Abstract
Dan Shechtman was the first to discover an actual quasicrystal (on April 8, 1982). He was, however, not the first to discover the pure possibility of this novel structure (the theoretical discovery), which had been excluded from the range of the possibilities of crystals (as it had been fixed by both theoretical and empirical means in the beginning of the twentieth century). Penrose and Mackay, in particular, had contributed to the discovery of the pure possibilities of quasicrystals quite some time before their actual discovery. These pure possibilities are mathematical–structural, and like purely mathematical entities, they do not exist spatiotemporally and causally, whereas actual quasicrystals exist only spatiotemporally and causally. The pure possibilities of quasicrystals do not depend on their actualities, and without them, these actualities would have been theoretically groundless, meaningless, and could not be correctly identified if at all. Hence, Mackay’s contribution to the meaning and theoretical basis of the discovery of actual quasicrystals is indispensable .
Similar content being viewed by others
References
http://press.web.cern.ch/press/PressReleases/Releases2012/PR17.12E.html
http://www.nobelprize.org/nobel_prizes/physics/laureates/2013/press.html
Gilead A (1999) Saving possibilities: an essay in philosophical psychology. Value inquiry book series, vol 80. Rodopi, Amsterdam
Gilead A (2003) Singularity and other possibilities: panenmentalist novelties. Value inquiry book series, vol 139. Rodopi, Amsterdam
Gilead A (2005) A possibilist metaphysical reconsideration of the identity of indiscernibles and free will. Metaphysica 6:25–51
Gilead A (2009) Necessity and truthful fictions: panenmentalist observations. Value inquiry book series, vol 202. Rodopi, Amsterdam
Gilead A (2010) Actualist fallacies, from fax technology to lunar journeys. Philosophy and Literature 34:173–187
Gilead A (2011) The privacy of the psychical. Value Inquiry Book Series, vol 233. Rodopi, Amsterdam
Gilead A (2013) Shechtman’s three question marks: impossibility, possibility, and quasicrystals. Found Chem 15:209–224
Gilead A (2014) Pure possibilities and some striking scientific discoveries. Found Chem 16:149–163
Gilead A (2014) We are not replicable: A challenge to Parfit’s view. Int Philos Q 54:453–460
Gilead A (2014) Chain reactions, “impossible” reactions, and panenmentalist possibilities. Found Chem 16:201–214
Gilead A (2015) Self-referentiality and two arguments refuting physicalism. Int Philos Q 55:471–477
Gilead A (2015) Can brain Imaging breach our mental privacy? Rev Philos Psychol 6:275–291
Gilead A (2015) Cruelty, singular individuality, and Peter the Great. Philosophia 43:337–354
Gilead A (2015) Neoteny and the playground of pure possibilities. Int J Humanit Soc Sci 5:30–39
Gilead A (2015) The twilight of determinism: at least in biophysical novelties. http://arxiv.org/ftp/arxiv/papers/1510/1510.04919.pdf
Levine D, Steinhardt P (1984) Quasicrystals: a new class of ordered structures. Phys Rev Lett 53:2477–2480
Lord EA, Mackay AL, Ranganathan S (2006) New geometries for new materials. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Hargittai I (2010) Structures beyond crystals. J Mol Struct 976:81–86
Mackay AL (1982) Crystallography and the Penrose pattern. Phys A Theor Stat Phys 114:609–613
Penrose R (1974) Role of aesthetics in pure and applied research. Bull Inst Math Appl 10:266
Shechtman D, Blech I, Gratias D, Cahn JW (1984) Metallic phase with long range orientational order and no translation symmetry. Phys Rev Lett 53:1951–1954
Mackay AL (1997/8) Bending the rules. Lecture 1997/98, HLSI 24/02. http://met.iisc.ernet.in/~lord/webfiles/Alan/CVU12.pdf
Mackay AL (1997) Lucretius or the philosophy of chemistry. Colloids Surf A 129–130:305–310
Mackay AL (1990) Crystals and fivefold symmetry. In: Hargittai I (ed) Quasicrystals, networks, and molecules of fivefold symmetry. VCH Publishers, New York, pp 1–18
Mackay AL (2002) Generalized crystallography. Struct Chem 13:215–220
Hargittai I (1997) Quasicrystals discovery: a personal account. Chem Intell 3:26–34
Hargittai I (2011) Dan Shechtman’s quasicrystal discovery in perspective. Isr J Chem 51:1145–1148
Hargittai I (ed) (1992) Fivefold symmetry. World Scientific, Singapore, pp xv, 97, 193, 200
Hargittai I (2011) “There is no such animal (אין חיה כזו)”—lessons of a discovery. Struct Chem 22:745–748
Hargittai I (2011) Stubbornness: “impossible” matter. In: Drive and curiosity: what fuels the passion for science. Prometheus Books, Amherst, pp 155–172
Hargittai I, Hargittai M (2000) In our own image: personal symmetry in discovery. Kluwer Academic, New York, pp 8, 151–157
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
This paper is dedicated to Alan L. Mackay on the occasion of his 90th birthday.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Gilead, A. The philosophical significance of Alan Mackay’s theoretical discovery of quasicrystals. Struct Chem 28, 249–256 (2017). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11224-016-0742-9
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11224-016-0742-9