh.2020.10
Schoch T, Staub K, Pfister C (2012) Social inequality and the biological standard of living: an anthropometric analysis of Swiss conscription data, 1875–1950. Econ Hum Biol 10(2):154–173. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ehb.2011.05.001
Serra M (2016) Breu història de l’abastament d’aigua a la ciutat de Girona. In: Girona. Aigua i ciutat (II). Ajuntament de Girona, Girona, pp 81–105
Silvestre J (2003) Inmigraciones interiores e industrialización: el caso de la ciudad de Zaragoza durante el primer tercio del siglo XX. Rev Demogr Histórica - J Iberoam Popul Stud 21(2):59–92
Steckel RH, Floud R (1997a) Introduction. In: Steckel RH, Floud R (eds) Health and welfare during industrialization. University of Chicago Press, Chicago, pp 1–17
Steckel RH, Floud R (1997b) Conclusions. In: Steckel RH, Floud R (eds) Health and welfare during industrialization. University of Chicago Press, Chicago, pp 423–449
Stolz Y, Baten J, Reis J (2013) Portuguese living standards, 1720–1980, in European comparison: heights, income, and human capital. Econ Hist Rev 66(2):545–578. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1468-0289.2012.00658.x
Szreter S (1988) The importance of social intervention in Britain’s mortality decline c.1850–1914: a re-interpretation of the role of public health. Soc Hist Med 1(1):1–38. https://doi.org/10.1093/shm/1.1.1
Szreter S, Mooney G (1998) Urbanization, mortality, and the standard of living debate: new estimates of the expectation of life at birth in nineteenth-century British cities. Econ Hist Rev 51(1):84–112. https://doi.org/10.1111/1468-0289.00084
Szreter S, Mooney G (2021) Scarlet fever and nineteenth-century mortality trends: a reply to Romola Davenport. Econ Hist Rev 74(4):1087–1095. https://doi.org/10.1111/ehr.13042
Takahashi E (1984) Secular trend in milk consumption and growth in Japan. Hum Biol 56(3):427–437
Tanner JM (1978) Foetus into man: physical growth from conception to maturity. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA
Tassenaar V (2019) Development of regional variety of the biological standard of living in the Netherlands, 1812–1913. Econ Hum Biol 34:151–161. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ehb.2019.02.004
Tello E, Ostos JR (2012) Water consumption in Barcelona and its regional environmental imprint: a long-term history (1717–2008). Reg Environ Chang 12(2):347–361. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10113-011-0223-z
Thompson EP (1967) Time, work-discipline, and industrial capitalism. Past Present 38(1):56–97. https://doi.org/10.1093/past/38.1.56
Thomson JKJ (1992) A distinctive industrialization: cotton in Barcelona, 1728–1832. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Thomson JKJ (2005) Explaining the ‘take-off’ of the Catalan cotton industry. Econ Hist Rev 58(4):701–735. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1468-0289.2005.00319.x
Troesken W, Tynan N, Yang YA (2021) What are the health benefits of a constant water supply? Evidence from London, 1860–1910. Explor Econ Hist 81:101402. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.eeh.2021.101402
Twarog S (1993) Heights and living standards in industrializing Germany: the case of Württemberg. The Ohio State University, Ph.D. diss.
Twarog S (1997) Heights and living standards in Germany, 1850–1939: the case of Wurttemberg. In: Steckel RH, Floud R (eds) Health and welfare during industrialization. University of Chicago Press, Chicago, pp 285–330
van Zanden JL, Baten J, Mira d’Ercole M et al (2014) How was life? Global well-being since 1820. OECD Publishing, Paris
Voth HJ (1998) Time and work in eighteenth-century London. J Econ Hist 58(1):29–58. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0022050700019872
Voth HJ (2001) The longest years: new estimates of labor input in England, 1760–1830. J Econ Hist 61(4):1065–1082. https://doi.org/10.1017/s0022050701042085
Voth HJ (2003) Living standards during the industrial revolution: an economist’s guide. Am Econ Rev 93(2):221–226. https://doi.org/10.1257/000282803321947083
Yoo D (2012) Height and death in the Antebellum United States: a view through the lens of geographically weighted regression. Econ Hum Biol 10(1):43–53. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ehb.2011.09.006
Zehetmayer M (2013) Health, market integration, and the urban height penalty in the US, 1847–1894. Cliometrica 7(2):161–187. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11698-012-0085-8
Zimran A (2019) Sample-selection bias and height trends in the nineteenth-century United States. J Econ Hist 79(1):99–138. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0022050718000694
Acknowledgements
Earlier versions of this paper were presented at Agricliometrics III – Quantitative Approaches to Rural, Agricultural and Environmental History, Magdalene College, University of Cambridge, 2017, Iberometrics VIII – Eight Iberian Cliometrics Workshop, Institute for Advanced Research in Business and Economics (INARBE), Universidad Pública de Navarra (UPNA), Pamplona, 2017, 12th European Historical Economics Society Conference, Tübingen, Germany, 2017, the workshop “Inequality, Poverty and Well-being in Spain: New Looks, New Approaches”, Universidad de Murcia, Murcia, 2018, and XVIII World Economic History Conference, Boston Marriott Cambridge & MIT Campus, Boston, 2018. We thank the participants at these meetings for their useful comments, and Daniel Gallardo-Albarrán for his careful reading and detailed suggestions regarding previous versions of this paper, Guillermo Esteban-Oliver for sharing his data on geographic distances, and Antonio Di Paolo for his useful advice. We are also very grateful to two anonymous reviewers and Claude Diebolt, the editor of this journal, for their constructive and helpful comments. The usual disclaimer applies.
Funding
Open Access funding provided thanks to the CRUE-CSIC agreement with Springer Nature. This study forms part of the Research project PID2020-113793GB-I00 funded by MCIN/AEI/10.13039/501100011033 and the research project PGC2018-093896-B-I00 funded by MCIN/AEI/10.13039/501100011033 and ERDF: A way of making Europe.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Ethics declarations
Conflict of interests
No conflict of interest.
Additional information
Publisher's Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Appendix
Appendix
Rights and permissions
Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article's Creative Commons licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article's Creative Commons licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this licence, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/.
About this article
Cite this article
Ramon-Muñoz, R., Ramon-Muñoz, JM. The urban–rural height gap: evidence from late nineteenth-century Catalonia. Cliometrica 18, 103–149 (2024). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11698-022-00263-8
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11698-022-00263-8