Abstract
Environmental pollution seriously affects human health. The concentration of negative air ions (NAIs), which were discovered at the end of the nineteenth century, is one of the factors used to evaluate air quality. Additionally, NAIs have been widely considered markers by scholars due to their unique biological function. The aim of this study was to summarize existing research and propose future research on the generation and temporal and spatial dynamic patterns of NAIs concentrations as well as the relationship between NAIs and human health. We identified 187 studies (published January 2013–January 2023) that met our inclusion criteria. Fourteen English studies evaluated the effects of NAIs on depression, the cardiovascular system, the respiratory system, reproduction and development, cognition, and sports muscle injury. Only two studies reported the associations of NAIs exposure with metabolic omics. NAIs concentrations vary temporally with solar radiation, air temperature, and relative humidity, while the temporal dynamic patterns of NAIs are affected by season, time, meteorological factors, air quality index, geographical location, forest vegetation, and other factors. Researchers have shown that exposure to NAIs may benefit our health by changing amino acid metabolism, which mainly manifests as increased anti-inflammation and reduced inflammation and antioxidation. Furthermore, exposure to NAIs promotes energy production, affects the expression of c-fos, and regulates 5-HT levels. There has been considerable interest in the potential effects of NAIs on human health and well-being, but the conclusions have been inconsistent and the mechanisms remain unclear. The use of omics to elucidate the biological mechanism of NAIs is relatively new and has some advantages.
Graphical Abstract
Similar content being viewed by others
Introduction
With the accelerating process of industrialization and urbanization, the problem of environmental pollution has gradually become more prominent, thereby seriously threatening the quality of human life and physical and mental health. Therefore, it is important to pay more attention to the living environment. Furthermore, since people spend more than 80% of their time indoors, previous studies have indicated that indoor air pollution has an equal or more significant effect on human health compared with ambient air pollution (Jia X et al. 2018).
Recently, urban air quality has become a hot research topic around the world, and the concentration of negative air ions (NAIs) is regarded as an essential indicator of urban air quality and the effects of forests on human health (Liu S et al. 2022). NAIs are negatively charged gas ions that are formed and generated by sunlight, radiant or cosmic rays, plant-based sources of energy, or other natural and artificial energy sources, also known as colorless, tasteless, and small particle size (Nazaroff WW et al. 2020). NAIs can effectively reduce the concentration of particulate matter, especially PM2.5 and PM10 (Jiang SY et al. 2021), and prevent volatile organic compounds (VOCs) from binding to PM2.5 (Zhang C et al. 2020), thereby improving air quality. Additionally, NAIs can be found at high concentrations in the atmosphere of forests, waterfalls, beaches, and so on, up to 0.5 × 103–10 × 103 ions/cm3. The NAIs distribution has noticeable diurnal, monthly, and interannual changes related to meteorological factors such as solar radiation, air temperature, and relative humidity, among others.
Many epidemiological studies and clinical investigations have reported that NAIs have many potential biological effects such as lowering blood pressure, improving body immunity, and improving erythrocyte deformability (Iwama H et al. 2002). In addition, they have also been found to enhance metabolism (Iwama H 2004), affect emotions, and inhibit the viability of airborne gram-positive and gram-negative bacteria (Comini S et al. 2021; Bowers B et al. 2018). NAIs can directly stimulate the nerve reflex and the humoral system. They play a physiological regulative role (Lv J et al. 2011; Wu CC et al. 2006) or affect the composition and distribution of ions in blood by releasing electric charge to improve the content of blood oxygen. Furthermore, they enhance the absorption and utilization of blood oxygen to promote the redox reaction of the body (Sirota TV et al. 2008). The mechanisms leading to NAIs-related biological effects are multifactorial and not yet fully understood. In recent years, high-throughput omics approaches have been utilized as powerful techniques to explore the effect of exposure to environmental factors on human physiology, thereby increasing knowledge regarding the biological response to exposure and the underlying molecular mechanism. However, their implications for air quality and health hazards have not been reviewed comprehensively.
The objective of this review was to evaluate the research literature published from 2013 to 2023 to assess the potential biological effects of NAIs on human health. We discussed the current state of the literature on the generation and dynamic patterns of atmospheric negative ions as well as the relationship between NAIs and human health. We focused on publications that applied omics studies to the biological effects of NAIs, as these are relatively new methods and have implications for improving air quality and reducing health hazards.
Literature search and study identification
This systematic review of studies on NAIs was initiated by searching the PubMed, Embase, and China National Knowledge Infrastructure databases to identify relevant experimental studies published between January 1, 2013 and January 1, 2023. Fig. 1 shows the step-by-step identification and selection process. Three keywords, i.e., “negative,” “air,” and “ion”, were used to search all collected articles in the databases. The database searches yielded a total of 1060 articles, and 675 could be retrieved in full. We then screened these articles by reviewing the titles and abstracts to exclude unrelated articles; a total of 187 references remained.
Identical search strings were used for the PubMed and Embase databases to obtain articles related to exposure (air ions, atmospheric ions, ionization, ionized air, and negative ions) and the outcomes of interest (depression, cardiovascular system, respiratory system, reproduction and development, cognition, and sports muscle injury). In addition, we manually reviewed the reference lists of all retrieved articles to identify potentially eligible publications. Ultimately, 14 English-language studies met our inclusion criteria and were included in the analysis (Table 1).
Overview of NAIs
NAIs and their generation
Neutral gas molecules in the atmosphere combine with free electrons to form negatively charged atmospheric negative ions, which is the general name of negatively charged particles in the atmosphere. For example, atmospheric negative oxygen ions refer to the negatively charged oxygen ions formed by the combination of oxygen molecules and free electrons in the atmosphere. They are colorless and tasteless and are also known as small particle-size negative ions, accounting for approximately 10–20% of the content of atmospheric negative ions (Gui HL et al. 2018).
There are three primary sources of atmospheric negative ions. ① Under the action of cosmic rays, ultraviolet rays, trace element radiation, high-voltage electric fields, lightning, and water molecule collisions, electrons ionize and escape into the air, becoming free electrons with a negative charge, which are then captured by air molecules, aerosols, and fine particles, and negatively charged. ② In the environment of waterfalls, waves, and rainstorms, water mist with a negative charge is formed, which is taken away by air flow. ③ Plant “tip discharge” and photosynthesis release free electrons and combine with oxygen or water molecules to form atmospheric negative ions (LI G F et al. 2019a, 2019b). NAIs components produced by various sources of NAIs, and the evolution of oxygen-based NAIs are shown in Fig. 2 (Jiang SY et al. 2018).
Temporal and spatial dynamic patterns of NAIs concentration
There are diurnal and seasonal changes in NAIs concentration. Most Chinese studies show that the concentration of NAIs in the air is higher in the morning and night, lower in the afternoon, higher in summer and autumn, and relatively lower in winter (Li A et al. 2022; Jiang ZH et al. 2021; Yao YP et al. 2019; Zhu SHX et al. 2019; LI Q Y et al. 2019a, 2019b; Zhang Yong et al. 2018). Furthermore, the concentration of NAIs is positively correlated with altitude (Zhang Yong et al. 2018; Jin Q et al. 2015). Li A et al. (Li A et al. 2022) found that the daily dynamics of NAIs concentration showed a bimodal curve in the Chinese Academy of Forestry (Fuyang District, Hangzhou, China, 30°03′35″N, 119°57′7″E). The peak NAIs concentration usually occurred in the early morning (5:00–7:00) and afternoon (15:00–17:00), and the lowest concentration usually occurred around noon (11:00–13:00). On a monthly scale, NAIs concentration was relatively high in February and August and relatively low in May and December. On the seasonal scale, NAIs concentration was significantly higher in summer than in other seasons. Autumn had the second highest NAIs concentration. Another study analyzed the continuous monitoring data of NAIs at three monitoring stations in Shennongjia, Yichang, and Jingzhou in Hubei Province. The results concluded that the concentration of NAIs was higher in summer and lower in winter, and that the concentration of NAIs was significantly higher at night than during the daytime. The highest value occurs between 4:00 and 7:00 in the morning (Gui HL et al. 2018). Yao YP (Yao YP et al. 2019) found that NAIs concentration has significant daily and monthly variation characteristics, with low concentration in the afternoon (13:00–16:00) and high concentration at night and in the morning (22:00–7:00). The concentration of NAIs was high from April to September and low in winter according to observations at 53 monitoring stations in Zhejiang Province in 2016.
It has been demonstrated that the concentration of NAIs varies in different observation areas. The concentration of NAIs in forest air is mostly between 900 and 5000/cm3 (Zhu SHX et al. 2019; LI Q Y et al. 2019a, 2019b; Zhang Y et al. 2018). The concentration in waterfalls and streams can be up to 10,000/cm3 (Wang W et al. 2013). Urban green space is 150–700/cm3 and varies with different green space compositions. The concentration of NAIs in urban traffic areas is generally between 200 and 300/cm3 (Yuan XY et al. 2014). Accordingly, the overall trend is arbor and shrub > arbor > shrub (Fei L et al. 2020).
Effect of environmental factors on NAIs concentration
The concentration of NAIs correlates with meteorological factors such as air temperature (Ta), relative humidity (RH), wind and radiation, forest vegetation, and environmental conditions, but the research conclusions are different due to the influence of study area, season, and forest type. Li A et al. (Li A et al. 2022) showed that the air quality index (AQI) was a key factor affecting NAIs concentration compared to Ta and RH, especially PM and ozone; they also found that NAIs concentration had a negative correlation with these indicators and was significantly higher under favorable air quality conditions than under polluted air conditions. NAIs concentration and Ta showed marked piecewise characteristics, with NAIs increasing linearly with rising Ta only if the Ta was separated into three ranges of − 5 to 10 °C, 10 – 30 °C, and 30–40 °C. NAIs concentration was correlated with RH spanning all seasons, and water was an important factor affecting the distribution of NAIs concentration in different time series, as Li C et al. reported (Li C et al. 2021). Additionally, Peng LY et al. found that the NAIs concentration in different garden types has a differing correlation with Ta, RH, and precipitation, but that both are positively correlated with rainfall. The NAIs concentration of primitive broad-leaved forests has a negative correlation with Ta and a positive correlation with RH, while it is positively correlated with Ta and negatively correlated with noontime and RH in plantations (Peng LY et al. 2020). Other studies have reported the relationship among NAIs concentration, air oxygen content, wind speed, altitude, and precipitation (Zhu SHX et al. 2019; Zhang Y et al. 2018; Chen BH et al. 2019).
Most conclusions on the influencing factors of NAIs concentration mainly come from research on the influencing factors of NAIs contents in forest areas, while research on other types of NAIs concentration is relatively scarce. Therefore, Feng YM analyzed the influencing factors of NAIs concentration in the air of different habitats of an urban ecosystem, and the findings showed that the NAIs concentration in wetland parks and campuses was positively correlated with Ta, RH, and wind speed, and that the NAIs concentration in a square, an arboretum, and a residential area was positively correlated with Ta and RH (Feng YM et al. 2017).
Evidence of the association between NAIs and their biological functions in human health
NAIs were first discovered in the natural environment at the end of the nineteenth century (Krueger AP 1972; Krueger AP et al. 1976). By the beginning of the twentieth century, NAIs were found to have a variety of potential biological functions including regulating respiratory system function, sedation, hypnosis, hypotension, regulating mood, neurological function, metabolism, and endocrine function, among others, in human health (Charry JM 1984; Day DB et al. 2018). Negative ion generators (NIAPs) have been widely utilized in various living environments and workplaces, and with the continuous development of science and technology, they have been gradually optimized, including the elimination of ozone as a byproduct (Jiang SY et al. 2021). Historically, various physiological or health effects related to exposure to charged air ions have been suggested, but the evidence of these effects is still ambiguous, and there seems to be a lack of in-depth mechanistic research.
NAIs exposure and cardiovascular events
Previous studies have suggested that NAIs can effectively inhibit the sympathetic nerve and activate the parasympathetic nerve. Additionally, the paraventricular nucleus of the hypothalamus (PVN), locus coeruleus (LC), and nucleus ambiguous (NA) plays a key role in the regulation of sympathetic nervous system activity (Lucini D et al. 2020; Farrell MC et al. 2020). Therefore, it is speculated that NAIs can affect the autonomic regulatory activity of PVN, LC, and Na neurons, thus affecting autonomic nerve function to adjust heart rate and blood pressure. However, the neural mechanism of NAI-mediated autonomic regulation is unclear. Bailey WH et al. reviewed the literature on animal experimentation and the potential biological effects of NAIs published from 1935 to 2015 (Bailey WH et al. 2018). Suzuki S et al. (Suzuki S et al. 2008) preliminarily explored the mechanism of NAIs regulating the activity of the autonomic nervous system. The laboratory selected adult male Wistar rats and randomly divided them into two groups. One group was exposed to 5000–8000/cm3 NAIs air, and the other group was exposed to approximately 400–500/cm3 normal air to control temperature and humidity. Blood pressure (BP), heart rate (HR), and heart rate variability (HRV) were monitored. The expression of c-fos in the PVN, LC, Na, and nucleus tractus solitarius (NTS) was detected by immunohistochemistry. The results showed that NAIs significantly reduced blood pressure and heart rate and increased the high-frequency power of the HRV spectrum. The expression of c-fos was significantly downregulated in the PVN and LC regions and upregulated in the NA and NTS regions. After vagotomy, the above physiological changes and neuronal activity were not observed. NAIs can regulate autonomic regulation by inhibiting the activity of PVN and LC neurons and activating NA neurons, and the vagal nerve may mediate these effects.
Additionally, some animal studies have not found that positive or negative air ion exposure affects heart rate, respiratory rate, or blood pressure. In 2021, Kim M et al. (Kim M et al. 2021) published an in vitro study to explore the antioxidant and anti-inflammatory pathways of NAIs. After NAIs-exposed or unexposed HaCaT cells were treated with particulate matter (PM), the levels of reactive oxygen species (ROS) and the inflammatory factor IL-1 were detected. The expression levels of nuclear transcription factor activator protein 1 (AP1) and p38 protein were also detected at the same time. The results showed that NAIs could exert anti-inflammatory and antioxidant effects by inhibiting the ROS/p38 MAPK (mitogen-activated protein kinase)/AP1 pathway in HaCaT cells exposed to PM.
Several population investigations have investigated the health effects of NAIs exposure. Dong W et al. published a randomized, double-blind crossover test in 2019 (Dong W et al. 2019). In the study, 44 students in Beijing were selected to use commercial anion air purifiers for 5 weeks to monitor the indoor NAIs, PM, black carbon (BC), and ozone concentrations and observe the changes in HRV of volunteers. The results demonstrated that HRV exhibited a negative change, and that the alteration of HRV was more significant at a high concentration of NAIs. However, some studies (Liu S et al. 2020; Gui HL et al. 2018) have not found that NAIs exposure can improve cardiopulmonary function in healthy people. It is considered to be associated with the adverse effects of byproduct ozone, or the beneficial effect is only related to the decrease in PM2.5 concentration.
Evidence on the function of NAIs in the respiratory system
High-concentration NAIs inhalation may improve lung function, regulate metabolism, and treat asthma symptoms. Alexander DD et al. (2013) systematically reviewed 23 studies related to negative ions and respiratory system function published from 1933 to 1993. The research population included in the literature involved infants, adolescents, and adults. The sample size varied from 8 to 123 subjects; most studies focused on 10–30 persons. There are few large-sample studies. A double-blind or single-blind crossover test was mainly used, and the exposure range of negative ions was 1600 to 1,500,000/cm3. Among them, two studies reported that NAIs exposure can improve the symptoms of patients with bronchial asthma. Overall, the review concluded that negative ion exposure did not significantly improve respiratory function or asthma symptoms. However, these studies are relatively old, limited by small sample sizes and different experimental methods, and had inconsistent conclusions. Dong W et al. (2019) also observed volunteers’ respiratory function changes and analyzed the correlation with environmental factors. The results showed that after using the air purifier, the PM0.5, PM2.5, PM10, and BC could be reduced by 48, 44, 34, and 50%, respectively. The concentration of NAIs increased from 12/cm3 to 12,997/cm3. The forced expiratory volume in 1 s (FEV1) of volunteers increased by 4.4%, and fractional nitric oxide (FeNO) decreased by 14.7%. Therefore, it could be considered that using a negative ion purifier can significantly improve the function of the respiratory system. Liu S et al. (2020) found that an increase in NAIs concentrations and a decrease in PM levels can improve respiratory system function by accelerating energy metabolism and improving anti-inflammatory and antioxidant capacity.
Other population studies have explored the effect of a high concentration of NAIs exposure on respiratory function during exercise or evaluated the effect of exercise and NAIs therapy on patients with respiratory diseases, but the research conclusions are also inconsistent (Su YF et al. 2018; Wen LY et al. 2017; A. Nimmerichter A et al. 2014; Mao QG et al. 2016; Shi YB et al. 2016). Su YF et al. (2018) evaluated the therapeutic effect of load-breathing training under NAIs synergistic treatment on 50 smokers with moderate and mild chronic obstructive pulmonary disease. The results showed that the volunteers exposed to high levels of NAIs exhibited a more significant improvement in lung function indices. Wen LY found that the level of NAIs is positively correlated with the training effect on respiratory function. Training in a high concentration of NAIs is conducive to improving respiratory muscle strength and pulmonary ventilation function (Wen LY et al. 2017). However, Nimmerichter A et al. did not find that a high concentration of NAIs (220 ± 30 × 103/cm3) exposure had any effect on oxygen metabolism during exercise (Nimmerichter A et al. 2014).
Several researchers have discussed the effects of NAIs exposure on the respiratory system in experimental animals. Bailey WH et al. (2018) systematically reviewed the effects of air ions on the ciliary flow in the trachea of anaesthetized rabbits, rats, guinea pigs, and mice and their potential relationship with the level of neurotransmitter haemolysin. Negative ions can reduce ciliary activity and mucus flow in the trachea. However, there is a lack of sufficient data on the experimental design and results, including the lack of statistical analysis, the failure to control temperature, humidity, possible byproducts, and other factors, and the inability to quantitatively evaluate these effects. Other laboratories have reported that their studies have not replicated the above results. Sirota TV et al. reported that daily exposure of rats to NAIs with a concentration of 100,000–600,000 ions/cm3 produced by a Lustre ionizer could lead to tracheal tissue damage and biochemical changes, suggesting that high concentrations of NAIs may cause oxidative stress. Additionally, this phenomenon has not been found in NAIs generators of other brands. The laboratory subsequently reported that rats exposed to the same level of NAIs did not produce tissue damage but did change the indicators of reactive oxygen species. This response was also consistent with the lower degree of ozone exposure, which was considered to be the effect caused by the byproduct ozone (Sirota TV et al. 2008).
Impact of NAIs on regulating emotion
It has been proposed that high-concentration NAIs exposure may reduce the severity of depression, psychological stress, and anxiety to improve well-being (Flory R et al. 2010). However, this conclusion is uncertain, as Perez V et al. found no correlations between air ions and emotion-related mental health (Perez V et al. 2013). The inconsistent findings may be due to confounding effects, such as air temperature, air humidity, air flow, electromagnetic field, and/or other unmeasured factors. Meta-analysis was conducted on five studies on negative ions and depression. The results showed that high-concentration NAIs exposure was significantly correlated with lower depression scores. The MD value in the high-level NAIs exposure group was 14.28 (95% CI: 12.93–15.62), and that in the low-level NAIs exposure group was 7.23 (95% CI: 2.62–11.83). Patients with seasonal or chronic depression can respond to higher levels of NAIs, but the effect of lower levels of NAIs is only observed in patients with seasonal depression.
Flory R et al. published a 5-year study to evaluate the efficacy of two active antidepressant therapies, white light and high-density NAIs, and two placebo therapies, dark red light and low-density NAIs, in seasonal affective disorder (SAD) (Flory R et al. 2010). Seventy-three female patients were included and exposed to one of the treatment methods in a controlled environment for 5 consecutive years in January of each year. A total of 12 consecutive cycles of treatment were carried out. Volunteers completed the seasonal pattern assessment questionnaire (SPAQ) before treatment and made a retrospective self-evaluation of the seasonal change patterns and degrees of sleep, social activities, mood, weight, appetite, and energy levels. After treatment, the treatment expectation questionnaire (TEQ), Structured Interview Guide for the Hamilton Depression Rating Scale-Seasonal Affective Disorder Version-Self Rating (SIGH-SAD-SR), and Beck Depression Inventory (BDI) were completed. The results revealed no significant difference in TEQ scores among the four groups. However, the SIGH-SAD-SR and BDI scores were positively correlated with NAIs treatment. Overall, the effect of white light therapy was higher than that of high-density anion therapy, both of which were higher than that of placebo therapy, but there was no significant difference in the effect of NAIs.
Bowers B et al. evaluated the continuous exposure of 40 SAD subjects to high-density or zero-density (placebo condition) NAIs for 18 days, 30 min, or 60 min a day (Bowers B et al. 2018). The results showed that high-density NAIs exposure was better than placebo in alleviating depression and atypical SAD symptoms. In the high-density anion group, 30 and 60 min of daily exposure could relieve depressive symptoms. In the high-density NAIs group, subjects with morning sleep were better treated than those with night sleep.
Biological mechanism of NAIs action based on omics analysis
In recent years, high-throughput omics approaches have been powerful techniques to study large-scale dynamic molecular changes. Omics-based technologies allow for global and sensitive identification of molecular changes relevant for monitoring disease development (Mostafavi N et al. 2017). However, inconsistencies in research on the biological effects of NAIs warrant further mechanistic investigations in humans. Current research has revealed that the potential effects of NAIs on humans are mainly concentrated in the physiological and psychological fields, including the regulatory mechanism of the neurotransmitter 5-hydroxytryptamine (5-HT) and anti-inflammatory and antioxidant effects. However, the biological events induced by NAIs appear to be complex, and there is still an urgent need to study the molecular mechanisms of NAIs-induced biological effects on cytotoxicity in depth and breadth.
Omics is a powerful platform for screening internal exposure- and effect-related biological functions. Some epidemiological studies have adopted omics to investigate the relationship between environmental pollution and its effect on fundamental processes such as gene and microRNA expression, protein synthesis, enteric microorganisms, and metabolism (Chu JH et al. 2016; Fitch MN et al. 2020; Jardim MJ 2011; Wang W et al. 2018). Song X et al. (2022) integrated metabolomics, proteomics, and toxicology and suggested that PM2.5 exposure triggered the inhibition of the integrin signaling pathway and oxidative stress as intracellular ROS increased. Heavy metals and macrocyclic PAHs are important toxic components in PM2.5, triggering an increase in intracellular ROS and inducing the integrin signalling pathway, p53 signalling pathway, glycolysis, and fatty acid metabolism disorders. Based on their results, in the Dalian area, PM2.5 could interfere with glycolysis and the TCA cycle within carbohydrate metabolism throughout the year while only dramatically disturbing lipid metabolism in the winter. Espín-Pérez A et al. (2018) investigated the impact of short-term exposure (2 h) to air pollutants on the blood transcriptome and microRNA expression levels. PM10, PM2.5, CO, and CO2 exposures appear to be the most significant in terms of the number of hits (transcripts and microRNA) responding to exposure levels. The genes identified involve cancer-related pathways such as TP53, TGF-beta receptor signalling, p75, WNT-beta-catenin, and nonsense-mediated decay. MVN models revealed that hsa-miR-197-3p, hsa-miR-29a-3p, hsa-miR-15a-5p, hsa-miR-16-5p, and hsa-miR-92a-3p were significantly expressed in association with exposure.
Many omics studies have investigated the mechanisms by which environmental pollutants interact with biology, but there are very few similar studies on NAIs. We retrieved only two omics studies of NAIs published by Liu S et al. in 2020 and 2022 (Liu S et al. 2020; Liu S et al. 2022). In 2020, they performed an untargeted metabolomics analysis of urine collected from an ionization air purifier intervention study in children to explore the molecular linkages between indoor NAIs, decreased PM, and the cardiorespiratory effect after purification via the meet-in-metabolite approach (MIMA) (Liu S et al. 2020). The results showed that twenty-eight metabolites were correlated with NAIs via linear mixed effect models. Scoring plots generated from partial least-squares discriminant analysis (PLS-DA) models present good separations of the metabolic profiles that characterized real and sham air purification. Thirteen of the twenty-eight metabolites were negatively associated with NAIs, while others were positively associated with them. In addition, forty-eight cardiorespiratory function-related compounds were further screened by two-way orthogonal PLS (O2PLS) models. Concerning NAIs-related metabolites, twenty-one are integrated with eleven respiratory function-related metabolites in the same pathways, which involve amino acid, lipid, glucose, pyrimidine, and purine metabolism, and benefit processes of energy production antioxidation and anti-inflammation. In addition, seventeen NAIs-related and eighteen HRV-related metabolites are integrated with uridine triphosphate (UTP) synthesis, the tricarboxylic acid (TCA) cycle, and amino acid and lipid metabolism. Overall, the metabolic network demonstrates the modes of energy production, antioxidation, anti-inflammation, and protecting nuclear integrity. Increased NAIs are related to ameliorated lung function with metabolic pathways similar to PM, mainly promoting energy production, anti-inflammation, and antioxidation reactions. Decreased PM ameliorated HRV with six main pathways, increasing energy production and anti-inflammation capacity, while increased NAIs deteriorated HRV with five main pathways, thereby lowering energy generation and antioxidation capacity (Fig. 3). Two years later, they published another repeated-measures panel study focusing on the associations of forest NAIs exposure with cardiac autonomic nervous function and the related metabolic linkages, and the results showed that forest NAIs were related to ameliorative changes in HRV indices, mainly through amino acid metabolism, anti-inflammation, and reduced inflammation, thereby promoting cardiac autonomic nervous function (Liu S et al. 2022).
Mechanism implications and gaps in current knowledge
NAIs are known as “air vitamins.” The concentration of NAIs in the atmosphere is affected by the season, time, meteorological factors, air quality index, geographical location, forest vegetation, and other factors, while these factors also interact with each other. How their interaction affects the concentration of NAIs in the air and the mechanism of interaction need further analysis and summary.
NAIs have benefits on human health, such as the respiratory system, cardiovascular system, emotion, learning and memory, cognition, brain development, reproduction, growth and development, and anticancer effects. The diversity in the direction of gene and microRNA expression, protein synthesis, and metabolism toward disease indicates complex biological interactions between environmental exposure and omics signals. Therefore, integrated multiomics to identify biomarkers of NAIs health function is an effective research method. Some events reflect toxic risks, while others may indicate adaptation, damage repair, or both. The interpretation of changes in various molecular events in terms of disease risk remains a challenge, since the identified intermediate or ultimate biomarkers may be derived from different tissues and because the signals may relate to processes that have not previously been linked to diseases or observed in earlier stages during disease development. Furthermore, the same markers may show different biological functions in different diseases.
A systematic review of the above limited studies of NAIs exposure finds that most of the research in this arena is relatively old, and little new research exists on this topic in recent years. Furthermore, many studies suffer from various reporting and methodological deficiencies, posing the risk of study bias. These limitations include the sample size being too small, the experimental methods being different, a lack of sufficient data on the experimental design and results, and the temperature, humidity, and possible byproducts (i.e., the presence of an electric field, the production of ozone and other gaseous byproducts, noise, and light) being not appropriately controlled.
Conclusions
In summary, our narrative review described the generation and temporal and spatial dynamic patterns of NAIs concentration as well as the relationship between NAIs concentration and health effects. Much of the research in this arena is relatively old, and very little new research on this topic has been pursued in recent years. Our conclusion is consistent with those of recent comprehensive reviews and meta-analyses of NAIs and their effects on health. Exposure to NAIs may benefit our health by changing amino acid metabolism, which mainly reflects increased anti-inflammation and reduced inflammation and antioxidation, promotes energy production, affects the expression of c-fos, or regulates 5-HT levels. Multiomics studies may provide a new perspective for research on the biological effects of NAIs.
References
Alexander DD, Bailey WH, Perez V, Mitchell ME, Su S (2013) Air ions and respiratory function outcomes: a comprehensive review. J Negat Results Biomed 12:14
Bailey WH, Williams AL, Leonhard MJ (2018) Exposure of laboratory animals to small air ions: a systematic review of biological and behavioral studies. Biomed Eng Online 17(1):72
Bowers B, Flory R, Ametepe J, Staley L, Patrick A, Carrington H (2018) Controlled trial evaluation of exposure duration to negative air ions for the treatment of seasonal affective disorder. Psychiatry Res 259:7–14
Charry JM (1984) Biological effects of small air ions: a review of findings and methods. Environ Res 34(2):351–389
Chen BH, Ying JH, Jin QF, Shou LY, Deng G (2019) Distribution characteristics of negative oxygen ions in the air of Baiyun Mountain National Forest Par. Zhejiang Agric Sci 60(02):337–339
Cheng YH, Li HK, Yao CA, Huang JY, Sung YT, Chung SD, Chien CT (2022) Negative air ions through the action of antioxidation, anti-inflammation, anti-apoptosis and angiogenesis ameliorate lipopolysaccharide induced acute lung injury and promote diabetic wound healing in rat. PloS One 17(10):e0275748
Chu JH, Hart JE, Chhabra D, Garshick E, Raby BA, Laden F (2016) Gene expression network analyses in response to air pollution exposures in the trucking industry. Environ Health 15(1):101
Chu CH, Chen SR, Wu CH, Cheng YC, Cho YM, Chang YK (2019) The effects of negative air ions on cognitive function: an event-related potential (ERP) study. Int J Biometeorol 63(10):1309–1317
Comini S, Mandras N, Iannantuoni MR, Menotti F, Musumeci AG, Piersigilli G, Allizond V, Banche G, Cuffini AM (2021) Positive and negative ions potently inhibit the viability of airborne gram-positive and gram-negative bacteria. Microbiol Spectr 9(3):e0065121
Dauphinais DR, Rosenthal JZ, Terman M, DiFebo HM, Tuggle C, Rosenthal NE (2012) Controlled trial of safety and efficacy of bright light therapy vs. negative air ions in patients with bipolar depression. Psychiatry Res 196(1):57–61
Day DB, Xiang J, Mo J, Clyde MA, Weschler CJ, Li F, Gong J, Chung M, Zhang Y, Zhang J (2018) Combined use of an electrostatic precipitator and a high-efficiency particulate air filter in building ventilation systems: effects on cardiorespiratory health indicators in healthy adults. Indoor Air 28(3):360–372
Dong W, Liu S, Chu M, Zhao B, Yang D, Chen C, Miller MR, Loh M, Xu J, Chi R, Yang X, Guo X, Deng F (2019) Different cardiorespiratory effects of indoor air pollution intervention with ionization air purifier: findings from a randomized, double-blind crossover study among school children in Beijing. Environ Pollut 254(Pt B):113054
Espín-Pérez A, Krauskopf J, Chadeau-Hyam M, van Veldhoven K, Chung F, Cullinan P, Piepers J, van Herwijnen M, Kubesch N, Carrasco-Turigas G, Nieuwenhuijsen M, Vineis P, Kleinjans JCS, de Kok TMCM (2018) Short-term transcriptome and microRNAs responses to exposure to different air pollutants in two population studies. Environ Pollut (Pt A):182–190
Farrell MC, Giza RJ, Shibao CA (2020) Race and sex differences in cardiovascular autonomic regulation. Clin Auton Res 30(5):371–379
Fei L, Yang P, Bin D, Xuerao L, Tingting L, Sha X (2020) Cognition of negative oxygen ions in air of residents near Fengxiang Wetland Park in Haikou city. Chin J Convalescent Med 29(08):794–797
Feng YM (2017) Spatial and temporal characteristics of air negative oxygen ion concentration in different habitats in Zhejiang Agricultural Science city ecosystem. Inner Mongolia Agricultural University
Fitch MN, Phillippi D, Zhang Y, Lucero J, Pandey RS, Liu J, Brower J, Allen MS, Campen MJ, McDonald JD, Lund AK (2020) Effects of inhaled air pollution on markers of integrity, inflammation, and microbiota profiles of the intestines in apolipoprotein E knockout mice. Environ Res 181:108913
Flory R, Ametepe J, Bowers B (2010) A randomized, placebo-controlled trial of bright light and high-density negative air ions for treatment of seasonal affective disorder. Psychiatry Res 177(1-2):101–108
Goldstein N (2002) Reactive oxygen species as essential components of ambient air. Biochemistry 67:161–170
Gui HL, Ren GL, Zhang XH (2018) Atmospheric negative oxygen ions and their variation in different environments. Heilongjiang Meteorol 35(01):18–19
Ho CS, Lee MC, Chang CY, Chen WC, Huang WC (2020) Beneficial effects of a negative ion patch on eccentric exercise-induced muscle damage, inflammation, and exercise performance in badminton athletes. Chin J Physiol 63(1):35–42
Hu YQ, Niu TT, Xu JM, Peng L, Sun QH, Huang Y, Zhou J, Ding YQ (2022) Negative air ion exposure ameliorates depression-like behaviors induced by chronic mild stress in mice. Environ Sci Pollut Res Int 29(41):62626–62636
Iwama H (2004) Negative air ions created by water shearing improve erythrocyte deformability and aerobic metabolism. Indoor Air 14(4):293–297
Iwama H, Ohmizo H, Furuta S, Ohmori S, Watanabe K, Kaneko T, Tsutsumi K (2002) Inspired superoxide anions attenuate blood lactate concentrations in postoperative patients. Crit Care Med 30(6):1246–1249
Jardim MJ (2011) microRNAs: implications for air pollution research. Mutat Res 717(1-2):38–45
Jia X, Yang X, Hu D, Dong W, Yang F, Liu Q, Li H, Pan L, Shan J, Niu W, Wu S, Deng F, Guo X (2018) Short-term effects of particulate matter in metro cabin on heart rate variability in young healthy adults: impacts of particle size and source. Environ Res 167:292–298
Jiang Z, Zeng CH (2021) Analysis of ecological environment characteristics of establishing China’s natural oxygen bar in Yunyang city. J Southwest China Normal Univ (Natural Science Edition) 46(02):86–91
Jiang SY, Ma A, Ramachandran S (2018) Negative air ions and their effects on human health and air quality improvement. Int J Mol Sci 19(10):2966
Jiang SY, Ma A, Ramachandran S (2021) Plant-based release system of negative air ions and its application on particulate matter removal. Indoor Air 31(2):574–586
Jin Q, Yang BZH YJ, Wang HJ (2015) Distribution characteristics of atmospheric negative oxygen ion concentration in spring in Hubei province and its relationship with environmental factors. Meteorological Sci Technol 43(04):728–733
Kim M, Jeong GJ, Hong JY, Park KY, Lee MK, Seo SJ (2021) negative air ions alleviate particulate matter-induced inflammation and oxidative stress in the human keratinocyte cell line HaCaT. Ann Dermatol 33(2):116–121
Kolarz P, Gaisberger M, Madl P, Hofmann W, Ritter M, Hartl A (2012) Characterization of ions at alpine waterfalls. Atmos Chem Phys 12:3687–3697
Krueger AP (1972) Are air ions biologically significant? A review of a controversial subject. Int J Biometeorol 16(4):313–322
Krueger AP, Reed EJ (1976) Biological impact of small air ions. Science. 193(4259):1209–1213
Li GF, Li QY, Yan LH, Liao JY (2019a) Study on the concentration characteristics of air negative oxygen ions in urban forest. Hunan Forest Sci Technol 46(02):52–56
Li QY, Li GF, Liao JY, Liu Y, Wu LS, Song Y (2019b) Study on the characteristics of negative air ion concentrations and its influential factors in Hunan Forest Botanical Garden. Hunan Forest Sci Technol 46(01):18–23
Li C, Xie Z, Chen B, Kuang K, Xu D, Liu J, He Z (2021) Different time scale distribution of negative air ions concentrations in Mount Wuyi National Park. Int J Environ Res Public Health 18(9):5037
Li A, Li Q, Zhou B, Ge X, Cao Y (2022) Temporal dynamics of negative air ion concentration and its relationship with environmental factors: results from long-term on-site monitoring. Sci Total Environ 832:155057
Lin HF, Lin JM (2017) Generation and determination of negative air ions. J Anal Test 1:6
Liu S, Huang Q, Wu Y, Song Y, Dong W, Chu M, Yang D, Zhang X, Zhang J, Chen C, Zhao B, Shen H, Guo X, Deng F (2020) Metabolic linkages between indoor negative air ions, particulate matter and cardiorespiratory function: a randomized, double-blind crossover study among children. Environ Int 138:105663
Liu W, Huang J, Lin Y, Cai C, Zhao Y, Teng Y, Mo J, Xue L, Liu L, Xu W, Guo X, Zhang Y, Zhang JJ (2021) Negative ions offset cardiorespiratory benefits of PM(2.5) reduction from residential use of negative ion air purifiers. Indoor Air 31(1):220–228
Liu S, Li C, Chu M, Zhang W, Wang W, Wang Y, Guo X, Deng F (2022) Associations of forest negative air ions exposure with cardiac autonomic nervous function and the related metabolic linkages: a repeated-measure panel study. Sci Total Environ 850:158019
Lucini D, Pagani M (2020) Heart rate variability, autonomic regulation and myocardial ischemia. Int J Cardiol 312:22–23
Lv J, Wang W, Krafft T, Li Y, Zhang F, Yuan F (2011) Effects of several environmental factors on longevity and health of the human population of Zhongxiang, Hubei, China. Biol Trace Elem Res 143(2):702–716
Ma M, Song QH, Xu RM, Zhang QH, Shen GQ, Guo YH, Wang Y (2014) Treatment effect of the method of tai chi exercise in combination with inhalation of air negative oxygen ions on hyperlipidemia. Int J Clin Exp Med 7(8):2309–2313
Mao QG (2016) Chinese Journal of Gerontology Effect of low load aerobic exercise combined with air negative oxygen ion inhalation on cotton pneumoconiosis. Chin J Phys Med Rehabil 38(09):702–704
Mostafavi N, Vlaanderen J, Portengen L, Chadeau-Hyam M, Modig L, Palli D, Bergdahl IA, Brunekreef B, Vineis P, Hebels DG, Kleinjans JC, Krogh V, Hoek G, Georgiadis P, Kyrtopoulos S, Vermeulen R (2017) Associations between genome-wide gene expression and ambient nitrogen oxides. Epidemiology. 28(3):320–328
Nazaroff WW, Weschler CJ (2020) Indoor acids and bases. Indoor Air 30(4):559–644
Nimmerichter A, Holdhaus J, Mehnen L, Vidotto C, Loidl M, Barker AR (2014) Effects of negative air ions on oxygen uptake kinetics, recovery and performance in exercise: a randomized, double-blinded study. Int J Biometeorol 58(7):1503–1512
Olimpia P, Francesco LR (2013) There’s something in the air. Empirical evidence for the effects of negative air ions on psychophysiological state and performance. Res Psychol Behav Sci 1(4):48–53
Parts TE, Luts A, Laakso L, Hirsikko A, Gronholm T, Kulmala M (2007) Chemical composition of waterfall-induced air ions: Spectrometry vs. simulations. Boreal Environ Res 12:409–420
Peng LY, Xu FY, Wand LF, Zheng Q, Ye Q, Zhang ZF, WSH B, FSH C, Xing JP (2020) Temporal and spatial variations of negative oxygen ion concentration and its influencing factors in Jiulian Mountain National Forest Park. J Northwest Forest Univ 35(05):233–239
Perez V, Alexander DD, Bailey WH (2013) Air ions and mood outcomes: a review and meta-analysis. BMC Psychiatry 13:29
Sekimoto K, Takayama M (2013) Collision-induced dissociation analysis of negative atmospheric ion adducts in atmospheric pressure corona discharge ionization mass spectrometry. J Am Soc Mass Spectrom 24:780–788
Shi YB (2016) Observation on the curative effect of deep breathing gymnastics training for college students with poor lung function under the intervention of negative oxygen ion. Chin J Phys Med Rehabil 38(08):599–601
Sirota TV, Safronova VG, Amelina AG, Mal’tseva VN, Avkhacheeva NV, Sofin AD, Ianin VA, Mubarakshina EK, Romanova LK, Novoselov VI (2008) Effect of negative air ions on respiratory organs and blood. Biofizika. 53(5):886–893
Song X, Liu J, Geng N, Shan Y, Zhang B, Zhao B, Ni Y, Liang Z, Chen J, Zhang L, Zhang Y (2022) Multi-omics analysis to reveal disorders of cell metabolism and integrin signaling pathways induced by PM2.5. J Hazard Mater 424(Pt C):127573
Su YF, Wenjie L, Chunlei Z, Hui L (2018) Effects of load breathing training combined with air negative oxygen ion intervention on lung function in smokers with moderate and mild chronic obstructive pulmonary disease. Chin J Gerontol 38(13):3134–3136
Suzuki S, Yanagita S, Amemiya S, Kato Y, Kubota N, Ryushi T, Kita I (2008) Effects of negative air ions on activity of neural substrates involved in autonomic regulation in rats. Int J Biometeorol 52(6):481–489
Wallner P, Kundi M, Panny M, Tappler P, Hutter HP (2015) Exposure to air ions in indoor environments: experimental study with healthy adults. Int J Environ Res Public Health 12(11):14301–14311
Wang W, Yu ZH (2013) Research progress on negative air ions in urban environment in China. Ecol Environ Sci 22(04):705–711
Wang W, Zhou J, Chen M, Huang X, Xie X, Li W, Cao Q, Kan H, Xu Y, Ying Z (2018) Exposure to concentrated ambient PM2.5 alters the composition of gut microbiota in a murine model. Part Fibre Toxicol 15(1):17
Wen LY (2017) Effect of air negative oxygen ion concentration on respiratory training of students with poor pulmonary function. Mod Prev Med 44(07):1187–1190
Wu CC, Lee GW, Yang S, Yu KP, Lou CL (2006) Influence of air humidity and the distance from the source on negative air ion concentration in indoor air. Sci Total Environ 370(1):245–253
Yamamoto D, Wako K, Sato Y, Fujishiro M, Matsuura I, Ohnishi Y (2014) Positive and negative ions by air purifier have no effects on embryo-fetal development in rats. J Toxicol Sci 39(3):447–452
Yamamoto D, Wako Y, Kumabe S, Wako K, Sato Y, Fujishiro M, Yasuda Y, Matsuura I, Ohnishi Y (2015) Positive and negative ions by air purifier have no effects on reproductive function or postnatal growth and development in rats. Fundam Toxicol Sci 2(3):101–110
Yao YP, Yu ZHY, Li ZHQ, Wang K, Fan GF, Mao YD (2019) Distribution characteristics of air anion concentration in Zhejiang Province. Meteorological Sci Technol 47(06):1006–1013
Yuan XY, Sun YX, Tian Y, Yang TT, Lei J (2014) Experimental research of air negative oxygen ion and their affecting factors in different ecological functional areas of Beijing. Environ Sci Technol 37(06):97–102
Zhang Y, Chen LY, Liu T, Xiao J (2018) Change characteristics and prediction model about concentration of anions in the Emei mountain scenic spot. J Meteorol Environ 34(02):61–68
Zhang C, Wu Z, Li Z, Li H, Lin JM (2020) Inhibition effect of negative air ions on adsorption between volatile organic compounds and environmental particulate matter. Langmuir. 36(18):5078–5083
Zhu SHX, Cui J, Liu QY, Chen QQ, Zhou P, Su Y, Zhang H, Lian RH, Li JY (2019) Evaluation of negative oxygen ion concentration and correlation analysis with environmental factors in Shimen National Forest Park. Forest Environ Sci 35(05):14–22
Funding
This study was supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (No 82060603) and the Province Natural Science Foundation of Hainan (No 820RC648).
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Contributions
Sha Xiao: writing (original draft) and funding acquisition; Tianjing Wei: conceptualization and methodology; Jindong Ding: writing (review and editing); Jing Zhou: investigation and supervision; Xiaobo Lu: writing (review and editing), project administration, and funding acquisition.
Corresponding author
Ethics declarations
Conflict of interest
The authors declare no competing interests.
Additional information
Responsible Editor: Lotfi Aleya
Publisher’s note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Rights and permissions
Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article's Creative Commons licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article's Creative Commons licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this licence, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/.
About this article
Cite this article
Xiao, S., Wei, T., Petersen, J.D. et al. Biological effects of negative air ions on human health and integrated multiomics to identify biomarkers: a literature review. Environ Sci Pollut Res 30, 69824–69836 (2023). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11356-023-27133-8
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11356-023-27133-8