Abstract
The representation of a complex but stable, self-regulated and, finally, harmonious nature penetrates the whole history of Ecology, thus contradicting the core of the Darwinian evolution. Originated in the pre-Darwinian Natural History, this representation defined theoretically the various schools of early ecology and, in the context of the cybernetic synthesis of the 1950s, it assumed a typical mathematical form on account of α positive correlation between species diversity and community stability. After 1960, these two aforementioned concepts and their positive correlation were proposed as environmental management tools, in the face of the ecological crisis arising at the time. In the early 1970s, and particularly after May’s evolutionary arguments, the consensus around this positive correlation collapsed for a while, only to be promptly restored for the purpose of attaching an ecological value on biodiversity. In this paper, we explore the history of the diversity–stability hypothesis and we review the successive terms that have been used to express community stability. We argue that this hypothesis has been motivated by the nodal ideological presuppositions of order and harmony and that the scientific developments in this field largely correspond to external social pressures. We conclude that the conflict about the diversity–stability relationship is in fact an ideological debate, referring mostly to the way we see nature and society rather than to an autonomous scientific question. From this point of view, we may understand why Ecology’s concepts and perceptions may decline and return again and again, forming a pluralistic scientific history.
Similar content being viewed by others
Notes
It is interesting to mention that 2 years before MacArthur’s paper, Good (1953), studying community distribution patterns, had already suggested Shannon’s index of entropy as a “measure of heterogeneity” of a biological community. This definition, however, has been widely attributed to Margalef (1958), who introduced Shannon’s index as an index of species diversity (for a more extended review see Nikisianis and Stamou 2011, 2012).
References
Balvanera P, Pfisterer AB, Buchmann N, He JS, Nakashizuka T, Raffaelli D, Schmid B (2006) Quantifying the evidence for biodiversity effects on ecosystem functioning and services. Ecol Lett 9:1146–1156
Bengtsson J (1998) Which species? What kind of diversity? Which ecosystem function? Some problems in studies of relations between biodiversity and ecosystem function. Appl Soil Ecol 10:191–199
Biggins DR (1976) Biology and ideology. Sci Educ 60:567–578
Boucher DH (1998) Newtonian ecology and beyond. Sci Cult 7:493–517
Brian MV (1953) Species frequencies in random samples from animal populations. J Anim Acol 22:57–64
Caldwell LK (1969) Health and homeostasis as social concepts: an exploratory essay. In: Woodwell GM, Smith HH (eds) Diversity and stability in ecological systems. Brookhaven National Laboratory, Upton, pp 206–223
Cardinale BJ, Nelson K, Palmer MA (2000) Linking species diversity to the functioning of ecosystems: on the importance of environmental context. Oikos 91:175–183
Chapin FS, Sala OE, Burke IC, Grime JP, Hooper DU, Lauenroth WK et al (1998) Ecosystem consequences of changing biodiversity. Bioscience 48:45–52
Connell JH (1978) Diversity in tropical rain forests and coral reefs. Science 199:1302–1310
Connell JH, Orias E (1964) The ecological regulation of species diversity. Am Nat 98:399–414
Cooper G (2003) The science of the struggle for existence: on the foundations of ecology. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Darwin C (1859) On the origin of species by means of natural selection, or the preservation of favoured races in the struggle for life. John Murray, London
De Angelis DL (1975) Stability and connectance in food web models. Ecology 56:238–243
De Angelis DL (1980) Energy flow, nutrient cycling, and ecosystem resilience. Ecology 61:764–771
Deevey ES Jr (1969) Specific diversity in fossil assemblages. In: Woodwell GM, Smith HH (eds) Diversity and stability in ecological systems. Brookhaven National Laboratory, Upton, pp 224–241
Deléage JP (1992) Histoire de l’écologie: une science de l’homme et de la nature. La Découverte, Paris
Doak DF, Bigger D, Harding EK, Marvier MA, O’malley RE, Thomson D (1998) The statistical inevitability of stability–diversity relationships in community ecology. Am Nat 151:264–276
Ehrlich PR, Birch LC (1967) The “balance of nature” and “population control”. Am Nat 101:97–107
Ehrlich P, Ehrlich A (1981) The rivet poppers. Not Man Apart 2:15
Elton CS (1958) The ecology of invasions by animal and plants. University of Chicago Press, London
Emerson AE (1954) Dynamic homeostasis: a unifying principle in organic, social, and ethical evolution. Sci Mon 78:67–85
Fisher RA, Corbet AS, Williams CB (1943) The relation between the number of species and the number of individuals in a random sample of an animal population. J Anim Ecol 12:42–58
Forbes SA (1887) The lake as a microcosm. Bull Peoria Sci Assoc 77–87
Foster JB, Clark B (2008) The sociology of ecology: ecological organicism versus ecosystem ecology in the social construction of ecological science, 1926–1935. Organ Environ 21:311–352
Gardner MR, Ashby WR (1970) Connectance of large dynamic (cybernetic) systems: critical values for stability. Nature 228:784
Gliboff S (2008) HG Bronn, Ernst Haeckel and the origins of German Darwinism. MIT Press, Cambridge
Good IJ (1953) The population frequencies of species and the estimation of population parameters. Biometrika 40:237
Goodman D (1975) The theory of diversity–stability relationships in ecology. Q Rev Biol 50:237–266
Grime JP (1997) Biodiversity and ecosystem function: the debate deepens. Science 277:1260–1261
Grman E, Lau JA, Schoolmaster DR Jr, Gross KL (2010) Mechanisms contributing to stability in ecosystem function depend on the environmental context. Ecol Lett 13:1400–1410
Hairston NG, Allan JD, Colwell RK, Futuyma DJ, Howell J, Lubin MD, Mathias J et al (1968) The relationship between species diversity and stability: an experimental approach with protozoa and bacteria. Ecology 49:1091–1101
Hardin G (1960) The competitive exclusion principle. Science 131:1292–1297
Hardin G (1968) The tragedy of the commons. Science 162:1243–1248
Hardin G (1969) Not peace, but ecology. In: Woodwell GM, Smith HH (eds) Diversity and stability in ecological systems. Brookhaven National Laboratory, Uptonn, pp 151–161
Harrison GW (1979) Stability under environmental stress: resistance, resilience, persistence, and variability. Am Nat 113:659–669
Harvey D (1996) Justice, nature and the geography of difference. Blackwell Publishing, Malden
Hector A, Schmid B, Beierkuhnlein C, Caldeira MC, Diemer M, Dimitrakopoulos PG et al (1999) Plant diversity and productivity experiments in European grasslands. Science 286:1123
Hendrickson JA, Ehrlich PR (1971) An expanded concept of ‘species diversity’. Not Nat Acad Nat Sci Phila 439:1–6
Hodgson JG, Thompson K, Wilson PJ, Bogaard A (1998) Does biodiversity determine ecosystem function? The Ecotron experiment reconsidered. Funct Ecol 12:843–848
Holling CS (1969) Stability in ecological and social systems. In: Woodwell GM, Smith HH (eds) Diversity and stability in ecological systems. Brookhaven National Laboratory, Upton, pp 128–141
Holling CS (1973) Resilience and stability of ecological systems. Annu Rev Ecol Syst 4:1–23
Holling CS (1996) Engineering resilience versus ecological resilience. Found Ecol Resil 51:31–43
Holling CS, Clark WC (1975) Notes towards a science of ecological management. In: van Dobben WH, Lowe-McConnell RH (eds) Unifying concepts in ecology: report of the plenary sessions of the first international congress of ecology. Dr. W. Junk B.V, The Hague, pp 247–251
Holt NR (1971) Ernst Haeckel’s monistic religion. J Hist Ideas 32:265–280
Hooper DU, Vitousek PM (1997) The effects of plant composition and diversity on ecosystem processes. Science 277:1302
Hurlbert SH (1971) The nonconcept of species diversity: a critique and alternative parameters. Ecology 52:577–586
Huston MA (1997) Hidden treatments in ecological experiments: re-evaluating the ecosystem function of biodiversity. Oecologia 110:449–460
Huston MA, Aarssen LW, Austin MP, Cade BS, Fridley JD, Garnier E, Grime JP et al (2000) No consistent effect of plant diversity on productivity. Science 289:1255
Hutchinson GE (1948) Circular causal systems in ecology. Ann N Y Acad Sci 50:221–246
Hutchinson GE (1958) Concluding remarks. In: Cold Spring Harbour Symposia on Quantitative Biology, vol 22, pp 415–427
Hutchinson GE (1959) Homage to Santa Rosalia or why are there so many kinds of animals? Am Nat 93:145–159
Jacobs J (1975) Diversity, stability and maturity in ecosystems influenced by human activities. In: van Dobben WH, Lowe-McConnell RH (eds) Unifying concepts in ecology: report of the plenary sessions of the first international congress of ecology. Dr. W. Junk B.V, The Hague, pp 187–207
Johnson MP, Raven PH (1970) Natural regulation of plant species diversity. Evol Biol 4:127–162
Johnson KH, Vogt KA, Clark HJ, Schmitz OJ, Vogt DJ (1996) Biodiversity and the productivity and stability of ecosystems. Trends Ecol Evol 11:372–377
Justus JR (2007) The stability–diversity–complexity debate of theoretical community ecology: a philosophical analysis. Dissertation, The University of Texas at Austin
Kareiva P (1996) Diversity and sustainability on the prairie. Nature 379:673–674
Kimmerer WJ (1984) Diversity/stabililty: a criticism. Ecology 65:1936–1938
King CE (1964) Relative abundance of species and MacArthur’s model. Ecology 45:716–727
King AW, Pimm SL (1983) Complexity, diversity, and stability: a reconciliation of theoretical and empirical results. Am Nat 122:229–239
Kingsland SE (1985) Modeling nature: episodes in the history of population ecology. University of Chicago Press, Chicago
Korfiatis KJ, Stamou GP (1994) Emergence of new fields in ecology: the case of life history studies. Pubbl Stn Zool Napoli 16:97–116
Kwa C (1989) Mimicking nature: the development of systems ecology in the United States, 1950–1975. Dissertation, University of Amsterdam
Kwa C (2002) Romantic and baroque conceptions of complex wholes in the sciences. In: Law J, Mol A (eds) Complexities: social studies of knowledge practices. Duke University Press, Durham, pp 23–52
Lawton JH, Naeem S, Woodfin RM, Brown VK, Gange A, Godfray HJC, Heads PA et al (1993) The Ecotron: a controlled environmental facility for the investigation of population and ecosystem processes. Philos Trans R Soc Lond B Biol Sci 341:181
Lecourt D (1976) Lysenko. François Maspero, Paris
Lecourt D (1992) Marx in the Sieve of Darwin. Rethink Marxism 5:6–28
Lefkaditou A (2012) Is ecology a holistic science, after all? In: Stamou GP (ed) Populations, biocommunities, ecosystems: a review of controversies in ecological thinking. Bentham Science Publishers, Oak Park Ill, pp 46–66
Leigh EG Jr (1965) On the relation between the productivity, biomass, diversity, and stability of a community. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 53:777
Lepš J, Brown VK, Len TAD, Gormsen D, Hedlund K, Kailová J, Korthals GW et al (2001) Separating the chance effect from other diversity effects in the functioning of plant communities. Oikos 92:123–134
Levins R (1968) Evolution in changing environments: some theoretical explorations. Princeton University Press, Princeton
Lewontin RC (1969) The meaning of stability. In: Woodwell GM, Smith HH (eds) Diversity and stability in ecological systems. Brookhaven National Laboratory, Brookhaven, pp 13–24
Lewontin RC (2000) Biology as ideology: the doctrine of DNA. Synalma, Athens
Long GE (1974) Model stability, resilience, and management of an aquatic community. Oecologia 17:65–85
Loreau M (2000) Biodiversity and ecosystem functioning: recent theoretical advances. Oikos 91:3–17
Loreau M, Naeem S, Inchausti P, Bengtsson J, Grime JP, Hector A et al (2001) Biodiversity and ecosystem functioning: current knowledge and future challenges. Science 294:804
MacArthur RH (1955) Fluctuations of animal populations and a measure of community stability. Ecology 36:533–536
MacArthur RH (1957) On the relative abundance of bird species. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 43:293
Maclaurin J, Sterelny K (2007) Biodiversity. University of Chicago Press, Chicago
Magurran AE (2003) Measuring biological diversity. Blackwell Publishing, Malden
Margalef R (1958) Information theory in ecology. Gen Syst 3:36–71
Margalef R (1963) On certain unifying principles in ecology. Am Nat 97:357–374
Margalef R (1968) Perspectives in ecological theory. University of Chicago Press, Chicago
Margalef R (1969) Diversity and stability: a practical proposal and a model of interdependence. In: Woodwell GM, Smith HH (eds) Diversity and stability in ecological systems. Brookhaven National Laboratory, Upton, pp 25–37
Margalef R (1975) Diversity, stability and maturity in natural ecosystems. In: van Dobben WH, Lowe-McConnell RH (eds) Unifying concepts in ecology: report of the plenary sessions of the first international congress of ecology. Dr. W. Junk B.V, The Hague, pp 151–160
Marshall A (2002) The unity of nature: wholeness and disintegration in ecology and science. Imperial College Press, London
May RM (1973) Stability and complexity in model ecosystems. Princeton University Press, Princeton
May RM (1975) Stability in ecosystems: some comments. In: van Dobben WH, Lowe-McConnell RH (eds) Unifying concepts in ecology: report of the plenary sessions of the first international congress of ecology. Dr. W. Junk B.V, The Hague, pp 161–168
May RM (1976) Patterns in multi-species communities. In: May RM (ed) Theoretical ecology, principles and applications. Blackwell Scientific, Oxford, pp 142–162
May RM (1986) The search for patterns in the balance of nature: advances and retreats. Ecology 67:1115–1126
Mayr E (1961) Cause and effect in biology. Science 134:1501–1506
McCann KS (2000) The diversity–stability debate. Nature 405:228–233
McCann KS (2005) Perspectives on diversity, structure, and stability. In: Cuddington K, Beisner B (eds) Ecological paradigms lost: routes to theory change. Elsevier Academic Press, New York, pp 183–200
McIntosh RP (1967) An index of diversity and the relation of certain concepts to diversity. Ecology 48:392–404
McIntosh RP (1985) The background of ecology: concept and theory. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
McNaughton SJ (1977) Diversity and stability of ecological communities: a comment on the role of empiricism in ecology. Am Nat 111:515–525
Miller JG (1965) Living systems: basic concepts. Behav Sci 10:193–237
Miller RS (1969) Competition and species diversity. In: Woodwell GM, Smith HH (eds) Diversity and stability in ecological systems. Brookhaven National Laboratory, Upton, pp 63–70
Mitman G (1992) The state of nature: ecology, community, and American social thought, 1900–1950. University of Chicago Press, Chicago
Motomura I (1947) Further notes on the law of geometrical progression of the population density in animal association. Physiol Ecol 1:55–60
Nieminen M (2000) The incontestable nature of biodiversity. In: Paper for the POSTI conference on Policy Agendas for Sustainable Technological Innovation, London
Nikisianis N, Stamou GP (2011) Quantifying nature: ideological representations in the concept of diversity. Hist Philos Life Sci 33:365–388
Nikisianis N, Stamou GP (2012) The ideology of diversity. In: Stamou GP (ed) Populations, biocommunities, ecosystems: a review of controversies in ecological thinking. Bentham Science Publishers, Oak Park Ill, pp 93–121
Novikoff AB (1945) The concept of integrative levels and biology. Science 101:209–215
Odum EP (1953) Fundamentals of ecology. Saunders, Philadelphia
Odum EP (1969) The strategy of ecosystem development. Science 164:262–270
Odum EP (1975) Diversity as a function of energy flow. In: van Dobben WH, Lowe-McConnell RH (eds) Unifying concepts in ecology: report of the plenary sessions of the first international congress of ecology. Dr. W. Junk B.V, The Hague, pp 11–26
Odum HT, Cantlon JE, Kornicker LS (1960) An organizational hierarchy postulate for the interpretation of species-individual distributions, species entropy, ecosystem evolution, and the meaning of a species-variety index. Ecology 41:395–399
Orians GH (1975) Diversity, stability and maturity in natural ecosystems. In: van Dobben WH, Lowe-McConnell RH (eds) Unifying concepts in ecology: report of the plenary sessions of the first international congress of ecology. Dr. W. Junk B.V, The Hague, pp 139–150
Paine RT (1969) A note on trophic complexity and community stability. Am Nat 103:91–93
Patten BC (1961) Preliminary method for estimating stability in plankton. Science 134:1010–1011
Pêcheux M (1969) Idéologie et histoire des sciences. In: Pêcheux M, Fichant M (eds) Sur l’Histoire des sciences. Maspero, Paris, pp 13–57
Peet RK (1974) The measurement of species diversity. Annu Rev Ecol Syst 5:285–307
Pimentel D (1961) Species diversity and insect population outbreaks. Ann Entomol Soc Am 54:76–86
Pimm SL (1979) Complexity and stability: another look at MacArthur’s original hypothesis. Oikos 33:351–357
Pimm SL (1984) The complexity and stability of ecosystems. Nature 307:321–326
Preston FW (1948) The commonness, and rarity, of species. Ecology 29:254–283
Preston FW (1969) Diversity and stability in the biological world. In: Woodwell GM, Smith HH (eds) Diversity and stability in ecological systems. Brookhaven National Laboratory, Upton, pp 1–12
Regier HA, Cowell EB (1972) Applications of ecosystem theory, succession, diversity, stability, stress and conservation. Biol Conserv 4:83–88
Reichle DE, O’Neill RV, Harris WF (1975) Principles of energy and material exchange in ecosystems. In: van Dobben WH, Lowe-McConnell RH (eds) Unifying concepts in ecology: report of the plenary sessions of the first international congress of ecology. Dr. W. Junk B.V, The Hague, pp 27–43
Romanuk TN, Vogt RJ, Kolasa J (2009) Ecological realism and mechanisms by which diversity begets stability. Oikos 118:819–828
Santana C (2014) Save the planet: eliminate biodiversity. Biol Philos 29:761–780
Sarkar S (2005) Biodiversity and environmental philosophy. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Sarkar S (2006) Ecological diversity and biodiversity as concepts for conservation planning: comments on Ricotta. Acta Biotheor 54:133–140
Sarkar S (2007) From ecological diversity to biodiversity. In: Hull DL, Ruse M (eds) The Cambridge companion to the philosophy of biology. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Sasaki T, Lauenroth WK (2011) Dominant species, rather than diversity, regulates temporal stability of plant communities. Oecologia 166:761–768
Schizas D (2012) Systems ecology reloaded: a critical assessment focusing on the relations between science and ideology. In: Stamou GP (ed) Populations, biocommunities, ecosystems: a review of controversies in ecological thinking. Bentham Science Publishers, Oak Park Ill, pp 67–92
Schwartz MW, Brigham CA, Hoeksema JD, Lyons KG, Mills MH, Van Mantgem PJ (2000) Linking biodiversity to ecosystem function: implications for conservation ecology. Oecologia 122:297–305
Sears PB (1954) Human ecology: a problem in synthesis. Science 120:959–963
Shannon C (1948) A mathematical theory of communication. Bell Syst Tech J 27:379–423
Simpson EH (1949) Measurement of diversity. Nature 163:688
Slobodkin LB (1965) On the present incompleteness of mathematical ecolog. Am Sci 53:347–357
Slobodkin LB, Sanders HL (1969) On the contribution of environmental predictability to species diversity. In: Woodwell GM, Smith HH (eds) Diversity and stability in ecological systems. Brookhaven National Laboratory, Upton, pp 82–95
Smocovitis VB (1992) Unifying biology: the evolutionary synthesis and evolutionary biology. J Hist Biol 25:1–65
Stavrakakis Y (1997) Green ideology: a discursive reading. J Polit Ideol 2:259–279
Takacs D (1996) The idea of biodiversity: philosophies of paradise. Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore, MD
Tansley AG (1935) The use and abuse of vegetational concepts and terms. Ecology 16:284–307
Taylor PJ (2005) Unruly complexity: ecology, interpretation, engagement. University of Chicago Press, Chicago
Taylor PJ (2010) A constructionist perspective on the structure of ecological complexity, follow-up questions. http://wp.me/pPWGi-B4
Tilman D (1996) Biodiversity: population versus ecosystem stability. Ecology 77:350–363
Tilman D (1999) Diversity and production in European grasslands. Science 286:1099
Tilman D (2000) Causes, consequences and ethics of biodiversity. Nature 405:208–211
Tilman D, Downing JA (1994) Diversity and stability in grasslands. Nature 367:363–365
Tilman D, Lehman CL, Bristow CE (1998) Diversity–stability relationships: statistical inevitability or ecological consequence? Am Nat 151:277–282
Tilman D, Reich PB, Knops J, Wedin D, Mielke T, Lehman C (2001) Diversity and productivity in a long-term grassland experiment. Science 294:843
Ulanowicz RE (1979) Complexity, stability and self-organization in natural communities. Oecologia 43:295–298
Van Voris P, O’Neill RV, Emanuel WR, Shugart HH (1980) Functional complexity and ecosystem stability. Ecology 61:1352–1360
Von Bertalanffy L (1972) The history and status of general systems theory. Acad Manag J 15:407–426
Walker BH (1992) Biodiversity and ecological redundancy. Conserv Biol 6:18–23
Wardle DA (1999) Is “sampling effect” a problem for experiments investigating biodiversity–ecosystem function relationships? Oikos 87:403–407
Watt KEF (1964) Comments on fluctuations of animal populations and measures of community stability. Can Entomol 96:1434–1442
Watt KEF (1969) A comparative study on the meaning of stability in five biological systems: insect and furbearer populations, influenza, Thai hemorrhagic fever, and plague. In: Woodwell GM, Smith HH (eds) Diversity and stability in ecological systems. Brookhaven National Laboratory, Upton, pp 142–150
Westman WE (1978) Measuring the inertia and resilience of ecosystems. Bioscience 28:705–710
Westman WE (1986) Resilience: concepts and measures. In: Dell B, Hopkins AJM, Lamont BB (eds) Resilience in mediterranean-type ecosystems. Junk Publishers, Dordrecth, pp 5–19
Whittaker RH (1960) Vegetation of the Siskiyou mountains, Oregon and California. Ecol Monogr 30:279–338
Whittaker RH (1972) Evolution and measurement of species diversity. Taxon 21:213–251
Whittaker RH (1975) The design and stability of plant communities. In: van Dobben WH, Lowe-McConnell RH (eds) Unifying concepts in ecology: report of the plenary sessions of the first international congress of ecology. Dr. W. Junk B.V, The Hague, pp 169–181
Wilson EO (1988) Biodiversity. National Academy Press, Washington, DC
Worster D (1985) Nature’s economy. A history of ecological Ideas. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Yachi S, Loreau M (1999) Biodiversity and ecosystem productivity in a fluctuating environment: the insurance hypothesis. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 96:1463
Yodzis P (1981) The stability of real ecosystems. Nature 289:674–676
Zaret TM (1982) The stability/diversity controversy: a test of hypotheses. Ecology 63:721–731
Zaret TM (1984) Ecology and epistemology. Bull Ecol Soc Am 65:4–7
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Nikisianis, N., Stamou, G.P. Harmony as Ideology: Questioning the Diversity–Stability Hypothesis . Acta Biotheor 64, 33–64 (2016). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10441-015-9272-x
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10441-015-9272-x