Parent material and pedogenic thresholds: observations and a simple model
- 1.1k Downloads
Pedogenic thresholds, where multiple soil properties vary substantially and coherently in a narrow portion of a broad environmental gradient, are well-described on basaltic soils in Hawaii. One such threshold occurs along climate gradients where primary minerals virtually disappear, base saturation decreases sharply, and aluminum is mobilized within a narrow range of increasing rainfall. A recent study that evaluated thresholds along a climate gradient of non-basalt-derived soils on the South Island of New Zealand found that while base saturation declined steeply in a narrow range of rainfall on that gradient, the change was not coherent across soil properties; a substantial fraction of the Ca present in primary minerals (40–60 %) remained through the highest-rainfall sites ((Dixon et al. in J Geophys Res, doi: 10.1002/2016JF003864, 2016). We developed a simple model to explore potential mechanisms driving differences between basalt-derived and non-basalt soils. Incorporating a broader spectrum of mineral weathering rates (including some primary minerals that are highly recalcitrant to weathering) into simulated non-basalt than simulated basalt-derived soils (and accounting for the lower rates of evapotranspiration in New Zealand) was sufficient to simulate observed differences between these substrates. Further, we used the simple model to evaluate the consequences of rainfall variation in the short- (time step to time step) and long-term (a change in rainfall after 50,000 time steps). Results of these analyses demonstrated that year-to-year variation in rainfall could play an important role in controlling changes in the position of the pedogenic threshold during soil development.
KeywordsHawaiian Islands Lithology Mineral weathering New Zealand Pedogenic thresholds
Basalt-derived soils in the Hawaiian Islands do not change linearly in response to extrinsic differences in environmental forcing such as rainfall; rather their response is characterized by “pedogenic thresholds” that represent abrupt and/or non-linear (but predictable) changes in soil properties and processes (Chadwick and Chorover 2001). For example; Chadwick et al. (2003) demonstrated that base (non-hydrolyzing) cation saturation of soil exchange sites dropped from high values to 5 % or less (to 1 m depth) across a narrow range of precipitation values (between 1700 and 1900 mm of rainfall on a climate gradient from 250 to 3000 mm/year, using rainfall from Giambelluca et al. 2012). This change was caused by depletion of primary minerals in higher rainfall sites, such that mineral weathering could not buffer atmospheric and biological acidity there. In support of this explanation, Sr isotopes (87Sr/86Sr) also changed abruptly at this threshold, from values characteristic of Hawaiian basalt in drier sites to those characteristic of marine aerosol in wetter sites (Stewart et al. 2001; Chadwick et al. 2003).
A similar pedogenic threshold has been observed along rainfall gradients on both younger (Lincoln et al. 2014) and older (Vitousek and Chadwick 2013) substrates in Hawaii, although this threshold occurs at differing average rainfall on the different-aged substrates. Additional thresholds associated with soil anaerobiosis (Chadwick and Chorover 2001; Miller et al. 2001; Thompson et al. 2011) and with biological uplift of plant macronutrients (Vitousek et al. 2004) have been described as well.
Pedogenic thresholds are well documented on basalt-derived soils, but there is evidence for their importance on other substrates as well (Muhs 1984). For example, Dahlgren et al. (1997) analyzed soil properties along a climate gradient in the Sierra Nevada Range and identified a relatively narrow zone where primary mineral weathering and clay mineral formation were enhanced greatly by a favorable combination of temperature and rainfall. Ewing et al. (2006) documented a strong shift from accumulation of atmospheric salts in the hyperarid core of the Atacama Desert to in situ mineral weathering and pedogenic carbonate formation on the wetter, arid fringes of the desert. Additional thresholds have been described along regional scale ecotones such as transitions from tundra to boreal forest (Ugolini and Spaltenstein 1992). At a global scale, a water-balance driven threshold in soil pH has been documented using a 60,000 pedon database (Slessarev et al. in press).
While climate-driven pedogenic thresholds occur in soils developed in diverse substrates, there is reason to anticipate that the threshold associated with mineral depletion in basalt-derived soils could differ fundamentally from thresholds in non-basalt soils. Most primary minerals present in basalt weather at similar (and relatively rapid) rates, in comparison with the much wider range of primary minerals present in most other lithologies.
In this paper, we use a simple “toy” model and observations from basaltic soils in Hawaii (Chadwick et al. 2003; Vitousek and Chadwick 2013) and non-basalt soils in New Zealand (Dixon et al. 2016) to evaluate the nature, dynamics, and underlying mechanisms driving the mineral depletion pedogenic threshold on basalt-derived and one type of non-basalt soil. Further, we use the model to explore the importance of rainfall variation in shaping changes in the position of this pedogenic threshold.
We developed a simple “toy” model (defined as a simplified set of objects and equations that can be used to understand a mechanism) to explore the influence of parent material and of rainfall variability on weathering, leaching, and the dynamics of the mineral depletion pedogenic threshold. The model is written in Matlab (Mathworks Inc.), and is available in on-line supplementary material; it simulates the release of a soluble weathering product from primary minerals, its concentration in soil, and its loss via leaching. Just one soil layer is considered; water enters via precipitation, and is lost via evapotranspiration (considered to have a maximum value per time step, progressively reduced by water contents below the water holding capacity of the soil) and via leaching (calculated as all water that remains in the soil after evapotranspiration, in excess of a fixed water holding capacity). The soluble product (conceptually, a soluble cation like calcium) is released from minerals via weathering; it occurs in soluble form in the soil, and is leached from the soil in proportion its concentration and to the fraction of total soil water (after precipitation and evapotranspiration, before leaching) that is leached from the soil.
Initially, we chose kinetic coefficients and solubilities to simulate the relatively rapid and consistent weathering of minerals in basalt by assuming that the three classes of minerals simulated vary in both solubility and kinetics at a ratio of 1:0.5:0.2. As reported below, the use of these coefficients yielded a coherent threshold in which both simulated “available” cations and simulated “cations remaining in mineral form” were depleted in simulated high-rainfall sites by 100,000 time steps of simulation—a pattern consistent with field observations on basalt soils (Chadwick et al. 2003).
We then explored a range of coefficients and solubilities for the more recalcitrant minerals, and found that at values >~0.1 for the second mineral, simulated pools of this mineral largely disappeared by 100,000 time steps of simulation. For the third (most recalcitrant) mineral, there was little simulated weathering in 100,000 time steps at kinetic coefficients/solubilities <~0.05. Based on these observations, we chose to use kinetic coefficients/solubilities for non-basalt parent material that vary by 1:0.1:0.01; we describe the implications of this choice in “Discussion” Section.
Finally, we explore the reversibility of the cation depletion pedogenic threshold by reducing the mean rainfall in the midst of a run. For this analysis, we run the model for 40,000 time steps at a constant rainfall level 50 % above that at which a threshold develops—and then cut rainfall in half and run the model for another 20,000 time steps.
We compared outputs from the toy model to soil properties measured on climate gradients of basalt-derived soils in Hawaii and of non-basalt-derived soils in New Zealand. The Hawaiian climate gradient is described in Chadwick et al. (2003) and Vitousek and Chadwick (2013); our comparisons are to Vitousek and Chadwick’s Hawi basalt sequence on 150 kyr old substrate, along which annual precipitation reaches from ~285 to ~3250 mm/year in soils that are largely derived from tephra. The most important parent minerals along this gradient are basaltic glass, plagioclase, olivine and pyroxene (Spengler and Garcia, 1988). Results for the New Zealand climate gradient are described in Dixon et al. (2016); this sequence was expanded from a 4-point gradient characterized by Webb et al. (1986) to a 28-site gradient that includes sites with mean annual rainfalls from ~400 to ~4700 mm/year (Kerr 2009). This climate gradient covers 60 km in Waitaki Valley, from just south of Aoraki/Mt Cook southeastward along Lake Pukaki into the rain shadow of the Southern Alps. Soils are developed in wind-derived loess deposited on well-mapped moraines of known age from 12.6 to 19.7 kyr (Schaefer et al. 2006; Putnam et al. 2010; Barrell et al. 2011); we sampled loess deposited on moraines and outwash from the pre-Holocene Last Glacial Maximum (LGM) (Tekapo Formation) and from a relatively old Post-LGM moraine (Birch Hill Formation). The loess and its underlying till are carbonate-poor and derived from greywacke and argillite bedrock of the Torlesse Supergroup, which is a component of uplifted Mesozoic turbidite sequences (Eden and Hammond 2003; Raeside 1964). These parent rocks yield a loess mineral assemblage including quartz, K-feldspar, muscovite, plagioclase, and minor chlorite (Spörli and Lillie 1974; Webb et al. 1986).
Hawaii soils were obtained as integrated soil samples from the surface to 30 cm depth in >150 locations on the 150 kyr Hawi substrate (Vitousek and Chadwick 2013); soils were also sampled by horizon to depths of up to 5 m (using a backhoe) in 13 sites along the gradient (Porder and Chadwick 2009). In New Zealand, we sampled soils developed in thin (~1 m) loess deposits on moraines and outwash as described in Dixon et al. (2016). All sample sites were located on the flat upper surface of moraines and abandoned outwash fans. Soil was collected from each of 28 profiles by integrated sampling every 10 cm from the soil surface to contact with coarse glacial till. The sampled soils range from about 40 to 150 cm in depth with most being 60 to 70 cm. Here we compare 30 cm depth-integrated samples from Hawaii with bulk-density-weighted integrations of the top three 10-cm samples from New Zealand. Results for the full soil profiles are in Dixon et al. (2016) for New Zealand, and in Chadwick et al. (2003), Porder et al. (2007), and Vitousek and Chadwick (2013) for Hawaii.
We focus here on two soil properties that are relevant to the mineral depletion threshold identified by Chadwick and Chorover (2001) and Chadwick et al. (2003), and that are comparable to outputs of the toy model—base saturation, and the proportion of calcium remaining in the soil (relative to the calcium present in parent material). The former is a measure of the abundance of potentially mobile (and biologically available) cations in the soil, while the latter represents calcium that is available for release into the soil.
On the Lake Pukaki sequence, the fraction of calcium remaining in soil initially declined from nearly 100 to ~60 % with increasing rainfall from ~400 to ~800 mm/year. This fraction ranged from ~40 to 60 % into the wettest sites. In contrast, Ca remaining in the Hawi tephra declined from ~40 to 80 % in sites receiving <1300 mm/year to <10 % in sites receiving >2100 mm/year (Fig. 1b). Again, soils from sites receiving <1000 mm/year had lower Ca remaining than sites receiving 1300 mm/year on the Hawi gradient, reflecting a stronger imprint of biological uplift in the moderate-rainfall soils (Vitousek and Chadwick 2013).
Model—parent material comparison
Earlier research demonstrated (Chadwick and Chorover 2001; Chadwick et al. 2003; Vitousek and Chadwick 2013) that the pedogenic threshold associated with mineral depletion on basalt-derived soils in Hawaii is both coherent and irreversible—coherent in that multiple soil properties change at the same small rainfall range across a broad gradient (Vitousek and Chadwick 2013), including both exchangeable cations (base saturation) and total cations remaining from parent material (Fig. 1), and irreversible because the depletion of cations remaining from primary minerals means that the low levels of available cations are permanent (absent fertilization, uplift, or dust deposition). Moist infertile soils now occur at rainfalls above the threshold, and if average rainfall declined substantially we would observe dry infertile soils there.
In contrast, while there is threshold behavior for exchangeable cations (base saturation) on the non-basalt soils in New Zealand, demonstrated by a sharp decline in base saturation in a narrow portion of the broad gradient (Fig. 1) (Dixon et al. 2016), this threshold is more complex than the comparable threshold on Hawaiian basalt. While base saturation declines sharply to low levels between 400 and 800 mm annual precipitation, and the amount of calcium retained from parent material decreases across this same rainfall range, a substantial fraction (40–60 %) of the calcium originally present in parent material remains within the soils receiving more 800 mm precipitation.
We used the toy model to explore possible mechanisms underlying the contrast between basalt-derived and non-basalt soils. The model is far from a complete description of soil formation and dynamics (cf Maher and Chamberlain 2014); rather, it is intended as a systematic way to explore the logical consequences of a relatively narrow range of (rapid) rates of weathering among primary minerals in basalt versus a broader range (including some with much lower rates) of weathering among primary minerals in non-basalt substrate. If model and observational results did not align qualitatively, we would conclude that the mechanism embedded in the model could not drive the observed pattern.
In this case, results of this simple model and observations agreed well (Figs. 1, 3), when we accounted for the lower rate of potential evapotranspiration in cool temperate New Zealand versus subtropical Hawaii. Very simple assumptions about variation in weathering rates among minerals suffice to yield sharp thresholds in available cations on both simulated substrates, levels of primary mineral cations near zero in simulated basalt soils wetter than the threshold, and substantially higher levels of primary mineral cations remaining above the threshold in simulated non-basalt substrate—results that are consistent with field observations across broad climate gradients on each substrate.
The qualitative concordance between our simple model and field observations (Figs. 1, 3) is intriguing, but we must ask “how realistic is the range of weathering rates assumed in the model”? Quartz is present in the arkosic (non-basalt) substrate in New Zealand and absent from Hawaiian basalt; it weathers much more slowly than does any abundant mineral in basalt, but it contains essentially no calcium. However, quartz can make more labile minerals inaccessible to weathering, in effect protecting them, and so can contribute to slower release of cations. Feldspars are the most recalcitrant minerals in Hawaiian basalt, and the most recalcitrant that contain substantial quantities of calcium on the New Zealand sequence—but different feldspars are important in each system. In basalt the dominant feldspar is plagioclase whereas in the arkosic materials it is a combination of plagioclase and more recalcitrant orthoclase (K feldspar). Moreover, plagioclase itself is composed of a solid solution ranging from a pure Ca endmember (anorthite) and a Na endmember (albite). Solubility varies greatly and linearly between these two endmembers (Log10 Ksp = 27.1 (at 25 °C) for anorthite and 3.1 for albite), while between these endmembers are minerals such as oligoclase that has a mixture of Ca and Na and a Log10 Ksp = 8.3 (Delany and Wolery 1989). In Hawaiian basalt about half the Ca resides in the anorthite end of the plagioclase series (with the rest in more soluble minerals such as volcanic glass and pyroxene), while in the arkosic loess in New Zealand, Ca is present (initially) in the more slowly weathering oligoclase to albite end of the plagioclase series.
In summary almost all of the Ca in Hawaiian basalt is hosted in more soluble minerals than is the majority of Ca in the New Zealand loess derived from arkosic rocks. Our selection of weathering rates mimics this fact without trying to be precise since there are many other controls on weathering including surface area, mineral protections by coatings and less soluble primary minerals (like the abundant quartz in the New Zealand sequence), and the heterogeneity of flow paths.
We also used the toy model to explore the influence of rainfall variation on two time scales. With constant rainfall (the same rainfall at every time step), a threshold change in available cations develops rapidly (within a few thousand time steps) in sufficiently wet sites on both basalt and non-basalt substrates, and this threshold then remains nearly fixed in place no matter how many time steps are added. However, when we incorporate stochastic time-step-to-time-step variation in rainfall to the model, the threshold migrates into drier conditions as more time steps are added (Fig. 4)—as we observe for thresholds on basalt substrates in the field in Hawaii (Vitousek and Chadwick 2013). This result is consistent with the suggestion that occasional high rainfall events determine properties of soils in the long term; indeed, the model may understate this effect, as maximum rainfall in a time step is constrained to be no more than ~4.5× the mean rainfall per time step (see “Methods” section).
Finally, by running the model under a consistent rainfall regime, allowing available cations to become depleted, and then systematically decreasing rainfall to a level at which cations would not have become depleted (had the second, lower rainfall level persisted from the beginning of the simulation), we could evaluate the reversibility of cation depletion under changing climatic conditions. We found simulated cation depletion to be irreversible by simply by decreasing rainfall on simulated basalt substrates – as expected from the depletion of primary mineral cations on basalt (Figs. 1, 5); on simulated non-basalt, where relatively large quantities of cations remain in parent material after available cations are depleted, the reversibility of depletion depends on whether the weathering of relatively recalcitrant primary minerals is constrained by solubility (in which case the depletion is irreversible) or by kinetics (in which case available cations can accumulate in soils after the change in rainfall—Fig. 5). This result makes sense—if weathering is constrained by low concentrations of available cations, then weathering can never provide high levels of those cations. However, we did not recognize the importance of the different mechanisms for constraining the weathering of recalcitrant minerals, until running the model.
Overall, evaluation of our field observations and simulations suggest that weathering-related pedogenic thresholds are widespread, although they may differ in fundamental ways in soils developed in different parent materials. These thresholds should be incorporated into considerations of climate constraints to ecosystem function and potential disruptions of ecosystems due to climate change.
This research was supported by NSF Grants ETBC-1020791 and ETBC-1019640 to Stanford University and the University of California, Santa Barbara. JLD acknowledges support by MT-IOE award from NSF EPS-1101342. We thank W.H. Schlesinger and S. Porder for helpful comments on an earlier draft.
- Barrell DJA, Andersen BG, Denton GH (2011) Glacial geomorphology of the Central South Island, New Zealand. GNS SciGoogle Scholar
- Delany JM, Wolery TJ (1989) The LLNL thermochemical database. Report UCRL-21658Google Scholar
- Kerr T (2009) Precipitation distribution in the Lake Pukaki catchment, New Zealand. PhD, University of Canterbury.Google Scholar
- Lincoln NK, Vitousek PM, Chadwick OA (2014) Indicators of soil fertility and opportunities for precontact agriculture in Kona, Hawaii. Ecosphere. doi: 10.1890/ES13-00328.1
- Muhs DR (1984) Intrinsic thresholds in soil systems. Phys Geogr 5:99–110Google Scholar
- Slessarev EW, Lin Y, Bingham NL, Johnson JE, Dai Y, Schimel JP, Chadwick OA (2016) Water balance creates a threshold in soil pH at the global scale. Nature (in press)Google Scholar
Open AccessThis article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made.