The Ethics of a Co-regulatory Model for Farm Animal Welfare Research
- 519 Downloads
Standards for farm animal welfare are variously managed at a national level by government-led regulatory control, by consumer-led welfare economics and co-regulated control in a partnership between industry and government. In the latter case the control of research to support animal welfare standards by the relevant industry body may lead to a conflict of interest on the part of researchers, who are dependent on industry for continued research funding. We examine this dilemma by reviewing two case studies of research published under an Australian co-regulated control system. Evidence of unsupported conclusions that are favourable to industry is provided, suggesting that researchers do experience a conflict of interest that may influence the integrity of the research. Alternative models for the management of research are discussed, including the establishment of an independent research management body for animal welfare because of its public good status and the use of public money derived from taxation, with representation from government, industry, consumers, and advocacy groups.
KeywordsAnimal welfare Co-regulatory model Livestock Research Stocking density Transport
Neither of the authors of this paper has a financial or personal relationship with people or organisations that inappropriately influenced or biased the content of this paper. No external funding was provided for this study.
- Australian Animal Welfare Standards. (2014). Bobby calf time off feed standard. Department of Agriculture. http://www.animalwelfarestandards.net.au/land-transport/bobby-calf-time-off-feed-standard/. Last accessed 12 August, 2014.
- Australian Animal Welfare Standards and Guidelines. (2012). Land transport of livestock. Version 1.1. Department of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food, Canberra, pp. 59.Google Scholar
- Australian Standards for the Export of Livestock Version 2.3. (2011). http://www.daff.gov.au/__data/assets/pdf_file/0010/1904365/australian-standards-v2.3.pdf. Accessed 10 April, 2014.
- Broom, D. M., & Johnson, K. G. (1993). Stress and Animal Welfare. London: Chapman & Hall.Google Scholar
- Campfield, L. A., Smith, F. J., Rosenbaum, M., & Hirsch, (1995). Transient declines in blood glucose precede increased hunger ratings in humans. Appetite, 24, 78.Google Scholar
- Department of Agriculture (2014). About the Department of Agriculture. http://www.daff.gov.au/. Accessed 7 August, 2014.
- Edwards, A.V. (1970). Carbohydrate metabolism in young animals. In:Physiology of Digestion and Metabolism in the Ruminant (Eds.), A.T. Phillipson. Oriel Press Newcastle upon Tyne. pp. 180–198.Google Scholar
- Fisher, A., Mansell, P., Stevens, B., Conley, M, Jongman, E., Lauber, M., & Hides, S. (2010). Determining a suitable time off feed for bobby calf transport under Australian conditions. Dairy Australia Project No. TIG 124. Dairy Australia, Southbank, Victoria. http://www.animalwelfarestandards.net.au/files/2011/05/Fisher-report-a-summary.pdf.
- Food and Agricultural Organisation of the United Nations (FAO). (2014). FAOStat statistical data. http://faostat.fao.org/site/535/DesktopDefault.aspx?PageID=535. Accessed 22 January, 2014.
- Grant, R. (2007). Taking advantage of natural behavior improves dairy cow performance. Proceedings of the Western Dairy Management Conference, Reno, NV, Manhattan, Kansas State University, pp. 225–236.Google Scholar
- Krawczel, P. D., Klaiber, L. B., Butzler, R. E., Klaiber, L. M., Dann, H. M., Mooney, C. S., et al. (2012). Short-term increases in stocking density affect the lying and social behavior, but not the productivity, of lactating Holstein dairy cows. Journal of Dairy Science, 95, 4298–4308.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Ferguson D., & Lea, J. (2013). Refining stocking densities. Final Report W.LIV.0253. Meat & Livestock Australia Limited, North Sydney, pp. 26. http://www.mla.com.au/Research-and-development/Final-report-details?projectid=15355. Accessed 31 March, 2014.
- Lumsden, J. H., Mullen, K., & Rowe, R. (1980). Hematology and biochemistry reference values for female Holstein cattle. Canadian Journal of Comparative Medicine, 44, 24–31.Google Scholar
- Meat and Livestock Australia. (2006). World Livestock Export Standards—A comparison of development processes, systems and outcomes achieved. Alliance Resource Economics, Sydney. pp 26-33. http://view.officeapps.live.com/op/view.aspx?src=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.daff.gov.au%2F__data%2Fassets%2Fword_doc%2F0011%2F2378198%2Findependent-review-australias-livestock-export-trade.doc. Accessed 1 April, 2014.
- Ministry of Agriculture, Fisheries, and Food, Department of Agriculture and Fisheries for Scotland & Department of Agriculture for Northern Ireland. (1984). Energy Allowances and Feeding Systems for Ruminants. London: Her Majesty’s Stationary Office. 36.Google Scholar
- Morris, T. R. (1999). Experimental Design and Analysis in Animal Sciences. Wallingford: CABI. 26.Google Scholar
- Morton, J., & Phillips, C. (2008). Stocking Density in Cattle Shipments and Animal Health and Performance—An Assessment of Existing Data. North Sydney: Meat and Livestock Australia.Google Scholar
- National Primary Industries Animal Welfare Research, Development and Extension (RD&E) Framework (NPIAW). (2010). http://www.animalwelfare.net.au/sites/default/files/Animal%20Welfare%20RDE%20Strategy%20Sept%202010%20Endorsed.pdf. Accessed 5 August, 2014.
- Palme, R., Touma, C., Arias, N., Dominchin, M. F., & Lepschy, M. (2013). Steroid extraction: get the best out of faecal samples. Wiener Tierarztliche Monatsschrift, 100, 238–246.Google Scholar
- Paradice, J., & Thornber, P. (2014). Facilitating the use of the OIE standards for the transport of animals by sea and by land. Proceedings of the Third OIE Global Conference on Animal Welfare, Kuala Lumpur 6-8 November, 2012 (pp. 45–52). Paris: World Organisation for Animal Health.Google Scholar
- Petherick, J. C., & Kilgour, R. (2001). Feedlot research: do the ethical, scientific and industry requirements conflict? In R. Baker, M. Fisher, & P. Hemsworth (Eds.), Farm Animals in Research—Can We Meet the Demands of Ethics, Welfare, Science and Industry? (pp. 96–101). Adelaide: ANZCCART.Google Scholar
- Petherick, J. C., Small, A. H., Mayer, D. G., Colditz, I. G., Ferguson, D. M., & Stafford, K. J. (2014a). A comparison of welfare outcomes for weaner and mature Bos indicus bulls surgically or tension band castrated with or without analgesia. 1. Behavioural responses. Applied Animal Behaviour Science, 157, 23–34.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Petherick, J. C., Small, A. H., Mayer, D. G., Colditz, I. G., Ferguson, D. M., & Stafford, K. J. (2014b). A comparison of welfare outcomes for weaner and mature Bos indicus bulls surgically or tension band castrated with or without analgesia. 2. Responses related to stress, health and productivity. Applied Animal Behaviour Science, 157, 35–47.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Pines, M., Petherick, J. C., Gaughan, J. B., & Phillips, C. J. C. (2007). Stakeholders’ assessment of welfare indicators for sheep and cattle exported by sea from Australia. Animal Welfare, 16, 489–498.Google Scholar
- Rind, M. I., & Phillips, C. J. C. (1999). The effects of group size on the ingestive and social behaviour of grazing dairy cows. Animal Science, 68, 589–596.Google Scholar
- Santurtun, E., Moreau, V., & Phillips, C.J.C. (2014b). Behavioral, body postural and physiological responses of sheep to sea transport motions. In: Proceedings of the 48th Congress of the International Society for Applied ethology, Spain, in press.Google Scholar
- Thornber, P. (2004). Australian standards for the export of livestock. http://www.daff.gov.au/__data/assets/pdf_file/0009/1046871/70-peter-thornber.pdf. Accessed 1 April, 2014.
- Van der Schott, A., & Phillips, C. J. C. (2013). Publication bias in animal welfare scientific literature. Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics, 26, 945–948.Google Scholar
- Van Eck, M., Berkhof, H., Nicolson, N., & Sulon, J. (1996). The effects of perceived stress, traits, mood states, and stressful daily events on salivary cortisol. Psychosomatic Medicine, 58, 447–458.Google Scholar
- Western Australian Farmers Federation (2014). Better live export. http://www.betterliveexport.com/. Accessed 25 June, 2014.