Deer herbivory affects the functional diversity of forest floor plants via changes in competition-mediated assembly rules

Abstract

Distorted plant diversity patterns due to ungulate herbivory could be explained by changes in community assembly processes, but the effects of ungulate herbivory on plant community assembly remain unclear. Here, we examined the role of deer herbivory in the regulation of the assembly processes of a forest floor plant community by assessing species and functional diversity in over- and no-grazing plots (control and exclosure plots, respectively) in Shiretoko National Park in Japan. Compared with the exclosure plot, vegetation coverage was considerably lower, and species richness and diversity were higher in the control plot. Functional traits associated with competitive ability (leaf area and chlorophyll content) were significantly higher in the exclosure plot. The pattern of functional diversity changed from overdispersion to clustering with an increase in local crowdedness. This trait clustering indicates that the local communities that were free from ungulate disturbance gradually became dominated by some competitively superior plant species, which led to low species diversity and biotic homogenization. In contrast, the reduction in vegetation due to overgrazing by deer resulted in an increase in the relative importance of stochastic assembly processes, which enabled the coexistence of various species, including less competitive ones. Our results emphasize that although deer overabundance is of concern, their complete exclusion has a negative consequence from an ecological perspective. Because deer herbivory is an inherent process that affects the biodiversity of plants on the forest floor, the establishment of fences requires careful consideration to ensure the conservation of ecological processes and their associated biodiversity.

Introduction

In terrestrial ecosystems worldwide, overgrazing by large ungulates (e.g., deer) has created major problems that have impacted the biodiversity, as well as other properties, of the ecosystems that these animals inhabit (Rooney 2001; Côté et al. 2004; Mori et al. 2015). Although herbivory is an inherently consumptive process in forest ecosystems, the overabundance of ungulates has been attributed to human activities, including anthropogenic warming (Forchhammer et al. 1998; Loison et al. 1999), land-use change (Bobek et al. 1984; Roseberry and Woolf 1998), reduced hunting pressure (Brown et al. 2000; Riley et al. 2003), and the loss of keystone predator species (Rooney 2001), and it has been proposed to have adverse effects on vegetation (Côté et al. 2004; Takatsuki 2009). Deer have direct and indirect impacts on the biotic interactions among coexisting plant species (Rooney and Waller 2003). The former includes selective herbivory that is associated with the palatability of plants (Augustine and McNaughton 1998), while the latter is exemplified by changes in habitat conditions due to browsing that can result in gap formation and altered nutrient cycling (Wardle et al. 2002; Bardgett and Wardle 2003). As a result, the structure, composition, and diversity of plant communities can be substantially altered (Russell et al. 2001; Horsley et al. 2003). To safeguard vegetation from overgrazing by ungulates, fences designed to exclude these large herbivores have often been established in various regions, but their effects on local plant diversity have been mixed (Côté et al. 2004; Inatomi et al. 2012). To understand these contradictory results, a rigorous assessment of how intense herbivory alters the structure of biodiversity is necessary, and in doing so, it is worth focusing on the theory of community assembly. However, while most research on the consequences of establishing ungulate fences has primarily quantified the changes in biodiversity patterns, the underlying assembly processes have not been fully assessed. To better guide conservation and management activities in the face of ungulate overabundance, this gap in our knowledge must be urgently addressed.

There are two possible processes of community assembly: deterministic and stochastic (Chase et al. 2011). The deterministic process is based on niche theory (Hutchinson 1959), and when this process is dominant, community composition should depend on local biotic and abiotic environmental conditions. In contrast, when stochastic processes are dominant, community assembly is primarily shaped randomly (Chase et al. 2011). The biotic interactions among species often act strongly at a fine scale (de Bello et al. 2013); thus, these interactions are affected by local factors, such as environmental conditions or disturbances, which have been shown to have various effects on community assembly by altering the relative importance of deterministic and stochastic processes (Chase 2007; Vellend et al. 2007; Chase et al. 2011). This may also be the case for deer herbivory (Begley-Miller et al. 2014; Ohashi and Hoshino 2014).

Recently, there has been a rapid increase in the use of trait-based approaches to reveal community assembly processes at local scales (Kraft et al. 2008, 2014; Angert et al. 2009; Cadotte et al. 2011; Weiher et al. 2011; Götzenberger et al. 2012). Functional traits are any measurable features that potentially affect individual performance or the fitness of organisms (Cadotte et al. 2011). Functional traits determine whether individuals survive or species persist (Lavorel et al. 1997), as well as how they interact with one another, which provide information regarding the strength of competition and the efficiency of consumptive interactions (Davies et al. 2007). When multiple trait dimensions are considered, the ecological differentiation between species may be elucidated because these sets of traits are likely relevant to the ecological tolerance, ecological niche, and competitive ability of a species (Cadotte et al. 2011; Mouillot et al. 2013). Importantly, functional diversity (FD), the dispersion of species in multidimensional trait space, provides information regarding how ecologically similar or dissimilar species are assembled (Petchey and Gaston 2007; Laliberté and Legendre 2010). In theory, a significant departure from random assembly can generate two opposing patterns that are suggestive of deterministic processes, and these patterns can emerge as either low or high FD, which indicate trait clustering or overdispersion, respectively. Under the classical paradigm, ecologically dissimilar species can coexist through niche partitioning, which is based on the theory that the coexistence of functionally similar species is limited by interspecific competition (i.e., limiting similarity; MacArthur and Levins 1967; MacArthur 1972; Chesson 2000). These niche differences can rise from species-specific interactions with resources, specialist consumers, pathogens, mutualists, or temporal environmental heterogeneity (Tilman 1982, 1988; Chesson 2000; Sammul et al. 2006; Chesson and Kuang 2008), and trait overdispersion is thought to be the consequence of this process. In contrast, shared adaptive characteristics among syntopic species promote the co-existence of species with similar traits. Under intense abiotic interactions, traits related to ecological tolerances are important (Cornwell et al. 2006; Grime 2006), but under resource-rich conditions, species with high competitive ability are superior to less competitive ones (Kunstler et al. 2012; Kraft et al. 2014). These processes promote trait clustering (Mayfield and Levine 2010). Likewise, the trait-based approach allows the important mechanisms underlying community assembly (Götzenberger et al. 2012) and the biodiversity response (Mori et al. 2013) to be inferred.

Serious ecological concerns regarding the overabundance of sika deer (Cervus nippon yesoensis) (e.g., overgrazing/browsing) throughout Japan have been frequently expressed (Takatsuki 2009), and these concerns even extend to areas with pristine vegetation that have been designated as protected areas. In Shiretoko National Park (located on the northeastern tip of Hokkaido, Japan), deer overabundance has resulted in numerous ecological issues, including negative impacts on forest understory plant communities (Kaji et al. 2004; Mori et al. 2015). To conserve forest vegetation, deer exclosure fences were established in the early 2000s, and since more than a decade has passed, we expect that the presence and absence of selective deer herbivory has considerably changed the biotic interactions among the plant species in these forests. This is because these areas are now characterized by both an overabundance and an underabundance of deer, which are expected to have impacted the forest understory communities. Here, we aimed to detect the ecological effects of sika deer on the mechanisms of plant species coexistence, as well as the consequences for the patterns of biodiversity, by assessing the differences in community assembly processes between these two ecological extremes (i.e., deer overgrazing and no overgrazing). We envision that this study will inform management treatments and policies that are designed to cope with deer overabundance in the study area and in other regions.

Methods

Study site

This study was conducted in Shiretoko National Park, which is located in northeastern Hokkaido, the northernmost island of Japan (Mori et al. 2016a), and is registered as a United Nations Educational, Scientific, and Cultural Organization World Natural Heritage Site because of its high biodiversity. The mean annual temperature and precipitation at the study site between 2004 and 2014 were 6.5 °C and 1271 mm, respectively (http://www.data.jma.go.jp/obd/stats/etrn/index.php). In this region, the population of sika deer has increased since the late 1980s, and in areas of high deer density, the ground layer of the plant community has been transformed. To address this problem, deer exclosure fences have been constructed in these areas. Horobetsu is one of the most highly populated areas on the Shiretoko Peninsula, and it is located in the northcentral part (44°06′00″N 145°01′42″E) of the peninsula. The forest here is characterized as a mixed coniferous and broad-leaved natural forest that is dominated by Abies sachalinensis, Quercus crispula, and Kalopanax septemlobus, and the forest floor is typically covered with snow from November to May (Kubota 2000). Since around 2000, the density of deer in this area has been as high as approximately 5–10 deer/km, as estimated by light censuses that were conducted in autumn (http://dc.shiretoko-whc.com/). To reduce the deer grazing pressure on the vegetation, exclosure fences were constructed in 2003, and as a result, the coverage of the ground-layer plants inside the boundaries of the fences has increased.

Field data collection

To quantify the effects of deer foraging on the composition of the ground-layer plant community, we established two study plots in the forest. The exclosure plot had fences to protect the vegetation from deer herbivory, and the control plot, which was located outside the boundaries of the fence, was exposed to deer herbivory. The sizes of the exclosure and control plots were 80 m × 120 m (0.96 ha) and 100 m × 100 m (1.00 ha), respectively, and they were located close together so that there was little difference in the species composition of the canopy trees (The Forestry Agency of Japan 2004). These exclosure and control plots were partitioned into 96 and 100 10 m × 10 m subplots, respectively, and at the center of each subplot, we established a 1 m × 1 m quadrat (i.e., there were 96 and 100 quadrats in the exclosure and control plots, respectively). Each plant species smaller than 50 cm in height within each quadrat was taxonomically identified, and its percent cover was estimated by a guided visual observation using a 1 m × 1 m nylon mesh that was divided into 100 10 cm × 10 cm grids. This survey was conducted from late June to early July 2014, the season during which most of the herbaceous species appear on the forest floor after thawing.

To evaluate the effects of biotic and abiotic conditions on plant community structure, we measured several environmental variables, including three soil variables (water content (WC), electrical conductivity (EC), and pH) and four stand structural variables (tree species richness, stem number, total basal area of the trees, and canopy openness), of the 10 m × 10 m subplots. We used the total vegetation ground cover on the forest floor as an indicator of local crowdedness, which can have important consequences for species composition via the prevention of seed colonization and the limitation of light availability at fine scales (Berntson and Wayne 2000; Mori and Takeda 2003), and this metric was arcsine-transformed to improve its normality (Snedecor and Cochran 1967; Sokal and Rohlf 2012). Soil WC (%) and soil EC (mS/cm) values were the means of three repeated random measurements in the 1 m × 1 m quadrats, and they were quantified by inserting a soil moisture meter (DM-18, Takemura Denki, Tokyo, Japan) and an EC tester (soil test HI 98331, Hanna Instruments, Chiba, Japan), respectively, into the top 10 cm of the soil. For soil pH, we collected a soil sample of approximately 0.3 cm³ from a depth of 2 cm in each quadrat, mixed it with the same amount of tap water, and performed the measurement with a pH meter (LAQUA twin B-71X, Horiba, Ltd., Kyoto, Japan). We calculated canopy openness with CanopOn2 (http://takenaka-akio.org/etc./canopon2) using hemispherical photographs taken by a Sony NEX-5 camera (Sony, Tokyo, Japan) mounted with a fish-eye lens (MADOKA, Yasuhara Co., Ltd., Tokyo, Japan) at the center of each subplot. The stand structural variables were sourced from the Forestry Agency of Japan (2014), which measured the size and species identity of all trees taller than 2 m at every 10 m × 10 m subplots.

Trait data collection

We used 10 plant functional traits related to growth, survival, and the response to environmental change (Pérez-Harguindeguy et al. 2013), including leaf area (LA; mm²), specific leaf area (SLA; mm² g⁻¹), chlorophyll content (measured by the SPAD device unit [see below]), maximum plant height (plant height; cm), leaf phenology, life form, growth form, herbaceous or woody, seed mass (g), and dispersal mode. For LA, SLA, and chlorophyll content, we collected and measured five samples from five individuals of each plant species (25 leaf samples for each species). First, we collected a fully formed adult leaf and measured its chlorophyll content using a Minolta SPAD-502 (Osaka, Japan), and then we immediately scanned the leaf before drying, and calculated the LA from the scanned images using Image-J (Rasband 1997–2008). We used the leaflets for plant species with compound leaves. To calculate the SLA, we dried the leaves for 72 h at 80 °C to obtain their dry weights. The values of the other traits were extracted from the literature and encyclopedias (ESM 1). Trait measurement and sample collection followed the protocols outlined in Pérez-Harguindeguy et al. (2013).

Data analysis

To describe the effect of deer presence/absence on plant communities, we calculated species richness and Shannon’s index values as measures of species diversity (Magurran and McGill 2011). To examine changes in plant community structure, we also determined the Bray–Curtis index, which is one of the most commonly used measures of vegetation compositional dissimilarity (Anderson et al. 2011). To evaluate differences in the species abundance distribution between the two plots, we plotted the frequency of occurrence of each plant species within all quadrats (the frequency of occurrence across all quadrats) by their dominance rank within the meta-community (hereafter, the species dominance-rank curve). We visually checked for differences in the curves and in the lists of dominant species between the two plots.

Furthermore, we calculated the community-weighted mean (CWM) trait values, which are the mean trait values of all species in the community weighted by their relative abundance (Garnier et al. 2004), for five numeric plant traits that are likely related to plant responses to deer herbivory: LA, SLA, chlorophyll content, plant height, and seed mass. It is known that deer selectively graze large LAs of Trillium grandiflorum (Knight 2003), and the SLA is the ratio of leaf area to leaf mass, which is positively correlated with the leaf nitrogen (N) concentration and negatively correlated with leaf longevity (Reich et al. 1997). Chlorophyll is highly correlated with tissue N (Markwell and Blevins 1999). These traits, which are related to the abundances of resources in leaves, are likely affected by deer herbivory. Maximum plant height is also associated with competitive ability (Vojtech et al. 2008) and vulnerability to deer herbivory, and seed mass is related to survival and establishment in the face of environmental hazards (Pérez-Harguindeguy et al. 2013). Although deer herbivory could increase the intraspecific variations in trait values, we used the mean values for each species to calculate the CWM values in this study.

We calculated functional diversity using the functional dispersion (FDis) index that was developed by Laliberté and Legendre (2010). The FDis is the mean distance of all species in the community in multidimensional trait space weighted by their relative abundance, and we selected this index because FDis is independent of species richness, can account for species abundances, and can be used for multiple traits (Laliberté and Legendre 2010). In this study, we calculated FDis using all of the functional traits that we measured (10 traits) to express the ecological differentiation between species (Cadotte et al. 2011; Mouillot et al. 2013). To evaluate the magnitude of deviation from a random assembly, we calculated the standardized effect size (SES) of the FDis, which was defined as (FDis_obs − FDis_null)/FDis_sd, where FDis_obs is the observed FDis in actual communities, and FDis_null and FDis_sd are the mean and standard deviation of FDis values that are calculated by 999 randomizations, respectively. We repeated this procedure for the exclosure and control plots. Randomization was based on the independent swap algorithm (Gotelli and Gotelli 2000), which maintains the species occurrence frequency and sample species richness based on the meta-community. Positive and negative SES values indicate higher (trait overdispersion) and lower (trait clustering) functional diversity, respectively, than expected at random; thus, to examine how biodiversity was structured, we tested for a correlation between the diversity measures (SES of the FDis and Shannon’s diversity) and environmental variables across quadrats. We used a standardized major axis (SMA) regression to describe how these variables were related (Warton et al. 2006; Sokal and Rohlf 2012).

Results

Field sampling

There were a total of 54 species in all of the study sites, of which 35 were found inside the fence (exclosure), and 43 were found outside the fence (control). Twenty-four species were common to both plots. The four dominant species were Dryopteris expansa, Maianthemum dilatatum, Sasa kurilensis, and Toxicodendron orientale, but their coverage was low in the control plot (Fig. S1). In addition, almost all of the other species that were common to both plots had lower coverage in the control plot than in the exclosure plot.

Species diversity

Mean species richness and Shannon’s diversity were significantly higher in the control plot (P < 0.001; t test) (Fig. 1a, b), as was the mean Bray–Curtis dissimilarity value (P < 0.001; t-test) (Fig. 1c). In contrast, the mean ground cover of the vegetation was significantly higher in the exclosure plot (P < 0.001; t-test) (Fig. 1d). The dominance-rank curve exhibited different forms between the two plots (Fig. 2). In the exclosure plot, the dominance of each species decreased sharply as species rank decreased; thus, species were divided into dominant and rare species. In contrast, the control plot exhibited a smooth curve that had more species with intermediate frequencies.

Fig. 1

Comparison of a species richness, b Shannon’s diversity index, c Bray–Curtis dissimilarity index, and d coverage (%) values for each quadrat between the exclosure and control plots. The numbers of samples used in a, b, and d are 96 and 100 for the exclosure and control plots, respectively, and in c, they are 4560 and 4950. Significance was assessed with a t-test

Fig. 2

Species dominance-rank curves of the exclosure and control plots. Dominance and species rank are based on the number of occurrence frequencies across all quadrats

Functional diversity

The control plot had a significantly lower LA and chlorophyll content compared with the exclosure plot (Table 1), but other traits (SLA, plant height, and seed mass) were not significantly different. There was no significant difference between the exclosure and control plots in terms of functional diversity (SES) (the mean SES values were −0.09 and 0.09, and the variances were 0.97 and 0.51, respectively).

Table 1 Differences in the community-weighted mean trait values (CWM) of five plant functional traits between the exclosure and control plots

In terms of the relationship between the SES and the environmental variables, there was a significantly negative correlation between the SES and local crowdedness in the exclosure plot (R = −0.248, P < 0.05) (Table 2; Fig. 3a). However, there were no other significant correlations between the SES and the environmental variables in either plot (Table 2), including local crowdedness in the control plot (R = −0.110, P = 0.285) (Fig. 3b). In the exclosure plot, there was a significantly negative correlation between the environmental variables and Shannon’s diversity (R = −0.317, P < 0.01) (Fig. 4a), but in the control plot, there was no significant correlation between the environmental variables and Shannon’s diversity (R = −0.116, P = 0.254) (Fig. 4b).

Table 2 Correlation coefficient (R) between the functional diversity standardized effect size and the environmental variables

Fig. 3

Correlation between standardized functional diversity and local crowdedness index, which is arcsine transformed, of a the exclosure plot and b the control plot. The regression line is the standardized major axis (SMA) between the two components

Fig. 4

Correlation between Shannon’s diversity and the local crowdedness index, which is arcsine transformed, of a the exclosure plot and b the control plot. The regression line is the standardized major axis (SMA) between the two components

Discussion

By focusing on the taxonomic and functional characteristics of plants on the forest floor, we found that deer herbivory played a significant role in shaping local plant communities. Most importantly, using a trait-based approach, we detected changes in the community assembly processes at a local scale, which may explain the mechanisms underlying the patterns of biodiversity.

Taxon- and trait-based evaluation

We compared several metrics of the forest floor plant community between the plots with (exclosure plot) and without (control plot) fences. The significantly lower local crowdedness in the control plot compared with the exclosure plot (Fig. 1d) suggests that deer herbivory played a significant role in suppressing the growth and survival of plants on the forest floor, and the species richness, Shannon’s diversity, and Bray–Curtis dissimilarity values were all higher in the control plot than in the exclosure plot (Fig. 1a–c). Previous reports on the effects of deer herbivory on plant diversity have provided mixed results depending on whether deer primarily consume the dominant species (Côté et al. 2004). In our study site, some dominant species had higher levels of abundance in the exclosure plot than in the control plot (Fig. S1), and the dominance-rank curve of the exclosure plot also showed a more skewed pattern than that of the control plot (Fig. 2). These results indicate that the dominant species with high competitive abilities interfered with the prosperity of the other species in the exclosure plot. Moreover, these results are consistent with the work of Schütz et al. (2003), who reported that a reduction in dominant species due to deer herbivory could enhance plant species richness. Taken together, we suggest that dominance reduction by deer herbivory is one of the important determinants of the maintenance of species diversity, and furthermore, that the lack of herbivory likely decreases the dissimilarity among local assemblages, leading to the homogenization of communities through the disproportionate representation of dominant species. Some studies reported that deer herbivory decreases plant diversity by leaving a limited subset of unpalatable species or, in the extreme case of intensive herbivory, bare soil and little plant cover (Takahashi and Kaji 2001; Rooney et al. 2004; Webster et al. 2005). Although it is difficult to practically compare the impacts of deer over/under-grazing on vegetation across regions, the level of the impacts on our plots may not have been as intense as these extreme cases. While the overabundance of deer has been a concern in the study region (Kaji et al. 2004; The Forestry Agency of Japan 2007, 2012), the intensity of deer herbivory in our study site could be at a level that can, to some extent, maintain plant diversity (as explained by the intermediate disturbance hypothesis; Grime 1973; Connell 1978). In other words, fencing has been affecting the understory plant communities in an adverse way by virtue of unnaturally excluding deer.

To further evaluate the compositional characteristics of forest floor plant communities in response to under- and overgrazing by deer, we used a trait-based approach. Here, we observed higher CWM trait values in LA and chlorophyll content in the exclosure plot than in the control plot (Table 1), which may be due to the selective grazing of large leaves (Knight 2003) and the vulnerability of more nutritious leaves to deer herbivory (Ammer 1996), respectively. Based on the skewed dominance-rank curve, CWM trait values are likely to be highly influenced by dominant species in the exclosure plot, and although the survival of these species cannot be explained by these traits alone, high values of these two traits are thought to be more advantageous under low herbivory pressure. In summary, plants with large leaves and high chlorophyll content are more competitive, but they are also more vulnerable to deer herbivory.

Community assembly processes

Because functional diversity deviated from that expected at random, we examined the community assembly processes at the local scale. In the control plot, the standardized functional diversity values were distributed around zero (Fig. 3b), and there was no significant relationship between standardized functional diversity and the environmental variables (Table 2). These results suggest that deterministic assembly processes, such as interspecific competition or environmental filtering, were weak; that is, stochastic processes predominated in the control plot. When vegetation coverage is reduced by deer, the likelihood of competitive exclusion (i.e., species exclusion by some species with more competitive traits) might decrease, which may increase the opportunities for species establishment (Grime 2006; Mayfield and Levine 2010). The observed pattern in the control plot is consistent with the idea that disturbance promotes random assembly processes (del Moral 2009); when food resources are depleted through selective herbivory, deer are known to graze on plants regardless of their palatability (Waller and Alverson 1997; Takahashi and Kaji 2001; Côté et al. 2004). Therefore, we infer that intensive deer herbivory has reduced vegetation coverage (Fig. 1d), regardless of the species traits at the study site. Stochastic processes often enhance species diversity (e.g., Chase 2010), thereby allowing various species to emerge independently of their traits.

In the exclosure plot, we observed a different pattern of functional diversity along the local crowdedness gradient, i.e., a shift from trait overdispersion to trait clustering (Fig. 3a), which suggests a gradual change in the relative importance of these different assembly processes. The mechanism for trait overdispersion is often interpreted as a consequence of niche partitioning that arises from limiting similarity (Chesson 2000), and in this study, more niches became available to more species as local crowdedness decreased. Niche partitioning promotes the coexistence of various species, thereby resulting in higher species diversity in less crowded localities (Fig. 4a). In terms of trait clustering, a few species became dominant while the majority of species decreased in abundance under fenced (Fig. 2) and crowded conditions, and this could have resulted from intense competition for light and nutrients (Berntson and Wayne 2000). These results suggest that weaker competitors had been excluded by competitively superior species, which led to trait clustering (Mayfield and Levine 2010), and the disappearance of weaker competitors could result in lower species diversity in more crowded localities (Fig. 4a).

In the exclosure plot, only local crowdedness was correlated with the functional diversity patterns of each quadrat; thus, to further understand the mechanisms underlying the functional diversity gradient, we must determine which factors caused the differences in local crowdedness among the localities (i.e., quadrats). Unfortunately, our snapshot datasets did not provide a complete picture, but the monitoring data support our interpretation of the factors that caused the variability in local crowdedness among the localities. According to a report by the Forestry Agency of Japan (2014), the abundance of dominant species has sharply increased since the construction of the fence (Fig. S2), which suggests that crowded localities have continued to expand and that trait clustering is still ongoing.

Implications

Deer overabundance has been caused by human activities, and to mitigate its negative consequences, deer exclosure fences have been constructed around the world with the aim of conserving vegetation. Fences have been reported to be efficient at promoting the regeneration of trees in forests (Shimoda et al. 1994; Nomiya et al. 2003; Kumar et al. 2006), as well as conserving specific species (Fletcher et al. 2001; Tamura et al. 2005) and vegetation ground cover (Kurten and Carson 2015; Tamura 2015). From the perspective of ecosystem-based management, we envision that establishing fences is not an absolute solution, as the importance of considering natural processes has recently been recognized as essential for the conservation of biodiversity and the sustainability of forest ecosystems (Christensen et al. 1996; Lindenmayer and Franklin 2002; Mori 2011). While its impact is often of concern in some situations, deer herbivory is also an inherent process that promotes species coexistence and community assembly through the relaxation of competitive relationships among plant species, and this was reaffirmed by our study. However, our results cannot be generalized because of the lack of spatial and temporal replication, and we were also unable to account for the reproductive status of the individual plants in the community, which could have important consequences for biodiversity conservation. Nonetheless, our results indicate that establishing fences is important if deer herbivory is severely impacting the vegetation. However, to restore and conserve plant diversity, it may be necessary to control the intensity of herbivory by opening/closing the fences, rather than completely eradicating deer herbivory. Therefore, adaptive management and restoration grounded on a mechanistic understanding of ecosystem processes (Mori et al. 2016b) are needed to adequately manage the deer population and its impact on plant diversity.