Journal of Business Ethics

, Volume 78, Issue 4, pp 575–600 | Cite as

Philosophical Foundations of Workplace Spirituality: A Critical Approach

Article

Abstract

It is an undeniable reality that workplace spirituality has received growing attention during the last decade. This fact is attributable to many factors, socioeconomic, cultural and others [Hicks, D.A. 2003: Religion and the Workplace. Pluralism, Sprtituality, Leadership (Cambridge University press, Cambridge)]. However the field is full of obscurity and imprecision for the researcher, the practitioner, the organisational analyst and whoever attempts to systematically approach this relatively new inquiry field. This article attempts to provide a critical review of the literature on workplace spirituality by examining the underlying rationale of the main trends regarding spirit at Work and by negotiating their strengths and weaknesses. Current approaches to workplace spirituality are distinguished to the exploratory, contextual and the consequential, acontextual ones. Particular attention is given to ‚Respectful Pluralism’ proposed by Douglas Hicks, as it is suggested that this theoretical framework is the most well-founded, elaborated and systematic up to date. However, it is proposed that even ‚Respectful Pluralism’ fails to fully capture the complexity of such a multidimensional phenomenon as spirituality. Drawing on mainstream ethical and philosophical traditions (deontology, utilitarianism, virtue ethics) supporting alternative value-systems, it is suggested that a more inclusive and philosophically affluent framework needs to be developed. Finally, some propositions and thoughts are made towards this direction.

Keywords

consequential approaches contextual models deontology organisational positive outcomes respectful pluralism workplace spirituality utilitarianism virtue ethics 

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

References

  1. Adams D. W., Csiernik R. (2002) Seeking the Lost Spirit. Understanding Spirituality and Restoring it to the Workplace. Employee Assistance Quarterly, 17(1):31–44Google Scholar
  2. Ancona D., Kochan T., Scully M., Van Maanen J., Westney D. E. (1999) Organizational Behaviour and Processes South-Western College Publishing, BostonGoogle Scholar
  3. Ashforth B. E., Pratt M. G. (2003) Institutionalized Spirituality: An Oxymoron? In R. A. Giacalone, C. L. Jurkiewicz (eds.), Handbook of Workplace Spirituality and Organizational Performance. M.E. Sharpe, Armonk, NY, pp. 93–107Google Scholar
  4. Ashmos D. D., Duchon D. (2000) Spirituality at Work: A Conceptualization and Measure. Journal of Management Inquiry 9(2):134–145Google Scholar
  5. Bell E., Taylor S. (2004) From Outward Bound to Inward Bound: The Prophetic Voices and Discursive Practices of Spiritual Management Development. Human Relations 57(4):439–466Google Scholar
  6. Benefiel M. (2003) Irreconcilable foes? The Discourse Of Spirituality And The Discourse Of Organizational Science. Organization 10(2):383–391Google Scholar
  7. Biberman J., Whitty M. (1997) A Postmodern Spiritual Future for Work. Journal of Organizational Change Management 10(2):130–138Google Scholar
  8. Boozer, R. W.: 1998, `Spirituality in Management Education', The Journal of Workplace Learning 10(6), 345–347Google Scholar
  9. Bouma G., Haidar A., Nyland C., Smith W. (2003) Work, Religious Diversity and Islam. Asia Pacific Journal of Human Resources 41(1):51–61Google Scholar
  10. Bowie N. (1998) A Kantian Theory of Meaningful Work. Journal of Business Ethics 17(9/10):1083–1092Google Scholar
  11. Bowie N. (2000) A Kantian Theory of Leadership. The Leadership and Organisational Development Journal 21(4):185–193Google Scholar
  12. Bragues G. (2006) Seek the Good Life, Not Money: The Aristotelian Approach to Business Ethics. Journal of Business Ethics 67(4):341–357Google Scholar
  13. Bright D. S., Cameron K. S., Caza A. (2006) The Amplifying and Buffering Effects of Virtuousness in Downsized Organizations. Journal of Business Ethics 64(3):249–269Google Scholar
  14. Brown R. B. (2003) Organizational Spirituality: The Sceptic’s Version. Organization 12(2):393–400Google Scholar
  15. Burack E. H. (1999) Spirituality in the Workplace. Journal of Organizational Change Management 12(4):280–291Google Scholar
  16. Capra F. (1982) The Turning Point: Science, Society and the Rising Culture Bantam Books, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  17. Cartwright S., Holmes N. (2006) The Meaning of Work. the Challenge of Regaining Employee Engagement and Reducing Cynicism. Human Resource Management Review, 16(2):199–208Google Scholar
  18. Casey C. (2004) Bureaucracy Re-enchanted? Spirit, Experts and Authority in Organizations. Organization 11(1):59–79Google Scholar
  19. Cavanagh G. E., Bandsuch M. R. (2002) Virtue as a Benchmark for Spirituality in Business. Journal of Business Ethics 38(1/2):109–117Google Scholar
  20. Crockett C. (2005) The Cultural Paradigm of Virtue. Journal of Business Ethics 62(2):191–208Google Scholar
  21. Deci R. M., Ryan E. L. (2001) On Happiness and Human Potentials: A Review of Research on Hedonic and Eudemonic Well-Being. Annual Review of Psychology 52:141–166Google Scholar
  22. deKlerk J. J. (2005) Spirituality, Meaning in Life and Work Wellness: A Research Agenda. International Journal of Organisational Analysis, 13(1):64–88Google Scholar
  23. Delbecq L. A. (1999) Christian Spirituality and Contemporary Business Leadership. Journal of Organizational Business Management 12(4):345–349Google Scholar
  24. Diener E., Lucas R. E. (1999) Personality and Subjective Well-Being. In D. Kahneman, E. Diener, N. Schwartz (eds.), Well-Being. The Foundations of Hedonic Psychology. Russell Sage Foundation, New York, pp. 213–229Google Scholar
  25. Driver M. (2005) From Empty Speech to Full Speech? Reconceptualizing Spirituality in Organizations Based on a Psychoanalytically-Grounded Understanding of the Self. Human Relations 58(9):1091–1110Google Scholar
  26. Duchon D., Plowman D. A. (2005) Nurturing the Spirit at Work: Impact on Work Unit Performance. The Leadership Quarterly 16(5):807–833Google Scholar
  27. Duffy R. D. (2006) Spirituality, Religion and Career Development: Current Status and Future Directions. Career Development Quarterly, 65(1):52–63Google Scholar
  28. Eisler R., Montouori A. (2003) The Human Side of Spirituality. In R.A. Giacalone, C. L Jurkiewicz (eds.), Handbook of Workplace Spirituality and Organizational Performance. M. E. Sharpe, Armonk, New York, pp. 46–56Google Scholar
  29. Fairholm, G. W.: 1996, `Spiritual Leadership: Fulfilling Whole-Self Needs at Work', Leadership and Organisation Development Journal 17(5), 11–17Google Scholar
  30. Freeman R. E. (1994) The Politics of Stakeholder Theory: Some Future Directions. Business Ethics Quarterly 4(4):409–422Google Scholar
  31. Freeman R. E. (1999) Stakeholder Theory and the Modern Corporation. In T. Donalddson, P. H. Werhane (eds.), Ethical Theory in Business. 6. Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliffs, NJ, pp. 247–257Google Scholar
  32. Freshman B. (1999) An Exploratory Analysis of Definitions and Applications of Spirituality in the Workplace. Journal of Organizational Change Management 12(4):318–327Google Scholar
  33. Frey B. S., Benz M. (2004) From Imperialism to Inspiration: A Survey of Economics and Psychology. In J. B. Davis, A. Marciano, J. Runde (eds.), The Elgar Companion to Economics and Philosophy. Edward Elgar, Cheltenham, UK, pp. 61–83Google Scholar
  34. Fry L. W. (2005) Toward a Theory of Ethical and Spiritual Well-Being, and Corporate Social Responsibility Through Spiritual Leadership. In R. R. Giacalone, C. L. Jurkiewicz, C. Dunn (eds.), Positive Psychology in Business Ethics and Corporate Responsibility. Information Age Publishing, Greenwich, CT., pp. 47–83Google Scholar
  35. Fry L. W. (2003) Towards a Theory of Spiritual Leadership. The Leadership Quarterly 14(6):693–727Google Scholar
  36. Garcia-Zamor J. C. (2003) Workplace Spirituality in the United States and the Former East Germany. In R. A. Giacalone, C. L Jurkiewicz (eds.), Handbook of Workplace Spirituality and Organizational Performance. M. E. Sharpe, Armonk, New York, pp. 314–335Google Scholar
  37. Giacalone R. A., Jurkiewicz C. L. (2003a) Toward a Science of Workplace Spirituality. In R. A. Giacalone, C. L Jurkiewicz (eds.), Handbook of Workplace Spirituality and Organizational Performance. M. E. Sharpe, Armonk, New York, pp. 3–28Google Scholar
  38. Giacalone R. A., Jurkiewicz C. L. (2003b) Right from Wrong: The Influence of Spirituality on Perceptions of Unethical Business Activities. Journal of Business Ethics 46(1):85–97Google Scholar
  39. Giacalone R. A., Jurkiewicz C. L., Frey L. W. (2005) From Advocacy to Science. The Next Steps in Workplace Spirituality Research. In R. F. Paloutzian, C.L. Park (eds.), Handbook of the Psychology of Religion and Spirituality. Guilford press, New York, pp. 515–528Google Scholar
  40. Gozdz K. (2000) Toward Transpersonal Learning Communities in Business. American Behavioral Scientist 43(8):1262–1258Google Scholar
  41. Graber D. R., Johnson J. A. (2001) Spirituality and Healthcare Organizations. Journal of Healthcare Management 46(1):39–50Google Scholar
  42. Gull G. A., Doh J. (2004) The ‚Transmutation’ of the Organization: Toward a More Spiritual Workplace. Journal of Management Inquiry 13(2):128–139Google Scholar
  43. Harrington W. J., Preziosi R. C., Gooden D. J. (2001) Perceptions of Workplace Spirituality Among Professionals and Executives. Employee Responsibilities and Rights Journal 13(3):155–163Google Scholar
  44. Heaton D. P., Schmidt-Wilk J., Travis F. (2004) Constructs, Methods and Measures for Researching Spirituality in Organizations. Journal of Organizational Change Management 17(1):62–82Google Scholar
  45. Herman S. W. (2004) Christian Business Ethics on the Employment Relation: Mapping the Terrain. In M. L. Pava, P. Primeaux (eds), Spiritual Intelligence at Work: Meaning, Metaphor and Morals. Research in Ethical Issues in Organizations, Vol. 5. Elsevier Ltd., Oxford, pp. 37–53Google Scholar
  46. Hicks D. A. (2000) Inequality and Christian Ethics Cambridge University Press, CambridgeGoogle Scholar
  47. Hicks D. A. (2002) Spiritual and Religious Diversity in the Workplace Implications for leadership. The Leadership Quarterly 13(4):379–396Google Scholar
  48. Hicks D. A. (2003) Religion and the Workplace. Pluralism, Spirituality, Leadership. Cambridge University Press, CambridgeGoogle Scholar
  49. Hicks D. A. (2005) Ethical Diversity and the Leader’s Religious Commitments. In J. B. Ciulla, T. L. Price, S. E. Murphy (eds.), The Quest for Moral Leaders. Essays on Leadership Ethics. Edward Elgar, Cheltenham, UK, pp. 45–61Google Scholar
  50. Hill P. C., Smith G. S. (2003) Coming to Terms with Spirituality and Religion in the Workplace. In R. A. Giacalone, C. L Jurkiewicz (eds.), Handbook of Workplace Spirituality and organizational Performance. M. E. Sharpe, Armonk, New York, pp. 231–243Google Scholar
  51. Hollenbach D. S. J. (2002) The Common Good and Christian Ethics. Cambridge University Press, CambridgeGoogle Scholar
  52. Howard S. (2002) A Spiritual Perspective on Learning in the Workplace. Journal of Managerial Psychology 17(3):230–242Google Scholar
  53. Jones C., Parkers M., ten Bos R. (2005) For Business Ethics Routledge, London and New YorkGoogle Scholar
  54. Jurkiewicz C. L., Giacalone R. A. (2004) A Values Framework for Measuring the Impact of Workplace Spirituality on Organizational Performance. Journal of Business Ethics 49(2):129–142Google Scholar
  55. Kahnweiler W., Otte F. L. (1997) In Search of the Soul of HRD. Human Resource Development Quarterly 8(2):171–181Google Scholar
  56. Keyes C. L. M., Shnotkin D., Ryff C. D. (2002) Optimizing Well-Being: The Empirical Encounter of Two Traditions. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 82(6):1007–1022Google Scholar
  57. King J. E., Crowther M. R. (2004) The Measurement of Religiosity and Spirituality. Examples and Issues from Psychology. Journal of Organizational Change Management 17(1):83–101Google Scholar
  58. King S., Nicol D. M. (1999) Organizational Enhancement through Recognition of Individual Spirituality: Reflections of Jaques and Jung. Journal of Organizational Change Management 12(3):234–242Google Scholar
  59. Kinjierski V. M., Skrypnek B. J. (2004) Defining Spirit at Work. Finding Common Ground. Journal of Organizational Change Management 17(3):165–182Google Scholar
  60. Klenke K. (2005) Introducing Spirituality. International Journal of Organisational Analysis, 13(1):4–7Google Scholar
  61. Konz G. N. P., Ryan F. X. (1999) Maintaining an Organizational Spirituality: No easy task. Journal of Organisational Change Management 12(3):200–210Google Scholar
  62. Korac-Kakabadse N., Kouzmin A., Kakabadse A. (2002) Spirituality and Leadership Praxis. Journal of Managerial Psychology 17(3):165–182Google Scholar
  63. Krishnakumar S., Neck C. P. 2002, The ‚What’ ‚Why’ and ‚How’ of Spirituality in the Workplace. Journal of Managerial Psychology 17(3):153–164Google Scholar
  64. Kurth K. (2003) Spiritually Renewing Ourselves at Work. Finding Meaning through Service. In R. A. Giacalone, C. L Jurkiewicz (eds.), Handbook of Workplace Spirituality and organizational Performance. M. E. Sharpe, Armonk, New York, pp. 447–460Google Scholar
  65. Ladkin D. (2006) When Deontology and Utilitarianism aren’t Enough: How Heidegger’s Notion of ‚Dwelling’ Might Help Organisational Leaders Resolve Ethical Issues. Journal of Business Ethics 65(1):87–98Google Scholar
  66. Lamont M. (2000) The Dignity of Working Men. Morality and the Boundaries of Race, Class and Imagination. Harvard University Press, Cambridge MAGoogle Scholar
  67. Lee D. J., Sirgy M. J., Efraty D., Siegel P. (2003) A Study of Quality of Work-life, Spiritual Well-being, and Life-Satisfaction. In R. A. Giacalone, C. L Jurkiewicz (eds.), Handbook of Workplace Spirituality and organizational Performance. M. E. Sharpe, Armonk, New York, pp. 209–230Google Scholar
  68. Lee C., Zemke R. (1993) The Search of Spirit in the Workplace. Training 30(6):21–27Google Scholar
  69. Leigh P. (1997) The New Spirit at Work. Training & Development 51(3):26–41Google Scholar
  70. Lewis J. S., Geroy G. D. (2000) Employee Spirituality in the Workplace: A Cross-Cultural View for the Management of Spiritual Employees. Journal of Management Education 24(5):682–694Google Scholar
  71. Lips-Wiersma M. (2003) Making Conscious Choices in Doing Research on Workplace Spirituality. Utilizing the ‚Holistic Development Model’ to Articulate Values, Assumptions and Dogmas of the Knower. Journal of Organizational Change Management 16(4):406–425Google Scholar
  72. Lips-Wiersma M., Mills C. (2002) Coming out of the Closet: Negotiating Spiritual Expression in the Workplace. Journal of Managerial Psychology 17(3):183–202Google Scholar
  73. Litvin D. R. (2006) Diversity: Making Space for a Better Case. In A. M. Konrad, P. Prasad, J. K. Pringle (eds.), Handbook of Workplace Diversity. Sage Publications, Thousand Oaks, CA, pp. 75–94Google Scholar
  74. Lund-Dean K., Fornaciari C. J., McGee J. J. (2003) Research in Spirituality, Religion and Work. Walking the Line Between Relevance and Legitimacy. Journal of Organizational Change Management 16(4):378–395Google Scholar
  75. Markow F., Klenke K. (2005) The Effects of Personal Meaning and Calling on Organisational Commitment: an Empirical Investigation of Spiritual Leadership. International Journal of Organisational Analysis 13(1):8–27Google Scholar
  76. Marques J. F. 2006, The Spiritual Worker: An Examination of the Ripple Effect that Enhances Quality of Life in- and Outside the Work Environment. Journal of Management Development 25(9):884–895Google Scholar
  77. McCormick, D. W.: 1994, `Spirituality and Management', Journal of Managerial Psychology 9(6), 5–8Google Scholar
  78. McGee, J. J.: 1998, The Emergence of a ‚secular’ Corporate Spirituality. Paper presented at the Academy of Management. San Diego, CA, AugustGoogle Scholar
  79. Milliman J., Czaplewski A. J., Ferguson J. (2003) Workplace Spirituality and Employee Work Attitudes: An Exploratory Empirical Assessment. Journal of Organizational Change Management 16(4):426–447Google Scholar
  80. Mitroff I. I., Denton E. A. (1999a) A Study of Spirituality in the Workplace. Sloan Management Review 40(4):83–92Google Scholar
  81. Mitroff I. I., Denton E. A. (1999b) A Spiritual Audit of Corporate America Jossey-Bass, San Francisco, CAGoogle Scholar
  82. Moore G., Beadle R. (2006) In Search of Organizational Virtue in Business: Agents, Goods, Practices, Institutions and Environments. Organization Studies 27(3):369–389Google Scholar
  83. Moxley R. S. (2000) Leadership and Spirit Jossey-Bass, San Francisco, CAGoogle Scholar
  84. Neal C. (1999) A Conscious Change in the Workplace. The Journal of Quality and Participation 22(2):27–30Google Scholar
  85. Neal J. (2000) Work as Service to the Divine. American Behavioral Scientist 43(8):1316–1333Google Scholar
  86. Neal J., Biberman J. (2004) Research that Matters: Helping Organizations Integrate Spiritual Values and Practices. Journal of Organizational Change Management 17(1):7–10Google Scholar
  87. Pava M. L. (2004) Intelligent Spirituality in Business: A Deweyan Conception. In M. L. Pava, P. Primeaux (eds.), Spiritual Intelligence at Work: Meaning, Metaphor and Morals. Research in Ethical Issues in Organizations, Vol. 5. Elsevier Ltd, Oxford, pp. 63–93Google Scholar
  88. Pava M. L. (1998) Religious Business Ethics and Political Liberalism: An Integrated Approach. Journal of Business Ethics, 17(15):1633–1652Google Scholar
  89. Pfeffer J. (2003) Business and the Spirit: Management Practices that Sustain Values. In R. A. Giacalone, C. L Jurkiewicz (eds.), Handbook of Workplace Spirituality and Organizational Performance. M. E. Sharpe, Armonk, New York, pp. 29–45Google Scholar
  90. Polley D., Vora J., SubbaNarasimha P. N. (2005) Paying the Devil his Due: Limits and Liabilities of Workplace Spirituality. International Journal of Organisational Analysis 13(1):50–63Google Scholar
  91. Praveen-Parboteeah K., Cullen J. B. (2003) Ethical Climates and Spirituality. An Exploratory Examination of Theoretical Links. In R. A. Giacalone, C. L. Jurkiewicz (eds.), Handbook of Workplace Spirituality and organizational Performance. M. E. Sharpe, Armonk, New York, pp. 137–151Google Scholar
  92. Phillips R. (1997) Stakeholder Theory and a Principle of Fairness. Business Ethics Quarterly 7(1):51–66Google Scholar
  93. Pruzan P., Miller W. C. (2006) Spirituality as the Basis of Responsible Leaders and Responsible Companies. In T. Maak, N. M. Pless (eds.), Responsible Leadership. Routledge, London and New York, pp. 68–92Google Scholar
  94. Rawls J. (1999) The Idea of Public Reason Revisited. In J. Rawls (ed.), Law of Peoples. Harvard University Press, Cambridge Mass, pp. 129–180Google Scholar
  95. Reave L. (2005) Spiritual Values and Practices Related to Leadership Effectiveness. The Leadership Quarterly 16(5):655–687Google Scholar
  96. Rosenthal S., Buchholz S. (2004) The Spiritual Corporation: A Pragmatic Perspective. In M. L. Pava, P. Primeaux (eds.), Spiritual Intelligence at Work: Meaning, Metaphor and Morals. Research in Ethical Issues in Organizations, Vol. 5. Elsevier Ltd, Oxford, pp. 55–62Google Scholar
  97. Ryff C. D. (1995) Psychological Well-Being in Adult-Life. Current Directory of Psychological Science 4(1):99–104Google Scholar
  98. Ryff C. D., Singer B. (1998) The Contours of Positive Human Health. Psychological Inquiry 9(1):1–28Google Scholar
  99. Ryff C. D., Singer B. (2000) Interpersonal Flourishing: A Positive Health Agenda for the New Millenium. Personal and Social Psychological Review 4(1):30–44Google Scholar
  100. Sass J. S. (2000) Characterizing Organizational Spirituality: An Organizational Communication Culture Approach. Communication Studies 51(3):195–207Google Scholar
  101. Sharma A. (2004) A Hindu Perspective on Spirituality and Management. In M. L. Pava, P. Primeaux (eds.), Spiritual Intelligence at Work: Meaning, Metaphor and Morals. Research in Ethical Issues in Organizations, Vol. 5. Elsevier Ltd, Oxford, pp. 203–211Google Scholar
  102. Solomon R. (1992) Corporate roles, Personal Virtues. An Aristotelian Approach to Business Ethics. Business Ethics Quarterly 2(3):317–339Google Scholar
  103. Solomon R. (1993) Ethics and Excellence. Cooperation and Integrity in Business. Oxford University Press, OxfordGoogle Scholar
  104. Solomon R. (1999) A Better Way to Think about Business Oxford University Press, OxfordGoogle Scholar
  105. Solomon R. (2004) Aristotle, Ethics and Business Organizations. Organization Studies 25(6):1021–1043Google Scholar
  106. Steingard D. (2005) Spiritually-Informed Management Theory. Toward Profound Possibilities for Inquiry and Transformation. Journal of Management Inquiry 14(3):227–241Google Scholar
  107. Tepper B. J. (2003) Organisational Citizenship Behaviour and the Spiritual Employee. In R. A. Giacalone, C. L Jurkiewicz (eds.), Handbook of Workplace Spirituality and Organizational Performance. M. E. Sharpe, Armonk, New York, pp. 181–190Google Scholar
  108. Thomas Whetstone J. (2005) A Framework for Organizational Virtue: The Interrelationship of Mission, Culture and Leadership. Business Ethics. A European Review 14(4):367–378Google Scholar
  109. Tischler L. (1999) The Growing Interest in Spirituality in Business. A Long Term Socio-Economic Explanation. Journal of Organizational Change Management 12(4):273–279Google Scholar
  110. Tischler L., Biberman J., Mckeage R. (2002) Linking Emotional Intelligence, Spirituality and Workplace Performance: Definitions, Models and Ideas for Research. Journal of Managerial Psychology 17(3):203–218Google Scholar
  111. Van Dierendonck D., Mohan K. (2006) Some Thoughts in Spirituality and Eudemonic Well-Being. Mental Health, Religion and Culture 9(3):227–238Google Scholar
  112. Wagner-Marsh F., Conely J. (1999) The Fourth Wave: The Spiritually Based Firm. Journal of Organizational Change Management 12(4):292–301Google Scholar
  113. Wearer G. R. (2006) Virtue in Organizations: Moral Identity as a Foundation for Moral Agency. Organization Studies 27(3):341–368Google Scholar
  114. White R. D. J. R. (2003) Drawing the Line. Religion and Spirituality in the Workplace. In R. A. Giacalone, C. L Jurkiewicz (eds.), Handbook of Workplace Spirituality and Organizational Performance. M. E. Sharpe, Armonk, New York, pp. 244–256Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media B.V. 2007

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.History and Philosophy of ScienceUniversity of AthensAthensGreece

Personalised recommendations