Abstract
New technical information may lead to scientific beliefs that diverge over time from the a posteriori right answer. We call this phenomenon, which is particularly problematic in the global change arena, negative learning. Negative learning may have affected policy in important cases, including stratospheric ozone depletion, dynamics of the West Antarctic ice sheet, and population and energy projections. We simulate negative learning in the context of climate change with a formal model that embeds the concept within the Bayesian framework, illustrating that it may lead to errant decisions and large welfare losses to society. Based on these cases, we suggest approaches to scientific assessment and decision making that could mitigate the problem. Application of the tools of science history to the study of learning in global change, including critical examination of the assessment process to understand how judgments are made, could provide important insights on how to improve the flow of information to policy makers.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Explore related subjects
Discover the latest articles, news and stories from top researchers in related subjects.Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
Abbott A (2005) Gut feeling secures medical Nobel for Australian doctors. Nature 437:801
Alley RB, Clark PU, Huybrechts P, Joughin I (2005) Ice-sheet and sea-level changes. Science 310:456–460 DOI 10.1126/science.1114613
Andronova NG, Schlesinger ME (2001) Objective estimation of the probability density function for climate sensitivity. J Geophys Res 106(D19):22,605–22,611
Arrow KJ, Fisher AC (1974) Environmental protection, uncertainty, and irreversibility. Q J Econ 88:312–319
Benedick R (1998) Ozone diplomacy: new directions in safeguarding the planet. Harvard Univ Press, Cambridge, MA
Bongaarts J, Bulatao RA (eds) (2000) Beyond six billion: forecasting the world’s population. National Academy Press, Washington, DC
Christie M (2001) Ozone layer: a philosophy of science perspective. Cambridge Univ Press, Cambridge, UK, New York
Craig PP, Gadgil A, Koomey JG (2002) What can history teach us? A retrospective examination of long-term energy forecasts for the United States. Annu Rev Energy Environ 27:83–118
Crutzen P, Oppenheimer M (2008) Learning about ozone depletion. Clim Change (this issue). DOI 10.1007/s10584-008-9400-6
Draper D (1995) Assessment and propagation of model uncertainty. J R Stat Soc Ser B Stat Methodol 57:45–97
Frederick S, Loewenstein G, O’Donoghue T (2002) Time discounting and time preference: a critical review. J Econ Lit XL:351–401
Funtowicz SO, Ravetz JR (1992) The emergence of postnormal science. In: von Schomberg R (ed) Science, politics, and morality. Kluwer Academic, Dordrecht, pp 85–123
Füssel H-M (2007) Methodological and empirical flaws in the design and application of simple climate-economy models. Clim Change 81:161–185
Ha-Duong M, Mégie G, Hauglustaine D (2003) A pro-active stratospheric ozone protection scenario. Global Environ Change 13:43–49
Hall J, Fu G, Lawry J (2007) Imprecise probabilities of climate change: aggregation of fuzzy scenarios and model uncertainties. Clim Change 81:265–281
Hansen JE (2005) Slippery slope: How much global warming constitutes “dangerous anthropogenic interference”? Clim Change 68:269–279
Henrion M, Fischhoff B (1986) Assessing uncertainty in physical constants. Am J Phys 54:791–797
Huntington HG (1994) Oil price forecasting in the 1980s: what went wrong? Energy J 15:1–22
Jones RA, Ostroy JM (1984) Flexibility and uncertainty. Revs Econ Studies L1:13–32
Joos F, Müller-Fürstenberger G, Stephan G (1999) Correcting the carbon cycle representation: how important is it for the economics of climate change? Environ Model Assess 4:133–140
Kaufmann R (1997) Assessing the dice model: uncertainty associated with the emission and retention of greenhouse gases. Clim Change 35:435–448
Keilman N (1999) How accurate are United Nations population forecasts? In: Lutz W, Vaupel JW, Ahlburg DA (eds) Issue supplement: frontiers of population forecasting, Pop Develop Rev 24:15–41
Keller K, McInerney D (2007) The dynamics of learning about a climate threshold. Clim Dyn 30:321–332 DOI 10.1007/s00382–007–0290–5
Keller K, Bolker BM, Bradford DF (2004) Uncertain climate thresholds and optimal economic growth. J Environ Econ Manage 48:723–741
Kelly DL, Kolstad CD (1999) Bayesian learning, growth, and pollution. J Econ Dyn Control 23:491–518
Kitcher P (1993) The advancement of science: science without legends, objectivity without illusions. Oxford Univ Press, New York
Kolstad CD (1996) Learning and stock effects in environmental regulation: the case of greenhouse gas emissions. J Environ Econ Manage 31:1–18
Kuhn TS (1962) The structure of scientific revolutions. Univ of Chicago Press, Chicago
Lange A (2003) Climate change and the irreversibility effect – combining expected utility and maximin. Environ Res Econ 25:417–434
Lee R, Tuljapurkari S, Lee RD, Auerback AJ (eds) (2000) Demographic change and fiscal policy. Cambridge Univ Press, Cambridge, UK
Lempert RJ, Schlesinger ME, Bankes SC (1996) When we don’t know the costs or the benefits: adaptive strategies for abating climate change. Clim Change 33:235–274
Lempert RJ, Popper SW, Bankes SC (2003) Shaping the next one hundred years: new methods for quantitative, long-term policy analysis. Rand Corporation, Santa Monica
Lenton TM et al (2008) Tipping elements in the earth’s climate system. PNAS 105:1786–1793
Little C et al (2007) Toward a new generation of ice sheet models. Eos 88:578–579
Lutz W, Sanderson W, Scherbov S (2001) The end of world population growth. Nature 412:543–545
MacAyeal DR (1992) Irregular oscillations of the West Antarctic ice sheet. Nature 359:29–32
Morgan MG, Henrion M (1990) Uncertainty: a guide to dealing with uncertainty in quantitative risk and policy analysis. Cambridge Univ Press, Cambridge, New York
Morgan MG, Kandlikar M, Risbey J, Dowlatabadi H (1999) Why conventional tools for policy analysis are often inadequate for problems of global change. Clim Change 41:271–281
Moss RH, Schneider S (2000). In: Pachauri R, Taniguchi T, Tanaka K (eds) Guidance papers on the cross cutting issues of the Third Assessment Report of the IPCC. IPCC, Geneva
Nordhaus WD, Boyer J (2000) Warming the world: economic models of global warming. MIT Press, Cambridge, Mass
NRC (1984) Causes and effects of changes in stratospheric ozone: update 1983. National Academy Press, Washington, DC
O’Neill BC, Scherbov S, Lutz W (1999) The long-term effect of the timing of fertility decline on population size. Pop Develop Rev 25:749–756
Oppenheimer M (1998) Global warming and the stability of the West Antarctic ice sheet. Nature 393:325–332
Oppenheimer M, Alley RB (2004) The West Antarctic ice sheet and long term climate policy. Clim Change 64:1–10
Oppenheimer M, O’Neill BC, Webster M, Agrawala S (2007) The limits of consensus. Science 317:1505–1506
Oreskes N, Shrader-Frechette K, Belitz K (1994) Verification, validation, and confirmation of numerical models in the earth sciences. Science 263:641–646
Overpeck JT, Otto-Bliesner BL, Miller GH et al (2006) Paleoclimatic evidence for future ice-sheet instability and rapid sea-level rise. Science 311:1747–1750
Parson E (2003) Protecting the ozone layer: science and strategy. Oxford Univ Press, Oxford, New York
Patt AG (1999) Extreme outcomes: the strategic treatment of low probability events in scientific assessments. Risk Decis Policy 4:1–15
Patt AG (2007) Assessing model-based and conflict-based uncertainty. Glob Environ Change 17:37–46
Pielke RA Jr (2001) Room for doubt. Nature 410:151
Popp D (2004) ENTICE: endogenous technological change in the DICE model of global warming. J Environ Econ Manage 48:742–768
Rahmstorf S (2007) A semi-empirical approach to projecting future sea-level rise. Science 315:368–370
Rahmstorf S, Cazenave A, Church JA, Hansen JE, Keeling RF, Parker DE, Somerville RCJ (2007) Recent climate observations compared to projections. Science 316:709
Rowland FS (1989) Chlorofluorocarbons and the depletion of stratospheric ozone. Am Sci 77:36–45
Schelling TC (1994) Intergenerational discounting. Energy Policy 23:395–402
Schneider SH, Turner BL, Garriga HM (1998) Imaginable surprise in global change science. J Risk Res 1:165–185
Shlyakhter AI (1994) An improved framework for uncertainty analysis: accounting for unsuspected errors. Risk Anal 14:441–447
Small MJ, Fischbeck PS (1999) False precision in Bayesian updating with incomplete models. J Hum Ecol Risk Assess 5(2):291–304
Somerville R, Le Treut H, Cubasch U, Ding Y, Mauritzen C, Mokssit A, Peterson T, Prather M (2007) Historical overview of climate change. In: Solomon S, Qin D et al (eds) Climate change 2007: the physical science basis. Contribution of working group I to the Fourth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. Cambridge Univ Press, Cambridge, UK, New York
Tversky A, Kahneman D (1974) Judgment under uncertainty: heuristics and biases. Science 185:1124–1131
UN Department of Economic and Social Affairs, Population Division (2005) World population prospects: the 2004 revision. United Nations, New York
van de Kaa DJ (1987) Europe’s second demographic transition. Population Bulletin 42(1), The Population Reference Bureau, Washington, DC
van Vuuren D, O’Neill BC (2006) The consistency of IPCC’s SRES scenarios to 1990–2000 trends and recent projections. Clim Change 75:9–46
Vaughan DG (2008) West Antarctic ice sheet collapse − the fall and rise of a paradigm. Clim Change, in press
Vaughan DG, Spouge JR (2002) Risk estimation of collapse of the West Antarctic ice sheet. Clim Change 52:65–91
Webster MD (2002) The curious role of learning: should we wait for more data? Energy J 23:97–119
Webster MD, Jakobovits L, Norton J (2008) Learning about climate change and implications for near-term policy. Clim Change (this issue). DOI 10.1007/s10584-008-9406-0
WMO (1986) Atmospheric ozone 1985: assessment of our understanding of the processes controlling its present distribution and change. Rep No 16, WMO, Geneva
WMO (1988) Report of the international ozone trends panel-1988. Global Ozone Research and Monitoring Project, Rep No18, WMO, Geneva
WMO (1991) Scientific assessment of stratospheric ozone 1991. Rep No 25, WMO, Geneva
WMO (2006) Scientific assessment of ozone depletion: 2006, executive summary. WMO and UN Environment Program, Geneva
Yohe G, Andronova NG, Schlesinger ME (2004) To hedge or not against an uncertain climate future? Science 306:416–417
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Electronic supplementary material
Below is the link to the electronic supplementary material.
Rights and permissions
Open Access This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Noncommercial License (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/2.0), which permits any noncommercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author(s) and source are credited.
About this article
Cite this article
Oppenheimer, M., O’Neill, B.C. & Webster, M. Negative learning. Climatic Change 89, 155–172 (2008). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10584-008-9405-1
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10584-008-9405-1