Abstract
Small arms must be considered as a public health problem, but quantifying the public health impact of small arms is difficult and studies are sparse in areas of conflict. This study considers the remote cross border area between Kenya and Uganda where pastoral conflict in the form of cattle raiding with the use of small arms has escalated in recent years, and where health facilities are scarce. Hospitals and clinics in Karamoja, Uganda, and West Pokot, Kenya were visited by the author, to collect any available data on small arms injuries. Interviews with hospital staff helped to provide further insight into the statistics. Statistics showed that most injuries were sustained during raiding, though worrying incidences of injury among noncombatants and young children were found. Many serious injuries and limb fractures were documented, likely to have some long-term implications for pain, growth, disability, and livelihood. Deaths and injuries are likely to be significantly underestimated by the statistics, due to problems of transport, insecurity, deaths prior to arrival, admission fees for some facilities, and fear of reporting injuries due to the criminal element. Police statistics support this conclusion. The situation appeared to be worse in Uganda as opposed to Kenya, but cooperation between the two countries is needed since pastoralists readily cross the borders both to raid and to attend clinics and hospitals.
Similar content being viewed by others
Notes
Interview with Dr. Marina Anghileri, Ministry of Health Matany mission hospital, Uganda, 21 June 2001. When I visited the Doctor she was so scared that she was even not willing to allow any interviews.
Mkutu [45].
See for example the military operation to flush our Ethiopian Oromo liberation front (OLF) rebels in Moyale Kenya. The conflict is spilling arms into Kenya. See Kenya Times 18 June 2004. http://kentimes.com/18jun04/nwsstory/news22.html. See also Daily Nation 18 June 2004 “Search for Ethiopian rebels is stepped up.” Seven guns and 70,000 bullets, landmines and grenades have been recovered from the armories belonging to OLF. See more in Mkutu [46, 48].
Interviews Moroto and Kotido October–November 2004.
IRIN, 3 February “Amnesty and Peace groups urge International Criminal Court to probe government army too”
Note that for many years Sudan government armed, trained and sheltered the LRA [Lord’s Resistance Army] in its territory and gave them the means to commit their crimes.
See for example IRIN 8 September 2003. “The Uganda government admitted using militia groups to fight the Lords resistance army.”
Interview elder Koritantoyo Nakiliro, 2 February 2003.
This include the vigilante groups and militia and warriors.
SAS [67]: 174–175 and 201–202.
Government of Kenya Economical Survey [21]: 44
GoK [22]. Poverty Reduction Strategy Program 2001–2004: 59
Mkutu [48]
SNV [68]
Research and policy tends to focus on supply-related issues such as the production and the mismanagement of stockpiles, inter-state transfers and illicit trade, technical aspects of weapons tracing, marking, collection and destruction, and on legal or normative regimes designed to stop the flow of weapons. See SAS [66]: 155.
Karamoja and Sebei in Uganda and Pokot, Turkana and even Tranzonia in Kenya.
West Pokot and Karamoja was part of the Eastern Province of Uganda until 1926, parts of the Eastern Province of Uganda including West Pokot was moved to Kenya by the British government.
Kotido (2), Moroto (2) and Nakapiripirit (1) see http://www.health.go.ug/health units.htm.
Based on the final results of the September 2002 National Population and Housing Census, Kotido District, which includes the newly created district of Kaabong has a population of 605,322 (302,206 males and 303,116 females). Moroto District has a population of 194,773 (98,145 males and 96,628 females). Nakapiripirit has a population of 155,150 (78,284 males and 76,866 females). These figures are questionable, how can a population increase from nearly 300,000 (1991) to nearly one million in 2003?. See Mkutu [48], Chapter 1 UBOs [72]. However, increase from 1991 figures to current figures is question see Mkutu [50].
See http://www.health.go.ug/health units.htm.
Kabongo became a district this year; initially the district headquarters for the region was Kotido.
GOK [20].
Interview Stephen Kaadu, 20 June 2001
The ratio of doctor to patient in West Pokot is 1:84. This is 528 in a population of 337,870 people. West Pokot Annual report 2002–2008, 2002:8
For an extensive write up on the methods see Mkutu [48] chapter 1.
If it is reported that the enemies made the injury the cost is 100,000 UgSh. But if a warrior is shot during raiding the cost is 200,000 Uganda Shillings. Interview medical officer, Name withheld, Moroto 27 November, 2004
Interview Peter Lodonga, Nursing assistant Lopotuku dispensary, 29 September 2004
See SNV [68]
Peterken former Resident District Commissioner. Interview, Nakapiripirit, Uganda, 26 January 2003.
Dr Kaadu, Stephen, former Doctor at Amudat mission hospital Interview Amudat, 18 June 2001. Also Dr. Motanya, David, former Ministry of Health in charge, Kapenguria District Hospital, Interview, Kapenguria, August, 2002.
Due to a road ambush of the supervisor at Matany, and because a big raid had just taken place, she was so upset that she refused to release any data.
Superintendent of Matany Hospital. Interview, Matany, 20 June 2001. On the day of the interview a big had taken place and 17 warriors had been brought to the hospital.
The hospital charged 20,000 Uganda shillings before they would touch any one admitted with a gunshot wound. The purpose was to discourage cattle raiding.
Interviews in June 2001, and also interviews at Amudat, 27 January 2003. Interview with a Solider based in Nakapiripirit noted that over 1000 people have been killed due to banditry on the Namalu-Moroto road.
Nurse, name with held, Interview, Amudat Hospital, 27 January 2003.
Records of District Health Office, Nakapiripirit, July 2001–2002.
Various sources from Kangole, Moroto, Namalu and Amudat, Uganda. See SNV [68]. Note that the Lutheran World Relief is trying to assist women in Nabilatuku to buy grain to sell But most of the women invested their money in local brew as it gives them better returns. See for example Daily Monitor 2 June 2003. http://www.monitor.co.ug/archives/2003main/jun/news/0602/news8.php. It notes that waragi (local beer) drinking has heightened insecurity is and therefore a cause of deaths in the area.
Motanya, David, Interview, Kapenguria, 22 May 2001
Adome, Lokwi, Local Council Chairman Kotido, Interview, Moroto, 22 November 2003.
Amukuriate Dispensary staff. Interviews, Alale, West Pokot, 2 August, 2002.
Ibid.
Cheboi Florence, op. cit.
Interviews Medical Superintendent Kapenguria District Hospital, Kapenguria, August 2002. The District commissioner concurred and not that at least in a month there is always one or two raids with many people injured. Interview Kapenguria, August 2002
Police Daily Occurrence Records, Kapenguria 2000.
Interview Alale, August 2002, Interview of warriors in Panyangara Oct 2004.
Interview Edison Achia, Moroto 2 October 2004.
SNV [68].
Interview young girl of 15 in Loputuk 29 October 2004.
Interviews Lotirir mothers group, 1 October, 2004
Interview Novelli, Moroto 17 July 2001; See Novelli [55]
Field research Alale, Kenya 2002 see Mkutu [48].
Interviews in November 2004 indicated that before you are operated it is now 100,000 and if wounded while in a raid it is 200,000 Uganda shillings.
Daily Nations 18 August, 2005 “20 million Kenyans can’t afford drugs” http://www.nationmedia.com/dailynation/nmgcontenterty.asp?category_id=1&newsid=55310 assed on 18 August. The study compared drug prices in 53 public health facilities, 57 private and 47 missions’ health centres.
Ibid.
See for example WHO [78] which argues that they are among the top five contributors to the global health burden among people aged 15–44.
References
Abbink, J. (2000). Violence and the crisis of conciliation. Suri, Dizi and the state in South-West Ethiopia. Africa, 70(4), 527–550.
Abrahams, R. E. (1987). Sungusungu: Village vigilante groups in Tanzania. African Affairs, 86, 179–190.
Anderson, D. (1986). Stock theft and moral economy in colonial Kenya. Africa, 56, 309–416.
Anderson, D. (2002). Vigilantes, violence and the problem of public order in Kenya. African Affairs, 101, 531–555.
Arya, N. (2002). Confronting the small arms pandemic. BMJ, 324, 990–991.
Belshaw, D., & Malinga, M. (1999). The Kalashnikov economies of the Eastern Sahel: Cumulative or cyclical differentiation between nomadic pastoralists. First workshop of the study group on conflict and security of the development studies association. South Bank University, South Bank, University of East Anglia.
Bollig, M. (1993). Intra and interethnic conflict in North-Western Kenya: A multicasual analysis of conflict behaviour. Anthropos, 87, 176–184.
Bollig, M. (2003). The emergence, intensification and decline of pastoralism: The case of the Kenyan Pokot. Konigswinter conference. Konigswinter.
Boutwell, J., & Klare, M. (2000). A scourge of small arms. Scientific American, 6, 48–53.
Bukururu, S. (1996). Combating crime among the Sukuma and Nyamwezi of west-central Tanzania. Crime, Law and Social Change, 24(3), 257–266.
Cappon, J. C. (2003). Why do communities want arms: Community security, small arms and governance in Kerio Valley. Controlling the demand for small arms: The search for strategies in the Horn of Africa and in the Balkans. The Hague: Pax Christi.
Cohen, D. (2005). Providing nomadic people with health care. BMJ, 331, 720.
Cukier, W. (2002). Small arms and light weapons: A public health approach. Brown Journal of World Affairs, IX(1), 261–280.
Dietz, T. (1987). Pastoralists in Dire Straits: Survival strategies and external interventions in a semi-arid region at the Kenya/Uganda border; Western Pokot, 1900–1986. Geography. Amsterdam: University of Amsterdam.
Egesa, J., & Mkutu, K. (2000). The role of provincial administration in the management of small arms. Nairobi: African Peace Forum.
Fleisher, M. (2000a). Sungusungu: State-sponsored village vigilante groups among the Kuria of Tanzania. Africa, 70(2), 209–228.
Fleisher, M. (2000b). Kuria cattle raiders: Violence and vigilantism on the Tanzania/Kenya frontier. Ann Arbor, MI: University of Michigan Press.
Fukui, K., & Turton, D. (Ed.) (1979). Warfare among East African herders. Senri ethnological series, no 3. Osaka: Museum of Ethnology.
Gomes, N., & Mkutu, K. (2003). The challenges of small arms and building capacity for development in Karamoja. Mbala: SNV/Paxi Christi.
Government of Kenya (GoK) (2001). 1999 Population and housing census. Nairobi: Central Bureau of Statistics.
Government of Kenya (GoK) (2004a). Economic survey. Nairobi: Government Printers.
Government of Kenya (GoK) (2004b). Poverty reduction strategy paper for period 2001–2004. Nairobi: Ministry of Finance.
Government of Uganda (GoU) (2004). Annual health sector performance report. Kampala: Uganda Ministry of Health.
Government of Uganda (GoU) (2005). Karamoja integrated disarmament and development programme: Creating conditions for promoting human security and recovery in Karamoja 2005–2008. Kampala: Office of the Prime Minister.
Gulliver, P. H. (1955). The family herds: A study of two pastoral tribes in East Africa: the Jie and Turkana. London: Routledge and Kegan.
Heald, S. (1999). Agricultural intensification and the decline of pastoralism: A Kenyan case study. Africa, 69(2), 213–237.
Heald, S. (2000). Tolerating the intolerable: Cattle raiding among the Kuria. In G. Aijmer & J. Abbink (Eds.), Meanings of violence. Oxford: Berg.
Heald, S. (2002). Domesticating Leviathan: Sungu Sungu Groups in Tanzania. London: Crisis Group.
Heald, S. (2006). State, law and vigilantism in northern Tanzania. African Affairs, 105(419), 265–283.
Hendrickson, D. (1999). The conflict, security and development group working paper 1. London: Center for Defence Studies.
Jackson, T., Marsh, N., Owen, T., & Thurin, A. (2005). Who takes the bullet? Understanding the issues. Oslo: Norwegian Church Aid (77).
Kimalu, P., Nafula, N., Manda, D., Bedi, A., Mwabu, G., & Kimenyi, M. (2004). A review of the health sector in Kenya. Nairobi: Kenya Institute of Public Policy Research and Analysis (KIPPRA).
Kinsella, D. (1994). Conflict context: Arms transfers and third world rivalries during the cold war. American Journal of Political Science, 38(3), 557–581.
Knighton, B. (2003). Raiders among the Karamojong, where there are no guns, they use threat of guns. African Affairs, 3, 427–455.
Lamphear, J. (1976). The traditional history of the Jie of Uganda. Oxford: Clarendon Press.
Lefebvre, J. A. (1992). Arms for the Horn: US security policy in Ethiopia and Somalia 1953–1991. Pittsburgh, PA: University of Pittsburgh Press.
Lyons, R. (1994). The USSR, China and the Horn of Africa. Review of African Political Economy.
Makinda, S. (1982). Conflict and superpower in the Horn of Africa. Third World Quarterly, 4(1), 93–103.
Makinda, S. (1992). Security in the Horn: An analysis of post cold- war developments in regional security and emerging strategic issues in Ethiopia, Somalia, Sudan and Djibouti. London.
Makinda, S. (1995). Security in the Horn of Africa: An analysis of post-cold war developments in regional security and emerging strategic issues in Ethiopia, Somalia, Sudan and Djibouti. London: IISS.
McCabe, T. J. (2004). Cattle bring us to our enemies: Turkana ecology, politics, and raiding in a disequilibrium system. Ann Arbor, MI: University of Michigan Press.
Mirzeler, M., & Young, C. (2000). Pastoral politics in the Northeast periphery in Uganda: AK-47 as change agent. Journal of Modern African Studies, 38(3), 407–429.
Mkangi, K. (1997). Indigenous social mechanism of conflict resolution in Kenya: A contextualized paradigm for examining conflict in Africa. Nairobi.
Mkutu, K. (2000). Banditry, cattle rustling and the proliferation of small arms: The case of Baragoi division of Samburu, district. Improving human security in East Africa. Nairobi: Africa Peace Forum.
Mkutu, K. (2001). Pastoralism and conflict in the Horn of Africa. Nairobi/London/Bradford: African peace forum/Safer world/University of Bradford.
Mkutu, K. (2003). Pastoralist conflict and small arms: Kenya–Uganda cross border region. London: Saferworld.
Mkutu, K. (2004). The challenges of small arms and insecurity and attempts at management in Northeastern Uganda, Karamoja. Seminar, paper presented at Oxford University, 31 January. Northeast Africa Seminar Series. St. Athoney College Oxford.
Mkutu, K. (2005). Pastoralist conflict, governance and small arms in the northrift, North East Africa. Peace studies. Bradford: 477.
Mkutu, K. (2007). Small arms amongst pastoralists on the Kenya-Uganda border area. African Affairs, 422(106), 47–70.
Mkutu, K. (upcoming). Pastoralist conflict, governance and small arms in NorthEast Africa. Upcoming. London.
Muhereza, E. F. (1997b). Cross-border grazing and challenges for development in the dry lands areas of Eastern Africa: The case of Karamoja. International conference on economic intergration and trans-boundary resources, Addis Ababa. Ethiopia.
Ndagala, D. K. (1990). Pastoralists and the state in Tanzania. Nomadic Peoples, 25(27), 51–64.
Niamir-Fuller, M. (1999). Conflict management and mobility among the pastoralists in Karamoja. Managing mobility in African rangelands. London: ITDG.
Novelli, B. (1999). Karimojong traditional religion. Kampala: Comboni Missionaries.
Novelli, B. (2001). Karimojong,traditional religion. Kampala: Comboni Missionaries.
Nyaba, A. P., & Otim, P. (2001). Cross border pastoral conflicts: A case of study of Kenya, Sudan and Uganda border sub-region. IGAD conflict early warning and response mechanism (CEWARN). Addis Ababa. (unpublished).
Ocan, C. E. (1992). Pastoral crisis in North-Eastern Uganda: The changing significance of cattle raids. Kampala: Center for Basic Research.
Odegi, A. (1992). Life in the balance: Ecological sociology of Turkana nomads. Nairobi: ACTs.
Patman, R. (1989). The Soviet Union in the Horn of Africa: The diplomacy of intervention and disengagement. London: Cambridge University Press.
Pazzaglia, A. (1982). The Karimojong some aspects. Bologna: Camboni Missionaries.
Pkalya, R., Mohammud, A., & Masinde, I. (2004). Indigeneous democracy: traditional conflict resolution mechanisms: Pokot, Turkana, Samburu and Marakwet. Nairobi, ITDG, Eastern Africa.
Porter, B. D. (1984). The USSR in the third world conflicts: Soviet arms and diplomacy in local wars 1945–1980. London: Cambridge University Press.
Quam, M. D. (1996). Creating peace in an armed society: Karamoja, Uganda. African Journal Studies Quarterly, 1(1).
Riamriam (2005). The Policy Advocacy Role (PAR) of Civil Society Organizations (CSOs) in Karamoja: The challenges and success. Moroto: Riamriam.
Robin, M. C. (1996). The effect of weapons on health. Lancet, 347, 450–451.
SAS (2002). The 2001 UN conference on small arms: Chapter 5. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
SAS (2004). Rights at risk. Oxford: Geneva.
SNV (2005). Armed pastoralist conflicts and peace building in Karamoja. The role of gender. Kampala: SNV.
SNV, Pax Christi (2004). Breaking the circle for violence, building capacity for development in Karamoja, Uganda. Kampala: SNV, Pax Christi.
Tornay, S. (1979). Armed conflict in the Lower Omo Valley, 1970–76: An analysis from within Nyangatom society. Warfare among the East African herders. In Fuki, Kurimoto, & D. Osaka (Eds.), Senri ethnological studies. National Museum of Ethnology.
Tornay, S. (1994). Generation set systems on the threshold of the third millennium: An anthropological perspective. In S. Kurimoto & Simonse (Eds.), Conflict age and power. London: James Currey.
UBOs (2003). Statistical abstracts for 2003/4. Kampala: Uganda Bureau of Statistics.
UN (1997). Report of the panel of government experts on small arms. Geneva: United Nations.
UNDP (1999). Kenya Human Development Report, http://www.ke.undp.org/Kenya_Human_Development_Report_1999.pdf.
Walker, R. (2002). Anti-pastoralism and the growth of poverty and insecurity in Karamoja: Disarmament and development dilemmas. Kampala: DFID.
WHO (1996). WHA 49.25:The prevention of violence: A priority for public health. Geneva: World Health Organization.
WHO (2001a). Macroeconomic and health: Investing in health for economic development. Report of the Commission on Macroeconomic and Health. Geneva, Switzerland: World Health Organization.
WHO (2001b). Small arms and global health: WHO contribution to the UN conference on illicit in small arms and light weapons 9th–20 July. UN conference on illicit in small arms and light weapons. New York: WHO.
WHO (2002). World report on violence and health, http://www.who.int/violence_injury_prevention/violence/world_report/en/chap1.pdf.
Acknowledgement
Thanks to SNV-Uganda for giving me the opportunity to work for them as an advisor and enabling me collect data. Thanks to my editor Tessa Mkutu, who is a general practitioner in Ashcroft Surgery, Undercliffe, UK.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Mkutu, K.A. Impact of small arms insecurity on the public health of pastoralists in the Kenya–Uganda border regions. Crime Law Soc Change 47, 33–56 (2007). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10611-007-9056-6
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10611-007-9056-6