Abstract
Despite having a focus on sustainability policy planning, failures occur during the implementation process. The gap between policy and its implementation causes failures of the sustainability policy. Against this backdrop, the primary objective of the present study is to explore the factors that create hurdles in the implementation of corporate sustainability policy in letters and spirits. The study adopts a systematic literature review (SLR) approach and reviews all the possible studies from 1950 to 2019 published by six major publishing houses. These studies were found using selected keywords. The findings of SLR reveal governance, education, and SMEs as frequently appearing words while exploring corporate sustainability. The stakeholder theory and the institutional theory appear as the most cited theories in the sustainability literature. The grassroots approach, environmental impact assessment, integrated sustainability assessment, evidence-based practice approach, systematic approach, economical instrument policy approach, and consultant services approach appear as the most relevant approaches used for policymaking in corporate sustainability. The SLR findings reveal five significant factors that influence corporate sustainability policy implementation and can cause the gap between policy and its implementation. These factors are government institutions (including macro and meso-institutions), internal and external stakeholders, management, organizational barriers, and normative references.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Abrams FW (1951) Management’s responsibilities in a complex world. Harvard Business Review 29(3):29–34
Abreu MCSD (2009) How to define an environmental policy to improve corporate sustainability in developing countries. Business Strategy and the Environment 18(8):542–556
Ahmed A, Ahmed I (2011) Corporate conscience CSR in Pakistan - a study. Bangalore: Sustainable Development Policy Institute (SDPI)
Al Am A (2016) Corporate social responsibility and sustainability: theory and practice in Lebanon. International Journal 8(1):59–75
Alam GM, Al-Amin AQ, Forhad AR, Mubarak MS (2020) Does the private university sector exploit sustainable residential life in the name of supporting the fourth industrial revolution? Technol Forecast Soc Change 159:120200
Alexander R (2020) Emerging roles of lead buyer governance for sustainability across global production networks. Journal of Business Ethics 162(2):269–290
Armstrong JH, Kamieniecki S (2019) Sustainability policy research: a review and synthesis. Policy Studies Journal 47:S45–S65
Atkinson R, Klausen JE (2011) Understanding sustainability policy: Governance, knowledge and the search for integration. J Environ Policy Plan 13(3):231–251
Bachus K, Vanswijgenhoven F (2018) The use of regulatory taxation as a policy instrument for sustainability transitions: old wine in new bottles or unexplored potential? Journal of Environmental Planning and Management 61(9):1469–1486
Bailey IG (1999) Competition, sustainability and packaging policy in the UK. Journal of Environmental Planning and Management 42(1):83–102
Bansal P (2005) Evolving sustainably: a longitudinal study of corporate sustainable development. Strategic management journal 26(3):197–218
Bansal P, Roth K (2000) Why companies go green: a model of ecological responsiveness. Academy of Management Journal 43:717–747
Barron V (2010) “How standards contribute to sustainable development”, BSI White Paper, available at: www.bsigroup.co.uk/en/Forms/Document-Downloads/How standardscontribute-to-sustainable-development/ (accessed March 20, 2011)
Baumgartner RJ (2014) Managing corporate sustainability and CSR: a conceptual framework combining values, strategies and instruments contributing to sustainable development. Corporate Social Responsibility and Environmental Management 21(5):258–271
Beise M, Rennings K (2005) Lead markets and regulation: a framework for analyzing the international diffusion of environmental innovations. Ecol Econ 52(1):5–17
Berle AA (1932) For whom corporate managers are trustees: a note. Harvard Law Review 45(8):1365–1372
Bonn I, Fisher J (2011) Sustainability: the missing ingredient in strategy. Journal of Business Strategy 32(1):5–14
Bos Brouwers HEJ (2010) Corporate sustainability and innovation in SMEs: evidence of themes and activities in practice. Business Strategy and the Environment 19(7):417–435
Bowen HR (1953) Social responsibilities of the businessman. Harper & Row, New York
Brundtland G, Khalid M, Agnelli S, Al-Athel S, Chidzero B, Fadika L, ..., Okita S (1987) Our common future ('Brundtland report'): Oxford University Press
Busch T, Hoffmann VH (2009) Ecology-driven real options: an investment framework for incorporating uncertainties in the context of the natural environment. Journal of Business Ethics 90:295–310. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10551-009-0043-y
Caldera HTS, Desha C, Dawes L (2019) Transforming manufacturing to be ‘good for planet and people’, through enabling lean and green thinking in small and medium-sized enterprises. Sustainable Earth 2(1):4
Carnegie A (1889) Wealth. The North American Review 148(391):653–664
Carroll AB (1991) The pyramid of corporate social responsibility: toward the moral management of organizational stakeholders. Business Horizons 34(4):39–48
Carroll AB (1999) Corporate social responsibility: evolution of a definitional construct. Business & Society 38:268–295
Clark JM (1916) The changing basis of economic responsibility. Journal of Political Economy 24(3):209–229
Clark JM (1926) Social control of business
Clark SG (2009) An informational approach to sustainability: “intelligence” in conservation and natural resource management policy. Journal of Sustainable Forestry 28(6-7):636–662
Clarke S, Roome N (1999) Sustainable business: learning action networks as organizational assets. Business Strategy and the Environment 8(5):296–310
Collier U (1997) Sustainability, subsidiarity and deregulation: new directions in EU environmental policy. Environmental Politics 6(2):1–23
Dankova P, Valeva M, Štrukelj T (2015) A comparative analysis of international corporate social responsibility standards as enterprise policy/governance innovation guidelines. Systems Research and Behavioral Science 32(2):152–159
Davies AR (2009) Does sustainability count? Environmental policy, sustainable development and the governance of grassroots sustainability enterprise in Ireland. Sustainable Development 17(3):174–182
Davis K (1960) Can business afford to ignore social responsibilities? California Management Review 2(3):70–76
Deakin S, Hobbs R (2007) False dawn for CSR? Shifts in regulatory policy and the response of the corporate and financial sectors in Britain. Corporate Governance: An International Review 15(1):68–76
Driessen PP, Dieperink C, van Laerhoven F, Runhaar HA, Vermeulen WJ (2012) Towards a conceptual framework for the study of shifts in modes of environmental governance–experiences from the Netherlands. Environmental Policy and Governance 22(3):143–160
Elkington J (1994) Towards the sustainable corporation: Win-win-win business strategies for sustainable development. California Management Review 36(2):90–100
Engert S, Baumgartner RJ (2016) Corporate sustainability strategy–bridging the gap between formulation and implementation. Journal of Cleaner Production 113:822–834
Engert S, Rauter R, Baumgartner RJ (2016) Exploring the integration of corporate sustainability into strategic management: a literature review. Journal of Cleaner Production 112:2833–2850
Epstein MJ, Roy MJ (2007) Implementing a corporate environmental strategy: establishing coordination and control within multinational companies. Business Strategy and the Environment 16(6):389–403
Fahey BK, Pralle SB (2016) Governing complexity: recent developments in environmental politics and policy. Policy Studies Journal 44(S1):S28–S49
Fairbrass J (2011) Exploring corporate social responsibility policy in the European Union: a discursive institutionalist analysis. JCMS: Journal of Common Market Studies 49(5):949–970
Feng C, Huang JB, Wang M (2018) Analysis of green total-factor productivity in China’s regional metal industry: a meta-frontier approach. Resour Pol 58:219–229
Fischer F (2000) Citizens, experts, and the environment: the politics of local knowledge. Duke University Press, Durham
Fischer D, Brettel M, Mauer R (2020) The three dimensions of sustainability: a delicate balancing act for entrepreneurs made more complex by stakeholder expectations. Journal of Business Ethics 163(1):87–106
Freeman RE (1984) Strategic management: a stakeholder approach. Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliffs
Friedman M (1962) Capitalism and Freedom. University of Chicago Press, Chicago (Capitalisme et Liberté, Paris, Robert Laffont, 1971)
Galbreath J (2009) Building corporate social responsibility into strategy. European Business Review 21(2):109–127
Gardner JS, Sinclair AJ (2003) Evaluation of capacity and policy development for environmental sustainability: a case from Himachal Pradesh, India. Canadian Journal of Development Studies/Revue canadienne d’études du développement 24(1):137–153
Gouldson A, Sullivan R (2007) Corporate environmentalism: tracing the links between policies and performance using corporate reports and public registers. Business Strategy and the Environment 16(1):1–11
Guohui S, Eppler MJ (2008) Making strategy work: a literature review on the factors influencing strategy implementation. Handbook of Strategy Process Research, 252–276
Hayat N, Hussain A, Lohano HD (2020) Eco-labeling and sustainability: a case of textile industry in Pakistan. Journal of Cleaner Production 252:119807
Helleno AL, de Moraes AJI, Simon AT (2017) Integrating sustainability indicators and Lean Manufacturing to assess manufacturing processes: application case studies in Brazilian industry. Journal of cleaner production 153:405–416
Hendriks CF (2004) A New Vision on the Building Cycle. Boxtel, Aeneas
Hörisch J, Schaltegger S, Freeman RE (2020) Integrating stakeholder theory and sustainability accounting: a conceptual synthesis. Journal of Cleaner Production 275:124097
Howard B (1953) Social responsibilities of the businessman. Happer & Brothers, New York
Islam T, Islam R, Pitafi AH, Xiaobei L, Rehmani M, Irfan M, Mubarak MS (2019) The impact of corporate social responsibility on customer loyalty: The mediating role of corporate reputation, customer satisfaction, and trust. Sustain Prod Consum 25:123–135
Janaina AK, Miguel P Jr, Davi BG, Barrella W (2020) Textile sustainability: a Brazilian etiquette issue. Environmental Science & Policy. 109:125–130
Jang YJ (2020) The role of stakeholder engagement in environmental sustainability: a moderation analysis of chain affiliation. J Hosp Tour Res 1096348020936348
Jasanoff S (2009) The fifth branch: science advisers as policymakers. Harvard University Press
Jiménez A, Pérez-Foguet A (2010) Water point mapping for the analysis of rural water supply plans: case study from Tanzania. Journal of Water Resources Planning and Management 137(5):439–447
Jnr BA, Majid MA, Romli A (2019) Green information technology adoption towards a sustainability policy agenda for government-based institutions. J Sci Technol Pol Manag
Kehbila AG, Ertel J, Brent AC (2010) Corporate sustainability, ecological modernization and the policy process in the South African automotive industry. Business Strategy and the Environment 19(7):453–465
Kennedy D (1996) Competition in regulated industries. Centre for the Study of Regulated Industries, London
Kessler EH (Ed.) (2013) Encyclopedia of management theory. Sage Publications
Khan SA, Mubarik MS, Kusi-Sarpong S, Zaman SI, Kazmi SHA (2020) Social sustainable supply chains in the food industry: A perspective of an emerging economy. Corporate Social Responsibility and Environmental Management (CSREM)
Klettner A, Clarke T, Boersma M (2014) The governance of corporate sustainability: empirical insights into the development, leadership and implementation of responsible business strategy. Journal of Business Ethics 122(1):145–165
Klewitz J, Zeyen A, Hansen EG (2012) Intermediaries driving eco-innovation in SMEs: a qualitative investigation. European Journal of Innovation Management 15(4):442–467
Konard R, Thorsten H, Carsten W, Patrick D, Pavel L (2008) Learning and classification
Kotler P (2001) Marketing Management, tenth edn. Pearson Education, London
Kreps TJ (1940) Measurement of the social performance of business: In an Investigation of concentration of economic power for the Temporary National Economic Committee. US Government Printing Office, Washington DC
Kumar PS, Saravanan A (2017) Sustainable wastewater treatments in textile sector. In Sustainable fibres and textiles (pp. 323-346). Woodhead Publishing
Lange P, Bornemann B, Burger P (2019) Sustainability impacts of governance modes: insights from Swiss energy policy. Journal of Environmental Policy & Planning 21(2):174–187
Luan CJ, Tien C, Wu PH (2013) Strategizing environmental policy and compliance for firm economic sustainability: evidence from Taiwanese electronics firms. Business Strategy and the Environment 22(8):517–546
Lynch-Wood G, Williamson D, Jenkins W (2009) The over-reliance on self-regulation in CSR policy. Bus Ethics Eur Rev 18(1):52–65
Ma Y, Rong K, Mangalagiu D, Thornton TF, Zhu D (2018) Co-evolution between urban sustainability and business ecosystem innovation: evidence from the sharing mobility sector in Shanghai. Journal of Cleaner Production 188:942–953
Marland G, Kowalczyk T, Cherry TL (2015) “Green fluff”? The role of corporate sustainability initiatives in effective climate policy: comment on “science-based carbon targets for the corporate world: The ultimate sustainability commitment, or a costly distraction?”. J Ind Ecol 19(6):934–936
Masurel E (2007) Why SMEs invest in environmental measures: sustainability evidence from small and medium-sized printing firms. Business Strategy and the Environment 16(3):190–201
Mathis A (2007) Corporate social responsibility and policy making: what role does communication play? Business Strategy and the Environment 16(5):366–385
McLean BL, Borén T (2015) Barriers to implementing sustainability locally: a case study of policy immobilities. Local Environment 20(12):1489–1506
Ménard C, Jimenez A, Tropp H (2018) Addressing the policy-implementation gaps in water services: the key role of meso-institutions. Water International 43(1):13–33
Mintzberg H, Waters JA (1985) Of strategies, deliberate and emergent. Strategic Management Journal 6(3):257–272
Miska C, Szőcs I, Schiffinger M (2018) Culture’s effects on corporate sustainability practices: a multi-domain and multi-level view. Journal of World Business 53(2):263–279
Moktadir MA, Rahman T, Rahman MH, Ali SM, Paul SK (2018) Drivers to sustainable manufacturing practices and circular economy: a perspective of leather industries in Bangladesh. Journal of Cleaner Production 174:1366–1380
Moore J (2005) Barriers and pathways to creating sustainability education programs: policy, rhetoric and reality. Environmental Education Research 11(5):537–555
Morgan G, Ryu K, Mirvis P (2009) Leading corporate citizenship: governance, structure, systems. Corporate Governance: The international journal of business in society 9(1):39–49
Mubarik MS (2015) Human capital and performance of small & medium manufacturing enterprises: A study of Pakistan (Doctoral dissertation, University of Malaya)
Mubarik MS, Naghavi N (2020) Digital technologies and consumption: how to shape the unknown?. In: The palgrave handbook of corporate sustainability in the digital era (pp. 529–541). Palgrave Macmillan, Cham
Nutley SM, Walter I, Davies HT (2007) Using evidence: How research can inform public services. Policy press
Nykvist B, Nilsson M (2009) Are impact assessment procedures actually promoting sustainable development? Institutional perspectives on barriers and opportunities found in the Swedish committee system. Environmental Impact Assessment Review 29(1):15–24
Orji IJ (2019) Examining barriers to organizational change for sustainability and drivers of sustainable performance in the metal manufacturing industry. Resources, Conservation and Recycling 140:102–114
Paulraj A (2009) Environmental motivations: a classification scheme and its impact on environmental strategies and practices. Business Strategy and the Environment 18(7):453–468
Pedersen ER (2006) Making corporate social responsibility (CSR) operable: how companies translate stakeholder dialogue into practice. Business and Society Review 111(2):137–163
Perrini F, Minoja M (2008) Strategizing corporate social responsibility: evidence from an Italian medium-sized, family-owned company. Business Ethics: A European Review 17(1):47–63
Radaelli CM (1995) The role of knowledge in the policy process. Journal of European Public Policy 2(2):159–183
Raja ASM, Arputharaj A, Saxena S, Patil PG (2019) Water requirement and sustainability of textile processing industries. In Water in textiles and fashion (pp. 155-173). Woodhead Publishing
Ramus CA, Montiel I (2005) When are corporate environmental policies a form of greenwashing? Business & Society 44(4):377–414
Rennings K, Ziegler A, Ankele K, Hoffmann E (2006) The influence of different characteristics of the EU environmental management and auditing scheme on technical environmental innovations and economic performance. Ecological Economics 57(1):45–59
Roosa SA (2007) Energy policy and sustainability in sunbelt cities in the United States. International Journal of Green Energy 4(2):173–196
Sheinbaum-Pardo C, Ruiz-Mendoza BJ, Rodríguez-Padilla V (2012) Mexican energy policy and sustainability indicators. Energy Policy 46:278–283
Sinclair AJ, Fenton RW (1997) Stewardship for packaging and packaging waste: key policy elements for sustainability. Canadian Public Administration 40(1):123–148
Spiller PT, Savedoff WD (1999) Spilled water: institutional commitment in the provision of water services. Inter-American Development Bank
Springett D (2003) An ‘incitement to discourse’: benchmarking as a springboard to sustainable development. Business Strategy and the Environment 12(1):1–11
Trianni A, Cagno E, Neri A (2017) Modelling barriers to the adoption of industrial sustainability measures. Journal of Cleaner Production 168:1482–1504
Türkel S, Akan A (2015) Corporate social responsibility (CSR) communication: a Turkish industry example. In Integrated communications in the postmodern era (pp. 151-174). Palgrave Macmillan, London
UN Global Compact (n.d.-a) The power of principle. Retrieved from https://www.unglobalcompact.org/what-is-gc/mission/principles. Accessed 10 July 2020
UN Global Compact (n.d.-b) 17 Goals to transform our world. Retrieved from: https://www.unglobalcompact.org/sdgs/17-global-goals. Accessed 10 July 2020
van Hemel C, Cramer J (2002) Barriers and stimuli for ecodesign in SMEs. Journal of Cleaner Production 10(5):439–453
Vincenza Ciasullo M, Troisi O (2013) Sustainable value creation in SMEs: a case study. The TQM Journal 25(1):44–61
WCED, S. W. S (1987) World commission on environment and development. Our Common Future 17:1–91
Werther WB Jr, Chandler D (2010) Strategic corporate social responsibility: stakeholders in a global environment. Sage
Whitmarsh L, Turnpenny J, Nykvist B (2009) Beyond the regime: can Integrated Sustainability Assessment address the barriers to effective sustainable passenger mobility policy? Journal of Environmental Planning and Management 52(8):973–991
Xanthos D, Walker TR (2017) International policies to reduce plastic marine pollution from single-use plastics (plastic bags and microbeads): a review. Marine pollution bulletin 118(1-2):17–26
Yang N, Ha-Brookshire JE (2019) Truly sustainable or not? An exploratory assessment of sustainability capability of textile and apparel corporations in China from the moral responsibility perspective. Fashion and Textiles 6(1):15
Yu Y, Chen Z, Wei L, Wang B (2017) The low-carbon technology characteristics of China’s ferrous metal industry. Journal of Cleaner Production 140:1739–1748
Zahn E (1979) Strategische Planung zur Steuerung der langfristigen Unternehmensentwicklung: Grundlagen zu einer Theorie der Unternehmensplanung. Duncker & Humblot
Zhou Y, Pan M, Zhou DK, Xue L (2018) Stakeholder risk and trust perceptions in the diffusion of green manufacturing technologies: evidence from China. J Environ Dev 27(1):46–73
Zhu Q (2016) Institutional pressures and support from industrial zones for motivating sustainable production among Chinese manufacturers. International Journal of Production Economics 181:402–409
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Contributions
The authors contributed to the study conception and design. Material preparation, search, and collection of relevant articles and reviews were performed by Mushtaq Ahmed and Muhammad Shujaat Mubarik. The first draft of the manuscript was written by Mushtaq Ahmed. Muhammad Shujaat Mubarik and Muhammad Shahbaz thoroughly checked the first draft. All authors have read and approved the final manuscript.
Corresponding author
Ethics declarations
Ethics approval and consent to participate
Not applicable
Consent of publication
Not applicable
Competing interests
Not applicable
Additional information
Responsible editor: Nicholas Apergis
Publisher’s note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Ahmed, M., Mubarik, M.S. & Shahbaz, M. Factors affecting the outcome of corporate sustainability policy: a review paper. Environ Sci Pollut Res 28, 10335–10356 (2021). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11356-020-12143-7
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11356-020-12143-7