Skip to main content

Oil palm and rubber expansion facilitates earthworm invasion in Indonesia

Abstract

Deforestation, plantation expansion and other human activities in tropical ecosystems are often associated with biological invasions. These processes have been studied for above-ground organisms, but associated changes below the ground have received little attention. We surveyed rainforest and plantation systems in Jambi province, Sumatra, Indonesia, to investigate effects of land-use change on the diversity and abundance of earthworms—a major group of soil-ecosystem engineers that often is associated with human activities. Density and biomass of earthworms increased 4—30-fold in oil palm and rubber monoculture plantations compared to rainforest. Despite much higher abundance, earthworm communities in plantations were less diverse and dominated by the peregrine morphospecies Pontoscolex corethrurus, often recorded as invasive. Considering the high deforestation rate in Indonesia, invasive earthworms are expected to dominate soil communities across the region in the near future, in lieu of native soil biodiversity. Ecologically-friendly management approaches, increasing structural habitat complexity and plant diversity, may foster beneficial effects of invasive earthworms on plant growth while mitigating negative effects on below-ground biodiversity and the functioning of the native soil animal community.

Introduction

Land-use change in the tropics is largely driven by the establishment of high-production agricultural systems in order to provide humanity with food and other agricultural products (Laurance et al. 2014; Edwards et al. 2019). Rainforests are cleared across tropical regions with recent deforestation being especially pronounced in Indonesia (Hansen et al. 2013). Over the last 30 years, most of the lowland rainforests in Sumatra (Indonesia) have been converted into plantations, with oil palm and rubber being the dominating crops (Margono et al. 2012). These land-use changes disturb habitats, degrade biodiversity and provide dispersal vectors for organisms, thereby opening opportunities for invasions by exotic species into the transformed ecosystems (Bellard et al. 2016; Clough et al. 2016; Rembold et al. 2017). Such invasions may have diverse impacts on biodiversity and ecosystem functioning on the local and regional scale, being among the strongest drivers of environmental changes globally (Simberloff 2011; IPBES 2019). For instance, terrestrial invertebrate invaders, on average, reduce plant and animal abundance, and may speed up ecosystem processes such as decomposition (Cameron et al. 2016). In Sumatra, plantations have been reported to be inhabited by a range of alien plant, tramp ant and common bird species (Prabowo et al. 2016; Rembold et al. 2017; J. Drescher personal communication). However, to date, little is known about the potential belowground invasions associated with the recent land-use change in Southeast Asia.

Below-ground invasions are largely unseen and thus have received little attention by science and society. However, below-ground invasions may be as dramatic and drive as large ecosystem changes as those above the ground (Hendrix et al. 2008; Craven et al. 2017). One important example of below-ground invasions is that of earthworms that have very pronounced ecosystem effects through their action as ecosystem engineers (Bohlen et al. 2004; Eisenhauer 2010; Frelich et al. 2019). More than 100 earthworm species are considered to be peregrine, i.e., having a wide distribution range and often being linked to human activities (Hendrix et al. 2008; Blakemore 2009). Human-induced long-distance dispersal likely is the most important mechanism facilitating the invasion of peregrine earthworms into new areas (Hendrix et al. 2008; Cameron and Bayne 2009; Klein et al. 2019). Introduced earthworms may change soil physical and chemical characteristics, nutrient and water cycling, gas emissions and plant communities, thus having a prominent impact on ecosystem functioning (Hale et al. 2006; Eisenhauer et al. 2012; Lubbers et al. 2013; Blouin et al. 2013). Recent meta-analyses summarized effects of introduced earthworms on northern North American forests, showing that earthworm invasions are associated with the decline in diversity and changes in community composition of plants (Craven et al. 2017), reduced soil biodiversity and altered depth distribution of soil communities (Ferlian et al. 2018), as well as homogenization of soil layers substantially changing nutrient pools and fluxes (Ferlian et al. 2020). Increased earthworm density may also cause multitrophic changes that cascade beyond the basal trophic level (Scheu 2003; Wurst 2010), altering the pathways of energy flux through trophic networks and reducing the provisioning of energy to predators (Potapov et al. 2019).

The Indonesian earthworm fauna is largely dominated by Megascolecidae, but also includes a number of species from other earthworm families (e.g., Moniligastridae, Lumbricidae) with 182 species records in total according to DriloBASE (Drilobase Project 2020). More than 50 alien earthworm species were recorded in Southeast Asia, demonstrating a large potential for belowground invasions in the region (Blakemore et al. 2006). Across tropical areas, Pontoscolex corethrurus (Rhinodrilidae) by far is the most frequently recorded peregrine earthworm invader particularly colonizing disturbed but also native ecosystems (Taheri et al. 2018b). It was first described from Brazil, but today has a pantropical distribution with several cryptic lineages (Taheri et al. 2018a; James et al. 2019). Invasion by P. corethrurus may result in significant modifications of soil bulk density, biochemical processes and abundance of other soil organisms, with the direction of change depending on soil type (Marichal et al. 2010; Taheri et al. 2018b). Most studies on the invasion by P. corethrurus were conducted in India, Brazil and Mexico, while only few records exist from Indonesia (Taheri et al. 2018b). Land-use change in tropical rainforest areas was suggested to facilitate the invasion by P. corethrurus into soils of high pH, C and N contents in particular after burning (Marichal et al. 2010). Pontoscolex corethrurus and other invasive earthworm species predominantly colonize agricultural fields (Darmawan et al. 2017; Taheri et al. 2018b), but below-ground invasions associated with the expansion of oil palm and rubber plantations across Indonesia (Margono et al. 2014; Vijay et al. 2016) have not been investigated yet.

Biomass of earthworms in oil palm and rubber plantations has been found to exceed that in rainforest in our previous study in Jambi province, Sumatra (Potapov et al. 2019). Building on these findings, here we expanded our sampling to investigate if the abundance of earthworms is systematically higher in plantations in comparison to rainforests. We specifically collected data at (1) riparian sites, (2) different years, (3) soil depths and (4) seasons. Further, we investigated the diversity of earthworm species in rainforest and plantation systems using COI barcoding to reveal if land-use change is associated with the spread of invasive species into lowland landscapes of Sumatra.

Methods

Study region

The study was conducted in the framework of the collaborative research project CRC990 “EFForTS” investigating ecological and socioeconomic changes associated with the transformation of lowland rainforest into agricultural systems (https://www.uni-goettingen.de/de/310995.html). Four land-use systems, rainforest (F), jungle rubber (J), rubber monoculture (R) and oil palm monoculture (O), were studied in lowlands of Jambi province, Sumatra, Indonesia (average temperature 26.7 ± 0.2 °C, annual precipitation 2235 ± 381 mm). Sampling plots were established in two landscapes, in and around Harapan rainforest and Bukit Duabelas national park. Each system was replicated eight times (four times in each of the two landscapes) resulting in a total of 32 “core plots”. In addition, four replicates of each rainforest, rubber and oil palm monocultures were established in riparian areas in the Harapan landscape (12 “riparian plots”; Fig. 1; Table S1). Rainforest sites were used as control and were close to natural conditions, but underwent selective logging between 1985 and 2000. Jungle rubber sites originated from logged rainforest sites planted with rubber trees (Hevea brasiliensis) and were dominated by rubber with some native tree species interspersed. Rubber and oil palm (Elaeis guineensis) monoculture plantations represent intensive land-use systems with fertilizer addition and regular herbicide application of an age of 10–20 years depending on the sampling event (see below). Most of the studied monocultures represent first-generation plantations and originated from logged and/or burned rainforest or replaced agroforests such as jungle rubber (Margono et al. 2012). Between 1990 and 2013, rainforest cover decreased from 49.5 to 34.5% in Jambi province, while combined rubber and oil palm cultivation increased from 26.4 to 32.5% (Grass et al. 2020). Soils at the sampling sites were acrisols with sandy loam texture in the Harapan and clay texture in the Bukit Duabelas landscape (Allen et al. 2016).

Fig. 1
figure 1

Map of the study region (Jambi province) with sampling plots. Colors show different land-use systems, ‘ + r’ marks riparian plots. Each sampling campaign was done on a subset of plots, as shown schematically here and described in the text. The background map was obtained from https://www.openstreetmap.org; latitude and longitude are shown as decimal degree

Sampling

In total, five sampling campaigns were conducted for this study (Fig. 1; Table 1). (1) The first sampling campaign took place during October and November 2012 (Barnes et al. 2014). In each of the 32 core plots, three soil samples of 50 × 50 cm were excavated to a depth of 20 cm, earthworms were collected manually by hand sorting and stored in 65% ethanol. In the laboratory, all earthworms were individually measured for length and width and weighed. In total, 848 earthworms were collected and analyzed. (2) The second sampling campaign was conducted during October and November 2013 (Klarner et al. 2017; Potapov et al. 2019). In each of 32 core plots, three soil samples 16 × 16 cm, litter and the upper 5 cm of the soil were taken, and earthworms were extracted by heat using a high-gradient extractor, collected in dimethyleneglycol—water solution (1:1) and then stored in 70% ethanol. All earthworms were individually measured for length and width. In total, 266 earthworms were collected. (3) The third sampling campaign was conducted during October and November 2016. All core plots, except for jungle rubber, and all riparian plots were sampled, resulting in a total of 36 plots (three samples per plot). Sampling and extraction were done as in the second sampling campaign. In total, 240 earthworms were collected and used to compare upland (core) and riparian sites. Material from these three sampling campaigns was used to assess earthworm abundance in different land-use systems. (4) The fourth sampling campaign (“seasonal”) was conducted in 2017. Samples were taken four times a year: end of the wet season (March), middle of the dry season (June), end of the dry season (September), and middle of the wet season (December), on core plots of the Harapan landscape, except for jungle rubber plots. On each of 12 plots in each season, one soil sample of 16 × 16 cm comprising litter and the upper 5 cm of the soil was taken, and earthworms were extracted by heat as described above. In total, 76 earthworms were collected and used for assessing seasonal changes in earthworm abundance (Table S2). (5) The fifth sampling campaign (“genetic”) was conducted in October 2017. All core plots of the Harapan landscape except jungle rubber, and all riparian plots were sampled, resulting in a total of 24 plots. On each plot two soil samples of 16 × 16 cm comprising litter and the upper 5 cm of the soil were taken, and earthworms were extracted directly into 96% ethanol using Tullgren funnels with heating plates (Semenina et al. 2015) and stored in a freezer (–20 °C). In total, 151 earthworms were collected, 104 of which were selected for genetic analysis to assess genetic diversity (see below).

Table 1 Summary of the sampling campaigns conducted

Biomass estimation

To estimate earthworm biomass, we used data collected during the first sampling campaign to establish region-specific coefficients for a body size—body mass regression. The regression was fitted using lm in R 3.5.3 (R Core Team 2019) as ln(mass) ~ ln(length) + log(width), where mass is the body mass in gram after storage in ethanol (as proxy for fresh weight), length and width were measured in millimeter and ln is the natural logarithm. The model had an R2 of 0.853, an intercept of –7.282, a length coefficient of 1.075 and a width coefficient of 1.415 (Fig. S1). This equation was used to calculate biomass of earthworms from the second sampling campaign, where only length and width, but not body mass, were measured. Measured body mass from the first campaign and estimated mass from the second sampling campaign were used to analyze the effect of land use on earthworm biomass (Appendix S1).

Genetic analysis

Out of 151 earthworms collected during the “genetic” sampling campaign, we selected 104 individuals. The selection was designed to cover all eight sampling plots in each of the land-use systems and to analyze one to six specimens per plot randomly, depending on availability. We obtained cytochrome c oxidase subunit I (COI) sequences of 72 individuals (69% success rate), of which 24 individuals were from rainforest, 28 from rubber and 20 from oil palm monoculture (Table S3). For genetic analyses, the final three segments of the hind end of earthworms were cut with a sterile scalpel avoiding transferring soil and gut content from the earthworm. For DNA extraction, we used the Agencourt DNAdvance Kit (Beckman Coulter, Krefeld, Germany) following the manufacturer’s protocol. Earthworm tissue was individually transferred into 200 µl lysis buffer, without 1 M DTT, on a 96 well plate and 7 µl of Proteinase K (20 µg/µl, Genaxxon, Ulm, Germany) was added. Samples were incubated overnight on a shaking heat-block at 55 °C and processed after 18 h on the automated robot system Biomek 3000 (Beckman Coulter, Krefeld, Germany) using the standard protocol for DNA extraction and an elution volume of 100 µl. The standard barcoding gene COI was amplified and sequenced. The PCR reaction mix of 25 µl volume contained 3 µl of template DNA, 12.5 µl of SuperHot Mastermix (Genaxxon, Ulm, Germany), 1 µl BSA (3%), 1 µl of each primer (10 pM, LCO1490 and HCO2198; Folmer et al. 1994). The PCR started with an initial activation step at 95 °C for 15 min, followed by 35 amplification cycles (denaturation at 95 °C for 30 s, annealing at 53 °C for 60 s, elongation at 72 °C for 60 s), and a final elongation step at 72 °C for 10 min, and products were sequenced at SeqLab Göttingen (Microsynth). Sequences were checked with Geneious Prime 2019 (www.geneious.com) and ambiguous positions were corrected using the electropherograms. Consensus sequences were aligned in AliView v1.25 (Larsson 2014) using default settings and truncated to equal lengths. The resulting alignment was analyzed for haplotype diversity using the DNA-to-haplotype collapser and converter of the online tool FaBox 1.5 (Villesen 2007). Haplotype identities were checked using the nucleotide BLAST algorithm of the NCBI database (www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov; Table S3). We further manually compared sequences of P. corethrurus with those available in NCBI to identify the particular lineage of this morphospecies (i.e., cryptic species) (Taheri et al. 2018a). To verify molecular identification, we additionally distinguished morphotypes of Pontoscolex spp. (Taheri et al. 2018a; Fig. S2) and estimated the proportion of juvenile earthworms in the material of the genetic sampling campaign (Table S5).

Data analysis

Statistical analyses were done in R 3.5.3 with R studio interface 1.0.143 (RStudio, Inc.). For the analyses, samples within plots were pooled and plots were treated as replicates. The effect of land use (F, J, R, O) on the number of earthworms per plot was evaluated using generalized linear models with negative binomial distribution using glm.nb in the MASS package. Data over dispersion was tested with the AER package. Two models were run separately: the first model was based on the data from the first sampling campaign (2012, sampling 0–20 cm of soil) and included land use and region (Harapan vs. Bukit duabelas) and their interaction as factors; the second model was based on the data from the second and third sampling campaigns (2013 and 2016, sampling 0–5 cm of soil) and included land use, region, their interaction and sampling year as factors. Pairwise differences among land-use systems in the models for abundance were tested using the glht package in the multcomp package. The data on biomass was very heterogeneous and was not well described by Gaussian, log-normal or gamma generalized linear models; thus, we fitted linear models using generalized least squares using gls in the nlme package. These models allowed us to explicitly account for unequal variances in different land-use systems by setting varIdent(form =  ~ 1|Landuse). Pairwise differences among land-use systems in the models for biomass were tested using non-parametric Median.test in the agricolae package. To test for differences in earthworm abundance between upland and riparian areas, we used data from the third sampling campaign and applied glm.nb with riparian status (true or false), land use and their interaction as factors. To inspect for differences in seasonal changes in earthworm abundance among land-use systems, we used data from the “seasonal” sampling and applied glm.nb with month (March, June, September and December), land use and their interaction as factors. To estimate earthworm diversity in each land-use system, we extrapolated the number of haplotypes using specpool based on individuals (Chao estimator) and also displayed rarefaction curves using specaccum in the vegan package in R. Proportion of Pontoscolex spp. in different land-use systems was illustrated using the bipartite package. Data in the text are presented as means and 1 SD.

Results

In the top 20 cm of soil (sampling in 2012), the number of earthworms in jungle rubber and both rubber and oil palm monoculture plantations was 15–30 times higher (Fig. 2a; effect of land-use system: χ23 = 89.8, p < 0.0001) and biomass was about 10 times higher (effect of land-use system: χ23 = 26.4, p < 0.0001) compared to rainforest. Among the agricultural systems, rubber monoculture had significantly higher biomass of earthworms (fresh mass 15.8 SD 12.6 g m−2) than jungle rubber (4.6 SD 4.5 g m−2) and oil palm monoculture (5.6 SD 3.9 g m−2). In rainforest biomass averaged only 0.5 SD 1.0 g m−2. In the litter and top 5 cm of soil (second and third sampling campaigns in 2013 and 2016), the number of earthworms was about four times higher (effect of land-use system: χ23 = 32.9, p < 0.0001), while the biomass in all agricultural systems was about 20 times higher (reaching the maximum 16.2 SD 14.7 g m−2 in jungle rubber) compared to rainforest (0.6 SD 0.9 g m−2; effect of land-use system: χ23 = 41.5, p < 0.0001; Fig. 2b). The discrepancy in the decline in biomass and abundance between the two methods was due to the underrepresentation of small earthworm individuals by hand sorting especially in rainforest (Fig. S2).

Fig. 2
figure 2

Abundance of earthworms in different land-use systems. Comparison of land-use systems based on sampling to the depth of 20 cm (a, first sampling campaign) and to the depth of 5 cm (b, second and third sampling campaigns); upland versus riparian sites (c, third sampling campaign); seasonal variation in different land-use systems (d, seasonal sampling campaign). Rainforest (F, green), jungle rubber (J, grey), rubber monoculture (R, blue), oil palm monoculture (O, yellow). White labels on the panels a and b represent mean values, means sharing the same letter are not significantly different (Tukey contrasts). For seasonal changes, ribbons represent standard errors of means

The number of earthworms averaged 134.5 SD 160.1 ind. m−2 in upland but only 44.5 SD 43.9 in riparian sites (effect of riparian area: χ21 = 11.2, p = 0.0008; Fig. 2c). In the ‘seasonal’ sampling campaign earthworm abundance was lowest in December (22.8 SD 26.1 ind. m−2) and highest in March (100.91 SD 126.5 ind. m−2; effect of season: χ21 = 12.9, p = 0.0048). However, seasonal changes were asynchronous in different land-use systems with the number of earthworms being high in plantations and low in rainforest in March, and the opposite being true in September (season × land use interaction: χ21 = 15.1, p = 0.0197; Fig. 2d). More detailed results of statistical models are given in Appendix S1.

The genetically analyzed samples showed that haplotype richness was considerably higher in rainforest (Chao-rarefied haplotype richness 65.0 SD 42.2) than in rubber (14.7 SD 11.3) and oil palm monoculture plantations (14.6 SD 11.1; Fig. 3). Overall, 50 out of 72 individuals were assigned to the morphospecies P. corethrurus, which represented > 50% of the individuals in oil palm monoculture and was the only morphospecies recorded in rubber monoculture plantations. Pontoscolex corethrurus was also present in rainforest, but at low abundance sharing dominance with other taxa (Fig. 3). In total, ten haplotypes were found within the morphospecies of P. corethrurus, five in rainforest, seven in rubber and four in oil palm monoculture plantations. The two most abundant haplotypes were present in all three land-use systems, while haplotypes specific for certain land-use systems were only represented by single individuals (Tables S3 and S4). Although comprising different haplotypes, all sequences of P. corethrurus matched Lineage 1 of P. corethrurus, i.e. P. corethrurus sensu stricto. The other sequences of earthworms poorly matched records of Megascolecidae and in part also Lumbricidae (80–85% similarity in most of the cases). Morphological identification of Pontoscolex spp. matched the genetic identification. The proportion of juvenile individuals among the earthworms that were morphologically identified as Pontoscolex spp. averaged 67 ± 45% in rainforest, 82 ± 19% in rubber, and 84 ± 20% in oil palm (Table S5). For accession numbers of COI sequences of the ten haplotypes of P. corethrurus see Table S6 (MT975675-MT975684). All other earthworm sequences were not submitted to a public database due to missing morphological identification, but are available from the corresponding author on request.

Fig. 3
figure 3

Genetic diversity of earthworm communities in different land-use systems. Rainforest (green, F), rubber monoculture (R, blue), oil palm monoculture (O, yellow). Rarefaction curves for the number of haplotypes based on individuals, semi-transparent ribbons reflect standard deviations (a). Connection width in the bipartite network (b) shows the relative abundance of Pontoscolex corethrurus in each land-use system among the total of 72 sequenced individuals (data is based only on the ‘genetic’ sampling campaign)

Discussion

Here we provided the first detailed assessment of how conversion of tropical lowland rainforest into oil palm and rubber plantations, the dominant agricultural systems in Sumatra and other regions in Southeast Asia (Margono et al. 2014; Corley and Tinker 2016; Grass et al. 2020), changes earthworm communities and facilitates belowground invasions. Our results are straightforward: the density and biomass of earthworms in plantation systems exceeded that in rainforest by factors of 4–30. The differences in earthworm density between land-use systems varied with season and were also prominent, although less pronounced, in riparian sites. Despite much higher abundance, earthworm communities in plantations were much less diverse with monoculture communities having far lower numbers of haplotypes and being dominated by the peregrine morphospecies P. corethrurus known as invasive species across tropical regions (Brown et al. 2006; Taheri et al. 2018b).

Context of the earthworm invasion

Here and below, we use the term ‘invasive’ following Valéry et al. (2008) “…species’ acquiring a competitive advantage following the disappearance of natural obstacles to its proliferation, which allows it to spread rapidly and to conquer novel areas within recipient ecosystems in which it becomes a dominant population”. Pontoscolex corethrurus, specifically Lineage 1, has a pantropical distribution and among other countries was recorded from Brazil, where the species was first described, and from Malysia (Taheri et al. 2018a; James et al. 2019). The suggested origin of the family Rhinodrilidae is South America (Righi 1984; Anderson et al. 2017), which fits well to the South American origin of the rubber tree H. brasiliensis, the crop that benefited P. corethrurus most in our study. Oil palm, the dominant crop in the region, originates from Africa, but today is planted across tropical lowlands (Corley and Tinker 2016). Although the history of the expansion of P. corethrurus remains unclear, human-induced occasional dispersal with soil and plants likely facilitated its spread (Taheri et al. 2018b). Considering the long cultivation history of rubber and oil palm in Indonesia, going back to the early twentieth century, and the recent massive expansion of these crops on Sumatra after the 1970s and 1990s (Barlow 1997; Margono et al. 2012; Corley and Tinker 2016), different earthworm invasion scenarios are possible. The most abundant haplotype of P. corethrurus in plantations was also found in rainforest, together with four other haplotypes. Whether the morphospecies was introduced with recent intensive deforestation or populations proliferated earlier after landscape transformation remains unclear, calling for studies at larger regional scale (Klein et al. 2019). The matches of sequences of other earthworm species in our dataset were poor and usually only at family level (80 to 85% match in the NCBI; Table S3) suggesting that they represent species not yet sequenced. Further, PCRs were negative or sequences were of low quality for about 30% of the individuals studied, indicating that we likely underestimated earthworm diversity and that comprehensive taxonomic work including sequencing needs to be done in the region. Below we discuss potential reasons and consequences of the invasion, finishing with potential strategies to control it.

Factors favoring earthworm invasion

Factors favoring the expansion of peregrine earthworms in the tropics are well studied. Our results match earlier findings that in particular P. corethrurus often proliferates in converted habitats, such as croplands, pastures, urban areas and gardens (Marichal et al. 2010), but may also colonize forests (Taheri et al. 2018b). A study from Java (Indonesia) showed a decline in native forest earthworm species in coffee and fruit vegetable plantations, while the exotic Ocnerodrilus occidentalis (Ocnerodrilidae) and P. corethrurus became dominant (Darmawan et al. 2017). Another study from Malaysia showed that oil palm plantations were only colonized by P. corethrurus (Sabrina et al. 2009). Pontoscolex corethrurus is known to colonize soils of high pH, N and P availability (Marichal et al. 2010; Taheri et al. 2018b). Matching these findings, at our study sites, P availability and pH are higher in plantation systems than in rainforest (Allen et al. 2016). Pontoscolex corethrurus was also observed to be abundant in habitats with scarce litter resources (Marichal et al. 2010; Shilenkova and Tiunov 2015), and this also matches our study sites, where the litter layer is less pronounced in plantation systems, in particular in oil palm, than in rainforest (Krashevska et al. 2015). Changes in environmental conditions associated with deforestation were shown to negatively impact foremost native earthworms species and this may open up niches for P. corethrurus thereby facilitating its proliferation (Marichal et al. 2010). The success of P. corethrurus in colonizing disturbed habitats may be facilitated by parthenogenetic reproduction, high fecundity, short development time, and reproductive and environmental plasticity (Taheri et al. 2018b).

Pontoscolex corethrurus is an endogeic geophagous earthworm species that was suggested to derive much of its tissue carbon from the rhizosphere in sugarcane plantations (Spain et al. 1990). Findings of our study suggest that this may not uniformly apply. Rubber is harvested by cutting the tree phloem, which reduces the allocation of carbon compounds to roots and, correspondingly, is likely reducing rhizodeposition. Despite that, P. corethrurus was particularly abundant in rubber monoculture plantations and was the only morphospecies recorded there, based on our ‘genetic’ sampling campaign in 2017. This may point to high trophic flexibility of P. corethrurus, allowing it to colonize habitats differing in resource availability. In addition, the density of large invertebrate predators in oil palm and rubber plantations is much lower than in rainforest (Barnes et al. 2014; Potapov et al. 2019), which may also facilitate P. corethrurus to thrive without much natural enemies.

Interestingly, the density of earthworms in the top 5 cm of soil declined during the dry season in plantations but not in rainforest suggesting that earthworms in plantations are more susceptible to reduced summer precipitation (Drescher et al. 2016) and either die or move to deeper soil layers. Potentially, this reflects that P. corethrurus dominating in plantations is more sensitive to soil desiccation than native species dominating in rainforest, but this needs further investigation.

Consequences of earthworm invasion

Consequences of the invasion by P. corethrurus for ecosystem processes also have been intensively studied. Pontoscolex corethrurus is generally known to compact soil and enhance N and P availability (Lavelle and Martin 1992; Lopez-Hernandez et al. 1993; Sabrina et al. 2009; Taheri et al. 2018b). Earthworms in general are known to accelerate organic matter and nutrient turnover, usually having positive effects on plant growth in the tropics (Brown et al. 1999). However, the magnitude and direction of the effects vary with soil characteristics and land use (Taheri et al. 2018b). Potential negative effects include the decline in herbaceous vegetation and tree seedlings resulting e.g., in shifts in plant-community composition in natural forests (Hale et al. 2006; Craven et al. 2017), the increase in net soil greenhouse-gas emissions (Lubbers et al. 2013), and reduced soil biodiversity (Ferlian et al. 2018).

Earthworm expansions are negatively affecting soil biodiversity on multiple trophic levels. The density of P. corethrurus is often inversely correlated with the density of other earthworm species, especially native ones (Lapied and Lavelle 2003; Taheri et al. 2018b). The dominance of the endogeic P. corethrurus and the exclusion of other functional groups of earthworms (epigeic and anecic) is expected to negatively affect ecosystem multifunctionality that depends on intact earthworm communities (Eisenhauer et al. 2012). However, changes in the composition of earthworm communities may also be due to changes in environmental conditions associated with deforestation rather than being caused by interactions between earthworm species (Marichal et al. 2010). Earthworms are known to impact nematodes and microorganisms (Lafont et al. 2007; Blouin et al. 2013), with evident negative effects on meso- and macrofauna (Eisenhauer 2010; Ferlian et al. 2018). Earthworms may function as ‘trophic whales’ in soil food webs, sequestering a large proportion of energy and reducing its propagation to higher trophic levels (Schwarzmüller et al. 2015; Potapov et al. 2019).

Overall, the invasion of earthworms is likely to accelerate nutrient cycling and to improve plant growth, but in the long-term may also contribute to depleting nutrient and carbon stocks in soil (Ferlian et al. 2020). Further, it may detrimentally affect biodiversity of understory plants and soil arthropods, thereby simplifying food-web structure and reducing ecosystem multifunctionality (Eisenhauer et al. 2019).

The future of earthworm invasion

The high abundance of earthworms in rubber and oil palm plantations connects our findings from Jambi province to changing land use at regional scales. Deforestation in Sumatra, Kalimantan, and other territories in Indonesia and Malaysia increased during the last 20–30 years, resulting in a large fraction of the lowland rainforest in the region being converted into plantations (Margono et al. 2014). Indonesia today produces more palm oil than any other country in the world and is overtaking deforestation rates in Brazil (Margono et al. 2014; Vijay et al. 2016). Our study was conducted approximately 30 years after massive land-use changes in Sumatra, suggesting that this period allows for drastic changes in earthworm communities to happen across the landscape. Our results suggest that the expansion of oil palm plantations will be followed by earthworm invasions and the spread of exotic generalists on large spatial scales. Whether this will result in mitigating or exaggerating effects of the conversion of rainforest into plantation systems on ecosystem services remains unclear, but is important to be investigated and potentially to be controlled. Notably, earthworms were less abundant in riparian areas, suggesting that these areas are more resistant to invasions by peregrine earthworms underlining their conservation potential.

Overall, the study documents that the conversion of rainforest into plantation systems facilitates the invasion by peregrine earthworms, with rubber monoculture plantations being most intensively colonized by P. corethrurus, potentially due to common evolutionary history of rubber trees and rhinodrilid earthworms. Facilitation of earthworm invasions in intensively managed monoculture plantations is likely to beneficially affect plant growth, but may reduce the diversity of other soil animals and the services they provide (Barnes et al. 2014; Clough et al. 2016; Potapov et al. 2019). Such negative effects may be mitigated by increasing habitat structure complexity, e.g. by increasing the amount of litter and coverage by understory vegetation (Ashton-Butt et al. 2018; Potapov et al. 2020). Recent research has shown that even moderate changes in existing practices of fertilization and weeding may beneficially affect biodiversity and ecosystem processes without reducing economic profit (Darras et al. 2019; Grass et al. 2020). Such ecologically-friendly approaches are promising and may allow to take advantage of positive effects of increased earthworm abundance on plant growth, while mitigating negative effects on biodiversity.

Availability of data and material

Raw data supporting the study conclusions are provided in the Supplementary materials and available from Figshare, https://doi.org/10.6084/m9.figshare.14369786.

Code availability

R commands and packages used for the statistical analysis are described in detail in the methods section. Statistical model formulas are given in the Supplementary materials.

References

Download references

Acknowledgements

This study was funded by the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (DFG, German Research Foundation)–Project ID 192626868 – SFB 990 in the framework of the collaborative German–Indonesian research project CRC990/EFForTS. We thank the following persons and organizations for granting us access to and use of their properties: local plot owners, PT REKI and Bukit Duabelas National Park. Sampling of animals used in this study was based on Collection Permits No. 2695/IPH.1/KS.02/XI/2012, S.07/KKH‐2/2013, and 2841/IPH.1/KS.02.04/X/2016, issued by the Indonesian Ministry of Forestry (PHKA). The authors are grateful to A. Barnes, S. Mumme, Megawati, A. Nur Faidah, B. Klarner and M. Italiensia who contributed to the physically and physiologically challenging field sampling campaigns, as well as measuring and counting of earthworms. We also thank U. Brose for designinng and supervision of the first sampling campaign. M. Jochum and N. Eisenhauer acknowledge support from the European Research Council (ERC) under the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation program (grant agreement no. 677232 to NE) and the German Centre for Integrative Biodiversity Research Halle–Jena–Leipzig, funded by the German Research Foundation (FZT 118).

Funding

Open Access funding enabled and organized by Projekt DEAL. The study was supported by the following bodies and grants: DFG–SFB 990 and FZT 118; ERC–677232.

Author information

Authors and Affiliations

Authors

Contributions

AP, SS, NE and MJ designed the study. AP, MJ and RW were involved in field sampling and export. IS did molecular work and sequence data evaluation. AP did morphological sorting statistical analysis and prepared the first draft of the paper. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.

Corresponding author

Correspondence to Anton Potapov.

Ethics declarations

Conflict of interest

The authors declare that they have no conflict of interest.

Additional information

Publisher's Note

Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.

Supplementary Information

Below is the link to the electronic supplementary material.

Supplementary file1 (DOCX 929 kb)

Rights and permissions

Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article's Creative Commons licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article's Creative Commons licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this licence, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/.

Reprints and Permissions

About this article

Verify currency and authenticity via CrossMark

Cite this article

Potapov, A., Schaefer, I., Jochum, M. et al. Oil palm and rubber expansion facilitates earthworm invasion in Indonesia. Biol Invasions 23, 2783–2795 (2021). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10530-021-02539-y

Download citation

  • Received:

  • Accepted:

  • Published:

  • Issue Date:

  • DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10530-021-02539-y

Keywords

  • Land-use change
  • Sumatra
  • Biomass
  • Soil biodiversity
  • Riparian zone
  • Seasonal changes
  • Genetic diversity
  • COI