Abstract
Purpose
Incineration is mainly studied when municipal solid waste (MSW) treatment options are assessed in life cycle assessment case studies. A variety of incineration models have been used to create life cycle inventories (LCIs), but they often do not represent the technology and input waste composition of a given incineration situation. This article describes development of the regionalised municipal solid waste incineration (RMWI) model designed at the city-to-country level and its application to French MSW incineration.
Methods
RMWI is based on previously published incineration models from the ecoinvent database and Koehler et al. (Environ Sci Technol 45:3487–3495, 2011). Its system boundaries include furnace, gas-treatment steps, transport and management of by-products (e.g. clinkers, residues from cleaning flue gas, scrap). Its first strong point is the ability to adapt input waste composition. Its second strong point is that MSW collection and energy, scrap and clinker recovery options are modelled as stocks. Thus, users may adapt RMWI for the types of waste input and regional outlets for energy and matter recovery. French data were used in the model for MSW input composition, emission limits of some exhaust gases and transport distances of by-products. The method used to the collect these data is described so it can be reproduced for another region.
Results and discussion
The RMWI model is designed in GaBi 6. Environmental impacts predicted by RMWI for France are assessed to identify hot spots and input parameters with high influence. Chemical production for gas treatments was identified as a major contributor to abiotic depletion, whilst NH3 and NOx emissions were mainly responsible for acidification and eutrophication. In a second approach, the consideration of the recovery of by-products as heat, electricity, clinker, iron and aluminium scraps aims at understanding their contributions to environmental impacts. Sensitivity analyses were performed to determine to what extent RMWI predictions are sensitive to French incineration conditions. Comparison to generic LCI approaches highlighted merits of a regionalised model, especially concerning the type of gas treatment. The RMWI model effectively links input waste composition and environmental impacts.
Conclusions
RMW-predicted impacts, representation of stocks, sensitivity analyses and comparison to generic approaches were assessed to examine the model’s relevance, robustness and limits. The model is now available for French incineration but also can be used to assess environmental impacts of an incineration plant or another regional (city-to-country) incineration situation by adapting and calibrating it.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
ADEME (2003) Incinération des déchets ménagers en France—Situation en 2000—Evolution et perspectives au 31.12.2002
ADEME (2010a) La composition des ordures ménagères et assimilées en France—Campagne nationale de caractérisation 2007
ADEME (2010b) Les installations de traitement des ordures ménagères en France—Résultats 2010
ADEME (2015) Les installations de traitement des ordures ménagères en France—Données 2012
ADEME, BRGM (2008) Mâchefers d’incinérations des ordures ménagères—États de l’art et perspectives. Technique et Ingénierie
Aissani L, Barbier R, Beurois C, Méry J, Schlierf K (2012) Résultats des inventaires et études de cas de l’utilisation des outils d’évaluation environnementale dans les processus décisionnels en matière de gestion des déchets. Livrable 1 du projet PRODDEVAL. Irstea, Engees, Médiation & Environnement
Aissani L, Barbier R, Beurois C, Déchaux C, Méry J, Ward-Perkins P (2014) Contributions à l’étude de l’insertion de l’évaluation environnementale dans les processus de décision de gestion des déchets—Livrable 2 du projet PRODDEVAL. Irstea, Engees, Médiation & Environnement
Allegrini E, Vadenbo C, Boldrin A, Astrup TF (2015) Life cycle assessment of resource recovery from municipal solid waste incineration bottom ash. J Environ Manag 151:132–143
Alston SM, Arnold JC (2011) Environmental impact of pyrolysis of mixed WEEE plastics part 2: life cycle assessment. Environ Sci Technol 45:9386–9392
Anex RP, Focht W (2002) Public participation in life cycle assessment and risk assessment: a shared need. Risk Anal 22:861–877
Antonini G (2005) Traitements thermiques des déchets—Procédés et technologies associées
Arena U, Mastellone ML, Perugini (2003a) The environmental performance of alternative solid waste management options: a life cycle assessment study. Chem Eng J 96:207–222
Arena U, Mastellone ML, Perugini (2003b) Life cycle assessment of a plastic packaging recycling system. Int J Life Cycle Assess 8:92
Assamoi B, Lawryshyn Y (2012) The environmental comparison of landfilling vs. incineration of MSW accounting for waste diversion. Waste Manag 32:1019–1030
Assefa G, Björklund A, Eriksson O, Frostell B (2005) ORWARE: an aid to environmental technology chain assessment. J Clean Prod 13:265–274
Baitz M et al. (2013) GaBi database & modelling principles 2013. PE International
Banar M, Cokaygil Z, Ozkan A (2009) Life cycle assessment of solid waste management options for Eskisehir, Turkey. Waste Manag 29:54–62
Beccali G, Cellura M, Mistretta M (2001) Managing municipal solid waste—energetic and environmental comparison among different management options. Int J Life Cycle Assess 6:243–249
Bergsdal H, Stromman AH, Hertwich EG (2005) Environmental assessment of two waste incineration strategies for central Norway. Int J Life Cycle Assess 10:263–272
Bhander GS, Christensen TH, Hauschild MZ (2010) EASEWASTE—life cycle modeling capabilities for waste management technologies. Int J Life Cycle Assess 15:403–416
Björklund A, Finnveden G (2007) Life cycle assessment of a national policy proposal—the case of a Swedish waste incineration tax. Waste Manag 27:1046–1058
Björklund A, Dalemo M, Sonesson U (1999) Evaluating a municipal waste management plan using ORWARE. J Clean Prod 4:271–280
Boesch ME, Vadenbo C, Saner D, Huter C, Hellweg S (2014) An LCA model for waste incineration enhanced with new technologies for metal recovery and application to the case of Switzerland. Waste Manag 34:378–389
Bozorgirad MA, Zhang H, Haapala KR, Murthy GS (2013) Environmental impact and cost assessment of incineration and ethanol production as municipal solid waste management strategies. Int J Life Cycle Assess 18:1502–1512
Brattebø H, Reenaas M (2012) Comparing CO2 and NOx emissions from a district heating system with mass-burn waste incineration versus likely alternative solutions—City of Trondheim, 1986–2009. Resour Conser and Recy 60:147–158
Burnley SJ (2007) A review of municipal solid waste composition in the United Kingdom. Waste Manag 27:1274–1285
Burnley SJ, Ellis JC, Flowerdew R, Poll AJ, Prosser H (2007) Assessing the composition of municipal solid waste in Wales. Resour Conserv Recycl 49:264–283
Buttol P, Masoni P, Bonoli A, Goldoni S, Belladonna V, Cavazzuti (2007) LCA of integrated MSW management system: case study of the Bologna District. Waste Manag 27:1059–1070
Chaya W, Gheewala SH (2007) Life cycle assessment of MSW-to-energy schemes in Thailand. J Clean Prod 15:1463–1468
Chen D, Christensen TH (2010) Life cycle assessment (EASEWASTE) of two municipal solid waste incineration technologies in China. Waste Manag Res 28:508–519
Cherubini F, Bargigli S, Ulgiati S (2009) Life cycle assessment (LCA) of waste strategies: landfilling, sorting plant and incineration. Energy 34:2116–2123
Cherubini F, Peters GP, Berntsen T, Stromman AH, Hertwich E (2011) CO2 emissions from biomass combustion for bioenergy: atmospheric decay and contribution to global warming. Glob Change Biol Bioenerg 3:413–426
Cherubini F, Stromman AH, Hertwich E (2013) Biogenic CO2 fluxes from bioenergy and climate—a response. Ecol Model 253:79–81
Christensen TH, Bhander G, Lindvall H, Larsen AW, Fruergaard T, Damgaard A, Manfredi S, Boldrin A, Riber C, Hauschild M (2007) Experience with the use of LCA-modelling (EASEWASTE) in waste management. Waste Manag Res 25:257–262
Ciroth A, Hagelüken M, Sonnemann GW, Castells F, Fleischer G (2002a) Geographical and technological differences in life cycle inventories shown by the use of process models for waste incinerators part I. Technological and geographical differences. Int J Life Cycle Assess 7:295–300
Ciroth A, Hagelüken M, Sonnemann GW, Castells F, Fleischer G (2002b) Geographical and technological differences in life cycle inventories shown by the use of process models for waste incinerators part I. Technological and geographical differences. Int J Life Cycle Assess 7:363–368
Dalemo M, Sonesson U, Björklund A, Mingarini K, Frostell B, Jönsson H, Nybrant T, Sundqvist JO, Thyseliusa L (1997) ORWARE – A simulation model for organic waste handling systems. Part 1: Model description. Resour Conserv Recy 21:17–37
Damien A (2009) Guide du traitement des déchets. Paris
De Feo G, Malvano C (2009) The use of LCA in selecting the best MSW management system. Waste Manag 29:1901–1915
den Boer E, Jedrczak A, Kowalski Z, Kulczycka J, Szpadt R (2010) A review of municipal solid waste composition and quantities in Poland. Waste Manag 30:369–377
Di Maria F, Micale C (2015) Life cycle analysis of management options for organic waste collected in an urban area. Environ Sci Pollut R 22:248–263
Doka G (2003) Life cycle inventories of waste treatment services. ecoinvent report no. 13. Swiss Centre for Life Cycle Inventories, St. Gallen
Doka G (2008) Calculation tool for waste disposal in municipal solid waste incinerators MSWI, 2.1 edn. ecoinvent, Zurich
Edelmann W, Schleiss K, Joss A (2000) Ecological, energetic and economic comparison of anaerobic digestion with different competing technologies to treat biogenic wastes. Water Sci Technol 41:263–273
Ekvall T, Assefa G, Bjorklund A, Eriksson O, Finnveden G (2007) What life-cycle assessment does and does not do in assessments of waste management. Waste Manag 27:989–996
Emery A, Davies A, Griffiths A, Williams K (2007) Environmental and economic modelling: a case study of municipal solid waste management in Wales. Resour Conserv Recy 49:244–263
Eriksson O, Bisaillon M (2011) Multiple system modelling of waste management. Waste Manag 31:2620–2630
Eriksson O, Frostell B, Björklund A, Assefa G, Sundqvist JO, Granath J, Carlsson M, Baky A, Thyselius L (2002) ORWARE: a simulation tool for waste management. Resour Conserv Recy 36:287–307. doi:10.1016/S0921-3449(02)00031-9
Eriksson O, Carlsson Reich M, Frostell B, Björklund A, Assefa G, Sundqviste JO, Granath J, Baky L, Thyselius L (2005) Municipal solid waste management from a systems perspective. J Clean Prod 13:241–252
European Commission (2006) Integrated pollution prevention and control—reference document on the best available techniques for waste incineration
European Commission (2010) International reference life cycle data system (ILCD) handbook—general guide for life cycle assessment—detailed guidance. Joint Research Centre—Institute for Environment and Sustainability, Luxembourg
European Parliament (2008) Directive 2008/98/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 19 November 2008 on waste and repealing certain directives
Finnveden G, Johansson J, Lind P, Moberg (2005) Life cycle assessment of energy from solid waste—part 1: general methodology and results. J Clean Prod 13:213–219
Gianfilippo MD, Costa G, Pantini S, Allegrini E, Lombardi F, Astrup TF (2016) LCA of management strategies for RDF incineration and gasification bottom ash based on experimental leaching data. Waste Manag 47:285–298
Goedkoop MJ, Heijungs R, Huijbregts M, De Schryver A, Struijs J, Van Zelm R (2009) ReCiPe 2008, A life cycle impact assessment method which comprises harmonised category indicators at the midpoint and the endpoint level; First edition Report I: Characterisation
Güereca LP, Gasso S, Baldasano JM, Jiménez-Guerrero (2006) Life cycle assessment of two biowaste management systems for Barcelona, Spain. Resour Conserv Recy 49:32–48
Guest G, Cherubini F, Stromman AH (2013) Global warming potential of carbon dioxide emissions from biomass stored in the anthroposphere and used for bioenergy at end of life. J Ind Ecol 17:20–30
Guinée JB et al (2002) Handbook on life cycle assessment. Operational guide to the ISO standards. I: LCA in perspective. IIa: guide. IIb: operational annex. III: scientific background. Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht
Haight M (2004) Technical report: integrated solid waste management model. University of Waterloo, Canada
Hellweg S, Hofstetter TB, Hungerbuhler K (2001) Modeling waste incineration for life-cycle inventory analysis in Switzerland. Environ Model Assess 6:219–235
Hla SS, Roberts D (2015) Characterisation of chemical composition and energy content of green waste and municipal solid waste from greater Brisbane, Australia. Waste Manag 41:12–19
Hong RJ, Wang GF, Guoc RZ, Cheng X, Liu Q, Zhang PJ, Qian GR (2006) Life cycle assessment of BMT-based integrated municipal solid waste management: case study in Pudong, China. Resour Conserv Recy 49:129–146
Hong J, Xiangzhi L, Zhaojie (2010) Life cycle assessment of four municipal solid waste management scenarios in China. Waste Manag 30:2362–2369
Horttanainen M, Teirasvuo N, Kapustina V, Hupponen M, Luoranen M (2013) The composition, heating value and renewable share of the energy content of mixed municipal solid waste in Finland. Waste Manag 33:2680–2686
Huijbregts MAJ, Norris G, Bretz CA, Maurice B, von Bahr B, Weidema B, de Beaufort ASH (2001) Framework for modelling data uncertainty in life cycle inventories. Int J Life Cycle Assess 6:127–132
Jeswani HK, Smith RW, Azapagic A (2013) Energy from waste: carbon footprint of incineration and landfill biogas in the UK. Int J Life Cycle Assess 18:218–229
Jolliet O, Margni M, Charles R, Humbert S, Payet J, Rebitzer G, Rosenbaum R (2003) IMPACT 2002+: a new life cycle impact assessment methodology. Int J Life Cycle Assess 8:324–330
JORF (2002) Arrêté du 20 septembre 2002 relatif aux installations d’incinération et de co-incinération de déchets non dangereux et aux installations incinérant des déchets d’activités de soins à risques infectieux
Kaplan PO, Ranjithan SR, Barlaz MA (2009) Use of life cycle analysis to support solid waste management planning for Delaware. Environ Sci Technol 43:1264–1270
Kirkeby JT, Birgisdottir H, Hansen TL, Christensen TH, Bhander GS, Hauschild M (2006a) Environmental assessment of solid waste systems and technologies: EASEWASTE. Waste Manag Res 24:3–15
Kirkeby JT, Birgisdottir H, Hansen TL, Christensen TH, Bhander GS, Hauschild M (2006b) Evaluation of environmental impacts from municipal solid waste management in the municipality of Aarhus, Denmark (EASEWASTE). Waste Manag Res 24:16–26
Koci V, Trecakova T (2011) Mixed municipal waste management in the Czech Republic from the point of view of the LCA method. Int J Life Cycle Assess 16:113–114
Koehler A, Peyer F, Salzmann C, Saner D (2011) Probabilistic and technology-specific modeling of emissions from municipal solid-waste incineration. Environ Sci Technol 45:3487–3495
Liamsanguan C, Gheewala SH (2008a) The holistic impact of integrated solid waste management on greenhouse gas emission in Phuket. J Clean Prod 17:1865–1871
Liamsanguan C, Gheewhala SH (2008b) LCA: a decision support tool for environmental assessment of MSW management systems. J Environ Manag 87:132–138
Margallo M, Aldaco R, Irabien A, Cariilo V, Fischer M, Bala A, Fullana P (2014) Life cycle assessment modelling of waste-to-energy incineration in Spain and Portugal. Waste Manag Res 32:492–499
McDougall F, White P, Franke M, Hindle P (2001) Integrated solid waste management: a life cycle inventory (2nd edition) Blackwell Publishing ISBN 0-632-05889-7 p 513
Merrild H, Damgaard A, Christensen TH (2008) Life cycle assessment of waste paper management: the importance of technology data and system boundaries in assessing recycling and incineration. Resour Conserv Recy 12:1391–1398
Merrild H, Larsen AW, Christensen TH (2012) Assessing recycling versus incineration of key materials in municipal waste: the importance of efficient energy recovery and transport distances. Waste Manag 32:1009–1018
Miliute J, Staniskis KJ (2010) Application of life cycle assessment in optimisation of municipal waste management systems: the case of Lithuania. Waste Manag Res 28:298–308
Moberg A, Finnveden G, Johansson J, Lind P (2005) Life cycle assessment of energy from solid waste—part 2: landfilling compared to other treatment methods. J Clean Prod 13:231–240
Moletta R (2009) Le traitement des déchets. Paris
Morris J (2005) Comparative LCAs for curbside recycling versus either landfilling or incineration with energy recovery. Int J Life Cycle Assess 10:273–284
Morselli L, Bartoli M, Bertacchini M, Brighetti A, Luzi J, Passarini F, Masoni P (2005) Tools for evaluation of impact associated with MSW incineration: LCA and integrated environmental monitoring system. Waste Manag 25:191–196
Ngahane EL (2015) Gestion technique de l’environnement d’une ville (Benbereke au Bénin): caractérisation et quantification des déchets solides émis; connaissance des ressources en eau et approche technique. Université de Liège
OJEU (2008) Directive 2008/98/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 19 November 2008 on waste and repealing certain Directives vol 2008/98/EC, 19 November 2008 edn. Official Journal of the European Union, Strasbourg
Ozeler D, Yetis U, Demirer GN (2006) Life cycle assessment of municipal solid waste management methods: Ankara case study. Environ Int 32:405–411
Resse A, Mallard P, Morvan B (2007) Etablissement d’une correspondance entre les méthodes de caractérisation des ordures ménagères sur sec et sur humide. ADEME/Cemagref
Riber C, Bhander GS, Christensen TH (2008) Environmental assessment of waste incineration in a life cycle perspective (EASEWASTE). Waste Manag Res 26:96–103
Salhofer S, Wassermann G, Binner E (2007) Strategic environmental assessment as an approach to assess waste management systems. Experiences from Austrian case study. Environ Model Softw 22:610–618
Scipioni A, Mazzi A, Niero M, Boatto T (2009) LCA to choose among alternative design solutions: the case study of a new Italian incineration line. Waste Manag 29:2462–2474
Solano E, Dumas RD, Harrison KW, Ranjithan SR, Barlaz MA, Brill ED (2002a) Life-cycle-based solid waste management. II: illustrative applications. J Environ Eng 28(10). doi:10.1061:/ASCE)0733–9372(2002)128:10(993)
Solano E, Ranjithan S, Barlaz M, Brill E (2002b) Life-cycle-based solid waste management. I: model development. J Environ Eng 128:981–992
Sonnemann GW, Schuhmacher M, Castells F (2003) Uncertainty assessment by Monte Carlo simulation in a life cycle inventory of electricity produced by a waste incinerator. J Clean Prod 11:279–292
Staley BF, Barlaz MA (2009) Composition of municipal solid waste in the United States and implications for carbon sequestration and methane yield. J Environ Eng 135:901–909
Stirling A (2006) Analysis, participation and power: justification and closure in participatory multi-criteria analysis. Land Use Policy 23:95–107
SVDU (2016) Technical characteristics and quantitative production data for the year 2011 of incineration plants in France. http://www.incineration.org/?-Usines-. Accessed 25 May 2016
Tang Y, Liu C, Shih K (2013) Beneficial metal stabilization mechanisms using simulated sludge incineration ash for ceramic products. J Chem Technol Biotechnol 89:536–543
Technical University of Denmark (2012) Easewaste - User manual p 135 http://documents.er.dtu.dk/Projects/Easewaste/Shared%20Files/pdf/120412%20-%20Documanual%20-%20Full.pdf
Toniolo S, Mazzi A, Niero M, Zuliani F, Scipioni A (2013) Comparative LCA to evaluate how much recycling is environmentally favourable for food packaging. Resour Conserv Recy 77:61–68
Tunesi S (2011) LCA of local strategies for energy recovery from waste in England, applied to a large municipal flow. Waste Manag 31:561–571
Turconi R, Butera S, Boldrin A, Grosso M, Rigamonti L, Astrup T (2011) Life cycle assessment of waste incineration in Denmark and Italy using two LCA models. Waste Manag Res 29:78–90
Vagt H, Rubik F, Jacob K, Huppes G, Ekvall T (2009) LCA options for sustainable governance assessed. CALCAS Co-ordination Action for innovation in Life-Cycle Analysis for Sustainability. Berlin
Vergara SE, Damgaard A, Horvath A (2011) Boundaries matter: GHG emission reductions from alternatives waste treatment strategies for California’s municipal solid waste. Resour Conserv Recy 57:87–97
Villeneuve J, Michel P, Fournet D, Lafon C, Ménard Y, Wavrer P, Guyonnet D (2009) Process-based analysis of waste management systems: a case study. Waste Manag 29:2–11
Weidema BP, Wesmaes M, Christiansen K, Koneczny K (2006) Life cycle based cost-benefit assessment of waste management options presentation for ISWA annual congress 2006. Copenhagen 2006(10):1–5
Weitz K, Barlaz M, Ranjithan R, Brill D, Thorneloe S, Ham R (1999) Life cycle management of municipal solid waste. Int J Life Cycle Assess 4:195–201
Wittmaier M, Langer S, Sawilla B (2009) Possibilities and limitations of life cycle assessment (LCA) in the development of waste utilization systems—applied examples for a region in northern Germany. Waste Manag 29:1732–1738
Zhao W, van der Voet E, Zhang Y, Huppes G (2009a) Life cycle assessment of municipal solid waste management with regard to greenhouse gas emission: case study of Tianjin, China. Sci Total Environ 407:1517–1526
Zhao Y, Wang HT, Lu WJ, Damgaard A, Christensen TH (2009b) Life cycle assessment of the municipal solid waste management system in Hangzhou, China (EASEWASTE). Waste Manag Res 27:399–406
Zhao Y, Christensen TH, Lu W, Wu H, Wang (2011a) Environmental impact assessment of solid waste management in Beijing City, China. Waste Manag 31:793–799
Zhao W, Huppes G, van der Voet E (2011b) Eco-efficiency for GHG emission mitigation of municipal solid waste management: a case study of Tianjin, China. Waste Manag 31:1407–1415
Zhao Y, Xing W, Zhang X, Christensen TH (2012) Environmental impact assessment of the incineration of municipal solid waste with auxiliary coal in China. Waste Manag 32:1989–1998
Acknowledgements
The authors thank Irstea for financially supporting the internship of LN and members of AgorACV, a network of LCA practitioners in western France, for the discussions and collaborations.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Responsible editor: Shabbir Gheewala
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Déchaux, C., Nitschelm, L., Giard, L. et al. Development of the regionalised municipal solid waste incineration (RMWI) model and its application to France. Int J Life Cycle Assess 22, 1514–1542 (2017). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11367-017-1268-0
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11367-017-1268-0