Abstract
A common issue with many commercial rehabilitative exoskeletons and orthoses are that they can be prohibitively expensive for an average individual to afford without additional financial support. Due to this a user may have limited to the usage of such devices within set rehabilitation sessions as opposed to a continual usage. The purpose of this review is therefore to find which actuator implementations would be most suitable for a simplistic, low-cost powered orthoses capable of assisting those with pathologic gait disorders by collating literature from Web of Science, Scopus, and Grey Literature. In this systematic review paper 127 papers were selected from these databases via the PRISMA guidelines, with the financial costs of 25 actuators discovered with 11 distinct actuator groups identified. The review paper will consider a variety of actuator implementations used in existing lower-limb exoskeletons that are specifically designed for the purpose of rehabilitating or aiding those with conditions inhibiting natural movement abilities, such as electric motors, hydraulics, pneumatics, cable-driven actuators, and compliant actuators. Key attributes such as technical simplicity, financial cost, power efficiency, size limitations, accuracy, and reliability are compared for all actuator groups. Statistical findings show that rotary electric motors (which are the most common actuator type within collated literature) and compliant actuators (such as elastic and springs) would be the most suitable actuators for a low-cost implementation. From these results, a possible actuator design will be proposed making use of both rotary electric motors and compliant actuators.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Explore related subjects
Find the latest articles, discoveries, and news in related topics.Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
Yagn, N: "Apparatus for Walking, Running, Jumping". United States of America Patent 420,179, (1890)
Vukobratovic, M., Hristic, D., Stojiljkovic, Z.: Development of active anthropomorphic exoskeletons. Med. Biol. Eng. 12(1), 66–80 (1974)
Specialty Materials Handling Products Operation General Electric Company, Hardiman I Prototype Project. (1968)
Zoss, A., Kazerooni, H. Chu, A.: "On the Mechanical Design of the Berkeley Lower Extremity Exoskeleton (BLEEX)," in IEEE/RSJ International Conference on Intelligent Robotics, pp. 3465–3472. (2005)
Sankai, Y.:"HAL: Hybrid Assistive Limb based on Cybernics," in Springer Tracts in Advanced Robotics, pp. 25–34. (2007)
Stoye, G., Zaranko, B.: "UK Health Spending," The Institute for Fiscal Studies. (2018)
Jones, A.: Interviewee, Ectron EksoNR cost. [Interview]. (2021)
Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services: "National Health Expenditures 2019 Highlights," Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services. (2019)
Gonzalez, A., Garcia, L., Kilby, J., McNair, P.: Robotic Devices for Paediatric rehabilitation: a review of design features. Biomed. Eng. Online 20(89), 1–33 (2021)
Slucock, T.:"A Systematic Review of Lower-Cost Actuator Implementations for Lower-Limb Exoskeletons - Addendums". [Online]. Available: https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1VbrkzbnWZbbhKiqB3QxtUqZAcasgIJnX?usp=sharing. (2021). Accessed 17 November 2021
Neuhaus, P. D., Noorden, J. H., Craig, T. J., Torres T., Kirschbaum, J., Pratt, J. E.: "Design and Evaluation of Mina a Robotic Orthosis for Paraplegics," in IEEE International Conference of Rehabilitation Robotics. (2011)
Moog: "BN34 Specifications," [Online]. Available: https://www.moog.com/content/dam/moog/literature/MCG/BN34-BrushlessDCMotorsDtS.pdf. Accessed 22 November 2021
Brundu, A.: Interviewee, Moog BN34–25EU-02 Servo Motor Costs. [Interview]. (2021)
Marian, P., Danut, I., Nirvana, P., Dorin, P.: "Engineered Devices to Support Stroke Rehabilitation," in 19th International Conference on Control Systems and Computer Science, pp. 289–295. (2013)
Omron: "SGDH Sigma-II servo Drive," [Online]. Available: http://www.farnell.com/datasheets/2923102.pdf. Accessed 2021 November 21
Omron: "Sigma-II rotary servo motors," [Online]. Available: https://assets.omron.eu/downloads/datasheet/en/v4/i47e_sgm_h-_sigma-ii_rotary_servo_motors_datasheet_en.pdf. Accessed 21 November 2021
Lerner, Z.F., Gasparri, G.M., Bair, M.O., Lawson, J.L., Luque, J., Harvey, T.A., Lerner, A.T.: An Untethered Ankle Exoskeleton Improves Walking Economy in a Pilt Study of Individuals With Cerebral Palsy. IEEE Trans. Neural Syst. Rehabil. Eng. 26(10), 1985–1993 (2018)
Maxon: "EC-4pole 22 Ø22 mm, brushless, 90 Watt | High Power," Maxon, [Online]. Available: https://www.maxongroup.com/maxon/view/product/323218. Accessed 21 November 2021
Baud, R., Ortlieb, A., Oliver, J., Bouri, M.: "HiBSO hip exoskeleton: Toward a wearable and autonomous design," in MESROB, pp. 185–195. (2016)
Maxon: "RE 30 Ø30 mm, Graphite Brushes, 60 Watt," [Online]. Available: https://www.maxongroup.com/medias/sys_master/root/8881622155294/EN-21-148.pdf. Accessed 21 November 2021
Maxon: "Screw Drive GP 22 S Ø22 mm, Metric spindle, M6 x 1," [Online]. Available: https://www.maxongroup.com/maxon/view/product/363826. Accessed 08 December 2021
Vouga, T., Baud, R., Fasola, J., Bouri, M., Bleuler, H.: "TWIICE - A Lightweight Lower-Limb Exoskeleton for Complete Paraplegics," in IEEE International Conference on Rehabilitaiton Robotics, pp, 1639–1645. (2017)
Sonceboz: "Brushless - DC Motors 5612," [Online]. Available: https://pdf.directindustry.com/pdf/sonceboz/brushless-dc-motors-5612/14206-588571.html. Accessed 22 November 2021
Yang,W., Yang, C.-J., Wei, Q.-X.: "Design of an Anthropomorphic Lower Extremity Exoskeleton with Compatible Joints," in IEEE International Conference on Robotics and Biomimetics, pp. 1374–1379. (2014)
Maxon; "EC 90 flat Ø90 mm, brushless, 90 Watt, with Hall sensors," [Online]. Available: https://www.maxongroup.com/maxon/view/product/323772. Accessed 21 November 2021
Zhang, T., Tran, M., Huang, H.: Design and Experimental Verification of Hip Exoskeleton With Balance Capacities for Walking Assistance. IEEE/ASME Trans. Mechatron. 23(1), 274–285 (2018)
Minhyung, L., Kim, J., Hyung, S., Lee, J., Seo, K., Park, Y.J., Cho, J., Choi, B.-K., Shim, Y., Choi, H.: A Compact Ankle Exoskeleton With a Multiaxis Parallel Linkage Mechanism. IEEE/ASME Trans. Mechatron. 26(1), 191–202 (2021)
Maxon: "DCX 32 L Ø32 mm, Graphite Brushes, ball bearings," [Online]. Available: https://www.maxongroup.com/maxon/view/product/motor/dcmotor/DCX/DCX32/DCX32L01GBKL470. Accessed 22 November 2021
Taylor, G.: Interviewee, ABSSAC SG0504 Costs. [Interview]. (2021)
Walsh, C. J., Paluska, D., Pasch, K., Grand, W., Valiente, A., Herr, H.: "Development of a lightweight, underactuated exoskeleton for load-carrying augmentation," in IEEE International Conference on Robotics and Automation, pp. 3485–3491 (2006)
Maxon: "RE 40 Ø40 mm, Graphite Brushes, 150 Watt," [Online]. Available: https://www.maxongroup.com/maxon/view/product/motor/dcmotor/re/re40/148866. Accessed 21 November 2021
Colombo, G., Jorg, M., Schrier, R., Dietz, V.: Treadmill training of paraplegic patinets using a robotic orthosis. J. Rehabil. Res. Dev. 37(6), 693–700 (2000)
Michimizos, K. P., Krebs, H. I.: "Assist-as-needed in Lower Extremity Robotic Therapy for Children with Cerebral Palsy," in IEEE International Conference on Biomedical Robotics and Biomechatronics, pp. 1081–1086 (2012)
"EC-4pole 22 Ø22 mm, brushless, 90 Watt | High Power," [Online]. Available: https://www.maxongroup.com/maxon/view/product/327739. Accessed 21 November 2021
Kardan, I., Akbarzadeh, A.: Robust output feedback assistive control of a compliantly actuated knee exoskeleton. Robot. Auton. Syst. 98, 15–29 (2017)
Ortlieb, A., Bouri, M., Baud, R., Bleuler, H.:"An Assistive Lower Limb Exoskeleton for People with Neurological Gait Disorders," in International Conference on Rehabiliation Robotics, pp. 441–446 (2017)
Maxon: "Planetary Gearhead GP 32 HP Ø32 mm, 4.0 - 8.0 Nm, Metal Version, High Power | High Power," [Online]. Available: https://www.maxongroup.com/maxon/view/product/326671. Accessed 22 November 2021
Washabaugh, E.P., Claflin, E.S., Gillespie, R.B., Krishnan, C.: A Novel Application of Eddy Current Braking for Functional Strength Training During Gait. Ann. Biomed. Eng. 44(9), 2760–2773 (2016)
The Robot Marketplace: "Banebots Gearboxes," [Online]. Available: http://www.robotcombat.com/products/0-P60K-55-0004.html. Accessed 2 December 2021
Anonymous-Company: Interviewee, Strain Wave Gear Example Price. [Interview]. (2021)
He, Y., Li, N., Wang, C., Xia, L.-Q., Yong, X., Wu, X.-Y.: Development of a novel autonomous lower extremity exoskeleton robot for walking assistance. Front. Inf. Technol. Electron. Eng. 30, 318–329 (2019)
Felix, P., Figueiredo, J., Santos, C. P., Moreno, J. C.: "Powered Knee Orthosis for Human Gait Rehabilitation: First Advances," in IEEE 5th Portuguese Meeting on Bioengineering, pp. 1–4. (2017)
Park, J.-H., Lee, J.-S., Shin, J.-S., Cho, B.-K.: "Design of a Lower Limb Exoskeleotn Including Roll Actuation to Assist Walking and Standing Up," in IEEE-RAS 15th International Conference on Humanoid Robotics (Humanoids), pp. 359–364. (2015)
Maxon: "Encoder ENC 16 RIO, 16384 counts per turn, 3-channel, with RS 422 line driver," [Online]. Available: https://www.maxongroup.com/maxon/view/product/575829. Accessed 2 December 2021
RLS: " RMB28 Rotary Magnetic Encoder Module," [Online]. Available: https://www.rls.si/eng/rmb28-rotary-magnetic-module?partNumbers=RMB28IC10BS11. Accessed 2 December 2021
Mouser Electronics: "HEDL-5640#A13," [Online]. Available: https://www.mouser.co.uk/ProductDetail/Broadcom-Limited/HEDL-5640A13?qs=sGAEpiMZZMuGN2ig0xo6GwpPTpKC14je. Accessed 2 December 2021
Emken, J.L., Wynne, J.H., Harkema, S.J., Reinkensmeyer, D.J.: A Robotic Device for Manipulating Human Stepping. IEEE Trans. Rob. 22(1), 185–189 (2006)
RS: "Models HSR-A and HSR-AM, Models HSR-LA and HSR-LAM," [Online]. Available: https://docs.rs-online.com/1cbb/0900766b80f448f1.pdf. Accessed 13 January 2022
Pietrusinski, M., Unluhisarcikli, O., Cajigas, I., Bonato, P.: "Design of Human - Machine Interface and Altering of Pelvic Obliquity with RGR Trainer," in IEEE International Conference on Rehabilitation Robotics, pp. 1–6. (2011)
KOMP-ACT: "KLM-40–0F4 KOMP-ACT LINEAR MOTOR," [Online]. Available: https://komp-act.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/06/KLM-40-0F4.pdf. Accessed 16 December 2021
Saito, Y., Kikuchi, H., Negoto, H., Oshima, T., Haneyoshi, T., Hatoyama-cho, I., Saitama, H.-G.: "Development of externally powered lower limb orthosis with bilateral-servo actuator," in 9th International Conference on Rehabilitation Robotics, pp. 394–399. (2005)
Zoss, A.B., Kazerooni, H., Chu, A.: Biomechanical Design of the Berkeley Lower Extremity Exoskeleton (BLEEX). IEEE/ASME Trans. Mechatron. 11(2), 128–138 (2006)
Kaminaga, H., Amari, T., Niwa, Y., Nakamura, Y.: "Development of knee power assist using backdrivable electro-hydrostatic actuator," in IEEE/RSJ International Conference on Intelligent Robots and Systems, pp. 5517–5524. (2010)
Kim, H.G., Lee, J.W., Jang, J., Park, S., HC: Design of an Exoskeleton with minimized energy consumption based on using elastic and dissipative elements. Int. J. Control Autom Syst 13(2), 463–474 (2015)
Sun, M., Ouyang, X., Mattila, J., Yang, H., Hou, G.: One Novel Hydraulic Actuating System for the Lower-Body Exoskeleton. Chin. J. Mech. Eng. 34(1), 1–10 (2021)
Staman, K., Vaele, A.J., van der Kooij, H.: Design, control and evaluation of the Electro-Hydrostatic Actuator, PREHydrA, for Gait Restoration Exoskeleton Technology. IEEE Trans. Med. Robot. Bionics 3(1), 156–165 (2021)
Kollmorgen: "AKM Servo Motor Selection Guide," [Online]. Available: https://cdn.kyklo.co/assets/ W1siZiIsIjIwMjEvMDMvMjEvMTIvNTUvMzcvNzY1Mjg2NGItNjIzNi00OWFjLWIyYzMtMGY0OTRmYmU3ZjZkL0tvbGxtb3JnZW4lMjAtJTIwQUtNJTIwc2VyaWVzJTIwLSUyMENhdGFsb2clMjAyMDE3LnBkZiJdXQ?sha=a34ad8186ed4c2fa. Accessed 8 December 2021
Minuteman | Empire: "9/16” Heavy Duty, Double Acting, Clevis Mount, 6," [Online]. Available: https://shop.maseas.com/9-16-heavy-duty-double-acting-clevis-mount-6-h9c-6d.html. Accessed 8 December 2021
iAutomation: "AKM22C-BNBNC-00," [Online]. Available: https://shop.i-automation.com/products/AKM22C-BNBNC-00. Accessed 8 December 2021
Wang, B., Liang, Y., Xu, D., Wang, Z., Ji, J.: Design on Electrohydraulic servo driving system with walking assisting control for lower limb exoskeleton robot. Int J Advanced Robotic Systems 18(1), 1–17 (2021)
H. Wu, A. Kitagawa, H. Tsukagoshi and C. Liu, "Development of a Novel Pneumatic Power Assisted Lower Limb for Outdoor Walking by the Use of a Portable Pneumatic Power Source," in 16th IEEE International Conference on Control Applications, pp. 1291–1296, 2007.
Fujikura Composites: "BF Cylinder," [Online]. Available: https://www.fujikura-control.com/english/product_info/index.php/search?cell003=Air+Cylinders&cell004=BF+cylinder&label=1. Accessed 23 November 2021
Sato, M., Yagi, E.: "A Study on Power Assist Suit Using Pneumatic Actuators Based on Calculated Retaining Torques for Lift-Up Motion," in SICE Annual Conference, pp. 628–632. (2011)
RS: "RS PRO Pneumatic Profile Cylinder 32mm Bore, 200mm Stroke, CDEM Series, Double Acting," [Online]. Available: https://uk.rs-online.com/web/p/pneumatic-piston-rod-cylinders/4802169. Accessed 1 December 2021
Li, Y. D., Hsiao-Wekscler, E. T.: "Gait Mode Recognition and Control for a Portable-Powered Ankle Foot Orthosis," in IEEE International Conference on Rehabilitation Robotics, pp. 1–8. (2013)
Parker: "Pneumatic Rotary Actuators," [Online]. Available: https://www.parker.com/Literature/Pneumatics%20Division%20Europe/PDE-Documents/Cylinders/Parker_Pneumatic_PRO-PRN_Pneumatic_Rotary_Actuators_PDE2502TCUK.pdf. Accessed 8 December 2021
Tidyco: "PRN30D-90–45," [Online]. Available: https://tidyco.co.uk/store/parker-hannifin/parker-hannifin-detail.asp?ProductID=PRN30D-90-45. Accessed 21 November 2021
Yamada, Y., Endo, G., Fukushima, E.F.: Pneumatic walking assistive deice for use over long period. Adv. Robot. 28(18), 1253–1264 (2014)
Zheng, H., Shen, T., Afsar, M. R., Kang, I., Young, A. J., Shen, X.: "A Semi-Wearable Robotic Device for Sit-to-Stand Assistance," in IEEE 16th International Conference on Rehabilitation Robotics, pp. 204–209. (2019)
Bimba: "Original Line® Air Cylinder," [Online]. Available: https://www.bimba.com/en/detail/original-line-cylinder?rp=173.5-DPY. Accessed 21 November 2021
Yamamoto, S., Miyoshi, T., Komeda, T., Hiramatsu, K., Nakazawa, K., Akai, M.: "Development of Pneumatic Gait Assist System," in IEEE/ICME International Conference on Coplex Medical Engineering, pp. 1337–1340. (2007)
Chandrapal, M., Chen, X.: "Intelligent Active Assistive and Resistive Orthotic Device for Knee Rehabilitation," in IEEE International Conference on Control and Automation, pp. 1880–1885. (2009)
Park, Y.-L., Chen, B.-R., Young, D., Stirling, L., Wood, R. J., Goldfield, E., Nagpal, R.: "Bio-inspired Active Soft Orthotic Device for Ankle Foot Pathologies," in IEEE/RSJ International Conference on Intelligent Robots and Systems, pp. 4488–4495. (2011)
FESTO: "Fluidic muscle DMSP," [Online]. Available: https://www.festo.com/media/pim/555/D15000100140555.PDF?siteUid=fox_gb&siteName=Festo+GB. Accessed 16 December 2021
FESTO: "Fluidic muscle," [Online]. Available: https://www.festo.com/gb/en/a/download-document/datasheet/541403/?CallerID=QuickSearch. Accessed 16 December 2021
Sasaki, D., Noritsugu, T., Takaiwa, M.: "Development of Pneumatic Lower Limb Power Assist Wear without Exoskeleton," in IEEE/RSJ International Conference on Intelligent Robots and Systems, pp. 1239–1244. (2012)
Sasaki, D., Noritsugu, T., Takaiwa, M.: "Development of Pneumatic Lower Limb Power Assist Wear driven with Wearable Air Supply System," in IEEE/RSJ International Conference on Intelligent Robots and Systems, pp. 4440–4445. (2013)
Chung, J., Heimgartner, R., O'Neill, C. T., Phipps, N. S., Walsh, C. J.: "ExoBoot, a soft inflatable robotic boot to assist ankle during walking: Design, Characterization, and Preliminary Tests," in 7th IEEE International Conference on Biomedical Robotics and Biomechatronics, pp. 509–516. (2018)
Park, J., Choi, J., Kim, S.J., Seo, K.-H., Kim, J.: Design of an Inflatable Wrinkle Actuator With Fast Inflation/Deflation Responses for Wearable Suits. IEEE Robot. Autom. Lett. 5(3), 3799–3805 (2020)
Mauer: "EMGR - EAS 90 L4," [Online]. Available: https://www.motor-mauer.de/elektromotor-wechselstrom-lichtstrommotor-emgr-eas90l4-wechselstrommotor-einphasen-230-v-motor-shop-kaufen-1-1-kw-1500-min-1. Accessed 14 December 2021
Thalman, C. M., Hertzell, T., Lee, H.: "Toward A Soft Robotic Ankle-Foot Orthosis (SR-AFO) Exosuit for Human Locomotion: Preliminary Results in Late Stance Plantarflexion Assistance," in 3rd IEEE International Conference on Soft Robotics, pp. 801–807 (2020)
PAR Group Ltd.: "TPU93 Thermoplastic Polyurethane - Orange BANCOLLAN, Technical Data Sheet," [Online]. Available: https://www.par-group.co.uk/site-content/1/Docs/updates/1-rubber-and-polyurethane/1.26-tpu93-thermoplastic-polyurethane-orange-bancollan-tds.pdf. Accessed 10 December 2021
Rockywoods: "200 DENIER COATED OXFORD NYLON FABRIC (SOLD PER YARD)," [Online]. Available: https://www.rockywoods.com/200-Denier-Packcloth-Nylon-Fabric. Accessed 10 December 2021
KOMP-ACT: "KDRV-1-MK-X-X Electronic Controller," [Online]. Available: https://komp-act.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/06/KDRV-1-MK-X-X.pdf. Accessed 16 December 2021
Chinchwad, Pimpri: Hydraulic Valves, Actuators, and Accessories.
iAutomation: "S20260-VTS," [Online]. Available: https://shop.i-automation.com/products/S20260-VTS. Accessed 8 December 2021
Adami, M., Seibel, A.: On-Board Pneumatic Pressure Generation Methods for Soft Robotics Applications. Actuators 8(2), 1–35 (2019)
Hussain, S., Xie, S.Q., Jamwal, P.K., Parsons, J.: An Intrinsically Compliant Robotic Orthosis for Treadmill training. Med. Eng. Phys. 34(10), 1448–1453 (2012)
Costa, N. R. S., Caldwell, D. G.: "Control of a Biomimetic "Soft-Actuated" Lower Body 10DOF Exoskeleton," in The First IEEE/RAS-EMBS International Conference on Biomedical Robotics and Biomechatronics, pp. 495–501 (2006)
Johnson, D. C., Repperger, D. W., Thompson, G.:"Development of a Mobility Assist for the paralyzed, Amputee, and Spastic Patient," in Fifteenth Southern Biomedical Engineering Conference, pp. 67–70 (1996)
Gu, Y., Lv, Y., Ma, X., Lu, C.: "Lower-Limb Soft Orthotic Device for Gait Assistance," in 4th Information Technology and Mechatronics Engineering Conference, pp. 894–897. (2018)
Sasaki, D., Nortisugu, T., Takaiwa, M.: Development of High Contractile Pneumatic Artificial Rubber Muscle for Power Assist Device. J. Robot. Mechatronics 24(1), 150–157 (2012)
MegaDepot: "STC 2S020–1/8A-3-D-V 2S020 Direct Acting 2 Way SS Solenoid Valve," [Online]. Available: https://megadepot.com/product/stcvalve-2s020-1-8a-3-d-v-2s020-110vac-din-coil-1-8-npt-9mm-direct-acting-2-way-ss-solenoid-valve. Accessed 19 December 2021
Wright, L. G. M. A. C. Kathy: Interviewee, Humphrey Enquiry. [Interview]. (2021)
ANSgear: "NINJA DURA PRO SLP CARBON FIBER AIR TANK - 68/4500 - BLACKOUT," [Online]. Available: https://www.ansgear.com/Ninja_Dura_Pro_SLP_Carbon_Fiber_Air_Tank_68_4500_p/ninjatankpro-68slpdurablackout.htm. Accessed 19 December 2021
DeWALT: "D55146 - 1.6 HP Continuous. 225 PSI, 4.5 Gallon Compressor," [Online]. Available: https://www.dewalt.com/products/storage-and-gear/air-compressors/16-hp-continuous-225-psi-45-gallon-compressor/d55146. Accessed 19 December 2021
MAUER: "EMGR 90 L4," [Online]. Available: https://www.motor-mauer.de/elektromotor-wechselstrom-lichtstrommotor-emgr-eas90l4-wechselstrommotor-einphasen-230-v-motor-shop-kaufen-1-1-kw-1500-min-1. Accessed 19 December 2021
California Air Tools: "California Air Tools 8010A," [Online]. Available: https://www.californiaairtools.com/ultra-quiet-series-of-air-compressor-contractor-grade/1-0-hp-air-compressors/cat-8010a/. Accessed 19 December 2021
Kohki, Nitto: "DAH 110," [Online]. Available: http://www.nitto-kohki.eu/en/products-en/pumps-a-compressors/dc-pumps/item/dah-110.html. [Accessed 19 December 2021
TOPSFLO: "TMD41A-A," [Online]. Available: http://www.topsflo.com/mini-diaphragm-pump/tmd45-diaphragm-pump.html#Specifications. Accessed 19 December 2021
Dandy, T.: Interviewee, Topsflo Diaphragm Pump. [Interview]. (2021)
Kohki, L. L. -. N: Interviewee, DAH 110 Information. [Interview]. (2021)
Mooney, L. M., Rouse, E. J., Herr, H. M.: "Autonomous Exoskeleton Reduces Metabolic Cost of Walking," in 36th Annual International Conference of the IEEE Engineering in Medicine and Biology Society, pp. 1–11 (2014)
Bryan, G.M., Franks, P.W., Klein, S.C., Peuchen, R.J., Collins, S.H.: A Hip-knee-ankle exoskeleton emulator for studying gait assistance. Int. J. Robot. Res. 40(4–5), 722–746 (2021)
Jin, X., Cui, X., Agrawal, S. K.: "Design of a Cable-driven Active Leg Exoskeleton (C-ALEX) and Gait Training Experiments with Human Subjects," in IEEE International Conference on Robotics and Automation, pp. 5578–5583, 2015.
Lee, Y., Lee, J., Choi, B., Lee, M., Roh, S.-G., Kim, K., Seo, K., Kim, Y.-J., Shim, Y.: Flexibile Gait Enhancing Mechatronics System for Lower Limb Assistance (GEMS L-Type). IEEE/ASME Trans. Mechatron. 24(4), 1520–1531 (2019)
Asbeck, A. T., Dyer, R. J., Larusson, A. F., Walsh, C. J.: "Biologically-inspired Soft Exosuit," in IEEE International Conference on Rehabilitation Robotics, pp. 1–8. (2013)
Mioskowska, M., Stevenson, D., Onu, M., Trkov, M.: "Compressed Gas Actuated Knee Assistive Exoskeleton for Slip-Induced Fall Prevention During Human Walking," in IEEE/ASME International Conference on Advanced Intelligent Mechatronics, pp. 735–740. (2020)
Kong, K., Jeon, D.: Design and Control of an Exoskeleton for the Elderly and Patients. IEEE/ASME Int. Trans. Mechatronics 11(4), 428–432 (2006)
Schmidt, K., Duarte, J.E., Grimmer, M., Alejandro, S.-P.: The Myosuit: Bi-Articular Anti-gravity Exosuit That Reduces Hip Extensor Activity in Sitting Transfers. Front. Neutorobot. 11(57), 1–16 (2017)
M. Gloger, G. Obinata, E. Genda, J. Babjak and Y. Pei, "Active Lower Limb Orthosis with One Degree of Freedom for People with Paraplegia," in International Conference on Rehabilitation Robotics, pp. 258–263, 2017.
Van den Bogert, A.J.: Exotendons for Assistance of Human Locomotion. Biomed. Eng. Online 2(17), 1–8 (2003)
Symons, C.: Interviewee, Carl Stahl Sava Industries steel cable 2081 Price. [Interview]. (2021)
Garcia, P.: Interviewee, Lexco 415310–00 outer cable Price. [Interview]. (2021)
Veneman, J.F., van der Helm, F.C., van der Kooij, H.: A Series Elastic- and Bowden-Cable-Based Actuation System for Use as Torque Actuator in Exoskeleton-Type Robots. Int. J. Robot. Res. 25(3), 261–281 (2006)
Veneman, J.F., Kruidhof, R., Hekman, E.E.G., Ekkelenkamp, R., Van Asseldonk, E.H.F., van der Kooij, H.: Design and Evaluation of the LOPES Exoskeleton Robot for Interactive Gait Rehabilitation. IEEE Trans. Neural Syst. Rehabil. Eng. 15(3), 379–386 (2007)
Maxon: "EC-4pole 30 Ø30 mm, brushless, 200 Watt," [Online]. Available: https://www.maxongroup.com/maxon/view/product/motor/ecmotor/ec4pole/305013. Accessed 21 November 2021
Nokon: "Products - Gear Systems," [Online]. Available: http://www.nokon.com/NokonUSA_Products%20(black).htm. Accessed 21 November 2021
Maxon: "EC-4pole 30 Ø30 mm, brushless, 200 Watt | High Power," [Online]. Available: https://www.maxongroup.com/maxon/view/product/305015. Accessed 21 November 2021
EC-i 40 Ø40 mm, brushless, 70 Watt, with Hall sensors, [Online]. Available: https://www.maxongroup.com/maxon/view/product/449470. Accessed 21 November 2021
Maxon: "EC-i 30 Ø30 mm, brushless, 75 W, with Hall sensors | High Torque," [Online]. Available: https://www.maxongroup.com/maxon/view/product/539485. Accessed 21 November 2021
Banala, S.K., Agrawal, S.K., Fattah, A., Krishnamoorthy, V., Hsu, W.-L., Scholz, J., Rudolph, K.: Gravity-Balancing Leg Orthosis and Its Performance Evaluation. IEEE Trans. Rob. 22(6), 1228–1239 (2006)
Wiggin, B., Sawicki, G. S., Collins, S. H.: "An Exoskeleton Using Controlled Energy Storage and Release to Aid Ankle Propulsion," in International Conference on Rehabilitation Robotics, pp. 1–5 (2011)
Ranaweera, R., Mann, G., Gopura, R.C.: Development of a Passively Powered Knee Exoskeleton for Squat Lifting. J. Robot. Netw. Artif. Life 5(1), 45–51 (2018)
Zhou, T., Xiong, C., Zhang, J., Chen, W., Huang, X.: Regulating Metabolic Energy Among Joints During Human Walking Using a Multiarticular Unpowered Exoskeleton. IEEE Trans. Neural Syst. Rehabil. Eng. 29, 662–672 (2021)
Wu, P., Chen, X., He, Y., Liu, Z.: "Unpowered Knee Exoskeleton during Stair Descent," in The 7th International Conference on Mechatronics and Robotics Engineering, pp. 106–110. (2021)
Giovacchini, F., Vannetti, F., Fantozzi, M., Cempini, M., Cortese, M., Parri, A., Tingfang, Y., Lefeber, D., Vitiello, N.: A Light-Weight Active Orthosis for Hip movement assistance. Robot. Auton. Syst. 73, 123–134 (2015)
Maxon: "EC 60 flat Ø60 mm, brushless, 100 Watt, with cover," [Online]. Available: https://www.maxongroup.com/maxon/view/product/motor/ecmotor/ecflat/ecflat60/408057. Accessed 18 December 2021
Kai, Y., Kitaguchi, S., Shotaro, K., Zhang, W., Tomizuka, M.: "Development of a Rehabilitation Robot Suit with Velocity and Torque-based Mechanical Safety Devices," in IEEE/RSJ International Conference on Intelligent Robots and Systems, pp. 1380–1385. (2014)
Maxon: "RE 40 Ø40 mm, Graphite Brushes, 150 Watt," [Online]. Available: https://www.maxongroup.com/maxon/view/product/148867. Accessed 18 December 18
MiSUMi: "Round Wire Coil Springs/Deflection 45%/I.D. Referenced (VUR8–20)," [Online]. Available: https://uk.misumi-ec.com/vona2/detail/110302604640/?HissuCode=VUR8-20. Accessed 8 December 2021
Alouane, M.A., Huo, W., Rifai, H., Amirat, Y., Mohammed, S.: Hybrid FES-Exoskeleton Controller to Assist Sit-To-Stand Movement. IFAC-PapersOnLine 51(34), 296–301 (2019)
Nikitczuk, J., Weinburg, B., Mavroidis, C.: "Rehabilitative Knee Orthosis Driven by Electro-Rheological Fluid Based Actuators," in IEEE International Conference on Robotics and Automation, pp. 2283–2289. (2005)
Zite, J. L., Ahmadkhanlou, F., Neelakantan, V. A., Washington, G. N.: "A Magnetorheological fluid based orthopedic active knee brace," in Smart Structures and Materials 2006: Industrial and Commercial Applications of Smart Structures Technologies, pp. 1–10. (2006)
Li, Y., Hashimoto, M.: Design and prototyping of a novel lightweight walking assist wear using PVC gel soft actuators. Sens. Actuators 239, 26–44 (2016)
Cheng, C.-Y., Okamoto, S., Li, P., Akiyama, Y., Qiu, C., Yamada, Y.: "Encouragement of Squat-Lifting: Feasability Study of a Highly Usable Passive Knee Assistive Device," in International Symposium on System Integration, pp. 504–508. (2020)
Yoshimi: "Shape memory alloy / taper wire φ1.5–0.7 × 300mm," [Online]. Available: https://www.yoshimi-inc.com/shopbrand/ct32/. Accessed 21 November 2021
Mueller Sports Medicine: "Self-Adjusting™ Hinged Knee Brace," [Online]. Available: https://www.muellersportsmed.com/b2c-us/en/Open-Catalog/By-Sport/Gymnastics/SELF-ADJUSTING-HINGED-KNEE-BRACE-OSFM/p/6455. Accessed 21 November 2021
Yoshizawa, N.: "Powered AFO for Achilles Tendon Rupture," in 30th Annual International IEEE EMBS Conference, pp. 4250–4253. (2008)
Washabaugh, E.P., Krishnan, C.: A Wearable Resistive Robot Facilitates Locomotor Adaptions during Gait. Resorative Neurol. Neurosci. 36(2), 215–223 (2018)
K&J Magnetics, Inc.: "DX04B-N52," [Online]. Available: https://www.kjmagnetics.com/proddetail.asp?prod=DX04B-N52. Accessed 21 November 2021
Chaichaowarat, R., Macha, V., Wannasuphoprasit, W.: "Passive Knee Exoskeleton Using Brake Torque to Assist Stair Ascent," in IEEE Region 10 Conference, pp. 1165–1170 (2020)
Misumi, "Warner series brake (Sinfonia Technology) (PB-260/FMS-AG)," [Online]. Available: https://us.misumi-ec.com/vona2/detail/221004995844/?HissuCode=PB-260%2fFMS-AG. Accessed 21 November 2021
Mankala, K. K., Banala, S. K., Agrawal, S. K.: "Passive Swing Assistive Exoskeletons for Motor-Incomplete Spinal Cord Injury Patients," in IEEE International Conference on Robotics and Automation, pp. 3761–3766. (2007)
Jin, S., Guo, S., Hashimoto, K., Xiong, X., Yamamoto, M.: "A Soft Wearable Robotic Suit for Ankle and Hip Assistance a Preliminary Study," in 40th Annual International Conference of the IEEE Engineering in Medicine and Biology Society, pp. 1867–1870. (2018)
Pratt, G. A., Williamson, M. M.: "Series Elastic Actuators," in IEEE/RSJ International Conference on Intelligent Robots and Systems. Human Robot Interaction and Cooperative Robots, pp. 399–406. (1995)
Madden, J.D.W., Vandesteeg, N.A., Anquetil, P.A., Madden, P.G.A., Takshi, A., Pytel, R.Z., Lafontaine, S.R., Wieringa, P.A., Hunter, I.W.: Artificial Muscle Technology: Physical Priciples and Naval Prospects. IEEE J. Oceanic Eng. 29(3), 706–728 (2004)
Allen, D.P., Little, R., Laube, J., Warren, J., Voit, W., Gregg, R.D.: Towards an ankle-foot orthosis powered by a dielectric elastomer actuator. Mechatronics 76(102551), 1–13 (2021)
Moltedo, M., Bacek, T., Junius, K., Vanderborght, B., Lefeber, D.: "Mechanical Design of a Lightweight Compliant and Adaptable Active Ankle Foot Orthosis," in IEEE RAS/EMBS International Conference on Biomedical Robotics and Biomechatronics, pp. 1224–1229 (2016)
SODEMANN Industrial Springs: "Compression Springs | Produced in Stainless Steel," SODEMANN, [Online]. Available: https://www.industrial-springs.com/products/compression-springs/range-a-b-stainless-steel?a_004=29315_29315&a_006=33271_33284. Accessed 06 September 2021
Malkawi, S., Al-Nimr, M., Azizi, D.: A multi-criteria optimization analysis for Jordan’s energy mix. Energy 127, 680–696 (2017)
Pinto, D., Garnier, M., Baras, J., Chang, S.-H., Charlifue, S., Field-Fote, E., Furbish, C., Tefertiller, C., Mummidisetty, C.K., Taylor, H., Jayaraman, A., Heinemann, A.W.: Budget impact analysis of robotic exoskeleton use for locomotor training following spinal cord injury in four SCI Model Systems. J. Neuroeng. Rehabil. 17(4), 1–13 (2020)
Brancato, E.L.: Estimation of Lifetime Expectancies of Motors. IEEE Electr. Insul. Mag. 8(3), 5–13 (1992)
Maxon: "Technology - short and to the point," November 2014. [Online]. Available: https://www.maxongroup.com/medias/sys_master/root/8815461597214/DC-Technology-short-and-to-the-point-14-EN-30-31.pdf?attachment=true. Accessed 15 April 2022
Woo, S.-W.: Estimating the Lifetime of the Pneumatic Cylinder in Machine Tool Subjected to Repetitive Pressure Loading. J. US-China Public Adm. 15(5), 221–238 (2018)
Bimba: "Cylinder Life Expectancy," May 2012. [Online]. Available: https://airinc.net/wp-content/uploads/2014/08/Original-Line-Cylinder_Life_Expectancy-1.pdf. Accessed 15 April 2022
Baldor: "Cog-free Brushless Servo Motors," [Online]. Available: https://literature.puertoricosupplier.com/024/MN23295.pdf. Accessed 27 November 2021
Baldor: "Servo, Linear & Motion Control," [Online]. Available: http://www.rgspeed.com/assets/documents/feedback/baldor/servo-linear-and-motion-control.pdf. Accessed 21 November 2021
Copley Controls Corp.: "ServoTube Application Guide," [Online]. Available: https://www.actronic-solutions.de/files/actronic/FTPROOT/Servotube-AppGuide.pdf. Accessed 1 December 2021
Kollmorgen: [Online]. Available: https://www.kollmorgen.com/sites/default/files/public_downloads/s200_vts_e.pdf. Accessed 8 December 2020
Elektromotoren: "Electric Motors," [Online]. Available: https://www.motor-mauer.de/mediafiles/datasheets/EMGR/EMGR-Hauptkatalog.pdf. Accessed 14 December 2021
FESTO: "Valve series VOVG," [Online]. Available: https://www.festo.com/cat/en-gb_gb/data/doc_ENUS/PDF/US/VOVG_ENUS.PDF. Accessed 19 December 2021
Parker, C., Borisoff, J.F., Mortenson, W.B., Mattie, J.: A Survey of stakeholder perspectives on exoskeleton technology. J. Neuroeng. Rehabil. 11(169), 1–10 (2014)
Wang, S., Wang, L., Meijneke, C., Asseldonk, E. V., Hoewllinger, T., Cheron, G., Ivanenko, Y., Scaleia, V. L., Sylos-Labini, F., Molinari, M., Tamburella, F., Pisotta, I., Thorsteinsson, F., Ilzkovtiz, M., Gancet, J., Nevatia, Y., Hauffe, R., Zanow F., Van der Kooij, H.: Design and Control of the MINDWALKER Exoskeleton. IEEE Trans. Neural Syst. Rehabil. Eng. 23(2), 277–286 (2015)
Bartenbach, V., Gort, M., Riener, R.: "Concept and Design of a Modular Lower Limb Exoskeleton," in International Conference on Biomedical Robotics and Biomechatronics, pp. 649–654 (2016)
Morichika, T., Kikkawa, F., Oyama, O., Yoshimitsu, T.: "Development of Walking Assist Equipment with Pneumatic Cylinder," in SICE Annual Conference, pp. 1058–1063. (2007)
TSI Solutions: "173.5-DPY Bimba 1–1/2" x 3.5" Original Line Cyl," TSI Solutions, [Online]. Available: https://www.tsisolutions.us/itemdetail/?itemCode=173.5-DPY. Accessed 6 September 2021
Dan: "Single-Acting Cylinders," Hydraulic Schematic Troubleshooting, 01 June 2018. [Online]. Available: http://www.hydraulicstatic.com/20180601_single-acting-cylinders.html. Accessed 04 Sep 2021
Dan: "Double-Acting Cylinder with a Piston Rod on One Side," Hydraulic Schematic Troubleshooting, 09 May 2019. [Online]. Available: http://www.hydraulicstatic.com/20190509_double-acting-cylinder-with-a-piston-rod-on-one-side.html. Accessed 04 September 2021
RS: "Bosch Rexroth Fixed Hydraulic Cylinder 100mm Stroke, 2952993400," [Online]. Available: https://uk.rs-online.com/web/p/fixed-hydraulic-cylinders/2638556/. Accessed 08 December 2021
HosesDirect: "BLACK COMPRESSED AIR HOSE WITH YELLOW STRIPE 20 BAR AIR HOSE. 15/30/100M COILS," [Online]. Available: https://www.hoses.co.uk/images/datasheets/BYA-6.pdf. Accessed 10 December 2021
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Contributions
Tom Slucock: Research and Manuscript Compilation.
Corresponding author
Ethics declarations
Conflicts of Interest
The Author Declares no Conflicts of Interest.
Ethics Approval
The Author has read and approved this manuscript.
Consent to Participate
Not Applicable.
Consent for Publication
The Author has agreed to publish this manuscript.
Additional information
Publisher's Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Supplementary Information
Below is the link to the electronic supplementary material.
Rights and permissions
Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article's Creative Commons licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article's Creative Commons licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this licence, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/.
About this article
Cite this article
Slucock, T. A Systematic Review of Low-Cost Actuator Implementations for Lower-Limb Exoskeletons: a Technical and Financial Perspective. J Intell Robot Syst 106, 3 (2022). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10846-022-01695-0
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10846-022-01695-0