Abstract
Chromonic liquid crystals are lyotropic materials which are attracting growing interest for their adaptability to living systems. To describe their elastic properties, the classical Oseen-Frank theory requires anomalously small twist constants and (comparatively) large saddle-splay constants, so large as to violate one of Ericksen’s inequalities, which guarantee that the Oseen-Frank stored-energy density is bounded below. While such a violation does not prevent the existence and stability of equilibrium distortions in problems with fixed geometric confinement, the study of free-boundary problems for droplets has revealed a number of paradoxical consequences. Minimizing sequences driving the total energy to negative infinity have been constructed by employing ever growing needle-shaped tactoids incorporating a diverging twist (Paparini and Virga in Phys. Rev. E 106: 044703, 2022). To overcome these difficulties, we propose here a novel elastic theory that extends for chromonics the classical Oseen-Frank stored energy by adding a quartic twist term. We show that the total energy of droplets is bounded below in the quartic twist theory, so that the known paradoxes are ruled out. The quartic term introduces a phenomenological length in the theory; this affects the equilibrium of chromonics confined within capillary tubes. Use of published experimental data allows us to estimate .
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
1 Introduction
Liquid crystals are ordered fluids divided into two big families: thermotropic and lyotropic. What distinguishes these families is the agent that drives the transition form ordinary, isotropic fluids to anisotropic ones, typically birefringent and optically uniaxial. It is temperature in the former family and concentration in the latter. Correspondingly, ordering takes place at sufficiently low temperature or sufficiently high concentration.
Here we shall be concerned with the nematic phase, where order arises only in the orientation of the typical elongated constituentsFootnote 1 of liquid crystals, not in their position in space. In both families, nematic order is described by the director , a unit vector field which designates the local prevailing orientation, corresponding to the optic axis. It can (easily) vary in space in response to different external agencies; its optical nature contributes to the aesthetic fascination of these materials.
When has not everywhere the same orientation, its distorted texture exhibits a curvature elasticity described by a stored energy expressed in terms of the invariants of , the latter taken to be a tensorial measure of local distortion. The classical theory of nematic elasticity is based on the assumption that in the ground state has everywhere the same orientation and that the energy stored in a distortion measures the work done to produce it starting from the ground state. The Oseen-Frank theory posits a stored energy quadratic in and features four elastic constants, one for each elementary distortional mode.
Chromonic liquid crystals (CLCs) are lyotropic materials, which include Sunset Yellow (SSY), a popular dye in food industry, and disodium cromoglycate (DSCG), an anti-asthmatic drug. In these materials, molecules stuck themselves in columns, which in aqueous solutions develop a nematic orientational order. In CLCs, the director designates the average direction in space of the constituting supra-molecular aggregates.
A number of reviews have already appeared in the literature [1–5], to which we refer the reader. They also witness the scientific interest surrounding this theme.
Experiments have been performed with these materials in capillary tubes, with either circular [6, 7] or rectangular [8] cross-sections, as well as on cylindrical shells [9], all enforcing degenerate planar anchoring, which allows constituting columns to glide freely on the anchoring surface, provided they remain tangent to it. These experiments revealed a tendency of CLCs to acquire at equilibrium a twisted configuration in cylinders, represented by an escaped twist (ET) director field. Due to the lack of chirality in both the molecular aggregates constituting CLCs and their condensed phase, ET fields come equally likely in two variants with opposite chiralities, as illustrated by the cartoons in Fig. 1. Footnote 2
Despite the lack of uniformity in the ground state of these phases,Footnote 3 their curvature elasticity has been modeled by the Oseen-Frank theory, albeit with an anomalously small twist constant \(K_{22}\). To accommodate the experimental findings and justify the twisted ground state, this constant has to be smaller than the saddle-splay constant \(K_{24}\), in violation of one of the inequalities Ericksen [14] had put forward to guarantee that the Oseen-Frank stored energy be bounded below.
Actually, as shown in [15], the violation of one Ericksen’s inequality does not prevent the twisted ground state from being locally stable in a cylinder enforcing degenerate planar anchoring on its lateral boundary. The same conclusion was reached in [16]. But, as shown in [17], free-boundary problems may reveal noxious consequences of violating Ericksen’s inequalities. If \(K_{22}< K_{24}\), a CLC droplet, tactoidalFootnote 4 in shape and surrounded by an isotropic fluid environment enforcing degenerate planar anchoring for the director at the interface, is predicted to be unstable against shape change: it would split indefinitely in smaller tactoids while the total free energy plummets to negative infinity (see [17], for more details).
This prediction is in sharp contrast with the wealth of experimental observations of CLC tactoidal droplets, stable in the biphasic region of phase space, where nematic and isotropic phases coexist in equilibrium. Experiments have been carried out with a number of substances (including DSCG and SSY) stabilized by the addition of neutral (achiral) condensing agents (such as PEG and Spm) [18–22]. These studies have consistently reported stable twisted bipolar tactoids.
Thus, we meet with a contradiction: if we adopt the Oseen-Frank theory to describe CLCs, we need to assume that \(K_{24}>K_{22}\) to explain the twisted nematic textures observed in cylindrical capillaries, but we also need to assume that \(K_{24}< K_{22}\) to justify the very existence of twisted tactoids observed in the biphasic coexistence region.
This paper presents our way to overcome this difficulty arising from applying the Oseen-Frank theory to the curvature elasticity of chromonics. We propose to add a specific quartic term to the stored-energy density.
Higher-order theories are not new in liquid crystal science. Go under this name either theories that allow for higher spatial gradients of in the energy and theories that allow for higher powers of the first gradient. Under the first category, which perhaps has seen its first manifestation in [23] (see also [24]), falls, for example, Dozov’s theory [25] for both twist-bend and splay-bend phases predicted long ago by Meyer [26] and more recently observed in real materials [27]. Under the second category falls, for example, a simple one-dimensional model for splay-bend nematics [28], then extended to incorporate a whole class of seven modulated ground states, of which twist-bend and splay bend are just two instances [29]. A hybrid theory was also proposed in [30], where both higher gradients of and higher powers of the first gradient are allowed in the stored-energy density, with spatial derivatives and their powers balanced according to a criterion motivated by a molecular model.Footnote 5
The single quartic energy term contemplated in our theory will only contain the twist measure of nematic distortion; hence the name quartic twist theory.
The paper is organized as follows. In Sect. 2, we describe the energetics of chromonics, starting from the classical quadratic Oseen-Frank theory. In particular, we see what our theory has to say about the paradoxes for chromonic droplets encountered within the Oseen-Frank theory. Although we do not solve any free-boundary problem within the proposed theory, we provide a uniform lower bound for the total energy that prevents the existence of the minimizing sequences with diverging energy that generate paradoxes within the Oseen-Frank theory. In Sect. 3, we apply the quartic twist theory to a CLC in a cylinder subject to degenerate planar anchoring on the lateral boundary and compare the predictions of this theory, for different values of a phenomenological length scale \(a\) brought in by the added quartic term, with those of the classical theory, which is recovered in the limit where \(a\) vanishes. Finally, in Sect. 4, we summarize our conclusions. In a closing Appendix, we collect the details of a fit of published data with our theory aiming at estimating both \(K_{24}\) and \(a\).
2 Energetics
An extended theory may become more acceptable if its parent theory is first laid out. Thus, we start by summarizing the classical quadratic theory for the elasticity of nematic liquid crystals, albeit formulated in a novel, equivalent way that serves better our purpose. It will then become easier to justify how it should be modified to prevent the paroxysmal concentration of twist which in free-boundary problems leads the total energy to negative infinity [17].
2.1 Classical Quadratic Energy
The classical elastic theory of liquid crystals goes back to the pioneering works of Oseen [33] and Frank [34].Footnote 6 This theory is variational in nature, as it is based on a bulk free energy functional \(\mathscr{F}_{\mathrm{b}}\) written in the form
where ℬ is a region in space occupied by the material and \(V\) is the volume measure. In (1), \(W_{\mathrm {OF}}\) measures the distortional cost produced by a deviation from a uniform director field . It is chosen to be the most general frame-indifferent, even function quadratic in ,
Here \(K_{11}\), \(K_{22}\), \(K_{33}\), and \(K_{24}\) are elastic constants characteristic of the material. They are traditionally referred to as the splay, twist, bend, and saddle-splay constants, respectively, by the features of four different orientation fields, each with a distortion energy proportional to a single term in (2) (see, for example, Chap. 3 of [36]).
Recently, Selinger [37] has reinterpreted the classical formula (2) by decomposing the saddle-splay mode into a set of other independent modes. The starting point of this decomposition is a novel representation of (see also [38]),
where is the bend vector, is the twist, is the splay, is the skew-symmetric tensor that has as axial vector, is the projection onto the plane orthogonal to , and \(\mathbf {D}\) is a symmetric tensor such that and \(\operatorname {tr}\mathbf {D}=0\). By its own definition, admits the following biaxial representation,
where \(q>0\) and is a pair of orthogonal unit vectors in the plane orthogonal to , oriented so that .Footnote 7
By use of the following identity,
we can easily give (2) the equivalent form
where . Since \((S,T,B,q)\) are all independent distortion characteristics, it readily follows from (6) that \(W_{\mathrm {OF}}\) is positive semi-definite whenever
which are the celebrated Ericksen’s inequalities [14]. If these inequalities are satisfied in strict form, the global ground state of \(W_{\mathrm {OF}}\) is attained on the uniform director field, characterized by
As already mentioned in the Introduction, inequality (7b) must be violated for the ground state of \(W_{\mathrm {OF}}\) to be different from (8), involving a non-vanishing \(T\).
The class of uniform distortions was defined in [13] as the one comprising all director fields for which the distortion characteristics are constant in space. Equivalently said, a uniform distortion is a director field that can fill three-dimensional space. It was proven that there are two distinct families of uniform distortions, characterized by the following conditions [13],
where \(q\) and \(b\) are arbitrary parameters such that \(q>0\) and \(B^{2}=2b^{2}\), and \(b_{1}\) and \(b_{2}\) are defined by the decomposition
The general director field corresponding to (9) is the heliconical ground state of twist-bend nematic phases,Footnote 8 in which makes a fixed cone angle with a given axis in space (called the helix axis), around which precesses periodically [13].Footnote 9 The special instance in which \(B=0\) corresponds to the single twist that characterizes cholesteric liquid crystals.
The distortion for which all characteristics vanish, but \(T\), is a double twist.Footnote 10 It is not uniform and cannot fill space; it can possibly be realized locally, but not everywhere. In words, we say that it is a frustrated ground state. It is, however, relevant to CLCs, as a double twist is attained exactly on the symmetry axis of both chiral variants of the ET field [15].
Liquid crystals are (within good approximation) incompressible fluids. Thus, when the region ℬ is not fixed, for a given amount of material, ℬ is subject to the isoperimetric constraint that prescribes its volume,
When ℬ is surrounded by an isotropic fluid, a surface energy arises at the free interface \(\partial \mathscr{B}\), which, following [42], we represent as
where is the outer unit normal to \(\partial \mathscr{B}\), \(\gamma >0\) is the isotropic surface tension, \(\omega >-1\) is a dimensionless parameter weighting the anisotropic component of surface tension against the isotropic one, and \(A\) denotes the area measure. For \(\omega >0\), \(\mathscr{F}_{\mathrm{s}}\) promotes the degenerate planar anchoring, whereas for \(\omega <0\), it promotes the homeotropic anchoring. For free-boundary problems, the total free energy functional will then be written as
and the domain ℬ, subject to (11), is also an unknown to be determined so as to minimize \(\mathscr{F}_{\mathrm{t}}\).
2.2 Quartic Twist Energy
The essential feature of our theory is to envision a double twist with two equivalent chiral variants as ground state of CLCs in three-dimensional space,
The degeneracy of the ground double twist in (14) arises from the achiral nature of the molecular aggregates that constitute these materials, which is reflected in the lack of chirality of their condensed phases.
The elastic stored energy must equally penalize both ground chiral variants. Our minimalistic proposal to achieve this goal is to add a quartic twist term to the Oseen-Frank stored-energy density:
where \(a\) is a characteristic length. Unlike \(W_{\mathrm {OF}}\) when (7b) is violated, \(W_{\mathrm {QT}}\) is bounded below whenever
If these inequalities hold, as we shall assume here, then \(W_{\mathrm {QT}}\) is minimum at the degenerate double-twist (14) characterized by
As a consequence, \(W_{\mathrm {QT}}\) obeys the following uniform bound,
The parameter \(a\) encodes the bare length scale associated with the (double) twist \(T_{0}\) favored locally by the ground state.Footnote 11 As to the physical size of such a length scale, it may fall in a wide range. While at the lower end we may place the persistence length of the molecular order, which characterizes the flexibility of CLC aggregates,Footnote 12 the upper end is hard to make definite. We expect that \(a\) would be exposed to the same difficulty that affects many (if not all) supramolecular structures in lyotropic systems. The most telling example is perhaps given by cholesteric liquid crystals, which give rise to a chiral structure (characterized by a single twist \(T=\pm 2q\)) starting from chiral molecules. If the macroscopic pitch (measured by \(\vert 1/T\vert \)) were determined by the molecular chirality,Footnote 13 it would result several orders of magnitude smaller than the observed ones.Footnote 14 Here, we shall treat \(a\) as a phenomenological parameter, to be determined experimentally.
From now on, in the definition (1) for \(\mathscr{F}_{\mathrm{b}}\) we shall replace \(W_{\mathrm {OF}}\) with \(W_{\mathrm {QT}}\).
2.3 Energy Lower Bound
Our quartic theory is built with the intent of curing the paradoxes encountered within the Oseen-Frank theory when handling free-boundary problems for chromonics. As shown in [17], these paradoxes ultimately rely on the explicit construction of minimizing sequences of director fields and admissible shapes for the total free energy \(\mathscr{F}_{\mathrm{t}}\) in (13), over which \(\mathscr{F}_{\mathrm{t}}\) diverges to negative infinity. Thus, in short, \(\mathscr{F}_{\mathrm{t}}\) is proved to be unbounded below in a class of free-boundary problems, if \(W_{\mathrm {OF}}\) is chosen to be the stored-energy density with (7b) violated.Footnote 15
Besides the violation of (7b), all minimizing sequences provided in [17] have a common feature: they induce a high concentration of twist in needle-shaped droplets made sharper and sharper. Here we show that such a disruptive mechanism cannot be at work within the quartic twist theory. We are not in a position to prove that free-boundary problems are well-posed within this theory. Indeed, these are formidable problems already within the classical quadratic theory (see, for example, the early works [50, 51] and the more recent contributions [52, 53]). We rather prove that \(\mathscr{F}_{\mathrm{t}}\) is uniformly bounded below.
It is an easy consequence of (18) and (11) that
Similarly, it follows from (12) that
where
and \(A(\partial \mathscr{B})\) is the area of \(\partial \mathscr{B}\). By the isoperimetric inequality (see, for example, [54]),
and so (19) and (20) imply that
thus establishing a lower bound for \(\mathscr{F}_{\mathrm{t}}\) that only depends on material constants and the prescribed volume \(V_{0}\).
3 Chromonics in a Cylinder
Having established that the paradoxical behavior encountered for chromonic droplets within the classical quadratic theory is ruled out by our quartic theory, we can study within the latter the problem that in [6, 7] first led to interpret as ET fields the equilibrium distortions observed in chromonics filling a cylinder enforcing degenerate planar anchoring conditions on its later boundary.
Here the domain ℬ is a circular cylinder of radius \(R\) and height \(L\) (see Fig. 2) and the director field is subject to a degenerate planar anchoring condition on the lateral boundary \(\partial _{R}\mathscr{B}\) of ℬ:
where denotes the outer unit normal to \(\partial _{R}\mathscr{B}\). Free-boundary conditions are imposed on the bases of ℬ; the solution is assumed to be invariant under translations along the cylinder’s axis.
As a consequence of (24), \(\mathscr{F}_{\mathrm{s}}\) in (12) is a constant independent of and will be omitted. The total free energy \(\mathscr{F}_{\mathrm{t}}\) in (13) thus reduces to \(\mathscr{F}_{\mathrm{b}}\) and will be scaled to the reference energy \(2\pi K_{22}L\),
We further assume that in the frame of cylindrical coordinates \((r,\vartheta ,z)\), with along the axis of ℬ, is represented as
where the polar angle \(\beta \in [-\pi ,\pi ]\), which makes with the cylinder’s axis, depends only on the radial coordinate \(r\). In these coordinates, \(\partial _{R}\mathscr{B}\) is represented as the set \(\{(r,\vartheta ,z):r=R,0\leqq \vartheta \leqq 2\pi ,0\leqq z\leqq L\}\), and (24) is automatically satisfied, as . Moreover, as shown in [15], the distortion characteristics for a director field represented by (26) are given by
where a prime denotes differentiation.
Standard computations transform \(\mathcal{F}_{\mathrm{b}}\) in (25) into the reduced functional
where \(\mathcal{F}_{2}\) corresponds to the (scaled) quadratic Oseen-Frank’s free energy functional,
while
is the quartic contribution. Here
and
are scaled elastic constants, which will be assumed to obey the inequalities
the strong form of (16c) and (16b), respectively.
For the integral in (28) to be convergent, \(\beta \) must be subject to the condition
which amounts to require that is along on the cylinder’s axis.Footnote 16 The strong form of the Euler-Lagrange equation for \(\mathcal{F}_{\lambda}\) in (28) reduces here to
subject to (35) and to the following free-boundary condition at \(\rho =1\),
Solution to (36) subject to (35) and (37) enjoy a chiral symmetry: if \(\beta (\rho )\) is a solution, then also \(-\beta (\rho )\) is so, which by (27a)–(27d) shares with the former all distortion characteristics, but \(T\), which is opposite in sign. All chirality-conjugated solutions have the same energy, as follows immediately from (28) with (29) and (30). For definiteness, in the following, we shall resolve this degeneracy by taking \(\beta \geqq 0\); it should always be taken as also representing its conjugated companion with opposite twist.Footnote 17
For \(\lambda =0\), equations (36), (35), and (37) have a closed-form solution, given by (see [55] and also [7, 15])
Unfortunately, for \(\lambda >0\), the solution is not known explicitly. We now discuss some numerical solutions for various values of \(\lambda \) and then study analytically their asymptotics.
3.1 Numerical Solutions
To illustrate our theory, we solve numerically equation (36) subject to (35) and (37) using the experimental data for DSCG available from [56] and [57]. The latter refer to an aqueous solution with concentration \(c=14.0\%\) (wt/wt) at temperature \(21.5\,^{\circ }\mathrm{C}\), for which \(k_{3}=30\) and \(k_{24}=7.5\).
These data were obtained by using the Oseen-Frank theory. We argue that the experimental determination in [56] of \(K_{11}\), \(K_{22}\), and \(K_{33}\) (and so of \(k_{3}\)) would not be affected by the quartic twist term introduced here in the elastic stored-energy density because those measurements result from an instability driven by a magnetic field; the occurrence of such an instability is determined by the change in sign of the second variation of the total free-energy functional. The quartic twist term does not affect the second variation, and thus neither does the quartic elastic constant the magnetic instability. On the other hand, in our theory, measurements of \(K_{24}\) are expected to reveal the role played by the quartic twist term.
For DSCG, the data available from [57] do not allow us to estimate both \(k_{24}\) and \(\lambda \), and so to illustrate the role of \(\lambda \), we first adopt the value of \(k_{24}\) derived from the quadratic theory. Below, in Sect. 3.1.1, we use more abundant data available for SSY to estimate both \(k_{24}\) and \(\lambda \) for that material using our quartic theory.
Figure 3 shows the graphs of the solution \(\beta _{\lambda}(\rho )\) for \(\lambda \) ranging from 0 to 4. For \(\lambda =0\) (red graph in Fig. 3), \(\beta _{\lambda}\) reduces to \(\beta _{0}\) in (38). As \(\lambda \) increases, the convexity of the graph becomes less and less pronounced, and it is almost lost for \(\lambda =4\), where the linear asymptotic regime described in Sect. 3.2 below is already nearly attained.
To further illustrate these solutions, we introduce the following dimensionless ratios,
where use was also made of both (27a)–(27d) and (17). They are functions of \(\rho \), which may be taken to represent local measures of uniformity and frustration, respectively. Where \(2q/T\) gets closer to 1, the distortion is nearer to be uniform, as intended in (9), and so fitter to fill space. Where \(T/T_{0}\) gets closer to 1, the distortion is farther from being frustrated, as the energy is closer to its absolute minimum. The graphs of both these ratios are plotted in Fig. 4 for different values of \(\lambda \). Upon increasing \(\lambda \), the distortion in the cylinder becomes both less uniform and less frustrated.
Finally, in Fig. 5, we plot the minimum of the total energy \(\mathcal{F}_{\lambda}[\beta _{\lambda}]\) (referred to \(\mathcal{F}_{0}[\beta _{0}]\)) against \(\lambda \). The asymptotic behavior shown by this graph as \(\lambda \to 0\) will be justified in Sect. 3.2 below.
3.1.1 Experimental Estimate
In [7], an experiment was performed with a solution of SSY in water (at a concentration \(c=30.0\%\) (wt/wt) and temperature \(25\,^{\circ }\mathrm{C}\)) inserted in a capillary tube with radius \(45.3\,\mu \mathrm{m}\pm 400\,\mathrm{nm}\). In equilibrium, the polar angle \(\beta \) was measured at different distances from the capillary’s axis; these data (taken from Fig. 3 of [7]) are reproduced in Fig. 6 (red curve). We regard this particular experiment as a case study where to put our theory to the test and show how both \(K_{24}\) and \(a\) could be determined. A systematic collection of data would be required to achieve a sound experimental determination of theses physical parameters.
Taking \(k_{3}=8.7\) from the measurements performed in [56] for the same material in the same conditions,Footnote 18 we determined \(k_{24}\) and \(\lambda \) from the best (least squares) fit shown in Fig. 6, obtaining
from which we estimate
The details of our fit are given in Appendix. Here we just heed that ours differs from the fit performed in [7] (blue curve in Fig. 6) under an important respect. We have taken the bulk moduli \(K_{22}\) and \(K_{33}\) (and hence \(k_{3}\)) as determined in [56] by customary bulk instabilities, whereas in [7] \(k_{3}\) was itself regarded as a fitting parameter in the analytic formula for the polar angle in (38). We consider the bulk determination of the bulk moduli more reliable.
We have also explored the consequences of taking \(k_{3}=8.7\) as in [56] and \(\lambda =0\): the best fit of the data in Fig. 6 with \(\beta _{0}\) in (38) was then found for \(k_{24}=222\), which is unrealistic. This negative result, however, shows how sensitive fitting these data is to the choice of \(k_{3}\).Footnote 19
As shown in Fig. 6, for this particular experiment, the fits for the two theories compared here are hardly discernible. Both theories and fits, however, differ substantially in their premises: the theories differ in their energies, the fits differ in their choices for \(k_{3}\).
The papers [7] and [6] have provided estimates of the ratio \(K_{24}/K_{33}\) for SSY. To compare these estimates to ours, which by (41) is \(K_{24}/K_{33}\approx 3.7\), we should remark that, due to a different scaling of the saddle-splay energy, the following conversion formulas apply
where \(K'_{24}\) and \(K''_{24}\) are the saddle-splay constants according to [7] and [6], respectively. Thus, \(K'_{24}/K_{33}\) in the range \((3.8,9.4)\) as in [7] becomes \(K_{24}/K_{33}\) in the range \((1.9,4.7)\) and \(K''_{24}/K_{33}\approx 6.7\) as in [6] becomes \(K_{24}/K_{33}\approx 3.4\). Our estimate seems to be in good agreement with these.
3.2 Asymptotics
Here, to justify the outcomes of the numerical computations shown above, we study the asymptotic behavior of \(\mathcal{F}_{\lambda}\) and its minimizers for both \(\lambda \to 0\) and \(\lambda \to \infty \).
We first take \(\lambda \ll 1\) and assume that in this limit \(\beta _{\lambda}\) is a perturbation to \(\beta _{0}\), the minimizer of \(\mathcal{F}_{0}\) described by (38),
where \(\alpha >0\) is a scalar parameter and \(u\) is a function in \(\mathcal{H}^{1}([0,1])\cap \mathcal{L}^{\infty}([0,1])\) subject to \(u(0)=0\), while remaining free at \(\rho =1\). We shall determine both \(\alpha \) and \(u\) by minimizing the approximate form of \(\mathcal{F}_{\lambda}\) evaluated at \(\beta _{\lambda}\) in (43).
To this end, we compute
where \(\delta \mathcal{F}_{0}(\beta _{0})\) and \(\delta ^{2}\mathcal{F}_{0}(\beta _{0})\) are the first and second variations of \(\mathcal{F}_{0}\) at \(\beta _{0}\), while \(\delta \mathcal{F}_{4}(\beta _{0})\) is the first variation of \(\mathcal{F}_{4}\). Since \(\beta _{0}\) is a critical point of \(\mathcal{F}_{0}\), \(\delta \mathcal{F}_{0}(\beta _{0})\equiv 0\). Moreover, as proved in [15], \(\delta ^{2}\mathcal{F}_{0}(\beta _{0})\) is positive definite, and the only minimizer of \(\mathcal{F}_{\lambda}\) in (44) is trivially \(u\equiv 0\) as long as \(\alpha <2\).
For \(\alpha =2\), \(u\) is determined by minimizing the quartic term in \(\lambda \), the least order depending on \(u\), which is a well-behaved functional with both quadratic and linear terms in \(u\). The quadratic term in \(\lambda \) already dominates the energy \(\mathcal{F}_{\lambda}\) and is independent of \(u\).
For \(\alpha >2\), the last term in (44) is dominant, but the minimizing \(u\) does not exist, as the functional
is unbounded below. This can easily be seen by computing \(\delta \mathcal{F}_{4}(\beta )[u]\) for \(u_{A}=A\rho \), with \(A\) a constant, and taking the limit as \(A\to -\infty \).
Thus, we have proved that (43) can hold only for \(\alpha =2\) and that both \(\beta _{\lambda}\) and \(\mathcal{F}_{\lambda}[\beta _{\lambda}]\) differ from \(\beta _{0}\) and \(\mathcal{F}_{\lambda}[\beta _{\lambda}]\), respectively, by terms in \(\lambda ^{2}\), as confirmed by the graphs in Figs. 3 and 5.
We now consider the limit as \(\lambda \to \infty \). In this case, we start by remarking that the uniform state represented by \(\beta \equiv 0\) is a solution of (36) for all values of \(\lambda \). As in (43), we perturb it by setting
where again \(\alpha >0\) and \(u\in \mathcal{H}^{1}([0,1])\cap \mathcal{L}^{\infty}([0,1])\) such that \(u(0)=0\). To determine \(\alpha \) and \(u\), we minimize \(\mathcal{F}_{\lambda}[\beta _{\lambda}]\), which for \(\lambda \gg 1\) is given the approximate form
where \(\delta ^{4}\mathcal{F}_{4}\) is the fourth variation of \(\mathcal{F}_{4}\), the first that does not vanish identically on \(\beta \equiv 0\).
For \(\alpha >1\), \(1/\lambda ^{2\alpha}\) is the dominant power in (47), but the minimum of \(\mathcal{F}_{\lambda}\) is not attained because \(\delta ^{2}\mathcal{F}_{2}(0)\) is unbounded below. To see this, it suffices to compute
for \(u_{A}=A\rho \), with \(A\) again a positive constant, which gives
by (34).
For \(\alpha =1\), both terms in (47) scale like \(1/\lambda ^{2}\) and \(\mathcal{F}_{\lambda}\) becomes
whose equilibrium equations are
which are solved by \(u= u_{\infty}\) with
For \(\alpha <1\), the second power in (47) prevails on the first, and the minimum is trivially \(u\equiv 0\). Thus, we conclude that in (46) we must set \(\alpha =1\) and \(u= u_{\infty}\), that is,
Correspondingly, it follows from (50) that
Finally, we study, for any given \(\lambda \), the behavior of the solutions to (36) subject to (35) for \(\rho \ll 1\). To this end, we take \(\beta _{\lambda}(\rho )\approx A\rho ^{\alpha}\) with \(A\) and \(\alpha \) positive constants and compute the limit as \(\rho \to 0\) in (36); it is easily checked that compatibility demands that \(\alpha =1\). Similarly, by taking \(\beta _{\lambda}(\rho )\approx A\rho +B\rho ^{2}\) and computing again the limit as \(\rho \to 0\) in (36), we see that \(B\) must vanish. We conclude that the minimum \(\beta _{\lambda}\) of \(\mathcal{F}_{\lambda}\) has the following asymptotic behavior,
with \(A\) a constant, in agreement with the graphs shown in Fig. 3. The constant \(A\) is related to the twist \(T\) on the cylinder’s axis, as it follows from (55) and (27b) that for \(\rho =0\) the distortion characteristics are
typical of a double twist.
4 Conclusions
The study of chromonics, which are lyotropic liquid crystals resulting from supramolecular aggregations dissolved in water, has revealed the emergence at the macroscopic scale of a twisted ground state, which owing to the achiral nature of the microscopic constituents occurs equally likely in two variants of opposite chiralities.
To accommodate these new materials within the classical elastic theory of liquid crystals, researchers hypothesized anomalously small twist constants and (comparatively) large saddle-splay constants, violating one of the Ericksen inequalities, which guarantee the classical Oseen-Frank stored energy to be bounded below. For equilibrium problems in confined, fixed geometries, such a violation seemed to have no consequences on the existence and stability of energy minimizers, but free-boundary problems were found paradoxical. In particular, minimizing sequences of tactoidal droplets were shown to drive the total energy to negative infinity by squeezing (double) twist within ever growing needle-shaped domains.
This paper proposes to describe the elasticity of chromonics by a adding to the Oseen-Frank classical energy density a term quartic in the measure of twist. In so doing, the theory introduces a phenomenological length \(a\), whose microscopic origin is as problematic as the origin of spontaneous (single) twist in cholesteric liquid crystals. We may speculate that \(a\) depends on temperature and it possibly arises from the flexibility of the supramolecular aggregates that constitute these materials.
Two are the major conclusions reached here. First, the proposed quartic twist theory is proven to remove the paradoxes encountered in free-boundary problems with the classical quadratic theory.
Second, when applied to chromonics confined in a capillary tube enforcing degenerate planar anchoring for the nematic director on the lateral boundary, the quartic twist theory predicts equilibrium configurations for that depend on the ratio \(\lambda =a/R\), where \(R\) is the capillary’s radius. Using published experimental data for SSY, we can estimate both \(K_{24}\) and \(a\). To further put the theory to the test, it might be worthwhile performing similar experiments on a series of capillaries with very different radia.
Two other theoretical challenges are suggested by this study. First, the proposed theory posits a degenerate double twist as ground state for chromonics. As recently shown in [41] for the non-degenerate double twist in the ground state of cholesterics, this is a source of elastic frustration. A natural question is then how such a frustration could be eased; the answer should depend on how the domain length scale compares with the phenomenological length \(a\).
A second, more demanding question is how \(a\) is related to the structure of the microscopic constituents of the material. A possible conjecture is that \(a\) arises from fluctuations in shape of the columnar aggregates that constitute the material. A statistical mechanics model that accounts for serpentining modes generated by the gliding of each molecular disk over its neighbors might identify the length scale associated with the most likely mode; this would then be related to \(a\).
These difficult questions should be addressed by future research.
Notes
These may be either molecules, molecular aggregates, or colloidal particles.
Tactoids are elongated, cylindrically symmetric shapes with pointed ends as poles.
It should also be noted that other theories are known as “quartic” (see, for, example, the classical paper [31] and the more recent contribution [32]), but they owe this name to an elastic term globally quartic in deGennes’ order tensor and its derivatives, added to the commonly considered version of the Landau-deGennes theory to resolve the splay-bend elastic constant degeneracy in the reduction to the Oseen-Frank theory. These theories serve a different purpose.
Also a paper by Zocher [35], mainly concerned with the effect of a magnetic field on director distortions, is often mentioned among the founding contributions. Some authors go to the extent of also naming the theory after him. Others, in contrast, name the theory only after Frank, as they only deem his contribution to be fully aware of the nature of as a mesoscopic descriptor of molecular order.
With opposite chiralities, one for each sign in (9).
In opposite senses, according to the sign of chirality.
In the elastic model proposed in [13] for twist-bend nematics, a quartic free energy was posited that admits as ground state either of two families of uniform heliconical fields with opposite chirality. There too, a length scale appears in the equilibrium pitch. The distortion state characterized by this length is the same everywhere.
The persistence length of self-assembled flexible aggregates is a length over which unit vectors tangential to the aggregates lose correlation. For CLCs, it is estimated on the order of tens to hundreds of \(\mathrm{nm}\) [43]
Via the naive geometric argument that represents chiral molecules as cylindrical screws and derives the pitch of their assemblies by close packing them so as to fit grooves with grooves.
For lyotropic cholesterics, the mismatch between microscopic and macroscopic pitches, which has recently received new experimental evidence in systems of basic living constituents [44, 45], is still debated. Interesting theories based on either molecular shape fluctuations [46, 47] or surface charge patterns [48] have met with some experimental disagreement [49].
Alternatively, we could require \(\beta (0)=\pm \pi \), but this would amount to change into , which does not affect the energy.
We are tacitly assuming that \(\beta \) has only one sign in \([0,1]\), which is a property expected for the minimizers of \(\mathcal{F}_{\lambda}\).
The absolute measured values are \(K_{11}\approx 4.3\,\mathrm{pN}\), \(K_{22}\approx 0.7\,\mathrm{pN}\), and \(K_{33}\approx 6.1\,\mathrm{pN}\).
This was further witnessed by checking how the fitting minimum error obtained for the parameters in (40) could be reduced by slightly reducing \(k_{3}\) from the chosen value \(k_{3}=8.7\).
References
Lydon, J.: Chromonic liquid crystal phases. Curr. Opin. Colloid Interface Sci. 3(5), 458–466 (1998). https://doi.org/10.1016/S1359-0294(98)80019-8
Lydon, J.: XVIII. Chromonics, pp. 981–1007. John Wiley & Sons, Weinheim, Germany (1998). https://doi.org/10.1002/9783527619276.ch15c
Lydon, J.: Chromonic review. J. Mater. Chem. 20, 10071–10099 (2010). https://doi.org/10.1039/B926374H
Lydon, J.: Chromonic liquid crystalline phases. Liq. Cryst. 38(11–12), 1663–1681 (2011). https://doi.org/10.1080/02678292.2011.614720
Dierking, I., Martins Figueiredo Neto, A.: Novel trends in lyotropic liquid crystals. Crystals 10(7), 604 (2020). https://doi.org/10.3390/cryst10070604
Nayani, K., Chang, R., Fu, J., Ellis, P.W., Fernandez-Nieves, A., Park, J.O., Srinivasarao, M.: Spontaneous emergence of chirality in achiral lyotropic chromonic liquid crystals confined to cylinders. Nat. Commun. 6, 8067 (2015). https://doi.org/10.1038/ncomms9067
Davidson, Z.S., Kang, L., Jeong, J., Still, T., Collings, P.J., Lubensky, T.C., Yodh, A.G.: Chiral structures and defects of lyotropic chromonic liquid crystals induced by saddle-splay elasticity. Phys. Rev. E 91, 050501 (2015). https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevE.91.050501. See also Erratum [58] and Supplementary Information
Fu, J., Nayani, K., Park, J., Srinivasarao, M.: Spontaneous emergence of twist and formation of monodomain in lyotropic chromonic liquid crystals confined to capillaries. NPG Asia Mater. 9, 393 (2017). https://doi.org/10.1038/am.2017.84
Javadi, A., Eun, J., Jeong, J.: Cylindrical nematic liquid crystal shell: effect of saddle-splay elasticity. Soft Matter 14, 9005–9011 (2018). https://doi.org/10.1039/C8SM01829D
Ondris-Crawford, R.J., Crawford, G.P., Zumer, S., Doane, J.W.: Curvature-induced configuration transition in confined nematic liquid crystals. Phys. Rev. Lett. 70, 194–197 (1993). https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.70.194
Cladis, P.E., Kléman, M.: Non-singular disclinations of strength \({S} = + 1\) in nematics. J. Phys. France 33(5–6), 591–598 (1972). https://doi.org/10.1051/jphys:01972003305-6059100
Meyer, R.B.: On the existence of even indexed disclinations in nematic liquid crystals. Philos. Mag. 27(2), 405–424 (1973). https://doi.org/10.1080/14786437308227417
Virga, E.G.: Uniform distortions and generalized elasticity of liquid crystals. Phys. Rev. E 100, 052701 (2019). https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevE.100.052701
Ericksen, J.L.: Inequalities in liquid crystal theory. Phys. Fluids 9(6), 1205–1207 (1966). https://doi.org/10.1063/1.1761821
Paparini, S., Virga, E.G.: Stability against the odds: the case of chromonic liquid crystals. J. Nonlinear Sci. 32, 74 (2022). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00332-022-09833-6
Long, C., Selinger, J.V.: Violation of Ericksen inequalities in lyotropic chromonic liquid crystals. J. Elast. (2022). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10659-022-09899-z
Paparini, S., Virga, E.G.: Paradoxes for chromonic liquid crystal droplets. Phys. Rev. E 106, 044703 (2022). https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevE.106.044703
Tortora, L., Park, H.-S., Kang, S.-W., Savaryn, V., Hong, S.-H., Kaznatcheev, K., Finotello, D., Sprunt, S., Kumar, S., Lavrentovich, O.D.: Self-assembly, condensation, and order in aqueous lyotropic chromonic liquid crystals crowded with additives. Soft Matter 6, 4157–4167 (2010). https://doi.org/10.1039/C0SM00065E
Tortora, L., Lavrentovich, O.D.: Chiral symmetry breaking by spatial confinement in tactoidal droplets of lyotropic chromonic liquid crystals. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 108(13), 5163–5168 (2011). https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1100087108
Peng, C., Lavrentovich, O.D.: Chirality amplification and detection by tactoids of lyotropic chromonic liquid crystals. Soft Matter 11, 7221–7446 (2015). https://doi.org/10.1039/C5SM01632K
Nayani, K., Fu, J., Chang, R., Park, J.O., Srinivasarao, M.: Using chiral tactoids as optical probes to study the aggregation behavior of chromonics. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. 114(15), 3826–3831 (2017). https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1614620114. https://www.pnas.org/content/114/15/3826.full.pdf
Shadpour, S., Vanegas, J.P., Nemati, A., Hegmann, T.: Amplification of chirality by adenosine monophosphate-capped luminescent gold nanoclusters in nematic lyotropic chromonic liquid crystal tactoids. ACS Omega 4, 1662–1668 (2019). https://doi.org/10.1021/acsomega.8b03335
Nehring, J., Saupe, A.: On the elastic theory of uniaxial liquid crystals. J. Chem. Phys. 54(1), 337–343 (1971). https://doi.org/10.1063/1.1674612
Oldano, C., Barbero, G.: An ab initio analysis of the second-order elasticity effect on nematic configurations. Phys. Lett. A 110(4), 213–216 (1985). https://doi.org/10.1016/0375-9601(85)90126-4
Dozov, I.: On the spontaneous symmetry breaking in the mesophases of achiral banana-shaped molecules. Europhys. Lett. 56(2), 247 (2001). https://doi.org/10.1209/epl/i2001-00513-x
Meyer, R.B.: Structural problems in liquid crystal physics. In: Balian, R., Weill, G. (eds.) Molecular Fluids. Les Houches Summer School in Theoretical Physics, vol. XXV–1973, pp. 273–373. Gordon and Breach, New York (1976)
Cestari, M., Diez-Berart, S., Dunmur, D.A., Ferrarini, A., de la Fuente, M.R., Jackson, D.J.B., Lopez, D.O., Luckhurst, G.R., Perez-Jubindo, M.A., Richardson, R.M., Salud, J., Timimi, B.A., Zimmermann, H.: Phase behavior and properties of the liquid-crystal dimer 1′′,7′′-bis(4-cyanobiphenyl-4′-yl) heptane: a twist-bend nematic liquid crystal. Phys. Rev. E 84, 031704 (2011). https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevE.84.031704
Lelidis, I., Barbero, G.: Nematic phases with spontaneous splay–bend deformation: standard elastic description. Liq. Cryst. 43(2), 208–215 (2016). https://doi.org/10.1080/02678292.2015.1078917
Barbero, G., Lelidis, I.: Fourth-order nematic elasticity and modulated nematic phases: a poor man’s approach. Liq. Cryst. 46(4), 535–542 (2019). https://doi.org/10.1080/02678292.2018.1512167
Lelidis, I., Barbero, G.: Nonlinear nematic elasticity. J. Mol. Liq. 275, 116–121 (2019). https://doi.org/10.1016/j.molliq.2018.11.029
Longa, L., Monselesan, D., Trebin, H.-R.: An extension of the Landau-Ginzburg-de Gennes theory for liquid crystals. Liq. Cryst. 2(6), 769–796 (1987). https://doi.org/10.1080/02678298708086335
Golovaty, D., Novack, M., Stenberg, P.: A novel Landau-de gennes model with quartic elastic terms. Eur. J. Appl. Math. 32(1), 177–198 (2021). https://doi.org/10.1017/S095679252000008X
Oseen, C.W.: The theory of liquid crystals. Trans. Faraday Soc. 29(4), 883–899 (1933). https://doi.org/10.1039/TF9332900883
Frank, F.C.: On the theory of liquid crystals. Discuss. Faraday Soc. 25, 19–28 (1958). https://doi.org/10.1039/DF9582500019
Zocher, H.: The effect of a magnetic field on the nematic state. Trans. Faraday Soc. 29, 945–957 (1933). https://doi.org/10.1039/TF9332900945
Virga, E.G.: Variational Theories for Liquid Crystals. Applied Mathematics and Mathematical Computation, vol. 8. Chapman & Hall, London (1994)
Selinger, J.V.: Interpretation of saddle-splay and the Oseen-Frank free energy in liquid crystals. Liq. Crystallogr. Rev. 6, 129–142 (2018). https://doi.org/10.1080/21680396.2019.1581103
Machon, T., Alexander, G.P.: Umbilic lines in orientational order. Phys. Rev. X 6, 011033 (2016). https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevX.6.011033
Selinger, J.V.: Director deformations, geometric frustration, and modulated phases in liquid crystals. Annu. Rev. Condens. Matter Phys. 13, 49–71 (2022). https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev-conmatphys-031620-105712. First posted online on October 12, 2021. Volume publication date, March 2022
Pedrini, A., Virga, E.G.: Liquid crystal distortions revealed by an octupolar tensor. Phys. Rev. E 101, 012703 (2020). https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevE.101.012703
Long, C., Selinger, J.V.: Explicit demonstration of geometric frustration in chiral liquid crystals. Soft Matter (2023). https://doi.org/10.1039/D2SM01420C
Rapini, A., Papoular, M.: Distorsion d’une lamelle mématique sous champ magnétique conditions d’ancrage aux parois. J. Phys., Colloq. 30(C4), 4–54456 (1969). Available at https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/jpa-00213715/document
Zhou, S.: Lyotropic Chromonic Liquid Crystals. Springer Theses. Springer, Cham, Switzerland (2017)
Stanley, C.B., Hong, H., Strey, H.H.: DNA cholesteric pitch as a function of density and ionic strength. Biophys. J. 89(4), 2552–2557 (2005). https://doi.org/10.1529/biophysj.105.064550
Tortora, M.M.C., Mishra, G., Prešern, D., Doye, J.P.K.: Chiral shape fluctuations and the origin of chirality in cholesteric phases of DNA origamis. Sci. Adv. 6(31), 5163–5168 (2020). https://doi.org/10.1126/sciadv.aaw8331
Harris, A.B., Kamien, R.D., Lubensky, T.C.: Microscopic origin of cholesteric pitch. Phys. Rev. Lett. 78, 1476–1479 (1997). https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.78.1476
Harris, A.B., Kamien, R.D., Lubensky, T.C.: Molecular chirality and chiral parameters. Rev. Mod. Phys. 71, 1745–1757 (1999). https://doi.org/10.1103/RevModPhys.71.1745
Kornyshev, A., Leikin, S., Malinin, S.: Chiral electrostatic interaction and cholesteric liquid crystals of DNA. Eur. Phys. J. E 7, 83–93 (2002). https://doi.org/10.1140/epje/i200101159
Grelet, E., Fraden, S.: What is the origin of chirality in the cholesteric phase of virus suspensions? Phys. Rev. Lett. 90, 198302 (2003). https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.90.198302
Virga, E.G.: Drops of nematic liquid crystals. Arch. Ration. Mech. Anal. 107, 371–390 (1989). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00251555. Reprinted in [59]
Lin, F.H., Poon, C.C.: On nematic liquid crystal droplets. In: Chow, B., Gulliver, R., Levy, S., Sullivan, J. (eds.) Elliptic and Parabolic Methods in Geometry, pp. 91–121. A. K. Peters/CRC Press, Wellesley (1996)
Geng, Z., Lin, F.: The two-dimensional liquid crystal droplet problem with a tangential boundary condition. Arch. Ration. Mech. Anal. 243, 1181–1221 (2022). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00205-021-01733-5
Lin, F., Wang, C.: Isotropic-nematic phase transition and liquid crystal droplets. Commun. Pure Appl. Math. (2022). https://doi.org/10.1002/cpa.22050
Osserman, R.: The isoperimetric inequality. Bull. Am. Math. Soc. 84, 1182–1238 (1978). https://doi.org/10.1090/S0002-9904-1978-14553-4
Burylov, S.V.: Equilibrium configuration of a nematic liquid crystal confined to a cylindrical cavity. J. Exp. Theor. Phys. 85(1), 873–886 (1997). https://doi.org/10.1134/1.558425
Zhou, S., Nastishin, Y.A., Omelchenko, M.M., Tortora, L., Nazarenko, V.G., Boiko, O.P., Ostapenko, T., Hu, T., Almasan, C.C., Sprunt, S.N., Gleeson, J.T., Lavrentovich, O.D.: Elasticity of lyotropic chromonic liquid crystals probed by director reorientation in a magnetic field. Phys. Rev. Lett. 109, 037801 (2012). https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.109.037801
Eun, J., Kim, S.-J., Jeong, J.: Effects of chiral dopants on double-twist configurations of lyotropic chromonic liquid crystals in a cylindrical cavity. Phys. Rev. E 100, 012702 (2019). https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevE.100.012702
Davidson, Z.S., Kang, L., Jeong, J., Still, T., Collings, P.J., Lubensky, T.C., Yodh, A.G.: Erratum: Chiral structures and defects of lyotropic chromonic liquid crystals induced by saddle-splay elasticity [Phys. Rev. E 91, 050501(R) (2015)]. Phys. Rev. E 92, 019905 (2015). https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevE.92.019905
Virga, E.G.: Drops of nematic liquid crystals. In: Markovitz, H., Mizel, V.J., Owen, D.R. (eds.) Mechanics and Thermodynamics of Continua, pp. 211–230. Springer, Berlin (1991)
Funding
Open access funding provided by Università degli Studi di Pavia within the CRUI-CARE Agreement.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Contributions
These authors contributed equally to this work.
Corresponding author
Ethics declarations
Competing interests
The authors declare no competing interests.
Additional information
Publisher’s Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Appendix: Data Fitting
Appendix: Data Fitting
In the experiment performed in [7] that we try to interpret with our theory, the capillary’s radius \(R=45.3\,\mu \mathrm{m}\) was determined within an error \(\Delta R=0.4\,\mu \mathrm{m}\). Thus, for a given \(a\), two different values of \(\lambda \) would be associated with \(R^{\pm}:=R\pm \Delta R\),
Actually, since \(\Delta R/R\approx 8.8\times 10^{-3}\), these values are close to one another and \(\lambda ^{+}/\lambda ^{-}\approx 1.02\). For a number of selected radii \(0< r_{i}< R\), the polar angle \(\beta \) was measured, producing data \(\beta _{i}\), each of which can be associated with any \(\rho ^{+}_{i}<\rho <\rho ^{-}_{i}\), where
Hence the red bar representing each \(\beta _{i}\) in Fig. 6.
We took \(k_{3}=8.7\) and used \(\lambda \) and \(k_{24}\) as fitting parameters and defined the (relative) error \(\mathsf{E}\) to be minimized as
where the sum is extended to all collected data. In Fig. 7, \(\mathsf{E}\) is plotted as a function of \(\lambda \) for several values of \(k_{24}\). The minimum of \(\mathsf{E}\) is attained for \(k_{24}=32.5\) and \(\lambda =0.142\); its value is \(\mathsf{E}_{\mathrm{min}}=0.263\). The corresponding function \(\beta _{\lambda}\) is plotted against the data bars in Fig. 6 (red curve). By setting \(\lambda =0\) and seeking the minimum of \(\mathsf{E}\) in both \(k_{3}\) and \(k_{24}\), we found \(k_{3}=6.67\) and \(k_{24}=27.5\), in complete agreement with [7]. For this choice of parameters \(\mathsf{E}_{\mathrm{min}}=0.254\). The corresponding function \(\beta _{0}\) is plotted against the data in Fig. 6 (blue curve); it is barely distinguishable from \(\beta _{\lambda}\).
Rights and permissions
Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article’s Creative Commons licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article’s Creative Commons licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this licence, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/.
About this article
Cite this article
Paparini, S., Virga, E.G. An Elastic Quartic Twist Theory for Chromonic Liquid Crystals. J Elast (2023). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10659-022-09983-4
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10659-022-09983-4