The continuously changing magnetic field of the Earth and its constant influence on the vital activity of all living organisms makes studies of magnetobiological effects important and in demand. The effects of weak magnetic fields, especially weak static magnetic fields, on living objects remains inappropriately understudied. The biological effects of weak magnetic fields result from chemical processes involving radicals, radical ions, and paramagnetic particles. As attenuation of the magnetic field is a stress factor for the body and given that the nervous system performs the most important regulatory functions in forming the body’s stress response, this review addresses the influences of weak static magnetic fields on the functioning of the nervous system. Our own and published data are summarized; these indicate that weak static magnetic fields affect key biological processes, such as gene expression, cell proliferation and differentiation, and apoptosis, as well as behavior. Special attention is paid to the therapeutic potential of weak magnetic fields for clinical use in neurological pathologies.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Adair, R. K., “Criticism of Lednev’s mechanism for the influence of weak magnetic fields on biological systems,” Bioelectromagnetics, 13, No. 3, 231–5 (1992).
Adamenko, V. G., Vilenskaya, R. L., Golant, M. B., et al., “Effects of millimeter waves on the indoor air microflora,” Elektron. Tekhn. Ser. 1. Elektron. SVCh, 12, 132–136 (1966).
Astakhova, L. A., Rotov, A. Yu., Kavokin, K. V., et al., “Relationship between the magnetic compass and photoreception in birds: hypotheses and unresolved issues,” Zh. Obsh. Biol, 80, No. 2, 83–94 (2019).
Baker, R. R., Human Navigation and Magnetoreception, Manchester University Press (1989).
Baker, R. R., Mather, J. G., and Kennaugh, J. H., “Magnetic bones in human sinuses,” Nature, 301, 78–80 (1983).
Bauréus Koch, C. L., Sommarin, M., Persson, B. R., et al., “Interaction between weak low frequency magnetic fields and cell membranes,” Bioelectromagnetics, 24, No. 6, 395–402 (2003).
Ben Yakir-Blumkin, M., Loboda, Y., Schächter, L., and Finberg, J. P. M., “Neuroprotective effect of weak static magnetic fields in primary neuronal cultures,” Neuroscience, 278, 313–326 (2014).
Ben Zablah, Y., Zhang, H., Gugustea, R., and Jia, Z., “LIM-kinases in synaptic plasticity, memory, and brain diseases,” Cells, 10, No. 8, 2079 (2021).
Betskii, O. V. and Lebedeva, N. N., “Current concepts of the mechanisms of the impact of low-intensity waves on biological objects,” Millimetr. Volny Biol. Med., 3, No. 24, 5–19 (2001).
Betskii, O. V., and Lebedeva, N. N., “Unusual properties of water in weak electromagnetic fields,” Biomed. Tekhnol. Radioelektron., 1, 37–44 (2003).
Binhi, V. N. and Prato, F. S., “Biological effects of the hypomagnetic field: An analytical review of experiments and theories,” PLoS One, 12, No. 6, e0179340 (2017).
Binhi, V. N. and Rubin, A. B., “Theoretical concepts in magnetobiology after 40 years of research,” Cells, 11, No. 2, 274 (2022).
Binhi, V. N. and Sarimov, R. M., “Zero magnetic field effect observed in human cognitive processes,” Electromagn. Biol. Med., 28, No. 3, 310–315 (2009).
Binhi, V. N., “Interference of ion quantum states within a protein explains weak magnetic field’s effect on biosystems,” Electro. Magnetobiol., 16, 203–214 (1997).
Binhi, V. N., Milyaev, V. A., Sarimov, R. M., and Zarutskii, A. A., “ The influence of electrostatic and zero magnetic fields on he psychophysiological state in humans,” Biomed. Tekhnol. Radioelektron., No. 8–9, 49–57 (2006).
Binhi, V. N., Principles of Electromagnetic Biophysics, Fizmatlit, Moscow (2011).
Blakemore, R. P., “Magnetotactic bacteria,” Science, 190, No. 4212, 377–379 (1975).
Blanchard, J. P. and Blackman, C. F., “Clarification and application of an ion parametric resonance model for magnetic field interactions with biological systems,” Bioelectromagnetics, 15, 217–238 (1994).
Buchachenko, A. L. and Kuznetsov, D. A., “The magnetic isotope effect – the key to the functioning of molecular machines,” Mol. Biol., 40, No. 1, 12–19 (2006).
Buchachenko, A. L., “Magnetically dependent molecular and chemical processes in biochemistry, genetics and medicine,” Usp. Khim., 83, No. 1, 1–12 (2014).
Buchachenko, A. L., Bukhvostov, A. A., Ermakov, K. V., and Kuznetsov, D. A., “A specific role of magnetic isotopes in biological and ecological systems. Physics and biophysics beyond,” Prog. Biophys. Mol. Biol., 155, 1–19 (2020).
Buchachenko, A. L., Kouznetsov, D. A., Breslavskaya, N. N., and Orlova, M. A., “Magnesium isotope effects in enzymatic phosphorylation,” J. Phys. Chem. B, 112, 2548–2556 (2008).
Chakeres, D. W. and de Vocht, F., “Static magnetic field effects on human subjects related to magnetic resonance imaging systems,” Prog. Biophys. Mol. Biol, 87, No. 2–3, 255 (2005).
Chen, Q., Gimple, R. C., Li, G., et al., “LIM kinase 1 acts as a profibrotic mediator in permanent atrial fibrillation patients with valvular heart disease,” J. Biosci., 44, No. 1, 16 (2019).
Deng, S., Liu, S., Mo, X., et al., “Polar drift in the 1990s explained by terrestrial water storage changes,” Geophys. Res. Lett., 48, No. 7, e2020GL092114 (2021).
Dileone, M., Carrasco-López, M. C., Segundo-Rodriguez, J. C., et al., “Dopamine-dependent changes of cortical excitability induced by transcranial static magnetic field stimulation in Parkinson’s disease,” Sci. Rep., 7, No. 1, 4329 (2017).
Dinčić, M., Krstić, D. Z., Čolović, M. B., et al., “Modulation of rat synaptosomal ATPases and acetylcholinesterase activities induced by chronic exposure to the static magnetic field,” Int. J. Radiat. Biol., 94, No. 11, 1062–1071 (2018).
Ding, H. M., Wang, X., Mo, W. C., et al., “Hypomagnetic fields cause anxiety in adult male mice,” Bioelectromagnetics, 40, No. 1, 27–32 (2019).
Dreyer, D., Frost, B., Mouritsen, H., et al., “The Earth’s magnetic field and visual landmarks steer migratory flight behaviour in the nocturnal Australian Bogong moth,” Curr. Biol., 28, No. 13, 2160–2166.e5 (2018).
Driessen, S., Bodewein, L., Dechent, D., et al., “Biological and health-related effects of weak static magnetic fields (1 mT) in humans and vertebrates: A systematic review,” PLoS One, 15, No. 6, e0230038 (2020).
Fleischmann, P. N., Grob, R., Muller, V. L., et al., “The geomagnetic field is a compass cue in Cataglyphis ant navigation,” Curr. Biol., 28, No. 9, 1440–1444 (2018).
Foley, L. E., Gegear, R. J., and Reppert, S. M., “Human cryptochrome exhibits light-dependent magnetosensitivity,” Nat. Commun., 2,356 (2011).
Furukawa, S., Nagamatsu, A., Nenoi, M., et al., “Space radiation biology for ‘living in space,’” Biomed. Res. Int., 2020, 4703286 (2020).
Gegear, R. J., Casselman, A., Waddell, S., and Reppert, S. M., “Cryptochrome mediates light-dependent magnetosensitivity in Drosophila,” Nature, 454, 1014–1018 (2008).
Greenebaum, B. and Barnes, F. (eds.), Biological and Medical Aspects of Electromagnetic Fields, CRC Press, Boca Raton (2019), 4th ed.
Harrison, C. S., Luo, J. Y., Putman, N. F., et al., “Identifying global favourable habitat for early juvenile loggerhead sea turtles,” J. R. Soc. Interface, 18, No. 175, 20200799 (2021).
Hsu, C. Y., and Weng, Y. T., “Long-term inhibition of ferritin2 synthesis in trophocytes and oenocytes by ferritin2 double-stranded RNA ingestion to investigate the mechanisms of magnetoreception in honey bees (Apis mellifera),” PLoS One, 16, No. 8, e0256341 (2021).
Ishikawa, T., Matsumoto, A., Kato, T., Jr., et al., “DCRY is a Drosophila photoreceptor protein implicated in light entrainment of circadian rhythm,” Genes Cells, 4, No. 1, 57–65 (1999).
Ivanova, P. N., Surma, S. V., Shchegolev, B. F., et al., “Influence of a weak static magnetic field on the development of rat tissue organotypic cultures,” Dokl. Akad. Nauk, 481, No. 4, 459–461 (2018).
Jalilian, H., Najafi, K., Reza, M., et al., “Assessment of static and extremely low-frequency magnetic fields in the electric-powered trains,” Int. J. Occupat. Hyg., 9, No. 2, 105–112 (2017).
Kaminskaya, A. N., Nikitina, E. A., Payalina, T. L., et al., “Effect of LIMK1 isoform ratio on courtship behavior in Drosophila melanogaster: a complex approach,” Ekol. Genetika, 9, No. 4, 3–14 (2011).
Karabetsos, E., Kalampaliki, E., and Koutounidis, D., “Testing hybrid technology cars: Static and extremely low-frequency magnetic field measurements,” IEEE Vehic. Technol. Mag., 9, No. 4, 34–39 (2014).
Karki, N., Vergish, S., and Zoltovski, B. D., “Cryptochromes: photochemical and structural insight into magnetoreception,” Protein Sci., 30, No. 8, 1521–1534 (2021).
Kholodov, Yu. A., Kozlov, A. N., and Gorbach, A. M., The Magnetic Fields of Biological Objects, Nauka, Moscow (1987).
Kirshvink, J., Jones, D., and MacFadden, B. (eds.), Magnetite Biomineralization and Magnetoreception in Organisms [Russian translation], Mir, Moscow (1989).
Kislovskii, L. D., The Universe in a Drop of Water, Belye Al’vy, Moscow (2005).
Lednev, V. V., “Possible mechanism for the influence of weak magnetic fields on biological systems,” Bioelectromagnetics, 12, 71–75 (1991).
Levina, A. S., Zakharov, G. A., Shiryaeva, N. V., and Vaido, A. I., “Comparative characteristics of the behavior of rats of two strains with different thresholds of nervous system arousability in a model of spatial learning in the Morris water maze,” Zh. Vyssh. Nerv. Deyat., 68, No. 3, 366–377 (2018).
Lin, W., Kirschvink, J. L., Paterson, G. A., Bazylinski, D. A., and Pan, Y., “On the origin of microbial magnetoreception,” Natl. Sci. Rev., 7, No. 2, 472–479 (2020).
Lindecke, O., Holland, R. A., Pētersons, G., and Voigt, C. C., “Corneal sensitivity is required for orientation in free-flying migratory bats,” Commun. Biol., 4, No. 1, 522 (2021).
Lopatina, N. G., Zachepilo, T. G., Dyuzhikova, N. A., et al., “Effects of changes in electromagnetic fields on the feeding and cognitive activity of the honey bee,” Integr. Fiziol., 1, No. 3, 231–241 (2020).
Lowenstam, H. A., “Magnetite in denticle capping in recent chitons (Polyplacophora),” Geol. Soc. Am. Bull., 73, No. 4, 435–438 (1962).
Lozano-Soto, E., Soto-León, V., Sabbarese, S., et al., “Transcranial static magnetic field stimulation (tSMS) of the visual cortex decreases experimental photophobia,” Cephalalgia, 38, No. 8, 1493–1497 (2018).
Malewski, S., Begall, S., and Burda, H., “Learned and spontaneous magnetosensitive behaviour in the Roborovski hamster (Phodopus roborovskii),” Ethology, 28, No. 6, 423–431 (2018).
Mamon, L. A., Bondarenko, L. V., Tret’yakova, I. V., et al., “Consequences of cellular stress in impaired synthesis of heat shock proteins in Drosophila,” Vestn. St. Peters. Gos. Univ., 24, No. 4, 94–107 (1999).
McCausland, H. C. and Komeili, A., “Magnetic genes: Studying the genetics of biomineralization in magnetotactic bacteria,” PLoS Genetics, 16, No. 2, e1008499 (2020).
Medvedeva, A. V., Molotkov, D. A., Nikitina, E. A., et al., “Regulation of genetic and cytogenetic processes by the actin remodeling signaling cascade: structure of the LIMK1 gene, chromosome architecture, and learning ability in spontaneous and mutant variants of the Drosophila agnostic locus,” Genetika, 44, No. 6, 669–681 (2008).
Medvedeva, A. V., Rebrova, A. V., Zalomaeva, E. S., et al., “The role of LIMK1 in dopamine and serotonin neurons in genome stability, learning, and memory in Drosophila during stress responses to geomagnetic field weakening,” Zh. Evol. Biokhim. Fiziol., 58, No. 1, 34–42 (2022).
Mo, W. C., Fu, J. P., Ding, H. M., et al., “Hypomagnetic field alters circadian rhythm and increases algesia in adult male mice,” Prog. Biochem. Biophys., 42, 639–646 (2015).
Mo, W. C., Zhang, Z. J., Wang, D. L., et al., “Shielding of the geomagnetic field alters actin assembly and inhibits cell motility in human neuroblastoma cells,” Sci. Rep., 6, 22624 (2016).
Newton, K. C. and Kajiura, S. M., “Magnetic field discrimination, learning, and memory in the yellow stingray (Urobatis jamaicensis),” Anim. Cogn., 20, No. 4, 603–614 (2017).
Nikitina, E. A., Medvedeva, A. V., Gerasimenko, M. S., et al., “Attenuation of the Earth’;s magnetic field: effects on genome transcriptional activity, learning, and memory in Drosophila melanogaster,” Zh. Vyssh. Nerv. Deyat., 67, No. 2, 246–256 (2017).
Novikov, S. M., Studies of the Effects of Attenuated Magnetic Fields on Nerve Cell Functioning: PhD Disserat. Abstr., 01.04.11, Moscow (2007).
Novikov, V. V., Yablokova, E. V., and Fesenko, E. E., “The role of water in the effect of weak combined magnetic fields on production of reactive oxygen species (ROS) by neutrophils,” Appl. Sci, 10, 3326 (2020).
Okano, H., “Effects of static magnetic fields in biology: role of free radicals,” Front. Biosci., 13, 6106–25 (2008).
Patent No. 2006121842/28(023712), A Composite Material for Protection against Electromagnetic Radiation, Russian patent No. 2324989, Kuznetsov, P. A., Farmakovskii, B. V., Askinazi, A. Yu., et al., (2008).
Patent No. 2014125121/14, May 20, 2015, A Means for the Treatment of Trigeminal Neuralgia and Neuritis, Russian Patent No. 2551228, Lazarenko, N. N., Gerasimenko, M. Yu., Amkhadova, M. A., et al., (2015).
Presman, A. S., Electromagnetic Fields and Living Nature, Nauka, Moscow (1968).
Qin, S., Yin, H., Yang, C., et al., “A magnetic protein biocompass,” Nat. Mater., 15, 217–226 (2016).
Ritz, T., Adem, S., and Schulten, K., “A model for photoreceptor-based magnetoreception in birds,” Biophys. J., 78, No. 2, 707–718 (2000).
Roulette, J., “Russian film crew wraps space station shoot and returns to Earth,” The New York Times, October 17. 2021.
Saliev, T., Begimbetova, D., Masoud, A.-R., and Matkarimov, B., “Biological effects of non-ionizing electromagnetic fields: Two sides of a coin,” Prog. Biophys. Mol. Biol., 141, 25–36 (2018).
Sandyk, R., “Alzheimer’s disease: improvement of visual memory and visuoconstructive performance by treatment with picotesla range magnetic fields,” Int. J. Neurosci., 76, No. 3–4, 185–225 (1994).
Sandyk, R., “Long term beneficial effects of weak electromagnetic fields in multiple sclerosis,” Int. J. Neurosci., 83, No. 1–2, 45–57 (1995).
Sandyk, R., “The influence of the pineal gland on migraine and cluster headaches and effects of treatment with picoTesla magnetic fields,” Int. J. Neurosci., 67, No. 1–4, 145–171 (1992).
Sandyk, R., Anninos, P. A., Tsagas, N., and Derpapas, K., “Magnetic fields in the treatment of Parkinson’s disease,” Int. J. Neurosci., 63, No. 1–2, 141–150 (1992).
Sarimov, R. M., Binhi, V. N., and Milyaev, V. A., “Influence of geomagnetic field compensations on human cognitive processes,” Biofizika, 53, No. 5, 856–866 (2008).
Savvateeva-Popova, E. V., Nikitina, E. A., and Medvedeva, A. V., “From neurogenetics to neuroepigenetics,” Genetika, 51, No. 5, 1–12 (2015).
Savvateeva-Popova, E. V., Zhuravlev, A. V., Brázda, V., et al., “Drosophila model for the analysis of genesis of LIM-kinase 1-dependent Williams-Beuren syndrome cognitive phenotypes: INDELs, transposable elements of the Tc1/Mariner superfamily and microRNAs,” Front. Genet., 8, 123 (2017).
Scanlan, M. M., Putman, N. F., Pollock, A. M., and Noakes, D. L. G., “Magnetic map in nonanadromous Atlantic salmon,” Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA, 115, No. 43, 10995–10999 (2018).
Schultheiss-Grassi, P. P., and Dobson, J., “Magnetic analysis of human brain tissue,” Biometals, 12, No. 1, 67–72 (1999).
Shakhparonov, V. V. and Ogurtsov, S. V., “Marsh frogs, Pelophylax ridibundus, determine migratory direction by magnetic field,” J. Comp. Physiol. A, 203, No. 1, 35–43 (2017).
Shiryaeva, N. V., Vaido, A. I., Pavlova, M. B., et al., “Effects of electromagnetic radiation on orientational-exploratory activity and cognitive functions in rats with contrasting nervous system arousability,” Integr. Fiziol., 1, No. 2, 126–136 (2020).
Smith, K. A., Waypa, G. B., and Schumacker, P. T., “Redox signaling during hypoxia in mammalian cells,” Redox Biol., 13, 228–234 (2017).
Surma, S., Stefanov, V., and Shchegolev, B., “Relief of peripheral neurogenic chronic pain by exposure to weak magnetic field,” J. Phys. Med. Rehabil. Res., 2, No. 1, 13–19 (2020).
Taoka, A., Kiyokawa, A., Uesugi, C., et al., “Tethered magnets are the key to magnetotaxis: direct observations of Magnetospirillum magneticum AMB-1 show that MamK distributes magnetosome organelles equally to daughter cells,” mBio, 8, No. 4, e00679-17 (2017).
Temur’yants, N. A., Vladimirskii, B. M., and Tishkin, O. G., Microwave Electromagnetic Signals in the Biological World, Nauk. Dumka, Kiev (1992).
Tenuzzo, B., Chionna, A., Panzarini, E., et al., “Biological effects of 6 mT static magnetic fields: a comparative study in different cell types,” Bioelectromagnetics, 27, 560–577 (2006).
Ukhtomskii, A. A., Collected Works, Vol. 1, Studies of Dominant, Leningrad State University, Leningrad (1950).
Vadalà, M., Vallelunga, A., Palmieri, L., et al., “Mechanisms and therapeutic applications of electromagnetic therapy in Parkinson’s disease,” Behav. Brain Funct., 11, 26 (2015).
Van Huizen, A. V., Morton, J. M., Kinsey, L. J., et al., “Weak magnetic fields alter stem cell-mediated growth,” Sci. Adv., 5, No. 1, eaau7201 (2019).
Vasilieva, S. A., Tokmacheva, E. V., Medvedeva, A. V., et al., “The role of parental origin of chromosomes in the instability of the somatic genome in Drosophila brain cells and memory trace formation in norm and stress,” Cell Tiss. Biol., 14, No. 3, 178–189 (2020).
Vernadskii, V. I., The Biosphere and Noosphere, Rol’f, Could (2002).
Vidotto, A. A., “The evolution of the solar wind,” Living Rev. Sol. Phys., 18, No. 1, 3 (2021).
Viudes-Sarrion, N., Velasco, E., Delicado-Miralles, M., and Lillo-Navarro, C., “Static magnetic stimulation in the central nervous system: a systematic review,” Neurol. Sci., 42, No. 5, 1733–1749 (2021).
Voeikov, V. L., Fundamental Role of Water in Bioenergetics. Biophotonic and Coherent Systems in Biology, Springer, New York (2006), pp. 89–104.
Walcott, C., Gould, J. L., and Kirschvink, J. L., “Pigeons have magnets,” Science, 205, No. 4410, 1027–1029 (1979).
Wan, G. J., Jiang, S. L., Zhang, M., et al., “Geomagnetic field absence reduces adult body weight of amigratory insect by disrupting feeding behavior and appetite regulation,” Insect Sci., 28, 251–260 (2021).
Wang, C. X., Hilburn, I. A., Wu, D. A., et al., “Transduction of the geomagnetic field as evidenced from alpha-band activity in the human brain,” eNeuro, 6, No. 2, ENEURO.0483-18.2019 (2019).
Wang, Z., Che, P. L., Du, J., et al., “Static magnetic field exposure reproduces cellular effects of the Parkinson’s disease drug candidate ZM241385,” PLoS One, 5, No. 11, e13883 (2010).
Wiltschko, R. and Wiltschko, W., “Magnetoreception in birds,” J. R. Soc. Interface, 16, No. 158, 20190295 (2019).
Wiltschko, R. and Wiltschko, W., Magnetic Orientation in Animals, Springer (1995).
Xue, X., Ali, Y. F., Luo, W., et al., “Biological effects of space hypomagnetic environment on circadian rhythm,” Front. Physiol., 12, 643943 (2021).
Yost, M. G. and Liburdy, R. P., “Time-varying and static magnetic fields act in combination to alter calcium signal transduction in the lymphocyte,” FEBS Lett., 296, No. 2, 117–122 (1992).
Zalomaeva, E. S., Ivanova, P. N., Chalisova, N. I., et al., “Effects of a weak static magnetic field and oligopeptides on cell proliferation and cognitive functions in organisms of various species,” Zh. Tekhn. Fiz., 90, No. 10, 1656–1662 (2020).
Zamoshchina, T. A., Krivova, N. A., Khodanovich, M. Yu., et al., “Influence of simulation of the hypomagnetic conditions of deep space flight on the rhythmic organization of behavioral activity in rats,” Aviakosm. Ekolog. Med., 46, No. 1, 17–23 (2012).
Zhadin, M. N., “Review of Russian literature on biological action of DC and low-frequency AC magnetic fields,” Bioelectromagnetics, 22, 27–45 (2001).
Zhang, B. and Tian, L., “Reactive oxygen species: Potential regulatory molecules in response to hypomagnetic field exposure,” Bioelectromagnetics, 41, No. 8, 573–580 (2020).
Zhang, B., Lu, H., Xi, W., et al., “Exposure to hypomagnetic field space for multiple generations causes amnesia in Drosophila melanogaster,” Neurosci. Lett., 371, 190–195 (2004).
Zhang, B., Wang, L., Zhan, A., et al., “Long-term exposure to a hypomagnetic field attenuates adult hippocampal neurogenesis and cognition,” Nat. Commun., 12, 1174 (2021a).
Zhang, H. T., Zhang, Z. J., Mo, W. C., et al., “Shielding of the geomagnetic field reduces hydrogen peroxide production in human neuroblastoma cell and inhibits the activity of CuZn superoxide dismutase,” Protein Cell, 8, 527–537 (2017).
Zhang, X., Yarema, K. J., and Xu, A., Biological Effects of Static Magnetic Fields, Springer Nature (2019), 1st ed.
Zhang, Z., Xue, Y., Yang, J., et al., “Biological effects of hypomagnetic field: Ground-based data for space exploration,” Bioelectromagnetics, 42, 516–531 (2021b).
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Translated from Zhurnal Vysshei Nervnoi Deyatel’nosti imeni I. P. Pavlova, Vol. 72, No. 6, pp. 783–799, November–December, 2022.
Rights and permissions
Springer Nature or its licensor (e.g. a society or other partner) holds exclusive rights to this article under a publishing agreement with the author(s) or other rightsholder(s); author self-archiving of the accepted manuscript version of this article is solely governed by the terms of such publishing agreement and applicable law.
About this article
Cite this article
Nikitina, E.A., Vasileva, S.A., Shchegolev, B.F. et al. Weak Static Magnetic Field: Actions on the Nervous System. Neurosci Behav Physi 53, 542–553 (2023). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11055-023-01453-1
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11055-023-01453-1